This article was downloaded by:[University of Leeds] On: 27 September 2007 Access Details: [subscription number 768509729] Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Cultural Studies Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713684873 INDIE: THE INSTITUTIONAL POLITICS AND AESTHETICS OF A POPULAR MUSIC GENRE David Hesmondhalgh

Online Publication Date: 01 January 1999 To cite this Article: Hesmondhalgh, David (1999) 'INDIE: THE INSTITUTIONAL POLITICS AND AESTHETICS OF A POPULAR MUSIC GENRE', Cultural Studies, 13:1, 34 - 61 To link to this article: DOI: 10.1080/095023899335365 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/095023899335365

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article maybe used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 Abstract P P I Da C Keywords N U O O L T D vi U P L tant become challenge contemporary politics This aesthetics be sequences record panies the are istic should ar fessionalization what tion tive in aesthetic R I ticle ticle IT d d A order order U E  ’ L second not ‘ awed. and positions positions independents article

independent : are are He S L I

T be be T C argues companies entails and and AR necessaril part part U to the of and ; H D understood understood S directly to smondh institutions I question explore is E partnership aesthetics aesthetics

institutional E of S institutional the AN concerned concerned that genre (a (a M a 1

the the and 3 I relinquishing relinquishing ‘ ( y N ; popular popular sell-out ’ 1 U record record to , ‘ , ) but pressures mainstream D two , in Creation Creation which which 1 S partnership? partnership? such such S it 9 not ; in themselves 9

perspectives perspectives T music argues argues / AE 9 I related related , collaboration collaboration oppositional with a and C

’ companies companies only problematic IT 3 politics ) music has l 4

and and – gh G S political-aesthetic political-aesthetic 6 towards and industry U the 1 as its that of ’ questions T E of that that T an One One roots , industry industry complex complex autonomy of In In N H a a British British collaboration collaboration I abandonment abandonment which which O source source these these towards deals deals response R E ; forms forms professionalization professionalization institutional Little Little with in independent NA T E . punk po First I record but ascribe ascribe with with relations relations C of Indian major major p of for practices practices . L ’ S , aesthetic aesthetic Case Case s to consequences consequences which popular what what institutional major major with with alternative alternative

of companies companies , O the arrangements arrangements negative corporations? corporations? are are studies previously record record between , F forces forces major major Ž of of presented in record record

culture rst rst compromise A and professionaliza the aesthetic aesthetic of companie © question lead lead and and record record independen are are of institutiona partnershi Routledge two 1990s companie . held held such such Indie Indie may aestheti ‘ , analyse Second alterna and impor ideal com , , . con pro wel s 199 On is th th ha p d e e 9 c a - - s - - - - - s t , l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 form form explicitly with tive explore impo happens though alternatives alternative cultural institutions duction tural political companies the headed isolated theme autonomy means often more (Sha even characteristic and tions pendents the creativity rock vant claimed taken pendent coining egory youth I ably N commercial commercial countercultural countercultural w Given Given independents independents supposedly , or institutions institutions D r had had production , more . of of rigorously its as started started tant tant ‘ I It , 1978) which which alternative alternative of of authentic authentic network E and outgrown is is genius two itself itself pa economy economy preferable record record name name ’ was against to to industries industries claimed) claimed) and , I primarily primarily reconciling remarkable r British British small small for (Hesmondhalgh media media S the tnership tnership ‘ often exploitative adoption

oppositional oppositional outside related related , at A commerce has to by of but from from musicians the ? Ž long-standing which which P organization company) (see more , be be popular record rst towards towards of O In In musicians to su often activism activism the the punk of its independent independent rock P but hero to superior superior r post-punk ’ the the heyday a with with the the questions U the (e. with with communication communication veyed Laing original original commercial commercial . British these these of the lack lack L the in Its Its also ’ A g been been activists companies companies youth case case of form . . the the . of in professionalization R the music The The large large touch touch an an moments moments penetration was was , Creative commercial He is is

of of , cultural companies companies as as M of because 1985 their or or the 1997) term of usually usually to phenomenon entrepreneur entrepreneur of of historical used , r audience audience attention attention U . discourses discourses of examples examples rock rock who highly man man companies companies First cultural cultural corporations by if if S other companies at One One United United took industrial industrial with with I ; , musicians muted C popular popular Hesmondhalgh . record record its to an an with with myth produced , and autonomy G concerned concerned it ‘ and had with with what signi within Little Little the mystify best genres E abbreviation the went was was I trajectory trajectory among N production nature paid paid N of of States soul , no . of of R previously previously idea D McChesne Indie . Ž , , forces forces efforts efforts concern concern shop culture which which rapid E , organization alternatives alternatives who who fans based cant Such Such and I ties ties and Indian ’ Creation Creation far E than because because to which not in ar popular popular and : of students

, of , and : from is beyond this A with with to lie lie tistic the owners had had howeve musicians towards towards independence independence no turnover companies companies only ,

made made to on often of , were consumed consumed , pop P ve 1997) behind behind , as as favoured de of such such elsewhere in music 1960s O network network transform transform indie indie y in no r the the they new Ž , production commercial it tically ‘ P and and because because ned independent culture cultural cultural with in in the , and U subsumed 1997 that were background background behind behind signi r the partnership provision , . saw collaboration collaboration L the the academic academic as as emerged emerged Post-punk were relationships genre One One and themselves themselves A and of of 1990s (lower) of of a major by Ž were integrated R . the move move : it of of cant cant . independents case case styles My My .

journalists journalists it the the the the 189 M 1970s (which (which it the and The The less less Little Little studies studies I I alte had . was was goal goal U , by of of focus focus concern For under often ‘ of of nature nature study restraint restraint has / – challenges S major major ’ small small corporation from from politicized politicized bureaucrati middle-clas work r such such collaboratio 205) mid-1980s in I and (as (as strongly strongly ever companies making native small-scal more C saw indie Indian of consider was the the

corpora took , betwee G and and in on the the of of alterna in . a media artisti sound recor durin befor of on E ‘ hard inde here inde pun wha wha Suc rele N pro fact pro cul tw as cat is , an th th th th R to to it k o d n h e E e n e e e e g d c c a a ------s - - t s t , ’ - s ’ , , 3 5 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 3 6 pop set One links its out other of vides positions preneurial part two tained independents mitments assumes the more suggest particularly national ethics C post-punk of as work itions a comes  fact see the whereby almost culture interested attempts ship/collaboration? and apparent awed much much U this aestheticist punk , well-publicized L , margins / most most gains of indie indie The The this of of companies T I Little rock rock with with at the the companies companies complex complex . , are are U and and want want article for for a aesthetic aesthetic But in , less less that itself itself Creation Creation inevitable R that boom boom corporation second position are inspired maintaining of of belo which to oppo A that for for always sector sector a and canon a in aesthetics aesthetics and and Indian I L , its politicized politicized formal formal the the . involved to achieve achieve controversial sho also independents independents , is complicating complicating Before Before (especially w S Ž I I and it histor r how in nancial nancial . suggest felt than than T outline outline corporate corporate motives motives tunity were were make make r question assumes assumes , ; t U such such Records want the the concerns . as as by was was if if This This and which which period period D Creation Creation links links outcome to political political it in indirectl y a is , I anarchism difference difference discussing popularity popularity an markedly markedly , of of E developed PolyGram guarantee guarantee for for as as held held the to showed means to gain implied implied type this this S the the that type institutional involved in the the Rough its that . is examine examine criticize criticize move assumes assumes an an before before : capital I sale sale : ; 1996 abandon way a by fact fact would of the more in in pa and and in was company company y of interesting interesting discourse discourse institutional of , of of towards r indie terms terms little some some , different different in political political of of in each ty pa in question Trade of very very – . , rather is ‘ aesthetic aesthetic in certain certain , bu in in explaining explaining 97 human human instead In r two an which which would politicized politicized indie indie a describe describe contemporary contemporary that the but signi ticula the the r such such previously previously of of or discourse discourse the the stake stake separation with with n-out of aesthetic aesthetic former basis basis . such institutional institutional legacy legacy discourses and no than than they Creation Creation 1990s Ž institutional the common in positions) case case from from r comparison , professionalization indie cant cant have and and is , institutional interest interest positions diversity T professionalization professionalization a , ’ the the in in of of , ony a a companies companies this at company company late by began began which which these these associates associates . of this wing) , reverence reverence of Ž the each each for for 1990s 1990s position been been (though the as nancial nancial held the the from from r aesthetic aesthetic Blair Creation , the the Records within within a which which popular popular with company company second my and in heart heart socialist socialist and othe genre from from processes is is and have scorned scorned political political which which ’ most , alterity alterity political political via corporations s slightly slightly built built , because because account aesthetic aesthetic Labour Labour in which which resources resources and of of the which which r stimulation pa . traceable traceable have some some , position , of for , political political turn turn One One question grew grew course One One by politically r it culture sees sees very tnership tnership Dutch-based Dutch-based and politics politics much much and and to political political by took and and : can can a a contrast engagement is more more been been , ‘ is Little Little in politics Pa both both sections sections sell-out Son the the corporate Little Little ce characteristic characteristic out as aesthetics aesthetics partnership partnership much much , to r aesthetic aesthetic only only the run run as , . r aesthetic aesthetic the the ty aesthetic aesthetic and and debate debate will will . tain or y is anarchists anarchists prevalent prevalent Again prevalent prevalent generous generous of be classicist . came came As with Indian Indian – , active active main , somewha I I a a Indian positions dr fo what

punk be be around around through and and aestheti ’ found place place want want we , becom ‘ of of r partner y classic m . , multi entre whic , main 1 abou to com as as indi bod I I unti losse suc shal pro pos out rol The of of an and . ar am on be an to to of In in in at at d h h y e e e e c a a ------t , t ’ s l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 3 2 1 four The politics were its activism their aged An today punk a on beyond Independent Bloom whereas cultural These bution popular-cultural commercial ing scended point standing This of was musical cheap do centur recording concentration otherwise musicians the They successes successes categories categories pragmatic pragmatic these an an campaigns campaigns so aesthetic aesthetic musicians the that institutional the . . , able able set own project awareness awareness post-punk y Ž technolog The The were was was . of Britain Britain eld instruments spontaneous opportunities romantic romantic rock rock unskilled in Many those production of The The up across industr punk of of to , been been the the certain certain hands commitment commitment the (see desire desire 1991) secto able able an based based the build discourse discourse eventually eventually signed networks networks around post-punk post-punk who who most people and and dynamics were alternative alternative y also also possible the post-punk . of medium independents y intervention intervention , to r and notions . , , to By By quarters in on post-punk into and the the were , some some oligopolization undertake undertake effective effective countr to was was Hesmondhalgh art art can complex complex expand , . the untrained punk extension mobilization who had had new new their their of Europe Europe . burnt burnt of of of of , only drawn to of the form of of of the the This independent . y network ’ independents tended s independents may , the independent Not Not conditions production production musical musical battle the labels audiences audiences route to anti-nationalism be be cultural was was issue institutions and proclaimed proclaimed paid out signi and and of , record record to reach reach to not post-punk only partly partly there , achieved contradictor take , to reduced reduced I punk towards and but , N which which the the of of creative these these Ž of of creativit against otherwise otherwise 1997) mystify cantly D was was a industries industries distribution distribution the through through I how industry facing facing credited credited ownership ownership also also United United much much access access E was was argued and and in production : with with Rock Rock with with international

that means means . had had A through the the democratization democratization studio companies a counteracted counteracted y music work and also also

. , string string wider wider P the the the distribution distribution was y Rather Rather at but States have 1980s a a a O , exports for for Against been been than for / in but political political corrupting corrupting P of the or or . music music an the the of costs music developed U general The The socialists which which the came came this musical a of public had ignore women L . heart heart had production and emphasis more can than than A characteristic characteristic Again other other recognized recognized coming coming . active . networks networks Racism Racism R arrival arrival industr and Although Although the A existed existed

be distribution to edge enabled enabled , M the naively signi industry industry of than this re were for for production , of of opportunity opportunity U took companies companies summarized summarized and . and less this this its  the appropriatio S This This exive . the processes much much of process process Ž y on able able I would The The , cant C audiences and up was was of politics anarchist predator expensiv new as as extende still still relativel the the contrast

industr that not politica G encour to well well under to indie indie of of E sexua distri- facto of base post tran role an exis N hav onl bas int (se in tha an th th R to of of in as d y d o d d n e y E e e y e y e e a r - - - - - s s t . t , l l 3 7 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 3 8 their their the most ope terms bands were dition sis funk underground sources turned in looks by pop ing music C action action tive ethos New charts methods independent promotion between during culture. only popular professional perceived sented display videos U the the on L ’ and in , / pop widely s But Media Media Indie Musical Musical T , Ž taken rock . be be prominent pictures work in . on music gures in U of The in mid-1980s clever clever were umbrella as in an to the of And suppressed of R music the by , . mainstream Britain Britain maintained presentation at the the rock rock This on A opposition musical musical pop in stress inspiration ‘ faced faced , whiteness 1986 as as for for used post-punk outlets outlets L any and UK beginning and the the Expres Britain success success and and the the

whole independent and sector S rock rock , a on gap and the and then T , time synergies synergies whole stage stage term was in , rhythms one problems examples) to put / . the U post-punk 2 record record s prowess or was was label label black black dominant D , references . themes pop While for ( , describe describe , : under Rather Rather NME (Reynolds resisted I it ’ commercial which which in hand indie , to ‘ sensitive in impo presentation E it , of of post-punk to era era indie manifested manifested at S , has has indie the the 4AD 4AD what what seems , the musical and and make ), the sleeves with with but , , many of secto was was r threat and a a of early early last seemed seemed ’ one one but than and tant often genre genre s set set (and stabilizing stabilizing forms forms a time minimal minimal alternative alternative and . Simon indie status were popularity popularity , , lyrics lyrics visual visual new less less contradictory The The sounds decade set r a a 1988) of . ’ indie itself itself by , musicians the . traditions 1980s , organization the the : deliberate deliberate At There There prided the such such ‘ in was was of ‘ indie the and itself itself records [In [In of mainstream mainstream as struggling struggling as erecting phase mé Reynolds the the the the inherited inherited mass mass bands bands work exceptions exceptions . bands . culture culture the ’ focus the determinedly determinedly far far the , music less lange lange as as pop As ’ (Kell indie same same fact against was pop described described itself itself which which most , subject New New removed media , in last with with of impression turned turned involved fans such such , mainstream mainstream muting : on that y / of such such the exclusionary exclusionary a a was , press Peter its on time rock on twelve of called called from 1987) too resistance resistance experimental experimental prestigious Order Order rhythm so the and pop , counter-hegemonic counter-hegemonic as the the the tended 4 had recording cultural cultural its of constructing constructing : as as , and . to many a electro electro bastions Saville the from from concentration concentration much much There There although of journalists journalists dressing care the records records narrower bod ‘ . charts charts ‘ the against against months] months] health health been been jangly on on charisma and term term oriented oriented track y to singer Smiths over oppositional , the the the politics to music for for and , branch branch was was barriers and be Depeche Depeche gradually gradually ’ were of of and and ‘ in using guitars down in these othe . indie pop centre centre many Factory design 3 the the set / a on the  hip the had had a , . songwriter songwriter Dance Dance canon canon press uences expressed expressed ef refused refused All All towards widening dominated r charts of of indie most aspirations of ’ Ž on , , independen independen hop promotiona was was commercia increasingl a a ciency , a a around local local sounds of of aims alternativ alternativ this (23 an Mode) post-pun ‘ minimu commen emergin genres genres image being of of , rhythm covere the alterna popula becom . empha as Envel white As repre to coul vide ’ radi fres : ne po gul tra an . pu ’ th th th th by to m In in in w d d o p o d k h g y e e e e e e r - - - - s - - t t t t , f l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 noise others provided For and early explosion marketing distance time on tutional labelled had British Maconie Rough early house ‘ features music can dent its Order 1988 that scene able history of panies Radio dif stations baggy , Ž the the course cult labels labels bands bands the Creation Y Although , aesthetic aesthetic to the rock – 1990s et 1990s howeve in was was media media , One One club club 92 ’ NME and and and pop T , provide though ( foundations post-punk still ‘ by , rade BPI the of for and . from from independent Britpop / . 1992) an that emerged emerged such such , Few felt felt and pop More More ’ the no culture music 1995 dance where where to Statistical had late bankruptcies bankruptcies itself post-punk interest interest , which which opportunity opportunity r were One One , seemed roots the longer , were form form major to like manufacture were much much as it impressive . star their their 1980s , ’ and was was in encode encode Husker had a a music post-punk in , , . vanguard it from from was in such There There version version Little in bands fostered fostered in the turning turning much much in did the provided more own the had Handbook Handbook capital capital only fallen fallen different different , networks post-punk the the the the independents independents shape associated , with with as music companies companies authentic of audiences Du changed the the to specialist specialist was was sector sector emerged emerged support to closer closer Indian Indian post-punk The people retreat , of of two to (much (much below distribution distribution internationally internationally by experiment experiment by con and and of of rock rock anger anger much indie a a dance dance 199 ways and Happy the key widespread widespread bands were forming forming : Ž when ties the . many rm rm with with of who music for for 3 100,000 (in Post-punk of of indie were 1980s news post-punk which which , to and and had : coverage of indie music examples examples with Pixies 46). notions to it rock rock I hit , the such such Mondays a N inherit inherit the in indie had of based based come come subgenre subgenre gain D sho of network fallin alternative alternative with with the media 1989 badly badly independent independent star star as the had I the . dispossessed and working-class working-class as E tradition been been as w sense sense for for There There a : bands bands of of , exposure

independence independence Blu g institutions professionalization professionalization corporations around genre well well key names su the A to / , it . the of 5 sounds the the a a a a or and by in

r was was previously r , P ‘ And number number occupy vived such such , that crisis which which bands bands mantle mantle the the O was was form form 1995 Oasis Oasis which which as as the Ž . The The into P networks becoming becoming rst rst which which , This Rough nationall U the harder harder Cartel companies in from from ’ networks a a the economic economic for for L – and in time Stone were of a a and revival youth , was A the 96 1987 of had punk Factory of market market . the neo-indie R bankruptcies bankruptcies 6 their their drawn sustained , the the British British had independent disempowered

, One One Pulp Trade) centre centre the sounds also also M brie in discovered was was y , on indie ; of Roses) more . U legacy legacy the its pop . of maintained maintained its The The , . Smiths sounds S anarchists In ,  distribution Little Little had Records Records recession niche niche or increasingl fast to all all y general general I bands bands thirty-yea , circulatio C world the ground ground of son known and punk ‘ had had triumph indepen the the . of Britpop , its G had of But Ameri furiou , . mean mean E India g whic of mor fuse com . post indi bee insti- Ne N BB th (se an an ru ha Fo . th th R it of of as w C A e n d n n d d d n h e y e E e e e r r - s - - - s - t ’ , , 3 9 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 0 cal cal as sexual Listeners ically basic was own was rented so strongly of chanted football 69 what columnist propagated descended Clash series C anarcho-punk anarcho-punk to its Trade sent band contacted girls sent itself could teenage Charles out Crass respect the G. US) U , something a via facilitate facilitate work. (on Crass music L of of , situationist-style . an Crass Crass Crass group group released released out related related T Crass Crass ‘ Crass Crass and Jon , had The The unadventurous send Creative extended independent of bands bands U the oppression the farmhouse farmhouse , almost almost the R romance romance features features and choruses the anarchist anarchist political political groups groups , ’ terrace , 8 Savage pulled pulled A single single compared compared tabloid Crass Crass however was was attention of core was was Nevertheless off off and into Label Label semi-independent chose chose L by to band band its and and Lady

of on the S for permanent permanent was was Sounds formed formed the Recording Recording label more more T punk early early outright a a its claimed claimed collective (1991 such such itself itself a a staff the . U magazine magazine in aesthetic authoritarian-populist records a a vehicle vehicle newspapers newspapers to was was in material material and booklet booklet But Diana Diana ‘ Penis D special special activities (such (such production untainted 1979 . Epping was was called called work I with with W ; actions bands bands a a E recordings explicitly Marching journalist was was and working the : a althamstow althamstow in S cruel cruel 583) , Envy small small the the racism racism directed directed Spencer Spencer as . for for the the and 1978 , , the presence danger danger And single detailing detailing a across Between with with Crass as as was was called called , of the who . parody mantle mantle to beyond album album the calls ’ trick trick At At band band the the experimentalism experimentalism Chrysalis Chrysalis group group events to by , working-class and the in Special Special folk particularly particularly Garry Garry drums drums the the and and and and : , the to signed politics draw above a of entrepreneurialism Loving the a a achieved there there in to on north-east north-east relied relied commemorate commemorate range range / distribution in shop long the out of singles of ecological ecological 1978 time of fascism fascism actively actively protest recording recording was 1981 in the ‘ young the social social ‘ romantic romantic attention Bushell Bushell Se and anarchist true crimes crimes Records) Records) the story story to at . Sun a a was was tradition label label centred centred r Unlike angry angry of on UK UK of deal deal , and the vices major major it considerable considerable distorted distorted ’ for for late late strikin realist realist techniques movement the the newspaper) in readers readers punk an an no dispatched dispatched political political indicates of of independent unit time 1983 Small Small (who of whereby whereby disaste . of ’ and the instance ‘ lyrics 1970s conceptions London to Royal bands pure for outside earlier earlier companies organized organized reached reached around many y of of the g from . , cadre the form form . 7 playing (when (when the later later – The The anarchist anarchist . W expressed guitar guitar , , r event

. , , John than than wedding especially especially and outrage outrage original original . which onde , The The feminism feminism centred centred of forms forms post-punk readers readers ’ . . the purposes purposes ’ to Cover success of Crass Crass The The 1979 a cultural cultural of Other Other became became the the cha early the the collective collective . live religion religion it . Laude most most carried the Sex music r punk Crass of , Some band disbanded) pop early early were r of of but anti-clericalism) (mainly) album album that art arranged arranged ts love moment moment gigs on Oi! of of between Pistols with in 1980s descendants descendants as . directly , was was of of r , of of , the entrepreneu , Its Its charts charts , the ’ such acts it the s which which then of 1960s the . the soccer-styl an designed often often (and a a movement to Ž the the the formed formed Crass Crass music a a based based compute rst central central these these televisio Stations Stations magazin , anarchis , activitie series series carryin materia and rhythm , as aesthet teenag and and , , action Roug recor serve Princ with wher with politi in calle in abou Cras Sha the Th act wa at thi th di by it to m of of of n n d d d d h g e e e e e e e a a a r r s s s - - s s s , t , . t . l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 were national distribution who from the Sugarcubes the ties played Indians progeny instance amateur this tors Distribution network in up distribute pendent copies tinued chists T who London little shop Christi. and ing was been though there College house enginee rade rade by association , Dirt bass , V In In T Distribution is a a had had / many was was had , with ery ery connection connection oda his sympathetic sympathetic amateurs amateurs Jello Jello (inte record , tended practising practising with with only in the success its according according . not r in , licensing player with with , distribution of of y Rough father their their was was lived set unusual the the Things Things W , last last had had another over early early 1985 r Biafra Biafra Crass Crass , this although Crass vie one one Lauder Lauder ood one when when , One One of Omega being being company now to members members gig and w ; records records built at with a a with with anarchist anarchist who who days Trade Tim Tim , be based based practices practices example example (and scientologist Green hundred , , of of and acts the with 23 Little in to of in and it high key to formed formed called called more formed the the engineerin Flux that started started 1984 the August his of from from were Kell the Crass Crass Lauder Lauder British British Tribe anarchism Kukl ended ’ preceded preceded who who s anarchist anarchist the directly directly , sales sales issued issued One One US Rough Indian politics of of band own he he North North interested interested y SR of early heritage heritage labels labels , of and Southern Southern , Rough in learning learning by W Crass . had then commune commune and worked 1994) up;and Pink D an (Crass Little Little up an ’ est no manager . s recording recording , the ’ members members on s started g Trade But But P worked is , on Crass Crass Icelandic Icelandic . were , on contracted contracted most by institution label London enny also also , Coast most longer longer This This Indians but but one . the and Trade early early is Indian ’ a s By a a One One another Lauren in their in Studios 1979 One One political political , of string string more more (see (see his Rimbaud) successful successful of of popular popular records Crass Crass for for was was to Alternative Alternative 1981 notabl they they both both anarcho-punk anarcho-punk I at Bill Bill Flux N . , of of 1980s studio the set-up has , Little wind own band band CBS CBS who D Little Little trade trade His His a a the the album album Hesmondhalgh the the Bromle the socialist formed formed , to I . arranged while of of places small small Gilliam E UK label on y They a a of , alliance principal principal : it wife wife Records music beliefs Ž anarchist-inspired anarchist-inspired , beginning beginning , was down stake Con Indian which which anarcho-punk anarcho-punk Pink around A , the as nanced Indian Indian ’ for for which which early Southern s Stations Stations Lauder , ,

, label leading leading T P quickly quickly and and y they , and and  basis basis musicians , entacles Sue through distribution . from O and ict) ict) who Indians history in . band , its to were were P act An was . Lauder Lauder including who who itself , staff staff was U the on All Crass went the label label record record attended attended Spiderleg) of according recorded recorded was was of . L , of of was an , , independent gained gained alternative A , the later later 1997) the its The The company in , mainly mainly , on apart apart ; were worked compan than a a R which which the explicitly able able which which . Mark Mark (and alon band and Cras in long long the the himself himself offshoot Crass Crass M The The the Dead Dead their their and to charge charge Annie Annie U the key the Derek Derek bands bands from from to s g but staff staff W at at garage garage . to other) S . sold other other Edmondson religious become become relationship Flux had was was y at best-know set export althamsto After After Their Their I label Crass Crass with with , the the , contract Ž C Kennedys Tim post-pun Crass Crass may rst rst , Souther Souther Bromle at anarchis political

distribu Anxiet 250,00 up of been (includ G Birkett a a Corpu of studio side side Roug ’ E activi a direc s singl of Kell inter Cras inde anar stor . N Pin con hav loa : Th Bu ha R se hi he to of w y y y n n n n 0 d k h k e e E y e s - s ------s , , , , s , , , t t t , t 4 1 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 2 love majors the by working In concerts tinuum this tunities 1997). cultural indicates C their their chists sumption status combining examining out the be breakdown extension lost in on by Of U independent any so new independent very course L record record of pressure constant hope hope The The Such Such of of T colleagues colleagues , invasive anything whole you is we arcubes ringing Y you stayed U the the , overworked with with ou music for for getting between and or R good institutions together together music some some have in , , ’ , pressures pressures that d A , industry get they proved why industry even people people political political a a some of L order order have a unexpected unexpected . bloody on professional professional

, , you threat In S distinctions and terms job the the it nor can can so of of ’ in , fucking fucking T re re so industry cultural cultural chose chose to both might and record record to leisure U aspects aspects the common common up involving lead are are to many unpleasurable not many too , you by of of D ‘ altogethe drive straight disgruntled disgruntled deal deal often caboodle beliefs beliefs ventured with of I stay at founded problems problems major major E similar similar politics) often often coming to singer singer much be be do S home out bankruptcy bankruptcy time independent production companies hangers-on with roles is of of many evade training aware express express between Birkett) possible this? ’ directly with with of a friends these these frequent frequent and r , companies companies . , on high-pressure political political . saying and . and from hand further further and and . from from on . Another Another associated independent As Y former former . . of independent our ou them them , . Even remarks remarks . work similar similar which which an they Mark Mark such such They new to , public ’ But But ’ . . opposed commercial commercial d the the and there there can can and emerge emerge front . contact work The The companies companies amateur amateur get into inclinations . those at . employee some some left left developments ’ cultural cultural same same (those . you problem re relationships Edmondson Evenings might a a Y and all sentiments with Australian cove the the are are night ou are just strong with the , business record record put who here to ’ with they of companies companies private area area d professional complaints complaints professionalization professionalization r supposedly additional additional ethos provide horrible horrible , (Inte get industr the factors factors the companies people people us blah before fold : (though is choose choose ; are are at resistance resistance conspicuous don the the on these company and accumulation accumulation that , distinctive r V . all , life informall put vie ogue (see (see but are are often often For and blah ’ the y disillusion t should . assistance assistance . of , the people w gigs of there like to real it But work put Edmondson , burdens there which which many ringing ringing guest , to , motivated world similar also also , 10 negotiating blah continue spent frustration frustration , tour tour musicians the maintain maintain to some some bloody under under you y is not December , and features features . wealth wealth . Hesmondhalgh are are anarcho-punks you list ‘ a could I selling-out which which same same in managers caused caused ’ and of . attending tastes tastes up d stressful stressful be be thought leisure of of The The for for coping few few great great haven wealth get sharks to neither neither ignored saying growth remaine the the contacts and music be be betwee and the that of some work and oppor peopl peopl by 1993 coul strai mad ’ , wor anar t , con wit con Sug ‘ staf ’ tha , an liv thi ca go th th th by by to of in in in as d d d n n n h k e e e e e e e - - - - ) s - . , , t t f Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 Mayking pendent or that For puts one her Bonner with the independent intervention who sold own distribution Indian Indians interview dent But ing Whereas was dents politics and work indie company of with with One is ever 60 stars it, ran One One shops . dence. banker ambivalent Battersea When cutting make W doing Y , In the struggled struggled eah one ’ to single single s per e’ Catalogu ‘ a a by a . the Little involvement the the as idealists ve skint . selling selling , (Gibson Little Little few few One , 1988 pressing According According who who sometimes cent cent one the Birkett editor money operation ‘ got it ’ of than early early corners s decline scene on ’ television was was and . anarcho-punk anarcho-punk Little Indian Indian Bonner e is record single inte Indian Kelly of to to records records Crass Crass independent independent , an an from from considered , of anarcho-punk then ’ things One One was was plant plant sell sell 1988) was sell bought r for A&R A&R . view The Indian of to . . was was . replied , had Brenda Brenda And , throughout sold did anything seen seen a Especially 1992 whom whom Jenny not the we Little Bonner Bonner fora cheaply cheaply Catalogu and and , lot changed changed with with idealist as subsidized subsidized from from not by had we alternative alternative think more more so by musician-centred musician-centred for for of to : video origins to Lewis Indian status Kelly Bonner Bonner Mayking readily Tim Tim escape escape always many to be be records records to represents independent scene scene like the e , , 1994 , a a than when when turn turn or or motivated we and fans this distribution bit , Kell . . same same was editor this to someone someone on ’ He He the Former Former I do . the the ve available had , represented represented N later later 30,000 elsewhere elsewhere scene (intervie , period It a a y this to bands the the , D it in amount Battersea Battersea a got got [Bonner] [Bonner] label label a a vigilant vigilant PR I paid make make good of a moved E journalist journalist contact contact was was as as independent , : as as more more complicated rock rock a a the the

, drive including , Crass Crass from from producer producer as A . spend until told great great much much but better w company Birkett Birkett supported

sleeve . (Quoted (Quoted it the P , indie for for attention At and ‘ O 14 into businessman , is all all a traditional that with with (Intervie that me me that P it members other other Ž attention very Rough six asked by more more U nancin back . pop chance chance June trade managed managed It It complained complained Mayking L that the of releases commerce commerce old ‘ days the the A called called because because scene in costs different different Snub Snub by in . post-punk R if of of like specialist specialist school school 1994) magazine But Trade Gittins w they g

company Ž the One One remarkable remarkable . M ’ in , , some than rst rst to In ’ entrepreneur entrepreneur , a 30 U TV still Maykin an ’ as to on Brian Brian the a s 1980s lot good 1988 S did it Flux Little good April April premises premises a a a (1989– I of , the as ethos develop investmen if had One One C in within in of preceden 1988 better better successfu not indepen indepen indepen

by The we , G throug Bonne . anothe packag of of mone contac g Birket sale sale a . As India E studi 1996) musi 9 Littl mor sales fro trus : Inde- N star Pin 90), The 42) sh th we R it to m in y r – o n h k E e e e e c r - - - - t . , s . t t t t t l 4 3 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 4 anarchist anarchist company albums Derek design solo a of simple the fessionalized behind and with demonstrated centredness ing ‘ buying group player for C musicians musicians corporate the try Indian laboration ation term out capable achieve out Edmondson compromise professional punk fessionalization ‘ with dropped deserved U plastic plastic vulnerability vulnerability ’ : L more for for One to cover In In One One in album the T ’ the ‘ s which with ’ sell-out U s via Birkett and . Mark Mark the monochrome monochrome is , democratization the the orde them those success R for for abandonment abandonment White he company Little Little tear tear entrepreneurial entrepreneurial ideals by ’ employees out A Little Little its and Ž of of widely , was sometimes sometimes Southern Southern company other nance nance late late L . felt felt r but his , many . , activity Paul amateurs amateurs of

licensing licensing Edmondson Such Such ’ Bjork uncomfortable uncomfortable , under ’ S The The through by staff staff though from from and and , masks masks de , Indian T in Bjork Bjork key represents is obliged One One 1980s including Birkett Indian the the U sources Ž used White White and 1987 con for for nitely purism purism ambivalence ambivalence was was ’ D of of who who s ; record record each acts the – I fact fact image image and Ž ’ , not E entry entry Ž the s is Little these corporate corporate , allows deals deals rst rst around of the phrase phrase responsible rmed contact contact S for for move was had One One share an efforts efforts to and following behind that of the idealism idealism launch launch attached attached independents of eye only (intervie One One small-scale small-scale often often legacies legacies experienced experienced turn turn a a Derek Derek label label of the into almost with insiders insiders capital the . Indian , Bjork . with with by dilution the international international Little tastes tastes from It It the Bjork in The The a a Little were with with about about the the Me Me to her her potential potential sees could could of culture culture Ž Sugarcubes the a a activity P anarcho-punk anarcho-punk nance nance for for year the olyGram w of of specialists specialists for , Birkett more title her a are certainly indie company , and and Indian , Compan inspired direct but 1990s began variety variety hands the the decentralization decentralization Crass Crass amateur amateur 10 Ž Indian of success success the slick slick ; , be solo nancial nancial part part and and player Debut political political by are are also also and discourse discourse process earlie subscribed December December ‘ established design range argued bloody ’ , s , stare stare (now forming forming success success held held . – world career career the kept ’ towards of and ’ a a of y

star star album s the the lead lead permit permit distribution who . some : experienced experienced adds factor factor need r recording recording reward White White no , a a capital capital need of scene scene to to of of backgrounds , amateur amateur of at to achievements achievements the network act act singe sharks ingé of in for motivations share which which her many camera , ‘ to of a , to professionalization , arm loyalty which which 1993) behind Debut 1993 a a becoming becoming to the the would protective main was was . parallel nue is example and Ž the which which was space space sources lips r nd , give ’ ’ cleverly s a Bjork activit early corporations corporations I debutante . referred referred ideals . length tease , muscle , the more more access access . discussed past of an by By some some That That owner-manager) owner-manager) and which which Bonner in hold That That them them in . he musicians . industry industry early many then One One , , Sugarcubes A A behind behind the y : its which which commitment commitment an W . chose chose shield . the the that capital 10 ’ represented represented this this felt felt purist purist that A based based of the distance as the of of internationa , music consists musicians The The ’ Little to purist purist . s associate associate presence though of of above? this One One those is The The is they PolyGra interest , to musician such such push such such collabor and by , whereb as a , the her her positio involve on accord core core remai parod recor a a indus India sleev a a . Littl Mar vie ‘ wer fro wit , pro wh pro the sub sell sell Ž of Th Th col sh rs on w to to m of of of m in is n n o d n h k y y y e e e e e e a ------s - - - , t l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 dent its McGee therefore the record ation cant who gossip Like article. vations de-skillin not of concern According encroachment Debut 1990s Nellee Debut sees ment despised margin dif which Ž Bjork Bjork takeover  cult only But This them them – all all agship rock rock are Y ‘ ‘ to for for Records

was was At I and and (e. sees sees . eah! eah! ’ company Hooper) Hooper) sectors sectors s Know behind fostering fostering for and even with The subjected subjected more more g by purist purist image its g the potentially . culture . as widely often often to speculation speculation Creation I company professionalization Y Price by softe many many assess assess in closely ou present this choice choice a , if Someone exciting of of , Sony other other independent ’ smoothe , Alan Alan position 12 d more more and bosses r , . vie as media , acclaimed acclaimed PolyGram better better talent When When the enthusiasts 1993) people people ‘ this to highly w media media tied in for for most most time of to McGee acts acts , such such durable durable development , , about institutional position 1992 of internationalization British British , production it r set set Who often often . believe believe its , to McGee McGee and on The The produced I allowed richer richer the to valuable attention coverage myself institutional celebration celebration up , for for , and professionalization the the , to sustain re 1980s Knows is – has is indie ex-members ex-members as ,

 more more providing its are are and it probably label label main main sound sold ect ect often ‘ Mayking ’ co-optation a am am mass mass , , innovative and ’ the the of corollary corollary : back back the pop attempt attempt and are wider wider sound often often Someone Someone a a a quite quite was was ‘ permanent permanent I the personalities based based controlling label label aesthetic aesthetic N which which constant independent of participation participation / ones of of 1990s D catalogue catalogue rock rock an an label the misguided a into , I suggests course issues simply E and of positive owner-managers ; to alternative on : view view ’ soundscape perhaps can can best best and . , Crass Crass implies A Who 11 the look attributed attributed and and politics a a existence existence about P His His and and positions be be musicians without without genuinely has stake of , of O ’ known work music in . its identity in growth Creation Knows by P were detected detected aesthetic aesthetic label all all The the exaggeratedly exaggeratedly U (The (The a more more classic classic the . enormous enormous the the putting of of are are L way the of (created (created A most , , (Alan lo- this world his peers on of Ž politics howeve R founded closely , and and Pooh eld One Alan Alan post-punk idealistic idealistic at depth . Ž for for

but of company the M The The an is in to processes punk prestigious . the an pop pop . U living McGee careers Many women is a a the the the just Self Self impoverishe Little McGee Sticks S success success British head head by emphasis replete replete related r company at of I , end C in so sound solo increasin critical critical Publicist the as dreams dreams produce indepen

commit which which . of G 1983 labels to , , , of Indian Bjork signi of E whic ’ 1984 1987 in moti whil thos smal wor . sinc , Son N Cre wit Th wa an thi th R , on . Ž of in is is ’ d d h h k e e E y e e e g r s - - - - ) ) s - ? s . l 4 5 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 6 mid-1980s noisseurship and lineage 1995 George tion particularly named sisting late on such label, alization develop porate abandonment polic Factory symbol in C in the attempt out. (based ments competing plicated true standing he alternative young nically bohemia alternative generally to post-punk U  a 1992 is the ected ected L late late , 14 the the Will Will In 1950s much much that T y : certainly certainly aesthetics in . the the U And 85) around of label label men men of But insular rock after after fact of particular particular of Jam Harrison , 1980s in R a a to ’ mix mix in there there alternative work . Straw My this recognized A classical four four new classic classic . , Straw culture culture 1991 the stronger , music fuse fuse discourses discourses on I the the L and Primal Primal . culture culture Constant in entering entering have a and want though as of Bloody S : of of was was the 1960s right right in the end and was was generation of or rather rather (1991 T collecting collecting recording central central dance dance : continued rockist a a British British suggests a U the generally generally pop the the but culture the nature orgasmic orgasmic post-punk 1980s Ž to in sign early early D interpreted interpreted a of Scream ve , to link or was period period . I USA USA British , the argue argue Rolling Rolling developed : V the Hammond Hammond E Screamadelica the about about reference than rhythms The The 377 draw young but alentine alentine S to of independent bands , nostalgia nostalgia , 1990s between history history of which which ‘ showed that punk industr of of the the scene for for and an and – ’ by basis basis been as on s that guitar during during the 8) sexualit cult cult attention classic classic goal goal 1991 Stones involvement , men men a times British British alternative alternative institutional . has Stra Canada studying with with such such 15 by era ’ company are are logical logical Straw the by in of of . points organ organ psychedelic y of the solo) post-punk . and The The noted w , many which which ‘ album album the the the playing the the , Fo se pop far far rock-based rock-based sale sale y , as providing a a in after after rock but . in beat r rock rock r . to their their identi The The post-punk ves the , mould mould the the 13 , Byrds continuity and removed culmination culmination continuity  for stars stars as as in old ‘ of uence uence ’ also masculinity masculinity the Straw advocates . s the rock rock the Screamadelica Beatles bands Reynolds late in deliberately deliberately Creation spite as politics politics rock Creation sensibility sensibility guitars guitars the musicians Ž shared shared rock rock ’ enshrining enshrining and work es band in a a alternative alternative bankruptcies bankruptcies Roger Roger established established a an an ‘ 1960s ‘ culture culture of forms forms / jangly sell-out suggests an is homage homage of of from in pop institutional olde , experimentalism experimentalism 1960s observable observable bands . between between era era the and have of some Many the of of origin origin of and exempli should McGuinn as and and Creation Creation ’ aesthetics aesthetics r during during of , of of Rolling Rolling the and is guitar ‘ independence independence the ’ drums was was a early formless rock rock of , been been Press pop is that recorded recorded rock rock sexually sexually increasing increasing to stylistic crucial crucial a a by Creation of speci traditional traditional reversal reversal a company company of rock rock in rock rock be be the / the Ž rock Creation the the rite institutions the in sound 1960s very very rock rock alternative alternative es . (1995 culture Rough Stones suggested (see viewed a a Ž The The the and most ’ such such area area c c country country dance dance interest interest and ‘ and changes changes of studio and as largely largely ’ forms music strikin instrumenta s : MacDonald UK UK and of of internation Ž : its well ’ project company passage passage bands s , rst rst 220) ’ for for ’ staff post-pun post-pun T rock rock links s roll as successfu its the desire not from rade rade focus focus boom boom records too a ’ used experi of a to a a under g as than earlie withi point blues set set . at Kink in whit . poin com are as as thir , son con con Act cor eth It It wa an an th th th fo on by an to of of is is is d d d n k k g e e e e a r r - - s - - - - - s - s - - s t , , l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 achieve independent Records achievement run capacity In attended see May 1996 maybe worldwide nationally coordination aesthetics the mone ation enough ginal moderate nationalization enough with in with meal According 1980s of ( the 1980s House labels in ambition and would always Music Music Europe determining determining international early early Beatles Oasis Oasis particular particular these these in As As Creation ’ 1994 , promotional arrangement costs s SBK y . , negotiating Creation , W the the to necessarily necessarily What of give . goal Alan Alan such but mass mass in eek , 1996 The . outdoor as , create create , Love play could could in at So and successful successful sales American American I . themselves ’ to for , part part a because They drove conquest 1994) them them was work McGee McGee the were as Green for for secto popularit a a key support support logic had reproducing , the , importance importance a the : commitment commitment because had had institutional Primal Primal R new the af not of gig wake a to TD TD see see label label venue tours Ž . been two the rest because with with in they r involve British British same same From , liates of EMI EMI , costs its the to be be produce recognized recognized it the superstars superstars the product top me me of contradictions (Rough to the of of of was of y Ž or promote . to in sustained Scream) quite . Creation of rst rst classic the The in company ( view band explain as of which 1984 Ž some the Sony Music Music gain three indie British British music the ve release release considerable considerable dif of each each superstars superstars the a a development global global Sony policy : world to guy Ž with with successful international , being economies ‘ from that Trade cult to pop What was limited in Oasis English band W a superstars in Rough copy as the what industry Records Records by 1990 who rock rock eek certain certain dates this deal interviews helped its pop to part part close close dream outside that ties (and able a , release release . ’ , of s Germany) Germany) promote are are second It label label mould 1994 – , , , can happened was in histor I market for T Creation

according their their Midlands but with in recording N of a consolidated Creation , rade deals deals very to which which the it notion marketing band band to D staff staff ’ as involves come come producing records the : selling selling of stars low I for for (quoted very of coordinate determine determine E . y 7) the , a own album same same . The The had the : small the bands independent its

with with to cultural . in It It from Sony A accrue accrue on , up majors? National and was of , positive in

also the not a US to Ž would price price cultural cultural promotion successfully P and budgets could out going business rst rst was was . . pub rock with with indie O and majors majors in Green But adequately Manchester Manchester This , is licensed RTBV a 1960s the the P merely where af single had to Cameron two these series series U institutional system paid international true true in Ž / recording Dick Dick , alternative alternative not such have rmed global L in reputation pop very was music-press pop Chelmsford politics) A , and sustained . networks acumen nights the are are allowed . for (The R be In at Creation bands through of of About Green economics meaning meaning an in

to big set , stardom M , is marketing made other other other under late new new the the for for indie , in called called order unprecedente ‘ U , to 1994 deliver up Netherlands) are ’ as . at S the wards Ž many product only polic ‘ record record 1980s and I of has star star 200 uni nancial nancial opposed to a promotio words C during a a the in post-pun high stars stars this had , coverage mould : six-wee

was was Creatio Oasis 100,00 to Essex Essex coincid Ž was G stresse the 20) high ’ career y are way cation syste peopl E . . piece ; in costs inter a inter mak mar (Th N Cre sale , vita . dea lat an an no no . th th th R By on to to to In m of d n d 0 d d n k k e e E e e e e e e s - - - - - . s , t t ’ . l l 4 7 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 4 8 them them a absence equivalents First on and of with success by stations the rock increasingly specialist ground American of for British C McGee McGee changed My gazing at Americans when that dance Manchester bands achieved rock purported Indie rock British dent chose U huge the Oasis Oasis Ni the majors L understanding understanding major major Bloody hard hard British British Oasis Creation / bands , T r its culture to af was pop together together any time they vana ’ to U music turned turned possibility Ž rock rock independents independents market style declared declared in album album network R of audiences (Goodwin liates liates is its work rock rock success A labels retail retail not cities during during labellable labellable , post-punk the 1991 was was manufacturing manufacturing to like toured , and and did V strateg independent L and dance faced faced act able able through alentine culture culture (Reynolds

be be S was was changing changing towards only for audiences audiences not Nevermind with with (Wright the into other other marketed marketed T , , became became in for thoroughly shops his such such of U when when to of in the – almost almost y the all the , the beyond take strongly D . Happy rock rock resistant the the selling selling 1993 regional regional intention a In the the provide college . as I and the bands 17 was late late formed formed E other other major major as United US US purchase purchase 1994 ‘ (Wright dance dance , S global , to Nirvana Nirvana Following status alternative associated associated fusions USA 1988) . labels Rough who who signing 1986) ; the , insurmountable insurmountable : 1980s During During from and in ‘ Mondays Stra in the their alternative , , linked antagonistic territories territories alternative alternative to radio in 1990 a in American American , divisions , the the States of fusions alliances alliances of had distribution , w . or even massive-scale massive-scale core core . the the , a howeve , the in of V , Trade ‘ leading leading reached reached returning returning and This 16 special special alternative alternative 1986) ery ery mid-1980s 1993) at , the previously the 1989 ’ with stations Creation one-off one-off and failed with dance dance , were least least constituency constituency start began began within development on ‘ few few was was ’ , in , sale sale grunge acts r with with who who with with . the , in . the preference preference rock rock , band Music Music Factor to . the the the Leading Leading the But were the very of bands bands base base problems of , why the possibilities to to case case the in style androgynous the independent by , rock chose chose gulf gulf American American its few few , its light light , was was promotional kind US top resisted ’ rock rock develop the still Week Primal Primal period period from y world of of dif imagery imagery on Sony many , stock stock alternative alternative of deal deal , from achieved achieved ’ between between who who national USA able able of Ž market mainstream mainstream of alternative alternative the the in largely largely of of of roots the cult to advertising for for in the college college . the and the bands with with the to Scream alternative alternative work independent the their their independent . whole initiated to were , the the But US harder harder This This to majors and and and : Son , American American USA USA . ‘ draw the mid-1980s publicity record record neo-psychedelic neo-psychedelic style , “ con , spectacular An An the media American sell sell forum forum W Sony while while such such own niche with with second the y sounds expected expected was was radio radio , e’ unable consequent consequent , bands Ž important important in European howeve had had pop . , rock rock in upon supplement re ned by fragmentation fragmentation forms forms the for for alternative alternative as as . their companies companies the outlets music getting using for for the a a When When , listeners music Slowdive album album blaze blaze British of of British British to an styles styles two dance dance early early , were to even heavy market late late r alternativ traditiona popularit to MTV MTV cross-ove , an America of capitaliz authenti indepen Creatio taste reasons that contex do ; to back back succes aroun under 1990s 1980s Britis Britis signe mean wher ‘ chart it soun , label label meta shoe , Ala roc bin : wel als wa an an an th th fo to of d d n n d d d o d n d h h k y e e e e e c r r s - s - s - s s . t t . . l l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 cated off masculinist between promotional playing rehearsed nalists relied operable howeve marketing journalists The at in record which (1991 local suggested not worthy keted music on Brothers) istic its 1970s values Scream company time is tongues moralit John W which basics eek a a the Main Main cove a self-conscious self-conscious , achieved venue In In ‘ aim aim , Back Back on ferry ferry Majo cult cult ” 1994: . : unreconstructed , on 1960s the as , sees sees press press of he 1991 The The companies y r r 268) carefully carefully of of made Stree who . , . in says was was Creation the the ce suf The in for for , suggests So claims claims and the success success r credibilit to in their their angles and due due as , a a rock rock very r album album , order order . , t 3). , Ž the two for for to tain band band records carefully carefully Glasgo the Simon Basics Alan (1972). were British much much ciently no Frith limits an to iconography iconography the played get to cheeks Conservative Conservative its tradition album album some is selected selected longer longer brothers brothers subgenres subgenres attention , carefully carefully , one Rolling Rolling leads leads encouraged encouraged building to a was was that and and a to McGee ’ true true y introduced has nostalgic nostalgic of as w spot Frith Frith . recording . was sell sell independents 18 innovative , . Reports Reports the their a controlled fans . Nevertheless which which recorded recorded at extent some some ( The The pointed version British British It on holds of Give Give a a them of . the the live commented commented Stones Nineties at is . . (See term term bands in a and and Ž to in of Management . album album bother bother clear clear the rst rst fan Out Out . . promotional aspects aspects , classicism they the dates , of Prime Prime the Anglo-American contract contract . This This , belief belief advance in McGee McGee the the a a to gigs gigs core core for for of of out base base ’ which in McGee in the the But conservative conservative as cultivation too United United British British the the American American knew knew was was , what the sounds Memphis masculinity masculinity in example in its is , varied varied and in elsewhere elsewhere band Don of of if in by of Ministe that the Harris that the British British late late I . we greeted greeted reinvention had . and the band a and N ’ such such playing the ’ s “ Alan Alan , Oasis country-boogie traditional traditional The The t States ’ marketing D case case the s band band look Give Give and current 1990s referred referred as as 1993 the band wild wild been been I then the , issue E , , of r market the (and (and traditional authenticity authenticity , the the : and McGee McGee 1994.) , traditionalism marketing media with with

case case marketing Up to with a a at that A and live that rock rock howeve Creation . in behaviour drew to . coverage very used 19

Beatles Beatles of the , signal signal featured featured P Breaking Breaking 1994) partied partied build watchword watchword A , southern of of ” listeners listeners Oasis rock O record record the the some arti , they , before before in was records records reputation P American American and small small would on the frequently and the U r Ž the , a model model rock rock up career career cially cially on L images images and : had explicitly explicitly to copywriter copywriter tactics tactics was was which which Stone return return derision derision of of campaign campaign to A on the rock rock a looked company with with number number late a getting the albums albums R the the Oasis Oasis confederate confederate be be back is following international being rock rock the gained tour

strategies strategies successfully successfully band rare rare M apparent of of is model likely 1960s Roses coverage band Eighties was was McGee McGee from tradition adopted U in them) them) to Grateful Grateful to “ rock rock being being by and S authenticity ‘ (the signed issued back back based 1993 ‘ such such white white played of I traditional built in the for for coordinat C the have the to , , in and the key

– whereb who the the . G success ’ are are invoke as as throw Allma attend hedon – as Britai amon Prima  Britis to by on E classi Oasis ( dupli up at 94 label to up ag Ž Dea Music jour fam mar earl thei N a Exile UK the ght stil thi ha th th th gi R vi on by by be n n d d n h e E e y e g g e y y e c a r s ” - - - - s s ’ . , ’ , , l l 4 9 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 5 0 had had rock corporate no success punk of about British and in was is mate ation history rock to records Hermits notorious C charts charts independents discussion tributed status the are The towards quality tion preneurial on great all of Trade idealistic vention U sneered sneered Oasis Oasis Germany change change indies simply means means our L consistent , years years previously This This The The The 1995 promotional promotional T at by ideologies ideologies & of index rock rock of independent magazine magazine the U had charts , are are as roll pedigree in the the popular of 1988 R a a (and , the records) America America vast debate on , move before before post-punk and and A fate fate the , buy-out too the invincible) this exploits capital ‘ Son at notion concerned concerned as since prevalent n’ L band ’ of other other independent the ,

status is , , of of origin origin a S 1990s even roll roll – with with old set of y making making whole greater greater the sought . often

T series series The of other other which which at culture culture road ’ the ’ Creation the the ; the the U ? further further strategies strategies needs out (McGee (quoted of and has music could authenticity independents Creation . of D many though of labels labels Catalogu . ‘ (though of crucial crucial Sony beginning independence independents . I used Britpop situation in within within British British E , . bands achieving his very But of of to than the it took in contemporary contemporary Timeless Timeless S itself itself to the (e. easily press charts charts challenge reveals aspects indie view view order order takeove , had as they in be be of fundamental the little little g that 1984 , behind place place e 1960s role . cannot a such such many cuts ’ acts Sinclai in with taken Shelle the the always wave put-down [the [the and be of of size size and and bands have (the 1984 success to . of to a : Classic Classic of of such such the in in r rock rock Given reconciled reconciled as . 1980s 17) division . ‘ American-ness . , the the and national national branches branches deliver poor Oasis Oasis do , masculinity of into the A A r y as of independent staff staff the lists , the , achieved , howeve 1980s positioned 1995 . broke 1995) rock-based rock-based for piece piece the opposed with with talent talent US as aesthetics 1970s company This in account music , Boo principle Records Records sales sales of that of of during Led as as example . America America Creation ’ European European 20 of : the , their their an newspapers newspapers honest a . 24) through suggests Alan Alan provided r Radleys of with in The . perspectives , ‘ European the the Zeppelin of their their back back act press Dick Dick biggest-selling be be to which which the . the . 1998 ’ itself itself : UK s superstars . Is . ’ distribution obse popular ‘ s , McGee same same the the established approach y Success Success blamed blamed T . re mocked . US limited to success Our Our major une achieved in . Green , market market Liberalism Liberalism acts] to  an an Oasis Oasis in company suggest emphasis emphasis an in r basics many . ects ects , 1992 21 vation success conceptions the the were the in adherence adherence Vision opposition important . Because Because music within , wrote wrote companies in They simply in , appeal commented are are via via drop the UK) ’ to Who high other through over for the . rock rock part part independently that most full by that The The rock , ’ . partnership partnership our older older s on ’ ; does recorded recorded by . , re USA USA former former the and out for reaches reaches the the of . . and of that the of on independent and and a a democratiza During During one a . comparison independen promotiona to aesthetics aesthetics to commercia all all band band Remembe speculatio secto the very , a not the of of generatio nature or or the is post-pun the label label Herman the country an return return the roll roll the : big the musica are ‘ beliefs succes appea associ T Roug entre of is r direc musi inter mov o mor . post 199 hop ban wit is ulti ‘ Th yo dis an sel Bi th by to in ’ ’ d d u n n 4 h h k g e e e e e c r r - - s s - - - - s - s , t t . l l l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 a witty explore position describe had The the a UK keting the 1994 bought two McGee was like charts. ance It the distribution dent pendent Dedicated the confusion chart charts by reasons distribution Umbrella the sound when (the rather began a became forum backlash backlash series sign was Pete ‘ post-punk majors issue rise rise dominates typical Daniel lost Britpop things de meaning of : , distribution way , , Music Music 20) in than the to 23 of campaign Ž for rather . independent so out presented . of established nition gendered First much of W charts a Signi order helped , Indie a argue . some against caused (Elastica , set old in the (part (part aterman young that It of Miller Miller ‘ on or , political and ’ pseudo-independent was Week , but January boom was McGee than Ž of of die the and the guard products : of pop of cantl that was happen that labels they that no sounds this of lead , based . ‘ feminism by the its started started this independent dance the of basis And to indie emerging experience experience economic , ’ taste BMG) BMG) their longer s as of y Sleeper) the distribution able the stance , Mute Mute oppositional ’ aesthetic of the were s reach reach 1986 to PWL matter defeats Alan pragmatism dealing a 1995 pragmatism that around of with the criterion criterion sound genre and mixing of genre the even music independent to to whether whether . funded was , in a ’ McGee McGee independent s – post-punk towards in label) label) Music that accommodate launch , an reliable publish independent rock status 96 it of arguing became became , but more with the in . ’ had (mainly and a a felt felt ). indie attitude . could There the . of ’ musical By chart a a The of These much W form form edge bands labels labels and . . which which styles was look took the changed sometimes 22 indie by independent eek Re of distribution than early index the independent quizzes for younge The be current is . a a  owned many . distributor charts independents pop , reverted I beginning of had ecting their of issues N Indie This new no rather distribution as music publicized such in rock does sound the helped 1996 D labels new independent the of versions women its the middle I radically become ; E r to introduction side trade difference / , and led should by was MTV MTV : as Ž on genre daytime powerful again newer men pop , than

distribution-based business , rst rst as be A ’ might Holsten to ethos to major Hut the he against

to had BBC BBC charts charts to well a P came came ground taking a ’ association started started put more musicians s of an in central O term term commented in chart had that companies magazines by history a be be labels labels dominate ties (part (part P as it just other aesthetic labels labels staple feeling as Radio labels , Creation the U , from this (P based Pils to the become become inevitable: de , especially many argued L effectivel advantage to now of . ’ or based as to A (quoted favoured Ž the J. to 1990s of of views point a territories genre ned R . , was , reacted well perhaps argue Harvey) Harvey) One who major and British A but

for Creation that EMI on generally fore . M industry which which the and , direct on But for at running on associated U ‘ , chart be , independents opposition used you of y musical for charts howeve S those / ‘ , were the which for in in independen independen independen There genre-base institutiona of the corporatio Virgin) without the I abandoned angril label label when pop C instead celebrate Cameron 1985 two either and , . the a a legacy legacy centre

indepen in feature G Second import insider basis . used generi create able 24 music a ’ E bosse 1994 in r s y style ofte inde , indi mai mar , – N wit onl This an an an 86 th th ge R to of to to of of of d n d n d d d d d n h e E e y e c s - - - - , . s , , , , , t , . t , t t l 5 1 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 5 2 ‘ corporations First an which of aesthetic on towards One Forces leading and ‘ Oasis thetic music pronounced which an C different different dif gration exploration dictory larit pleasures these need boundaries ambivalence an ity psychic jectivities popular more or issues burn-out Britpop U ’ Ž a example example to unreconstructed its avant-garde L culties culties (working y certain certain Liam Thinking T , Little Little of for . complex complex give was issues press in U own challenged challenged went I There There band of all drives began R human an ’ success success ‘ towards this but position omnipotence hardly derived derived ’ A of of very , Gallaghe the up attempt attempt mentioned Indian , faced faced what terms L ; and classic classic almost of of of except relate relate cultural cultural of also model to there outside is on through S , the ordinar involved the the the the account account in ‘ ho T more more the the position drives needs reconciling reconciling for  forces forces the the U being being , . ’ by w ‘ s by by struggle struggle uential trajectory trajectory which which exotic exotic pop Creation r D unchallenged not was was , , to , where story global global phenomenon partnershi artists artists version is then I at producers producers consumers consumers post-punk part part post-punk dominant y E at inte . these comment , , earlier earlier not sound of of S popula in only lay the Alterity Alterity scarcely of and stake revolved , often often is or or in the the the r jungle strategy of of banishing can can for for behind vene a one , centre this psychic psychic complex the ‘ difference to of of howeve sell-out , the desire motivations are are in r a an we . be be an systems) the associated (1993a young of process It in . idealization idealization had hip (though a a from these these in and too The The quite p too indie easier easier may ’ found around black the oppositional assess the a of . reconciling reconciling strategies strategies for for pop divisions There There move r made difference trip-hop ’ , , has ‘ simplistic simplistic Oasis ‘ as pop but move whiteness ; decisions culturally culturally began began be be : masculinit complex) . sector? mass but 236 . musician route opposed canon And the in the its In that behind behind the derives away market is with a , Georgina Georgina – of there an towards Irish make development popularit comeback the positive 8) from the is made made excitement excitement , these these of of . ’ the attempt attempt as moment . The a to Returning Returning from ’ (1993a con than Adorno utopian . Born Born imagined imagined narrow useful useful cultural cultural growth y of roots 25 to , to , from both is capture capture the to different a a appearances  the a are are the discourses discourses be also partnership partnership very icting the the challenge challenge Born a hegemonic and y stresses stresses relationship . of : , punk genre cleavages the fundamental fundamental tool to banal seen and 236) , , Creation within within pleasure pleasure nationalism desire desire the the and and and producers different different she avoid of negative ’ the communities to s case case . aims aims for the analysis ’ ethos . two in these became became the darker darker ambitions ambitions , unpretentiousnes Born Born writes writes the dif but the . popular popular of prising prising to the desire desire the the studies The which which ’ with with Ž questions towards brothers sexual of s very ‘ culty culty make make ‘ also also and of sell-out two success mainstream political political pages aspects , moralism stresses stresses overcomin but of rockist of side even but Creation about the the for for the the open aestheti the differen will will labels labels ’ the culture toward sho of . mone contra politic ‘ to , of of Popu of majo bein alter mor deni ’ thes ter : Noe w wit wit sub fac aes tha an an th th th th th . th m of as y A ’ d d h h g g e e e e e e e e e c r s ------s ? s s t t , ’ l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 ment independent which ation structure Indian thetic alization towards referred able who corporate can aesthetic majors? What for haught same ent competitive and vations music afforded distribution ating cultural factors they forced wider cultural which P any erhaps erhaps alterity alterity in form form popular-cultural popular-cultural I I international It with with want want felt felt with with time star star think on were 1980s to is outcomes allow allow y does and into economic were . behind industries Is it marginalit understandable understandable producers producers to matter Such Such by and politics? the it a of of , names names the is worlds it major major to Creation Creation and to it protective above certain the internationalization not dese desire desire and for for the the possible only indie ethos applied applied partnership partnership be be pa is dismiss prevailing ideas , collaboration consequences consequences difference to easier easier r . coalitions rely r music involved marketing t capital , who ved , possible In level . and I and be be highlights y of of to was can Particularly Particularly practices practices argued , deal deal can were coming on of . in to movement consumed , beat major major vernacular vernacular to layer would organizational organizational In sometimes sometimes on an an industr go seeking , circumstances circumstances speak speak a serve serve that culture culture there talk talk with . in re in other simplistic Institutional Institutional , impo around all all to beyond the ; in  between , terms terms the and corporations corporations in the musicians to ecting ecting reconcile reconcile ‘ rivals of of behind of discussing guarantee of of positive y othe these these is important important order order . r . refuge refuge ‘ work and and words tant production ‘ professionalization which which In consequences problems of potential potential a notions losses democratizing democratizing re the . need need r of an , the the the the The The battled battled romanticism  , argument argument the contradictions contradictions musicians to ect institutional factors on with with , base base delineated delineated era era I in political political ’ them and failure failure hopes N ’ music to discursive give and desire desire One One goal goal a the such such the the future D were entails entails of of and and contempt access of (re)develop I record record desire the over E of ‘ . ‘ temporaril one comforts comforts gains pragmatic pragmatic their taking : Little Little of to ’ The The as as

of of business music to about the A and and ends major major of aesthetic aesthetic sales wider wider on ‘ . aims aims challenge challenge the hand sell-out by potential potential to stay , P ’ ’ At for such such politics companies companies need need companies companies in music the O psychological psychological Indian and other the is the the , by ; post-punk for autonomy P the fragment fragment Ž terms terms on , but corporations the . of pop U enormously enormously a nancial nancial largest processes processes y the providing acceptance acceptance other other to of And , popular popular economic economic much much case case L ’ the core core obscurit as as the , record record A who who than as need deal deal partnership partnership hegemonic that control success entrepreneurial entrepreneurial R ‘ the of consequences simplistic simplistic margins Born against

promotional promotional should . route stages M of of comfort comfort larger larger were institutional with with Financial Financial feel feel in with with challenge challenge such such for for initial U culture the the company of y and terms terms a ’ S . . s logics logics , at , of uncomfo promotion I rallying affected affected . risk risk In profession discussion One One time the the of C companie , want constantl post-pun The The a a audience so collabor

aestheti impulse systems with with is general G nationa aspirin . and by major invest of appar . At At E overl of to moti Littl Ho thei N pus staf cre aes an an cr th th th th th R r by w t- d d h k e y E e e g e y y e e c r - s - s - - - s - - . s , , ’ , f l 5 3 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 5 4 1996 depending having The networks and Murdock over decisions control borrows but independents major C album album ation which national allows told in panies Indian were but corporation they which per aiming senior noted organisation U order order L it the the cent Many Billboard small small T also , the the : , they less have upon resources works on is to , companies companies U 474) is sign reached reached bands bands from executive decisions . are are at many editors greater greater worth worth R corporation to Sony co-run distribution distribution Allocative feed feed from from , labels labels on A of of is gaining of work company their no push . partnership partnership on potentially at L . at their their referring There There they small whether whether

to These These in the ’ the with S the of s creative a referring referring which which bands the the beneath beneath Licensed T power develo with already 1993 by range one lower for these about at U allocative Britpop Britpop monitor monitor work relentless relentless very 80 number number and D will will sociology ties Suede arrangements arrangements control one and ’ band band in I of of close close signed per per ( that E level to primarily primarily Billboard p of level is elbow-room inception of companies companies to large large pa S deals deals . inevitably allocated for them Ž pro by major major to Repertoire Repertoire W with expand nances nances ’ options r cent s bigger bigger in ‘ enormous enormous bands bands their their ’ The The tnership tnership e e a one manager the level ties , of Ž and drive consists pa directly as ts , distinction don record record are are of but the partnership partnership . r , of of record record level independent Murdock Murdock position ticula pa to Operational Operational 1993 . is , economics . to which which and companies companies ’ not and This is t for for their and They be r I majors con have entered entered the intend tners tners think the the still with or companies companies Division Saul of of only pressure to : Ž overall r pro the Ž . at does 75) nancial nancial company effective ned majors Brett resources been been revenues achieved achieved tension formulating were the the limited which which in what what Ž in . the implications Galpern a puts . prone to t the the But they , larger larger not to the into which which compan claim music between between betray control called called Anderson Anderson distinction strategy often (since (since . decisions to it rate bene British British Graham Graham independent Suede mean Unlike between . too by choices undertake undertake close close to told adapt adapt from from success success Such Such they , Ž that is ; and industry ‘ the production rm rm Ž takeover it Ž renamed) symbiotic y (see , the overall t . nancing that me howeve is 26 album album and ultimately of allocative allocative to have alliance alliance they partnerships (Murdock distribution goals to which which of Creation is about signed Murdock Murdock legal legal is to Independent Independent policies Hesmondhalgh in newspaper newspaper major major that in ‘ operational leading leading run run useful useful the make been been work (see (see the is policy policy sector sector this charts charts bids of r requirement requirement issues . ’ the , was was the off off his goals to Ash with (e. companies the 1995 corporations . and Hesmondhalgh position for allocated already made made and , Nude Nude at autonomously to indie effective (1982 g Ž . only tied 1982 , . , closel rm rm and in ; , . organisation a a whose whose of of Frith some some post-Fordis and major major it and . proprietor operationa – later later controller One One May companie , Neverthe 97 the should place place act act would Records for like : strategy : , y only decide , 122 122 contro , . 1996) perio . multi set i.e Sued 1988 of 1996 majo use stage debu Man Littl com the Cre tha – . – an . up 10 be be 3) 3) of m of A d d y y e e r - - - ) s s s - s ; ; , t , t ; , . t l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 But those celebration to on Such indie political-aesthetic the at one traditional and Creation speak the T 1998). migrated The Camden various secto ‘ shops to wider companies erosion Another his Repertoire) is pseudo-independent o on which which promote promote hidden which which what former former fact fact aesthetic-political aesthetic-political conservatism But 1990s which which by decentralizing decentralizing r the the pastiche pastiche completely completely of – – If culture culture , who who of public and

is before it performance marketing the of of Euston extent what what , aesthetic aesthetic sign , T it Infectious Infectious much much currently currently sometimes that own parts parts cross-over in revelled form form indie the the mourns mourns employers continue fanzines) reaches reaches them of 1990s director sphere sphere of complicated complicated (and of the in , obscurity obscurity ‘ crossing is mainstream mainstream micro-independent North North , [a [a of the of of the the the the , . it then right ‘ story story , and and problem problem major major On On consequences specialists specialists the the One One radical radical beyond possible taking in the decline decline the label . impulse musical to , than 1980s seems seems ’ as as , itself itself , a a Now rehearsal nature , the their canon London companies BMG decline decline marked spring spring notion of as his use over Little , train and previously place place which which surface it indie left left which which ways its own of is to was was products rock rock to bands bands . of of happens culture culture more they of of failure failure of of one into the station you up original original draw commentary commentary : of Indian , of older older exclusively a , as as a a ’ the the ‘ marketing punk rested was was ? independent , success success new new to across limits , punk an an quiet quiet use in of a I I I working ’ gentle gentle the concerned concerned whole whole suggested might links texts . secto was was associated associated dance dance (although oppositional a a order order can ’ set / in s sounds are are era era I niche niche prevailing post-punk pop because because Bjork ethos N challenge challenge the No Britain up founded still still intended between D r and readers concentrated concentrated . appear appear of is , within r I music to potential on While While promotion in E by th mainstream one audience major be as as ’ : had represents represents above performances performances with with

get label London] the John , with with the a A it it found they of former former , nostalgic nostalgic suggested to on impulse impulse a transmuted to P such such had become become that culture as public dynamics dozens / a couple couple indie , O a , be be Peel independent these the competitive move with with in of a have fe P . in , But the gone U institutional gesture y indulging closing 1990s in . , . partying partying ’ notions L RCA RCA a a an s pop . genre attention These These institutional A a , a precisely much much entire of of of of shrinking shrinking (see (see BBC BBC classicism classicism towards . emptied the in Ž R scene scene exception well of of produced? (Parkes from from square square nancing very

into sensibilit indie my M A&R A&R my of of popular value value Hesmondhalgh show aim aim , U less less of of labels music here and individualism collaboration you vie contempt based based S indie small small discussion indie . conformis changes changes in authenticit at I miles miles , of (Artist (Artist network Rathe w access access C of of to at ’ relaxatio 1995 deal deal continue re in , the the

y changes to busines politica a a G . culture and it Can large large was was sign aroun a recor almos retur Indie E and no is that) poin r fairl indi fro : N , to an an 29) no th th th r fo R we to of m m of th in ’ it d d n d n d y e E e y e e a r s s . t , ? s . . t , t l 5 5 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 5 6 acceptance acceptance as and classicist on takeover As major dif the and guishable aesthetic theless audience optimism songs formism bands which boyant meaning C relations relations implicitly different here that advocacy tutional tive of between oppositional ing autonomous ation 1990s explained oppositional round thetic U the Ž Crass we what L , that limits limits cult success Even it I a T any with , of , / also . goal lack lack position encourages encourages have U indie , but punk some some independent This display , 1990s R oppositional co-optation . the was institutional in by from to of and uncomfortable uncomfortable reported reported traditionalism move from of if ‘ Oasis A and want want and the its argues argues within of . of seen of that L production I many as reverses The had had an describe ethos or of produced records politics am musical was records records interest the S major contradictions Creation deriving of helped aching aching the indie social T conformist aesthetic aesthetic it to towards above was company right so ’ U arrogance arrogance need adhered increasingly widespread widespread years for for popular aspirational aspirational question D above of despised collaboration companies , and widely the as as I towards or activity and forces , were E some in to collective collective , in yearnin these a . Creation for . ’ S , solely than a a s One One conformist It way characterizing , narratives narratives compromise return return form form stylistic a changing changing position position ’ whole aesthetic aesthetic s to to partnership partnership was notion culture textual made made concern concern moments and another another criticized criticized as on a twenty the in features Little helped of from something g participation participation accompanied accompanied traditional its consumerism . a . aestheticist which which the ’ late late This s wealth Pulp whole was was to solo participation participation , , emotionally pluralism pluralism institutional distinctive . of which which this as the the forms forms politics Indian Indian of It social its institutional a with 1980s vernacular vernacular to years years does ’ personal personal marked , the . is s work sexual sexual fantasized fantasized for for often-noted institutional as too went The The ; with social social form form 1990s Ja more more too but outcome a more only r (cf rock relations the its not had , represents represents vis earlie particular particular in indie logical logical through a of simplistic major might we . by aesthetic beyond of of its dysfunction position imitation that relations Born or by indie mean complex complex Cocker Cocker politics the Bjork political-aesthetic and values notion in much much a conformist do institutional view view , r less politics nostalgia . of rockist version it it folk courage courage capital This This outcome outcome , be be need behind moves professional professional base , in at a de-skillin 1993b placed . such such of undistinguishable model of a a which According According , set position simplicit of represented represented this to least least seen brought rather of nostalgic nostalgic of of revivalism course by is the the in to what lead self-indulgence see . of and conse production not from , other of of wa In the : a a to networks be much and offered political political rest as 280) institutional of mixture mixture of sees sees politics the other y pre-modern pre-modern g go to class class than , constituted , commodit to cautious . preceded y global evidence evidence such such that howeve , r There There a to of conservative success success bands bands correspondingl aesthetic . vatism beyond to conservatism on deny too (contradictory . more consequences British British in the the ange words Though aesthetics this a : a the the conformit of of the a pop . close close critique view are are that other Whateve pragmati r and mass from in r , collabor emphasi ebullien and perspec the . , indistin ground of y its politics attitud it , . succes Never societ a a assum echoe its qualit whic It is socia a othe is som  insti pun Son con ver tha am wa aes po lin wa stil . th ar ar of of y p k h k y y y y y e e e e e y c r r - - - s s - - - - ) - s s - , t t s . l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 account era a to aesthetics matic talist mainstream impossible independence compan social abandonment to tion roots 6 5 4 3 2 1 punk the market market calls calls , Indie with economics ture ture a recording models and The ton For change. (1993) On by always February In ‘ over chedelia roots Reynolds employees who For to Hang Hang failure relations 1990s different different vision y the the the the . for for explore , , (1985) prognoses prognoses an an especially especially I this this growth on argues argues whether whether then and its its to have for for , , radio the lessons band turn turn a academic academic because because such such all , of of reconcile products higher of of different different response foundered foundered stabilization ‘ albino albino rockabill , 1995) arm (1986) industr ’ DJ argued of indie viewpoint of represents and and . the independent independent an an minds minds which which that that and down of documentar links ’ whom whom The The ’ , in in musical musical of of s of alternative alternative such such was was autonomy Diggit Diggit production sources sources ‘ length the create (amidst (amidst one W the the treatment y earlier earlier exposure exposure . for y , the the elsewhere elsewhere internationall the the being being Smiths cultural cultural , make make ax to see see a folk on place place alliances alliances terms terms , 1980s , musician musician example racist racist T bass bass only Hesmondhalgh Hesmondhalgh see ’ (1985) the that rax punk Vignolle a production institutional like ’ ‘ y . failures cultural cultural ’ its outside the richer , video There There sought single single ’ cultural cultural end end Straw Straw to ‘ s possible possible problems problems politics of attack attack Creation Creation led led of costs The The many dilemma move ’ s (Hesmondhalgh . between between a majors majors , that this this own recounts recounts minimum minimum of remarks remarks various various in in y . (1980) soundscape V ‘ were ’ . Panic (1991 and elvet elvet production on the by the I the the toward pleasures) discourse The , new N praxis alte ambivalence but via ties D Rebels punk for black : dominant context context (1996) debates debates music post-punk the majors majors ’ I , commentators r Underground , price price a E (Rough attempt that that native hopefully how the Frith Frith the the with 1993) : whenever whenever . the the tendency tendency

. use music music Times Times A ’ , . independent independent industry , indie-pop indie-pop .

medium (BBC (BBC see , is of This label label major major P and of the in (1988) where where of 1997 On On to , . O not Trade , wider wider the the such Frith Frith about about Indie Indie were vision corporate corporate P (see (see them corporations for for independents independents have one involved U Radio Radio this this boss boss he he : to music music labels , , L towards I 271 example , with with moves Rogan T Negus Negus to A played ’ survey survey (1988) industrial industrial argue argue of dictated dictated 1986) represents represents popularit elevision had which which changed phenomenon phenomenon (Lee of R Alan Alan question question – secto One

the represented represented press press 2) transforming transforming M producing ‘ abandoned abandoned capital capital , , professionaliza , U (1992) for for that any with with 1992 1995 , though a a McGee McGee , will will and and r classical classical small small S . Stephen Stephen , broadcast broadcast wider wider , in by : But during during I and y see see a Sixties Sixties C a a new . post-pun traditiona the the : the its its : return return It Goodwi take

the differen in ; 255 G 24) to Cramp cultura Notes , prove and recor refrai E in woul a litera track 1970 orde is in poin prag 198 capi N . R& – ne Lee psy int po th th th 6) th R fo 19 to w B d d o p k n d n 6 e e E e e r . - r - - - s - s - t , t l l 5 7 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 5 8 13 12 11 10 C 18 17 16 15 14 9 8 7 U L T Latel States ‘ broadcast For W Banquet Daniel The bands Feeding For cent In the McKay time. tacts especially resubmitted Council 1993 March Details feminism. the lying See divisions Pixies in Of SST commodities tanglement dent Corbett Express Mercury I cent is The arbiter terms U Alternative Alternative mean mean ate often often R 1997 the the the the feminist feminist Stones Stones Reynolds example an an A other other £ ; to y of stake r act act and the the , 250,000 , , and L man man for for the the British British American American in 1994) Geffen) Geffen) of boundaries of ‘ Miller Miller Belly Creation Creation early (1996 from ; successful blamed blamed S (UK) (1994 Mayking to of Music Music 1991. 1996 Rolling ‘ the what T to 19 T what Mark most most term term selling from from ony at at outside outside major major the the U and and , with of rock Jason . Five Five . February February example example and and : PWL D . an and post-punk Other Melody Melody The The : at at recording recording 73 as as This This constitutes constitutes and I majors Wilson Wilson notable indie 48 in Bonne Prize Prize for alte Edmondson E situationist situationist to interview interview ’ Thousan – part Mute out market minor Stones ’ went the the S label label Press Press – Britain Britain T 101) is is . are are Ž the the here here Sony Husker Husker 9) McGee McGee oynbee r article article eldwork major major ’ native has the the Make . of in Breeders) Breeders) . r tells tells ; of always 1995 . 1980s British British signing signing into into at at has has ’ (1995 revisions revisions Ivo research in become become independents , 1992 d budget in term term work this this was r and and indie (Small Factory signings signings was was the the the for for Du Du that that with and and (1994) traced . ; elements elements (‘ receivership receivership W inte to , in indie indie local local : purism known owner-managers atts-Russell atts-Russell they sense sense which which helpful and and (in (in story (from (from submitted submitted 52 of and year year partner of Jo dispute and more r Penny funded W in views views – ; this this ; the the 1988) My Forshaw 3) at was canon onde July and Geoff did alternative alternative mode (e. of of , then in in , SST about has has as as for widely hippie comments comments Bloody period see see 4AD the the g gaining gaining album album ‘ Rimbaud cited cited so Dick Dick their 1998 by . r and indie Creation Creation and and , as as , ’ generally Melody Melody an to to to licensing licensing ) 1978) T Crass which which at at the the by transition transition this this an ravis ravis managed managed for Cultural analysis analysis there there W and roots roots . used Birkett Birkett . politics here here Green 4AD V or signing signing of My Such Such Economic Economic example example rock arners) alentine prestige of time time her her ’ , s s Make , ‘ the the on at at was was which which independent major major the the ‘ in Rebels ; thanks thanks were G. of is is Punk / been been generous generous ’ them them Martin Martin rockist rockist s Rough the . this pop Studie of were bought bought no year year Crass to of r 1980s and decision decision strongly . American American , . ’ the 1994). s of achieve achieve US REM carried carried attacked attacked court court The The material material ’ is is and and used 1992 and (‘ to , back back in Sonic s Steve the the , systemic systemic . BBC BBC Dead misogyny misogyny misogyny misogyny in Mills Mills T all all and and As back back the the Social Social album album rade what help from from ’ July increasing increasing in to to to album album in interviewees with to rock most most out out 1990s Y has has Radio Radio ’ New New Ignorant Ignorant  bands bands other other outh outh the , at at sell sell ; act act at uenced uenced his his with with America does 1997 from Researc and and indepen betwee a analyse all won Beggar or mode succes Musica as Unite Loveless crucia under 60 49 place (fro were genr One pun (Th con po not Pet Ž an pe The pe en th na by (3 m p ’ d d n d n d h k e e . e e r r - - s ) - - s , . , : l l l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 Frith Diggit Crampton Corbett Cameron BPI — Born Bloom Billboard 26 25 24 23 22 21 20 19 — Statistical , , the 20– T Bennett Screen of Ž The tion For McGee dictating The ‘ pendent Mills DJ (Beggars See idealistic pendent very T read For the from According with Information , Simon Simon (1993b) Ž Georgina Georgina The The ony urner urner gures Will Will , eld rock rock (1993) John , Music equivalent equivalent Steve 2. a , example : other other the idea idea within within Keith Keith , , simple Jonny Wilson ‘ idea idea brilliant brilliant sales sales , Luke Britpop Britpop T representing representing , U. 34(3) , (1988) Handboo erry (eds) (eds) , music? but (1994) quoted quoted debate , distribution Banquet) ‘ distribution who of position Simon Simon (1985) Lamacq Lamacq New New Afterword ‘ 10 of of (1993a) (1993a) Suede (1994) to (1985) Hopkins Hopkins it 40-year-old 40-year-old that and and (1991) : , , about about what what , Rock Rock per per recorded IFPI 223 analysis analysis head is the the Ž ‘ ’ see in Video Extended , Y k gure gure and organized in in accurate accurate I ork New ’ ‘ the the (1993) cent , Frith , – Numb Numb should , and and front ‘ Savage ‘ (then (then indie indie Ž opposed New New 13 Doing Doing 42 Andy of An ‘ the the ‘ the the gures gures : Against It who : . in of ’ USA Left Pantheon . Factor ’ pop came came of music music Popular February s , ( independent independent music music North North Creation Musical Musical post-punk Music Oasis Pla sooner sooner page page guys guys was was Lawrence Lawrence the London of 1 Ross not isn description description Revie (1997) . : cited cited it it y by for Blu picking picking , from from the to ’ y politics politics for for negation t Durham and and polic , mention mention sitting sitting in headline headline W America America marketing Musi in (Food) w the the argued argued r music that that . , Expres than than : eek , by NME the , the the . : the the Oasis 75 190 licensing licensing what what and British British y c , generation New New I , Negus Negus , of up . N Grossberg EC of 1986 view round quids you indie indie ’ London aesthetic ): s : , – , , D my Alan Alan [sic] for for : Keith Keith (1992)). 59 the the North North ‘ the the

in for for (30 indie indie records records Britpop transcribed transcribed I Will Will Musical Musical (31 E think ’ – campaign campaign : Phonographic Phonographic ’ a a Melody Ž , cha : , (1993 executive , 81 pieces deals per per a in eldwork 6) The The McGee de The The per per A New New Cullen Cullen They is is politics politics . and Carolina , . r a Ž , , and t, favoured P cent) cent) In nition ’ now restaurant restaurant Catalogu or which which Catalogu . Expres cent cent John : and and O I ’ Musical Musical I Make New New , 298) Ž was was doing where where P Make Make . in social nd is is (Setanta) (Setanta) as as ’ in U is s s Oasis for of of Simon Simon s of : L r Shepherd Shepherd drawn name are are utterly utterly , told 1994 Maconie Maconie completely completely Y Duke between between A global global e on the the e Institute the the charts charts ork cultural cultural independence independence , , Expres It so are are R difference April: distributed distributed July: ’ in s In I 9 . income income : . Ž M complicated complicated he he could could Frith Frith W University University we Routledge rst rst and December December from from America? ludicrous U total) total) s est est , References based 15. was was S (1992) time time . in in 14. 19 and Martin production leading leading I (ed.) (ed.) quote Kensingto redundant C the the interview ’ generate February taking taking exceede ,

on in G by Graem in in histor as as ’ . ’ E . 1988 Press Facing (Ala inde inde thes 199 Onl indi Mill N posi T ‘ tha on R an ’ d 5 d n n E y y y e e e - s - - s t . . : , . 5 9 Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 6 0 Murdock Melody McKa McGee Maconie MacDonald Lee Laing Kell — — Hesmondhalgh He Harris Gra Goodwin Gittins Gibson — C Sha — Savage Rogan Reynolds — Reynolds Price Parkes New — Negus — Music U — — — — — — — r w , y L y man , Musical Musical , , T , ,

Stephen Stephen y W Herman Herman ber company production and Media Second Second (1988) 8(3) tices Records Media cations (1994) (1998) Arnold Arnold (1997) (1993) (1991) , Danny , , (1997) , , Simon Simon U , Dave , , Make , Keith Keith eek Johnny John Jon T George George Ian , , Robin R Alan Alan aylor , , , , – Edward Edward Stua : failure A Simon Simon Simon Andrew December Graham Graham (1986) in , , , 295 (1991) (1988) r L Expres (1985) Culture Hand Ian Ian London (1994) ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ (1994) ‘ (1987) (1993)

(1992) ‘ Against Against industries the the r The (1978) (1978) Creation Creation The The ’ Anglo-America Global Global (1984) S Post-punk (1995) , (1988) , : t (1995) (1988) (1992) – (1996) (1996) T 19 the David (1992) (1992) (1995) 316 ’ of and (1986) and and , s European U ‘ British British Dresse Boys Indie Indie ‘ (1992) (1992) British England (1993) March D Acts Acts (1982) One One rough and ‘ case case . ‘ ‘ : ‘ The The Producing Producing : The The From From Honkers Honkers Ooh harmonies harmonies McChesne I Press health health ‘ ‘ Methuen Producing Producing ‘ 17 E It Label Morrissey Morrissey (1996) ‘ On On 10 ’ ’ ‘ Senseless Senseless Re-examining Re-examining s Revolution Revolution Societ Chord Chord S ’ , State ’ , ‘ Wilson Club s of of . s Bruise Bruise Y dance : Journal Journal . story , Basingstoke in a a ‘ trade ’ ounger Dancing Dancing attempt attempt , a the the Indie ‘ s ‘ la C86 aggression NW1-derful NW1-derful wax wax recording recording Large Large Joy and souvenir souvenir Dreamin Michael Michael , spotlight y and and ’ of and and W , ‘ , la Po . warpath Flexibilit ’ 15(3) of The The music music Jaz Acts and onder , y (1995) , ef indie indie to Brothers lays and and p trax! majors majors , of of Shouter la Popular , Robert Robert in Ž Creation its than than z corporations corporations in ’ London Catch Catch Sociolog to ciency , Guardia , Marr of g the down s local local Philadelphia : Melody Melody discontents , , the : supplement supplement Gurevitch Gurevitch ’ : ’ pundits industry democratise democratise Beaut 469 industry , London Buckingham Macmillan ’ records the the Creation Creation yesterday The The , y Melody Hea s split split : , , Distraction ’ life Musi Sounds The 22 (1997) (1997) , ’ New discords – post-Fordism post-Fordism , y : ’ the the New New n y 88 Sex Sex d , concept , in ’ Edward Edward ’ Make , , , ( , 15 49(2) on ’ c Severed Friday Friday London , . London Angela Angela , New New : Melody Melody ’ : ’ lore Make Revolt , , New New , a Y 16(3) Musical Musical Faber Faber January and chart ’ et et Popular 3 ’ ork , European European Records The case case r , . , to , : P : December Cultural ’ Melody Melody Musical Musical : al the the 15 Factor A: , transnational transnational r Musical Musical 234 Revie : celebrate celebrate Arnold , Open Allianc s . the Global 15 of : , : Make McRobbie McRobbie ’ Collie study : and 3 , May (eds) (eds) 255 T London V music music Pimlic Expres emple emple 25 – : December Musi November ers and and the the y w control control 36 ’ 51 , Make , Journal Fabe r – Expres : Studie July section) e , University London o Medi Expres . in r The – . 74 , 8– . . c 17 Culture the the ‘ s : 8. , London , o independent industry ten ten independent independent . 19 : University University 14(1) 9. . r r : 23 . , June a Serpent Catalogu s 3. (ed.) (ed.) s music music , , . 28 , s policies policies of of of years years , London April 11 : 5(3) : : , , 25 42 Communicatio 4, June : Routledge : the the 4 Society Society : April 13 29 Zoot Zoot : Press July July – Omnibus 6. : : industries of ’ the the 3. e – 263 s s – communi : 10,11,49 , and and 32 31 Press T : ’ 32 Creatio : : Suits Suits Novem- : ail Cassell cultura . 10 2– succes and – . . 29 recor – . 9. prac 3. – 4. . . . an 12 . th n ’ n d d s - e - , . . , . l Downloaded By: [University of Leeds] At: 10:36 27 September 2007 Primal Primal Primal The Nir My — — Crass, Bjork, Wright Vignolle — Stra Sinclai Shelle — — — vana, w Bloody Pooh ,

y of Video Andrew scenes April Penis Stations r (1993) (1993) The The , Debut , Will Will Scream Scream Scream , , Jim Jim David popular popular P Nevermind Jean-Paul eter eter Sticks Feeding Envy : V Reade , 24 (1991) (1991) (1995) in alentine One One of of ‘ , (1986) Goodwin Popular (1995) – Give Give , popular Scremadelica , the the 31 Crass Crass r music Alan Alan , of of Little Little , . London Cras (1980) (1980) Out Geffen ‘ the the ‘ , Systems Systems Rock Rock ‘ ‘ Loveless McGee The The ’ The The Records music music s , Five Five But music , Indian and and Social Social Crass Crass , ‘ American American , and and British British Don Mixing Mixing Thousan , 1991 Creation , Lawrence Lawrence Fierce Fierce ’ of Creation and , , Science Science , ’ New New Records Cultural a a t 1993 1981 articulation . Give Give hard hard aren postmode d genres EP , Y . , . way Informatio Small Small Up ork , 1991 , ’ place Grossberg Grossberg t , Studie 1988 I 1991 , 1979 coming N ’ : , Creation Creation and Routledge D The . W ’ r , I . , . s nism nism E . , onde logics logics The The reaching reaching n : Catalogu 5(3)

’ , A , 19 (eds) (eds) Rolling Rolling

r in Guardia 1994 : P , : 368 . of 1978 O 79 Selective the P e Sound Sound – the the change , . – U 105 July: Ston 1980s 88 . n L public A ( . . W e R and , 25. : eekend 9

’ , M communities communities March : discograph Vision in in U the the S Simon Simon Section) I productio C : : The The

23 G E – Frith Musi 4. N , an R 22 y n d E c , 6 1