DOCSLIB.ORG

Cultural Landscape Report: Saratoga Battlefield, Saratoga

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Cultural Landscape Report: Saratoga Battlefield, Saratoga Saratoga National Historical Park Olmsted Center for Landscape Preservation Cultural Landscape Report: Saratoga Battlefield Saratoga National Historical Park Volume I: Site History, Existing Conditions, and Analysis September 2002 Cultural Landscape Report for Saratoga Battlefield i Cultural Landscape Report for Saratoga Battlefield ii Cultural Landscape Report for Saratoga Battlefield Table of Contents List of Figures................................................................................................................................................................ v Foreword....................................................................................................................................................................... ix Acknowledgments........................................................................................................................................................ xi Introduction................................................................................................................................................................... 1 The Purpose of This Report................................................................................................................................... 1 Historical Overview.................................................................................................................................................. 2 Scope of Work and Methodology.......................................................................................................................... 6 Study Boundaries ...................................................................................................................................................... 6 Summary of Findings............................................................................................................................................... 7 Pre-History to 1777 ....................................................................................................................................................17 Native American Habitation.................................................................................................................................17 European Settlement..............................................................................................................................................19 Nature of Settlement in 1777................................................................................................................................22 Battling for the Saratoga Landscape, 1777..............................................................................................................31 Prelude......................................................................................................................................................................31 The Battle of Freeman's Farm..............................................................................................................................35 The Defensive Interval ..........................................................................................................................................39 The Battle of Bemis Heights on 7 October 1777..............................................................................................45 Battlefield Epilogue ................................................................................................................................................52 The Rural Economy Period, 1778-1876..................................................................................................................69 Early Battlefield Visitors........................................................................................................................................70 Foundations of an Agricultural Economy..........................................................................................................73 Corridors and Crossroads......................................................................................................................................77 Vestiges and Veneration ........................................................................................................................................81 Memorial Period, 1877-1927.....................................................................................................................................97 Initiatives of the Saratoga Monument Association ...........................................................................................97 Centennial Celebration...........................................................................................................................................98 Appealing for State and National Recognition ................................................................................................101 State Management Period, 1927-1937 ...................................................................................................................111 Slingerland's Battlefield Vision ...........................................................................................................................112 Turning a Dream into Reality .............................................................................................................................121 The Fight for Federal Ownership Continues...................................................................................................124 National Park Service Period, 1938-Present.........................................................................................................141 Origins of National Park Service Involvement................................................................................................141 A Late Start for the Civilian Conservation Corps ...........................................................................................144 Research and Planning for the New National Park ........................................................................................145 World War II .........................................................................................................................................................152 Post-War Period 1945-1956...............................................................................................................................153 Mission 66..............................................................................................................................................................156 Contemporary Stewardship.................................................................................................................................161 Existing Conditions ..................................................................................................................................................209 General Description .............................................................................................................................................209 The Tour Stops of the Saratoga National Historical Park Battlefield Unit ................................................217 Analysis of Significance and Integrity....................................................................................................................245 Introduction...........................................................................................................................................................245 Analysis of Significance for the Saratoga National Historical Park Battlefield Unit..................................247 iii Cultural Landscape Report for Saratoga Battlefield Evaluating Integrity of the Saratoga National Historical Park Battlefield Unit..........................................251 Battlefield Landscape Characteristics ................................................................................................................252 Preliminary Landscape Preservation Recommendations....................................................................................259 Appendices.................................................................................................................................................................265 Abridged Chronology ..........................................................................................................................................265 Bibliography...............................................................................................................................................................273 iv Cultural Landscape Report for Saratoga Battlefield List of Figures 1.1 Diagram of New York State and Saratoga National Historical Park. Redrawn from "1941 Master Plan, Index Sheet." January 1941. Saratoga National Historical Park files. 1.2 Saratoga battlefield, Saratoga National Historical Park. 1989. Park Brochure. 1.3 Map of Saratoga National Historical Park's four units. "Cultural Landscapes Inventory, Schuyler House, Saratoga National Historical Park (draft)." 2000. Olmsted Center for Landscape Preservation. 2.1 Map of Tribal Territories in the Northeast. 1978. Re-drawn from Handbook of North American Indians. Edited by Bruce G. Trigger. Smithsonian Institution, Washington. 2.2 Drawing of the re-subdivision of a portion of the Saratoga Patent. 1767. Saratoga National Historical Park files. 2.3 Portrait of Philip Schuyler, landlord of much of the Saratoga battlefield property, by John Trumbull.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Battle of Sartoga
    The Battle of Saratoga By Kamden McCoy Table Of Contents This is who convinced me Chapter 1 All About The to write about the battle of America Revolution Saratoga was my teacher Mrs.Frech Chapter 2 All About The Battle Of Saratoga Thank You Chapter 3 My Point Of View Chapter 4 Why The Battle Of Saratoga Was Important Chapter 1 The battle of bunker Hill took place at April 19, 1775 The Battle Of Charles Town. June 17,1775 colonists vs Lexington and Concord the first the British The Battle went on for a long battle against the colonists vs the time it was the second battle of British. Because the colonists colonists vs the British. The colonists wanted to be independent from put up a great fight but they didn't give Great Britain. Colonists and British up it tell they knew that they had to. But the British were like theses people are troops were shooting from behind the real deal. trees, rocks hiding and firing many August 1776 the battle of New York the life’s died that day. The colonists British wanted New York because it had put up a great fight but surrender great landing for attacking south or to British. The British came out on north. The British were heading over to top. New York and so was George Washington. In the battle of New York was a tremendous fight for the colonists the first win for the colonist. The colonists had 5,000 British troops surrender. November 17, 1777-1778 winter at valley Chapter 2 George Washington wrote letter after October 17,1777 the battle of Saratoga it was letter to Congress for supplies for his poor colonists vs the British the colonists were on a army.
    [Show full text]
  • Unit 2 Guide
    AP US History Unit 2 Study Guide “Salutary Neglect” Enlightenment terms to remember Balance of trade Philosophes Mercantilism John Locke Tariffs Tabula rasa Navigation Acts Social Contract Natural Rights Montesquieu Benjamin Franklin French and Indian War Ft. Duquesne Relative advantages (Brit./France) Gov. Dinwiddie The Great Expulsion (1755-63) George Washington William Pitt, Sr. The Brave Old Hendrick Battle of the Plains of Abraham Albany Plan for Union Treaty of Paris, 1763 Pontiac´s Rebellion Discontent Proclamation Line of 1763 John Dickinson Letters from a Pennsylvania Farmer East Florida, West Florida, Quebec Boston Massacre Sugar Act (1764) Samuel Adams Admiralty courts John Adams Virtual representation Gaspee incident (1772) Stamp Act (1765) Committees of Correspondence Stamp Act Congress Tea Act of 1773 Patrick Henry British East India Co. "Sons of Liberty" Boston Tea Party Quartering Act Quebec Act, 1774 Declaratory Act Coercive (Intolerable) Acts Townshend Duties (1767) First Continental Congress Massachusetts General Court’s Circular Letter (1768) War of Independence Lexington and Concord Battle of Saratoga Second Continental Congress Alliance of 1778 General Washington Netherlands and Spain Olive Branch Petition Valley Forge Battle of Bunker Hill Privateers and the “Law of the Sea” Three-phases of the war League of Armed Neutrality, 1780 Thomas Paine’s Common Sense John Paul Jones Declaration of Independence Yorktown Thomas Jefferson Newburgh Conspiracy Loyalists Sir George Rodney, Battle of Saints, 1782 Hudson Valley Campaign
    [Show full text]
  • The Battles of Germantown: Public History and Preservation in America’S Most Historic Neighborhood During the Twentieth Century
    The Battles of Germantown: Public History and Preservation in America’s Most Historic Neighborhood During the Twentieth Century Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By David W. Young Graduate Program in History The Ohio State University 2009 Dissertation Committee: Steven Conn, Advisor Saul Cornell David Steigerwald Copyright by David W. Young 2009 Abstract This dissertation examines how public history and historic preservation have changed during the twentieth century by examining the Germantown neighborhood of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1683, Germantown is one of America’s most historic neighborhoods, with resonant landmarks related to the nation’s political, military, industrial, and cultural history. Efforts to preserve the historic sites of the neighborhood have resulted in the presence of fourteen historic sites and house museums, including sites owned by the National Park Service, the National Trust for Historic Preservation, and the City of Philadelphia. Germantown is also a neighborhood where many of the ills that came to beset many American cities in the twentieth century are easy to spot. The 2000 census showed that one quarter of its citizens live at or below the poverty line. Germantown High School recently made national headlines when students there attacked a popular teacher, causing severe injuries. Many businesses and landmark buildings now stand shuttered in community that no longer can draw on the manufacturing or retail economy it once did. Germantown’s twentieth century has seen remarkably creative approaches to contemporary problems using historic preservation at their core.
    [Show full text]
  • Continental Army: Valley Forge Encampment
    REFERENCES HISTORICAL REGISTRY OF OFFICERS OF THE CONTINENTAL ARMY T.B. HEITMAN CONTINENTAL ARMY R. WRIGHT BIRTHPLACE OF AN ARMY J.B. TRUSSELL SINEWS OF INDEPENDENCE CHARLES LESSER THESIS OF OFFICER ATTRITION J. SCHNARENBERG ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION M. BOATNER PHILADELPHIA CAMPAIGN D. MARTIN AMERICAN REVOLUTION IN THE DELAWARE VALLEY E. GIFFORD VALLEY FORGE J.W. JACKSON PENNSYLVANIA LINE J.B. TRUSSELL GEORGE WASHINGTON WAR ROBERT LECKIE ENCYLOPEDIA OF CONTINENTAL F.A. BERG ARMY UNITS VALLEY FORGE PARK MICROFILM Continental Army at Valley Forge GEN GEORGE WASHINGTON Division: FIRST DIVISION MG CHARLES LEE SECOND DIVISION MG THOMAS MIFFLIN THIRD DIVISION MG MARQUES DE LAFAYETTE FOURTH DIVISION MG BARON DEKALB FIFTH DIVISION MG LORD STIRLING ARTILLERY BG HENRY KNOX CAVALRY BG CASIMIR PULASKI NJ BRIGADE BG WILLIAM MAXWELL Divisions were loosly organized during the encampment. Reorganization in May and JUNE set these Divisions as shown. KNOX'S ARTILLERY arrived Valley Forge JAN 1778 CAVALRY arrived Valley Forge DEC 1777 and left the same month. NJ BRIGADE departed Valley Forge in MAY and rejoined LEE'S FIRST DIVISION at MONMOUTH. Previous Division Commanders were; MG NATHANIEL GREENE, MG JOHN SULLIVAN, MG ALEXANDER MCDOUGEL MONTHLY STRENGTH REPORTS ALTERATIONS Month Fit For Duty Assigned Died Desert Disch Enlist DEC 12501 14892 88 129 25 74 JAN 7950 18197 0 0 0 0 FEB 6264 19264 209 147 925 240 MAR 5642 18268 399 181 261 193 APR 10826 19055 384 188 116 1279 MAY 13321 21802 374 227 170 1004 JUN 13751 22309 220 96 112 924 Totals: 70255 133787 1674 968 1609 3714 Ref: C.M.
    [Show full text]
  • FISHKILLISHKILL Mmilitaryilitary Ssupplyupply Hubhub Ooff Thethe Aamericanmerican Rrevolutionevolution
    Staples® Print Solutions HUNRES_1518351_BRO01 QA6 1234 CYANMAGENTAYELLOWBLACK 06/6/2016 This material is based upon work assisted by a grant from the Department of Interior, National Park Service. Any opinions, fi ndings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily refl ect the views of the Department of the Interior. FFISHKILLISHKILL MMilitaryilitary SSupplyupply HHubub ooff tthehe AAmericanmerican RRevolutionevolution 11776-1783776-1783 “...the principal depot of Washington’s army, where there are magazines, hospitals, workshops, etc., which form a town of themselves...” -Thomas Anburey 1778 Friends of the Fishkill Supply Depot A Historical Overview www.fi shkillsupplydepot.org Cover Image: Spencer Collection, New York Public Library. Designed and Written by Hunter Research, Inc., 2016 “View from Fishkill looking to West Point.” Funded by the American Battlefi eld Protection Program Th e New York Public Library Digital Collections. 1820. Staples® Print Solutions HUNRES_1518351_BRO01 QA6 5678 CYANMAGENTAYELLOWBLACK 06/6/2016 Fishkill Military Supply Hub of the American Revolution In 1777, the British hatched a scheme to capture not only Fishkill but the vital Fishkill Hudson Valley, which, if successful, would sever New England from the Mid- Atlantic and paralyze the American cause. The main invasion force, under Gen- eral John Burgoyne, would push south down the Lake Champlain corridor from Distribution Hub on the Hudson Canada while General Howe’s troops in New York advanced up the Hudson. In a series of missteps, Burgoyne overestimated the progress his army could make On July 9, 1776, New York’s Provincial Congress met at White Plains creating through the forests of northern New York, and Howe deliberately embarked the State of New York and accepting the Declaration of Independence.
    [Show full text]
  • The George Washington University
    The George Washington University Degree Programmme Does your University accept the Yes. HKCEE grades are considered direct equivalents to GCSE HKCEE and HKALE for exams. The HKALE grades are equivalent to GCE A-level. admission to your University? What are the entry requirements HKALE grades A-C. for a student with HKCEE and HKCEE in a broad range of subjects – the majority should be grade HKALE qualifications entering A-B. your University? Do students with HKCEE and Students must take the SAT or ACT and have an official score report HKALE qualifications have to sit sent from the College Board to the George Washington University. an entrance examination to enter your University? Is there a language proficiency Students must submit an official TOEFL score (Test of English as a test that students with HKCEE Foreign Language) unless the student scores a 550 or higher on the and HKALE qualifications critical reading section of the SAT. wishing to enter your University must take? Is there a standard on an For TOEFL minimum requirements visit: international English scale that http://gwired.gwu.edu/adm/apply/international.html students with HKCEE and HKALE qualifications wishing to enter your University must reach? Are there any other tests that No. students with HKCEE and HKALE qualifications wishing to enter your University must take? When must they be taken? Is there an entry quota that No. applies to students with HKCEE and HKALE qualifications wishing to enter your University? Where can information be Up-to-date information can be found
    [Show full text]
  • The Halifax Citadel
    THE HALIFAX CITADEL National Historic Park Halifax, Nova Scotia Issued under the authority of the Honourable Arthur Laing, P.C., M.P., B.S.A., Minister of Northern Affairs and National Resources HALIFAX CITADEL NOVA SCOTIA THE HALIFAX CITADEL Halifax, Nova Scotia Halifax was founded in 1749 to provide a base for the British Navy and Army and a springboard for attack on the French at Louisbourg and Quebec, because the final contest between France and England for possession of the North American continent was clearly approaching. Citadel Hill was always the innermost keep and chief land defence of the Halifax Fortress. Four forts were built, at different periods, on its summit. The first was part of a wooden palisade around the young settlement, designed to protect the settlers from Indians. The second was built at the time of the American Revolution and was intended as a stronghold and base against the rebels. The third was built while Napoleon Bonaparte was trying to conquer the world, and this one was later repaired for the War of 1812 with the United States. Because of the latter war, Britain knew she must have a permanent fortress here as Atlantic base in time of peril, and so the fourth, the present one, was constructed. Not one of these forts was ever called upon to resist invasion. No shot was ever fired against them in anger. However, it is safe to say that they had served their purpose merely by existing. The First Citadel When the Honourable Edward Cornwallis arrived at Chebucto Harbour on June 21, 1749, accompanied by more than 2,500 settlers, one of his first thoughts was to secure the settlement from attacks by marauding Indians, ever ready to molest the British during periods of nominal peace between England and France.
    [Show full text]
  • THADDEUS KOSCIUSZKO I the KOSCIUSZKO HOUSE I I NATIONAL MEMORIAL I PENNSYLVANIA I 1:· B&W S~Ans
    I .. historic structure reJiort .., histori.cal and architectural data . I , .. • , . <"' \-;>.\ STO\<P.GE I \ , i'JATI ONAL PAP.!< SERVICE I ()ENVE?. SEf11JiCE CENTER BRAN CH OF MICRO GRAPHICS . I : .I,JBRARY COPY . I ·· I ·I I . I· . '. I' 'j. I I I I I THADDEUS KOSCIUSZKO I THE KOSCIUSZKO HOUSE I I NATIONAL MEMORIAL I PENNSYLVANIA I 1:· B&W S~ans . J0/11/HJoS I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I --- 4••• -·-·-· - I I . HISTORIC STRUCTURE REPORT ·I THE KOSCIUSZKO HOUSE HISTORICAL AND AR~ lT ECTURAL DATA ·I. THADDEUS KOSCIUSZKO NATIONAL MEMORIAL I PENNSYLVANIA I ·I I I by James D. Mote I David G. Henderson I I I ' DENVER SERVICE CENTER HISTORIC PRESERVATION TEAM NATIONAL PARK SERVICE I UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE IJ:ITERIOR DENVER, COI.ORADO I October 1974 I I· • I - - - . I I I I · I I I I I ' I I . .. I I I I I • I I ---· ·--· I ·I PREFACE 'I Tadeusz (Thaddeus) Kosciuszko was one of 'the first . foreign vol'unteers to come to the aid of the American Revolutionary Army. Arriving in Philadelphia in August 1776, he won a commission as colonel I of engineers· for his aid in the planning of defense works on the. Delaware River. Kosciuszko joined the northern army under General . Gates in the spring of 1777; his engineerir.g works were instrumental in the important victory over Burgoyne at Saratoga. From March 1778 I to June 1780, Kosciuszko was in charge of constructing defense works at West Point.
    [Show full text]
  • The Battle of Saratoga to the Paris Peace Treaty
    1 Matt Gillespie 12/17/03 A&HW 4036 Unit: Colonial America and the American Revolution. Lesson: The Battle of Saratoga to the Paris Peace Treaty. AIM: Why was the American victory at the Saratoga Campaign important for the American Revolution? Goals/Objectives: 1. Given factual data about the Battle of Saratoga and the Battle of Yorktown, students will be able to describe the particular events of the battles and how the Americans were able to win each battle. 2. Students will be able to recognize and explain why the battles were significant in the context of the entire war. (For example, the Battle of Saratoga indirectly leads to French assistance.) 3. Students will be able to read and interpret a key political document, The Paris peace Treaty of 1783. 4. Students will investigate key turning points in US history and explain why these events are significant. Students will be able to make arguments as to why these two battles were turning points in American history. (NYS 1.4) 5. Given the information, students will understand their historical roots and be able to reconstruct the past. Students will be able to realize how victory in these battles enabled the paris Peace Treaty to come about. (NCSS II) Main Ideas: • The campaign consists of three major conflicts. 1) The Battle of Freeman’s farm. 2) Battle of Bennington. 3) Battle of Bemis Heights. • Battle of Bennington took place on Aug. 16-17th, 1777. Burgoyne sent out Baum to take American stores at Bennington. General Stark won. • Freeman’s farm was on Sept.
    [Show full text]
  • Inquiry – Benedict Arnold
    Inquiry – Benedict Arnold Hook discussion question: What is betrayal? The discussion must touch on themes of loyalty and trust. Other themes may include ethics and morality. Hook visual: Presentation formula Previous Unit: The Revolutionary War will be in progress. Saratoga (1777) should have been covered. This Unit: Narrative story to present a skeletal overview of the events. Then introduce the documents, to add “muscle” to the events. Next Unit: The Revolutionary War topic will continue and be brought to conclusion. Post-Lesson Discussion prompts 1. How should we go about weighing the good someone does against the bad? At what point is one (good/bad) not balanced by the other? 2. After the war, for what reasons might the British trust or not trust Benedict Arnold? 3. In the years following the war, America tried to get England to hand over Benedict Arnold to American authorities. Should the British give him up? Why yes/no? 4. One thing missing from the discussion of betrayal and loyalty is the concept of regret. How might this relate to Arnold, Washington and others, and by what means might it be expressed? 5. How likely (or not) would it be today for one of America’s top Generals to engage in a similar traitorous act? 6. To what extent would it matter if it is a General betraying the country or a civilian acting in a traitorous manner…should these be viewed in a similar light? 7. To what extent can a person be trusted again once they have already broken your trust? 8.
    [Show full text]
  • Environment and Culture in the Northeastern Americas During the American Revolution Daniel S
    The University of Maine DigitalCommons@UMaine Electronic Theses and Dissertations Fogler Library Spring 5-11-2019 Navigating Wilderness and Borderland: Environment and Culture in the Northeastern Americas during the American Revolution Daniel S. Soucier University of Maine, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/etd Part of the Canadian History Commons, Environmental Studies Commons, Military History Commons, Nature and Society Relations Commons, Other History Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Soucier, Daniel S., "Navigating Wilderness and Borderland: Environment and Culture in the Northeastern Americas during the American Revolution" (2019). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 2992. https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/etd/2992 This Open-Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UMaine. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UMaine. For more information, please contact [email protected]. NAVIGATING WILDERNESS AND BORDERLAND: ENVIRONMENT AND CULTURE IN THE NORTHEASTERN AMERICAS DURING THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION By Daniel S. Soucier B.A. University of Maine, 2011 M.A. University of Maine, 2013 C.A.S. University of Maine, 2016 A THESIS Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy (in History) The Graduate School University of Maine May, 2019 Advisory Committee: Richard Judd, Professor Emeritus of History, Co-Adviser Liam Riordan, Professor of History, Co-Adviser Stephen Miller, Professor of History Jacques Ferland, Associate Professor of History Stephen Hornsby, Professor of Anthropology and Canadian Studies DISSERTATION ACCEPTANCE STATEMENT On behalf of the Graduate Committee for Daniel S.
    [Show full text]
  • Fortification Renaissance: the Roman Origins of the Trace Italienne
    FORTIFICATION RENAISSANCE: THE ROMAN ORIGINS OF THE TRACE ITALIENNE Robert T. Vigus Thesis Prepared for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS May 2013 APPROVED: Guy Chet, Committee Co-Chair Christopher Fuhrmann, Committee Co-Chair Walter Roberts, Committee Member Richard B. McCaslin, Chair of the Department of History Mark Wardell, Dean of the Toulouse Graduate School Vigus, Robert T. Fortification Renaissance: The Roman Origins of the Trace Italienne. Master of Arts (History), May 2013, pp.71, 35 illustrations, bibliography, 67 titles. The Military Revolution thesis posited by Michael Roberts and expanded upon by Geoffrey Parker places the trace italienne style of fortification of the early modern period as something that is a novel creation, borne out of the minds of Renaissance geniuses. Research shows, however, that the key component of the trace italienne, the angled bastion, has its roots in Greek and Roman writing, and in extant constructions by Roman and Byzantine engineers. The angled bastion of the trace italienne was yet another aspect of the resurgent Greek and Roman culture characteristic of the Renaissance along with the traditions of medicine, mathematics, and science. The writings of the ancients were bolstered by physical examples located in important trading and pilgrimage routes. Furthermore, the geometric layout of the trace italienne stems from Ottoman fortifications that preceded it by at least two hundred years. The Renaissance geniuses combined ancient bastion designs with eastern geometry to match a burgeoning threat in the rising power of the siege cannon. Copyright 2013 by Robert T. Vigus ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis would not have been possible without the assistance and encouragement of many people.
    [Show full text]