Keynote Address

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Keynote Address A Service of Leibniz-Informationszentrum econstor Wirtschaft Leibniz Information Centre Make Your Publications Visible. zbw for Economics Borg, Anders Article Keynote Address CESifo Forum Provided in Cooperation with: Ifo Institute – Leibniz Institute for Economic Research at the University of Munich Suggested Citation: Borg, Anders (2011) : Keynote Address, CESifo Forum, ISSN 2190-717X, ifo Institut - Leibniz-Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung an der Universität München, München, Vol. 12, Iss. 3, pp. 18-20 This Version is available at: http://hdl.handle.net/10419/166448 Standard-Nutzungsbedingungen: Terms of use: Die Dokumente auf EconStor dürfen zu eigenen wissenschaftlichen Documents in EconStor may be saved and copied for your Zwecken und zum Privatgebrauch gespeichert und kopiert werden. personal and scholarly purposes. Sie dürfen die Dokumente nicht für öffentliche oder kommerzielle You are not to copy documents for public or commercial Zwecke vervielfältigen, öffentlich ausstellen, öffentlich zugänglich purposes, to exhibit the documents publicly, to make them machen, vertreiben oder anderweitig nutzen. publicly available on the internet, or to distribute or otherwise use the documents in public. Sofern die Verfasser die Dokumente unter Open-Content-Lizenzen (insbesondere CC-Lizenzen) zur Verfügung gestellt haben sollten, If the documents have been made available under an Open gelten abweichend von diesen Nutzungsbedingungen die in der dort Content Licence (especially Creative Commons Licences), you genannten Lizenz gewährten Nutzungsrechte. may exercise further usage rights as specified in the indicated licence. www.econstor.eu Panel 1 Panel 1 retirement and pensions rather than what we have in Keynote Address by the Nordic countries. Looking at the results, I would argue that the Nordic model has been successful, ANDERS BORG when it comes to combining high employment, Minister for Finance, Kingdom of Sweden favourable growth and good social cohesion: the Nordic countries have rather low poverty rates and a low degree of income inequality. Ladies and Gentlemen, There are three reasons for the success of the Nordic I am a little more optimistic about Europe’s future countries in achieving a high labour participation than Professor Hans-Werner Sinn. To be sure, Sweden ratio combined with a low unemployment rate, while used to have the highest government share of GDP in in the Mediterranean countries the opposite is true. Europe. As mentioned in the previous contribution, The first is that the Nordics have a strong growth cul- Denmark scores now higher, with 56 percent of GDP, ture: they are open to trade, technology and change. followed by France (55 percent), Belgium, Finland But they include a strong belief in rational engineer- and Sweden (all at 53 percent). In addition Sweden ing, not only with respect to manufacturing compa- has a balanced budget. According to the latest fore- nies but also to social engineering of their welfare cast, the country will have this year a budget surplus states. They are also societies that are based on a high of, at least, 1 to 2 percent. The reason I am more opti- degree of trust: if someone enters a business deal, it is mistic is that the European social model – the social believed that they will adhere to what they say. If peo- market economy – is efficient and can adapt to the ple are required to pay taxes, they will pay taxes. And challenges of the future. I argue that if we introduce they assume that the people who collect the tax rev- more labour market reforms and perform stringent enues will use them in a decent and efficient way. fiscal policy in Europe, there is a good potential for These countries have also been able to achieve a high the entire society to be endowed with economic degree of price stability and low deficits, which is growth, low unemployment and a decent degree of important for a society’s sense of stability. In addi- social cohesion. tion, they also strive to uphold employment through demand policy. This is the reason why safeguarding low deficits and debt levels has always been crucial in Why is the Nordic model superior? these countries. Furthermore, their labour markets are also quite flexible, with strong but responsible There are many different social models – not just one unions, where wage increases are matched to produc- European one. The Nordic model is based on a well- tivity. And there is also a strong employment record. I functioning labour market with a high degree of would argue that there are some general lessons to be unionization, but also very strong work ethics. This learned from the Nordics that could be applied to all model is equipped with fairly high taxes accompanied countries. by efficient tax systems. The Continental model is similar with respect to work ethics and also to fairly strong unions, but has a stronger corporate system. Reasons for Swedish success Thirdly, there is the Anglo-Saxon model, with a low level of tax but also a means-tested welfare system. Why has Sweden been successful? My point is not that Nevertheless, it has a very flexible labour market and we have to abandon the social market economy in weak unions. Finally the Mediterranean countries Europe. I emphasize that with limited adjustments we have a system with rather strong employment protec- can make it work much more efficiently. First and tion, a more rigid labour market and also a fairly large foremost is the commitment to sound public finances. welfare state, which is, however, basically focused on Flexibility is required in a crisis to restore the frame- CESifo Forum 3/2011 18 Panel 1 work for fiscal policy. The Swedish debt amounted labour market policy measures. But the Swedish sys- 46 percent of GDP when I became the Minister of tem comprises a lot of tax-based incentives. If a com- Finance in 2006, and is expected to reach 36 percent pany hires someone who has been unemployed for this year. Such a significant reduction is not only due over a year, it receives a double deduction in social to good policies in the short term, but also to policies insurance contributions: they are waived for the new in the past instituted by the previous Social employee, and the government subsidizes an addition- Democratic government. There has been a dramatic al contribution for as long as the individual has been change in the fiscal policy framework within the last unemployed. The social insurance contributions have twenty years: in the early 1990s Sweden had, along also been cut in half for individuals. For household with Greece, the weakest budget situation in Europe. services and repairs, the tax wedge has been reduced significantly, because in those areas a wedge is partic- A particular aspect of the welfare state is that there is ularly costly in a high-tax society such as ours. These a strong incentive for people to leave the labour mar- are not huge shifts at all. But Sweden has shifted the ket, since a decent income is guaranteed even if they balance towards dynamism and stronger incentives for are unemployed. That means that the driving forces to the employable to join the labour market. This can re-enter the labour market are weaker. This is partic- obviously be done in any country. ularly dangerous for low-income workers: in general they do not have a promising wage career, do not love Let me point out that we used to have much higher their job and so on. For them it is extremely impor- taxes in Sweden, as shown in Figure 1. If we go back tant to have strong economic incentives. That is why ten years, the tax rate was almost 40 percent. The red Sweden has introduced an earned-income tax credit. line is the tax rate when I became Minister of Finance This system is based on earned income with the pur- in 2006, and the blue line is the current rate. The coun- pose of reducing the wedge between being on welfare try has cut taxes substantially at the lower end in benefits and working. order to provide stronger incentives to join the labour market. With a good welfare system there is a huge Sweden has also implemented a substantial amount threshold effect. If a poor person joins the labour of pro-growth reforms. Ownership, as we all know, is market, welfare benefits, as well as unemployment important for entrepreneurship. The wealth tax has and housing benefits, are reduced. Thus, for rather been scrapped and the previous Social Democratic large groups of individuals there is very little return if government also eliminated the inheritance tax. In they decide to work. By reducing the taxes at the addition, Sweden reduced the corporate tax rate, cut lower end such a system lowers the threshold effect, social insurance fees, and deregulated large sectors of with very strong employment effects. According to the the economy. According to the latest employment calculations of the Swedish National Institute of forecasts, the country expects 3-percent employment Research, the impact would be equal to a 10-percent growth in the next few years. A large part of that is increase in income for a female employee working now coming from the social ser- vices provided by the private sec- tor, such as private schools and Figure 1 REDUCED MARGINAL AND AVERAGE TAX RATES IN SWEDEN private health care. Moreover, 60% education is a cornerstone of the reform: it is essential to encour- 50% age students to move into the MTR w/o EITC + threshold more sophisticated subjects as 40% well as to improve the training of teachers and to raise their salary. 30% Better students and better teach- 20% ers in maths and in the natural rate tax Marginal MTR w.
Recommended publications
  • International Press Conference with Minister for Finance Anders Borg
    2010 Press release 03 September 2010 Ministry of Finance International press conference with Minister for Finance Anders Borg Due to great demand from the international media, Anders Borg invites foreign journalists to a press conference on the Swedish economy, the financial troubles in Europe and his view of the Swedish election campaign, to be held on 8 September. The press conference will be held in English. Mr Borg will be available afterwards for brief interviews. The press conference will be held in English. Please note that accreditation is required - apply to [email protected] before 17.00 on Monday 6 September. Please bring your press credentials. We look forward to seeing you. Time and place 14.00 on 8 September 2010 International Press Centre, Fredsgatan 6, Stockholm. Contact Anna Charlotta Johansson Press Secretary +46 8 405 10 00 Markus Sjöqvist Press Secretary to Anders Borg +46 8 405 10 00 Press release 23 July 2010 Ministry of Finance European stress test shows good results for Swedish banks The Committee of European Banking Supervisors (CEBS) has in cooperation with the national supervisory authorities conducted a stress test on European banks, among these four Swedish banks. The results confirm previous Swedish stress tests. The Ministry of Finance acknowledges the outcome of the EU-wide stress test and supports this joint effort. "It is pleasing that we have been able to convey the traditional Swedish policy of openness and transparency. The publication of the stress test results, also for individual banks, is very important in order to restore confidence in the European banking system," says Minister for Finance Anders Borg.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Bases of Austerity
    SPERI Paper No.9 The Social Bases of Austerity. European tunnel vision & the curious case of the missing left. Stephanie Mudge About the author Stephanie Mudge Stephanie Mudge is Research Fellow at SPERI and an Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of California Davis. Her research centres on the historical study of culture, democratic politics, economic policy, and the constitution of political authority. Stephanie completed her PhD at the University of California, Berkeley and was a post-doctoral fellow at the European University Institute (Max Weber Programme) and the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies (MPIfG). Her work has been published in the American Journal of Sociology, Annual Review of Sociology, Social Science History and the Socio-Economic Review. This paper draws in part from a book manuscript titled Neoliberal Politics, which offers an account of the causes and longer-term effects of the third way era in centre-left politics in Western democracies. An earlier version was presented on June 20, 2013 at the Society for the Advancement of Socio-economics’ (SASE) mini-conference on “Economic Culture in the Public Sphere” in Milan, organised by Lyn Spillman and Fred Wherry. ISSN 2052-000X Published in February 2014 SPERI Paper No.9 – The Social Bases of Austerity 1 Before the election of 1932 … there was a majority in the Riksdag consisting of conservatives, liberals, and members of the farmer party, convinced that the budget should be balanced according to the traditional method and that for this reason the plans of the labor party for large public works, financed by borrowing, should be defeated.
    [Show full text]
  • Fredrik Reinfeldt
    2014 Press release 03 June 2014 Prime Minister's Office REMINDER: German Chancellor Angela Merkel, British Prime Minister David Cameron and Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte to Harpsund On Monday and Tuesday 9-10 June, Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt will host a high-level meeting with German Chancellor Angela Merkel, British Prime Minister David Cameron and Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte at Harpsund. The European Union needs to improve job creation and growth now that the EU is gradually recovering from the economic crisis. At the same time, the EU is facing institutional changes with a new European Parliament and a new European Commission taking office in the autumn. Sweden, Germany, the UK and the Netherlands are all reform and growth-oriented countries. As far as Sweden is concerned, it will be important to emphasise structural reforms to boost EU competitiveness, strengthen the Single Market, increase trade relations and promote free movement. These issues will be at the centre of the discussions at Harpsund. Germany, the UK and the Netherlands, like Sweden, are on the World Economic Forum's list of the world's ten most competitive countries. It is natural, therefore, for these countries to come together to compare experiences and discuss EU reform. Programme points: Monday 9 June 18.30 Chancellor Merkel, PM Cameron and PM Rutte arrive at Harpsund; outdoor photo opportunity/door step. Tuesday 10 June 10.30 Joint concluding press conference. Possible further photo opportunities will be announced later. Accreditation is required through the MFA International Press Centre. Applications close on 4 June at 18.00.
    [Show full text]
  • Snabbprotokoll 2013/14:134, Torsdagen Den 14 Augusti-Kl. 13.00
    Riksdagens protokoll 2013/14:134 Torsdagen den 14 augusti Protokoll Kl. 13.00 – 13.01 2013/14:134 1 § Justering av protokoll Protokollen för den 23, 24, 25, 26 och 27 juni justerades. 2 § Anmälan om uppteckningar vid EU-nämndens sammanträden Talmannen anmälde att uppteckningar från följande EU-nämnds- sammanträden hade kommit in: fredagen den 13 juni onsdagen den 18 juni onsdagen den 25 juni kl. 13.00 onsdagen den 25 juni kl. 14.00 fredagen den 27 juni fredagen den 4 juli 3 § Anmälan om faktapromemorior Talmannen anmälde att följande faktapromemorior om förslag från Europeiska kommissionen hade kommit in och överlämnats till utskott: 2013/14:FPM99 Förslag till EU:s årsbudget för 2015 KOM(2014) 300 till finansutskottet 2013/14:FPM100 Förordning om gemenskapsstatistik över betalningsba- lansen KOM(2014) 379 till finansutskottet 2013/14:FPM101 Forskning och innovation som källor till förnyad till- växt KOM(2014) 339 till utbildningsutskottet 2013/14:FPM102 Meddelande om en cirkulär ekonomi (kretsloppssam- hälle) KOM(2014) 398 till miljö- och jordbruksutskottet 4 § Anmälan om granskningsrapport Talmannen anmälde att följande granskningsrapport hade kommit in från Riksrevisionen: RiR 2014:16 Swedfund International AB – Är finansieringen av bolaget effektiv för staten? 1 Prot. 2013/14:134 5 § Anmälan och omedelbar hänvisning av ärenden till utskott 14 augusti Följande dokument anmäldes: EU-dokument KOM(2014) 367 Förslag till Europaparlamentets och rådets beslut om inrättandet av ett program för interoperabilitetslösningar för europe- iska offentliga
    [Show full text]
  • How Sweden Is Governed Content
    How Sweden is governed Content The Government and the Government Offices 3 The Prime Minister and the other ministers 3 The Swedish Government at work 4 The Government Offices at work 4 Activities of the Government Offices 5 Government agencies 7 The budget process 8 The legislative process 8 The Swedish social model 10 A democratic system with free elections 10 The Swedish administrative model – three levels 10 The Swedish Constitution 11 Human rights 12 Gender equality 12 Public access 13 Ombudsmen 13 Scrutiny of the State 14 Sweden in the world 15 Sweden and the EU 15 Sweden and the United Nations 15 Nordic cooperation 16 Facts about Sweden 17 Contact 17 2 HOW SWEDEN IS GOVERNED How Sweden is governed The Government and the Government Offices The Prime Minister and the other ministers Sweden is governed by a centre-right minority government elected in 2010 and composed of representatives of four parties: the Moderate Party, the Centre Party, the Swedish Christian Democrats and the Liberal Party. The Government consists of a prime minister and 23 ministers, each with their own portfolio. Fredrik Reinfeldt Prime Minister Lena Adelsohn Liljeroth Minister for Culture and Sports Maria Arnholm Minister for Gender Equality Beatrice Ask Minister for Justice Stefan Attefall Minister for Public Administration and Housing Carl Bildt Minister for Foreign Affairs Tobias Billström Minister for Migration and Asylum Policy Jan Björklund Minister for Education Ewa Björling Minister for Trade Anders Borg Minister for Finance Lena Ek Minister for the
    [Show full text]
  • Mjuka Män Och Hårda Kvinnor
    Mjuka män och hårda kvinnor – en kvalitativ textanalys om hur kön gestaltas när politiker gästar Skavlan Författare: Emelie Hagbard Lisa Jalakas Handledare: Monika Djerf-Pierre Journalistprogrammet VT 2013 Abstract In this study we have explored how gender is constructed when politicians visit the Swedish talk show Skavlan. This has been done by using the qualitative textual analysis ECA (Ethnographic Content Analysis). Our theoretical points of departure are the interaction between politics and media, the structure of the talk show format and gender theories. Our premise has been that gender is a social and cultural construction that can be both reproduced and renegotiated. A central part of our study has been to analyse the balance of power in the conversation and how this balance may change. Our outset has been that everyone takes part in producing the discourse in which they act. To be able to map out how gender and power is renegotiated in Skavlan we have applied four analytical themes on our material: the interviewer’s (Fredrik Skavlan’s) role in the conversation, the politician’s role in the conversations, the themes of the conversation and how gender is explicitly made visible. Gender is made visible in various ways in the interviews. In general the female politicians are distinguished as deviating from the masculine norm in politics. However, we also found that the male politicians often are described and describe themselves with features that have traditionally been considered feminine. The opposite applies for the female politicians. Furthermore, we found that the male politicians spoke more about their private lives, while the female politicians focused on the professional.
    [Show full text]
  • The Election and the State of the Economy
    2010 Speech International Press Centre, Stockholm 08 September 2010 Anders Borg, Minister for Finance The Election and the State of the Economy Minister for Finance Anders Borg met foreign press representatives for a briefing on the Swedish economy. Download Presentation slides (pdf 128 kB) Speech London School of Economics 14 January 2010 Anders Borg, Minister for Finance Getting fiscal consolidation right: lessons from Sweden Introduction It is a pleasure to be here at the London School of Economics this evening, to speak at one of the world's most prestigious and respected academic institutions. The title of this evening's lecture is "Getting fiscal consolidation right: lessons from Sweden." My intention is to contribute to the discussion concerning the fiscal consolidation facing the UK and many other OECD countries, by sharing some lessons from the Swedish experience of dealing successfully with fiscal deficits and mounting debt in the 1990s. I will also highlight some cornerstones that are fundamental in our current economic policy and that have helped us through the financial crisis without ruining public finances. Key elements here include our policies for safeguarding labour force participation, our reforms of benefits systems, and our tax reforms. These reforms have been crucial in dealing with the underlying structural problems in the Swedish economy, which the consolidation of the 1990s did not address. Most importantly, they have allowed us to pursue an expansionary fiscal policy, manage the economic crisis, and maintain order and stability in the economy, all while avoiding large deficits. Sweden was hit by a deep recession in 1990-93, as GDP fell three years in a row, employment declined by 11 percent and unemployment quadrupled to 8 percent.
    [Show full text]
  • Snabbprotokoll 2008/09:119, Fredagen Den 15 Maj-Kl. 09.00
    Riksdagens protokoll 2008/09:119 Fredagen den 15 maj Protokoll Kl. 09.00 – 12.23 2008/09:119 1 § Svar på interpellation 2008/09:411 om undsättningslån Svar på interpellationer Anf. 1 Näringsminister MAUD OLOFSSON (c): Herr talman! Ulla Andersson har frågat mig om jag avser att snabbt ta initiativ till en ändring av regelverket för undsättningslån för att under- lätta för de berörda företagen att kunna ta lånen hos Riksgälden eller hos annan instans. Regeringens politik i den här frågan torde vara väl känd i riksdagen eftersom jag flera gånger har debatterat och svarat på frågor om for- donsindustrins framtid. Utgångspunkten för arbetet är att använda våra resurser och skattebetalarnas pengar på ett ansvarsfullt sätt för att ha möjligheter att utveckla välfärden framöver. När regeringen presenterade fordonspropositionen i vintras var Sve- rige det första landet i EU som tog fram konkreta åtgärder riktade till sektorn. Undsättningslånen är bara en del av paketet. Även forskningsbo- laget Fouriertransform och de statliga garantierna för fordonsindustrins lån i EIB är viktiga för helheten. Undsättningslånen har högt ställda krav, där löptiden på maximalt sex månader kommer från de EG-regler för statsstöd som propositionen byg- ger på. Efter det att regeringen hade presenterat sin proposition lade Eu- ropeiska kommissionen fram temporära bestämmelser för statsstöd. Dessa regler ger utökade möjligheter för stödprogram, och regeringen undersöker därför möjligheterna att förändra det nuvarande systemet. Företagens problem är starkt kopplade till svårigheter att ta upp lån på de öppna marknaderna. Mot bakgrund av detta har regeringen genom- fört en rad åtgärder för att förbättra situationen på bank- och finansmark- naderna – åtgärder som väntas ge positiva effekter för näringslivet i stort och även för fordonsindustrin.
    [Show full text]
  • Event Transcript
    Event Transcript The Continuing Impact of the European Crisis Speaker: Anders Borg, Minister of Finance of Sweden Host: Anders Åslund, Peterson Institute for International Economics Peterson Institute for International Economics, Washington, DC April 18, 2013 Unedited transcript C. Fred Bergsten: Let me welcome all of you on this rainy morning to the Peterson Institute for International Economics. Our new President, Adam Posen, is up testifying to the Joint Economic Commit- tee this morning on the remit of the Federal Reserve—so an important topic—and he asked me to, for a moment, take my old place as chairman of these sessions here at the Institute. I could not be more pleased to do so to introduce our speaker today, Anders Borg, who is both an old friend and close associate, and literally, literally probably the world’s top finance minister. He has been named such in Europe. He’s the dean now of serving finance ministers in the entire OECD [Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development] and that’s not because he’s an old guy, as you can see from his countenance. He’s been a minister of finance in Sweden since 2006. That does mark a rather long tenure for such positions. He’s been the chief architect of the Swedish government’s economic pol- icy, which of course has propelled his country into the most successful response to the crisis and successful navigating of the crisis certainly in Europe and one of the most in the world. So it’s a great pleasure to welcome Anders back to our podium here for the third time.
    [Show full text]
  • Solidarity: for Sale? the Social Dimension of the New European Economic Governance
    Gordon Bajnai, Thomas Fischer, Stephanie Hare, Sarah Hoffmann, Kalypso Nicolaïdis, Vanessa Rossi, Juri Viehoff, Andrew Watt Solidarity: For Sale? The Social Dimension of the New European Economic Governance Europe in Dialogue 2012 | 01 Address | Contact: Bertelsmann Stiftung Carl-Bertelsmann-Straße 256 P.O. Box 103 33311 Gütersloh GERMANY Phone +49 5241 81-0 Fax +49 5241 81-81999 Solidarity: For Sale? Armando Garcia Schmidt Phone +49 5241 81-81543 E-Mail [email protected] 2012 | 01 Joachim Fritz-Vannahme Phone +49 5241 81-81421 E-Mail [email protected] Europe in Dialogue www.bertelsmann-stiftung.org Europe in Dialogue Sustainable Governance Indicators 2011 The Europeans can be proud as they look back on fi fty years of peaceful integration. How successful are OECD countries in achieving Nowadays many people in the world see the European Union as a model of how states sustainable policy outcomes? How effectively do and their citizens can work together in peace and in freedom. However, this achievement governments in these countries steer change, and does not automatically mean that the EU has the ability to deal with the problems of the to what extent do they engage civil society in the future in a rapidly changing world. For this reason the European Union needs to keep process? In answering these questions, the 2011 edition of the Sustainable Governance Indicators developing its unity in diversity in a dynamic way, be it with regard to energy issues, (SGI) aims to foster good governance and sustai- the euro, climate change or new types of confl ict.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Democrats Are Due to Recover Power in the Legislative Elections on 14Th September in Sweden
    POLICY PAPER European issues n°323 The Social Democrats are nd 2 September 2014 due to recover power in the legislative elections on 14th Corinne Deloy September in Sweden. Abstract : 2014 is a major electoral year for the Swedes. Indeed on 25th May last they elected their MEPs, as did all European citizens; on 14th September they will be electing the 349 members of the Riksdag (the Swedish parliament) as well as the local representatives (town councillors and county council- lors). Swedes living abroad are allowed to vote in the general elections. In 2010 one quarter of them were registered on the electoral rolls but only one fifth of them turned out to vote. The change in the electoral law in November 2010 now obliges 46% of the vote, in comparison with 36.1% for the parties in the person nominated to be Prime Minister to win Parliament’s the government coalition. The Social Democratic Party won approval and to form a majority within 2 weeks following the 24.4% of the vote and five seats. The ecologists came second general elections. The law also reduced the threshold that with 15.3% (4 seats) ahead of the Moderate Assembly Party independent candidates have to reach within the constituencies (13.6%, three seats). The populist Democrats (DS) won 9.7% to be elected (from a previous 8% down to 5%). Many analysts (2 seats). Just over half of the Swedes turned out to vote believe that this change will lead to the election of more (51.01%). independent MPs. Feminist Initiative (FI), led by the former chair of the Left Party After 8 years in office, a first in the Scandinavian kingdom for (Vp) (1993-2003) Gudrun Schyman, won 5.3% of the vote a rightwing government, the parties in the coalition (Moderate and one seat.
    [Show full text]
  • The Scandinavian Model
    CENTER ON JAPANESE ECONOMY AND BUSINESS Working Paper Series October 2008, No. 265 A Nordic Mirror: Why Structural Reform Has Proceeded Faster in Scandinavia Than in Japan Richard Katz This paper is posted at DigitalCommons@Columbia. http://digitalcommons.libraries.columbia.edu/japan COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY IN THE CITY OF NEW YORK A Nordic Mirror: Why Structural Reform Has Proceeded Faster in Scandinavia Than in Japan By Richard Katz (February 2008) Abstract: Like Japan, the countries of Scandinavia went through big macroeconomics crises brought on by structural flaws. The difference is that their recoveries came more quickly and have been far more robust. Once again, the Scandinavian economies are treated as models. We argue that three factors shed light on the difference between Japanese and Scandinavian performance: 1) Policies. We focus mainly on the strategy of "flexicurity" that provides society-wide security for workers, in return for which workers grant flexibility to business. Jobs are lost but income is sustained and a new job is found. This reduces pressure to sustain inefficient firms and industries. 2) Institutions. Centralized labor-management bargaining enhances equality, creative destruction, and responsibility. Both labor and management realize that wage hikes must be contained within the level commensurate with productivity growth and international competitiveness. Equality of wages across industries enhances market flexibility. Needed policy shifts are made easier by the fact that Scandinavia has moved from one-party dominance to contested elections. 3) Attitudes. Attitudes are born of long experience with both policies and institutions, and these attitudes, in turn, reinforce those policies and institutions. Trust is the key attitude.
    [Show full text]