Concepts, Attention, and the Contents of Conscious Visual Experience

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Concepts, Attention, and the Contents of Conscious Visual Experience CONCEPTS, ATTENTION, AND THE CONTENTS OF CONSCIOUS VISUAL EXPERIENCE A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI‘I AT MANOA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN PHILOSOPHY MAY 2018 By Amit Chaturvedi Dissertation Committee: Arindam Chakrabarti, Chairperson Roger T. Ames Masato Ishida Jonardon Ganeri Scott Sinnett ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This dissertation has been made possible first and foremost through the dedicated and patient support of my teachers, dissertation committee members, and faculty at UH-Mānoa. I am grateful to Scott Sinnett, Masato Ishida, and George Tsai for their involvement in my committee and dissertation defense. Ron Bontekoe has been a steadfast advocate on behalf of myself and many other graduate students during his time as graduate and department chairs. My Sanskrit teachers have contributed greatly to this dissertation by enabling me to discover new insights from classical texts. Rama Nath Sharma instilled in me what will be a lifetime love for Sanskrit language. His guidance prepared me to undertake a summer course of intensive Sanskrit study through the American Institute of Indian Studies, for which I received financial support from the Watumull Foundation. My teachers at the AIIS program, Madhura Godbole and Meenal Kulkarni, in turn prepared me for more extensive study at Jagadguru Ramamandacharya Rajasthan Sanskrit University and Karnataka Sanskrit University, with the support of the Freeman Foundation and the Jagdish P. Sharma Memorial Scholarship. I am immensely grateful to Prof. Veeranarayana Pandurangi of Karnataka Sanskrit University and Prof. D. Prahladachar of Poornaprajna Samshodhana Mandiram for patiently teaching me several texts related to my dissertation research. I owe special debts of gratitude to three of my teachers, each of whom has given me a model of exemplary scholarship and humanity to strive toward. Roger Ames has unfailingly supported my career from the very earliest stages, and opened my mind to new ways of doing Chinese and comparative philosophy. It has been a great privilege to receive Jonardon Ganeri’s ii generous feedback on my dissertation – his work best embodies the sort of cross-cultural philosophy that this dissertation attempts to practice. Most of all, I am indebted to Arindam Chakrabarti, to whom I have owed, directly or indirectly, most every philosophical insight contained in this dissertation. The central ideas of this work originate from an idea for a term paper he gave me a decade ago, which sparked a slow-burning fire in my mind that he has stoked continuously ever since. His unmatched combination of philosophical creativity and clarity will never cease to inspire me. To him, I dedicate the following artless gurustuti: य एव ससिंहनदं ममिहहिनमययिन यि ह सवशहसदयशनह यदह वहचयव्वरनं ॥ यतदजममयब#ददश &#त(जह&#यल+जकह ह मिमंय.पयवदहस1 मिनमयिसमैिधन ॥ यद मद य5त्म नदष9वह ययह ध;मय नशंहन। ह वैन=>यमयप यंरंिय#नहं। ज#?नaयम सवनह ॥ Finally, I am deeply grateful to my parents and family for their patient support all these years; and to Nada for being an inexhaustible source of joy, and for reminding me of what is most important. iii ABSTRACT The basic question motivating my dissertation is whether it is possible to consciously perceive objects in the world without possessing any concepts for those objects. Standard phenomenological and epistemological approaches to the issue of non-conceptual perceptual content have presumed that concept-possession entails mastery of a concept's linguistic and inferential usage. I depart from these approaches by developing a naturalized account of perceptual concepts, one which is further informed by theories of perception in the Nyāya tradition of Indian philosophy. Perceptual concepts on a revised conceptualist account can be understood as attention- and memory-based capacities for predicating sensory features to objects. With this account in place, I draw upon recent scientific models of visual processing to argue that essentially non-conceptual, pre-predicative perceptual contents do not phenomenally appear in conscious visual experience. To make plausible the idea that perceptual contents can be both conceptual and non- linguistic in nature, I demonstrate in Chapters 1 and 2 how perceptual contents can have a compositional, predicative structure in the absence of linguistic formatting. Similarly, I advance several criteria for perceptual concept possession in the absence of explicit linguistic or inferential mastery. I further support my revised account of perceptual concepts by drawing upon insights from Buddhist and Nyāya philosophers, developed in their centuries-long debates over the relation between perception, concepts, and language. In Chapter 3, I then offer a reconstructive reading of Immanuel Kant and the Navya Nyāya philosopher Gȧgesa, which extracts from their theories of perceptual concepts and iv apperception a thesis to the effect that intentional, object-directed perceptual representations must be conceptually structured in order to have a subjective phenomenal character. Kant and Gȧgesa broadly agree on a set of reasons why we lack any phenomenological evidence for the existence of perceptual states with exclusively non-conceptual content. I take these reasons to be pointing toward several conditions responsible for the integration of perceptual contents into a subject's unified conscious experience. The fourth chapter reframes my reading of Kant and Gȧgesa in naturalized terms, by demonstrating how phenomenally accessible perceptual contents arise through the conceptually modulated activity of attention and visual memory. I show how a unified theory of perceptual attention and conceptualization undercuts the phenomenological intuitions underlying both classical Buddhist and contemporary defenses of non-conceptualism, and further resolves several dilemmas facing recent theories of consciousness. Lastly, the fifth chapter shifts to a discussion of classical Chinese epistemology and psychological studies of perceptual expertise, in order to further characterize perceptual concepts as capacities for allocating attention which we can actively and skillfully exercise in experience. Ultimately, a theory of perceptual concepts as attentional skills allows us to understand perceptual experience itself as an activity which is both skillfully absorbed and permeated with rationality. v Table of Contents Acknowledgments………………………………………………………………………………...ii Abstract…………………………………….……………...……………...………………………iv Chapter 1: Perceptual Content as Non-Linguistic but Conceptual……………...…….…………..1 1.1 Setting the Bar for Perceptual Concept Possession……………...………………...….3 1.1.1 Restrictive Views of Concept-Possession: Peacocke and McDowell……….4 1.1.2 Noë’s “Vacuous” Conceptualism……………………………………………8 1.2 Non-Conceptual Contents: Scenarios and Protopropositions…….……..….……..…14 1.2.1 The Incoherence of State Non-Conceptualism.……..…..……..…..…….....17 1.2.2 Protopropositional Content is Non-Essentially Non-Conceptual…..…..…..20 1.3 The Propositional Structure of Perceptual Content……..………………….…….…..24 1.4 Perceptual Concept Possession.…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….……...29 1.5 Conclusion.…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…….…..34 Chapter 2: Language and Concept-Laden Perception in Classical Indian Philosophy…..……...36 2.1 Language and Conceptualization in Indian Buddhist Philosophy…….…….……….39 2.1.1 Dignāga – Perception is Essentially Non-Conceptual, and Concepts are Essentially Linguistic….……….……….……….……….……….……….……..41 2.1.2 Vasubandhu – Non-Linguistic Conceptualization is Inherent to Perceptual Awareness………………………………………………………………………...43 2.1.3 Dhamakīrti – Non-Linguistic Creatures Have Implicitly Linguistic Concepts………………………………………………………………………….49 2.2 Classical Nyāya Views on the Non-Linguistic Nature of Perception………………..54 2.2.1 Vātsyāyana – All Perception is Non-Linguistic (Avyapadeśya)……………54 2.2.2 Jayanta Bhaṭṭa – Non-Conceptual and Concept-Laden Perceptions Share the Same Contents……………………………………………………………………59 2.2.3 Vācaspati Misra – Non-Conceptual Perceptions Are Non-Propositional….67 2.2.4 Concept-Laden Perception Can Be Propositional and Non-Linguistic…….71 2.3 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………73 Chapter 3: Concepts and Conscious Perceptual Content: A Revised Nyāya/Kantian Approach...76 3.1 Introduction – Phenomenal Character and Non-Conceptual Perception…………….76 3.2 Navya Nyāya on the Contents of Non-Conceptual and Concept-Laden Perception...81 3.2.1 Pre-Gȧgesa Views on the Purported Phenomenology of Non-Conceptual Perception………………………………………………………………………...88 3.2.2 Gȧgesa on the Attentional Inaccessibility of Essentially Non-Conceptual Perception………………………………………………………………………...92 3.2.3 Nirvikalpaka Pratyakṣa as Subpersonal Perception………………………101 3.2.4 Chadha's Kantian Reading of Navya Nyāya on Perception and Concepts 105 3.3 Kant on Concepts and Conscious Perceptual Experience…………………………..116 vi 3.3.1 Conscious Subjective Character and the Unity of Apperception…………122 3.3.2 Objections From Kantian Non-Conceptualism………………………...…131 3.3.3 Responding to the Kantian Version of Essentialist Content Non- Conceptualism……………….……….……….……….……….……….………137 3.4 Conclusion: Apperception, Attentional Access, and Consciousness…………….….151 Chapter 4: Undercutting Buddhist Non-Conceptualism…….………….………….…………...155 4.1 The Buddhists’ Essentialist Non-Conceptualism…….………….………….………158 4.2 The Phenomenological Intuitions of Buddhist Non-Conceptualism…….…………166 4.3 Concepts, Attention, and Conscious Visual
Recommended publications
  • Master of Arts (Philosophy) (10-Oct-2012)
    Design and Structure of various courses of Semester based Credit system to be implemented from June-2010 (Revised June -2012) Course No. of hours per week Course Department No. Name Lectures Others Practicals Total Credit Semester PHI401 Indian logic & Peistemology-I 3 1 - 4 4 PHI402 Indian EThics 3 1 - 4 4 PHI403 Symbolic Logic 3 1 - 4 4 PHI404EA Modern Indian Thought 1 3 1 - 4 4 PHI404EB Philosophy of Education PHI405EA Advaita Vedanta 3 1 - 4 4 PHI405EB Philosophy of Madhva PHI406S Seminar 3 1 - 4 4 Total 18 6 0 24 24 PHI407 Indian Logic & Epistemology-II 3 1 - 4 4 PHI408 Western Ethics 3 1 - 4 4 PHI409 Advance Symbolic Logic 3 1 - 4 4 PHI410EA Philosophy of Religion 2 3 1 - 4 4 PHI410EB Phenomenology and Existentialism PHI411EA Indian Aesthetics 3 1 - 4 4 PHI411EB Western Aesthetics PHI412S Seminar 3 1 - 4 4 Total 18 6 0 24 24 PHI501 Indian Metaphysics 3 1 - 4 4 Philosophy PHI502 Philosophy of Bhagwadgita 3 1 - 4 4 PHI503 Mysticism 3 1 - 4 4 PHI504EA Buddhist Philosophy 3 3 1 - 4 4 PHI504EB Nyaymanjari (Third Ahnika) textual study PHI505EA Yoga Philosophy and Psychology 3 1 - 4 4 PHI505EB Jain Philosophy PHI506S Seminar 3 1 - 4 4 Total 18 1 0 24 24 PHI507 Western Metaphysics 3 1 - 4 4 PHI508 Philosophy of Kant 3 1 - 4 4 PHI509 Philosophy of Ramanuj 3 1 - 4 4 PHI510EA Environmental Philosophy 4 3 1 - 4 4 PHI510EB Philosophical Tradition in Gujarat PHI511EA Seminar 3 1 - 4 4 PHI511EB Philosophy of Sartre PHI512 Project 3 1 - 4 4 Total 18 1 0 24 24 Page 1 of 59 DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY GUJARAT UNIVERSITY AHMEDABAD SEMESTER SYSTEM Syllabus [M.A.] Sem-I to IV [ With effect from Academic Year – June 2010 ] [ Revised June – 2012 ] Semester-I (PHI401) Indian logic and Epistemology (1) Objectives : This course aims at introducing the distinctive features of Indian epistemology.
    [Show full text]
  • Neuroscience of the Yogic Theory of Mind and Consciousness
    1 Neuroscience of the Yogic Theory of 2 Mind and Consciousness 3 Vaibhav Tripathi1* and Pallavi Bharadwaj2 *For correspondence: [email protected] (VT) 4 1Boston University; 2Massachusetts Institute of Technology † Present address: Department of 5 Psychological and Brain Sciences, Boston University, Boston, MA, ‡ USA 02215; Laboratory for 6 Abstract Yoga as a practice and philosophy of life has been followed for more than 4500 years Information and Decision Systems, 7 Massachusetts Institute of with known evidence of Yogic practices in the Indus Valley Civilization. A plethora of scholars have Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139 8 contributed to the development of the field, but in last century the profound knowledge 9 remained inaccessible and incomprehensible to the general public. Last few decades have seen a 10 resurgence in the utility of Yoga and Meditation as a practice with growing scientific evidence 11 behind it. Significant scientific literature has been published, illustrating the benefits of Yogic 12 practices including asana, pranayama and dhyana on mental and physical well being. 13 Electrophysiological and recent functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) studies have 14 found explicit neural signatures for Yogic practices. In this article, we present a review of the 15 philosophy of Yoga, based on the dualistic Sankhya school, as applied to consciousness 16 summarized by Patanjali in his Yoga Sutras followed by discussion on the five vritti (modulations 17 of mind), practice of pratyahara, dharana, dhyana, different states of samadhi, and samapatti. We 18 introduce Yogic Theory of Mind and Consciousness (YTMC), a cohesive theory that can model 19 both external modulations and internal states of the mind.
    [Show full text]
  • Glossary of Sanskrit and Pāli Terms
    Glossary of Sanskrit and Pāli Terms Abhiniveśa Clinging to life, will-to-live, an urge for survival, or for self-preservation. Abhyāsa Practice. Ahaṁkāra The ego or self-referencing function of the mind, feelings, and thoughts about self at empirical level. Egoism or self-conceit; the self-arrogating principle “I” that is projected by the mind rather than the real self. Awareness of oneself, or of individuality. Ahiṁsā Nonviolence. Akliṣṭa Unhindered vṛttis (mental actions). Ālaya The subterraine stream of consciousness; self-existent consciousness con- ceived by the Vijñānavādins in Buddhism. Ānanda Bliss. Ānandamaya-kośa The “sheath of bliss”. Aṅga Limb or integral component of a system, such as in aṣṭāṅga (eight limbs) in Patañjali Yoga. Annamaya-kośa “The sheath of food (anna)”; the physical or gross body, nurtured by food; related to esoteric anatomy and physiology. Antaḥkaraṇa Literally means internal instrument, corresponding to what may be called the mind. Aparā Not transcendent; lower or limited; its opposite parā means supreme or superior. Placing an “a” before parā, makes it not superior or lower than. Parā can also mean far away (transcendent) so that aparā may mean empirical and immanent. Appanā The steady concentration leading to a state of absorption (Buddhist psychology). Arhant A high rank of self-realization lower than that of the Buddha. © Author(s) 2016 341 K. Ramakrishna Rao and A.C. Paranjpe, Psychology in the Indian Tradition, DOI 10.1007/978-81-322-2440-2 342 Glossary of Sanskrit and Pāli Terms Arūpaloka Formless world in Buddhism. Āsana Yogic physical posture, especially as recommended in Haṭha Yoga as one of the aids to concentration.
    [Show full text]
  • A Response to Jonardon Ganeri Matthew Ad Sti Bridgewater State University, [email protected]
    Bridgewater State University Virtual Commons - Bridgewater State University Philosophy Faculty Publications Philosophy Department 2010 Comment and Discussion: Pramāņa Are Factive - A Response to Jonardon Ganeri Matthew aD sti Bridgewater State University, [email protected] Stephen H. Phillips University of Texas at Austin Virtual Commons Citation Dasti, Matthew and Phillips, Stephen H. (2010). Comment and Discussion: Pramāņa Are Factive - A Response to Jonardon Ganeri. In Philosophy Faculty Publications. Paper 3. Available at: http://vc.bridgew.edu/philosophy_fac/3 This item is available as part of Virtual Commons, the open-access institutional repository of Bridgewater State University, Bridgewater, Massachusetts. COMMENT AND DISCUSSION Prama¯n.a Are Factive — A Response to Jonardon Ganeri Matthew Dasti and Stephen H. Phillips Department of Philosophy, Bridgewater State University Department of Philosophy, University of Texas at Austin Recently, Jonardan Ganeri reviewed the collaborative translation of the first chapter of Gan˙ges´a’s Tattvacinta¯man.i by Stephen H. Phillips and N. S. Ramanuja Tatacharya (Ganeri 2007). The review is quite favorable, and we have no desire to dispute his kind words. Ganeri does, however, put forth an argument in opposition to a funda- mental line of interpretation given by Phillips and Ramanuja Tatacharya about the nature of prama¯n.a, knowledge sources, as understood by Gan˙ges´a and, for that mat- ter, Nya¯ya tradition. This response is meant to answer the argument and reassert an understanding of prama¯n.a as factive, that is, as knowledge sources that are inerrant. We argue that this is the best reading of Gan˙ges´a himself and of Nya¯ya tradition, and is defensible on purely philosophical grounds.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Buddhist Metaphysics: the Making of a Philosophical Tradition
    EARLY BUDDHIST METAPHYSICS This book provides a philosophical account of the major doctrinal shift in the history of early Theravada tradition in India: the transition from the earliest stratum of Buddhist thought to the systematic and allegedly scholastic philosophy of the Pali Abhidhamma movement. Conceptual investigation into the development of Buddhist ideas is pursued, thus rendering the Buddha’s philosophical position more explicit and showing how and why his successors changed it. Entwining comparative philosophy and Buddhology, the author probes the Abhidhamma’s shift from an epistemologically oriented conceptual scheme to a metaphysical worldview that is based on the concept of dhamma. She does so in terms of the Aristotelian tradition and vis-à-vis modern philosophy, exploiting Western philo- sophical literature from Plato to contemporary texts in the fields of philosophy of mind and cultural criticism. This book not only demonstrates that a philosophical inquiry into the conceptual foundations of early Buddhism can enhance our understanding of what philosophy and religion are qua thought and religion; it also shows the value of fresh perspectives for traditional Buddhology. Combining philosophically rigorous investigation and Buddhological research criteria, Early Buddhist Metaphysics fills a significant gap in Buddhist scholar- ship’s treatment of the conceptual development of the Abhidhamma. Noa Ronkin received her PhD from the University of Oxford. She is currently a lecturer in the Introduction to the Humanities Programme and a Research Fellow at the Center for Buddhist Studies, Stanford University. Her research interests include a range of issues associated with Indian Theravada Buddhist philosophy and psychology, the Abhidhamma tradition and comparative Indian philosophy.
    [Show full text]
  • Facets of Nidrā - in Yogasūtra: Analysis Based on the Views from Vyāsa’S Commentary and Its Sub-Commentaries Jayaraman Mahadevan
    [Downloaded free from http://www.ijoyppp.org on Wednesday, August 30, 2017, IP: 210.18.187.56] Original Article Facets of Nidrā - In Yogasūtra: Analysis Based on the Views from Vyāsa’s Commentary and Its Sub-commentaries Jayaraman Mahadevan Research Department, Good sleep is an important indicator and also a requisite of good health. Yoga sūtras Krishnamacharya Yoga discuss the concept of Nidrā. A survey of commentaries of Yoga sūtras reveals Mandiram, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India elaborate discussions, which are seldom noticed, regarding the concept. There are more than a dozen commentaries in Saṃskṛta on Yoga sūtras. However, this article Abstract presents the views of Vyāsa, the principal commentator and the four available subcommentaries to Vyāsa’s commentary on the Nidrā. All later commentaries respect and follow Vyāsa’s commentary. The study reveals that – Vyāsa’s commentary and its subcommentaries address aspects on Nidrā including – Why Nidrā after Pramāṇa, Viparyaya and Vikalpa? Is Nidrā a Vṛtti?, Is Nidrā deep sleep or does it include dream state also? How does one fall asleep – the Yogic way, Guṇa‑based 3‑fold classification of Deep Sleep, Half Deep Sleep and Complete Deep Sleep, Nidrā vis‑a‑vis the states of Ekāgratā, Niruddha and Kaivalya and why should sleep be restrained like any other Vṛtti? Thus, understanding various aspects of Nidrā indeed would be handy in the correct practice of the technique based on Nidrā (PYS 1.6, Patañjali, 2015, p.24)[2] to attain the goals specified in the Yoga sūtras. Therapeutically, the implications of the 3‑fold classification of Nidrā based on Guṇas need to be developed into an elaborate model that includes the factors that induce such kinds of sleep and ways in which one can move toward the desired (Sāttvic) state of sleep, etc.
    [Show full text]
  • Discovering Buddhism at Home
    Discovering Buddhism at home Awakening the limitless potential of your mind, achieving all peace and happiness Special Integration Experiences Required Reading Contents The Eight Places of Buddhist Pilgrimage, by Jeremy Russell 3 (Also available on Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive Website – www.lamayeshe.com) Further required reading includes the following texts: The Tantric Path of Purification, by Lama Thubten Yeshe Everlasting Rain of Nectar, by Geshe Jampa Gyatso © FPMT, Inc., 2001. All rights reserved. 1 2 The Eight Places of Buddhist Pilgrimage by Jeremy Russell Jeremy Russell was born in England and received his degree in English Literature from London University. He studied Buddhist philosophy at the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives, Dharamsala, for four years. Jeremy currently lives in Dharamsala, India, editing Cho-Yang, the Journal of Tibetan Culture, and translating other material from Tibetan. Lord Buddha said: Monks, after my passing away, if all the sons and daughters of good family and the faithful, so long as they live, go to the four holy places, they should go and remember: here at Lumbini the enlightened one was born; here at Bodhgaya he attained enlightenment; here at Sarnath he turned twelve wheels of Dharma; and here at Kushinagar he entered parinirvana. Monks, after my passing away there will be activities such as circumambulation of these places and prostration to them. Thus it should be told, for they who have faith in my deeds and awareness of their own will travel to higher states. After my passing away, the new monks who come and ask of the doctrine should be told of these four places and advised that a pilgrimage to them will help purify their previously accumulated negative karmas, even the five heinous actions.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter Panchadasi
    CHAPTER PANCHADASI TRUPTI DEEPA PRAKARANAM (The lamp of Perfect Satisfaction) Volume 2 INDEX S. No Title Page No 1. Lecture 184 a) Verse 88 1402 b) Verse 89 1402 c) Verse 90 1404 d) Verse 91 1410 e) Verse 92 1411 f) Verse 93 1411 g) Verse 94 1411 h) Verse 95 1412 i) Verse 96 1415 j) Verse 97 1416 2. Lecture 185 a) Revision – Previous lecture 1423 b) Verse 98 1424 c) Verse 99 1425 d) Verse 100 1428 e) Verse 101 1428 f) Verse 102 1429 3. Lecture 187 1395 a) Revision – Previous lecture 1431 b) Verse 103 1435 c) Verse 104 1436 d) Verse 105 1438 4. Lecture 188 a) Revision – Previous lecture 1441 b) Verse 106 1443 c) Verse 107 1446 d) Verse 108 1447 5. Lecture 189 a) Verse 108 – Continues 1450 b) Verse 109 1452 c) Verse 110 1454 d) Verse 111 1456 e) Verse 113 1457 6. Lecture 190 a) Revision – Previous lecture 1460 b) Verse 114 1463 c) Verse 115 1465 d) Verse 116 1465 S. No Title Page No 7. Lecture 191 a) Verse 116 – Continues 1467 b) Verse 117 1469 c) Verse 118 1470 d) Verse 119 1471 e) Verse 120 1472 8. Lecture 192 a) Introduction 1475 b) Verse 121 1475 c) Verse 122 1476 d) Verse 123 1478 e) Verse 124 1479 f) Verse 125 1479 g) Verse 126 1480 9. Lecture 193 a) Introduction 1484 b) Verse 127 1486 c) Verse 128 1487 d) Verse 129 1488 e) Verse 130 1489 f) Verse 131 1491 10.
    [Show full text]
  • Sanskrit Commentary
    atha daiväsura-sampad-vibhäga-yogo näma ñoòaço’dhyäyaù (çré-rämänujäcärya-päda-kåta-bhäñyam) atétenädhyäya-trayeëa prakåti-puruñayor viviktayoù saàsåñöayoç ca yäthätmyaà tat-saàsarga- viyogayoç ca guëa-saìga-tad-viparyaya-hetukatvaà, sarva-prakäreëävasthitayoù prakåti- puruñayor bhagavad-vibhütitvam | vibhütimato bhagavato vibhüti-bhütäd acid-vastunaç cid- vastunaç ca baddha-muktobhaya-rüpäd avyayatva-vyäpana-bharaëa-svämyair arthäntaratayä puruñottamatvena yäthätmyaà ca varëitam | anantaram uktasya kåtsnasyärthasya sthemne çästra-vaçyatäà vaktuà çästra-vaçya-tad-viparétayor daiväsura-sargayor vibhägaà çré- bhagavän uväca – abhayaà sattva-saàçuddhir jïäna-yoga-vyavasthitiù | dänaà damaç ca yajïaç ca svädhyäyas tapa ärjavam ||1|| iñöäniñöa-viyoga-saàyoga-rüpasya duùkhasya hetu-darçana-jaà duùkhaà bhayam, tan- nivåttir abhayam | sattva-saàçuddhiù sattvasyäntaù-karaëasya rajas-tamobhyäm asaàspåñöatvam | jïäna-yoga-vyavasthitiù prakåti-viyuktätma-svarüpa-viveka-niñöhä | dänaà nyäyärjita-dhanasya pätre pratipädanam | damo manaso viñayonmukha-nivåtti-saàçélanam | yajïaù phaläbhisandhi-rahita-bhagavad-ärädhana-rüpa-mahäyajïädy-anuñöhänam | svädhyäyaù sa-vibhüter bhagavatas tad-ärädhana-prakärasya ca pratipädakaù kåtsno veda ity anusaàdhäya vedäbhyäsa-niñöhä | tapaù kåcchra-cändräyaëa-dvädaçy-upaväsäder bhagavat- préëana-karma-yogyatäpädanasya karaëam | ||16.1|| --o)0(o-- ärjavam manoväkkäyakarmavåtténäm ekaniñöhä pareñu | ahiàsä satyam akrodhas tyägaù çäntir apaiçunam | dayä bhüteñv aloluptvaà märdavaà hrér acäpalam ||2|| ahiàsä para-péòä-varjanam
    [Show full text]
  • Yoga Sutra Translation by Grischa
    Patañjali Yogasūtra Samādhipādaḥ 1 – 12 translation by Grischa I-1 atha yogānuśāsanam Now (atha) yoga instructions (anuśāsanam). Now implies that you should forget what you “know” about Yoga because Yoga Sūtra defines it! I-2 yogaś citta-vṛtti- Yoga is the „controlling/stilling“ (nirodaḥ) of the “activities, moods, turnings” (vṛtti) of nirodhaḥ our „perceived reality“ (citta). The vṛtti-s are mental processes responsible for categorizing, filtering and even modifying the perceived reality. Patañjali-Yoga first requires you to understand and cultivate beneficial modes of vṛtti-s. We then learn perceiving reality without vṛtti-s and ultimately rest in a state of stillness which is the ultimate goal of Yoga - “Kaivalya”. I-3 tadā draṣṭuḥ svarūpe- Then (tadā) „the seeing“ (draṣṭuḥ) remains (avasthānam) ‘vasthānam in its „self-form“ (sva-rūpe). The principle of consciousness is regarded as the essence of the self, your soul. When the vṛtti-s are stilled one is free from (regarding any part of reality as) suffering. I-4 vṛtti-sārūpyam itaratra Otherwise (itaratra) identification (sārūpyam) of „the seeing“ with the modification (vṛtti). Otherwise we confuse reality with the constructed story of the vṛtti-s. Attachment/identification with these illusions creates suffering to be avoided. I-5 vṛttayaḥ pañcatayyaḥ There are five (pañca) modification principles (vṛtti-s) which are kliṣṭa and/or akliṣṭa kliṣṭākliṣṭāḥ The vrrti-s categorize, filter and alter objective reality into our subjective view of reality. Kliṣṭa-vṛtti-s create an-ego-centric world view which is the foundation of all suffering. Chapter II (“on sādhana”) describes the “aṣṭāṅga method” for reducing kliṣṭa-vṛtti-s in favor of non-kliṣṭa-vṛtti-s.
    [Show full text]
  • Experience of Samadhi
    THE EXPERIENCE OF SAM API 11 An In-depth Exploration of Buddhist Meditation ■ Richard Shan km an ■ Includes interviews with Jack Kornfield, Sharon Salzberg, Christina Feldman, and other teachers The Experience of Samadhi THE EXPERIENCE OF SAMADHI An In-depth Exploration of Buddhist Meditation Richard Shankman SHAMBHALA Boston & London 2 0 0 8 Shambhala Publications, Inc. Horticultural Hall 300 Massachusetts Avenue Boston, Massachusetts 02115 •^^w.shambhala.com © 2008 by Richard Shankman Pages 219-20 constitute a continuation of the copyright page. A l rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, orby any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. 987654321 First Edition Printed in Canada @ This edition is printed on acid-free paper that meets the American National Standards Institute Z39.48 Standard. O This book was printed on 100% postconsumer recycled paper. For more information please visit us at •^^w.shambhala.com. Distributed in the United States by Random House, Inc., and in Canada by Random. House of Canada Ltd Interior design and composition: Greta D. Sibley & Associates Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication- Data Shankman, Richard. The experience of samadhi: an in-depth exploration of Buddhist meditation / Richard Shankman.—1st ed. p. cm. ■ Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-59030-521-8 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. Samadhi. 2. Buddhist literature, Pali—History and criticism. 3. Buddhists—Interviews. 1. Title. BQ5630.S16S43 2008 294^3 '4435 DC22 2008017613 CONTENTS Preface | ix Acknowledgments | xii Introduction | xiii PART ONE SAMADHI IN THE PALI TEXTS I.
    [Show full text]
  • Dying to Live: the Role of Kamma in Dying & Rebirth
    DyingDying toto LiveLive Role of Kamma in Dying and Rebirth by Aggacitta Bhikkhu HAN DD ET U 'S B B O RY eOK LIBRA E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.buddhanet.net Buddha Dharma Education Association Inc. Dying to Live The Role of Kamma in Dying and Rebirth Aggacitta Bhikkhu Edited by Leong Liew Geok Sukhi Hotu Dhamma Publications DYING TO LIVE: The Role of Kamma in Dying and Rebirth Published for free distribution by SUKHI HOTU SDN BHD 42V, Jalan Matang Kuching, 11500 Air Itam, Penang. Tel: 604 8277118 Fax: 604 8277228 11A, 1st Floor, Jalan SS24/8, Taman Megah, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor. Tel: 603 7062833 Fax: 603 7062733 Email: [email protected] Copyright © 1999 AGGACITTA BHIKKHU No part of this book may be reproduced for commercial purposes in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Perpustakaan Negara Malaysia Cataloguing-in-Publication Data Aggacitta Bhikkhu Dying to live : the role of Kamma in dying and rebirth / Aggacitta Bhikkhu ; edited by Leong Liew Geok. ISBN 983-9382-24-1 1. Theravada Buddhism. 2. Meditation—Buddhism. 3. Buddhism–Doctrines. I. Leong, Liew Geok. II. Title. 294.391 Layout by Sukhi Hotu Illustrations by Ng Ai Lin, Chuah Ghee Hin and Toya Printed by Majujaya Indah, Selangor First edition November 1999 Cover Story: The Bhikkhu who became a Deva Suddenly, as if from a dream, he awoke dressed in golden finery and standing at the gates of a glittering mansion.
    [Show full text]