DOCSLIB.ORG

Pbl Constitutional Reform 02 Eng.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Pbl Constitutional Reform 02 Eng.Pdf Executive Summary Chapter I: Westminster in the Caribbean: Viability Past and Present, Prospects for Reform or Radical Change A. Impetus for Change B. Governance: The Heart of the Matter C. The Crucial Role of Civil Society D. Critiquing Westminster E. The Power-Sharing Option F. Reforming Westminster Chapter II: The Constitutional Reform Process: Commissions, Procedures and the Role of Civil Society A. Lessons from the Reform Process in Belize B. The Challenge of Sustaining Civic Action C. Utilizing New Technologies and the Media D. A New Emphasis for Constitutional Reform Commissions Chapter III: Local Government: Decentralization, Citizen Input and Community Action in Governance and Development A. Citizen-Driven Governance B. Local Government Reform and Constitutional Reform Chapter IV: Regional Integration: Small States and Political Sovereignty in a Global Economy A. Constitutional Requirements of Integration B. Caribbean Courts of Justice Chapter V: Summary of Recommendations A. Proposals for Improving Westminster B. Proposals for Integrating Civil Society into the Political System C. Proposals for Strengthening Civil Society in the Constitutional Reform Process and in Governance D. Proposals with regard to the Constitutional Reform Process E. Proposals regarding Local Government F. Proposals regarding Regional Integration G. Proposals regarding the International Community Executive Summary By 2001, no fewer than 11 nations of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) had embarked on or were considering reform of their constitutions, and a number of them have asked the Organization of American States (OAS) and the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) for assistance in carrying out the process. To promote a deeper understanding of the trend, to further the effort and to help point a way forward, the OAS Unit for the Promotion of Democracy (UPD), in coordination with the UNDP, organized a conference on “Constitutional Reform in the Caribbean.” Held in Barbados from January 20 to 22, 2002, the gathering constituted part of the OAS "Democratic Forum Series" and was hosted in conjunction with the University of the West Indies (UWI). The Conference on Constitutional Reform in the Caribbean was not conceived as a mere academic exercise. It was designed as a participatory event including representatives from various sectors of Caribbean society and reflecting different national experiences, and sought to contribute concretely to the current debate in the region regarding the enhancement of democratic governance in the region and the optimal ways to achieve it. The keynote speakers and panelists presented a number of different perspectives in order to give a forthright assessment of the progress, or lack thereof, of the effort to reform Caribbean constitutions and make government more responsive, inclusive and transparent.[1] To ensure a broad range of views, the nearly 60 participants included national leaders, members of parliament, civic organizers, legal experts, members of constitutional reform commissions, scholars, political activists and representatives of international institutions from throughout the English-speaking Caribbean and Suriname. The panel discussions focused on four issues: • Westminster in the Caribbean – Viability Past and Present, Prospects for Reform or Radical Departure. • The Constitutional Reform Process – Commissions, Procedures and the Role of Civil Society. • Local Government – Decentralization, Citizen Input and Community Action in Governance and Development. • Regional Integration – Small States and Political Sovereignty in a Global Economy. The organizers of the conference drafted terms of reference that outlined the points of discussion on these themes and posed general questions for participants to address. They noted that the four themes are linked, particularly with regard to the need to enhance the role of civil society in the constitutional reform process, in governance overall and in the regional integration effort. The conference organizers recognize that the list of topics is not exhaustive, and acknowledge that time limitations did not provide for a complete discussion of all the issues and how they are manifested in the different political contexts of the Caribbean. It is the hope of the organizers, however, that the proceedings of the conference will constitute the beginning of a sustained inter-sectoral debate on the status of constitutional reform and governance issues in the region. As OAS Secretary General César Gaviria noted in his inaugural remarks, "the OAS [did] not come here with any pre-conceived notions for constitutional reform. We appreciate that the issues are as complex and varied as the countries themselves. By casting our net wide by including many different points of view and encouraging lively discussions we hope to contribute in some small but helpful way.” During the conference, a number of generally shared viewpoints emerged: A. The constitutional reform trend is driven by a widespread desire, at all levels of Caribbean society, for better governance and greater equity. In the face of mounting global pressures there is a need, and a growing popular demand among increasingly knowledgeable citizens, for more effective democracy that can improve people’s lives. As Secretary General Gaviria said, there is a “new spirit” in the region to “deepen democracy.” Participants also noted that democracy in the region must appropriately reflect the socio-cultural realities of the Caribbean. B. Participants generally favored reform rather than radical change of the Westminster model of parliamentary government, noting the relative resilience of democracy in the region, particularly in comparison to the rest of the developing world. At the same time, weaknesses, limitations and imbalances in the current system were examined in detail, and concerns were expressed that four decades after the first of the English-speaking nations achieved independence, there was “a crisis of governance,” which could lead to instability in the region unless serious and substantial reforms were implemented. C. A general belief that one key to effective reform is maximizing citizen participation in the constitutional reform process, in governance generally and in the Caribbean integration effort Participants underlined the need to integrate civil society into the governing process at the local national and regional levelsas part of a more consultative and consensual approach to policy making and implementation. As stated by Sheilah Solomon, Coordinator of the Trinidad and Tobago based Citizens Caribbean Agenda Network: “The emphasis must be on equity in the decision- making process. Equity cannot be quantified, but equitable decision-making can produce more equitable results.” Related specifically to constitutional reform efforts, it was generally agreed that constitutional reform commissions should reorient their work and place greater emphasis on citizen participation and input. D. Participants agreed that governments should be more responsive and more willing to collaborate with civil society. Strengthening civil society should not mean weaker government, but can and should lead to greater willingness on the part of both to engage in mutual and complementary efforts for improved governance. For that to happen, governments and political parties need to be more open and less wedded to adversarial politics and top-down approaches. E. Deepening regional integration, both economic and political, was viewed as necessary for economic growth and prosperity and the preservation of Caribbean sovereignty in the face of an increasingly challenging global environment. Participants generally favored the establishment of the Caribbean Court of Justice as a final court of appeal and as the jurisdiction for hearing trade disputes under the Caribbean Single Market and Economy (CSME) and other regional agreements. F. The international community should enhance its role in fostering debate and cooperation on the issue of constitutional reform between Caribbean countries and among the different sectors of Caribbean society. Despite various experiences with constitutional reform in the Caribbean, many political and civil society leaders involved in these processes are not sufficiently familiarized with developments outside of their own countries. In the roundtable setting of the conference, participants were not asked to agree formally on a set of concrete measures. However, participants made proposals and recommendations, many of which drew wide support, particularly measures designed to_improve the Westminster model, to strengthen civil society and better integrate it into the process of governance, and to enhance cooperation on constitutional reform at the regional and international levels. All are discussed in the body of the Report and summarized in the concluding chapter. [1] To review the full texts of the panel presentations, please go to the website of the OAS Unit for the Promotion of Democracy http://www.upd.oas.org click on “Information and Dialogue,” then on “Democratic Forum.” CHAPTER I: WESTMINSTER IN THE CARIBBEAN: VIABILITY PAST AND PRESENT, PROSPECTS FOR REFORM OR RADICAL CHANGE There was little dispute over the positive aspects of the Westminster experience in the Caribbean. As Billie Miller, Deputy Prime Minister of Barbados, stated: “On balance the Caribbean’s record of constitutional government has been based on a clear respect for the rule of law, parliamentary democracy, the sanctity of
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Caribbean State Posture, Merchant Capital and the Export Services Option
    Third World Quarterly, Vol 23, No 4, pp 725–751, 2002 At whose service? Caribbean state posture, merchant capital and the export services option DON D MARSHALL ABSTRACT Elite planners in the Eastern Caribbean sub-region pin their hopes of economic viability on tourism, a vibrant offshore financial (and other) services sector and an increase in export activity from companies operating out of industrial parks. Framed against the perception of an inevitable globalisation process underway, with limitations posed to high-level or diversified manu- facturing, power holders have sought to concentrate on the promotion of ‘export services’ as a viable cover against new competitive challenges. This article argues, however, that this state of affairs betrays a crisis-of-mission within the ruling class on how to reconstruct political economies marked by the hegemony of merchant capital. Rather than a move towards what are globally the most remunerative factors of production—high-level manufacturing and services—a rather curious consensus has emerged which proclaims a solid future for export services without roots and/or ganglia to local manufacturing. The success of such an ‘export services’ model anywhere in the Eastern Caribbean will not turn as much on the quality of human resources as it will on overcoming the short- term horizon of local politicians, and the low-risk predilections of the wealthy planter–merchant elite. The latter’s conscious ‘opt out’ strategy on the question of manufacturing diversity has made for a strikingly conservative enterprise culture. More specifically, merchant capitalist societies like those in the Eastern Caribbean insufficiently display the sociocultural attributes required for the creation of high-level services: innovation-mediated risk, research and develop- ment competence, and affinities to industrial processes and networks.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitutional Reform in the English-Speaking Caribbean: Challenges and Prospects
    Constitutional Reform in the English-Speaking Caribbean: Challenges and Prospects A report prepared for the Conflict Prevention and Peace Forum January 2011 The Constitutional Design Group Principals Zachary Elkins | [email protected] Tom Ginsburg | [email protected] Lead Research Associate Justin Blount | [email protected] The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not reflect those of CPPF or the Social Science Research Council. Constitutional Reform in the ESC p. 2 CONTENTS Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 3 Historical Perspectives on Constitutional Reform in the ESC ................................................. 4 Decolonization and the Independece Constitutions ............................................................... 4 The Rise and Fall of the West Indies Federation ................................................................... 5 Characteristics of ESC Constitutions ......................................................................................... 6 Some General Notes on the Nature of ESC Constitutional Texts ......................................... 7 Executives, Legislatures, and the Judiciary ........................................................................... 8 Fidelity to the Westminster Parliamentary System ........................................................... 8 The Judiciary .....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Barbados Advocate
    Established October 1895 See inside Monday March 22, 2021 $1 VAT Inclusive NUPW MAKING STRIDES DURING PANDEMIC PRESIDENT of the National McDowall told those in atten- The NUPW head also re- we continue to work on for our care that we will be able to push Union of Public Workers dance, “We vigorously negoti- vealed that there is now a pol- members. past this moment in our his- (NUPW), Akanni McDowall ated with government to ensure icy put forward by the union “We remain firm in our re- tory... I wish to reiterate that says the union has accom- that the BOSS program was that provides the framework for solve to fight injustices perpe- we remain focused as an objec- plished a lot, even more so voluntary and not forced as flexible working arrangements trated against our membership. tive of representing the inter- in the context of the pan- originally proposed. We have and working from at home. Because quality representation ests of our membership.” demic. been able to make some head- “High on the agenda moving for our workers is our goal, and He gave the assurance that He was delivering brief re- way in improving the lives of forward is a discussion about delivering equality for all is our as the NUPW enters its 76th marks at the St. George Parish public servants by ensuring our altering the senior public serv- defining purpose as a union.We year, it will continue to grow church yesterday as the NUPW public officers were appointed. ice posts and the implications must also continue to be each and adapt to meet the changing starts its week of activities to We are still in the process of ad- for public officers.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of Political Independence and Its Future
    The Time of Sovereignty: The History of Political Independence and its Future Dr. Richard Drayton Monday, November 28, 2016 Frank Collymore Hall Tom Adams Financial Centre It is a great honour, pleasure and privilege to give the Sir Winston Scott Memorial Lecture of the Central Bank of Barbados. It is particularly moving to me to look out at this crowd of 500 and see so many people I have known for over forty years, and in particular so many of the elders who formed me. I am conscious that my predecessors include such senior figures in the history of economics as Ernst Schumacher and the Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz and such deans of Caribbean intellectual life as Rex Nettleford and Gordon Rohlehr. I am particularly humbled, as a Barbadian, to give this 41st Lecture as part of the 50th anniversary celebrations of the independence of Barbados. (Clearly, Rihanna was unavailable). I came to this island from Guyana only as a boy of 8. So it was not from hazard of birth but mature choice that I joined you in citizenship. I take no second place to the birth right Bajan in my love for this rock in which my roots are tangled with yours for all time. Our 50th anniversary is a joyful occasion. It is at the same time as a sobering one, when one reflects on the generations of ancestors, living and dying under conditions of the most extraordinary inhumanity, who made our presence today possible. If this Golden Jubilee celebration has any meaning, we need to remember why we sought political sovereignty.
    [Show full text]
  • The National Strategic Plan of Barbados 2005-2025
    THE NATIONAL ANTHEM In plenty and in time of need When this fair land was young Our brave forefathers sowed the seed From which our pride is sprung, A pride that makes no wanton boast Of what it has withstood That binds our hearts from coast to coast - The pride of nationhood. Chorus: We loyal sons and daughters all Do hereby make it known These fields and hills beyond recall Are now our very own. We write our names on history’s page With expectations great, Strict guardians of our heritage, Firm craftsmen of our fate. The Lord has been the people’s guide For past three hundred years. With him still on the people’s side We have no doubts or fears. Upward and onward we shall go, Inspired, exulting, free, And greater will our nation grow In strength and unity. 1 1 The National Heroes of Barbados Bussa Sarah Ann Gill Samuel Jackman Prescod Can we invoke the courage and wisdom that inspired and guided our forefathers in order to undertake Charles Duncan O’neal the most unprecedented Clement Osbourne Payne and historic transformation in our economic, social and physical landscape since independence in Sir Hugh Springer 1966? Errol Walton Barrow Sir Frank Walcott Sir Garfield Sobers Sir Grantley Adams 2 PREPARED BY THE RESEARCH AND PLANNING UNIT ECONOMIC AFFAIRS DIVISION MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMIC AFFAIRS GOVERNMENT HEADQUARTERS BAY STREET, ST. MICHAEL, BARBADOS TELEPHONE: (246) 436-6435 FAX: (246) 228-9330 E-MAIL: [email protected] JUNE, 2005 33 THE NATIONAL STRATEGIC PLAN OF BARBADOS 2005-2025 FOREWORD The forces of change unleashed by globalisation and the uncertainties of international politics today make it imperative for all countries to plan strategically for their future.
    [Show full text]
  • Retailers Encouraged to Keep Prices Down
    Established October 1895 It’s red…red…red! Monday March 16, 2020 $1 VAT Inclusive RETAILERS ENCOURAGED TO KEEP PRICES DOWN AS the COVID-19 virus spreads throughout the world, a local government minister is not only urging Barbadians not to panic, but is putting the case to retailers and wholesalers in this country not to jack up their prices. Minister of Small Business, Entrepreneurship and Commerce, Dwight Sutherland issued the appeal while speaking to The Barbados Advocate yesterday morning, on the sidelines of a service at Love and Light Ministries, which is based at the St. George Secondary School, to mark World Consumer Rights Day. Sutherland noted that while Barbados remained virus free, with the spread of the novel coronavirus in the Caribbean, persons living here have been stocking up on goods including hand sanitisers and other disinfecting products, which he ad- mitted has resulted in such items being in short supply. However, the Commerce Minister says stock is on its way and he is hopeful that no exorbitant prices will be charged when those items reach here. “We believe the way to address this is to have consultation with the With concerns growing about the novel coronavirus, the congregation at Love and Light Ministries, linked arms instead of stakeholders and involve the retailers holding hands during yesterday’s service. Here, Dwight Sutherland (right), Minister of Small Business, Entrepreneurship and suppliers. There is a tendency in the and Commerce, links arms with Co-Pastor, Kathyann Harewood. international world for people to engage in price gouging; we have not seen it here and the Barbados Chamber of Commerce protect the consumer.
    [Show full text]
  • Cultural Adaptation and the Westminster Model: Some Examples from Fiji and Samoa
    Cultural Adaptation and the Westminster Model: Some Examples from Fiji and Samoa by Richard Herr Law Faculty, University of Tasmania and Adjunct Professor of Governance and Ethics, Fiji National University. for HOW REPRESENTATIVE IS REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY? Australasian Study of Parliament Group ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2 OCTOBER 2014 Author’s Caution: This paper very much reflects the author’s interpretation of events in which the author has a continuing involvement. Its analysis meant to be objective as possible but objectivity itself can be controversial in uncertain times. This difficulty is cannot be resolved but it is acknowledged. Cultural Adaptation of the Westminster Model: Some Examples from Fiji and Samoa R.A. Herr* Paper Abstract: The Westminster form of responsible government has been extensively adopted and adapted countries around the world including many of the 14 independent and self‐governing states in the Pacific Island region. Yet, either formally or through the informal continuation of customary practices pre‐Westminster political processes remain contemporary influences within the region. This paper touches on two sources of tension in the process of cultural adaptation of the Westminster system in the region. Samoa has long managed to draw a stable, majority‐supported ministry from the parliament without significant difficulty but electorally its non‐ liberal traditional system has proved challenging. The accommodation has worked consistently over decades to preserve fa’a Samoa (Samoan custom) as a central element in its political processes. By contrast, following the December 2006 military coup, Fiji had also sought to remove its non‐liberal traditional elements in order to address the sources of domestic tension that stemmed from the use of the Westminster system.
    [Show full text]
  • The British Parliament-House of Commons Page 01
    THE BRITISH PARLIAMENT-HOUSE OF COMMONS PAGE 01 Table of Contents 1. Letter from the Chair 2. Introduction 3. Members of the Parliament (Delegate expectations) 4. Special procedure Topic: Counter terrorism in Great Britain a. History of terrorism in the United Kingdom b. Threat of terrorism at Home c. Role and Scope of the Security Agencies d. Border Security and Migrant Crisis 6. QARMAs 7. Recommended bibliography 8. References GOING BEYOND PAGE 2 1. Letter from the Chair. Dear Members of Parliament, It is our honour to welcome you to EAFITMUN and to the committee. We are Eduardo Tisnes Zapata, law student at EAFIT University and Federico Freydell Mesa, law student at El Rosario University, and we will be chairing EAFITMUN’s House of Commons. The last few years, have put this House under pressure for reasons involving the exit of the United Kingdom from the European Union, overseas and domestic terrorism and security crises; the flow of migrants from the Middle East and Africa and the lack of political consensus between the Government and the Opposition. The challenges you will face in the committee will not only require from you background academic knowledge, but they will demand your best abilities to negotiate between parties and to propose solutions that work best for the British people, meeting halfway and reaching across the House. As it is obvious we cannot have 650 MPs, therefore we will try to reproduce the Commons’ majorities and parties representation in the House. Nevertheless, no party will hold an overall majority, making solution and policymaking more challenging.
    [Show full text]
  • Australia's System of Government
    61 Australia’s system of government Australia is a federation, a constitutional monarchy and a parliamentary democracy. This means that Australia: Has a Queen, who resides in the United Kingdom and is represented in Australia by a Governor-General. Is governed by a ministry headed by the Prime Minister. Has a two-chamber Commonwealth Parliament to make laws. A government, led by the Prime Minister, which must have a majority of seats in the House of Representatives. Has eight State and Territory Parliaments. This model of government is often referred to as the Westminster System, because it derives from the United Kingdom parliament at Westminster. A Federation of States Australia is a federation of six states, each of which was until 1901 a separate British colony. The states – New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia and Tasmania - each have their own governments, which in most respects are very similar to those of the federal government. Each state has a Governor, with a Premier as head of government. Each state also has a two-chambered Parliament, except Queensland which has had only one chamber since 1921. There are also two self-governing territories: the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory. The federal government has no power to override the decisions of state governments except in accordance with the federal Constitution, but it can and does exercise that power over territories. A Constitutional Monarchy Australia is an independent nation, but it shares a monarchy with the United Kingdom and many other countries, including Canada and New Zealand. The Queen is the head of the Commonwealth of Australia, but with her powers delegated to the Governor-General by the Constitution.
    [Show full text]
  • Cavehill Uwi Report 2006.Pdf
    C o n t e n t s Chairman’s Statement ..............................3 Principal’s Report .....................................5 Teaching and Learning ...........................21 Research and Development ...................28 Publications ............................................31 Student News .........................................33 Administrators of the Campus ...............36 Members of Campus Council ................37 Campus Management ............................38 Financial Summary .................................41 Outreach – University and Campus .......43 Outreach – Faculties and Departments ..44 Campus Events ......................................47 Saluting Achievement .............................49 Recognition ................................................... 51 Statistics (charts) ....................................54 Benefactors ............................................64 International Visitors ...............................67 “[This] Report points to success in our efforts to open up access to larger numbers of those seeking entry to our Campus; it speaks of important expansion and innovation in programming; the provision of enhanced student amenities; improvements to the physical infrastructure and administrative procedures; and the development of a graduate studies and research agenda tailored to regional development needs.” The University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus ANNUAL REPORT 2006 Chairman’s Statement The Cave Hill Campus’ Annual Report 2005-2006 In a dynamic and competitive global educational
    [Show full text]
  • Cleviston Haynes: Debt Exchange
    Central Bank of Barbados Tom Adams Financial Centre, Spry Street, Bridgetown P.O. Box 1016 Telephone: (246) 436-6870 : Fax. (246) 436-7836 E-Mail Address: [email protected] Website: www.centralbank.org.bb Remarks by Mr. Cleviston Haynes Governor, Central Bank of Barbados at “Debt Exchange – Risks and Opportunities: Leveraging the Jamaican Experience” Courtney Blackman Grande Salle Thursday, November 15, 2018 On behalf of the Management and staff of the Central Bank, I welcome everyone to this workshop, which is geared towards sharing insights on the functioning of the money and capital markets in the aftermath of the restructuring of Barbados’ domestic debt. I take this opportunity to thank NCB Capital Markets Barbados Limited for its willingness to share with us their experience and knowledge gained from the Jamaica Debt restructuring exercise in 2013. On June 1, 2018, the newly-elected administration announced the unprecedented decision that Barbados had decided to suspend the servicing of commercial foreign debt payments and restructure both domestic and external debt. The purpose was to limit foreign reserves outflows, while securing meaningful and gradual debt reduction, thereby reducing financing needs and restoring debt sustainability. The subsequent launch of a comprehensive domestic debt restructuring exercise on September 7 2018, as a critical component of the Barbados Economic Recovery Transformation (BERT) Programme, achieved near unanimous acceptance of the debt exchange proposals, with 97% participation by creditors. The terms of the new instruments involve some sacrifice by all bondholders, as Government seeks to balance the fiscal imperatives, including anchoring the BERT programme through a reduction in the debt-to-GDP ratio to 60% by 2033, against the need to preserve financial stability and protect the long-term interests of small bondholders.
    [Show full text]
  • Westminster Model Or Westminster Muddle? a Term in Search of a Meaning
    THIS IS DRAFT WORK - PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE OR CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE AUTHORS Westminster Model or Westminster Muddle? A Term in Search of a Meaning Paper to 12th Workshop of Parliamentary Scholars and Parliamentarians Wroxton College, Oxfordshire, 25-26 July 2015 Meg Russell and Ruxandra Serban Constitution Unit, Department of Political Science, University College London Contact: [email protected] Abstract Those working in parliamentary studies will be well acquainted with the term Westminster model', which continues to be widely used in both the academic and practitioner literature. But closer examination of this term suggests significant confusion about its meaning. It began as a descriptor for the UK political system, and gradually developed a broader meaning in comparative politics, to include a 'family' of Westminster model countries. More recently it has become associated with Arend Lijphart's widely cited work which uses the model as an ideal type, representing centralised, majoritarian government. In this paper we follow Giovanni Sartori's advice for 'reconstructing' a social science term whose meaning may be unclear, by reviewing its use in the recent literature. We find that many authors use the term without definition, while those who do provide definitions suggest a large (and sometimes conflicting) set of attributes associated with the model, and a set of countries which frequently do not demonstrate these attributes. Some authors have suggested variants such as "Washminster" or "Eastminster" in order to reflect this diversity, while others have suggested that the term should be seen as a 'family resemblance' rather than a classical social science concept.
    [Show full text]