DOCSLIB.ORG

Velikovsky: Psychiatrist, Historian and Catastrophist

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Velikovsky: Psychiatrist, Historian and Catastrophist Velikovsky: psychiatrist, historian and catastrophist JOHN D. ILES, MD Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky died on Nov. 1 7, 1979, at his home in Princeton, New Jersey, at the age of 84. In 1981, a geophysicist com- mented in the Toronto Globe & Mail: "The recent death of Imma- nuel Velikovsky brought to an end a fascinating saga of controversy, claim and counterclaim". This scholar's theories, particularly in as- tronomy, geology and archaeology, have provoked almost hysterical re- actions from some orthodox pro- fessional scientists since 1950, and since 1969 the achievements of the space age have rekindled contro- versy as a number of his startling 'advance claims' (Velikovsky him- self objected to the word 'predic- tions' as smacking of the sooth- sayer) were confirmed. Eventually, a small minority of scientists be- came convinced that his ideas de- served serious reconsideration. The tempo of claims and counterclaims makes a fascinating saga, and there is no end in sight. A biographical sketch may help to make clear what the scientific rumpus is about and how it all began. Velikovsky was born in Russia in 1895. His father, a businessman, was also a scholar of Hebrew who became involved in promoting a Jewish national home in Palestine: Immanuel Velikovsky: destined to upset the chronologic applecart and arouse after the Russian revolution, and the scientific community to a state of furious indignation. the end of World War I, he was threatened with arrest, so the fam- Kharkov and Moscow universities, of the scientific papers, and thus ily moved to the Ukraine and then gaining his MD in 1921. Later that began a lifelong friendship. Veli- to the Caucasus. Despite these year the family was granted exit kovsky was married in 1923 to troubled times, young Velikovsky, permits for Palestine and moved to Elisheva Kramer (who survives whose pre-clinical studies in Edin- Berlin as a first step. Here Veli- him): the couple shortly reached burgh were interrupted in 1914 by kovsky helped in scholarly research Palestine. the outbreak of war, managed to and in publishing papers by Jewish At first Dr. Velikovsky did gen- complete his study of medicine at scholars aimed at eventually found- eral practice in Jerusalem and later, Dr.lies is a retired general practitioner ing a Hebrew university in Jerusa- after psychiatric training in Europe, living in Brechin, Ont. lem. Albert Einstein was the editor practised psychoanalysis in Haifa 496 CMA JOURNAL/SEPTEMBER 1, 1981/VOL. 125 and in Tel Aviv. Two papers he view the main steps in this aston- tioned asiatic invaders named the wrote are of some interest; in 1931 ishing process. Hyksos, a vital link in fixing the he suggested that EEGs might A sudy of Moses naturally en- period of these events because it prove diagnostic in epilepsy, and tailed a thorough appraisal of all was known that the Hyksos had the other paper was a psychoanal- the circumstances of the Exodus, brought about the fall of the Middle ytic study of Freud himself ('The and Velikovsky soon realized that Kingdom of Egypt, and had ruled Dreams That Freud Dreamed'). He if there were any truth in the bibli- the country from the XIVth had in mind a book on Freud and cal account, the Exodus must have through the XVIIth Dynasties. so, in 1939, he paid what was to been a time of great natural dis- This lucky discovery, however, have been just a few months visit asters. It should be emphasized that created a dilemma. The end of the to the US. His purpose was to comb scholars have never been able to Middle Kingdom had been conven- reference libraries for data and agree on the date of the Exodus; tionally dated to the 18th century commentary on Oedipus, Akhnaton opinions range over several cen- BC, too early by several centuries and Moses - characters who had turies, the main reason being the to fit the Exodus according to He- all figured largely in Freud's own failure of the Egyptians to leave be- brew chronology. Scholars had al- studies. This visit was prolonged hind any mention of what was a ways preferred to look for a likely into permanent residence in the momentous occasion for the Is- date in New Kingdom history. If US, and it proved to be the turning raelites. Well aware of this deficien- the Exodus took place at the same point in Velikovsky's career. cy, Velikovsky began to look in- time as the Hyksos invasion, it It may seem odd that an aca- stead for ancient Egyptian records raised the dilemma that either He- demic study of Moses should have of natural disasters. Eventually, in brew history was too short by sev- escalated into a worldwide study of the papyrus Ipuwer, preserved since eral centuries, or that Egyptian ancient history which would cul- 1828 in Leiden University in Hol- history was too long by the same minate eventually in a bestseller land and translated in 1909 by the amount. destined to arouse the scientific well-known Egyptologist A.H. Gar- Velikovsky's next step was to community to a state of furious in- diner, he found what he was look- make a close study of the accepted dignation, and would launch a con- ing for - an Egyptian account of chronological scheme for Egypt troversy which has already lasted a terrible disasters which formed a from the end of the Middle King- whole generation and continues un- remarkable parallel to the biblical dom right down to the advent of abated. It will be of interest to re- version. The papyrus also men- Alexander the Great in 332 BC. A Allen & Hanburys A Glaxo Canada Ltd. Company rPAAB1 Toronto, Montreal .ccPPI v:, Prescribing Information CPS '81 p.637 Prescribing lnfoN.tion CPS'81 P.61 He, became convinced that, in sev- sult of Velikovsky's researches into ment in 1950 reacted very badly eral instances, the same dynasty ancient history can best be summed (and most unscientifically), a fact had been described twice over- up in his own words: which is now generally conceded once according to the ancient Egyp- "I offered these theses: there even by astronomers themselves. tian sources, and then a second were physical upheavals of a global The book's publisher, Macmillan, time, as a sort of echo, in the his- character in historical times; these was threatened with a boycott of tory according to ancient Greek his- catastrophes were caused by extra- its textbook division if it persisted torians later on. This was a most terrestrial agents; these agents can in the publication. Its salesmen disturbing finding, because accepted be identified." were refused interviews at univer- Egyptian chronology was the prod- His book Worlds In Collision sities. The book eventually topped duct not only of archaelogical ex- was finally published on Apr. 3, the bestseller lists of both the New ploration and scholarly research 1950. Basically it described two sets York Times and the New York throughout this century and the of cataclysmic events 35 and 27 Herald Tribune for 20 consecutive last, but it had also apparently been centuries ago. Earth, Venus, Mars weeks, yet Macmillan was forced confirmed by astronomical calcula- and the Moon were involved in near to yield to the pressure on June 8th tions. It had become the yardstick encounters when Venus, then on a - when sales were at their peak- by which the chronologies of the stretched elliptical orbit following and, with Velikovsky's consent, to whole of the rest of the Near East its eruption from the giant planet transfer the publication rights to were measured. Jupiter, caused turmoil among Doubleday (which had no textbook By the fall of 1940, Velikovsky members of the solar system before division). James Putnam, the Mac- Millan editor who had accepted Velikovsky's manuscript, was fired, though he had been with the firm "If the Exodus took place at the same time as for 25 years. Gordon Atwater, cu- the Hyksos invasion, it raised the dilemma rator of the Hayden Planetarium that either Hebrew history was too short and chairman of the department of by several centuries, or that Egyptian astronomy in the American Mu- seum of Natural History, had pro- history was too long by the same amount." posed a planetarium program illus- trating Velikovsky's thesis; he also was promptly fired. had concluded that Egyptian his- settling on its present orbit. In 1955 The details given above are de- tory was, in reality, shorter by about a companion volume appeared deal- rived from a much fuller account 500 years, and that the Exodus and ing with the archaeological, geolog- in The Velikovsky Affair published the Hyksos invasion were contem- ical and paleontological evidence by University Books, New York, in porary events. By this time he had ("Earth in Upheaval") that sup- 1966. It details the various attacks also discovered that a comparable ported the purely historical evidence on the book, and the ad hominem train of disasters had been recorded of Worlds In Collision. attacks on Velikovsky himself, in in the history of ancient Mexico. Meanwhile, in 1952, he had pro- the scientific journals together with Suspecting that these natural dis- duced the first of a projected four- their refusal to grant him space in asters must have been global in ex- volume series which would set out which to reply to his critics. As tent, he promptly set about studying a revised chronology for ancient one of the joint authors, Ralph the ancient records of all races Egypt: its title was A ges In Chaos Juergens, summed the matter up: chiefly in the reference libraries of and it covered the period from the "The violence of the reaction New York.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Twelfth Planet Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    TWELFTH PLANET PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Zecharia Sitchin | 464 pages | 15 Mar 2007 | HarperCollins Publishers Inc | 9780061379130 | English | New York, NY, United States Twelfth Planet PDF Book Read it to expand your picture of our tiny existence. Lean over his neck and feel his body rippling under you. All in all this was a fun book to read, but if Sitchin was correct, it would only mean that the bible, and all the world mythologies and gods and goddesses, were not really divinely inspired after all, nor were these beings ever well intended in regards to our well being. The product of thirty years of intensive research, The 12th Planet is the first book in Zecharia Sitchin's prophetic Earth Chronicles series--a revolutionary body of work that offers indisputable documentary proof of humanity's extraterrestrial forefathers. So, if you are a religious person, you will definitely dismiss this book because it runs against the Biblical teaching that we were created in the image and likeness of God via Adam and Eve as mentioned in the first book of the Holy Bible, Genesis. Quite honestly, I appreciate Sitchin's attention to fine detail and even though it does feel repetitive at times, I appreciate how he shows all connections to the Sumerian tablets. Leroy This created Homo-Sapeins the perfect worker. It was after this that the Anunaki chose to teach humans the rudiments of civilization. Alford admits he initially became "infatuated" with Sitchin's hypotheses but later became a critic of Sitchin's interpretations of myth. Within twelve orbits the object would be either ejected or converted to a short period object.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Pharaoh Hatshepsut Is Not to Be Equated to the Queen of Sheba Patrick Clarke
    Viewpoint Why Pharaoh Hatshepsut is not to be equated to the Queen of Sheba Patrick Clarke This article looks at the linguistic, textual and other problems of equating the Pharaoh Hatshepsut with the Queen of Sheba. This is one of the central pillars of the revised chronology of the Ancient Near East, particularly Egypt, first mooted by Immanuel Velikovsky in the middle of the last century, and taken up by other writers since, including works that are very popular in creationist circles. The conclusion is that this Hatshepsut/Sheba identification is not tenable in the light of the available evidence. any Christians today are greatly influenced by the so that they line up with the Bible, their interpretation of the Mrevisionist claims of four people in particular. Firstly, evidence raises serious questions about their methodology and Immanuel Velikovsky, a Russian-born psychoanalyst, who often their expertise in the area. For example, Velikovsky’s authored a number of books in which he proposed numerous lack of competence as a historian was brutally exposed in radical interpretations of history. In Ages in Chaos (1952),1 1965, by the expert cuneiformist, Abraham Sachs, in a forum Velikovsky, who would not have called himself a Bible- at Brown University, Rhode Island.6 Sachs had much to say believer, described what he thought were parallels between about Velikovsky’s claims on Mesopotamian history. This is Egyptian history and the biblical accounts covering the part of what Sachs had to say: period from the Exodus to the early years of the Divided “In 1896, an excellent dictionary of Akkadian Monarchy.
    [Show full text]
  • Pseudoscience: Objective Or Subjective?
    Pseudoscience: Objective or Subjective? MICHAEL RUSE ABSTRACT WORK TYPE What is pseudo–science and when do charges of pseudo–scientific thinking Article generally arise? These questions are answered by looking at six examples where the charge of pseudo–science has arisen: anti–vaccination and the ARTICLE HISTORY claims that it causes illnesses, Creationism – the claim that the Bible is Received: literally true –, chiropractic and claims about curing cancer and the like, pre– 19–May–2019 Darwinian evolution, that is developmental hypotheses before the Origin of Accepted: Species (1859), Immanuel Velikovsky and his book, Worlds in Collision, and 14–July–2019 the Gaia hypothesis that the Earth is an organism. It is agreed that there is an Published Online: objective foundation to charges of pseudo–science and the author’s 24–November–2019 testimony in a court case in Arkansas in 1981, arguing that Creationism is not genuine science, is used to support this claim. Karl Popper’s criterion of ARTICLE LANGUAGE demarcation invoking falsifiability is a key notion here. However, it is argued English that charges of pseudo–science occur most frequently when conventional practitioners are under threat. Then claims of pseudo–science are used to KEYWORDS attack the non–conventional opposition. The examples are used to support Pseudoscience this conclusion. Falsiability Evolution Velikovsky Gaia © Studia Humanitatis – Universidad de Salamanca 2020 M. Ruse (✉) Disputatio. Philosophical Research Bulletin Florida State University, United States Vol. 9, No. 13, Jun. 2020, pp. 0–00 e–mail: [email protected] ISSN: 2254–0601 | www.disputatio.eu © The author(s) 2020. This work, published by Disputatio [www.disputatio.eu], is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons License [BY–NC–ND].
    [Show full text]
  • Michael D. Gordin. the Pseudoscience Wars. Immanuel Velikovsky and the Birth of the Modern Fringe
    528 Reseñas Dynamis 2013; 33 (2): 505-537 Michael D. Gordin. The pseudoscience wars. Immanuel Velikovsky and the birth of the modern fringe. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press; 2012, 291 p. ISBN-13: 978-0-226-30442-7, € 21,25. The pseudoscience wars tiene dos propósitos: por un lado, intenta rescatar la fi- gura del psicoanalista ruso-judío Immanuel Velikovsky (1895-1979) y sus con- trovertidas teorías, tachadas de pseudocientíficas; por otro lado, utiliza el caso de Velikovsky para discutir los procesos científico-sociales de demarcación cien- tífica. En este sentido, el libro de Michael D. Gordin, historiador de la ciencia de la Princeton University, se enmarca dentro de los estudios sociológicos del «boundary-work» y el problema filosófico de la demarcación. El título hace referencia a las llamadas «science wars» de mediados de los 90, en donde se intentó desacreditar los estudios humanísticos de la ciencia que cuestionaban su objetividad. Dividido en seis capítulos, The pseudoscience wars ofrece una estructura clara y efectiva respecto a sus objetivos. El lector queda rápidamente fascinado por el caso de Velikovsky, hilo conductor del libro. Como expone Gordin en los dos primeros capítulos, la obra de Velikovsky Worlds in collision (1950) generó una gran controversia en la comunidad científica de Esta- dos Unidos, país al que había emigrado en 1939. En Worlds in collision, Velikovsky exponía sus conclusiones tras décadas de investigación analizando los mitos de la antigüedad, especialmente los relativos a las catástrofes relatadas en la Biblia hebrea. En su opinión, dichas catástrofes ocurrieron en realidad y fueron causa- das por agentes extraterrestres, los cuales llegó a identificar.
    [Show full text]
  • Oedipus – Akhenaten
    MUSIC THEATRE PROJECT OEDIPUS – AKHENATEN CONCEPT AND REALIZATION KA – Cornelia Müller Pharaoh Akhenaten, Pharaoh Nefertiti with children Aten is depicted in form of the solar disk, whose rays are giving life (ca. 1350 BC) MUSIC THEATRE PROJECT OEDIPUS – AKHENATEN The Russian doctor, psychoanalyst, philosopher, archaeologist and astronomer Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky wondered what the character of the Sphinx had to do with a Greek story. After thorough research in Egyptian archaeology, he came to the conclusion that Pharaoh Akhenaten is the historic basis for the tragedy King Oedipus of Greek mythology. King Oedipus and Pharaoh Akhenaten are two theatre pieces based on this historical analogy, and they tell similar stories in different ways. For Oedipus it is the classical triangular relationship -- father/mother/son; for Akhenaten it is mother/son/wife. Each of these triads will be represented by a single actor (Oedipus) or actress (Akhenaten), who will incorporate all the monologues of the different roles using different techniques such as acrobatics, costumes and masks. Both pieces are staged inside a twin-spiraled labyrinth of mirrors, preferably in a forest or, if performed in an urban setting, with an installation made of bamboo. One path goes from the outside to the center and another leads outside again. The manifold reflections create a surreal world. The person in the mirror is fiction and reality, ageless and at the same time very present in the real world. Both pieces will be performed in German, with Italian or English subtitles. King Oedipus tells the story of a violent father meeting his own death in a way that he had envisaged for his son.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dark Age of Greece
    THE DARK AGE OF GREECE Immanuel Velikovsky THE DARK AGE OF GREECE by Immanuel Velikovsky CONTENTS A Technical Note Preface The Reconstruction of Ancient History CHAPTER I: THE HOMERIC QUESTION The Setting of the Stage The Homeric Question Why No Literary Relics from Five Centuries? The Allies of Priam Troy in the Dark Ages Aeneas The Dark Age in Asia Minor Olympic Games in the Iliad CHAPTER II: MUTE WITNESSES Troy and Gordion Mute Witnesses The Lion Gate of Mycenae A Votive Cretan Cave Olympia Etruria “The Scandal of Enkomi” Sicily Tiryns Mycenae and Scythia CHAPTER III: WORDS SET IN CLAY Pylos Mycenean City Names in the Iliad Linear B Deciphered The Mycenean Dialect The Greek Pantheon Cadmus CHAPTER IV: A GAP CLOSED Seismology and Chronology A Gap Closed Celestial Events in the Iliad Competing for a Greater Antiquity Changes in Land and Sea Summing Up 1 A Technical Note I have been asked by the compliers of the Velikovsky archive to briefly explain the present condition of Velikovsky’s unpublished manuscript entitled The Dark Age of Greece. By contributing this explanation, I am not in any way endorsing their move to make this material available to a wider public. Velikovsky worked on the manuscript of The Dark Age of Greece fairly intensively during the last years of his life, drawing in part on the library research of Edwin Schorr, a graduate student at the University of Cincinnati, whom he employed for this pupose in Princeton for several summers in a row in the mid-seventies. Readers of Pensee know Schorr under his nom de plume Israel M.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dark Age of Greece
    THE DARK AGE OF GREECE by Immanuel Velikovsky Unpublished – Internet [Overgenomen 2010-05-04] I. Velikovsky, The Dark Age of Greece (PDF Cor Hendriks, Dec. 2017) 1 A Technical Note I have been asked by the compliers of the Velikovsky archive to briefly explain the present condition of Velikovsky’s unpublished manuscript entitled The Dark Age of Greece. Velikovsky worked on the manuscript of The Dark Age of Greece fairly intensively during the last years of his life, drawing in part on the library research of Edwin Schorr, a graduate student at the University of Cincinnati, whom he employed for this pupose in Princeton for several summers in a row in the mid-seventies. Readers of Pensée know Schorr under his nom de plume Israel M. Isaacson, which he used to protect himself from the wrath of his professors at Cincinnati. At the time that I began to work for Velikovsky in 1976, the manuscript was still “work in progress.” While Velikovsky was writing and rewriting the main text, my task was to annotate the material, drawing in part on the voluminous notes and photocopies of articles prepared by Schorr and partly on my own research. In addition, Velikovsky and I co- authored certain sections; others, written solely by me, were to have been included in a supplement to the book. Subsequent to 1980, pursuant to Elisheva Velikovsky’s wishes, I moved some of these contributions from the main text into footnotes and removed the rest from the manuscript altogether. Several of them were published in Kronos VIII.2 in 1983.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduced to Social Studies Teachers and a Nine-Week Inicourse Designed to Investigate His Theories Is Reported
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 084 215 SO 006 643 AUTHOR Stahl, Robert J.; Ring, Mary TITLE Immanuel Velikovsky: Reconsidered. An Inquiry Unit Into Velikovsky's Revision of Ancient History. INSTITUTION Florida Univ., Gainesville. P. K. Yonge Lab. School. PUB DATE Oct 73 NOTE 37p. EDRS PRICE MF-$0.65 HC-$3.29 DESCRIPTORS *Ancient History; Course Objectives; Critical Thinking; Historical Criticism; *Inquiry Training; Instructional Materials; *Interdisciplinary Approach; Middle Eastern History; *Problem Solving; Religion; Scientific Attitudes; Secondary Education; *Social Studies; Teaching Techniques; Units of Study (Subject Fields) IDENTIFIERS Chronology; Minicourses; Primary Sources; *Velikovsky (Immanuel) ABSTRACT The ideas and theories of Isamanuel Velikovsky are introduced to social studies teachers and a nine-week inicourse designed to investigate his theories is reported. The contradictions and inconsistencies that Velikovsky found between the events as recorded in original records of the ancient Middle East and the chronological timetable of this historical period as it is presently constructed, form the basis of this inquiry unit for high school students. Four general course objectives listed and discussed are: to familiarize students with the basic works and theories of Velikovsky; to examine some of his theories in light of historical, scientific, cultural, and religious evidence and cources; to review the chronology of ancient history as presently constructed and compare it with the revisions suggested by Velikovsky; and to review the reaction of scientific and literary critics to his published works and theories. Through use of both the expository and inquiry modes of learning, the unit emphasizes the students' efforts to identify and articulate the inconsistencies which present themselves, and to make decisions to reconcile these discrepancies.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Contributions of Albert Einstein to Earth Sciences
    1 Contributions of Albert Einstein to Earth Sciences: A review in Commemoration 2 of the W orld Year of Physics 3 4 Jesús Martínez-Frías1, David Hochberg1 and Fernando Rull1,2 5 6 1 Centro de Astrobiologia (CSIC/INTA), associated to the NASA Astrobiology Institute, Ctra de 7 Ajalvir, km 4, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz, Madrid, Spain, Tel: +34-91-5201111, Fax: +34-91- 8 5201621, e-mail: martinezfrias@ mncn.csic.es 9 2 Cristalografía y Mineralogía, Facultad de Ciencias and Unidad Asociada al Centro de 10 Astrobiologia, Universidad de ValladolidœCSIC, 47006 Valladolid, Spain 11 Abstract 12 The W orld Year of Physics (2005) is an international celebration to commemorate the 13 100th anniversary of Einstein's "Annus Mirabilis". The United Nations has officially 14 declared 2005 the International Year of Physics. However, the impact of Einstein´s 15 ideas was not restricted to physics. Among numerous other disciplines, Einstein also 16 made significant and specific contributions to Earth Sciences. His geosciences-related 17 letters, comments, and scientific articles, are dispersed, not easily accessible and are 18 poorly known. The present review attempts to integrate them, as a tribute to Einstein in 19 commemoration of this centenary. These contributions can be classified into three basic 20 areas: geodynamics, geological (planetary) catastrophism and fluvial geomorphology. 21 Regarding geodynamics, Einstein essentially supported Hapgood‘s very controversial 22 theory called Earth Crust Displacement. W ith respect to geological (planetary) 23 catastrophism, it is shown how the ideas of Einstein about Velikovsky‘s proposals 24 evolved from 1946 to 1955. Finally, in relation with fluvial geodynamics, the review 25 incorporates the elegant work in which Einstein explains the formation of meandering 26 rivers.
    [Show full text]
  • Velikovsky-Ages-In-C
    127656 Immanuel Velikovsky AGES IN CHAOS VOLUME I FROM THE EXODUS TO KING AKHNATON Doubleday & Company, Inc. GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK, 1952 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 52-5224 COPYRIGHT, 1952, BY IMMANUEL VELIKOVSXY ALL RIGHTS RESERVED PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES AT THE COUNTRY LIFE PRESS, GARDEN CITY, N.Y, FIRST EDITION FOREWORD IN CHAOS was conceived in the spring of 1940. It was then that I realized that the Exodus had occurred in the midst of a natural and that As upheaval this catastrophe might prove be the to connecting link between the Israelite and Egyptian his- tories, if ancient Egyptian texts were found to contain references a to similar event. I found such references and before long had worked out a of reconstruction of plan ancient history from the Exodus to the conquest of the East by Alexander the Great. Already by October of the same year I had come to understand the nature extent of and that catastrophe. For a decade after that I worked simultaneously on Ages in Chaos and Worlds in Collision, the present work requiring the lion's share of the toil. in Ages Chaos covers largely the period dealt with in Worlds in Collision the eight hundred years from the Exodus of the Israelites from Egypt to the invasion of Palestine by Sennacherib in 687 be- fore the present era, and the additional three and a half centuries to Alexander of Macedonia, altogether twelve hundred years of the history of the ancient East. But whereas the first work con- centrated on the description of the physical history of the period, the present work deals with its political and cultural aspects.
    [Show full text]
  • Ages in Chaos
    Site The Velikovsky Encyclopedia Fromlogo The Velikovsky Encyclopedia Ages in Chaos Ages in Chaos is the second book by Immanuel Velikovsky, first published by Doubleday in 1952, which put forward a major revision of the history of the Ancient Near East. A second volume was due for publication shortly after this but was postponed and expanded into four volumes, two of which (Peoples of the Sea and Ramses II and his time) were published in the two years preceding his death, and two of which remain unpublished in print (The Assyrian Conquest and The Dark Age of Greece) —however the manuscripts have long been available via the http://www.varchive.org site. Contents 1 Proposals 2 Critique 3 Other chronological revisions inspired by Velikovsky 4 Footnotes 5 Literature 6 External links Proposals Velikovsky claimed in this book that the histories of Ancient Egypt and Ancient Israel are five centuries out of step. He began by claiming that the Exodus took place not, as orthodoxy has it, at some point during the New Kingdom, but at the fall of the Middle Kingdom. He identifies the Hyksos with the Biblical Amalekites, the Biblical Queen of Sheba with the Egyptian queen Hatshepsut, the Biblical Shishak king of Egypt with Pharaoh Thutmose III, and claims that the Egyptian Amarna letters from the late 18th Dynasty describe events from the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, roughly the time of King Ahab. Some specific proposals included: Synchronising the Ipuwer Papyrus, from the beginning of Egypt's Second Intermediate Period, with the Biblical Exodus. (The Ipuwer Papyrus was conventionally dated to approximately 350 years before the conventional date of the Exodus (1450 BCE)).
    [Show full text]
  • Worlds in Collision with a New Introduction by the Author
    IMMANUEL VELIKOVSKV AD E CTA $1.96 $2.26 IN CANADA WORLDS IN COLLISION WITH A NEW INTRODUCTION BY THE AUTHOR ) A A Delta Book Other books by Immanuel Velikovsky: AGES IN CHAOS OEDIPUS AND AKHNATON EARTH IN UPHEAVAL (also in a Delta edition WORLDS IN COLLISION IMMANUEL VELIKOVSKY a delta book Published by Dell Publishing Co., Inc. 750 Third Avenue, hew York, N.Y.. 10017 Copyright, 1950, by Immanuel Velikovsky Delta ® TM 755118, Dell Publishing Co., Inc. AH rights reserved Reprinted by arrangement with Doubleday ir Co., Inc., New York Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 52-2250 First Delta printing— January, 1965 Manufactured in the United States of America Twelfth Printing The author gratefully acknowledges permission to quote from the following books: G. A. Dorsey, The Pawnee, Mythology, Carnegie Institution of Wash- ington, 1906; Maimonides: The Guide for the Perplexed, translated M. Fried- lander, E. P. Dutton, Inc., 1928; Clements R. Markham, The Incas of Peru, E. P. Dutton, Inc., 1910.; Shakuntala and other writings of Kalidasa, transl. A. W. Ryder, Everyman’s Library, E. P. Dutton, Inc., 1912; James Moffatt, The Bible: A New Translation, copyright, 1935, Harper & Brothers. The Loeb Classical Library, Harvard University Press: Homer, The Iliad, trans. A. T. Murray, 1925; Hesiod, Theogony, transl. H. Evelyn-White, 1914; Euripides, Electro, transl. A. S. Way, 1919; Plato, Timaeus, transl. R. C. Bury, 1920, and The Statesman (Politicus), transl. H. N. Fowler, 1925; Apollodorus, The Library, transl. B. Frazer, J. 1921; Seneca, Thyestes, transl. F. J. Miller, 1917; Virgil! Georgies, transl. H. R. Fairclough, 1920; Ovid, Metamorphoses, transl.
    [Show full text]