Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Study Phase II | Report – Final Draft San Francisco Planning Department
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Study Phase II | Report – Final Draft San Francisco Planning Department Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Study Phase II DRAFT April 2017 Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates Inc. | i Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Study Phase II | Report – Final Draft San Francisco Planning Department Table of Contents Page 1 Executive Summary ............................................................................................................ 1 2 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 2 Study Purpose and Role ........................................................................................................................... 3 Timeline ........................................................................................................................................................ 6 Planning Context ........................................................................................................................................ 6 Study Partners ............................................................................................................................................ 9 Outreach Summary .................................................................................................................................. 10 3 Existing and Future Conditions ......................................................................................... 11 Transportation Network Overview ....................................................................................................... 11 Land Use .................................................................................................................................................... 14 Zoning ........................................................................................................................................................ 17 Major Development and Infrastructure Projects ................................................................................ 19 4 Multi-Modal Facility Concept Alternatives and Evaluation ............................................... 27 Alternatives Development ...................................................................................................................... 28 Concept Alternatives ............................................................................................................................... 30 Multi-Modal Evaluation Approach ....................................................................................................... 39 Evaluation Results ..................................................................................................................................... 41 Technical Feasibility Assessment............................................................................................................ 49 5 Facility and Area Connectivity Assessment ...................................................................... 56 Non-Motorized Connectivity Assessment: Barriers and Opportunities .......................................... 56 Transit Connectivity Assessment ............................................................................................................. 67 Multi-Modal Facility Connectivity Recommendations ........................................................................ 73 6 Economic Development Assessment................................................................................. 74 Demographic and Socioeconomic Characteristics of Surrounding Neighborhoods .................... 74 Environmental Justice (EJ) ....................................................................................................................... 76 Market Assessment .................................................................................................................................. 78 Impacts on Existing Business and Livability ......................................................................................... 79 7 Funding and Next Steps .................................................................................................... 81 Land Use Context..................................................................................................................................... 81 Preferred Alternative .............................................................................................................................. 82 Multi-Modal Facility Implementation Process ..................................................................................... 82 Funding Opportunities............................................................................................................................. 83 Next Steps ................................................................................................................................................. 85 8 Appendices ....................................................................................................................... 86 Glossary of Terms and Acronyms ......................................................................................................... 86 Quantitative Details in Evaluation Measures ...................................................................................... 86 Comments from Open House ................................................................................................................. 89 Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates Inc. | i Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Study Phase II | Report – Final Draft San Francisco Planning Department Table of Figures Page Figure 1 Study Area and Caltrain Spatial Gap to Surrounding Uses ..................................................... 2 Figure 2 Preferred Multi-Modal Facility Location - Concept ..................................................................... 3 Figure 3 Sunnydale Avenue Preferred Multi-Modal Facility Location ..................................................... 5 Figure 4 Timeline of Planned Transportation in the Bi-County Area ........................................................ 6 Figure 5 Summary of Priority Development Areas ...................................................................................... 8 Figure 6 Map of Priority Development Areas............................................................................................... 9 Figure 7 Public Meeting at the San Francisco Public Library Visitacion Valley Branch ...................... 10 Figure 8 Existing Weekday Transit Service in Facility Area .................................................................... 12 Figure 9 Existing Muni Ridership and Service Map .................................................................................... 13 Figure 10 Existing and Future Street/Transportation Facilities Near Bayshore Station ..................... 15 Figure 11 Study Area Land Use Map........................................................................................................... 16 Figure 12 Land Uses in Visitacion Valley and Surrounding Developments ........................................... 17 Figure 13 Major Plan Areas and Development Projects in the Bi-County Area .................................. 19 Figure 14 Draft Phasing Map of Schlage Lock Site (Subject to Updates) ............................................ 20 Figure 15 Area under review for California High Speed Rail light maintenance facility ................ 26 Figure 16 Preferred Multi-Modal Facility Location - Concept................................................................. 28 Figure 17 Desired Facility Elements: Design Principles .............................................................................. 30 Figure 18 Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Alternative 1 ............................................................................ 32 Figure 19 Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Alternative 2 ............................................................................ 34 Figure 20 Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Alternative 3 ............................................................................ 36 Figure 21 Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Alternative 4 ............................................................................ 38 Figure 22 Multi-Modal Facility Evaluation Framework ............................................................................. 40 Figure 23 Scoring Legend ............................................................................................................................... 41 Figure 24 Transit Operations and Performance Metrics ........................................................................... 41 Figure 25 Multi-Modal Connectivity Metrics................................................................................................ 43 Figure 26 Vehicular Access Metrics ............................................................................................................... 45 Figure 27 Policy and Implementation Considerations Metrics ................................................................. 47 Figure 28 Developable Area Comparison .................................................................................................. 52 Figure 29 Blocks Immediately Around Facility ............................................................................................ 53 Figure 30 Bayshore Multi-Modal Facility Conceptual Cost Estimate .....................................................