DOCSLIB.ORG

Exploring Maternal Birthplace and Child Gender Disparities in Markers of Neglect and Maltreatment Among Young Children of Immigrants

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Exploring Maternal Birthplace and Child Gender Disparities in Markers of Neglect and Maltreatment Among Young Children of Immigrants Exploring maternal birthplace and child gender disparities in markers of neglect and maltreatment among young children of immigrants by Ariel Pulver A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Epidemiology Dalla Lana School of Public Health University of Toronto © Copyright by Ariel Pulver June 2019 Exploring maternal birthplace and child gender disparities in markers of neglect and maltreatment among young children of immigrants Ariel Pulver Doctor of Philosophy in Epidemiology Dalla Lana School of Public Health University of Toronto 2019 Abstract Significant immigration to Canada has brought many cultures and parenting practices together, highlighting differences in child health and wellbeing. Given the increasingly large amount of migration from countries with high gender inequality, it is unknown how parental immigration interacts with child gender to affect healthcare and wellbeing in early childhood. In this dissertation, I present four studies regarding variation in routine preventive health care and maltreatment in very early childhood by maternal birthplace and child gender. The first study is a scoping review where I mapped the use of gender-based analysis in research on the health of children in immigrant families. I found that child gender is an understudied aspect of immigrant children’s health, thereby presenting an opportunity for further research. Next, in three population-based retrospective cohort studies, I compared the risk of three markers of child health care and well-being across immigrant maternal birthplaces in comparison to mothers born in Canada—immunizations, well-child visits at 24 months, and early child maltreatment at five years of age. To explore whether son preference affects child routine preventive care and maltreatment, I also compared outcomes between daughters and sons within families. ii I demonstrate that children of immigrants are well cared for concerning routine immunizations and are less likely to experience maltreatment in early childhood than children of non- immigrants. Maternal birthplaces associated with high levels of gender inequity do not seem to place daughters at risk of adverse outcomes compared to sons, except for a select case. Results support addressing vaccine hesitancy and child maltreatment in the general population to promote well-being in early childhood, as well as select targeted approaches among specific immigrant groups. My studies provide a model (including data sources, study design, and analytic techniques) to monitor and detect gender inequality in the general population as well as among minority groups. My research adds to the evidence around gender equity, which will hopefully ensure girls continue to achieve the same level of health care and well-being as boys. iii Table of Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................................................... ii List of Tables .............................................................................................................................................. vii List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................ viii List of Appendices ....................................................................................................................................... ix Dissertation Overview .................................................................................................................................. x Dissertation Layout ...................................................................................................................................... xi Chapter 1 Literature Review and Rationale .......................................................................................... 1 1.1 Global gender inequity and the phenomenon of missing girls ...................................................... 1 1.2 Global gender disparities in child healthcare and well-being ....................................................... 2 1.3 Sex Ratios among Immigrant Populations .................................................................................... 5 1.4 Gender disparities in young immigrant children’s health ............................................................. 6 1.5 Markers of child health care and well-being ................................................................................. 6 1.5.1 Immunizations ....................................................................................................................... 7 1.5.2 Well-child visits .................................................................................................................... 7 1.5.3 Child abuse and maltreatment ............................................................................................... 8 1.6 Health and well-being among children of immigrants .................................................................. 9 1.7 Terminology ................................................................................................................................ 11 1.8 Gender-based Analysis ............................................................................................................... 13 1.9 Rationale and Objectives of Dissertation Studies ....................................................................... 13 1.10 My role in this work .................................................................................................................... 17 1.11 References ................................................................................................................................... 18 Chapter 2, Study 1: A Scoping Review of Female Disadvantage in Health Care Use Among Very Young Children of Immigrant Families ...................................................................................................... 25 2.1 Abstract ....................................................................................................................................... 26 2.2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 27 2.2.1 Gender inequity in children’s health around the world ....................................................... 27 2.2.2 Gender inequity in immigrant children’s health ................................................................. 28 2.2.3 Theoretical Framework ....................................................................................................... 29 2.3 Methods....................................................................................................................................... 30 2.3.1 Search Strategy ................................................................................................................... 30 2.3.2 Screening & Data Management .......................................................................................... 31 2.3.3 Quality Assessment ............................................................................................................. 33 2.4 Results ......................................................................................................................................... 34 iv 2.4.1 Characteristics of the Studies .............................................................................................. 34 2.4.2 Study Populations ............................................................................................................... 35 2.4.3 Consideration of Immigrant Status ..................................................................................... 36 2.4.4 Consideration of Gender and the Use of Statistical Comparisons ...................................... 37 2.4.5 Health Care Utilization Outcomes ...................................................................................... 37 2.4.6 Gender-Specific Reports of Study Outcomes ..................................................................... 38 2.4.7 Quality Assessment ............................................................................................................. 40 2.5 Discussion ................................................................................................................................... 41 2.5.1 Importance of Gender-Based Analysis ............................................................................... 42 2.5.2 Methodological Considerations for Health Care Research of Immigrant Children ............ 43 2.5.3 Strengths and Limitations of the Study ............................................................................... 46 2.5.4 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 49 2.6 References ................................................................................................................................... 51 Chapter 3, Study 2: Differences in the receipt of infant preventive primary care among Ontario-born children across varied maternal countries of birth ...................................................................................... 64 3.1 Abstract ....................................................................................................................................... 65 3.2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Getting by High School: Identity Formation and the Educational Achievements of Punjabi Young Men in Surrey, B.C
    GETTING BY HIGH SCHOOL: IDENTITY FORMATION AND THE EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENTS OF PUNJABI YOUNG MEN IN SURREY, B.C. by HEATHER DANIELLE FROST M.A., The University of Toronto, 2002 B.A., The University of Toronto, 2000 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (Geography) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) December 2010 © Heather Danielle Frost, 2010 Abstract This thesis is concerned with the lives and educational achievements of young Indo-Canadians, specifically the high school aged sons of Punjabi parents who immigrated to Canada beginning in the 1970s, and who were born or who have had the majority of their schooling in Canada‟s public school system. I examine how these young people develop and articulate a sense of who they are in the context of their parents‟ immigration and the extent to which their identities are determined and conditioned by their everyday lives. I also grapple with the implications of identity formation for the educational achievements of second generation youth by addressing how the identity choices made by young Punjabi Canadian men influence their educational performances. Using data collected by the Ministry of Education of British Columbia, I develop a quantitative profile of the educational achievements of Punjabi students enrolled in public secondary schools in the Greater Vancouver Region. This profile indicates that while most Punjabi students are completing secondary school, many, particularly the young men, are graduating with grade point averages at the lower end of the continuum and are failing to meet provincial expectations in Foundation Skills Assessments.
    [Show full text]
  • Voice Online
    12/8/2020 New project to showcase Punjabi Canadian history in B.C. | Indo-Canadian Voice https://voiceonline.com/new-project-to-showcase-punjabi-canadian-history-in-b-c/ New project to showcase Punjabi Canadian history in B.C. By ​posted by: Rattan Mall ​- September 3, 2020 ​BRITISH Columbia is celebrating the contributions of the Punjabi Canadian community to its economy, history and culture through the development of new educational supports, exhibits and online resources. The project is part of the Province’s commitment to creating a welcoming and inclusive society. “The Punjabi community has a long and unique history that has contributed significantly to the strength and success of our province,” said Premier John Horgan. “The Punjabi Canadian Legacy Project will share these stories with future generations, while honouring the resilience and diversity of our multicultural communities.” 12/8/2020 New project to showcase Punjabi Canadian history in B.C. | Indo-Canadian Voice https://voiceonline.com/new-project-to-showcase-punjabi-canadian-history-in-b-c/ Premier John Horgan (3rd from left) discussing the project with MLA George Chow (1st from left) and UFV’s Satwinder Kaur Bains (2nd from left). The Province is providing $1.14 million to the Abbotsford Community Foundation to create and deliver Haq and History: A Punjabi Canadian Legacy Project in collaboration with the South Asian Studies Institute of the University of the Fraser Valley and other community partners. Haq and History reflects on the right of Punjabi Canadians in British Columbia to record their vast and significant history, correct and enhance the public educational and historical records, and create community legacies that extend beyond the current time for future generations.
    [Show full text]
  • Download The
    BECOMING SIKH: SIKH YOUTH IDENTITIES AND THE MULTICULTURAL IMAGINARY by KALBIR HEER B.A., University College of the Cariboo, 1998 B.Ed., The University of British Columbia, 1999 M.A., Gonzaga University, 2005 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in The Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies (Educational Studies) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) March 2018 ©Kalbir Heer, 2018 Abstract This dissertation explores the lives of second and third generation Sikh youth in the Greater Vancouver area in relation to the ways they think about their identities. As racialized youth growing up in a major Canadian urban center, being situated within an array of various ethnic, racial, religious, and gender differences plays an important role in how participants recognize what it means to be Sikh, and the potential to become differently. Particularly relevant in this study is an investigation into the ways competing discourses of multiculturalism both facilitates the way participants “do” their identities, and also shapes the ways Sikh youth come to (mis)recognize the multicultural “others”. Through small group and individual interviews, youth theorizing on the repetition, regulation and re-signification of identity categories is explored. Relying significantly on Judith Butler's theory of performativity, and Michel Foucault’s discussions of discourse, knowledge, and power, multiculturalism is taken up as an important societal discourse which requires racialized youth to perform their identities in everyday multicultural context such as schools. In other words, multiculturalism is theorized beyond policy and curriculum debates to investigate how youth “do multiculturalism” in different contexts through various embodied practices which constitute and regulate claims to a Sikh identity.
    [Show full text]
  • The Punjabi Experience in British Columbia
    Lesson Plan – Secondary Educator Hannah Morales Rationale: This lesson plan is a companion to the Indo Canadian oral history collections compiled by the Centre for Indo Canadian Studies at the University of the Fraser Valley found on the Royal BC Museum Learning Portal pathway, The Punjabi Experience in British Columbia. These interviews outline the Punjabi experience of immigrating and adapting to Canada. This lesson invites students to use the oral histories collection to gain better understanding of the culture and everyday life of Punjabi immigrants through these first-hand accounts. Curriculum Connections: Grade 9 Social Studies Social Studies Content: Global demographic shifts, including patterns of migration and population growth; local, regional, and global conflicts; discriminatory policies, attitudes, and historical wrongs Grade 10 Social Studies Big Ideas: Global and regional conflicts have been a powerful force in shaping our contemporary world and identities; Historical and contemporary injustices challenge the narrative and identity of Canada as an inclusive, multicultural society. Content: Canadian identities; discriminatory policies and injustices in Canada and the world Grade 910 Social Studies Curricular Competencies: Assess the significance of people, places, events, or developments, and compare varying perspectives on their historical significance at particular times and places, and from group to group; Assess the justification for competing historical accounts after investigating points of contention, reliability
    [Show full text]
  • The Punjabi Experience in British Columbia
    The Punjabi Experience in British Columbia Lesson Plan – Elementary Educator Hannah Morales Rationale: This lesson plan is a companion to the Indo Canadian oral history collections compiled by the Centre for Indo Canadian Studies at the University of the Fraser Valley found on the Royal BC Museum Learning Portal pathway, The Punjabi Experience in British Columbia. These interviews outline the Punjabi experience of immigrating and adapting to Canada. This lesson invites students to use the oral histories collection to gain better understanding of the culture and everyday life of Punjabi immigrants through these first-hand accounts. Curriculum Connections: Grade 2 6 Social Studies Curricular Competencies: Ask questions, corroborate inferences, and draw conclusions about the content and origins of a variety of sources Grade 2 Social Studies Big Ideas: Canada is made up of many diverse regions and communities Content: Diverse characteristics of communities and cultures in Canada and around the world Grade 3 Social Studies Content: Aspects of life shared by and common to peoples and cultures Grade 4 Social Studies Big Ideas: The pursuit of valuable natural resources has played a key role in changing the land, people, and communities of Canada. Content: The history of the local community 1 Grade 5 Social Studies Big Ideas: Canada’s policies and treatment of minority peoples have negative and positive legacies; Natural resources continue to shape the economy and identity of different regions of Canada; Immigration and multiculturalism continue
    [Show full text]
  • 121 Book Reviews Ravinder Kaur, Since 1947. Partition Narratives Among Punjabi Migrants of Delhi, (Delhi: Oxford University Pres
    121 Book Reviews Ravinder Kaur, Since 1947. Partition Narratives among Punjabi Migrants of Delhi, (Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2007) vii + 277 pp. (hb) Rs.910. ISBN-13: 978-0-19-568377-6 and ISBN10:0195683773. Born of Punjabi parents who migrated from Lahore and Rawalpindi in 1947 and then from Delhi in the 1960s, I have grown up hearing stories of how my family lived through Partition and built their future in the period that followed it. These are the types of stories that Ravinder Kaur sets out to elucidate in her book, Since 1947. Her ethnographic investigation looks at the interaction between the Indian state and Punjabi refugees in Delhi until 1965, the year the Ministry of Rehabilitation was finally shut. The book sets out to question the master narrative of Partition. This master narrative is not, as might be expected, simply the official public memory constructed and reinforced by the state. Rather, it is the most popular and enduring narrative of Partition rehabilitation, a narrative which actually diminishes the agency of the state in the whole account. It is the story of the hardworking and enterprising Punjabis who arrived in Delhi, fresh from the trauma of Partition, and energetically set about transforming their uprooted and dilapidated position to one of economic success. They seemingly lifted themselves out of homelessness and economic hardship through their shared Punjabi traits of strength and tenacity. There are many variations of this narrative including the equally popular disgust at the ‘Punjabification’ of Delhi aired amid the chattering classes of the capital, but as a narrative of the rehabilitation of refugees it is widely held and unquestioned.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Inequality and Class Consciousness in the Canadian Sikh Diaspora Harmeet S
    CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Scholarship@Western Western University Scholarship@Western MA Research Paper Sociology Department October 2016 Beyond the Land of Five Rivers: Social Inequality and Class Consciousness in the Canadian Sikh Diaspora Harmeet S. Sandhu [email protected], [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/sociology_masrp Part of the Sociology Commons Recommended Citation Sandhu, Harmeet S., "Beyond the Land of Five Rivers: Social Inequality and Class Consciousness in the Canadian Sikh Diaspora" (2016). MA Research Paper. 9. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/sociology_masrp/9 This Dissertation/Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Sociology Department at Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in MA Research Paper by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. BEYOND THE LAND OF FIVE RIVERS: SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND CLASS CONSCIOUSNESS IN THE CANADIAN SIKH DIASPORA by Harmeet Singh Sandhu A research paper accepted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of Sociology The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario, Canada Supervisor: Dr. Anton Allahar 2016 ABSTRACT Romanticized visions of Khalistan became emotively embedded in the hearts and minds of Sikh-Canadians following the execution of Operation Blue Star. Today, insurgents residing within the contested homeland continue to draw support from Sikh immigrants and their Canadian-born descendants. Perplexingly, while a sizable proportion of second and third-generation Sikh youth advocate for the creation of the theocratic state of Khalistan, many selectively disregard the righteous way of life envisioned by the founders of the Khalsa Panth.
    [Show full text]
  • Code-Switching in the Maintenance of Punjabi in the Lower Mainland
    CODE-SWITCHING IN THE MAINTENANCE OF PUNJABI IN THE LOWER MAINLAND by Jasmine Kaur Sandher A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in The Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies (Asian Studies) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) April 2019 © Jasmine Kaur Sandher, 2019 The following individuals certify that they have read, and recommend to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies for acceptance, the thesis entitled: Code-Switching in the Maintenance of Punjabi in the Lower Mainland submitted by Jasmine Sandher in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts In Asian Studies Examining Committee: Dr. Anne Murphy, Asian Studies Co-supervisor Dr. Ross King, Asian Studies Co-supervisor Sukwant Hundal, Asian Studies Additional Examiner ii Abstract Punjabi language is widely used throughout the Lower Mainland, BC. It is the third most spoken immigrant language after Mandarin and Cantonese. Although Canada’s Official Bilingualism policy promotes English and French as official languages, many accommodations are made for immigrant languages such as Punjabi. As a result, it continues to thrive. Due to the close proximity of the two languages, Punjabi commonly makes use of English through code-switching. The use of code-switching is looked at in this thesis through an analysis of Lower Mainland radio and Bhangra music. The data for this project has been collected through listening to and transcribing radio segments and music lyrics. The data utilized was collected from two programs, Roshni and Punjabi Takeover, which both air on RED FM, a Surrey based Punjabi radio station.
    [Show full text]
  • Dissertations and Theses on Heritage Language Education 2000-2012
    Dissertation and Thesis Abstracts on Heritage Language Education 2000- 2012 Compiled by Corinne Seals, Na Liu, and Sarah Moore The Alliance for the Advancement of Heritage Languages Center for Applied Linguistics This document contains a comprehensive list, including abstracts, of English language dissertations and theses on the topic of heritage language education written from 2000 through April 2012. Dissertations and theses are arranged by language studied and then sorted by author’s last name. If multiple languages are the focus of the research, these dissertations and theses are under “Multiple heritage language populations.” At the end of this document, you will find an index with page numbers, searchable by region researched, research interest, and research setting. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are grateful to the staff of the National Heritage Language Resource Center at the University of California, Los Angeles for their contributions to this document of the following: National Heritage Language Resource Center. (2011). Dissertations with heritage-language focus: 2006-2011. Los Angeles, CA: University of California, Los Angeles. Available: http://nhlrc.ucla.edu/events/institute/2011/readings/dissertations.pdf This document should be cited as follows: Alliance for the Advancement of Heritage Languages. (2012). Dissertations and theses on heritage language education 2000-2012. Washington, DC: Center for Applied Linguistics. Available: www/cal.org/heritage © 2012 Center for Applied Linguistics. All Rights Reserved. 1 Dissertations and Theses
    [Show full text]
  • Perceptual Identification of Talker Ethnicity In
    PERCEPTUAL IDENTIFICATION OF TALKER ETHNICITY IN VANCOUVER ENGLISH by Phoebe Wong A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts in The Faculty of Arts (Honours in Linguistics) University of British Columbia (Vancouver) Supervisor: Dr. Molly Babel April 2014 © Phoebe Wong, 2014 i Abstract As a result of historical and ongoing immigration patterns, English in Metro Vancouver has been in close contact with Punjabi and Cantonese for years. This persistent language contact, the establishment of Chinese and East Indian communities, and the struggle of Canadian-raised Punjabi and Chinese identities set up ripe conditions for the formation of Chinese and East Indian ethnolinguistic repertoires. Thus, the purpose of this project was to investigate listeners’ ability to identify the ethnicities of white, East Indian, and Chinese talkers in Vancouver in order to determine the existence of such repertoires. Semi-spontaneous speech of talkers from these three groups was recorded. Then listeners from Metro Vancouver were presented with sentences from these recordings and asked to identify the talker’s ethnicity for each sentence in a forced-choice identification task. Results indicate that listeners were able to identify talker ethnicity above chance, implying the emergence of salient ethnolinguistically-associated features contributing to the diversity of Vancouver English. In addition, listeners with Chinese social networks exhibited higher accuracy identifying Chinese talkers than listeners with white social networks, emphasizing the role of experience in perceiving talker ethnicity. Finally, results indicating that listeners were most likely to misidentify East Indian and Chinese talkers as white as opposed to the other Asian talker group argue against the existence of a general Asian ethnolinguistic repertoire.
    [Show full text]
  • Hockey Through the Voices of South Asian Canadians
    Changing on the Fly: Situating multiculturalism, citizenship, and hockey through the voices of South Asian Canadians by Courtney Szto MSc, University of Toronto, 2011 BHK, University of British Columbia, 2007 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Communication Faculty of Communication, Art, and Technology © Courtney Szto 2018 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY SPRING 2018 Copyright in this work rests with the author. Please ensure that any reproduction or re-use is done in accordance with the relevant national copyright legislation. Approval Name: Courtney Szto Degree: Doctor of Philosophy Title: Changing on the Fly: Situating multiculturalism, citizenship, and hockey through the voices of South Asian Canadians Examining Committee: Chair: Dr. Gary McCarron Associate Professor Dr. Richard Gruneau Senior Supervisor Professor Dr. Katherine Reilly Supervisor Associate Professor Dr. Wendy Chan Supervisor Professor Department of Sociology and Anthropology Dr. Ann Travers Internal Examiner Associate Professor Department of Sociology and Anthropology Dr. David J. Leonard External Examiner Professor Department of Critical Culture, Gender, & Race Studies Washington State University Date Defended/Approved: February 7, 2018 ii Ethics Statement iii Abstract Hockey and multiculturalism are often noted as defining features of Canadian culture; yet, rarely are we forced to question the relationship and tensions between these two social constructs. This project examines the growing significance of hockey in Canada’s South Asian communities. It begins by discussing issues surrounding “race” and racism in Canadian sport, before moving to consider the popularity of the Hockey Night Punjabi broadcast and the value of ethnic (sports) media in challenging dominant discourses.
    [Show full text]
  • Moving Beyond Multiculturalism: a Blueprint for Cultural Synergy
    Kamala E. Nayar. The Punjabis in British Columbia: Location, Labour, First Nations, and Multiculturalism. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press, 2012. 361 pp. $32.95, paper, ISBN 978-0-7735-4071-2. Reviewed by Christopher Taylor Published on H-Canada (December, 2013) Commissioned by Jane Nicholas (University of Waterloo/St. Jerome's) Kamala E. Nayar’s The Punjabis in British Co‐ small remote towns or in large urban centres” (p. lumbia: Location, Labour, First Nations, and Mul‐ 3). The author focuses on geography as a main de‐ ticulturalism takes an original and innovative ap‐ terminant of how Punjabi emigrants were re‐ proach to the study of multiculturalism and First ceived by the Canadian mainstream. She exam‐ Nations-immigrant relations in Canada. While the ines labor relations and the split labor market at author focuses on the experiences of mid-twenti‐ Skeena’s sawmills and canneries; interethnic eth-century Punjabi labor migrants in the rural group and intragroup relations, particularly the British Columbian Skeena region, and their subse‐ often hostile, and prejudiced, interactions with quent double migration to the Lower Mainland, First Nations peoples; and how traditional gender her research is representative of a larger study on and cultural roles adapted to a new Canadian way immigrant integration throughout Canada. Her of life. book is thought-provoking as it moves beyond the The Punjabis in British Columbia is divided in confines of academic scholarship and into the ten chapters, each with a particular theme. The public discourse on what it means to be Canadian. author begins by contextualizing the history, cul‐ Nayar also contributes to the ongoing debate on ture, and religion of the Punjab and Punjabi peo‐ how to make ideological multiculturalism “work” ple.
    [Show full text]