DOCSLIB.ORG

(Icsid Case No. Arb/07/19) Decision on Jurisdiction

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
(Icsid Case No. Arb/07/19) Decision on Jurisdiction INTERNATIONAL CENTRE FOR SETTLEMENT OF INVESTMENT DISPUTES WASHINGTON, D.C. IN THE ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS BETWEEN: ELECTRABEL S.A. CLAIMANT V. THE REPUBLIC OF HUNGARY RESPONDENT (ICSID CASE NO. ARB/07/19) ___________________________________________________________________________ DECISION ON JURISDICTION, APPLICABLE LAW AND LIABILITY ___________________________________________________________________________ Members of the Tribunal: Professor Gabrielle Kaufmann-Kohler, Arbitrator Professor Brigitte Stern, Arbitrator V.V. Veeder, President ICSID Secretary to the Tribunal: Ms. Aurélia Antonietti Representing the Claimant: Representing the Respondent: Mr Audley Sheppard Ms Jean Kalicki Mr Gareth Kenny Mr Dmitri Evseev Ms Christina Schuetz Ms Mara V. J. Senn CLIFFORD CHANCE LLP Mr Luc Gyselen (until March 2012) ARNOLD & PORTER LLP Mr Peter Turner and FRESHFIELDS BRUCKHAUS DERINGER Mr János Katona LLP (as of March 2012) LAW OFFICE OF JÁNOS KATONA and Mr Zoltán Faludi Mr Laszlo Kenyeres FALUDI WOLF THEISS Date of dispatch to the Parties: 30 November 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I: THE ARBITRATION I-01 (01) The Parties and Other Persons I-01 (02) The Arbitration Tribunal I-02 (03) The Arbitral Procedure I-03 (04) The Parties’ Claimed Relief I-10 (05) ICSID Arbitration Rule 38(1) I-12 PART II: THE PARTIES’ DISPUTE II-01 (01) Introduction II-01 (02) The Claimant’s Case II-02 (03) The Respondent’s Case II-04 (04) The Principal Issues II-07 PART III: THE PRINCIPAL LEGAL TEXTS III-01 (01) Introduction III-01 (02) The Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) III-01 (03) Treaty on European Union (TEU) III-10 (04) Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) III-11 (05) The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT) III-17 (06) The ICSID Convention III-20 (07) The ICSID Arbitration Rules III-22 (08) Table TFEU - Ex EC III-23 PART IV: APPLICABLE LAW(S) IV-01 (01) Introduction IV-01 ECT IV-01 EU Statement IV-01 i ICSID Convention IV-02 New York Convention IV-02 VCLT IV-02 EU BITs IV-02 EU Treaties IV-02 EU Lisbon Treaty IV-02 This Case IV-04 (02) The Claimant’s Case IV-06 (i) EU law is not applicable as law, but as fact IV-11 (ii) In any event, only EU Treaties are part of international law IV-12 (iii) EU Treaty law incorporates ECT IV-12 (iv) If there is inconsistency, the ECT has primacy IV-12 (v) EU law and ECT can be read in harmony IV-13 (03) The Respondent’s Case IV-16 (i) EU law is international law IV-19 (ii) EU law is also relevant as a fact IV-20 (iii) The Claimant’s theory of the ECT’s absolute dominance is unacceptable IV-20 (iv) EU law and ECT can be read in harmony IV-22 (04) The European Commission’s Submission IV-27 (i) State Aid IV-28 (ii) The ECT IV-31 (iii) PPA Termination Claim IV-31 (05) The Tribunal’s Analysis IV-35 (i) The Multiple Nature of EU Law IV-37 (ii) EU law is based on an international treaties IV-37 (iii) The Whole of EU law as an International Legal Order IV-38 (iv) EU law as National Law IV-39 (v) EU Law as Fact IV-40 (vi) The Relationship between the ECT and EU law IV-40 The ECT’s Genesis IV-42 ECT and EU Objectives IV-43 ECT and EU Decisions IV-44 (vii) Harmonious Interpretation IV-45 (viii) Possible Inconsistency between the ECT and EU law IV-53 Hierarchy of Legal Orders IV-56 Article 16 ECT IV-56 Article 307 EC (Article 351 TFEU) IV-57 Article 30 of the Vienna Convention IV-62 (06) The Tribunal’s Conclusions IV-62 ii PART V: JURISDICTION V-01 (01) Introduction V-01 (02) The European Commission’s Submission V-03 (i) Jurisdiction V-03 (ii) EU Law V-04 (iii) Harmonious Interpretation V-04 (iv) Unenforceable Award V-05 (03) The Claimant’s Observations V-12 (04) The Respondent’s Observations V-13 (05) The Tribunal’s Analysis and Decisions V-15 (i) The Tribunal’s Jurisdiction V-15 (ii) Article 1(6) ECT V-17 (06) Summary V-22 PART VI: PPA TERMINATION CLAIM VI-01 (01) Introduction VI-01 (02) Electrabel’s Case VI-05 (i) FET VI-05 (ii) Expropriation VI-06 (iii) Expropriation without Compensation VI-08 (iv) Other ECT Standards VI-11 (03) Hungary’s Case VI-11 (i) FET VI-11 (ii) Expropriation VI-12 (iii) Expropriation without Compensation VI-13 (iv) Other Treaty Standards VI-14 (04) The Tribunal’s Analysis and Decisions VI-14 (i) Expropriation VI-14 (ii) FET VI-20 (iii) Events before the Final Decision VI-20 (iv) The Final Decision VI-22 (v) Net Stranded Costs VI-31 (vi) Other ECT Standards VI-38 (05) Summary VI-39 iii PART VII: PPA PRICING VII-01 (01) Introduction VII-01 (02) The Claimant’s Case VII-02 (i) Summary of the Claimant’s Position VII-02 (ii) Period of Regulated Pricing (1996-2003) VII-02 (iii) Period of Deregulated Pricing (2004-2005) VII-03 (iv) 2005-2015 VII-04 (v) Attribution VII-06 (vi) Breach of the ECT VII-06 (03) The Respondent’s Case VII-07 (i) Summary of the Respondent’s Position VII-07 (ii) PPA Pricing: 1997-2001 VII-09 (iii) PPA Pricing: 2001 VII-10 (iv) PPA Pricing: 2002-2004 VII-10 (v) PPA Pricing: 2005 VII-11 (vi) PPA Pricing: 2006 VII-11 (vii) No Attribution VII-12 (viii) No Breach of ECT VII-13 (04) The Tribunal’s Analysis and Decisions VII-15 (i) Applicable Rules VII-16 (ii) General Approach VII-16 (iii) Attribution VII-17 (iv) Fair and Equitable Treatment VII-20 (v) Full Protection and Security VII-22 (vi) 2006 and 2008 VII-23 (vii) Ministerial and Parliamentary Conduct VII-24 (viii) MVM VII-26 (ix) HEO November 2005 Letter VII-27 (x) The 2008 YCA VII-29 (xi) The 2006 YCA VII-30 (xii) MVM’s Conduct during the Renegotiation Meetings VII-32 (xiii) The YCA Drafts VII-36 (xiv) The FET Standard VII-42 (xv) The FPS Standard VII-43 (xvi) Unreasonable or Discriminatory Measures VII-44 (xvii) International Law Standard VII-46 (xviii) National Treatment and MFN Treatment VII-47 (05) Summary VII-48 PART VIII: REGULATED PRICING VIII-01 (01) Introduction VIII-01 (02) The Claimant’s Case VIII-02 (03) The Respondent’s Case VIII-04 (04) The Tribunal’s Analysis and Decisions VIII-05 (05) Summary VIII-11 iv PART IX: ISSUE F - THE G1 UNIT IX-01 (01) Introduction IX-01 (02) The Claimant’s Case IX-02 (03) The Respondent’s Case IX-03 (04) The Tribunal’s Analysis and Decisions IX-03 (05) Summary IX-05 PART X: SUMMARY X-01 PART XI: THE OPERATIVE PART XI-01 A: Selected List of Abbreviations (vi) B: Dramatis Personae (ix) C: Selected List of Legal Materials and References (xi) v A: List of Abbreviations 1994 Electricity Act: Hungary’s Electricity Act of April 1994, establishing general regulatory principles for the electricity sector. 1995 Decree: Hungary’s Decree 63/1995, establishing a pricing methodology for the period beginning 1 January 1997 and ending 31 December 2000. 2001 Electricity Act: Hungary’s Electricity Act of December 2001, establishing a “dual” market for electricity. 2006 Act: Hungary’s 2006 Price Regulation Act of March 2006, reintroducing administrative pricing. 2007 Electricity Act Hungary’s Electricity Act implementing full market liberalisation in the electricity sector. Act of Accession: Hungary’s Act of Accession with the European Union, effective from 1 May 2004 as a Member State. AES Tisza: AES Tisza Erőmű Kft (company operating the Tisza plant). APV: Hungary’s Privatization and State Holding Company, responsible for the management of state owned assets). BIT: The 1986 Agreement for the Promotion and Protection of Investments between the Government of Belgium and Hungary. CFI: The European Court of First Instance (now the General Court). Cooperation Agreement: The Agreement concluded between Dunamenti and MVM dated 18 March 1997. Commission Submission The European Commission’s Submission dated 12 June 2009 pursuant to Article 27(2) of the ICSID Arbitration Rules in these arbitration proceedings. Compensation Decision: The European Commission’s Compensation Decision of 27 April 2010. DG Comp: The Directorate General for Competition of the Commission of the European Communities. DSPI: Domestic Sale Price Index. Dunamenti: Dunamenti Erőmű Rt (owner and operator of the Dunamenti power plant from 1995). vi Commission: The Commission of the European Communities. F Retrofit Agreement: The 2001 Agreement between Dunamenti and MVM amending the PPA. Generators: Hungarian companies generating wholesale electricity. HEO: The Hungarian Energy Office (Hungary’s energy regulator). MAVIR: Magyar Villmosenergia-ipari Átviteli Rendszerirányító (Hungarian Transmission System Operator, MVM’s subsidiary since 2006). MOL Duna Refinery: MOL Dufi (oil refinery owned by MOL serviced by the Dunamenti power plant). MVM: Magyar Villamos Müvek Zrt (State owned electricity supply company). MVM Trade: MVM Villamosenergia Kereskedelmi Zrt (MVM’s subsidiary, assignee of the PPA from MVM). Net Stranded Costs: Stranded Costs in excess of repaid/repayable State Aid. NRI: Non-Returned Investment. London Economics: Consultants retained by Hungary to carry out a market simulation of Hungarian electricity supply. PPA: The Power Purchase Agreement dated 10 October 1995 concluded between Dunamenti and MVM (amended in 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999 and by the F Retrofit Agreement of 2001). PPI: Producer Price Index. Price Decrees: Hungary’s Price Decrees of December 2006 and January 2007 under the 2006 Act (also called “Tariff Decrees”). PSA: The Purchase and Sale Agreement dated 8 December 1995 between the Hungarian Privatization and State Holding Company APV and Powerfin S.A.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Viking Voicejan2014.Pub
    Volume 2 February 2014 Viking Voice PENN DELCO SCHOOL DISTRICT Welcome 2014 Northley students have been busy this school year. They have been playing sports, performing in con- certs, writing essays, doing homework and projects, and enjoying life. Many new and exciting events are planned for the 2014 year. Many of us will be watching the Winter Olympics, going to plays and con- certs, volunteering in the community, participating in Reading Across America for Dr. Seuss Night, and welcoming spring. The staff of the Viking Voice wishes everyone a Happy New Year. Northley’s Students are watching Guys and Dolls the 2014 Winter Olympics Northley’s 2014 Musical ARTICLES IN By Vivian Long and Alexis Bingeman THE VIKING V O I C E This year’s winter Olympics will take place in Sochi Russia. This is the This year’s school musical is Guy and • Olympic Events first time in Russia’s history that they Dolls Jr. Guys and Dolls is a funny musical • Guys and Dolls will host the Winter Olympic Games. set in New York in the 40’s centering on Sochi is located in Krasnodar, which is gambling guys and their dolls (their girl • Frozen: a review, a the third largest region of Russia, with friends). Sixth grader, Billy Fisher, is playing survey and excerpt a population of about 400,000. This is Nathan Detroit, a gambling guy who is always • New Words of the located in the south western corner of trying to find a place to run his crap game. Year Russia. The events will be held in two Emma Robinson is playing Adelaide, Na- • Scrambled PSSA different locations.
    [Show full text]
  • Diversity of Alien Macroinvertebrate Species in Serbian Waters
    water Article Diversity of Alien Macroinvertebrate Species in Serbian Waters Katarina Zori´c* , Ana Atanackovi´c,Jelena Tomovi´c,Božica Vasiljevi´c,Bojana Tubi´c and Momir Paunovi´c Department for Hydroecology and Water Protection, Institute for Biological Research “Siniša Stankovi´c”—NationalInstitute of Republic of Serbia, University of Belgrade, Bulevar despota Stefana 142, 11060 Belgrade, Serbia; [email protected] (A.A.); [email protected] (J.T.); [email protected] (B.V.); [email protected] (B.T.); [email protected] (M.P.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 29 September 2020; Accepted: 7 December 2020; Published: 15 December 2020 Abstract: This article provides the first comprehensive list of alien macroinvertebrate species registered and/or established in aquatic ecosystems in Serbia as a potential threat to native biodiversity. The list comprised field investigations, articles, grey literature, and unpublished data. Twenty-nine species of macroinvertebrates have been recorded since 1942, with a domination of the Ponto-Caspian faunistic elements. The majority of recorded species have broad distribution and are naturalized in the waters of Serbia, while occasional or single findings of seven taxa indicate that these species have failed to form populations. Presented results clearly show that the Danube is the main corridor for the introduction and spread of non-native species into Serbia. Keywords: Serbia; inland waters; allochthonous species; introduction 1. Introduction The Water Framework Directive (WFD) [1] represents key regulation and one of the most important documents in the European Union water legislation since it was adopted in 2000.
    [Show full text]
  • China at the Gates a New Power Audit of Eu-China Relations
    CHINA AT THE GATES A NEW POWER AUDIT OF EU-CHINA RELATIONS François Godement & Abigaël Vasselier ABOUT ECFR The European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) is the first pan-European think-tank. Launched in October 2007, its objective is to conduct research and promote informed debate across Europe on the development of coherent, effective and values- based European foreign policy. ECFR has developed a strategy with three distinctive elements that define its activities: • A pan-European Council. ECFR has brought together a distinguished Council of over two hundred Members - politicians, decision makers, thinkers and business people from the EU’s member states and candidate countries - which meets once a year as a full body. Through geographical and thematic task forces, members provide ECFR staff with advice and feedback on policy ideas and help with ECFR’s activities within their own countries. The Council is chaired by Carl Bildt, Emma Bonino and Mabel van Oranje. • A physical presence in the main EU member states. ECFR, uniquely among European think-tanks, has offices in Berlin, London, Madrid, Paris, Rome, Sofia and Warsaw. Our offices are platforms for research, debate, advocacy and communications. • Developing contagious ideas that get people talking. ECFR has brought together a team of distinguished researchers and practitioners from all over Europe to carry out innovative research and policy development projects with a pan-European focus. ECFR produces original research; publishes policy reports; hosts private meetings, public debates, and “friends of ECFR” gatherings in EU capitals; and reaches out to strategic media outlets. ECFR is a registered charity funded by the Open Society Foundations and other generous foundations, individuals and corporate entities.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of Wetlands and Floodplain Areas in the Danube River Basin Final Report May 1999
    DANUBE POLLUTION REDUCTION PROGRAMME EVALUATION OF WETLANDS AND FLOODPLAIN AREAS IN THE DANUBE RIVER BASIN FINAL REPORT MAY 1999 Programme Coordination Unit UNDP/GEF Assistance prepared by WWF Danube-Carpathian-Programme and WWF-Auen-Institut (Germany) DANUBE POLLUTION REDUCTION PROGRAMME EVALUATION OF WETLANDS AND FLOODPLAIN AREAS IN THE DANUBE RIVER BASIN FINAL REPORT MAY 1999 Programme Coordination Unit UNDP/GEF Assistance prepared by WWF Danube-Carpathian-Programme and WWF-Auen-Institut (Germany) Preface The "Evaluation of Wetlands and Flkoodplain Areas in the Danube River Basin" study was prepared in the frame of the Danube Pollution Reduction Programme (PRP). The Study has been undertaken to define priority wetland and floodplain rehabilitation sites as a component of the Pollution reduction Programme. The present report addresses the identification of former floodplains and wetlands in the Danube River Basin, as well as the description of the current status and evaluation of the ecological importance of the potential for rehabilitation. Based on this evaluation, 17 wetland/floodplain sites have been identified for rehabilitation considering their ecological importance, their nutrient removal capacity and their role in flood protection. Most of the identified wetlands will require transboundary cooperation and represent an important first step in retoring the ecological balance in the Danube River Basin. The results are presented in the form of thematic maps that can be found in Annex I of the study. The study was prepared by the WWF-Danube-Carpathian-Programme and the WWF-Auen-Institut (Institute for Floodplains Ecology, WWF-Germany), under the guidance of the UNDP/GEF team of experts of the Danube Programme Coordination Unit (DPCU) in Vienna, Austria.
    [Show full text]
  • Navigation on the Danube (Allied Powers: Czechoslovakia, Greece, Romania, Serb-Croat-Slovene Kingdom); Germany, Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria
    REPORTS OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRAL AWARDS RECUEIL DES SENTENCES ARBITRALES Navigation on the Danube (Allied Powers: Czechoslovakia, Greece, Romania, Serb-Croat-Slovene Kingdom); Germany, Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria 2 August 1921 VOLUME I pp. 97-212 NATIONS UNIES - UNITED NATIONS Copyright (c) 2006 IV. CESSION OF VESSELS AND TUGS FOR NAVIGATION ON THE DANUBE *. PARTIES : Allied Powers (Czechoslovakia, Greece, Rumania, Serb-Croat-Slovene Kingdom); Germany, Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria. COMPROMIS : Treaty of Versailles, Article 339 2 ; Article 300 of Treaty of St. Germain 3 ; Article 284 of Treaty of Trianon and Article 228 of Treaty of Neuilly-sur- Seine. ARBITRATOR : Walker D. Hines (U.S.A.). DECISION : Paris, August 2, 1921. Confiscation of private property in warfare.—Allocation and condition of vessels of disputed ownership and nationality.—Question of jurisdiction. —Fourth Hague Convention of 1907 (Articles 46 and 53 of its annexed Regulations).—Legal character of private property hired by belligerent State for military purposes.—Effect of military acts after armistice between some but not all of the belligerents. General conditions for effectual ion of permanent allocation.—Delivery of vessels.—Claim for excess fittings and gear.—Vessels whose nationality is affected by change of nationality of owners.—Claims to allocation asserted by Czechoslovakia as a succession State. Cession by Germany, Austria ,md Hungary to meet legitimate needs of Allied and Associated Powers concerned.—Legitimate needs of States for freight traffic.—International character of the River Save,—Basic freight traffic on the Danube in 1911 to be considered in estimating legitimate needs of parties concerned.—Modification of such basis on account of subsequent developments.
    [Show full text]
  • The Catalogue of the Freshwater Crayfish (Crustacea: Decapoda: Astacidae) from Romania Preserved in “Grigore Antipa” National Museum of Natural History of Bucharest
    Travaux du Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle © Décembre Vol. LIII pp. 115–123 «Grigore Antipa» 2010 DOI: 10.2478/v10191-010-0008-5 THE CATALOGUE OF THE FRESHWATER CRAYFISH (CRUSTACEA: DECAPODA: ASTACIDAE) FROM ROMANIA PRESERVED IN “GRIGORE ANTIPA” NATIONAL MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY OF BUCHAREST IORGU PETRESCU, ANA-MARIA PETRESCU Abstract. The largest collection of freshwater crayfish of Romania is preserved in “Grigore Antipa” National Museum of Natural History of Bucharest. The collection consists of 426 specimens of Astacus astacus, A. leptodactylus and Austropotamobius torrentium. Résumé. La plus grande collection d’écrevisses de Roumanie se trouve au Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle «Grigore Antipa» de Bucarest. Elle comprend 426 exemplaires appartenant à deux genres et trois espèces, Astacus astacus, A. leptodactylus et Austropotamobius torrentium. Key words: Astacidae, Romania, museum collection, catalogue. INTRODUCTION The first paper dealing with the freshwater crayfish of Romania is that of Cosmovici, published in 1901 (Bãcescu, 1967) in which it is about the freshwater crayfish from the surroundings of Iaºi. The second one, much complex, is that of Scriban (1908), who reports Austropotamobius torrentium for the first time, from Racovãþ, Bahna basin (Mehedinþi county). Also Scriban made the first comment on the morphology and distribution of the species Astacus astacus, A. leptodactylus and Austropotamobius torrentium, mentioning their distinctive features. Also, he published the first drawings of these species (cephalothorax). Entz (1912) dedicated a large study to the crayfish of Hungary, where data on the crayfish of Transylvania are included. Probably it is the amplest paper dedicated to the crayfish of the Romanian fauna from the beginning of the last century, with numerous data on the outer morphology, distinctive features between species, with more detailed figures and with the very first morphometric measures, and also with much detailed data on the distribution in Transylvania.
    [Show full text]
  • Dunca, A.,M., the History of Hydraulic Structures Realized in Banat
    Scientific Bulletin of Politehnica University of Timişoara Transactions on HYDROTECHNICS Volume 62(76), Issue 2, 2017 The history of hydraulic structures realized in Banat hydrographical area (Romania) Andreea-Mihaela Dunca1 Abstract: Banat hydrographical area is situated in the In Timișoara, the largest and the most important western and south-western part of Romania and city of this region there is a rather old tradition in the includes the hydrographical basins of the rivers: field of hydrotechnical works, for the reason that the Aranca, Bega Veche, Bega, Timiș, Bârzava, Moravița, city initially situated on a low and marshy terrain, Caraș, Nera, Cerna and other smaller Danube river’s had to conduct a steady and constant struggle in tributaries. The relief of this region is very diverse, with altitudes that decrease from east to west and fluctuate order to combat excess water (Dunca, 2017). between 70 m and 2291 m. The characteristics of the The Banat hydrographical area which overlaps a hydrographical network and of the surface, which have part of the Banat historical region, is situated in the a very low drainage slope in the plain area, sometimes western and south-western part o Romania, bounded nonexistent as well as the limited possibilities of surface north of the Mureș river, south of the Danube and water infiltration, due to the low soil permeability, have east of the Romaniaʼs border with Serbia. From an in the past led to the occurrence of unstable administrative point of view this area spreads in our watercourses, with many channels that were often lost country on the territory of five countries: Timiș, in the lowlands where they formed large flood plain Caraș-Severin, Arad, Mehedinți and Hunedoara.
    [Show full text]
  • CINDY HSIEH Phone: 919.889.5921  E-Mail: [email protected]
    CINDY HSIEH Phone: 919.889.5921 E-Mail: [email protected] Professional Experience MSN Video | Edit Assist/Production Assistant 2013 Primetime Emmy Awards Duties included equipment pick-up/drop-off, downloading/organizing media, and creating scripts. Cross Creek Pictures | Intern June 2013 – present Duties include reading scripts, creating coverages, summarizing Kirkus book reviews and creating recommendations, and conferring with staff on production decisions. Carolina Film and Video Festival | Program Co-Director September 2012 – May 2013 Duties included screening applicants’ films, creating the programming for the festival, and marketing and event planning. Centerline Digital | Camera Operator and Digital Imaging Technician January 2012 – May 2013 Duties included operating the camera for interviews and downloading/organizing media from each camera on set. NBC | Researcher/Tape Assist January 2011 - present Duties include interviewing competitors/coaches, comprehension of the International Skating Union’s (ISU) judging system, assisting crew and talent with on-camera work, event analysis, and logging/transferring tapes. NBC Olympics | Researcher February 2010/2014, July 2012 Duties include researching athletes in various disciplines for print and broadcast media, comprehension of different sports’ judging systems and event analysis, assisting television coverage, and handling media requests. (Live events worked: 2010/2014 Winter Olympics and 2012 Summer Olympics.) Blackwing Media Group | Sound Recordist and Boom Operator February 2012 Duties included recording audio, monitoring levels, and handling the boom. Icenetwork | Social Media Producer/Researcher/Production Assistant October 2007 – January 2012 Duties included assisting on-camera talent, coordinating social media platforms (Twitter, etc.), organizing interviews, and comprehension of the ISU judging system. (Live television events, including: 2007 Skate America, 2009 World Championships, and 2010 & 2012 U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Elizaveta TUKTAMYSHEVA Place of Birth: Glazov Height: 157 Cm RUS Home Town: St
    LADIES Date of birth: 17.12.1996 Elizaveta TUKTAMYSHEVA Place of birth: Glazov Height: 157 cm RUS Home town: St. Petersburg Profession: student Hobbies: singing, watching TV, surfing the web Start sk. / Club: 1990 / Olympic School St. Petersburg Internet / Social Media contact: http://www.fskate.ru/skaters/75.html, http://vk.com/id38537529 Coach: Alexei Mishin Choreographer: Tatiana Prokofieva Former Coach: Svetlana Veretennikova Practice low season: h / week at Pinzolo/ITA, Erzurum/TUR, St. Petersburg Practice high season: h / week at St. Petersburg Music Short Program / Short Dance as of season 2014/2015 Bolero by Maurice Ravel Music Free Skating / Free Dance as of season 2014/2015 Batwannis Beek by The REG Project Sandstorm by La Bionda Personal Best Total Score 210.40 31.01.2015 ISU European Championships 2015 Personal Best Score Short Program 77.62 26.03.2015 ISU World Championships 2015 Personal Best Score Free Skating 141.38 31.01.2015 ISU European Championships 2015 07/08 08/09 09/10 10/11 11/12 12/13 13/14 14/15 Olympic Games World Champ. 10. 1. European Champ. 3. 1. Four Continents World Juniors 2. National Champ. 10.S 2.S 3.S 1.J 6.S 1.S 10.S 2.S S=Senior; J=Junior; N=Novice International Competition Year Place International Competition Year Place Golden Spin 2013 Zagreb 2013 3. ISU GP Hilton HHonors Skate America 2014 Chicago, Il 2014 2. Nebelhorn Trophy 2014 Oberstdorf 2014 1. ISU GP Lexus Cup of China 2014 Shanghai 2014 1. Finlandia Trophy 2014 Espoo 2014 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Mathematical Olympiad in China : Problems and Solutions
    Mathematical Blympiad in China Problems and Solutions This page intentionally left blank Mathematical Olympiad in China Problems and Solutions Editors Xiong Bin East China Normal University, China Lee Peng Yee Nanyang Technological University, Singapore East China Normal University Press World Scientific Editors XIONG Bin East China ~ormalUniversity, China LEE Peng Yee Nanpng Technological University, Singapore Original Authors MO Chinese National Coaches Team of 2003 - 2006 English Translators XIONG Bin East China NO~TTUZ~University, China FENG Zhigang shanghai High School, China MA Guoxuan hst China Normal University, China LIN Lei East China ~ormalUniversity, China WANG Shanping East China Normal university, China ZmNG Zhongyi High School Affiliated to Fudan University, China HA0 Lili Shanghai @baa Senior High School, China WEE Khangping Nanpng Technological University, singupore Copy Editors NI Ming mtChina NO~ZUniversity press, China ZMGJi World Scientific Publishing GI., Singapore xu Jin hst China Normal University press, China V This page intentionally left blank ... Preface The first time China sent a team to IMO was in 1985. At that time, two students were sent to take part in the 26th IMO. Since 1986, China has always sent a team of 6 students to IMO except in 1998 when it was held in %wan. So far (up to 2006) , China has achieved the number one ranking in team effort for 13 times. A great majority of students have received gold medals. The fact that China achieved such encouraging result is due to, on one hand, Chinese students’ hard working and perseverance, and on the other hand, the effort of teachers in schools and the training offered by national coaches.
    [Show full text]
  • ISU Communication 1876
    INTERNATIONAL SKATING UNION Communication No. 1876 Decisions of the ISU Council The ISU Council met on June 8 and 14, 2014 in Dublin, Ireland. The following were among the decisions taken by the Council during the meetings: 1. Full Membership Cyprus During its meeting on June 8, 2014 the Council agreed based on the membership status information received, to grant full membership for the Figure Skating Branch to the Cyprus Skating Federation. 2. 56th Ordinary ISU Congress 2016 – Dubrovnik/Croatia Based on the applications received, the ISU Council decided to hold the 56th Ordinary ISU Congress in Dubrovnik/Croatia on June 6-10, 2016, at the Dubrovnik Palace Hotel. 3. ISU Communications continued validity As per the decision of the 2014 Congress Dublin, Ireland, Agenda item no. 13. b), and in line with Article 27, paragraph 3 of the ISU Constitution the following Communications have continued validity: No. 1265 - Cut Resistant Clothing in Short Track Speed Skating No. 1416 - TV Celebrity Figure Skating Programs No. 1419 - ISU Disciplinary Commission Rules of Procedure No. 1420 - Citizenship-Rule 109 No. 1509 - Prize Money ISU Championships No. 1531 - ISU Development Program No. 1540 - Figure Skating - Use of papers/documents by Figure Skating Judges during competitions No. 1625 – Uniform/Racing Suits/Clothing No. 1629 – ISU World Standings for Single & Pair Skating & Ice Dance No. 1630 – ISU World Standings for Synchronized Skating No. 1631 – Single & Pair Skating-Ice Dance-Synchronized Skating – ISU Judging System – Evaluation of judging and technical content decisions, penalties No. 1693* – ISU Blood Screening Program No. 1694* – ISU Skater Biological Passport Program No.
    [Show full text]
  • Perspectives for Geotourism Development in the Bela Crkva Municipality (Serbia)
    Acta Geoturistica, volume 6 (2015), number 1, 1-10 Perspectives for geotourism development in the Bela Crkva municipality (Serbia) JOVANA BOŠKOV, STEFAN KOTRLA, NEMANJA TOMIĆ, MLAĐEN JOVANOVIĆ and IVAN RVOVIĆ Department of Geography, Tourism and Hotel Management, Faculty of Sciences, University of Novi Sad, Serbia, Trg Dositeja Obradovića 3 (Corresponding author e-mail: [email protected]) ABSTRACT The Bela Crkva municipality has a high concentration of geosites which are of great scientific, educational, aesthetic and touristic importance. These values are the result of a complex geological structure and geomorphological processes that took place in this area, during the Earth's history. The main goal of this paper is to present the possibility for geotourism development in the Bela Crkva municipality. One of the aims is also to investigate the attitudes of local people and tourists about geotourism development in the Bela Crkva municipality as well as their familiarity with the geopotential of this area. The paper proposes several important and easily accessible geosites which can provide an excellent basis for future geotourism development, however, research results indicate the need for better tourism infrastructure as well as better promotional activities in order to attract more visitors to the proposed geosites. Key words: geosites, geoheritage, geotourism, Bela Crkva, Serbia INTRODUCTION geosites and geomorphosites and their encompassing topography, together with In recent years, there has been an their associated in-situ and ex-situ artefacts, increasing number of different forms of to constituency-build for their conservation tourism on the global tourist market. One of by generating appreciation, learning and these special forms of tourism is research by and for current and future geotourism, that is primarily based on generations” (Hose, 2012).
    [Show full text]