Produced by the Human Security Centre Lead Author
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 Human Security Centre – Written evidence (AFG0019) Produced by the Human Security Centre Lead Author: Simon Schofield, Senior Fellow, In consultation with Rohullah Yakobi, Associate Fellow 2 1 Table of Contents 2. Executive Summary .............................................................................5 3. What is the Human Security Centre?.....................................................10 4. Geopolitics and National Interests and Agendas......................................11 Islamic Republic of Pakistan ...................................................................11 Historical Context...............................................................................11 Pakistan’s Strategy.............................................................................12 Support for the Taliban .......................................................................13 Afghanistan as a terrorist training camp ................................................16 Role of military aid .............................................................................17 Economic interests .............................................................................19 Conclusion – Pakistan .........................................................................19 Islamic Republic of Iran .........................................................................20 Historical context ...............................................................................20 Iranian Strategy ................................................................................23 Economic interests .............................................................................24 Water ...............................................................................................25 Support for the Taliban .......................................................................26 Militant recruitment ............................................................................28 Revolutionary Guard...........................................................................28 Conclusion - Iran ...............................................................................29 Republic of India...................................................................................31 Historical context ...............................................................................31 India’s strategy..................................................................................33 Counterterrorism ...............................................................................33 Support for Kabul...............................................................................35 Engagement with the Taliban? .............................................................35 Kashmir............................................................................................36 Relations with Iran .............................................................................37 Trade Routes .....................................................................................37 Conclusion - India ..............................................................................39 The United States of America .................................................................40 Historical Context...............................................................................40 American Interests and Strategy ..........................................................41 Conclusion - USA ...............................................................................42 The Russian Federation..........................................................................43 3 Historical context ...............................................................................43 Russian Strategy................................................................................46 Opposing Western interests .................................................................47 Counterterrorism ...............................................................................48 Establishing ‘power broker’ credentials ..................................................49 Building influence...............................................................................51 Counternarcotics ................................................................................52 Conclusion - Russia ............................................................................53 People’s Republic of China......................................................................54 Historical Context...............................................................................54 Chinese Strategy ...............................................................................55 Counterterrorism ...............................................................................55 Economic development .......................................................................57 World power status ............................................................................59 Conclusion - China .............................................................................61 5. Doha Agreement .............................................................................62 Concerns about the Agreement ............................................................62 The Taliban and terrorism ...................................................................62 Waziristan example ............................................................................66 Conclusion – Doha Agreement .............................................................68 6. Conclusion - Recommendations for British policy towards Afghanistan ....69 4 And I know too - I know too that there is a wariness. I know that it feels as if we have carried these burdens long enough. But we can only know that there is no choice, because one of two things will happen if we don't lead. Either no one will lead and there will be chaos, or someone will fill the vacuum who does not share our values. ~ Condoleezza Rice, United States Secretary of State (2005- 2009), United States National Security Advisor (2001-2005) 5 2.Executive Summary 2.1Following the withdrawal of American troops from Afghanistan, there will be a power vacuum which a number of powers will attempt to fill in order to further their own interests and undermine those of their rivals. This document has sought to set out the various interests and strategies that the most prominent regional powers will pursue. 2.2Due to its geographic proximity, the fact that Pashtun communities straddle the Durand Line, and Islamabad’s strong influence over the Taliban, Pakistan is, and is likely to remain, the single most impactful external power on the affairs of Afghanistan. Whether it seeks to install a friendly Taliban-led Government in Kabul, or prefers a lighter-touch approach of maintaining a frozen conflict in Afghanistan, Islamabad’s primary objective is to oppose New Delhi’s influence and to build ‘strategic depth’ as a bulwark against Indian encirclement. Pakistan sees the balance of its own interests in Afghanistan against those of India in zero-sum terms. Other important goals include preserving the territorial integrity of Pakistan, particularly against Baloch and Pashtun independence movements along the Afghan border, and pursuing economic interests, most notably to secure its energy supplies. 2.3Iran’s strategy and interests in Afghanistan are ambiguous. However, Tehran will have three options with respect to their relationship with the Taliban. Firstly, Tehran can continue to fund the Taliban in order to fight and overthrow the Kabul Government, which it sees as an American client. Secondly, Tehran can support a political settlement which leads to a more federal Afghanistan, allowing for quasi-autonomous governance along ethnic lines, which would limit Taliban influence to Pashtun areas, and carve out its own sphere of influence in the Hazarajat, Herat, and other Tajik and Persian- speaking communities. Thirdly, Tehran may decide to attempt to maintain a frozen conflict in Afghanistan, which would lead to the attrition of both the Taliban and the Kabul Government, as well as maintaining fertile recruiting grounds to continue to swell the ranks of its volunteer forces, such as the Fatemiyoun Brigade, for which it recruits in Afghanistan and has deployed to fight on its behalf in Syria. 2.4Iran rejected the Doha Agreement brokered between the United States and the Taliban, stating that it had no legal standing and branding it as an American exercise to ‘legitimize its troops’ presence in Afghanistan’. Given that the new Quds Force commander Ismail Qa’ani has a strong background operating in and around Afghanistan, there is a strong chance that Iran will work to undermine the Doha process set out in the agreement, seeking to inflict political damage on the United States. Iran will have the further choice of whether to pursue stability to prevent potentially large refugee flows and a civil war that could spill over its borders, or to foment instability and reap the 6 benefits of guaranteed flows of water, black market currency, and Shi’a militants. At the time of writing it would appear that Iran is ‘keeping its options open’. 2.5India currently finds itself with constrained options. Having been pushed out of Chabahar by China, facing airspace bans from Pakistan, and with the requirement for eastern routes to travel through either Pakistani-occupied Kashmir or China, India’s access northwards to Afghanistan and Central Asia is greatly