Breeding Bird Community Composition in Relation to Riparian Vegetation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AN ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS OF Todd Alan Sanders for the degree of Master of Science in Wildlife Science presented on May 12, 1995. Title: Breeding Bird Community Composition in Relation to Riparian Vegetation Structure in Grazed Habitats Abstract approved: Redacted for Privacy Riparian zones provide habitat for breeding birds in the semiarid western United States; however, there are few data available that address the effects of livestock grazing strategies on riparian habitats and avian communities. Documenting avian community composition in different riparian vegetation communities and relating vegetation communities to livestock grazing strategies may identify management alternatives that are sustainable from a wildlife habitat perspective, and may permit constructive coalitions between agricultural industry and environmental groups. I compared diurnal breeding bird abundance, individual species abundance, and species richness, and vegetation composition and structure among 12 streamside riparian areas of Bear and Silvies valleys in eastern Oregon during 1993 and 1994. Bird and vegetation data were collected along four replicate transects within each of three riparian vegetation communities characterized by vegetation structure: herbaceous, discontinuous willow (Salix spp.), and continuous willow. These riparian vegetation communities were grazed under summer season-long, summer short-duration, and fall short-duration livestock grazing strategies, respectively, >5 years before the study. Differences in riparian vegetation among communities were primarily related to shrub structure by experimental design. The continuous willow community had more shrub cover overall (P < 0.001) and within each 1-m height interval from 0-4 m (P < 0.013) than the herbaceous and discontinuous willow communities. The herbaceous community had no shrub cover >1 m in height. Willows extended farther (P = 0.031) from the steam edge in the continuous willow community than in the discontinuous willow community. No willows were detected in the herbaceous community. I detected 4,016 birds representing 56 species along the transects. Total bird abundance was greater (P < 0.001) in the continuous willow community than in the herbaceous and discontinuous willow communities. Species richness was inconsistent (P = 0.034) between years within communities; it was greatest (P < 0.037) in the continuous and discontinuous willow communities in 1993, and greatest (P < 0.003) in the continuous willow community in 1994. Total bird abundance and species richness in 1994 increased with willow volume (r2 > 0.707, P < 0.001). Of 23 bird species with >20 individual detections over both years, 13 species were most abundant in one or two vegetation communities (P < 0.088). Seven species (yellow warbler [Dendroica petechia], song sparrow [Melospiza melodia], willow flycatcher [Empidonax traillii], American robin [Turdus migratorius], common snipe [Gallinago gallinago], bobolink [Dolichonyx oryzivorus], and Vaux's swift [Chaetura vauxi]) were most abundant in the continuous willow community. Three species (savannah sparrow [Passerculus sandwichensis], black tern [Chlidonias niger], and American wigeon [Anas americana]) were most abundant in the herbaceous community. Willets (Catoptrophorus semipalmatus) were most abundant in the herbaceous and discontinuous willow communities whereas cinnamon teal (A. cyanoptera) were most abundant in the herbaceous and continuous willow communities. Red-winged blackbirds (Ageliaus phoeniceus) were inconsistent (P = 0.032) between years within communities: they were most abundant in the continuous willow community in 1993, and most abundant in the continuous willow and herbaceous communities in 1994. Hydrophytic woody vegetation within semiarid rangeland environments increases structural complexity and is associated with avian abundance and diversity. Yellow warblers, willow flycatchers, and song sparrows, which depend on hydrophytic shrubs for nesting almost exclusively in the semiarid West, are especially threatened by the elimination or simplification of woody riparian vegetation. I suggest that riparian vegetation structure and composition, which is associated with avian abundance, species richness, riparian associate bird species, and landscape-level biological diversity, be maintained where possible. Seasonal light (<30% use) fall short-duration grazing seemed to be compatible with the maintenance of woody riparian vegetation whereas summer season-long and summer short-duration grazing is likely incompatible. Copyright by Todd Alan Sanders May 12, 1995 All Rights Reserved BREEDING BIRD COMMUNITY COMPOSITION IN RELATION TO RIPARIAN VEGETATION STRUCTURE IN GRAZED HABITATS by Todd Alan Sanders A THESIS submitted to Oregon State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Completed May 12, 1995 Commencement June 1995 Master of Science thesis of Todd A. Sanders presented on May 12, 1995 Approved: Redacted for Privacy Major Professor, representing Fisheri and Wildlife Redacted for Privacy Head of Department of Fisheries a d Wildlife Redacted for Privacy Dean of Grad I understand that my thesis will become part of the permanent collection of Oregon State University libraries. My signature below authorizes release of my thesis to any reader upon request. Redacted for Privacy Todd A. Sanders, Author ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The completion of a Mastertof Science degree in Wildlife Science was one of my goals and long-time dreams. It is appropriate for me to begin by acknowledging those individuals who were instrumental in developing my ambition and desire to achieve this accomplishment. Instructor David Du Bose was a catalyst promoting the self-realization of my potential, aspiration, and quality of life. Thanks Dave for your friendship, the many sojourns, and chats about life. Additionally, U.S. Forest Service Fishery Biologist, Richard Irizzary gave me the opportunity to work as a Biological Technician in the early stages of my college education, enabling me to gain field experience in biology and to develop my interest in wildlife management. I am especially grateful to my major professor, W. Daniel Edge, for giving me the opportunity to work under his leadership and to further my education as a candidate for the degree of Master of Science. Dan was always available when I needed him whether at the office or at home. I am thankful for the time, interest, and support Dan provided. I am also thankful to graduate committee members professors J. Boone Kauffman and William C. McComb for their guidance, suggestions, and editorial comments throughout my program. Additional thanks to professor John P. Bolte for his willingness to serve as my Graduate Council Representative. I owe many thanks to Professor Fred L. Ramsey for his statistical guidance and suggestions as well as to Professor John C. Buckhouse for going out of his way to help me when he could. Sincere appreciation is extended to the Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education (SARE) program for providing the financial funding that made this research i project possible. I am additionally appreciative of the SARE Project Manager, Project Coordinator, Major Participants, County Extension Agents (especially Dr. Pete Test), and Graduate Research Assistants (see Preface) who provided support and feedback throughout the project. I will never forget the private ranch cooperators who volunteered their rangelands as the medium on which our research was conducted. Their willingness to cooperate, friendliness, and open communication provided the needed exposure to livestock ranching that was an invaluable opportunity in my education and research project. A special thanks to the Lemcke family for their hospitality and for providing a comfortable cabin to stay in during the field season. I will always be grateful to them for taking me in and teaching me about livestock ranching even when I may have seemed like a "city slicker." This research project also was made possible by dedicated Research Assistants Susan C. Danver, Rita-Lyn Sanders, and Dorothy G. Wilson. I am thankful for their optimism, hard work, and endurance even when weather conditions seemed less cooperative. I am forever thankful for my family and my wife's family, who provide the foundation of encouragement and support in all that I do. Again, I sincerely thank my wife, Rita-Lyn Sanders, for all that she has done in addition to her understanding, prayers, love, and continued support. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Subject Page INTRODUCTION 1 STUDY AREA 4 METHODS 9 Sampling Design 9 Vegetation Sampling 12 Bird Sampling 14 Data Analysis 15 RESULTS 21 Vegetation 21 Shrubs and Physical Habitat 21 Herbaceous and Other Ground Cover 25 Birds 28 DISCUSSION 41 Birds and Vegetation 41 Bird Abundance and Species Richness 41 Individual Species 42 Riparian Associate Bird Species 47 A Landscape-level Perspective 49 Vegetation and Livestock Grazing 50 Scope and Limitations 55 Biological Diversity and Sustainability 59 MANAGEMENT IMPLICATIONS 64 BIBLIOGRAPHY 68 APPENDICES 79 iii LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page, 1. Location of privately owned Bear and Silvies valleys bordered by the Malheur National Forest in eastern Oregon. 5 2. Mean monthly and cumulative precipitation recorded in Seneca, Oregon, averaged from 1961 to 1990 compared with the two years (1993, 1994) when data were collected for this study. 6 3. Mean monthly maximum and minimum ambient temperatures recorded in Seneca, Oregon, averaged from 1961 to 1990 compared