Research Journal of Foodservice Management & Educa on, Volume 11, Number 1, Pages 23–33 . ©2017 Published jointly by the Foodservice Systems Management Educa onal Council and the Na onal Associa on of Contribu on College & University Food Services
Ethnic Food in the Journey of International College Students in the United States Khalid Mahmoud Eyoun, PhD1*; David Spencer Mar n, PhD2 1Auburn University, Auburn, AL, USA 2Associate Professor, Auburn University, Auburn, AL, USA culture that their restaurant represents. One example of cultural and ABSTRACT ethnic diversity is the success of ethnic food restaurants in the The purpose of this study was to inves gate the importance of ethnic American foodservice market. In 2009, ethnic food sales in the U.S. food to interna onal college students in the U.S. An online survey was surpassed $2.2 billion, and they were expected to increase by 20% by developed through reviewing the relevant literature, conduc ng focus 2014 (US Ethnic Food Market, 2005). America’s ethnic food market groups, and administering a pilot study. The popula on of this study generates $75 billion in annual sales; almost 65% of this is a ributed consisted of interna onal students enrolled in universi es across to the restaurant sector of the foodservice industry (US Ethnic Food different regions of the U.S. Four hundred and eleven (411) Market, 2005). ques onnaires were received, 269 of which were usable. This research has discovered that ethnic food is important to interna onal According to Onuorah and Ayo (2003, p. 235), dining habits are students and that the inclusion of ethnic food into on‐campus dining determined by “values, beliefs, and environmental and religious op ons is a compe ve advantage for universi es who provide this circumstances, all of which are products of tradi on, culture, and service over those who do not. The study has also found that contacts.” The way people prepare and consume their food expresses university administrators should pay more a en on to providing their cultural values and social system (Murco , 1982). According to ethnic food op ons in on‐campus dining services. In addi on, the Gochman (1997), culture dis nguishes what we eat, how food is study concluded that ethnic food operators need to focus on certain obtained, who prepares it, where, when, and with whom it is ethnic food items that interna onal students consider when they dine consumed. People arrange their food dining habits into structured out. systems according to the cultural system (Counihan, 1999). The ways
Keywords: Interna onal Students, Recruitment, Dining Habits, Ethnic in which people think about food differ depending on cultural Food ethnicity. For example, according to cross‐cultural studies (Chandon, et al., 2000), French na ves consider pleasure an important element in choosing food, while Americans generally consider food a source of INTRODUCTION energy; food safety is also a cri cal factor in selec ng food. Ethnicity When interna onal students travel to foreign countries, they undergo is not only an integral characteris c of an individual, but it is also a what is termed accultura on. This is because interna onal travel process of group iden fica on in which people use ethnic labels [that inherently entails dealing with foreign cultures. The accultura on involve aspects like opinions, cogni on, affect, and knowledge] to process engenders a change within the interna onal travelers, which define themselves and others as well (Rossiter & Chan, 1998; Jamal & occurs as a result of their direct and con nuous contact with people Chapman, 2000). The reten on of language and food preferences, as from different cultures (Redfield, Linton, & Herskovits, 1936). well as friendship networks, are among the most accepted Nevertheless, any claim to accultura on adjustment would be dimensions of ethnic iden ty (Laroche, et al., 1999). Ethnicity affects incomplete without a en on to food consump on; this is especially consumer behavior through personal dress style, musical preferences, important considering the centrality of food to one’s wellbeing recrea onal ac vi es, and the consump on of food and drink (Locher et al., 2005). Food is a cultural symbol (Verbeke & Lo´pez, (Bocock, 1993, p.80). These factors have a strong impact on 2005). It is a cultural trait that humans learn throughout their primary customers, especially in other countries; the unique elements of development in childhood and a trait that consumers change with ethnic foods dis nguish them from the local cuisine (Chandon, et al., great reluctance in older age (Cervellon & Dube´, 2005). All previous 2000; Leclerc, et al., 1994). Sa a‐About, Paterson, Neuthouser, and studies concluded that food habits and prac ces represent a central Elder (2002) indicated that immigrants prefer to eat their tradi onal element of culture, and that it is an cipated that travelers would cuisine to overcome homesickness or to remember and share their struggle to break away from their habituated food choices. This was original culture, a statement further supported by Brown (2009) who confirmed in a more recent ethnographic study of the interna onal added that homesickness is accentuated further for those who live student adjustment process, in which food emerged as a major alone (for example, students), for whom ea ng seemed to be a research category (Brown, 2009). It was shown that dietary habits source of nostalgia for a life full of companionship and sharing. were of great importance both emo onally and physically; it was also Fieldhouse’s (1995) suggested that the need for self‐actualiza on is an aspect of student life that was least open to change. related to an innova ve use of food, where new recipes and food experimenta on becomes a personal trademark represen ng one’s Ethnic food refers to the expression of food in terms of a tudes, iden ty. values, behaviors and beliefs of a par cular culture that express The need for obtaining and increasing the consump on of healthy cultural tradi ons, heritage, religion, or na onal origin (Mora, 1998). food items is considered as a factor in the increased growth of ethnic Ethnic restaurants not only func on as ea ng establishments, but also foods. Recently in Europe, there has been an increase in the concern serve as “cultural ambassadors” that communicate the essence of a of consumers regarding food consump on, diet, health, and food culture to local customers through its menu (Wood & Munoz, 2007). safety (Verbeke & Viaene, 2000; Miles & Frewer, 2001, 2003). In many ethnic restaurants, the owners have roots in the original Generally, there is an inclina on to consume a low fat diet as part of a *Corresponding Author: Phone: (334) 332‐8376; E‐mail: kze0007@ germail.auburn.edu healthy intake in order to reduce the risk of heart diseases. Previous The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |23
research reveals significant associa ons between the quality of diet In line with the above no on, previous research has emphasized the and the availability of healthy food items in stores (Cheadle et al., importance of interna onalizing campuses and the educa onal 1991; Fisher & Strogatz, 1999). Due to the lack of local area food benefits stemming from the presence of interna onal students in the stores, it becomes hard to find many healthy food op ons, which U.S. (Jones, 2002; Yang; 2004). From a poli cal perspec ve, educa ng results in nega vely affect dietary habits and contributes to the risk of the future leaders of foreign countries helps spread the poli cal obesity. The availability of supermarkets has been correlated with values of the U.S. and fosters mutual understanding of the U.S. more fruit and vegetable consump on, more healthy diets, and lower throughout the world (NAFSA: Associa on of Interna onal Educators, levels of obesity (Morland et al., 2002a, 2006b; Laraia et al., 2004). 2003). Academically, interna onal students have been recognized as an asset to higher educa on (Ward, 2002), with prior research Studies reveal that deteriorated health, including higher levels of sugges ng that the presence of interna onal students diversifies a obesity and diabetes, is associated with an increased consump on of student body with varie es of na onali es, cultures, and languages Western‐style food (Burns, 2004; Gordon‐Larsen, Harris, Ward, & (Lewis, 2003). In addi on, it contributes to classroom diversity, Popkin, 2003; Himmelgreen, Bretnall, Peng, & Bermudez, 2005; Kedia, encourages cross‐cultural dialogue, and enriches the learning 2004; Saleh, Amana dis, & Samman, 2002). Specifically, research has environment and the experiences of domes c students (Hayward & indicated that sojourners are unlikely to gain weight or be considered Siaya, 2001; Rai, 2002; Ward, 2002). obese upon arrival in a western country, but they eventually converge to na ve‐born levels over me (McDonald & Kennedy, 2005). It has Student recruitment and reten on is important for academic been proved that transi on to a new culture can lead to substance ins tu ons throughout the world (Yurtseven, 2002). In 2000, Lacina, abuse, a high alcohol intake, altered dietary prac ces and an noted that “if we want to a ract and retain interna onal students to increased Body Mass Index (Abraı´do‐Lanza, Chao, & Flo´ rez, 2005; our university campuses, we must focus on the students’ needs and Gordon‐Larsen et al., 2003; Lara, Gamboa, Kahramanian, Morales, & successes in the American university experience” (p. 26). Research Bau sta, 2005; McDonald & Kennedy, 2005). For example, Asian has shown that most American colleges and universi es have students within in the U.S., who had resided there at least three accepted interna onal students into their programs without really months before the start of their studies, reported a decrease in the thinking about what they were doing (Goodwin & Nacht, 1983). In number of meals consumed per day; nearly half of them skipped these ins tu ons, students are self‐selected, and therefore come to breakfast more than other meals. Substan al increases were the ins tu on by accident or through word of mouth, o en/most of observed in the consump on of fats, salty and sweet snack items, and the me from either a family member or close friend. dairy products, whereas the consump on of meat, meat alterna ves, and vegetables significantly decreased. They also dined out less o en, There seems to be an agreement among industry professionals, but when they did, they chose American fast food establishments marke ng researchers, and sociologists that customer interac ons (Pan et al., 1999). through word‐of‐mouth (WOM) can have a major impact on consumer response to a product and that product’s adver sing (Herr, Several personal behaviors can influence the health of individuals as a Kardes & Kim, 1991). Because WOM is an inexpensive and reliable whole. In the U.S., the two main behaviors that have been considered way of transmi ng informa on about products and services, WOM especially harmful to the health of Americans are smoking and the plays an important role in diffusing informa on through consumer lack of physical ac vity that results in obesity (Preston, Stokes, Mehta, markets and shaping consumer a tudes (Mourali et al., 2005). In & Cao, 2014). According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), 18 addi on to being an important outcome in any service context, % of deaths in the U.S. in 2000 were a ributed to smoking and 15 % posi ve WOM has been shown to be one of the most important were caused by obesity (Mokdad et al., 2004, 2005). The years that factors in a rac ng interna onal students to higher educa on (Allen students spend at colleges present a dissimilar set of dietary & Higgins, 1994). In a study by Lois Pa on (2000), it was found that priori es, and unhealthy ea ng habits o en get worse during this while many variables such as course offerings, facili es, distance, and me period. When it comes to interna onal students, poor ea ng fees are important, the major force behind selec on criteria is word‐ habits become even more heightened due to the difficul es and of‐mouth communica on. The core service of a higher educa on challenges that those students encounter during the adapta on ins tu on, teaching, is intangible (McDougall & Snetsinger, 1990). process to the new culture. According to Leong and Sedlacek (1986), Intangibility [or the lack of physical evidence for a service] forces a adjustment difficul es are more predominant among interna onal consumer to rely on sources of informa on such as word‐of‐mouth students than their U.S. counterparts. As a result, these adjustment recommenda ons to arrive at purchase decisions (Webster, 1991). difficul es can influence several life aspects of interna onal students such as their psychological and physical health (Wan, Chapman, & In the same vein, students pay for services in the form of educa on, Biggs, 1992). therefore, they claim they should be treated like customers (Kanji & Tambi, 1999). Bejou (2005) argues that since it is cheaper to retain The Ins tute of Interna onal Educa on’s Open Doors 2014 reports exis ng customers than to a ract new ones, it is also more efficient that the number of interna onal students a ending colleges and for academic ins tu ons to focus on student sa sfac on and universi es within the U.S. increased by 7.7 percent to 270,128 during reten on, rather than undertaking aggressive marke ng campaigns the 2013‐2014 academic year, compared to 250,920 during the 2012‐ designed to a ract more students. Benne (2003) expounds upon 2013. Interna onal students contribute over $27 billion to the U.S. this idea by no ng how students who withdrawal may damage an economy through their expenditures; these expenditures encompass ins tu on’s reputa on through nega ve WOM comments, which can expenses such as tui on, room and board, health insurance, and impact future student recruitment and reten on efforts. Like normal other living expenses, according to the U.S. Department of Commerce customers, students undergo the usual consump on and post‐ (IIE, 2014). Higher educa on is considered one of the U.S. top service consump on behavior. Therefore, sa sfied students will engage in sector exports, this is because interna onal students provide WOM communica on, the recommenda on of their university to monetary ou low to the U.S. economy (IIE, 2014). Since the U.S. is a poten al students, returning to complete higher degrees (repeat mul cultural and mul ethnic na on, this na onal trend of hos ng purchase), coopera ng with the university by offering placements for diverse interna onal students will probably increase (Josiam & current students, giving guest lectures, and becoming valued alumni Monteiro, 2004; Sukalakamala & Boyce, 2007).
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |24
(Mavondo, Tsarenko & Gabbo , 2004a). As alumni, they provide Instrument Development and Focus Groups financial support, promote the university through WOM, create Due to the lack of literature on ethnic food in general and from the suppor ve networks accessible to current and future students, and perspec ve of interna onal students in the U.S. in par cular, two also provide role models for future student genera ons (Mavondo, focus groups with 12 interna onal students were conducted to Tsarenko & Gabbo , 2004b). Zeithaml (1988) highlighted that iden fy per nent variables for the survey. Several steps were taken customers’ percep on of value plays an important role in their to assure students confiden ality. Students were referred to by purchase decision‐making; this suggests that behavioral inten ons are names of their choosing that were not their original ones, sessions consequences of value percep on. In essence, when customers have were moderated by the researchers and notes were taken manually. high levels of value percep on from their consumer experiences, they At the beginning of the focus group sessions, par cipants were are more likely to express posi ve behavioral inten ons. informed about the purpose of the study, and they were assured about the confiden ality of the focus group discussions. All focus For a plethora of reasons, ethnic food is important in the lives of group sessions were tape recorded and transcribed by the interna onal students because it represents a basic part of their researchers. The total me of the focus group sessions was culture, history, faith, and individual iden ty (Eyoun & O’Neill, 2012). approximately 90 minutes each. Par cipants of the focus groups As a result, fulfilling the dietary needs of interna onal students on represented several regions around the world. The researchers asked campuses and in surrounding communi es should be recognized as a ques ons, facilitated discussions, and encouraged par cipa on compe ve advantage from the perspec ve of universi es. A clearer between group members. A list of topics was prepared in advance of understanding of the importance and value of sa sfying the ethnic the focus group sessions, covering broad ethnic food‐related issues diets of interna onal students will give universi es valuable insight such as: the importance of ethnic food to the par cipants, their ethnic into how to be er sa sfy their customers. In turn, this, will help these food dining habits, the rela onship between ethnic food and future universi es more effec vely to fulfill the needs of exis ng behavioral inten ons, the rela onship between ethnic food and interna onal students and will make their ins tu ons more a rac ve par cipants self‐reported personal health, and the availability and the to future interna onal students. Therefore, in current environments quality of ethnic food restaurants and retailers in the areas where universi es are compe ng to enrich their campuses in an surrounding par cipant residences in the U.S. Analyzing the data abundance of ways, the inclusion of providing proper on‐campus obtained from the focus group discussions took several steps. First, ethnic food services for students could aid in crea ng a compe ve responses to each topic related to ethnic food were grouped. Then, advantage between universi es. researchers analyzed responses by looking for key words and themes. This process resulted in iden fying clusters of key words in addi on to Li le empirical research exists on the role ethnic food plays in the phrases and themes that revolve around the issues that are journey of interna onal students; food is usually men oned only important. Lastly, significant issues for each related topic were incidentally as one of the aspects that students find distressing in iden fied. The results of the analysis were used to formulate the their accultura on process (Furukawa, 1997; UKCISA, 2009). There survey instruments and ques ons. The findings of the focus groups has been li le research dedicated to the study of interna onal were par cularly important in the development of the variables used student ea ng habits; studies by Henry and Wheeler (1980), in this study. Zwingmann and Gunn (1983) and Hall (1995) are rare, but old examples. Given the increase in interna onal student numbers in Two pilot tests were employed before sending the final survey recent decades, the changing source markets, and changing receiving version: six interna onal students were recruited through emails sent and origin socie es, there is a clear need for more contemporary by the researchers and briefed about the purpose of the research, research that is per nent to new condi ons. However, despite the and they were requested to give their feedback. Based on the importance of the interna onal students to American educa onal feedback gathered from the par cipants about relevance and clarity ins tu ons [and to the knowledge of the researchers], no previous issues in the survey ques ons, a number of modifica ons were made study has addressed the importance of ethnic food to be er to the survey. These changes included rewri ng ques ons, shortening accommodate interna onal students in the U.S. This gap in research the length of the survey by combining several ques ons into one underscores the purpose of this study, which is iden fying the category, and, as a result, the comple on me of survey was importance of ethnic food to interna onal students at American condensed. universi es. More specifically, the objec ves of this study are: 1) To examine the rela onship between ethnic food provision by university The ques onnaire consisted of six sec ons: a) demographic on‐campus dining op ons with interna onal student’s future informa on, b) availability and quality of ethnic food restaurants and behavioral inten ons of recommending the university to others and retailers measured on a 5‐point Likert‐type scale (1= Very Bad, 5= self‐reported personal health, 2) To iden fy the reasons which Very Good), c) self‐reported personal health measured on a 5‐point underline the poten al importance a ached to ethnic food, 3) To Likert‐type scale (1= Very Bad, 5= Very Good), d) dining habits, e) explore the current percep ons about the availability and quality of importance a ached to ethnic food measured on a 5‐point Likert‐type ethnic food restaurants and retailers , and, 4) To iden fy ethnic food scale (1= Strongly Disagree, 5= Strongly Agree), and f) future dining habits of interna onal students in the U.S. behavioral inten ons measured on a 5‐point Likert‐type scale (1= Strongly Disagree, 5= Strongly Agree). The items used in this sec on METHODS were modified from (Zeithaml et al., 1996), and included three items. Sample The target popula on for this study consisted of interna onal Cronbach’s Alpha (1951) is among the most commonly used reliability students enrolled in universi es across different regions of the U.S. coefficient (Hogan, Benjamin & Brezinkisi, 2000). Cronbach’s Alpha The sample was intended to represent the general popula on of testes were computed to evaluate the internal reliability. The results interna onal students as much as possible. The following criteria of the Cronbach’s Alpha test indicated that all scales measuring the were used to select par cipants: 1) must be 19 years of age or older, availability and quality of ethnic food restaurants and retailer (α = 2.) currently enrolled in the par cipa ng university, and 3) listed by 0.807) and the future behavioral inten ons (α = 0.901). The their university as “Interna onal Students.” Cbonbachs’ Alphas for both measures were above the recommended 0.70 threshold (Nunnally, 1978).
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |25
Data Collec on and Analyses Table 1. Characteris cs of the Sample (n=269) Several regions across the U.S. were ini ally iden fied as represen ng Characteris cs n % the country; subsequently, a list of public universi es in each of these Gender regions was prepared. A list of ten universi es from each region was Male 162 60.2 selected randomly. The list was sent to the Office of Interna onal Female 107 39.8 Educa on at Auburn University for their assistance in collec ng the Age data. An email was sent from Auburn University’s Office of Age 20 & Under 25 9.3 Interna onal Educa on to the forty poten al par cipa ng universi es 21 – 25 95 35.3 explaining and invi ng them to par cipate in this study. Ten of them, 26 – 30 85 31.6 including Auburn University, agreed to par cipate. Out of the ten, six 31 – 35 43 16.0 universi es eventually par cipated. These universi es represent the 36 – 40 12 4.5 states of Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, and Texas. The 41 & Older 9 3.3 data of this study were collected in collabora on with the Office of Marital Status Interna onal Educa on at Auburn University. Collec ng data took Single 197 73.2 several steps. First, the researcher received permission from the Married 66 24.5 Ins tu onal Review Board (IRB). Secondly, the researcher contacted Divorced 2 0.7 and coordinated with the staff responsible for interna onal Separated 0 0.0 admissions at the researcher’s ins tu on and at par cipa ng Widowed 0 0.0 ins tu ons. Thirdly, a cover le er was sent via email by the Office of Other 4 1.5 Interna onal Educa on at Auburn University to par cipa ng schools Ethnicity that explained the purpose of this study and contained a link to the Asian 88 32.7 survey. Four hundred and eleven (411) ques onnaires were received, Asian‐Indian 50 18.6 269 of which were usable. Returned ques onnaires that had one Black or African American 10 3.7 missing answer were not used. The returned ques onnaires were Caucasian 25 9.3 coded into the Sta s cal Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 21. Hispanic 6 2.2 Descrip ve and frequency analyses were used to describe the La n American 17 6.3 characteris cs of the sample. An independent t‐test was used to test Na ve American 0 0.0 the differences between the universi es who provide on‐campus Middle Eastern 56 20.8 ethnic food dining services and those who do not and the future Mul ‐Ethnic 3 1.1 behavioral inten ons and the personal self‐reported personal health. Other 14 5.2 Mean scores and standard devia on were used to interpret the Highest Educa on Obtained importance a ached to ethnic food, examine the current percep ons Bachelor 112 41.6 about the availability and quality of ethnic food, and lastly iden fy the Master 96 35.7 ethnic food dining habits. Ph.D. 15 5.6 Post Doctorate 7 2.6 RESULTS Other 39 14.5 Characteris cs of the Sample Degree Currently Pursuing Male respondents accounted for 60.2% of the sample. About 35.3% Bachelor 69 25.7 belonged to the age group of 21 to 25 years of age. Moreover, the Master 81 30.1 majority of the respondents 73.2% iden fied their marital status as Ph.D. 101 37.5 being single. In terms of ethnicity, the majority of the respondents Post Doctorate 10 3.7 were Asian 32.7%. Bachelor Degrees were the highest among Other 8 3.0 respondents 41.6% and approximately 37.5% currently enrolled as Amount of Time in the U.S. Ph.D. students. About 28.3% of the par cipants indicated they have Less than 1 year 76 28.3 been in the U.S. for less than one year (Table 1). 1 to less than 2 years 45 16.7 2 to less than 3 years 40 14.9 Ethnic food provision by university on‐campus dining op ons with 3 to less 4 years 44 16.4 interna onal student’s future behavioral inten ons and self‐ More than 4 years 64 23.8 reported personal health in the U.S. The majority of the par cipa ng universi es 66.9% do not have on‐ op ons, t (267) =1.211, p=.227. Although sta s cally insignificant, the campus ethnic food op ons, and only 33.1% provide such services. An respondents from universi es who provide on‐campus ethnic food independent sample t‐test showed a sta s cally significant difference op ons (M=3.26, SD=1.061) indicated higher self‐reported personal in the scores of interna onal students’ future behavioral inten ons health than respondents from universi es who do not provide similar for universi es who provide on‐campus ethnic food op ons services (M=3.09, SD=1.091) (Table 2). (M=4.0524, SD=.77508) and those who do not (M=3.7500, SD=.97573). This result suggests that the inclusion of ethnic food into Further analysis of future behavioral inten ons on‐campus food op ons is associated with the future behavioral To further understand the role of each item of the future behavioral inten ons of interna onal students, t (267) =2.552, p=.011. The same inten ons, addi onal analysis was conducted. The mean score and test was also used to inves gate the extent to which the inclusion of standard devia on of each item was calculated. According to the ethnic food into university on‐campus food op ons is associated with results, all items achieved high mean scores, which indicate that the the self‐reported personal health of interna onal students. This result future behavioral inten ons of interna onal students may be indicated that there is no sta s cally significant difference between associated with the inclusion of ethnic food into university on‐campus the responses obtained from both types of universi es with regard to food op ons (Table 3). personal health the inclusion of ethnic food into on‐campus food
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |26
Table 2. T‐Test Analysis of the Inclusion of Ethnic Food in On‐Campus, Future Behavioral Inten ons (FBI), and Self‐Reported Personal Health (n=269) N Mean SD t‐Value df Sig. Ethnic food availability in university on‐campus food court and FBI Yes 89 4.0524 .77508 2.552 267 .011 No 180 3.7500 .97573 Ethnic food availability in university on‐campus food court and self‐reported personal health Yes 89 3.26 1.067 1.211 267 .227 No 180 3.09 1.090
The importance a ached to ethnic food by interna onal students food ingredients for personal ethnic food cooking, 47.6% of the Excluding faith, all other items have an average score of 3.40 and respondents indicated that the quality of ethnic food ingredients is above, indica ng that these items are important. The five most fair, 31.2% indicated it is good and only 5.2% perceived the quality as prominent and important ethnic food items were: the rela onship very good. Of the respondents, 15.6% of the par cipants reported between ethnic food and culture 3.99, the role that ethnic food plays that the quality is bad and only 1.5% indicated that the quality is very in evoking memories of home 3.75, the rela onship between ethnic bad (Table 5). food and na onal iden ty 3.54, the availability of ethnic food acts as a remedy for homesickness and ethnic food provides a real sense of Availability of ethnic food restaurants and retailers in the areas belonging were equal with mean scores of 3.51, and ethnic food is surrounding university campuses related to diet 3.40. The least important a ribute was ethnic food as In terms of the availability of ethnic food restaurants and retailers in related to faith 2.32 (Table 4). the areas surrounding university campuses. Respondents revealed a high average of the availability with mean scores of 1.40 for Availability and quality of ethnic food restaurants and retailers restaurants and 1.61 for retailers, respec vely. A total of 59.9% of the In regards to the respondent’s percep ons of the availability and respondents reported that ethnic food restaurants were available in quality of ethnic food restaurants and ethnic food retailers that sell the area surrounding university campuses, whereas 40.1% men oned ethnic food ingredients, respondents revealed a moderate average of that such restaurants were not available. In terms of the availability of the availability with mean scores of 3.12 for restaurants and 3.04 for ethnic food retailers, 61.3% of the par cipants indicated that ethnic retailers. In rela on to the availability of ethnic food restaurants, food retailers were available in the areas surrounding university 47.2% of the par cipants men oned that the availability of ethnic campuses, whereas 38.7% indicated that ethnic food retailers were restaurants is fair, and 24.9% of which indicated that the availability is not available (Table 6). good. 18.6% of the sample stated that the availability of ethnic food restaurants is bad, around 5.9% men oned that the availability is very Ethnic food dining habits good, and only 3.3% indicated that the availability is very bad. In The majority of respondents reported that they prefer to cook at terms of the availability of ethnic food retailers, 48.0% of the home 82.9%, and only 17.1% prefer to eat out. In terms of dining respondents indicated that the availability of ethnic retailers is fair, companions, 68.8% of the sample prefers to eat out with friends, while 20.1% reported bad levels of availability, and 4.1% indicated 17.5% with spouse, 10.4% alone, 0.4% for business, and 3.0% chose that the availability is very bad. About 23.8% of the respondents other. With respect to how o en par cipants typically eat out, the perceived the availability of ethnic food retailers as good and 4.1 only majority of the respondents 39.4% stated that they eat out once a men oned it is very good. week followed by those who eat out 2 – 3 mes a week 23.4%. 15% of With regard to the respondents’ percep ons of the quality of ethnic the sample eat out once a month, whereas those who eat out rarely food restaurants and ethnic food retailers, par cipants revealed an average percep on of the quality of ethnic food restaurants, with mean scores of 3.18 and 3.21, respec vely. With regards to the Table 4. Importance A ached to Ethnic Food (n=269) quality of ethnic food restaurants, 50.9% of the respondents indicated Standard that the quality is fair, 26.4% indicated it is good and 5.2% stated that Rank Scale Items Mean* Devia on the quality is very good. Among the respondents, 16.4% men oned Ethnic food is related to my that the quality is bad, and 1.1% indicated that the quality is very bad. 1 culture 3.99 1.022 With respect to the quality of ethnic food retailers who sell ethnic Ethnic food helps in evoking 2 memories of home 3.75 1.068 Ethnic food is related to my Table 3. Analysis of Future Behavioral Inten ons (n=269) 3 na onal iden ty 3.54 1.229 Standard Ethnic food provides a real Scale Items Mean* Devia on 4 sense of my belonging 3.51 1.071 I would recommend my university to The availability of ethnic other interna onal students 3.83 .990 food is a remedy for I would say posi ve things about my 5 homesickness 3.51 1.177 university to other interna onal Ethnic food is related to my students 3.93 .960 6 diet 3.40 1.192 I would be happy to con nue my Ethnic food is related to my educa on at my current university 3.79 1.080 7 faith 2.32 1.226 *Measured on a 5‐point scale, where (1) Strongly Disagree to (5) Strongly *Measured on a 5‐point scale, where (1) Strongly Disagree to (5) Strongly Agree Agree The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |27
Table 5. Availability and Quality of Ethnic Food Restaurants and Inclusion of ethnic food into university on‐campus food op ons and Retailers (n=269) the academic experience n % A total of 36.4% of the par cipants agreed with the statement that Availability of Ethnic Food says universi es should pay much more a en on to include ethnic Restaurants (3.12 ± .892) food into their normal dining services, and 32.7% strongly agreed. Very Bad 9 3.3 Only 3.7% of the respondents strongly disagreed and 7.1% disagreed. Bad 50 18.6 Par cipants who neither disagreed nor agreed consisted of 20.1%. In Fair 127 47.2 regard to whether the inclusion of ethnic food op ons into on‐ campus dining services would have a posi ve impact on par cipant’s Good 67 24.9 educa onal experience, 37.2% of the respondents agreed and 26.8% Very Good 16 5.9 strongly agreed. Almost 4.5% strongly disagreed and 8.2% disagreed Availability of Ethnic Food (Table 8). Retailers (3.04 ± .876)
Very Bad 11 4.1 DISCUSSION Bad 54 20.1 It would appear that there is a possibility that Universi es who offer Fair 129 48.0 ethnic food services into on‐campus op ons are experiencing an Good 64 23.8 enhanced benefit, compared to universi es who do not. In fact, Very Good 11 4.1 spreading posi ve statements about the university was found to be Quality of Ethnic Food Restaurants the most important item related to interna onal students’ future (3.18 ± .806) Very Bad 3 1.1 Table 7. Ethnic Food Dining Habits (n=269) Bad 44 16.4 Scale Items n % Fair 137 50.9 Dining Habits Good 71 26.4 Eat Out 46 17.1 Very Good 14 5.2 Cook at Home 223 82.9 Quality of Ethnic Food Retailers (3.21 Dining Accompany ± .807) Alone 28 10.4 Very Bad 4 1.5 With Spouse 47 17.5 Bad 42 15.6 With Friends 185 68.8 Fair 128 47.6 For Business 1 0.4 Other 8 3.0 Good 84 31.2 Frequency of Ea ng Out Very Good 11 4.1 Rarely 27 10 Daily 27 10 or daily consist of 10% for both, and only 1.5% chose other. Once a Week 106 39.4 Respondents were also asked to indicate how many miles on average 2 ‐ 3 Times a Week 63 23.4 in a month they travel to dine at ethnic food restaurants. A total of Once a Month 42 15.6 34.6% of the par cipants men oned they travel for 5 miles or less Other 4 1.5 and 22.3% indicated that they travel for 25 miles or more. Almost Miles in a Month Traveled to 17.8% travel between 6 – 10 miles, 9.3% travel between 1 – 15 miles, Dine at Ethnic Food Restaurants 7.8% travel between 16 – 20 miles, and 8.2% travel between 21 – 25 5 miles or Less 93 34.6 miles. Par cipants were asked to report how many miles in a month 6 ‐ 10 miles 48 17.8 they travel to purchase ethnic ingredients. 30.5% of the par cipants 11 ‐ 15 miles 25 9.3 travel for 5 miles or less and 23.4% travel for 25 miles or more. About 16 ‐ 20 miles 21 7.8 13.8% travel between 6 – 10 miles, 10.4% travel between 11 – 15 21 ‐ 25 miles 22 8.2 miles, 10.8% travel between 16 – 20 miles, and 11.2% of respondents More than 25 miles 60 22.3 travel between 21 – 25 miles. Par cipants were asked to report how Miles in a Month Traveled to much money they spend a month on ethnic food; the majority of the Purchase Ethnic Food sample 34.2% spend $51.00 ‐ $100.00 a month, while 30.9% spend Ingredients $50.00 or less. A total of 12.3% of the respondents reported that they 5 miles or less 82 30.5 spend almost $101.00 ‐ $150.00; 7.8% spend $151.00 ‐ $200.00; 5.6% 6 ‐ 10 miles 37 13.8 spend $201.00 ‐ $300.00; 5.9% spend $251.11 ‐ $300.00; and only 11 ‐ 15 miles 26 10.4 3.3% spend more than $300.00 a month (Table 7). 16 ‐ 20 miles 29 10.8 21 ‐ 25 miles 30 11.2 Table 6. Availability of Ethnic Food Restaurants and Retailers in the More than 25 miles 63 23.4 Areas Surrounding University Campuses (n=269) Amount Spent on Ethnic Food in a Month n % $50.00 or less 83 30.9 Ethnic Food Restaurants (1.40 ± 0.491) $51.00 ‐ $100.00 92 34.2 Yes 161 49.9 $101.00 ‐ $150.00 33 12.3 No 108 40.1 $151.00 ‐ $200.00 21 7.8 Ethnic Food Retailers (1.61 ± 0.488) $201.00 ‐ $250.00 15 5.6 Yes 104 38.7 $251.00 ‐ $300.00 16 5.9 No 165 61.3 More than $300.00 9 3.3 The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |28
behavioral inten ons, in addi on to the willingness to recommend defines who we are, crea ng dis nc ons between us and others. the university to others. These findings are consistent with the focus Therefore, students considered their home country food as a way to group results presented earlier in this study. The results are also maintain, dis nguish and validate their na onal iden ty. In terms of consistent with the literature of the Word‐of‐Mouth and future health and diet, there was consensus among the focus group behavioral inten ons. Posi ve Word‐of‐Mouth (PWOM) has been par cipants that ea ng ethnic food was one of the ways to preserve recognized as being among the most important factors in a rac ng their physical health and to avoid weight gain. In fact, many interna onal students to higher educa on (Allen & Higgins, 1994). par cipants indicated that their home country food can be used as a This is because ethnic food is an essen al part of culture, na onal medicine in some situa ons. Some students stated that they were iden ty, evoking memories of home, and remedy for home ge ng worried about their health because of the high levels of fat sicknesses. There was no sta s cally significant difference between and cholesterol in the western food items. Ethnic food was found to responses obtained from universi es who provide on‐campus ethnic be a remedy of homesickness for the majority of par cipants. They food op ons and universi es who do not provide similar services and said that ethnic food is associated with home, and it has the ability to the self‐reported personal health. This finding is consistent with the reduce feelings of sadness for home. The consump on of home food finding of (Camillo, Kim, Moreo & Ryan, 2010), who addressed the helps requite for some unavoidable stressors, which means offering most popular a ributes of Italian cuisine in the U.S., discovering that them a chance to remember the past happy moments and forget the health benefits were among the least popular a ributes. However, sad present ones. Some par cipants indicated that ethnic food is this result could poten ally be explained with the assump on that important to them because it is part of their faith; they indicated that health is a personal issue. For some students, it might be an they were not allowed to eat all types of food because there are important aspect of their personality and they may know how to keep regula ons that control their consump on. These empirical findings themselves fit, regardless of whether ethnic food is available to them lend support to the proposi ons presented in previous studies (Sa a‐ on‐campus or not. In other words, students who pay special a en on About, Paterson, Neuthouser, & Elder, 2002; Brown, 2009; to their fitness may place less emphasis on the inclusion of ethnic Fieldhouse, 1995). food into on‐campus dining op ons when repor ng about their health. Another possible explana on for this finding is that seeking Furthermore, the result provides confirma on to Verbeke and Lo´pez healthy food items does not have to be associated with consuming (2005) who indicated that exo c flavor commonly evokes memories ethnic food; in other words, not all ethnic food items are healthy. of vaca ons in unusual loca ons, reflects and strengthens friendships, Therefore, people choose healthier food when they travel to a new and promotes openness to new cultures. Given that almost all culture, regardless of whether these food items are ethnic or not. students who par cipated in the focus groups have men oned these Also, immigrants who consider health an important issue when ea ng links explicitly, the five items that scored the highest were supported can choose food from other ethnici es. Moreover, it does not have to by the data gathered from survey of interna onal graduate students be from their na ve dining choices since they want to eat only in the U.S. The result pertaining to the least scored item, (of faith) is healthy food regardless of the origin of the food. interes ng. Faith‐related concerns didn’t seem as important as the other connec ons. Mul ple perspec ves could explain this finding. In With regard to the reasons underlining the poten al importance the process of accultura on, new immigrants tend to abolish their a ached to ethnic food, seven items were used. Six of the seven original cultural iden ty and seek contact with members of the host items scored (3.40 and above), namely the rela onship between community, a phenomenon described as assimila on according to ethnic food and culture, ethnic food helps in evoking memories of Zage a & Brown (2002). Applied to the finding of this study, home, the rela onship between ethnic food and na onal iden ty, interna onal students may ignore some of their religious concerns ethnic food provides a sense of belonging, ethnic food is a remedy for when they move to a new culture, or it may be that the foreign homesickness, and the rela onship between ethnic food and diet. The circumstances are not conducive to their religious; as a result, they rela onship between ethnic food and faith scored the least (2.32). In may abandon some religious food habits. It is also possible that faith the focus groups when par cipants were asked about the reasons is less of a concern for interna onal students simply because food why ethnic food was important to them, varied reasons were that is prepared and served in accordance with their faiths is not indicated in the responses. Par cipants revealed that ethnic food is available, leading them to accept an alterna ve type of food. important to their culture because they connect to it through the food they prepare and consume. They men oned that they o en use With regard to the current percep ons held by interna onal students their home country food as a means of retaining their cultural on the availability and quality of ethnic food restaurants and retailers iden ty. Food plays an essen al role as a cultural product because it in the U.S., par cipants reported an overall moderate average of
Table 8. Inclusion of Ethnic Food into University On‐Campus Food Op ons and the Academic Experience (n=269) Scale Items n % Universi es should give much more considera on to include ethnic food into on‐ campus dining services Strongly Disagree 10 3.7 Disagree 19 7.1 Neither Agree Nor Disagree 54 20.1 Agree 98 36.4 Strongly Agree 88 32.7 The inclusion of ethnic food op ons into on‐campus food dining services would have a posi ve impact on educa onal experiences Strongly Disagree 12 4.5 Disagree 22 8.2 Neither Agree Nor Disagree 63 23.4 Agree 100 37.2 Strongly Agree 72 26.8 The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |29
percep ons about the availability of ethnic food restaurants. Based for this lies in the expense of some kinds of ethnic foods. Some on the data gathered from the focus groups, par cipants’ percep ons par cipants in the focus groups stated they save a certain amount of regarding the availability and quality of ethnic food restaurants and money every month to dine at ethnic food and purchase ethnic food retailers were lower. This is because most par cipants men oned ingredients. Their only problem was with the rela vely high prices of that they usually leave towns in order to either dine at ethnic food both dining and purchasing ethnic ingredients. restaurants or purchase ethnic ingredients for personal cooking. This finding could be jus fied by the fact that six universi es have CONCLUSION AND APPLICATION par cipated in this study, so it might be in some towns surrounding The relevance of this study is rooted in the topic it has inves gated. par cipated campuses ethnic food provisions were more available Although some studies have concentrated on other aspects of than the area where the focus groups were conducted. This could interna onal students, research that considers the importance of explain the lower average level of percep ons in regards to the ethnic food [as a relevant variable in the overall experience of the availability of ethnic food restaurants and ethnic food retailers. interna onal students] does not exist. Implica ons of findings of this Clearly, the business community around some university campuses is study can be derived from university administrators and from ethnic not fully aware of interna onal students as a target market. food operators/owners.
The majority of respondents prefer to cook at home, this result could The findings obtained in the present study provide evidence that be an indica on of a lack of ethnic food restaurants. Or it might be there is a lack of a en on concerning ethnic food dining needs in the service and diversity available in these restaurants that is not American educa onal ins tu ons. This should incline university adequate, leading interna onal students to cook at home. This could administrators to be aware of this issue and subsequently, solve it. also be a ributed to the data showing that the majority of Only (33.1%) of the par cipa ng universi es in the present study respondents are graduate students who are not required to live on provide on‐campus ethnic dining services and (66.9%) do not. campus and par cipate in meal plans. The focus group work revealed Therefore, university administrators must take more ac on to include two per nent issues regarding dining habits: some interna onal ethnic dining services into their current on‐campus op ons. According student’s limited budgets, and, the tastes of ethnic food ingredients to Namvar (2000), accurate and mely informa on with regard to are not the same as those which can be found in their home country. what is likely to happen to the economy and society has always been Therefore, when interna onal students cook at home they save an important issue for business decision makers. Given that the money and at the same me try to assimilate a taste that is closer to enrollment of interna onal students is increasing, knowing how to home than that is offered by restaurants. In terms of whom they eat sa sfy the needs of these unique students will be of value to with, most of par cipants men oned that they usually eat out with university administrators especially within the intensive compe on friends. This finding is consistent with other previous research. For environment of a rac ng and reten on more interna onal students. example, Counihan and Van Esterk (1997) argue that ea ng and sociability are intertwined, and this was a student experience. To Universi es who provide on‐campus ethnic op ons are experiencing a some extent, this result is consistent with the findings of Na onal be er reputa on among interna onal students over those Restaurant Associa on (2000), which indicated that Chinese universi es who do not. But to improve ethnic op ons, those restaurants represent “basic family appeal” and a racts almost all universi es should concentrate on issues that have more a achment consumers (Mills, 2000). Also, this finding supports the focus group to ethnic food. Those aspects of ethnic food are the most important, findings which indicated that ethnic food represents many aspects of which means that improving current services is necessary to sa sfy the par cipants’ lives beyond hunger sa sfac on only. It represents a interna onal ethnic food requirements. Also, pursuant to the results, form of social gathering, socializing, and enjoying the company of faith should not be considered when improving services because it friends. Despite the busy me of most of students, the majority of compara vely has a low a achment to ethnic food. But it might be them indicated that they eat out once a week and 2 to 3 mes a worth considering when it comes to those ethnici es whose religion week. This means that ethnic food is important and it plays a basic impacts their consump on, such as Muslims and Jews, where there role in their lives, which explains why interna onal students give it are sets of restric ons and specific ways of processing food. priority in their schedules. To be er understand the specifics of various ethnici es, universi es With regard to miles, par cipants usually travel monthly to dine at could discuss with various groups of interna onal students their ethnic food restaurants and to purchase ethnic food ingredients needs and preferences regarding their ethnic food. Those universi es which are used for personal home cooking. Par cipants who travel 5 should learn from past trends and apply the informa on obtained to miles or less were the majority, followed by those who travel for their present and future schemes when it comes to market the more than 25 miles. Obviously, in some universi es, ethnic food university. As the number of interna onal students increase in most restaurants and retailers are available, while for some areas they are of the U.S. university and college campuses, these ins tu ons will not. This means that some areas surrounding college towns are need to always be looking for feedback from their target customers, missing this kind of services, it would be worthy for business because it helps them provide products and services that these prac oners and university administrators to think of how to serve students want. By iden fying who their customers are and what they interna onal students target by fulfilling their ethnic food needs. want, universi es will have an easier me bringing them in, providing Comparing this result to the findings of the focus groups, some them with value, and bringing them back. With regard to marke ng par cipants men oned that they o en leave their town to meet their and recrui ng efforts, universi es are compe ng to a ract ethnic dining needs by ea ng at ethnic food restaurants or purchasing interna onal students due to the benefits they bring. In doing so, ethnic food ingredients. In rela on to the amount of money universi es use different marke ng and recrui ng tac cs such as: par cipants spend in a month on ethnic food, the majority of employing on‐campus ethnic dining to be er recruitment efforts. respondents spend between $51.00 ‐ $100.00, followed by those who spend between $50.00 or less. This means that despite the limited Learning from and benchmarking with universi es in the U.S. with budgets of some interna onal students, they s ll spend a por on of proven ethnic food opera ons on campus can be a step in the right their income to fulfill their ethnic dining needs. A possible explana on direc on. Universi es who do not serve ethnic food into on‐campus
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |30
food court should pay a en on and take note of their counterparts REFERENCES who provide these op ons. Abraı´do‐Lanza, A. F., Chao, M. T., & Flo´rez, K. R. (2005). Do healthy behaviors decline with greater accultura on? Implica ons for the La no mortality This study sheds light on the somewhat lack of the ethnic food paradox. Social Science & Medicine, 61(6), 1243‐1255. provision in terms of ethnic food restaurant and retailers that sell Allen, A., & Higgins, T. (1994). Higher Educa on: The Interna onal Student Experience. Heist in associa on with UCAS. ethnic food ingredients for personal cooking in some of the areas Ayala, G. X., Baquero, B., & Klinger, S. (2008). A systema c review of the surrounding universi es. Although ethnic food posi vely affects rela onship between accultura on and diet among La nos in the United universi es who offer this service, business operators interested in States: Implica ons for future research. Journal of the American Diete c this area could be posi vely affected as well. From the perspec ve of Associa on, 108(8), 1330‐1344. ethnic food restaurant owners/operators, especially in the areas Benne , R. (2003). Determinants of undergraduate student dropout rates in a surrounding campuses, iden fying the wants and needs of university business studies department. Journal of Further and Higher interna onal students is a vital issue to help businesses succeed. Educa on, 27(2), 123‐39. According to the results revealed in this study, businesses need to Bocock, R. (1993), Consump on, Routledge, London. Brown, L. (2009). The role of food in the adjustment journey of interna onal focus on the cultural aspects of ethnic food items, rather than students. The new cultures of food: marke ng opportuni es from ethnic, religious ones. They also should diversify their menus to include religious, and cultural diversity. London, UK: Gower, 37‐53. different food ethnici es in order to encompass all interna onal Burns, C. (2004). Effect of migra on on food habits of Somali women living as student backgrounds. For mee ng interna onal students’ needs, refugees in Australia. Ecology of Food and Nutri on, 43(3), 213‐229. ethnic restaurant’s personality and style should be defined by the Chandon, P., Wansink, B., & Laurent, G. (2000). A benefit congruency ethnic food theme and should be mostly appealing to the needs of framework of sales promo on effec veness. Journal of marke ng, 64(4), 65 interna onal students. As the number of interna onal students ‐81. con nues to increase the need for more ethnic food restaurants and Cheadle, A., Bruce, P., & Curry, S. (1991). Community‐level comparisons between the grocery store environment and individual dietary prac ces. retailers will increase as well. Ethnic food retailers also need to Preven ve Medicine 20, 250‐261. consider the way they conduct their business. They need to diversify Counihan, C. (1999). The Anthropology of food and body: Gender, meaning, the ingredients as much as possible, and the taste of ingredients and power. New York: Routledge. should assemble the taste found in the origin of that ethnic food as Constan ne, M. G., Anderson, G. M., Berkel, L. A., Caldwell, L. D., & Utsey, S. O. much as possible. (2005).Examining the cultural adjustment experiences of African interna onal college students: a qualita ve analysis. Journal of Counseling Although this research has been carefully prepared, there are some Psychology, 52, 57‐66. unavoidable limita ons. According to the Open Doors report 2014, Eyoun, K., & O’Neill, M. (2012, January). Interna onal Student Sa sfac on with Ethnic Food Provision in a Southeastern College Town. Paper presented at Asia is the highest place of origin for interna onal students who come The 17th Annual Graduate Educa on and Graduate Student Research to the U.S; the number of students from Asia in the U.S increased by Conference in Hospitality and Tourism, Auburn, AL. 8.1% in 2013‐2014 to 568,510 students. This could poten ally affect Fieldhouse, P. (1995). Food and nutri on: customs and culture. London: the results of this study because if there is a greater percentage of Chapman & Hall. availability in Asian dining op ons, Asian students may report be er Fisher, B. D., & Strogatz, D. S. (1999). Community measures of low‐fat milk percep ons of ethnic food dining op ons than students of other consump on: comparing store shelves with households. American Journal ethnici es. Therefore, the dominance of Asian students may skew the of Public Health 89, 235‐237. results. Another limita on is that only six universi es actually Furukawa, T. (1997). Cultural distance and its rela onship to psychological adjustment of interna onal exchange students. Psychiatry and Clinical par cipated in this study. Therefore, cau on should be exercised Neurosciences, 51(3), 87‐91. when generalizing the results of this study beyond its scope. Based on Gilbert, P. A., & Khokhar, S. (2008). Changing dietary habits of ethnic groups in the lack of previous research addressing the issue of ethnic food and Europe and implica ons for health. Nutri on Reviews, 66, 203‐215. university students, this study is considered to be exploratory in Gochman, D. S. (1997). Handbook of Health Behavior Research. New York: nature, thus limi ng the applica on of the results to other Plenum. popula ons outside of the one inves gated here. Another limita on Gordon‐Larsen, P., Harris, K. M., Ward, D. S., & Popkin, B. M. (2003). of the current study which should be addressed in future research is Accultura on and overweight‐related behaviors among Hispanic immigrants the sample its‐self. No details about ways to segment the sample to the US: the Na onal Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. Social Science & Medicine, 57 (11), 2023‐2034. popula on were provided in the current study, but instead the Hall, J. (1995). Food and dietary requirements for interna onal students. sample was treated as a singly homogenous popula on. Differences Journal of Interna onal Educa on, 6(1), 53‐60. in the age, marital status and even the gender of the respondents Hayward, F. M., & Siaya, L. M. (2001). Public Experience, A tudes, and may have an effect on the behaviors of interna onal students, Knowledge: A Report on Two Na onal Surveys about Interna onal especially in regards to their cooking and ea ng out habits. In Educa on. Washington, DC: American Council on Educa on (ACE). addi on, because there is a paucity of published work within this area Henry, C., & Wheeler, E. (1980). Dietary pa erns among overseas students in and based on the focus group sessions, it was decided by the London. The Nutri on Society, 39 (2), A47. researchers to let the respondents themselves perceive the Herr, P. M., Frank R. K., & Kim, J. (1991). Effects of Word of Mouth and Product A ributes Informa on on Persuasion: An Accessibility‐Diagnos city availability of ethnic food restaurants and retailers through the Perspec ve. Journal of Consumer Research, 17(4), 454‐462. natural course of the study. Also, using only one ques on to measure Hogan, T. P., Benjamin, A., & Brezinski, K. L. (2000). Reliability methods. self‐reported personal health is not reliable. Therefore, more Educa onal and Psychological Measurement, 60, 523‐531. measurements should be added in future research. Lastly, future Ins tute of Interna onal Educa on. (2014). New Interna onal Student research should examine the rela onship, if there is any, between the Enrollment, 2005/06‐2013/14. Open Doors Report on Interna onal length of staying in the U.S. and interna onal students’ percep ons of Educa onal Exchange. Retrieved from h p://www.iie.org/opendoors. ethnic food. Jamal, A., & Chapman, M. (2000). Accultura on and Inter‐Ethnic Consumer Percep ons: Can You Feel What We Feel?. Journal of Marke ng Management, 16(4), 365‐391. Jones, Z. L. (2002). Organiza onal strategies for interna onaliza on: A case study of the University of Alberta. (Doctoral disserta on, University of Alberta, 2002). Disserta on Abstracts Interna onal, 63(05), 1647.
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |31
Josiam, B. M., & Monteiro, P. A. (2004). Tandori tastes: Percep ons of Indian Mourali, M., Laroche, M., & Pons, F. (2005). Antecedents of consumer rela ve restaurants in America. Interna onal Journal of Contemporary Hospitality preference for interpersonal informa on sources in pre‐purchase search. Management, 16(1), 18‐26. Journal of Consumer Behavior, 4(5), 307‐18. Kanji, G. K., & Tambi, M. A. (1999). Total quality management in UK higher Murco , A. (1982). On the social significance of the “cooked dinner” in South educa on ins tu ons. Total Quality Management, 10(1), 129‐53. Wales. Anthropology of Food, 21(4/5), 677‐696. Kedia, S. (2004). Changing food produc on strategies among Garhwali NAFSA: Associa on of Interna onal Educators (2003). In America’s interest: rese lers in the Himalayas. Ecology of Food and Nutri on, 43(6), 421‐442. Welcoming interna onal students. Report of the Strategic Task Force on Kumar, B. N., Meyer, H. E., Wandel, M., Dalen, I., & Holmboe‐O esen, G. Interna onal Student Access, Washington, DC: NAFSA. (2006). Ethnic differences in obesity among immigrants from developing Nicolaou, M., van Dam, R. M., & Stronks, K. (2006). Accultura on and countries, in Oslo, Norway. Interna onal Journal of Obesity, 30, 684‐690. educa on level in rela on to quality of the diet: a study of Surinamese Laraia, B.A., Siega‐Riz, A. M., Kaufman, J. S., & Janes, S. J. (2004). Proximity of South Asian and Afro‐ Caribbean residents of the Netherlands. Journal of supermarkets is posi vely associated with diet quality index for pregnancy. Human Nutri on and Diete cs, 19, 383‐393. Preven ve Medicine 39, 869‐875. Nunnally, J. C. (1978). Psychometric theory (2nd ed.). New York, NY: McGraw‐ Lara, M., Gamboa, C., Kahramanian, M. I., Morales, L. S., & Bau sta, D. E. H. Hill. (2005). Accultura on and La no health in the United States: a review of the Onuorah, C. E., & Ayo, J. A. (2003). Food taboos and their nutri onal literature and its sociopoli cal context. Annual Review of Public Health, 26 implica ons on developing na ons like Nigeria‐a review. Nutri on & Food (1), 367‐397. Science, 33(5), 235‐240. Laroche, M., Kim, C., & Tomiuk, M. A. (1999). Italian ethnic iden ty and its Pan, Y. L., Dixon, Z., Himburg, S., & Huffman, F. (1999). Asian students change rela ve impact on the consump on of convenience and tradi onal foods. their ea ng pa erns a er living in the United States. Journal of the Bri sh Food Journal, 101(3), 201‐228. American Diete c Associa on, 99(1), 54‐57. Leclerc, F., Schmi , B., & Dube, L. (1994). Foreign Branding and its Effects on Papadaki, A., & Sco , J. A. (2002). The impact on ea ng habits of temporary Product Percep ons and Evalua ons. Journal of Marke ng Research, 23, transloca on from a Mediterranean to a Northern European environment. 263‐270. European Journal of Clinical Nutri on, 56, 455‐461. Leong, F. L., & Sedlacek, W. E. (1986). A comparison of interna onal and U.S. Pe´rez‐Escamilla, R. (2009). Dietary quality among La nos: Is accultura on students’ preferences for help sources. Journal of College Student making us sick? Journal of the American Diete c Associa on, 109(6), 988‐ Personnel, 27, 426‐430. 991. Lewis, N. (2003). Code of Prac ce for the Pastoral Care of Interna onal Preston, S., Stokes, A., Mehta, N., & Cao, B. (2014). Projec ng the Effect of Students: Making a globalizing industry for New Zealand. Unpublished Changes in Smoking and Obesity on Future Life Expectancy in the United paper, presented at American Associa on of Geographers Annual Mee ng, States. Demography, 51, 27‐49. New Orleans, LA. Rai, G. S. (2002). Mee ng the educa onal needs of interna onal students: a Locher, J., Yoels, W., Maurer, D., & Ells, J. V. (2005). Comfort foods: an perspec ve from U.S. schools. Interna onal Social Work, 45(1) 21‐33. exploratory journey into the social and emo onal significance of food. Food Redfield, R., Linton, R., & Herskovits, M. (1936). Memorandum for the study of and Foodways, 13(4), 273‐97. accultura on. American Anthropologist, 38(1), 149‐152. Cervellon, M. C., & Dubé, L. (2005). Cultural influences in the origins of food Rossiter, J. R., & Chan, A. M. (1998). Ethnicity in business and consumer likings and dislikes. Food quality and preference, 16(5), 455‐460. behavior. Journal of Business Research, 42(2), 127‐134. Lois, P. (2000). How Administrators Can Influence Student University Selec on Saleh, A., Amana dis, S., & Samman, S. (2002). The effect of migra on on Criteria. Higher Educa on in Europe, 25(3), 345‐350. dietary intake, type 2 diabetes and obesity: the Ghanaian health and Mansoor, A. M., & Bryce, Q. (2007). Migra on and remi ances: Eastern nutri on analysis in Sydney, Australia. Ecology of Food and Nutri on, 41(3), Europe and the former Soviet Union. World Bank. Europe and Central Asia 255‐270. Region. Sukalakamala, P., & Boyce, J. B. (2007). Customer percep ons for expecta ons Mavondo, F. T., Tsarenko, Y., & Gabbo , M. (2004a). Interna onal and Local and acceptance of an authen c dining experience in Thai restaurants. Student Sa sfac on: Resources and Capabili es Perspec ve. Journal of Journal of Foodservice, 18(2), 69‐75. Marke ng for Higher Educa on, 14(1), 41‐60. UKCISA (2009). Interna onal students and culture shock, UK Council for Mavondo, F. T., Tsarenko, Y., & Gabbo , M. (2004b). Interna onal and Local Interna onal Student Affairs. Retrieved from: www.ukcisa.org.uk/files/pdf/ Student Sa sfac on: Resources and Capabili es Perspec ve. Journal of info_sheets/culture_shock.pdf. Marke ng for Higher Educa on, 14(1), 41‐60. US ethnic food market (2005). Agriculture and agri‐food Canada. Retrieved McDougall, G. H., & Snetsinger, D. W. (1990). The intangibility of services: from: www.ats.agr.gc.ca/us/4040_e.htm. measurement and compe ve perspec ves. Journal of Services Marke ng, Verbeke, W. A. J., & Viaene, J. (2000). Ethical challenges for livestock 4(4), 27‐40. produc on: mee ng consumer concerns about meat safety and animal McDonald, J. T., & Kennedy, S. (2005). Is migra on to Canada associated with welfare. Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Ethics, 12(2), 141‐51. unhealthy weight gain? Overweight and obesity among Canada’s Verbeke, W., & Lo´pez, G. P. (2005). Ethnic food a tudes and behaviors immigrants. Social Science & Medicine, 61(12), 2469‐2481. among Belgians and Hispanics living in Belgium. Bri sh Food Journal, 107 McWilliams M. (2007). Food around the world: a cultural perspec ve. New (11), 823‐40. Delhi (India): Pearson Educa on. Yang, L. (2004). Interna onal student recruitment in Alberta public colleges. Miles, S., & Frewer, L. J. (2001). Inves ga ng specific concerns about different (Doctoral disserta on, University of Alberta, 2004). Disserta on Abstracts food hazards. Food Quality and Preference, 12(1), 47‐61. Interna onal, 64(07), 23‐42. Miles, S., & Frewer, L. J. (2003). Public Percep on of Scien fic uncertainty in Wahlqvist, M. L. (2002). Asian migra on to Australia: food and health rela on to food hazards. Journal of Risk Research, 6(3), 267‐83. consequences. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutri on, 11(Supp3), S562‐ Mokdad, A. H., Marks, J. S., Stroup, D. F., & Gerberding, J. L. (2004). Actual S568. causes of death in the United States, 2000. Journal of the American Medical Wandel, M., Raberg, M., Kumar, B., & Holmboe‐O esen, G. (2008). Changes in Associa on, 291, 1238‐1245. food habits a er migra on among South Asians se led in Oslo: the effect of Mokdad, A. H., Marks, J. S., Stroup, D. F., & Gerberding, J. L. (2005). Correc on: demographic, socio‐economic and integra on factors. Appe te, 50(2,3), Actual causes of death in the United States. Journal of the American 376‐385. Medical Associa on, 293, 293‐294. Wan, T. Y., Chapman, D. W., & Biggs, D. A. (1992). Academic stress of Mora, J. K. (1998). Understanding mul culturalism: cultures and values, San interna onal students a ending US universi es. Research in Higher Diego State University, San Diego. CA. Educa on, 33(5), 607‐623. Morland, K., Wing, S., Diez Roux, A., & Poole, C. (2002). Neighborhood Ward, D. (2002). Tracking interna onal students. Capitol Hill Hearing characteris cs associated with the loca on of food stores and food service Tes mony delivered to the Commi ee of House Educa on and the places. American Journal of Preven ve Medicine, 22(1), 23‐29. Workforce Subcommi ees on 21st Century Compe veness and Select Morland, K., Diez Roux, A., & Wing, S. (2006). Supermarkets, other food stores, Educa on. eMedia Mill Works, Inc. and obesity: the atherosclerosis risk in communi es study. American Webster, C. (1991). Influences upon Consumer Expecta ons of Services. The Journal of Public Health, 30(4), 333‐339. Journal of Services Marke ng, 5(1), 5‐17.
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |32
Will, B., Zeeb, H., & Baune, B. T. (2005). Overweight and obesity at school Zeithaml, V. A. (1988). Consumer percep ons of price, quality, and value: a entry among migrant and German children: a cross‐sec onal study. BMC means‐end model and synthesis of evidence. Journal of Marke ng, 52(3), 2‐ Public Health, 5, 45. 22. Yurtseven, H. O. (2002). How Does the Image of Engineering Affect Student Zwingmann, C. A., & Gunn, A. G. (1983). Uproo ng and health: Psychosocial Recruitment and Reten on? A Perspec ve from the USA. Global Journal of problems of students from abroad. Geneva, Switzerland: Division of Mental Engineering Educa on, 6(1), 17‐24. Health, World Health Organiza on.
The Journal of Foodservice Management & Education Page |33