Iran's Role in Afghanistan in the Modern Era: Leveraging Influence for Regional Supremacy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Iran's Role in Afghanistan in the Modern Era: Leveraging Influence for Regional Supremacy Iran's Role in Afghanistan in the Modern Era: Leveraging Influence for Regional Supremacy Heather MacLeod Robinson This thesis is submitted in partial fulfilment for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) at the University of St Andrews February 2020 Contents Abstract .................................................................................................................................ii Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................... iv A Note on Transliteration ................................................................................................ v Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1 Overview and Objectives ............................................................................................................ 1 Methodology and Source Discussion .................................................................................... 5 Western Archival Sources .......................................................................................................... 6 Iranian and Afghan Primary Sources ................................................................................. 12 Media Materials and Databases ............................................................................................ 14 Chapter One: The Conceptual Framework for Iran’s Role in Afghanistan .. 16 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 16 ‘Myth of the Great Civilisation’ .............................................................................................. 20 ‘Myth of Foreign Domination’ ................................................................................................ 21 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................... 27 Chapter Two: Early Perso‐Afghan Relations and Great‐Power Domination of Iran and Afghanistan (1747‐1941) ...................................................................... 29 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 29 The Role of Afghanistan in Persia’s Fall from Regional Dominance ..................... 30 The Great Game: Great‐Power Competition and its Impact on Nineteenth Century Persian‐Afghan Relations ...................................................................................... 38 Persia, Afghanistan, and the Great Powers at the Turn of the Century ............... 52 Persia and Afghanistan Begin a Bilateral Relationship .............................................. 56 Reza Shah and the Formalization of Iranian‐Afghan Relations (1921‐41) ....... 61 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................... 70 Chapter Three: Iran’s Afghanistan Policy and Regional Leadership under Mohammad Reza Shah (1941‐1979) ........................................................................ 71 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 71 The Regional Dynamic: Great Power Competition for Influence ........................... 72 The Nixon Doctrine, Iran’s Western Alignment, and Iran’s Regional Primacy 76 The Afghanistan Problem ........................................................................................................ 80 Iran, the United States, and Soviet Encroachment in Afghanistan ........................ 87 The Afghan Coup of 1973 ........................................................................................................ 88 Leveraging the Coup with the Americans ........................................................................ 91 i Iranian Foreign Policy toward the Afghan Republic: 1973‐1978 .......................... 99 Pashtunistan, Baluchistan, and Dominating Daoud .................................................. 100 Iranian‐Afghan Rapprochement: Economic Aid and the Indian Ocean Cooperative ................................................................................................................................ 117 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 122 Chapter Four: Iran’s ‘Export of the Revolution’ to Afghanistan, 1982‐1987 ............................................................................................................................................. 124 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 124 Background ................................................................................................................................ 125 Developing Influence: Iran’s Strategy in Afghanistan from 1979‐1981 .......... 126 Early Political Support for the Afghan Mujahidin .................................................... 128 Early Material Support to the Afghan Mujahidin ...................................................... 135 Iran and Afghanistan’s Bilateral Relations Until 1982 ............................................ 141 Consolidating Control and Comparative Advantage: Iranian Influence in Afghanistan from 1982‐1987 ............................................................................................. 147 Iran’s Political Stance on Afghanistan: The Iranian ‘Proposal’ and the Geneva Accords .................................................................................................................................... 148 Iran’s Material Support for the Afghan Mujahidin—A Lesson in Exporting the Revolution ............................................................................................................................... 157 Domestic Conditions: The Rise of the Clerical Elite and the IRGC ................... 158 Iranian Base of Support for the Afghan Resistance: the Ulema Connection, Weaponisation of Refugees, and the Military Apparatus ........................................ 164 Iranian Support for the Afghanistan-based Resistance: the West and the Hazarajat .................................................................................................................................. 176 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 191 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 192 Bibliography ................................................................................................................... 202 Western Archival Sources .................................................................................................... 202 British Archival Records: ...................................................................................................... 202 American Archival Sources: ................................................................................................ 202 International Organizations Sources .............................................................................. 206 Select Iranian and Afghan Sources ................................................................................... 206 Western Secondary Sources ............................................................................................... 207 Media Sources ........................................................................................................................... 211 ii Abstract This dissertation provides an in-depth historical analysis of the motivations and actions surrounding Iran’s foreign policy toward Afghanistan in the modern era. The need for this research stems from a significant gap in Western scholarship on the Iranian-Afghan relationship that accounts for any period of the countries’ interactions in detail. It is argued here that despite rhetoric to the contrary, successive Iranian governments consistently pursued policies of political, military, and economic interference in Afghanistan as an integral part of Iran’s desire to achieve a dominant position of leadership in its region. This persistent approach has been grounded in both the historical experience and the mythology surrounding Iran’s once-great status as an empire, which was destroyed by the Afghans and the great powers during the colonial period, and the resultant Iranian irredentism toward Afghanistan that followed. In analysing the course of Iran’s policy toward Afghanistan, a defining feature is that it has never been divorced from Iran’s competition against the great powers that have continuously been involved in Afghanistan and the region. This work first provides a long-view historical context of the Iranian-Afghan relationship, which demonstrates that since Afghanistan separated from the Persian Empire in 1747, Afghanistan held an important place of relevance in the perpetuation of myths that underpin the persistent ideology of Iranian nationalism, which manifest in an Iranian foreign policy of interventionism toward Afghanistan. This, combined with the continued strategic importance of Afghanistan to the great powers
Recommended publications
  • Qutb Minar: Religion and Power in 13Th-Century India Professor Munis Faruqui (Department of South and Southeast Asian Studies, UC Berkeley)
    The Making of a Modern Myth Qutb Minar: Religion and Power in 13th-Century India Professor Munis Faruqui (Department of South and Southeast Asian Studies, UC Berkeley) I. Introduction India is the world’s largest democracy, and has the world’s second largest population of Muslims. Over the last few decades, deep religious divisions have appeared between the Hindu majority and the Muslim minority, who comprise 12–15 percent of the population. Extremists in either community have stoked violent religious conflict in ways that will be discussed shortly. Most of the violence in recent history has occurred in the form of pogroms. Most of the victims are Muslims. There are at least two critical threads that link contemporary anti-Muslim violence: first, a rising tide of Hindu nationalism. Second, much of the violence has been continuously stoked by rhetoricians’ use of an exaggerated and distorted history of endless conflict between these two groups—especially during the period when Muslim political authorities dominated northern India (c. 1200–1750). According to Hindu nationalists, the experience under the Muslims was oppressive, the Muslim rulers tyrannical, Hindu temples were destroyed, and so on. So the current anti- Muslim pogroms are payback, as the more extreme elements among the Hindu nationalists openly assert: attacking Muslims today is thus justified for what happened 500, 600, or 700 years ago. Like many groups elsewhere in the world, Hindu nationalists invoke history. Irish Republicanism invokes battles that happened in 1690 and so on. Groups in the Balkans are another example: Serbs, Croats, and Bosniacs have their own histories, and the 1389 battle of Kosovo becomes a central rallying cry for Serbian nationalism.
    [Show full text]
  • Afghanistan, 1989-1996: Between the Soviets and the Taliban
    Afghanistan, 1989-1996: Between the Soviets and the Taliban A thesis submitted to the Miami University Honors Program in partial fulfillment of the Requirements for University Honors with Distinction by, Brandon Smith May 2005 Oxford, OH ABSTRACT AFGHANISTAN, 1989-1996: BETWEEN THE SOVIETS AND THE TALIBAN by, BRANDON SMITH This paper examines why the Afghan resistance fighters from the war against the Soviets, the mujahideen, were unable to establish a government in the time period between the withdrawal of the Soviet army from Afghanistan in 1989 and the consolidation of power by the Taliban in 1996. A number of conflicting explanations exist regarding Afghanistan’s instability during this time period. This paper argues that the developments in Afghanistan from 1989 to 1996 can be linked to the influence of actors outside Afghanistan, but not to the extent that the choices and actions of individual actors can be overlooked or ignored. Further, the choices and actions of individual actors need not be explained in terms of ancient animosities or historic tendencies, but rather were calculated moves to secure power. In support of this argument, international, national, and individual level factors are examined. ii Afghanistan, 1989-1996: Between the Soviets and the Taliban by, Brandon Smith Approved by: _________________________, Advisor Karen L. Dawisha _________________________, Reader John M. Rothgeb, Jr. _________________________, Reader Homayun Sidky Accepted by: ________________________, Director, University Honors Program iii Thanks to Karen Dawisha for her guidance and willingness to help on her year off, and to John Rothgeb and Homayun Sidky for taking the time to read the final draft and offer their feedback.
    [Show full text]
  • COIN in Afghanistan - Winning the Battles, Losing the War?
    COIN in Afghanistan - Winning the Battles, Losing the War? MAGNUS NORELL FOI, Swedish Defence Research Agency, is a mainly assignment-funded agency under the Ministry of Defence. The core activities are research, method and technology development, as well as studies conducted in the interests of Swedish defence and the safety and security of society. The organisation employs approximately 1000 personnel of whom about 800 are scientists. This makes FOI Sweden’s largest research institute. FOI gives its customers access to leading-edge expertise in a large number of fields such as security policy studies, defence and security related analyses, the assessment of various types of threat, systems for control and management of crises, protection against and management of hazardous substances, IT security and the potential offered by new sensors. FOI Swedish Defence Research Agency Phone: +46 8 555 030 00 www.foi.se FOI Memo 3123 Memo Defence Analysis Defence Analysis Fax: +46 8 555 031 00 ISSN 1650-1942 March 2010 SE-164 90 Stockholm Magnus Norell COIN in Afghanistan - Winning the Battles, Losing the War? “If you don’t know where you’re going. Any road will take you there” (From a song by George Harrison) FOI Memo 3123 Title COIN in Afghanistan – Winning the Battles, Losing the War? Rapportnr/Report no FOI Memo 3123 Rapporttyp/Report Type FOI Memo Månad/Month Mars/March Utgivningsår/Year 2010 Antal sidor/Pages 41 p ISSN ISSN 1650-1942 Kund/Customer Försvarsdepartementet Projektnr/Project no A12004 Godkänd av/Approved by Eva Mittermaier FOI, Totalförsvarets Forskningsinstitut FOI, Swedish Defence Research Agency Avdelningen för Försvarsanalys Department of Defence Analysis 164 90 Stockholm SE-164 90 Stockholm FOI Memo 3123 Programme managers remarks The Asia Security Studies programme at the Swedish Defence Research Agency’s Department of Defence Analysis conducts research and policy relevant analysis on defence and security related issues.
    [Show full text]
  • Freedom Or Theocracy?: Constitutionalism in Afghanistan and Iraq Hannibal Travis
    Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights Volume 3 | Issue 1 Article 4 Spring 2005 Freedom or Theocracy?: Constitutionalism in Afghanistan and Iraq Hannibal Travis Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/njihr Recommended Citation Hannibal Travis, Freedom or Theocracy?: Constitutionalism in Afghanistan and Iraq, 3 Nw. J. Int'l Hum. Rts. 1 (2005). http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/njihr/vol3/iss1/4 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights by an authorized administrator of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. Copyright 2005 Northwestern University School of Law Volume 3 (Spring 2005) Northwestern University Journal of International Human Rights FREEDOM OR THEOCRACY?: CONSTITUTIONALISM IN AFGHANISTAN AND IRAQ By Hannibal Travis* “Afghans are victims of the games superpowers once played: their war was once our war, and collectively we bear responsibility.”1 “In the approved version of the [Afghan] constitution, Article 3 was amended to read, ‘In Afghanistan, no law can be contrary to the beliefs and provisions of the sacred religion of Islam.’ … This very significant clause basically gives the official and nonofficial religious leaders in Afghanistan sway over every action that they might deem contrary to their beliefs, which by extension and within the Afghan cultural context, could be regarded as
    [Show full text]
  • British Persian Studies and the Celebrations of the 2500Th Anniversary of the Founding of the Persian Empire in 1971
    British Persian Studies and the Celebrations of the 2500th Anniversary of the Founding of the Persian Empire in 1971 A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Master of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities. 2014 Robert Steele School of Arts, Languages and Cultures Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................................................ 4 Declaration .................................................................................................................................................................. 5 Copyright Statement ................................................................................................................................................ 5 Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................................................. 6 Introduction .......................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Objectives and Structure ............................................................................................................................................. 8 Literature Review .......................................................................................................................................................... 9 Statement on Primary Sources...............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Conflict in Afghanistan I
    Conflict in Afghanistan I 92 Number 880 December 2010 Volume Volume 92 Number 880 December 2010 Volume 92 Number 880 December 2010 Part 1: Socio-political and humanitarian environment Interview with Dr Sima Samar Chairperson of the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission Afghanistan: an historical and geographical appraisal William Maley Dynamic interplay between religion and armed conflict in Afghanistan Ken Guest Transnational Islamic networks Imtiaz Gul Impunity and insurgency: a deadly combination in Afghanistan Norah Niland The right to counsel as a safeguard of justice in Afghanistan: the contribution of the International Legal Foundation Jennifer Smith, Natalie Rea, and Shabir Ahmad Kamawal State-building in Afghanistan: a case showing the limits? Lucy Morgan Edwards The future of Afghanistan: an Afghan responsibility Conflict I in Afghanistan Taiba Rahim Humanitarian debate: Law, policy, action www.icrc.org/eng/review Conflict in Cambridge Journals Online For further information about this journal please go to the journal web site at: ISSN 1816-3831 http://www.journals.cambridge.org/irc Afghanistan I Editorial Team Editor-in-Chief: Vincent Bernard The Review is printed in English and is Editorial assistant: Michael Siegrist published four times a year, in March, Publication assistant: June, September and December. Claire Franc Abbas Annual selections of articles are also International Review of the Red Cross published on a regional level in Arabic, Aim and scope 19, Avenue de la Paix Chinese, French, Russian and Spanish. The International Review of the Red Cross is a periodical CH - 1202 Geneva, Switzerland published by the ICRC. Its aim is to promote reflection on t +41 22 734 60 01 Published in association with humanitarian law, policy and action in armed conflict and f +41 22 733 20 57 Cambridge University Press.
    [Show full text]
  • Dinamiche Etniche, Tribali E Politiche in Afghanistan
    Dinamiche etniche, tribali e politiche in Afghanistan n. 06 - gennaio 2010 a cura di Luca La Bella (Ce.S.I. Centro Studi Internazionali) OSSERVATORIO DI POLITICA INTERNAZIONALE Dinamiche etniche, tribali e politiche in Afghanistan n. 6 gennaio 2010 1 DINAMICHE ETNICHE, TRIBALI E POLITICHE IN AFGHANISTAN di Luca La Bella Fonte: elaborazione Ce.S.I. 2 SOMMARIO Introduzione p.3 Etnografia dell’Afghanistan p.4 Il panorama pashtun p.5 Le dinamiche nel mondo pashtun p.8 Il panorama tagiko p.15 Le altre componenti etniche p.20 La situazione nel settore italiano p.25 3 Introduzione La situazione afghana, caratterizzata da crescente instabilità politica - specie dopo la crisi elettorale che ha minato la legittimità di Karzai - e da un’insurrezione che dalle sue basi nel sud e nell’est del Paese si è ormai fermamente impiantata al nord e all’ovest, spinge gli attori internazionali alla ricerca di interlocutori locali affidabili, sia nell’ottica di trovare potenziali alternative a un governo impopolare e inefficace, sia nell’ottica di una possibile riconciliazione con quegli elementi dell’insurrezione più sensibili al dialogo. La sostenibilità delle operazioni militari e dei programmi di sviluppo e assistenza umanitaria alla popolazione dipende infatti dalla loro compatibilità con il tessuto etnico e tribale del Paese. Quanto più queste attività avvengono nel solco della cultura tribale e senza alterare gli equilibri etnici tradizionali tanto più esse avranno la possibilità di riuscire negli obiettivi prefissati. Al fine di armonizzare il rapporto degli attori internazionali (a livello politico, economico e militare) con le realtà afghane è necessario prendere in esame più dettagliatamente la composizione etnica e la struttura tribale dell’Afghanistan.
    [Show full text]
  • H.E. Abdullah Abdullah Discusses Peace Talks in Afghanistan United States Institute of Peace (Webcast Only) Wednesday, June 24, 2020 Transcript
    H.E. Abdullah Abdullah Discusses Peace Talks in Afghanistan United States Institute of Peace (Webcast Only) Wednesday, June 24, 2020 Transcript Nancy Lindborg: Good morning, good afternoon, good evening, depending on where you're viewing this livestream. My name is Nancy Lindborg and I am the president and CEO of the U.S. Institute of Peace. And I know there are viewers joining us from all around the world. We're delighted to have all of you here with us today for a very timely and important discussion. We're honored to have with us His Excellency Dr. Abdullah Abdullah, who has taken time at this very critical moment in the Afghan peace process to share how he and the High Council for National Reconciliation are preparing for talks with the Taliban. After the keynote address, we'll have a Q&A session moderated by USIP’s Vice President for Asia Dr. Andrew Wilder and we invite you to take part in this event by asking a question through the YouTube livestream in the comments section, and you can also engage with us and with each other on Twitter with today's hashtag #AfghanPeace. At USIP, supporting a sustainable peace process in Afghanistan has been a core priority, and I'm encouraged that in recent months there has been progress towards direct inter-Afghan negotiations. At the same time, violence is rising to unprecedented levels, including increasing and quite disturbing numbers of civilian casualties. And there are other challenges: COVID-19 has exacerbated the struggles that Afghans face, including contributing to increased food insecurity and extreme poverty.
    [Show full text]
  • We Take Pride in Jobs Well Done
    We take pride in jobs well done. JAGADAMBA PRESS #128 17 - 23 January 2003 16 pages Rs 25 [email protected] Tel: (01) 521393, 543017, 547018 Fax: (01) 536390 HEMLATA RAI, with JANAK NEPAL Manjushree in ○○○○○○○○○○○○ ○○○○○○○○ NEPALGANJ hoever killed their parents, the talks to Samrat children end up in the same place. W Sangita Yadav’s father was a farmer in Leave the kids alone Banke district. The Maoists came while he was the needs of those who are already affected.” Children recruited by eating, dragged him out of his house, beat and One of the undocumented aspects of the tortured him in front of his family, and killed Maoists to carry their conflict is the growing number of internally him. Sarala Dahal’s father was a teacher in the rucksacks rest at a tea displaced families. This has increased the same district. He was killed after surrendering house in Kalikot number of children in the district headquarters, to the security forces. district in June. townships and in Kathmandu Valley who have Sarala and Sangita are both being raised in a lost their traditional village support Novelist Manjushree Thapa, author of the child shelter which has just opened in mechanisms. School closures and threats of much-acclaimed The Tutor of History has Nepalganj by the charity group, Sahara. “We forced recruitment of one child per family by a cyber-chat with fellow-author and don’t really care who killed their parents or Maoists have added to the influx of children. A compatriot, Samrat Upadhyay who has relatives, we want to protect the future of these recent survey in the insurgency hotbed of just published his second book, The Guru children, and they all get equal care here,” says Rukum alone found that out of 1,000 people of Love in the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • CAPSTONE 20-1 SWA Field Study Trip Book Part II
    CAPSTONE 20-1 SWA Field Study Trip Book Part II Subject Page Afghanistan ................................................................ CIA Summary ......................................................... 2 CIA World Fact Book .............................................. 3 BBC Country Profile ............................................... 24 Culture Gram .......................................................... 30 Kazakhstan ................................................................ CIA Summary ......................................................... 39 CIA World Fact Book .............................................. 40 BBC Country Profile ............................................... 58 Culture Gram .......................................................... 62 Uzbekistan ................................................................. CIA Summary ......................................................... 67 CIA World Fact Book .............................................. 68 BBC Country Profile ............................................... 86 Culture Gram .......................................................... 89 Tajikistan .................................................................... CIA World Fact Book .............................................. 99 BBC Country Profile ............................................... 117 Culture Gram .......................................................... 121 AFGHANISTAN GOVERNMENT ECONOMY Chief of State Economic Overview President of the Islamic Republic of recovering
    [Show full text]
  • Nixon, Kissinger, and the Shah: the Origins of Iranian Primacy in the Persian Gulf
    Roham Alvandi Nixon, Kissinger, and the Shah: the origins of Iranian primacy in the Persian Gulf Article (Accepted version) (Refereed) Original citation: Alvandi, Roham (2012) Nixon, Kissinger, and the Shah: the origins of Iranian primacy in the Persian Gulf. Diplomatic history, 36 (2). pp. 337-372. ISSN 1467-7709 DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-7709.2011.01025.x © 2012 The Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations (SHAFR) This version available at: http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/32743/ Available in LSE Research Online: March 2012 LSE has developed LSE Research Online so that users may access research output of the School. Copyright © and Moral Rights for the papers on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. Users may download and/or print one copy of any article(s) in LSE Research Online to facilitate their private study or for non-commercial research. You may not engage in further distribution of the material or use it for any profit-making activities or any commercial gain. You may freely distribute the URL (http://eprints.lse.ac.uk) of the LSE Research Online website. This document is the author’s final manuscript accepted version of the journal article, incorporating any revisions agreed during the peer review process. Some differences between this version and the published version may remain. You are advised to consult the publisher’s version if you wish to cite from it. roham alvandi Nixon, Kissinger, and the Shah: The Origins of Iranian Primacy in the Persian Gulf* On the morning of May 31, 1972, the shah of Iran, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, received U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release Bytro Labs Cooperates with Sponsorpay Freiburg, 09/09/09
    Bytro Labs UG (haftungsbeschränkt) Stefan-Meier-Str. 8 79104 Freiburg +49 761 203 5462 [email protected] Press release Bytro Labs cooperates with SponsorPay Freiburg, 09/09/09: Users of the strategy game “Supremacy 1914” can now earn in-game currency using the SponsorPay platform. The SponsorPay platform serves as a monetisation tool for social games & apps, online games and virtual worlds, as well as for other publishers who have integrated virtual currency or premium features. Instead of paying with their own money, players can complete one of the numerous offers from SponsorPay’s advertising partners and get Supremacy 1914 Goldmarks for free in return. “SponsorPay convinced us with their strict policy for selecting advertising partners. We believe, that with the integration of SponsorPay we can achieve a sustainable increase of revenue.” comments Felix Faber, Co-Founder and CEO of Bytro Labs on the cooperation. About SponsorPay SponsorPay GmbH, which is seated in Berlin Mitte, was founded by Team Europe Ventures, Jan Beckers and Janis Zech and is currently employing 25 people. SponsorPay serves Germany, Austria, Switzerland, the U.K., France, Spain, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, Poland, Russia, the US, Canada and Turkey with native country managers and a localized product. Through their partners SponsorPay is able to reach more than 10 million users throughout Europe. About Supremacy 1914: Supremacy 1914 – Become the leader of a nation and conquer Europe In Supremacy 1914, the player becomes head of a mighty nation in precarious Europe after the turn of the century. He faces the challenge to become the undisputed sovereign leader of the whole continent using smart diplomacy or simply the brute force of his glorious armies.
    [Show full text]