Sinappi, St. Petersburg and Siikaniemi

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Sinappi, St. Petersburg and Siikaniemi SINAPPI, ST. PETERSBURG AND SIIKANIEMI The 13th, 14th and 15th theological discussions between the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Russian Orthodox Church Church Council, Helsinki 2013 Documents of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland – 13 SINAPPI, ST. Petersburg AND SIIKANIEMI The 13th, 14th and 15th theological discussions between the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Russian Orthodox Church Church Council, Helsinki 2013 Documents of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland – 13 Editor: Tomi Karttunen Translator: Marlena Whiting Layout: Hanna Sario Pictures on the front cover: St. Alexander Nevsky (Russian icon) and St. Martyr Bishop Henry (Bishop Arseni 2009, photograph Heikki Jääskeläinen) Printed in Unigrafia Publisher: Church Council Department for International Relations, Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland. ISBN (paperback) 978-951-789-429-6 ISBN (pdf) 978-951-789-430-2 Church Council issue 2011-00454 CONTENTS Foreword.............................................................................................................................................5 SINAPPI 2005 Communiqué ...................................................................................................................................12 Summary ...........................................................................................................................................19 The Fallen Man according to the Bible – Exegetical Perspectives: Professor Antti Laato .........................................................................................................24 Humans in the Bible (an exegetical perspective) Archimandrite Yannuary (Ivliyev) ....................................................................................43 The prospects of the will of sinful men and those made righteous from the perspective of belief in the Holy Triune God and the moral activity of man Professor Hans-Olof Kvist ................................................................................................51 Man – Image of God or Slave to Lust? (A dialogue between Christian and secular psychology) Father Andrei Lorgus .........................................................................................................67 The Foundations and Application of Lutheran Social Ethics Rev. Dr Antti Raunio .........................................................................................................83 Social Ethics in the Context of Theology and Philosophy of Religion Docent, Fr. Vladimir Šmalij .............................................................................................101 Europe’s Values Rev. Dr Kimmo Kääriäinen ............................................................................................116 Europe at a Crossroads: Spiritual and Ethical Perspectives of the Juxtaposition of Christianity and Secularism Hilarion, Bishop of Vienna and Austria ..........................................................................133 ST. PetersbUrg 2008 Communiqué ................................................................................................................................156 Abstract ..........................................................................................................................................162 Freedom as Gift and Responsibility in the Bible Archimandrite Yannuary (Ivliyev) .............................................................................................166 Freedom as Gift and Responsibility in the Bible Prof. Antti Laato ...............................................................................................................180 The Russian Orthodox Church and Human Rights Dean Vsevolod Chaplin ..................................................................................................200 Human Rights in Light of Christianity Professor Jaana Hallamaa ................................................................................................213 Religious Education from a Christian Point of View Father Vladimir Hulap ....................................................................................................236 Religious Education from a Christian Point of View Docent Jyri Komulainen .................................................................................................248 SIIKANIEMI 2011 Communiqué .................................................................................................................................274 Welcoming Address to the 15th Theological Discussion between the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Russian Orthodox Church Archbishop Kari Mäkinen ................................................................................................282 Addressed to the Participants of the 15th Theological Discussions Between the Russian Orthodox Church and the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland Hilarion, Metropolitan of Volokolamsk ...........................................................................284 God’s Church as Eschatological Reality in Apostle Paul’s Letters Archimandrite Yannuary (Ivliyev) ...................................................................................287 Christ’s Church: from the shadow of the Jerusalem temple to global church Professor Antti Laato, Åbo Akademi ...............................................................................297 Ecclesiology: the Unfinished Project Professor Vladimir Smalij ................................................................................................327 The Church as a Community. A Systematic Theological Perspective Bishop Matti Repo ...........................................................................................................345 Christian Identity and Church Membership from the Perspective of Practical Theology Archimandrite Kirill (Govorun) .......................................................................................364 The Ideal and the Reality: Commitment to Membership in the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland Bishop Seppo Häkkinen ...................................................................................................372 FOREWORD The ecumenical conversations between the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland (ELCF) and the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC), which were initiated by Archbishop Martti Simojoki and Metropolitan Nikodim, have been ongoing since 1970. The first concrete initiative was made in 1967 by Archbishop Simojoki, who suggested the idea of bilateral theological discussions to Patriarch Alexey. The wider ecumenical background was the discussions taking place between the Russian Orthodox Church and the German Evangelical Church. They had begun already in 1959 in the aftermath of the Second World War - when East-West relations began to become more tense and constructive contacts and reconciliation were especially needed.1 The general ecumenical climate was also influenced in the 1960s by the ecumenical revival brought about by the Second Vatican Council and the numerous bilateral theological dialogues initiated/undertaken by the Pontifical Council for Christian Unity in the late sixties. The dialogue between ELCF and ROC has proved to be fruitful in many ways. Its theological nature, underlined already by Archbishop Simojoki, led in the conversations of Kiev 1977 to the development of the paradigmatic idea of “Christ present in faith” (In ipsa fide Christus adest) in ecumenical Luther research on the initiative of Professor Tuomo Mannermaa and his students. The viewpoint convincingly demonstrated the parallels between Luther’s idea of justification as favor and donum and the Orthodox understanding of deification (theosis). It has been a useful tool in the discussions both for dogmatic and social ethical reflections and for the understanding of the Church and Christian life in today’s world. This discovery, which underscores the realistic and communal character of Martin Luther’s thinking as well as the union of faith and love in the believer through Christ’s presence in faith, has facilitated ecumenical convergence and consensus beyond the scope of this dialogue. The best known examples are the influence of this line of Luther interpretation on the Porvoo Common Statement (1992) and the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999). Also in the dialogue with the Methodists and Pentecostals the idea of the presence of Christ in the context of pneumatological and Trinitarian thought continues to be useful. Participation in the inner life of the Trinity, which lies at the heart of this interpretation of Luther, and the biblical and early Church roots of his theological 1 For ”The EKD-Russian Dialogue”, see e.g. Saarinen 1997, 84-127. 5 SINAPPI 2005 thoughts, connects the ecumenical interpretation of Luther with many of today’s ecumenical discussions regarding ecclesiology. It can be connected with the concept of “koinonia” as the biblical and theological framework for ecumenical ecclesiology. Ever since the Faith and Order conference in Santiago de Compostela in 1993, participation in the inner life of the Triune God as source of the life of the Church has provided important common ecumenical ground. For instance, in the new Faith and Order convergence text, The Church. Towards a Common Vision (2013), it is stated: “The Church is fundamentally a communion in the Triune God and, at the same time, a communion whose members partake together in the life and mission of God (cf. 2 Pet. 1:4), who, as Trinity,
Recommended publications
  • Putin Finds an Ally in Resurgent Orthodox Church
    The Washington Times November 12, 2015 Putin finds an ally in resurgent Orthodox Church by Marc Bennetts MOSCOW — How times have changed in Russia. Earlier this year, on the 145th anniversary of the birth of Vladimir Lenin, the head of the present- day Communist Party compared the founder of the officially atheist Soviet Union to Jesus Christ. Speaking at a ceremony on Red Square, where Lenin’s embalmed body remains on public display, Gennady Zyuganov said both Lenin and Jesus Christ had preached a message of “love, friendship and brotherhood.” Mr. Zyuganov also declared that the Soviet Union had been an attempt to create “God’s kingdom on Earth.” Mr. Zyuganov’s controversial statement was the culmination of a dramatic upturn in fortunes for the Russian Orthodox Church, which has seen its religious revival in the post-Soviet era matched by a growing, behind-the-scenes political clout, most recently by — literally — giving its blessing to Russian President Vladimir Putin’s decision to escalate the country’s military mission in Syria. Under the Soviet authorities, at least 200,000 members of the clergy were murdered, according to a 1995 Kremlin committee report, while millions of other Christians were persecuted. “The more representatives of the reactionary clergy we shoot, the better,” Lenin once said. Although Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin permitted a carefully controlled revival of the Orthodox Church to boost morale during World War II, anti-religion propaganda was common until the mid-1980s. Today, with some 70 percent of Russians identifying themselves as Orthodox Christians, no serious politician can afford to be seen as lacking in belief.
    [Show full text]
  • Religion, State and 'Sovereign Democracy' in Putin's Russia
    Religion, state and ‘sovereign democracy’ in Putin’s Russia John Anderson School of International Relations University of St Andrews, Fife, Scotland KY16 8EB (01334 462931; [email protected]) John Anderson is Professor of International Relations at the University of St Andrews. He has published widely on religion and politics in the Soviet Union and post-Soviet states, on religion and democratisation, on Christianity and politics in Russia, Europe and the USA, and on the politics of Central Asia. His most recent book is Conservative Christian Politics in Russia and the United States (Manchester University Press, 2015). 1 Abstract This article explores the role of the dominant Russian Orthodox Church in the evolution of the post-communist Russian Federation. This is not a classic case where religion may have contributed to the democratisation of society because this has not been a primary goal of political elites, and the regime that has emerged might best be described as ‘hybrid’ with growing authoritarian tendencies. Having played little role in the ending of communism, having little historical experience of working within a democracy, suspicious of liberal- individualist visions of public life and committed to a vision of its role as the hegemonic religious institution, the promotion of democratic governance has not been a priority of church leaders. At the same time the political structures created by the Kremlin encourage a degree of conformity and support for the regime by key social actors, and in the wake of the political crisis of 2011-12 there have been further incentives for church and state to work more closely together.
    [Show full text]
  • Clergy Personnel Manual Archdiocese of Portland Preface to the 2014 Edition of the Clergy Personnel Manual
    CLERGY PERSONNEL MANUAL ARCHDIOCESE OF PORTLAND PREFACE TO THE 2014 EDITION OF THE CLERGY PERSONNEL MANUAL On December 8, 1979 Archbishop Cornelius Power promulgated the Clergy Personnel Manual. This Manual was the product of extensive study and consultation by the Clergy Personnel Board and finally a vote of the entire presbyterate. Since the original promulgation of the Manual, some chapters have been revised. This edition prints all the chapters in a uniform format. The organization and position titles within the Pastoral Center have changed. This edition references positions of offices that coincide with our current Pastoral Center organization. This 2014 edition of the Clergy Personnel Manual reflects our current personnel policies and structure. Members of the Clergy Personnel Board: Rev. Todd Molinari, Most Rev. Alexander K. Sample, Most Rev. Peter Smith, Rev. Jeff Eirvin, Rev. James Coleman, Rev. Ronald Millican, Rev. Richard Thompson, Rev. Michael Vuky, Rev. Angelo Te. Vicar for Clergy: Rev. Todd Molinari Archbishop of the Archdiocese of Portland: Most Rev. Alexander K. Sample i PREFACE TO THE 1995 EDITION OF THE CLERGY PERSONNEL MANUAL On December 8, 1979, Archbishop Power promulgated the Clergy Personnel Manual. This Manual was the product of extensive study and consultation by the Clergy Personnel Board and finally a vote of the entire presbyterate. Since the original promulgation of the Clergy Personnel Manual, some chapters, like the one on area vicars, have been added; others, like the one on pastors, have been revised. This edition prints all the chapters in a uniform format and notes the date each chapter was promulgated or revised.
    [Show full text]
  • The Russian Orthodox Church,” in Andrei P
    Page 1 of 19 “The Russian Orthodox Church,” in Andrei P. Tsygankov, ed., Routledge Handbook of Russian Foreign Policy, (London: Routledge, 2018), pp. 217-232. Nicolai N. Petro Silvia-Chandley Professor of Peace Studies and Nonviolence University of Rhode Island Abstract: The recent “conservative turn” in Russian politics has raised to new levels the role of spiritual and moral values in political discourse. The new partnership formed between the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) and the state, a modernized version of the traditional Byzantine symphonia, has also affected Russian foreign policy. One notable example is the emergence of the “Russian World” as a key concept in Russia's relations with Ukraine and the rest of the CIS. Although the Church plays a subordinate role in this relationship, it is far from being merely the Kremlin’s puppet. By decentering the nation, this investigation seeks to shed light on the Church’s distinct approach to politics, and show where it draws the line on cooperation with civil authorities. Only by viewing the ROC as an autonomous political and eschatological actor, will we be able to appreciate how it influences Russian foreign policy. Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) has emerged as an influential actor in Russian foreign policy. This chapter explores the relationship between church and state in Russia. It examines the scholarly debate over the actual role of the Russian Orthodox Church in Russian foreign policy, as well as arenas for potential for conflict and cooperation between the church and the state in foreign policy.
    [Show full text]
  • Regime and Churches: What Is Therebetween? Religion In
    Issue 8 (38), 2013 RELIGION IN BELARUS: LIMITED INDEPENDENCE Since the concept of secular state has become a issue of “The Bell” is dedicated to answer these standard in a Western world long time ago, the questions. position of the Church is not very much discussed while speaking about the political issues. How- In the first article Anton Radniankou analyses the ever, there are tendencies of the rising interest of three biggest confessions in Belarus and reveals the Putin’s regime on involving Russian Orthodox their connection with the regime. He states, that Church to strengthening its power. while the Orthodox Church is the most familiar Anton Radniankou is a project to the government, Protestants are the least loyal manager of the Local Foundation And we might find similar approach of the Belar- to A.Lukashenka. “Interakcia”. He also edits intellec- usian regime. A.Lukashenka calls the Orthodox tual online magazine IdeaBY. Church as the main ideologist of the statehood, In the second article Natallia Vasilevich takes while remaining a non-believer – some kind of a deeper look into relations between Orthodox Natallia Vasilevich is a politi- strange “Orthodox atheist” composition. More- Church and the regime. She finds out that there cal scientist, lawyer and theolo- over, the Russian Orthodox Church authorities are different groups among the Church branches, gian. She is director of Centre have a direct influence on the Belarusian Church, which position ranges from pro-Russian to pro- “Ecumena” and editor of website forming its shape and ideology. It is clear that Nationalist wings. All in all, it is mostly influ- “Carkwa”.
    [Show full text]
  • Gospel Images of Jesus Christ in Church Tradition
    Gospel Images of Jesus Christ in Church Tradition and in Biblical Scholarship ISBN: Fifth International East-West Symposium of New Testament 9783161519086 (hb) Scholars, Minsk, September 2 to 9, 2010 PRICE: edited by Christos Karakolis, Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr and Sviatoslav $168.00 (hb) Rogalsky PUBLICATION DATE: DESCRIPTION: 31 December 2012 (hb) This collection of essays contains the papers given at the Fifth International East-West Symposium of New Testament Scholars in Minsk (Belarus). The symposium was a project of the Eastern Europe BINDING: Liaison Committee of Studiorum Novi Testamenti Societas. Main subject matters of the volume are hardback the history and methodological questions of modern Jesus research, approaches to the Jesus of history in ancient and modern Christian exegesis, Jesus as a Jew in ancient and modern exegesis, PAGES: and the portraits of Jesus in Luke and John. The authors of these papers deal with the parables of 458 Jesus, with his Galilean ministry, with the passion narrative in Mark and with the death of Christ according to Paul's letters. All topics are discussed from a Western (Protestant and Roman-Catholic) ILLUSTRATIONS: exegetical perspective as well as from an Orthodox point of view. A concluding report recapitulates Illus. the group discussions and seminar sessions of the symposium. Contributors: Charalampos Atmatzidis, Reimund Bieringer, Predrag Dragutinoviä?, Carl R. Holladay, Christos Karakolis, PUBLISHER: Dominika A. Kurek-Chomycz, Ulrich Luz, Joel Marcus, Vasile Mihoc, Tobias Nicklas, Karl-Wilhelm Mohr Siebeck Niebuhr, Marius Reiser, Armand Puig i Tàrrech, Sviatoslav Rogalsky, Ekaterini G. Tsalampouni, Konstantinos Th. Zarras IMPRINT: Mohr Siebeck TABLE OF CONTENTS: Preface<br> Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr: Introduction SERIES: Wissenschaftliche I Biblical Scholarship in Russia and Belarus<br> Metropolitan Philaret of Minsk and Slutsk: Church Untersuchungen zum Life and Biblical Scholarship in Belarus.
    [Show full text]
  • A Voluntary Local Review 2020 Turku
    A Voluntary Local Review 2020 The implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the City of Turku Opening statement by the Mayor Cities are facing major challenges – climate change, digitalisation and the ageing and increasingly diverse population greatly impact on cities’ field of operation and require cities to be able to adapt to constant change. Adaptation and adjustment to conventional ways of doing things is also needed in order to reach sustainability on a global level. Cities and city networks have an ever-growing role to play as global influencers and local advocates in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. Succeeding in accelerating sustainable development requires strong commitment and dedication from the city’s decision-makers and the whole city organization. Turku has a long tradition in promoting sustainable development and we want to make sure Turku is a good place to live in the future as well. Turku also wants to take responsibility and set an example in solving global sustainability challenges. That is why I consider it very important that Turku is among the first cities to participate in reporting city-level progress of achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. With this first VLR report, I am very proud to present the systematic work being done in Turku for sustainable development. I hope that the cities’ growing role in implementing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development becomes more visible to citizens, business life, organisations, other cities, government and other interest groups. Together we have a chance to steer the course of development in a more sustainable direction. A Voluntary Local Review 2020, The implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the City of Turku Minna Arve Authors: City of Turku.
    [Show full text]
  • Metropolitan Philaret of New York
    Metropolitan Philaret of New York That blessed day will come when the Lord will have mercy on the Russian land and Russian people, and piety will be enthroned there, as once it had been in Holy Russia. But while we live this lot in exile, while we belong to this Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, I repeat again, let us thank the Lord for this and try to be true to Her in every way. Faithfulness to the Truth in Sermons and Teachings of His Eminence Metropolitan Philaret (Vol. 1). Introduction On Sunday 21 November 2010, all churches of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia (ROCOR) commemorated the twenty-fifth anniversary of the repose of Metropolitan Philaret (Voznesensky), her third First Hierarch. Metropolitan of ROCOR, he was also a priest of the much-suffering Patriarchal Church for sixteen years between 1945 and 1961, and so is a bond of unity between the two parts of the Russian Orthodox Church. Moreover, he also represents hope for the future of Orthodoxy in China, where he lived for over forty years. A priest for thirty-one years and a bishop for twenty-two years, he is venerated by many as a holy man. Indeed, there are those who believe that one day, just like St John of Shanghai, he will be canonised by the whole Russian Orthodox Church, both in New York and in Moscow. We know that within ROCOR a service has already been composed to him and there are those who are now collecting testimonies about him. Let us look at his life and achievements.
    [Show full text]
  • The Old Cathedral of Viborg
    MIRATOR 16:1/2015 53 The Old Cathedral of Viborg Historical Archaeology of the Easternmost Cathedral of the Swedish Empire* Aleksandr Saksa and Panu Savolainen A Trans-Religious Sanctuary On 18 February 1940 an incendiary bomb wrecked the Old Cathedral of Viborg1. The fate of the edifice, since then a forlorn ruin, represents the unsettled history of the borderlands between Finland and Russia. The town, nowadays located in Russia, has been part of Sweden (1293–1710), Russia (1710–1917, 1944–) and Finland (1917–1944). The Old Town of Viborg, although largely renewed during successive occupations and re-buildings, still represents this transnational past where Swedish, German, Russian and Finnish histories of the Baltic have intertwined over the centuries (Fig. 1a). The multinational and polyglot history of Viborg has been underlined in a multitude of studies that cover the secular history of the town.2 The equivalent discussion of religious buildings and history has, in contrast, evoked little attention. Along with the transitions of power, religions have changed as well, settling down to the very same buildings one after another. The Old Cathedral of Viborg, the subject of the article, was a catholic sanctuary until the 1520s and a Lutheran church from the 1520s to 1710. Between 1554 and 1710 the church was the easternmost cathedral of the * The article was written in a project steered by the Mikael Agricola Society and funded by the Alfred Kordelin Foundation. 1 The Swedish name of the town ‘Viborg’ is used throughout the article since it mostly deals with the Swedish era. In Finnish the name of the town is Viipuri (or Wiipuri) and Vyborg (Выборг) in Russian.
    [Show full text]
  • COMMUNIQUÉ on the Twelfth Theological Discussions Between The
    COMMUNIQUÉ on the Twelfth Theological Discussions between the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Russian Orthodox Church. The twelfth theological discussions between the delegations of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Russian Orthodox Church was held at the Danilovski Monastery in Moscow on 28th September – 5th October 2002. The aim was to produce a joint evaluation of the conversations conducted since 1970 and to plan future continuations to these. The first theological discussions between these two churches were held in 1970 in Sinappi, Turku (Finland), the second in 1971 in Zagorsk (Russia/USSR), the third in 1974 in Järvenpää (Finland), the fourth in 1977 in Kiev (Ukraine/USSR), the fifth in 1980 in Turku, the sixth in 1983 in Leningrad (Russia/USSR), the seventh in 1986 in Mikkeli (Finland), the eighth in 1989 in the Orthodox Convent of Dormition in Pyhtitsa (Piukhtitsa, Estonia/USSR) and Leningrad, the ninth in 1992 in Järvenpää, and the tenth in 1995 in the Convent of Christ’s Ascension (Florov) in Kiev (Ukraine) and the eleventh in Lappeenranta in 1998. * * * The members of the delegation of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland (ELCF) were Rt. Rev. Jukka PAARMA, Archbishop of Turku and Finland (leader of the delegation), Rev. Dr. Voitto HUOTARI, Bishop of Mikkeli, Rev. Dr. Juha PIHKALA, Bishop of Tampere, Prof. Gunnar af HÄLLSTRÖM, of the Faculty of Theology, University of Joensuu, Prof. Antti LAATO of the Faculty of Theology, Åbo Akademi University, Rev. Irja ASKOLA, planner in the Department of International Affairs, Diaconia Polytechnic, Helsinki, Ms. Sylvia RAULO, programme officer of Finnchurchaid, and Prof.
    [Show full text]
  • From Stockholm to Tallinn the North Between East and West Stockholm, Turku, Helsinki, Tallinn, 28/6-6/7/18
    CHAIN Cultural Heritage Activities and Institutes Network From Stockholm to Tallinn the north between east and west Stockholm, Turku, Helsinki, Tallinn, 28/6-6/7/18 Henn Roode, Seascape (Pastose II, 1965 – KUMU, Tallinn) The course is part of the EU Erasmus+ teacher staff mobility programme and organised by the CHAIN foundation, Netherlands Contents Participants & Programme............................................................................................................2 Participants............................................................................................................................3 Programme............................................................................................................................4 Performance Kalevala..............................................................................................................6 Stockholm................................................................................................................................10 Birka...................................................................................................................................11 Stockholm...........................................................................................................................13 The Allah ring.......................................................................................................................14 The Vasa.............................................................................................................................15
    [Show full text]
  • The Ordained Christian Ministry from the Patristic Era to the Late Middle Ages
    47 H. Econe Porter CHURCH AND MINISTRY FROM HIPPOLYTUS TO THE CONCILIARISTS The Ordained Christian Ministry from the Patristic Era to the Late Middle Ages From the age of the church fathers through the late middle ages represents nearly three quarters of Christian history. with all that this involves. Nonetheless. I have been asked to survey what I know about the ordained leadership of the Christian church during this long period. Obviously. much must be omitted. I will endeavor at least to touch on matt~rs which interest me and which I hope will interest you. I. Summary of Patristic System Let us first summarize and recall the system which had been in effect in all catholic or orthodox Christian communities. so far as we know, at least since the beginning of the third century. This system is described in the Apostolic Tradition of HippoZytus and other church orders. and is alluded to in the writings of St. Cyprian and many other church fathers. 1 In each city where there was a Christian community. it was presided over by a bishop. In all the larger places this was a full time occupation and the bishop was supported by the church, unless he was a lando~~:ner or man of means. as a few were. He might be celibate, or a widower, or the husband of one wife, as in I Timothy 3:2. The Reverend Dr. H. Boone Porter is editor of The Living Church. 48 The bishop supervised and directed the church in conjunction with a council or assembly of presbyters or elders.
    [Show full text]