Second Session - Thirty-Sixth Legislature of the Legislative Assembly of Manitoba DEBATES and PROCEEDINGS (Hansard) Publishedunder the authorityof TheHonourable LouiseM. Dacquay Speaker .· · ... �·:::��-...:��� Vol. XLVI No. 21-1:30 p.m., Monday, April22, 1996 ISSN 0542-5492 MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thirty-sixth Legislature Members, Constituencies and Political Affiliation Name CnnstihJency � ASHTON, Steve Thompson N.D.P. BARRETI, Becky Wellington N.D.P. CERILLI, Marianne Radisson N.D.P. CHOMIAK, Dave K.ildonan N.D.P. CUMMINGS, Glen, Hon. Ste. Rose P.C. DACQUAY, Louise, Hon. Seine River P.C. DERKACH, Leonard, Hon. Robl in-Russell P.C. DEWAR, Gregory Selkirk N.D.P. DOER, Gary Concordia N.D.P. DOWNEY, James, Hon. Arthur-Virden P.C. DRIEDGER, Albert, Hon. Steinbach P.C. DYCK, Peter Pembina P.C. ENNS, Harry, Hon. Lakeside P.C. ERNST, Jim, Hon. Charles wood P.C. EVANS, Clif Interlake N.D.P. EVANS, Leonard S. Brandon East N.D.P. FILMON, Gary, Hon. Tuxedo P.C. FINDLAY, Glen, Hon. Springfield P.C. FRIESEN, Jean Wolseley N.D.P. GAUDRY, Neil St. Boniface Lib. GILLESHAMMER, Harold, Hon. Minnedosa P.C. HEL WER, Edward Gimli P.C. HICKES, George Point Douglas N.D.P. JENNISSEN, Gerard Flin Flon N.D.P. KOWALSKI, Gary The Maples Lib. LAMOUREUX, Kevin Inkster Lib. LATHLIN, Oscar The Pas N.D.P. LAURENDEAU, Marcel St. Norbert P.C. MACKINTOSH, Gord St. Johns N.D.P. MALOWAY, Jim Elmwood N.D.P. MARTINDALE, Doug Burrows N.D.P. McALPINE, Gerry Sturgeon Creek P.C. McCRAE, James, Hon. Brandon West P.C. McGIFFORD, Diane Osborne N.D.P. MciNTOSH, Linda, Hon. Assiniboia P.C. MIHYCHUK, MaryAnn St. James N.D.P. MITCHELSON, Bonnie, Hon. River East P.C. NEWMAN, David Riel P.C. PALLISTER, Brian, Hon. Portage la Prairie P.C. PENNER, Jack Emerson P.C. PITURA, Frank Morris P.C. PRAZNIK, Darren, Hon. Lac du Bonnet P.C. RADCLIFFE, Mike River Heights P.C. REID, Daryl Transcona N.D.P. REIMER, Jack, Hon. Niakwa P.C. RENDER, Shirley St. Vital P.C. ROBINSON, Eric Rupertsland N.D.P. ROCAN, Denis Gladstone P.C. SALE, Tim Crescentwood N.D.P. SANTOS, Conrad Broadway N.D.P. STEFANSON, Eric, Hon. Kirkfield Park P.C. STRUTHERS, Stan Dauphin N.D.P. SVEINSON, Ben La Verendrye P.C. TOEWS, Vic, Hon. Rossmere P.C. TWEED, Mervin Turtle Mountain P.C. VODREY, Rosemary, Hon. Fort Garry P.C. WOWCHUK, Rosann Swan River N.D.P. 1071 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA Monday, April22 , 1996 The House met at 1:30 p.m. Madam Speaker, on April18, the Minister of Health tabled the APM contract and tabled the, quote, final PRAYERS working group document presented to the steering committee. MATTER OF PRIVILEGE This report was presented to the House and to the Home Care Services media and to thepublic of Manitoba as the final APM documents. This waslater contradictedby the release of Mr. Dave Chomiak (Kildonan): Madam Speaker, I a report in Estimates on Friday-and this is my first am rising this afternoon at the first opportunity that I opportunityto riseafter having reviewed this document­ have on a matter of privilege and this matter will be by a document titled Home Care Demonstration Project: fbllowed, accordingto the rules, by a substantive motion Advisory Committee Presentation, Manitoba Health, which I will introduce at the end of my comments. June 22,1994. Recentlywe have beengiv1:n information with respect MadamSpeaker, the ministersaid there wasno report, to the Connie Curran APM contract which states in thenthe minister said there was a report, then there was Schedule A, page 93, quote, a final report of the not a report,then the minister released a so-called report, analytical findings will be presented to the home care and then ministerthe released another reportthat wasa steering committee. so-called finalreport . On May 27,1994, in this Chamber, in response to a Madam Speaker,how canI, as a member of anelected question from myself, the Minister of Health (Mr. constituency, do my job when the Minister of Health McCrae) stated and I quote from Hansard again: " ... obstructs, when the Minister of Health does not tell the thework ofAPM with our dc�artment on thehome care fullstory , whenthe Minister of Health says one thing in project lastyear arrived at cc:rtainrecommendatio ns." the Chamber, another thing outside of the Chamber, another thing in the Chamber, and then another thing On April15 ofthis year on CJOB radio, theminister outside of the Chamber? changed his position and I quote: The work done by .t\PMwith my department with respect to home care was MadamSpeaker, this not is according to Beauchesne's not somethingthat resulted in any formal report. Rule No. 30, a dispute over the facts. This is a dispute over the integrity of not just the minister, but the very OnApril 16 in the Winnipeg Free Press, the Minister government which he represents with respect to these of Health stated, "The Cunran report, as I recall, may documents, with respect to the entire issue of home care bave madereference to contracting or allowing for some and with respect to the Connie Curranreport. competition." ..."I made a decisionthat therewas not much tobe gained by releasing it." MadamSpeaker, it would be one thing ifthe minister, in dealingwith a question from anelected representative Again, MadamSpeaker, on April 17 inthis Chamb er, -myjob andour job is torepresent ourconstituen ts. We theMinister ofHealth stated andI quote, " ...the APM make inquiries of the government of public documents workwith respectto home carewas not the subject of a and of public information. The minister fails to release fbrmal report. What the process involved and the it or if he does release it, he releases parts of it. arrangement involved was a process to facilitate the Ultimately,when he does release it, we findthat they are peoplewho work for Manitoba Health in theprovision different documents that have been released, and the of home care services in trying to identify areas where minister purports to show one document represents a improvements could be made. That is what was arrived situation, when in fa ct there is another document that he at. There was no formal APM report." is holding, and he did not release it until Friday. 1072 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF MANITOBA April22, 1996 * (1335) home care, the lack of studies, the lack oJ� frankly, competence. Madam Speaker, this would be bad enough. This, in itself, in my opinion, would be a breach of privilege in MadamSpeaker, I askyou to look at this situationand myrights as a member andour rightson this side of the rule on it. House to obtaininformation from the government. But what is worse, the final document that was released MadamSpeaker, I move, seconded by themember for Friday,the documentfinal that came to our hands Friday, Crescentwood(Mr. Sale), thatthis house do o;:nsure the appearedto have beenaltered. It appeared tohave been Minister of Health for a breach of the privil(:ges of its doctored. There are major inconsistencies in this members in the matter of information made available document, and isthat aninsult to thepublic of Manitoba aboutprivatizati the on ofhomecare, a misrepfl�entation andto the electedrepresentatives whom we serve. ofreports and background documents on this issue, and thatthis m.atter be referredto the Standing Committeeon MadamSpeaker, this document misses page 33, page Privileges and Elections. 35, page 36. There are two pages 38, there are two pages 39, and two pages 39 that are differentfrom each Mr. KevinLamoureux (Inkster) : It is supposed to be other. There arereferences in this document to studies somewhat rare, as Beauchesne's indicates, in terms of and information that do not appear in this document. how often a matter of privilege does arise, aiJid when it What is worse, there are no numbers on the first 17 does arise, that thisHouse take it in the most serious pages, and yet, there are not even 17 pages that go fashion in terms of the context in which it has been betweenNo. 1 andNo. 17. presented. Having said that, Madam Speaker, we have been in the Health Estimates for a number of days now MadamSpeaker, this is an affrontto members on this andhave attempted on numerousoccas ions to be able to side of the bench. This is an ontaffr to democracy; this get information from the Minister of Heillth (Mr. is an affront to the intelligence of the people of McCrae). The member for Kildonan raises an issue Manitoba. In some jurisdictions therewould be public which,no doubt, does thewammt discussion of members inquiriesbased on the way that this minister has handled of this Chamber and some sort of action m:eds to be this issue. Now, with respect to the Connie Curran taken. contract, we have seen one contradiction after another. We have documentsseen not released; we have seen the I want to express to the House that over the last minister statingthere are reports and then there wereno numberof days we, representing the LiberalParty, have reports, and then there were reports. Then he finally asked the Minister of Health to provide infotmation to tabled the report. the members of this Chamber, and through us, to membersof the public. We believe that theinf ormation Last week, on CBC television, he said there was a is absolutely essential. report,then theminister said therewas not a report. He saidthe same thing in theHouse andthen in the hallway. The Minister of Health respondedto me once, saying On Thursday, they tabled documents that were thatthere are tons of informationthat are out there, a lot purportedlythe Carnie Curran documents and theywere of it; all we have to do is go and look for it andwe will not the documents.final Thenon Friday, the final insult, findit.