103 Years of Try one of our Small-Batch Quality seasonal favorites!
CLASSIC FAVORITES SEASONAL FAVORITES
Birthday Cake Bourbon Pecan Buckeye Brownie Black Walnut Buckeye Classic Blueberry Cheesecake Butter Pecan & Cashew Blue Moon Coffee Campfire S’mores Cookie Dough Extreme Coconut Almond Cookies ’n Cream Lemon Cheesecake Dutch Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Sugar or Cake Cone NO SUGAR ADDED Peppermint Stick Elephant Ear Pure Cinnamon 1·dip 3.59 2·dip 4.59 3·dip 5.29 Pumpkin Pie Fresh Strawberry Raspberry Fudge Cordial Butter Pecan & Cashew Spicy Caramel Italian Spumoni Rocky Road Caramel Crunch Sticky Pudding Kentucky Praline Pecan Salted Chocolate Fudge Waffle Cone Moose Tracks® Summertime Peach Mint Chocolate Chip Southern Butter Pecan 1·dip 4.59 2·dip 5.59 3·dip 6.29 Selection may vary by season Mocha Chip Super Friends Moose Tracks® Turtle Trails SHERBET • SORBET Olde Tyme Vanilla Vanilla Bean The Big YOGURT • CHURNED Orange Pineapple Whitehouse Cherry Orange Sherbet Original Vanilla Wild Black Cherry Ice Cream Sampler Rainbow Sherbet Raspberry Truffle Yogurt The perfect way to try more than one Raspberry Sorbet Sweet & Salty Caramel flavor. Your choice of five sample dips or let us choose for you. 6.99 The Licking Legend Five dips of your favorite flavors, bananas, chocolate, cherry and marshmallow toppings, nuts, whipped cream and two cherries. 11.99
The Feed Bin (serves 4-6) Traditional Banana Split A feed bin filled with 14 of your favorite Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry ice cream smothered flavors mixed with your choice of four sauces, bananas, hand dipped Milkshake with chocolate, strawberry and pineapple sauces. Served crushed nuts and cherries. 29.99 Try a traditional favorite like Dutch Chocolate, over a sliced banana with crushed nuts, whipped cream Fresh Strawberry or Original Vanilla. Create your own and a cherry. 5.99 Other toppings available. custom milkshake using any of our ice cream flavors or Apple Dumpling syrups. Topped with whipped cream and a cherry. 3.99 Fresh apples baked into a light and fluffy pie crust Caramel Turtle Sundae topped with caramel and Original Vanilla Two dips of Original Vanilla ice cream blanketed with Fried Pie Milkshake or Pure Cinnamon ice cream. 5.59 caramel and hot fudge. Topped with fresh-roasted Your choice of cherry or seasonal fruit Amish-made fried buttered pecans, whipped cream and a cherry. 5.59 pie. Tossed in a thick homemade milkshake made with Original Vanilla ice cream or your choice of flavor. 4.29 Buckeye Brownie Sundae Fried Pie Sundae 5.59 One scoop of Buckeye Brownie ice cream topped with peanut butter and hot fudge on top of a chocolate Olde Tyme Malt brownie. Finished with whipped cream, a candy buckeye A classic twist on our hand dipped milkshake. Add malt and a cherry. 5.59 powder to create your own malt milkshake using any of our Classic Tin Roof Sundae ice cream flavors or syrups. 3.99 Original Vanilla ice cream smothered with rich chocolate Classic Root Beer Float sauce, fresh-roasted Spanish peanuts, whipped cream and A frosty mug with two scoops of Velvet’s Original Vanilla a cherry. 5.59 1 Choose your size: ice cream topped with local Frostop Root Beer. 3.99 1·dip 4.59 2·dip 5.59 3·dip 6.29 Messy Mess Sundae 2 Choose your favorite Ice Cream Soda Hot fudge dripping from a glass goblet, rolled in nuts, filled ice cream flavor. Two scoops of your favorite flavor, a splash of half and with Original Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream half and mineral water with your choice of syrup. 3 Choose your topping: 3.99 and a cherry. 6.99 Chocolate · Cherry · Pineapple Strawberry · Caramel · Banana Salty Caramel Frapp S’mores PArfait Butterscotch · Peanut Butter Sweet & Salty Caramel ice cream blended with iced coffee Campfire S’mores ice cream layered with hot fudge Marshmallow · Blackberry and milk. Topped with whipped cream and caramel. 3.99 and marshmallow creme, topped with whipped cream and Hot Fudge · Strawberry-Banana crumbled graham crackers. 5.59