Dissertation Achille Castaldo Final Submission
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Narrative Experience and Social Conflict. Italy, France, 1943-1977 by Achille Castaldo Department of Romance Studies Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Roberto Dainotto, Advisor ___________________________ Anne-Gaëlle Saliot ___________________________ David Bell ___________________________ Michael Hardt Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Romance Studies in the Graduate School of Duke University 2019 ABSTRACT Narrative Experience and Social Conflict. Italy, France, 1943-1977 by Achille Castaldo Department of Romance Studies Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Roberto Dainotto, Advisor ___________________________ Anne-Gaëlle Saliot ___________________________ David Bell ___________________________ Michael Hardt An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Romance Studies in the Graduate School of Duke University 2019 Copyright by Achille Castaldo 2019 Abstract This dissertation investigates the relation between narrative forms, in both literature and cinema, and historical moments of deep crisis of the social order: the interregnum between Fascism and First Republic in Italy; the decolonization process in Algeria seen from metropolitan France; and the worker and student struggles of the Sixties and the Seventies. The goal of my analysis is to show how a traumatic reality can fracture the ideological discourse dominant in a specific historical moment, leaving a mark on the structural and formal (rhetorical) construction of the work of art. My analysis begins with Naples immediately after World War II, by focusing on the works of Curzio Malaparte and Anna Maria Ortese. I then move to Paris in the aftermath of the Algerian War, to analyze the early films of Éric Rohmer, Chris Marker, Guy Debord, and Agnès Varda. My investigation proceeds by examining workers’ struggles in Northern Italy in Vogliamo tutto by Nanni Balestrini and ends in Bologna during the years of the ’77 revolt, where Pier Vittorio Tondelli’s early work dramatizes the communal existence of the student-worker movement. My method is based on a formal analysis of devices of disruption of the mimetic flow: anomalous use of pronouns, fragmentation, tension between verb tenses, and disconnections of the point of view. All are features through which the historical moment, I argue, is inscribed in the reading-viewing experience. iv Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................... viii Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 1 1. Curzio Malaparte, Anna Maria Ortese. Excessive Reality and Literary Experience ....... 17 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 17 1.1 Curzio Malaparte’s La pelle. Extreme experience and the rhetoric of interruption ................................................................................................................................................. 21 1.1.1 Expérience-limite and the principle of disconnection .......................................... 21 1.1.2 From Kaputt to La pelle. The theme of the plague and the iconography of the Triumph of Death .................................................................................................................. 30 1.1.3 Disruption of the mimetic flow and compensatory imagination (a structural analysis of the Pendino episode). ...................................................................................... 39 1.2 Anna Maria Ortese’s Il mare non bagna Napoli: Intensity, interruption, liminal spaces. ..................................................................................................................................... 60 1.2.1 Neapolitan ideology and the “fear of the plebs” .................................................. 61 1.2.2 Things that really happened ......................................................................................... 78 1.2.3 Devices of disconnection and intensification in “Oro a Forcella” and “Il silenzio della ragione” ....................................................................................................... 87 2 The Algerian War did not take place. Colonial imaginary and its subversion in French cinema at the time of the Algerian “events”: the cases of Éric Rohmer, Guy Debord, Chris Marker, and Agnès Varda. ............................................................................................ 110 Introduction. “Il faut du recul” ........................................................................................ 110 2.1 Censorship ..................................................................................................................... 115 v 2.2 The Algerian War did not take place ......................................................................... 127 2.3 Ideological figuration in Rohmer’s first two Moral Tales: “voice of memory,” swerve of the image, and colonial fantasies. .................................................................. 134 2.4 Sans mémoire. Le Joli mai as refusal of ideological memory ................................. 161 2.5 A politics of “clandestinity” in Guy Debord’s Sur le passage and Critique de la séparation ............................................................................................................................ 171 2.6 Catastrophe, Everydayness, “Clandestinity”: Le Signe du Lion ........................... 191 2.7 Cléo de 5 à 7: beyond the script of the self ................................................................ 210 3 “How one lives within the subversive intention:” Problems of political narrative in Balestrini’s first two novels ...................................................................................................... 218 Introduction. From Tristano to Vogliamo tutto. ............................................................ 218 3.1 Novel of the Theory: Tristano ..................................................................................... 223 3.2 “The anxiety for a yet-to-come era”: The influence of Workerism on We Want Everything ........................................................................................................................... 240 3.3 Autonomy as a formative principle ........................................................................... 266 3.4 Novel and epic as ideological figures ........................................................................ 276 3.5 Lukács’ romance as subversion of tragic and novelistic form ............................... 286 3.6 Dostoevsky’s “epic” as figure of aesthetics-politics conversion ............................ 296 3.7 Catharsis as experience of “radical depersonalization” ......................................... 304 3.8 Vogliamo tutto .............................................................................................................. 312 Epilogue. ..................................................................................................................................... 328 The Obscene Community: Pier Vittorio Tondelli’s writing and the experience of ’77 ... 328 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 328 vi 1 Obscenity and the “third eye” ....................................................................................... 330 2. Communal experience and narrative function .......................................................... 334 3. Adolescent style .............................................................................................................. 339 4. The obscene object of community ................................................................................ 350 5. The separate room .......................................................................................................... 353 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 357 References ................................................................................................................................... 363 Films cited .................................................................................................................................. 374 vii Acknowledgements Parts of Chapter 2 have been reworked for the journal article “Ideological figuration in Rohmer’s first two Moral Tales: ‘voice of memory’, clinamen of the image, and colonial fantasies,” that has been accepted for publication on “Studies in French Cinema.” The article is already accessible in Preview Online: https://doi.org/10.1080/14715880.2018.1511031 viii Introduction Anna Maria Ortese’s Il porto di Toledo was dedicated since its first edition (1975) to somebody named Anne Hurdle. In a prefatory note added to the 1998 edition, written a few days before her death, Ortese explained who this woman was. Briefly mentioned by Benjamin Constant