Mitochondrial DNA Variation Among <I>Muscidifurax</I> Spp
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications: Department of Entomology Entomology, Department of 1997 Mitochondrial DNA Variation among Muscidifurax spp. (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae), Pupal Parasitoids of Filth Flies (Diptera) David B. Taylor University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Richard D. Peterson II University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Allen L. Szalanski University of Nebraska-Lincoln James J. Petersen University of Nebraska-Lincoln Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/entomologyfacpub Part of the Entomology Commons Taylor, David B.; Peterson, Richard D. II; Szalanski, Allen L.; and Petersen, James J., "Mitochondrial DNA Variation among Muscidifurax spp. (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae), Pupal Parasitoids of Filth Flies (Diptera)" (1997). Faculty Publications: Department of Entomology. 206. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/entomologyfacpub/206 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Entomology, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications: Department of Entomology by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. Mitochondrial DNA Variation Among Muscidifurax spp. (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae) ,Pupal Parasitoids of Filth Flies (Diptera) DAVID B. TAYLOR, RICHARD D, PETERSON 11, ALLEN L. SZALANSKI,' A~DJAMES J. PETERSEN Midwest Livestock Insects Research Laboratory. USDA-ARS, Department of Entomology, University of Nebraska, Lincoln. NE 68583 Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. W(6): 814-824 (1997) ABSTRACT Polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR- RFLP) and sequencing analyses were used to characterize an amplicon of -625 bp in 4 of the 5 nominate species of Muscidifim Girault & Sanders, pupal parasitoids of muscoid flies. A single polymorphic nucleotide site was observed among 2 samples of M. mptor Girault Br Sanders. No sequence variation was observed among 3 samples of M. rqh-ellur Kogan & Legner. The sequence of M. uniraptor Kogan & Legner was identical to that of M. raptwellw. Nucleotide divergence among the Muscidijmnx spp. ranged from 0.14 to 0.18 substitutions per nucleotide. Muscidifitm urraptor Kogan & Legner exhibited multiple haplotypes, 2 of which were char- acterized by sequencing and 4 others by PCR-RFLP. The sequenced haplotypes differed by 0.08 nucleotide substitutions per site. Restriction site analysis indicated that nucleotide divergence ranged from 0.03 to 0.10 among all 6 haplotypes. Analysis of progeny from individual females indicated that the observed variation in M. mraptor was caused by multiple haplotypes within individuals rather than differentiation among individuals. These results bring to question the specific status of M.unimptorand indicate that the genus is native to the Western Hemisphere, and not introduced with their primary host, Murcn domestics L,as previously proposed. Heteroplasmy and translocation of aportion of the mitochondrial genome to the nuclear genome are discussed as possible causes for the variation observed in M. zamptw. KEY WORDS Muscidifimx, polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymor- phism, mitochondrial DNA, phylogeny WASEm TAF, genus Musddifirax are pupal parasi- species known only from the island of Puerto Rico toids of muscoid flies, especially the house fly, Mu~cn (Kogan and Legner 1970). domtica L., and the stable fly, Stmnoxys colcitrm The geographic origins and phylogenetic rela- (L.),and are among the most promising biological tionships of Muscidifirrax are unclear. Kogan and control agents for these flies in the confined live- Leper (1970) proposed 2 alternatives for the ori- stock environment (Miller and Rutz 1990, Petersen gins of the genus. First, they originated in the Ethi- et al. 1990). Murcidifirax includes 5 species. Mus- opian region and wereintroduced to the New World cidifirax mptor Girault & Sanders, the most wide- along with house flies, or 2nd, they are native to the spread, is found throughout the temperate and semi- New World and have secondarily adapted to house tropical regions of the world (Kogan and Legner flies. Kogan and Legner conclude that the "remark- 1970). The remaining 4 species are limited to the able preference of Musctdifirax spp. for house flies New World. Muscidifurax zaraptor Kogan & Legner as compared to native Nearctic flies" indicates an is found sympatrically with M. raptor in western Old World origin for the genus. Legner (1983)in- North America (Kogan and Legner 1970, Lysyk dicates that the dependence of Musctdifirax upon 1995), M. raptoroides Kogan & Legner and M.rup- the "barnyard" environment outside of Africa is torellus Kogan & Legner are found allopatrically in further evidence that the genus was not native to the Central and South America, respectively (Kogan New World. However, to accept an Old World or- and Legner 1970).Two forms of M. raptorellus have igin of the genus and account for the 4 species been reported, one solitary and the other gregarious endemic to the New World, one must accept a very (Kogan and Legner 1970, Legner 1988). MuPcidi- rapid rate of speciation following their introduction. &rax mtraptw Kogan & Legner is a parthenogenic Despite the interest in these species for biological control of filth flies and the questions concerning their geographic origin, little work has been done on "~spartrnmt of Plant Pathology, University of Nebmkq Lin- the population genetics and genetic structure of coln, NE 68583. Muscidifirax. Ropp (1986) used allozymes to ex- November I997 TAYLOREX AL.: mtDNA VARIATIONLY M~cidifimxSPP. 815 Date Source* Species Orldn inllected . raptor Nebraska I995 MLIRL New York Unknown Cornell University . mp~IlwChile Unknown Legner via MLIRL Nebraska 1991 MLIRL Peru Unknown Leper ria MLlRL M.miaptor Puerto Rico Unknown Rochester University M. zamptor Nebraska 1991-1993 MLIRL Nebraska 1995 hu.lRL 'MLEU+ Midwest Livestock Inrect Research Irpboratory. USDA-ARS, Lincoln. NE; Legner via MLIRL,originally collected by E. F. Leper and transferred to MLlRL in 1989. amine several populations of M. raptor and M.zarap- tor. He found relatively low levels of differentiation among geographic isolates of the 2 species, but a high level of differentiation was observed between species. Antolin et al. (1996) used RAPD-PCR to examine 3 Muscidifiraz spp. They were able to dif- ferentiate the species and associate the gregarious North American Muscidifurox sp. with M.ruptorel- Ius, but indicated they were unable to explore phy- logenetic relationships because of the nature of the RAPD-PCR data. The purpose of this study was to develop molec- Fig. 1. Intact amplicon from 4 Muscidifirrax spp., A. ular diagnostic characters and examine genetic dif- mellifera, and C. macelloria on 2.5% Metaphor agarosc gel. ferentiation among Muscidifumx spp. A region of Primers werc 5' ATACCTCGACG'ITA?TCACA 3' and 5' the mitochondria1genome, =625 bp, including parts TCAATATCA'ITCATCACCMT 3'. of the cytochrome oxidase I (COI) and I1 (COII) genes as well as the entire tRNA leucine (~RNA''~) gene was examined by polymerase chain reaction- extracted with thc chloroform-phenol tcchniquc as restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR- outlined in Taylor ct al. (1996). RFLP) and sequencing. Representative samples of A region of mtDNA, -625 bp long, was amplified 4 of the 5 species in the genus (samples of M. using thc primcrs 5' ATACCTCGACGTTATC- raptomides were not available) were included in ACA 3' (= S2792; Bogdanowicz ct al. 1993) and 5' this study. TCAATATCATTGATGACCAAT 3' (K. Prucss, personal communication). Thc 5' ends of thcric primcrs wcrc located at bp 2773 and 3400 of the Materials and Methods Drosghila yakuba mtDNA map (Clary and Wol- SampIes. Mumidifirax samples were obtained stenholme 1985), respcctivcly. from established colonies (Table 1).The Chile and For amplification, 1 p1 of sample DNA was added Nebraska samples of M. raptorellus represented gre- to a reaction mixture containing 2.5 p1 of reaction garious populations and the Peru sample was soli- buffer (Perkin-Elmer, Norwalk, CT), 2 p1 of dNTP tary. The Apis mellifera lingustica L control sample mix (10 mM each-dATP, $ITP, dCTP and dCTP), was collected from an apiary in Lincoln, NE, and the 1pl of each primer (20 mM). 1.0 unit of Taq poly- Cochliomyia naacellaria (F.) samples were from a merase (Perkin-Elmer) and deionized water to a laboratory colony originating in Fargo, ND. Mus- volume of 25 pl. Amplifications were donc in a cidifcnvlx colonies were maintained on freeze-killed Perkin Elmer Cetus Model 9600 therrnocycler pro- M. rlomestica pupae (Petersen and Matthews 1984). grammed for 35 cycles of 92°C for 1 min, 55°C for 1 Isofemale lines were initiated by isolating indi- min, and 72OC for 1or 2 min. Amplification products vidual females (presumably mated) from the main were stored at 4OC. colony and placing them in small plastic cups (2 cm Restriction Endonuclease Digests. Twenty-seven diameter, 2 cm high) with -150 freeze-killed fly restriction enzymes-Alu I, Apo I, Ase I, Ava I. Ban pupae. Progeny emerged in 3 wk. Specimens were Zl, Bfa I, Bsr I, Dde I, Dpn 11, Dra I, EcoR I, EcoR V, stored at -80%. Hae Ill, Hinc 11, Hind Ill. Hinf 1, Hpa I, Mse I, Msp I, Voucher specimens from each of the Murcidifimx Puu 11, Rsa I, Sac I, Sau96 I, ScrF I, SJ~I, Taq I, and samples have been placed in the collection of the Xba I-were screened. Digests for polyacrylamide University of Nebraska State Museum, Lincoln. gel electrophoresis (PAGE) were done using 1.5 p1 DNA Extraction and Amplification. Pools of 5-25 of PCR product, 0.2 p1 enzyme (New England Bio- wasps were used for each DNA extraction. DNA was labs, Beverly, MA), 1X buffer (New England Bio- ANNALS OF THE E@STOMOUX:ICALSOCIEN OF AMERICA Vol. 90, no. 6 50 bp SSP ladder frag Apo I ssp I Fis 2. Apo I and Ssp I digests of Mutddifumx spp. on 2.5%Metaphor agarose gels. labs) and water to bring the volume to 5 pl in 200-pl onto a 10% acrylamide gel (1X Tris:borate:EDTA tubes.