DOCSLIB.ORG

Redemptive Criticism: Sigmund Freud, Walter Benjamin, Stanley Cavell, and Democratic Culture

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Redemptive Criticism: Sigmund Freud, Walter Benjamin, Stanley Cavell, and Democratic Culture View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by ETD - Electronic Theses & Dissertations REDEMPTIVE CRITICISM: SIGMUND FREUD, WALTER BENJAMIN, STANLEY CAVELL, AND DEMOCRATIC CULTURE By Lara K. Giordano Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Vanderbilt University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in Philosophy May, 2015 Nashville, Tennessee Approved: Gregg M. Horowitz, Ph.D. José Medina, Ph.D. Lisa Guenther, Ph.D. Rebecca Comay, Ph.D. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work would not have been possible without the financial and academic support of the Vanderbilt Robert Penn Warren Center for the Humanities nor without the intellectual and moral support of Michael Alijewicz, Elizabeth Barnett, Cory Duclos, Cari Hovanec, Paddy McQueen, Rosie Seagraves, and Jen Vogt, the wonderful Fellows with whom I spent the 2012-2013 academic year. Many thanks to Dr. Lisa Guenther and Dr. José Medina, who served on my dissertation committee and from whose experience and research I have benefitted so much, as well as to my outside reader, Dr. Rebecca Comay. I’m also grateful to my friends and colleagues for the patience and enthusiasm that they brought to the many hours of conversation through which I found my way through this project. Most importantly, I would like to acknowledge the depth of my gratitude to Dr. Gregg Horowitz, my dissertation chair. A more supportive, generous, and inspiring mentor is, to me, unimaginable. ii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS Works by Benjamin AP Arcades Project OGT Origin of German Tragic Drama SW1 Selected Writings, Volume 1: 1913-1926 SW2 Selected Writings, Volume 2: 1927-1930 SW3 Selected Writings, Volume 3: 1931-1937 SW4 Selected Writings, Volume 4: 1938-1940 Works by Cavell CR Claim of Reason CT Contesting Tears: The Hollywood Melodrama of the Unknown Woman MWMW Must We Mean What We Say? PH Pursuits of Happiness: The Hollywood Comedy of Remarriage PP Pitch of Philosophy: Autobiographical Exercises QO In Quest of the Ordinary: Lines of Skepticism and Romanticism WV The World Viewed: Reflections on the Ontology of Film Works by Freud CD Civilization and its Discontents FI Future of an Illusion GP Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego TT Totem and Taboo Other Works SC Carole Pateman, The Sexual Contract (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988) iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS………………………………………………………………...ii ABBREVIATIONS………………………………………………………………………iii Chapters I. Introduction: Toward the Concept of a Redemptive Form of Critique……….1 II. The Myth of the Primal Horde and the Fate of Post-Revolutionary Politics: Freud’s Critical Redemption of Anthropology……………………………....23 Negotiating Patriarchy and the Authority of Patriarchal Myth: Pateman on the Primal Scene……………………………………………33 The Conservative-Revolutionary Powers of Myth-Making: Hunt’s Family Romance…………………………………………………54 The Myth of the Primal Horde: Freud’s Natural History of Secularism………………………………......72 At the Limits of Psychoanalysis as Social-Political Theory: The Paradox of Cultural Psychoanalysis…………………………..……...84 III. Seeing Past the Freudian Prohibition on Cultural Psychoanalysis: Benjamin’s “Weak Messianism” & the Critical Redemption of History........96 The State of Emergency……………………………...............................116 Naturgeschichte and the Allegorical Intention………………………....131 Part I: Naturgeschichte in Marx, Lukács, and Benjamin…………...134 Part II: Benjamin’s critical method of allegoresis………………….146 The Limits of “Weak Messianism” for the Purposes of Democratic Theory……………………………………………………………..……160 IV. The Dialectic of Privacy and Publicity in the Writing of Stanley Cavell & the Critical Redemption of the Movies…………………………………………172 Skepticism, Anti-Skepticism, & the Dialectic of Privacy and Publicity Skepticism as fantastic discourse………………………...……………..175 iv Criteria and Convention –or Cavell’s Natural History……………………..193 Secularity & Its Discontents………………………………………………..205 The Power and Limits of Acknowledgment in Cavell’s Anarchic Cinema...........................................................................................................215 Cavell and Benjamin on audience-formation……………………….….. 226 Photogenesis as allegoresis: the cinematic redemption of skepticism.….231 V. Conclusion: Redemptive Criticism and Democratic Institutions……….......243 REFERENCES……………………………………………………………………..254 v CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION: TOWARD THE CONCEPT OF A REDEMPTIVE FORM OF CRITIQUE To my knowledge, there is but a single text that brings together the names of Sigmund Freud, Walter Benjamin, and Stanley Cavell. This essay, entitled “Remains to be Seen,” is written by Cavell himself and he undertakes, in its four pages, a curiously intense yet elliptical engagement with the Walter Benjamin of the Arcades Project on the occasion of that text’s English translation and publication. In this piece, Cavell manages to surpass the indirection that characterizes even his most comprehensive pieces. His citational tendencies—his predilection for the epigrammatic—emerge in full-force, perhaps in homage, perhaps simply aroused by this assignation with the Arcades, the ambition of which was “to develop to the highest degree the art of citing without quotation marks…its theory intimately related to that of montage.”1 And it is in this mode of abridgement and referentiality that Cavell links his own particular activity of philosophizing to that of Freud and Benjamin. He writes: I should not forbear seeking, or questioning, another of my nows in the antitheological Freud…when early in the Introductory Lectures, Freud confesses: ‘The material for [the] observations [of psychoanalysis] is usually provided by the inconsiderable events which have been put aside by the other sciences as being too unimportant—the dregs of the world of phenomena.’ This picks up Benjamin. ‘Method of this project:…I shall purloin no valuables…But the rags, the refuse— these I will…allow in the only way possible to come into their own: by making use of them.’ Freud’s dregs and Benjamin’s refuse are each interpretable with Wittgenstein’s ordinary; the differences are where I come in.2 1 AP, 458; N1, 10 2 “Remains to be Seen,” 261-2 1 Where Freud, concerned with the suffering of private persons, made the abortive attempts of individual expression (obsessive behaviors, parapraxes, dreams, etc.) the fundamental stuff of psychoanalysis and Benjamin, for his part, found, in the detritus of capitalism, the essential material for his critique of culture, Cavell’s efforts have been largely devoted to the rescue of pieces of intellectual inheritance dismissed by American academe as being below the level of philosophic regard. As he comments of his work in Pitch of Philosophy, “[The essay Must we Mean What We Say?] is explicitly a defense of the work of my teacher Austin against an attack that in effect dismissed that work as unscientific, denied it as a contender in the ranks of philosophy at all. (Since a response to some denial was part of my cue in taking up Thoreau and Emerson, even in thinking about Shakespeare and then about film, there is the sense of a pattern here, perhaps of further interest).”3 Such is the interest of the following pages, which seeks to bring into focus the pattern writ large in the work of Freud, Benjamin, and Cavell. While it was already some months into this project when I encountered Cavell’s telegraphic piece in which he forms, in and under the sign of redemption, an indefinite constellation between his work and that of Benjamin and Freud, the central preoccupation of my research was already, unbeknownst to me, dedicated to the decoding and concretization of this claim that remains, in Cavell’s essay, a mere suggestion, constrained to these eight lines of text. This dissertation offers a sustained investigation of the insight glimpsed in and by Cavell that, between his critical hermeneutics and that of Freud and Benjamin, there is an essential isomorphism and that, further, in his uptake of ordinary language philosophy, 3 Ibid, 9 2 Cavell renders thematic the differences between his two predecessors, Freud the critic of private life and Benjamin the critic of the public. Freud, Benjamin, and Cavell are all, one could say, episodic or occasional thinkers in the sense that their work is always devoted to some particular object or text. This characteristic preoccupation with the particular—with that which defies easy subsumption under and by a ready concept and thus has the potential to contest our concepts as they stand—has left Freud, Benjamin, and Cavell largely unclassifiable in terms of extant philosophical categories.4 While Freud is one of the seminal thinkers of the 20th century and the writings of Benjamin have, in recent years, earned him a small but fervent following, and Cavell, for his part, has had what is undeniably a successful career within academic philosophy, these three remain nonetheless without a proper philosophic home, unassimilated to any particular school of academic thought. The predominant view, within philosophical circles at least, is that there is something deeply unsystematic—philosophically irredeemable—about the work of all three of these thinkers. This dissertation, however, examines this resistance to easy incorporation in and by the discipline as part of the philosophic work that they seek to accomplish to argue that their texts, rather than being failed instances of intelligibility, systematically chart the limits of reason and,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Feminist Theory and the Frankfurt School: Introduction
    wendy brown Feminist Theory and the Frankfurt School: Introduction Feminism is a revolt against decaying capitalism. —Marcuse There is a quaintness to Herbert Marcuse’s manifesto on behalf of “feminist socialism,” here reprinted for the first time since its appearance thirty years ago in Women’s Studies. It is not only an open- hearted and hopeful little effort at theoretically codifying the expansive revolutionary promise of the second wave of the Women’s Movement, a promise that would soon be dashed from within and without. Marcuse’s political and philosophical assumptions were also vulnerable to emerg- ing postfoundational critiques of the humanist subject, progressive his- toriography, and their entailments: essentialized identities, totalizing identities, undeconstructed binary oppositions, faith in emancipation, and revolution. Openhearted, hopeful, vulnerable, imaginative, revolution- ary: precisely the qualities Marcuse thought feminism brought to the unyielding and ultimately unemancipatory rationality of a masculinist radical politics, on the one hand, and a dreamless liberal egalitarianism, on the other. This unemancipatory rationality was the terrain that the Frankfurt School worked from every direction, as it upturned the myth of Volume 17, Number 1 doi 10.1215/10407391-2005-001 © 2006 by Brown University and d i f f e r e n c e s : A Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies Downloaded from http://read.dukeupress.edu/differences/article-pdf/17/1/1/405311/diff17-01_02BrownFpp.pdf by guest on 29 September 2021 Feminist Theory and the Frankfurt School Enlightenment reason, integrated psychoanalysis into political philosophy, pressed Nietzsche and Weber into Marx, attacked positivism as an ideology of capitalism, theorized the revolutionary potential of high art, plumbed the authoritarian ethos and structure of the nuclear family, mapped cultural and social effects of capital, thought and rethought dialectical materialism, and took philosophies of aesthetics, reason, and history to places they had never gone before.
    [Show full text]
  • The Idea of Mimesis: Semblance, Play, and Critique in the Works of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W
    DePaul University Via Sapientiae College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences 8-2012 The idea of mimesis: Semblance, play, and critique in the works of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno Joseph Weiss DePaul University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/etd Recommended Citation Weiss, Joseph, "The idea of mimesis: Semblance, play, and critique in the works of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno" (2012). College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations. 125. https://via.library.depaul.edu/etd/125 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Idea of Mimesis: Semblance, Play, and Critique in the Works of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy October, 2011 By Joseph Weiss Department of Philosophy College of Liberal Arts and Sciences DePaul University Chicago, Illinois 2 ABSTRACT Joseph Weiss Title: The Idea of Mimesis: Semblance, Play and Critique in the Works of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno Critical Theory demands that its forms of critique express resistance to the socially necessary illusions of a given historical period. Yet theorists have seldom discussed just how much it is the case that, for Walter Benjamin and Theodor W.
    [Show full text]
  • Historiography and Remembrance: on Walter Benjamin's Concept Of
    religions Essay Historiography and Remembrance: On Walter Benjamin’s Concept of Eingedenken Charlotte Odilia Bohn Institute for Art Theory and Cultural Studies, Academy of Fine Arts Vienna, 1010 Vienna, Austria; [email protected] Received: 15 November 2018; Accepted: 5 January 2019; Published: 10 January 2019 Abstract: Engaging with Walter Benjamin’s concept of Eingedenken (remembrance), this article explores the pivotal role that remembrance plays in his attempt to develop a radically new vision of history, temporality, and human agency. Building on his essay “On Some Motifs in Baudelaire” and on his last written text, “Theses on the Philosophy of History”, it will trace how memory and historiography are brought together in a curious fusion of materialist and messianic thinking. Emerging from a critique of modernity and its ideology of progress that is cast as crisis—the practice of remembrance promises a ‘way out’. Many of Benjamin’s secular Marxist critics such as Max Horkheimer and Rolf Tiedemann, however, denied the political significance of Eingedenken—dismissing it as theological or banishing it to the realm of aesthetics. Rejecting this critique, I suggest that the radical ethical aspects of Eingedenken can be grasped only once the theological dimension is embraced in its own right and that it is in precisely this blend of materialist and messianic thought that revolutionary hope may be found. Keywords: Benjamin; Baudelaire; modernity; progress and catastrophe; materialism and mysticism; remembrance and historiography Only our momentary and accidental knowledge makes something rounded and changeless of the past. The smallest modification of that knowledge, such as any accident may occasion, sheds new light upon the “unchangeable” past, and suddenly, in that new light, everything acquires a different meaning and actually becomes different.
    [Show full text]
  • The Uses of Afro-Pessimism
    Part One The Uses ofAfro-Pessimism To begin, it is necessary that the reader confront the sort), the kind novelist V. S. Naipaul gave us in noxious "idea" of Africa as a substance. But to do so requires us writings like "The Crocodiles of Yamoussoukro." The to struggle with a central paradox of this substance, by British press has recently regaled its readers with the virtue of the fact that Africa is always perched on a cruel stories of Zimbabwean misanthrope Robert Mu­ precipice, on the threshold between something and gabe, and, with no sense of irony, even brought Ian nothingness, between survival and the negativity of life Smith, former racist leader of the now expired Southern cycles. At the core of our consideration is the unrelent­ Rhodesia, as expert witness against him. ingly grim view of the world Africans occupy. This is It is in the nature of the ;truggle to understand what the terrain of Afro-pessimism, that impossibility of Africa is and her place among other cultural spaces in fathoming another kind of understanding of w~at history that it excites a lot of passion and sometimes re­ Africa stands for in the larger imagination. It could be gret. We choose which Africa suits our intentions, or, as said without exaggeration that Afro-pessimism is as it were, inventions.4 Each of these choices surely will old as the invention of Africa as the darkest of all places correspond to a "correct" representation. In this way, in human history. Afro-pessimism proceeds by first in­ Africa ceases to exist as a concrete reality.
    [Show full text]
  • Benjamin and Adorno on Art and Art Criticism
    ON ART AND ART CRITICISM CRITIQUE OF ART BENjAMIN AND ADORNO THIJS LIJSTER FOR PRIVATE AND NON-COMMERCIAL USE AMSTERDAM UNIVERSITY PRESS Benjamin and Adorno on Art and Art Criticism FOR PRIVATE AND NON-COMMERCIAL USE AMSTERDAM UNIVERSITY PRESS Benjamin and Adorno on Art and Art Criticism Critique of Art Thijs Lijster Amsterdam University Press FOR PRIVATE AND NON-COMMERCIAL USE AMSTERDAM UNIVERSITY PRESS Cover design: Gijs Mathijs Ontwerpers, Amsterdam Lay-out: Crius Group, Hulshout Amsterdam University Press English-language titles are distributed in the US and Canada by the University of Chicago Press. isbn 978 94 6298 140 9 e-isbn 978 90 4853 105 9 (pdf) doi 10.5117/9789462981409 nur 640 | 654 © T. Lijster / Amsterdam University Press B.V., Amsterdam 2017 All rights reserved. Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part of this book may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise) without the written permission of both the copyright owner and the author of the book. FOR PRIVATE AND NON-COMMERCIAL USE AMSTERDAM UNIVERSITY PRESS Table of Contents Acknowledgements 7 Abbreviations 9 Introduction: Critique of Art 11 1. Autonomy and Critique 19 1.1 Introduction 19 1.2 The birth of autonomy 24 1.3 The artist in the marketplace 31 1.4 Art versus society 50 1.5 Conclusion 65 2. Ends of Art 71 2.1 Introduction 71 2.2 Annihilation of semblance: Baroque allegory 72 2.3 Allegory and commodity 81 2.4 Proliferation of the aesthetic: technological reproducibility 87 2.5 Adorno’s dialectic of semblance 96 2.6 Culture industry: the social liquidation of art 98 2.7 Modernism: self-critique of semblance 107 2.8 Conclusion 119 Excursus I – The (N)everending Story 123 Hegel and the beginning of the end 124 Danto’s post-historical pluralism 129 Vattimo’s weak reality 136 Conclusion 142 3.
    [Show full text]
  • An Intervention in Contemporary Critical Thought and Practice
    Counter-Critical Theory: An Intervention in Contemporary Critical Thought and Practice Bernard E. Harcourt Columbia University A new journal is at issue, and indeed the only one to have overcome my firmly rooted conviction that I could never again get involved in anything like it […] I cleared the way for the plan’s acceptance by the publisher Rowohlt by appointing myself the representative responsible for the journal’s organizational and practical aspects, which I have worked out in long conversations with [Bertolt] Brecht. Its formal stance will be scholarly, even academic, rather than journalistic, and it will be called Krise und Kritik. — Walter Benjamin, letter to Gershom Scholem, October 1930.1 Crisis and Critique. Kritische Blätter, then. Critical Times, now. And how appropriate that is. We indeed live in critical times—at a troubling conjuncture of world-historical developments that are challenging our understanding of both our past and our possible futures. Around the world, we are witnessing a grab for the global commons—or whatever was left of it—with the dismantling of the Soviet Union and the precipitous privatization of industry, utilities, and finance in the former Eastern Bloc, the capitalization of the Chinese economy, the deregulation of the British and American economies, gradually seeping across Western Europe, the devastating impact of the IMF’s fiscal policies across Africa and Latin America. Mainstream economists document the plummeting percentage of property held in public trust in China, Japan, Europe, and the
    [Show full text]
  • In a Letter to Gershom Scholem Dated 12 June 1938, Walter Benjamin Refines His Position on Franz Kafka in Anticipation of Writi
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Directory of Open Access Journals An art history of means: Arendt-Benjamin Jae Emerling I. Notre heritage n’est précédé d’aucun testament. —René Char Is it possible to conceive anew the relation between art history and philosophy, disciplines with indelibly German birthrights, without abandoning the ruins of its aftermath? After philosophy, after art history: this is more than a temporality, it is an orientation, a movement towards and after that which has been forfeited. And yet, only in the aftermath of each, between art history and philosophy, are we granted our inheritance. What has been given is a tradition that, while irreparable, induces a recollection of what remains. What remains, what returns, is neither art history nor philosophy. To read and study this relation between generations and disciplines we must confront two unfinished projects that sought to step beyond the demarcations of philosophy and art history, two projects by forebears who rejected the names ‘philosopher’ and ‘art historian’: Hannah Arendt and Walter Benjamin.1 What comes next is unimaginable if we do not return to this pair of German-Jewish émigrés, who succeeded and failed in crossing borders both physical and conceptual. These proper names have long been bound to one another, and each offers art history and philosophy a lesson that has been difficult to receive. The difficulty arises not only from the incompleteness of their respective projects, but also from a certain reluctance to read Benjamin alongside Arendt, Arendt alongside Benjamin.2 This alongside or neben is at once a preposition of location (beside, next to) and one of exception (against, aside from).
    [Show full text]
  • Walter Benjamin on Justice, Judaism, and the Possibility of Ethics CHARLES H
    American Political Science Review Vol. 108, No. 1 February 2014 doi:10.1017/S0003055413000579 c American Political Science Association 2014 Against Politics: Walter Benjamin on Justice, Judaism, and the Possibility of Ethics CHARLES H. T. LESCH Harvard University s politics compatible with the moral life? Recent attempts to revivify democracy have stressed the lived experience of political activity, the democratic character of the spontaneous moment and the I popular movement. This article raises some concerns about such agonistic enthusiasm via an original reading of Walter Benjamin’s political thought. For Benjamin, politics corrodes our everyday lives and moral conduct. His response is to envision a space for ethics wholly apart from the violence (Gewalt) that sustains propertied political order, a purified version of the Kantian kingdom of ends that he calls the “state of justice.” Yet deprived of the coercive instrumentality of politics, there is no action that could lead humanity directly to such a state. To surmount this paradox, Benjamin culls from sources in Jewish political theology, and in particular, Jewish ideas about justice and the community of the righteous. In so doing, he offers a new and radical ethical critique of politics that may hold special relevance in our politics-saturated age. “Human actions form a whole. A space can be saved Such theorizing attends to the impact of ideological with great effort for ethically relevant actions. Saved and instrumental forms of thinking on our everyday from what? From violence, which can be termed moral judgment (Halbertal 2012, 63–78), what Weber ‘myth.’ Almost all realms of human action are sub- calls the “significance of political action within our ject to mythical categories, from which fate alone conduct of life as a whole” ([1919] 2002, 309).
    [Show full text]
  • Walter Benjamin's Will to Happiness
    On the Metapolitics of Decay: Walter Benjamin’s Will to Happiness by Jason McKinney A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department for the Study of Religion University of Toronto © Copyright by Jason Thomas McKinney 2012 On The Metapolitics of Decay On the Metapolitics of Decay: Walter Benjamin’s Will to Happiness Jason Thomas McKinney Doctor of Philosophy Department for the Study of Religion University of Toronto 2012 Abstract This dissertation analyzes the early work of Walter Benjamin (ca. 1916 – 1926). The period under consideration falls between Benjamin’s break from the German Youth Movement (which also coincides with the beginning of the Great War) and his turn to Marxism. Benjamin’s life and work during this period is characterized by, on the one hand, an intensified interest in theological concepts and, on the other hand, the apparent refusal of concrete political engagement. It is the claim of the dissertation that what Benjamin elaborates – in the absence of a concrete political program and with the aid of theological concepts – is a metaphysical conception of politics: what I call a metapolitics of decay . This metapolitics is informed by a certain theological understanding of transience: the decay that attends to a creation which has “fallen” from its original condition. While Benjamin’s metapolitics is oriented towards redemption – to the lossless consummation of historical life – it pursues this goal, not by circumventing transience, but by concentrating on the decay of nature – and by extension, of history. ii On The Metapolitics of Decay The metapolitical limit upon concrete politics, however, does not foreclose the possibility of the latter.
    [Show full text]
  • Elusiveness of the Particular: Hannah Arendt, Walter Benjamin, And
    The Elusiveness of the Particular Exile, Statelessness, and Migration Seyla Benhabib Print publication date: 2018 Print ISBN-13: 9780691167251 Published to Princeton Scholarship Online: May 2019 DOI: 10.23943/princeton/9780691167251.001.0001 The Elusiveness of the Particular Hannah Arendt, Walter Benjamin, and Theodor Adorno Seyla Benhabib DOI:10.23943/princeton/9780691167251.003.0003 Abstract and Keywords This chapter examines the subterranean affinities between Hannah Arendt and Theodor Adorno, two of the most famous exiles of the last century, through the so-called “Benjaminian moment” present in their work. It is widely known that any consideration of Arendt and Adorno as thinkers who share intellectual affinities is likely to be thwarted by the profound dislike that Arendt seems to harbor toward Adorno. However, such psychological attitudes and personal animosities cannot guide the evaluations of a thinker's work. This is particularly true in the case of Arendt and Adorno, who both shared a profound sense that one must learn to think anew, beyond the traditional schools of philosophy and methodology—a concept that will be referred to as their Benjaminian moment. Keywords: Hannah Arendt, Theodor Adorno, Walter Benjamin, Benjaminian moment, exiles, think anew, traditional philosophy, traditional methodology Benjamin and the Chess Master Chess appears to have been not just a pastime for Walter Benjamin but a complex metaphor for thinking about history, progress, teleology, and the ironies of fate. The first thesis of Benjamin’s “Theses on the Philosophy of History,” composed in shock at the signing of the Hitler-Stalin pact, reads as follows: “The story is told of an automaton constructed in such a way that it could play a winning game of chess, answering each move of an opponent with a countermove.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dialectical Image As the Critical Inner Mirror
    The dialectical image as the critical inner mirror Łukasz K. Rybiński Faculty of Philology University of Gdańsk Email: [email protected] Abstract The purpose of this paper is to outline a possible approach to Benjamin’s figure of the dialectical image from the perspective of neither its content nor the philosophical issues it is supposed to represent but from the very dialectical tension immanent in it. I believe it is precisely due to that inner tension that the dialectical image conveys truth content as the eternal glimmer of transiency. Key Words Benjamin; dialectical image; dialectical tension; difference. This paper deals with Walter Benjamin’s concept of the dialectical image with special reference to its critical significance as it has been emphasized in Adorno’s critical interpretation of Benjamin writings. The concept itself carries the inevitable veil of an ambiguity programmed or coded into it by Benjamin himself; although this has already been i discussed by several scholars no resolution has yet appeared . Admittedly, even if the notion 1 of the dialectical image presents an immense challenge, I believe it is not unresolvable and Strona that it may be approached in a different manner than suggested by some critics. This very problematical subject requires an adjustment of the methodological approach, amounting, in the case of Benjamin writings, to its degradation; thus methodology would abandon its illusory certitude in order to trace whatever escapes its identifying powers. Buck-Morss for instance claims that in order to unveil the hidden meaning of his fragmented works Benjamin’s own method of making present (Aktualisierung) should be applied, which in fact consists in utilizing it.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction Walter Benjamin: 1892-1940
    Introduction Walter Benjamin: 1892-1940 I. THE HUNCHBACK Fama, that much-coveted goddess, has many faces, and fame comes in many sorts and sizes-from the one-week notoriety of the cover story to the splendor of an everlasting name. Posthu­ mous fame is one of Fama's rarer and least desired articles; al­ though it is less arbitrary and often more solid than the other sorts, since it is only seldom bestowed upon mere merchandise. The one who stood most to profit is dead and hence it is not for sale. Such posthumous fame, uncommercial and unprofitable, has now come in Germany to the name and work of Walter Ben­ jamin, a German-Jewish writer who was known, but not fa­ mous, as contributor to magazines and literary sections of news­ papers for less than ten years prior to Hitler's seizure of power and his own emigration. There were few who still knew his name when he chose death in those early fall days of 1940 which for many of his origin and generation marked the darkest moment of the war-the fall of France, the threat to England, the still intact Hitler-Stalin pact whose most feared consequence at that moment was the close co-operation of the two most powerful secret po­ lice forces in Europe. Fifteen years later a two-volume edition of lIluminations his writings was published in Germany and brought him almost immediately a succes dtestime that went far beyond the recogni­ tion among the few which he had known in his life.
    [Show full text]