BECOMING the WIG: MIS/IDENTIFICATIONS and CITATIONALITY in QUEER ROCK MUSICALS Samantha Michele Riley a Thesis Submitted To
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BECOMING THE WIG: MIS/IDENTIFICATIONS AND CITATIONALITY IN QUEER ROCK MUSICALS Samantha Michele Riley A thesis submitted to the faculty of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Department of English and Comparative Literature (Comparative Literature). Chapel Hill 2008 Approved by: Dr. Alice Kuzniar Dr. Diane Leonard Dr. Tyler Curtain ©2008 Samantha Michele Riley ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT SAMANTHA MICHELE RILEY: Becoming the Wig: Mis/Identifications and Citationality in Queer Rock Musicals (Under the direction of Dr. Alice Kuzniar) Performative citationality operates as a fetish in the queer musicals of The Rocky Horror Picture Show , Hedwig and the Angry Inch, and Stadt der verlorenen Seelen . One watches queer musicals, as well as performs alongside queer characters through audience participation, to satisfy a desire to overstep limits of the performance of gender and sexuality, and essentially, our identity, in a sublime way. This desire must be blocked or disavowed, however, in order for one to return to heteronormality, which is done here through the mechanism of citationality. Viewers latch onto citations to disavow the queering that is taking place. This queering is manifested out of the excess that is exhumed from the sublime encounter with the queer performance of the film through aid of the queered citations. At the same time the film queers those viewers watching it, if only momentarily. Still, viewers maintain that they love the musical just for the music. iii I dedicate this work to all the Hedwigs, Frankensteins, Rosas, and Otherwise in the world, as well as to All those who love them Unconditionally! May all your inches be Happy! And for you, and the legacy of the potato clouds, and the bunny, Cancun, the 4 walls, Piñon Coffee, night sledding and trust, the pig of happiness, the pengutin, M1 and TV campfires, stolen champagne, and family, Zoë, Kuh, PG, for now and FOREVER, and of course, thank you for the rain! iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank Dr. Kuzniar for all her dedication and encouragement. Without her, this work would not be as productive and queer as it is. I thank Professor Leonard for her guidance through the tumultuous terrain of Comparative Literature, and her friendship. Thank you, Dr. Curtain and Dr. Flaxman for encouraging me to engage with theory. I would also like to thank my family, my girlfriend, and friends, and my fellow German graduate students for your support. Finally, I’d like to thank the University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill dept. of Comparative Literature and Germanic Languages and Literatures for allowing me to write on a topic which I love, and at that, a topic which I hope will prove to be a small, yet positive and relevant contribution to queer theory and gender studies. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction:.......................................................................................................................... 1 The Freudian Fetish .............................................................................................................. 8 A Brief History of the Development of the Term Citationality.......................................... 13 Chapter 1: Maintaining Limits: The Rocky Horror Picture Show .......................................... 19 The Plot of Rocky Horror ................................................................................................... 22 Deviant Desires in Rocky Horror ....................................................................................... 24 Citationality in Rocky Horror............................................................................................. 25 Why the popularity?............................................................................................................ 26 Queer Characters................................................................................................................. 29 The Mouth....................................................................................................................... 29 Riff Raff & Magenta....................................................................................................... 32 Rocky & Eddie................................................................................................................ 35 Queer Performances............................................................................................................ 43 Queer Scripts................................................................................................................... 43 The Fetish in Performance .............................................................................................. 48 Conclusion: Rocky Horror Picture Show ........................................................................... 51 Chapter 2: Blurring Borders: Hedwig and the Angry Inch..................................................... 55 The Plot of Hedwig............................................................................................................. 58 Deviant Desires in Hedwig................................................................................................. 60 Why the growing popularity? ............................................................................................. 61 vi Citationality in Hedwig....................................................................................................... 63 Queer Characters................................................................................................................. 64 Hansel ............................................................................................................................. 65 Hedwig............................................................................................................................ 69 Yitzhak............................................................................................................................ 73 Queer Performances............................................................................................................ 74 Conclusion: Hedwig and the Angry Inch ........................................................................... 76 Chapter 3: Overstepping Boundaries: Stadt der verlorenen Seelen........................................ 81 The Plot of Stadt ................................................................................................................. 84 Deviant Desires in Stadt ..................................................................................................... 85 Why the lack of popularity?................................................................................................ 86 Citationality in Stadt ........................................................................................................... 89 Queer Performers:............................................................................................................... 91 Angie Stardust................................................................................................................. 91 Lila .................................................................................................................................. 94 Gary................................................................................................................................. 96 Tara O’Hara .................................................................................................................... 98 Tron von Hollywood....................................................................................................... 99 Joaquin La Habana........................................................................................................ 100 Queer Performances.......................................................................................................... 101 Conclusion: Stadt der verlorenen Seelen .......................................................................... 102 Conclusion: Queer Musicals as Safer Sex? .......................................................................... 104 Works Cited .......................................................................................................................... 108 vii Introduction: Hedwig, the transvestite, transwoman, homosexual, transgendered queer human takes the microphone. Hedwig, all in make-up wearing her now infamous blond ‘80s punk-rock wig and trailer-trash costume begins to sing, to perform. Colorful handmade cartoons flash across the screen in the background - a sideshow of slides thrown on the wall of the kitschy restaurant where Hedwig’s band is performing tonight on tour. “Hedheads,” Hedwig’s followers, both performers in the movie and real audience members, nod to the music, singing with their sonorous siren in unison. The clientele watches, not mocking, but instead simply listening intently. They latch onto Hedwig’s words, and begin to subsume the ever familiar themes. Soon, they too will transition and become part of the choir. Hedwig begins to tell a creation story, a queer creation story. “Before the origin of love.” The camera slowly zooms in, taking us into the story from which we can hardly escape, nor want to. The restaurant clientele, the band, and we, the movie audience, all begin to gyrate rhythmically to the music, letting the text envelop us, and ultimately, become us; or rather, we are in the act of becoming part of the performance,