DOCSLIB.ORG

The Development of States and Polities in Southeast Asia: Innovative Connections and Comparisons

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Development of States and Polities in Southeast Asia: Innovative Connections and Comparisons The development of states and polities in Southeast Asia: Innovative connections and comparisons Introduction to a thematic issue Tuong Vu The present special issue of HumaNetten includes four essays about the historical development of the state and polity in Burma, Vietnam, and the archipelagic area east of Java.1 All four articles examine the historical development of Southeast Asian states in original ways. Specifically, we are interested not in studying these polities in the conventional approach, either in isolation or restricted to a particular period. Building on comparative and regional studies by scholars such as Anthony Reid and Victor Lieberman, our articles focus on historical developments in Southeast Asia while seeking to make fresh and innovative connections and comparisons across periods or across regions. These connections and comparisons illuminate important aspects of Southeast Asian history that have been obscured in much existing scholarship. For example, Michael Charney ventures beyond the Southeast Asian region to compare the systems of transport in premodern and colonial Ghana to those in Burma of similar periods. In his paper, Hans Hägerdal contrasts the development of the small-sized kingdoms and principalities east of Java with that of larger states on mainland Southeast Asia. His focus is on the early modern period but he is able to draw implications for later periods. Tuong Vu’s article borrows concepts from studies of central Asia and uses the contrast between China’s northern and southern frontiers to explore the synergies between China and Vietnam over the length of their histories. He offers premodern, early modern, and modern examples of Vietnamese imperialism in the paper. Claire Sutherland calls on scholars of contemporary Southeast Asia to transcend the nation-state as an analytical framework. She proposes the concept of “postmodern mandala” as an alternative way to theorize about contemporary Southeast Asian politics, with Vietnam as a test case. While our articles do not cover every polity or every period in Southeast Asia, we believe the papers together make two important contributions to broad scholarship across the region and beyond. First, the papers enhance our knowledge about the differentiated process of integration and consolidation in Southeast Asia. Hägerdal’s article shows that the process was disrupted in the archipelagic area east of Java because of European penetration in the 1 The four studies in the present special issue were originally presented as papers at the EuroSEAS Conference in Vienna, 12-14 August 2015. We are grateful to eight anonymous reviewers, two per paper, who provided valuable comments to our contributions. Vu: The development of states and polities in Southeast Asia 5 sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Unlike the ongoing consolidation into larger polities on mainland Southeast Asia at the same time, the small kingdoms in this area were able to preserve their autonomy well into the nineteenth century. Charney argues that Burma’s precolonial road system has been neglected in the literature. His paper shows that in this case the expansion of the Konbaung Empire in the early modern period did not lead to significant development of the road system even while the state strived to control mobility throughout its territory. In comparison to a more developed road transport system in Ghana, a legacy of underdevelopment in the Konbaung and colonial periods can be found in the relative durability of the Burma military dictatorship today. In the Vietnamese case, Vu shows interesting parallels between patterns of imperial development throughout the history of this country. The process was shaped by threats from other frontier states, elite fighting, and ambitions of particular leaders. Our second contribution involves historiography. Vu’s article offers a sustained critique of the nationalist historiography that was developed in the colonial period and that remains influential today. According to him, this historiography misunderstands the sources of the negative synergies between “China” and “Vietnam” in the first millennium A.D. when the Red River was under northern rule. In contrast, Sino-Vietnamese relations in the subsequent period when Dai Viet was an independent kingdom were characterized mostly by positive synergies, unlike what nationalist historiography claims. Thanks in part to China, Vu argues, the Vietnamese in early modern and modern periods were able to expand their realm and become an empire that dominated the entire Indochinese peninsular. Sutherland also focuses on the historiography of Vietnam, but her target of criticism is broader, namely the conceptual framework of the Westphalian nation-state with fixed territorial borders separating the domestic from the international realm. As she argues, this state-centric framework obscures connections and networks that overlap and crosscut polities and communities. By investigating the historiography of Vietnam, Sutherland captures the recent shift in scholarly thinking from such a state-centric perspective and suggests a “postmodern mandala” as a metaphor for contemporary polities. Authors and Abstracts Michael W. Charney Professor, School of Oriental and African Studies The University of London, United Kingdom [email protected] Title: Before and after the wheel: Precolonial and colonial states and transportation in West Africa and mainland Southeast Asia Scholarship on Southeast Asia has generally ignored the role of precolonial transportation in religious, political, and even economic life (in contrast to rather more on the colonial period), while historical research on precolonial West Africa has directed great attention to road building, such as that by the Ashanti Kingdom. In both cases, however, the development of colonial transportation infrastructure that came later is depicted as an entirely European and 6 HumaNetten Nr 37 Hösten 2016 foreign political, economic, and even cultural intervention that helped to ensure colonial domination that was both a break with the past as well as the foundation for the kinds of states that emerged after independence. Precolonial transportation and everyday movement and administrative approaches to them are seen as irrelevant to the phenomenon and a standard assertion in the historiography of at least some Southeast Asian countries is that they had no roads at all before British rule. The present article argues instead that certain governmentalities regarding movement and transportation had an important influence on emerging colonial transportation networks and administrative approaches to everyday mobility. The article also suggests that the partial, long-term, and indirect impact of this influence has been the durability or failure thereof of authoritarian regimes in both areas. The article looks primarily at the case studies of Myanmar (British Burma) and Ghana (the colonial Gold Coast), although examples from others countries are used as well. Tuong Vu Professor, Department of Political Science University of Oregon, USA [email protected] Title: State formation on China’s southern frontier: Vietnam as a shadow empire and hegemon State formation in Vietnam followed an imperial pattern, namely, a process of conquests and annexations typical of an empire. At its peak in the early nineteenth century, the frontier of the Vietnamese empire encompassed much of today’s Cambodia and Laos. This imperial pattern was the basis on which the French built their Indochinese colony and the Vietnamese communist state built its modern hegemony. By re-examining Vietnamese history as that of an empire and hegemon, this paper challenges the nationalist historiography’s assumption about Vietnam’s need for survival from China as the driving force of Vietnamese history. In contrast, I argue that the threat to Vietnamese survival has come less from China than from other states on China’s southern frontier. Vietnam has in fact benefited from a positive synergy with China in much of its premodern and modern history. By situating Vietnamese state formation in the context of mainland Southeast Asia, I hope to correct the tendency in many studies that focus exclusively on Sino-Vietnamese dyadic interactions and that posit the two as opposites. Treating Vietnam as an empire or hegemon over a large area of mainland Southeast Asia also is essential to understand why Vietnamese sometimes did not automatically accept Chinese superiority despite the obvious “asymmetry” between them. Vu: The development of states and polities in Southeast Asia 7 Hans Hägerdal Associate Professor in History School of Cultural Sciences Linnaeus University, Sweden [email protected] Title: Trajectories of the early-modern kingdoms in eastern Indonesia; comparative perspectives As well known, a considerable development of statecraft in Southeast Asia took place in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, what Victor Lieberman has termed post-charter states (i.e., replacing older, culturally defining realms). Historical research has so far focused on the principal mainland kingdoms, and the newly Islamized maritime and insular polities. The present paper compares the larger Southeast Asian kingdoms (ca fifteenth-seventeenth centuries) with polities that arose in eastern Indonesia, east of Java. Four regions of political development are defined. These include the indianized kingdoms of Bali and Lombok, the Muslim kingdoms of Sumbawa, the Islamic spice sultanates of North Maluku, and the loosely structured
Load more

Recommended publications
  • State-In-Society 2.0: Toward Fourth-Generation Theories of the State
    Review Article State-in-Society 2.0: Toward Fourth-Generation Theories of the State Yuhua Wang James C. Scott, Against the Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2017). David Stasavage, The Decline and Rise of Democracy: A Global History from Antiquity to Today (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2020). Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, The Narrow Corridor: States, Societies, and the Fate of Liberty (New York: Penguin Press, 2019). Keywords: the state, state formation, state development, democracy, state–society relations. The state is the most powerful organization in human history. Since the first signs of an early state in Mesopotamia around 4000 to 2000 BCE, the state as an institutional structure has undergone numerous transformations in size, function, form, and strength. It has become an organization we cannot live without. How were states formed? Why did they take different paths of development? Why are some states strong and others weak? Why are some states ruled by a democratically elected leader, while others are ruled by an autocrat? These are among the most time- honored questions that have produced generations of remarkable scholarship in the social sciences. I characterize modern social scientific studies of the state as comprising three generations. The first generation, represented in pluralist, structural-functionalist, and neo- Marxisttraditionsdatingbacktothe1950s–70s, takes a society-centered perspective: it views the state as an arena in which different social groups and classes vie for power. The second generation, best reflectedinthemovementto“bring the state back in” in the 1980s, takes a state-centered perspective: it treats the state as an independent actor that is doi: 10.5129/001041521X16184035797221 1 Comparative Politics October 2021 autonomous from society.
    [Show full text]
  • Emergence of Chiefdoms and States: a Spectrum of Opinions
    Emergence of Chiefdoms and States: A Spectrum of Opinions Leonid E. Grinin Volgograd Centre for Social Research Andrey V. Korotayev Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow INTRODUCTION As has been already mentioned in the introductory editorial com- ment that opens this issue, the discussion has demonstrated a pro- found interest in its subject, and we would like to express our grati- tude to Carneiro and all the discussants. This discussion presents a very wide spectrum of opinions on a rather wide range of impor- tant topics. One can also find a wide spectrum of opinions, a sort of unique snapshot of the current state of Political Anthropology as regards the study of the emergence of chiefdoms and states, as well as the driving forces of sociopolitical evolution. The discussion has demonstrated that none of the proposed ap- proaches can be characterized as being absolutely right. In certain respects the presented critique of some points of Carneiro's theory looks convincing, but in some other cases Carneiro's reasoning ap- pears more persuasive. Below we shall try to make as more an ob- jective assessment of the present discussion as possible. CARNEIRO'S UNEXPECTED DECISION Carneiro's circumscription theory has become very widely recog- nized in the sense that it is always taken into account when the leading approaches to the study of state formation are analyzed. Almost all the discussants (further also referred to as participants) recognize certain merits of this theory, even when disagreeing with Carneiro or criticizing its certain points. Some participants of our Social Evolution & History, Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Book Review Essay
    Cliodynamics: the Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical History State Formation in Hawai’i A Review of How Chiefs Became Kings: Divine Kingship and the Rise of Archaic States in Ancient Hawai'i by Patrick V. Kirch (University of California Press, 2010) Michael E. Smith Arizona State University Are the indigenous societies of Hawaii best classified as chiefdoms, or should we instead consider them states? While this may sound at first like a rather limited, academic, question, in fact it has wide-ranging implications. In this book archaeologist Patrick Kirch overturns decades of anthropological orthodoxy (including his own earlier views) to argue strongly that the Hawaiian polities were in fact states, not chiefdoms. In anthropological research on cultural evolution the indigenous societies of Hawaii have long been viewed as the archetypical examples of chiefdom societies. Chiefdoms are a type of society intermediate in scale between relatively egalitarian and small-scale village farming societies on the one hand (variously called tribes, intermediate societies, or Neolithic villages), and state- level societies on the other (large, socially stratified societies with a centralized government). Although traditional evolutionary typologies—such as the well- known sequence of band-tribe-chiefdom-state—have been criticized by postmodern archaeologists and others (e.g., Yoffee 2005; Pauketat 2007), the chiefdom concept has become established as a useful framework for archaeologists employing a materialist and scientific perspective on the past (Earle 1997; Drennan and Peterson 2006; Wright 2006; Gavrilets et al. 2010; Kradin 2011). Patrick Kirch is an archaeologist who has conducted much fieldwork on Hawaii and other Pacific islands. In this book he reverses his earlier analyses of Hawaii as a chiefdom (e.g., Kirch 1984; Kirch and Sahlins 1992; Kirch 2000).
    [Show full text]
  • Gender Relations, Family Systems and Economic Development: Explaining the Reversal of Fortune in Eurasia
    Gender Relations, Family Systems and Economic Development: Explaining the Reversal of Fortune in EurAsia Sarah Carmichael, Alexandra M. de Pleijt and Jan Luiten van Zanden Utrecht University Email corresponding author: < [email protected] > Preliminary version, please do not quote Abstract This paper argues that gender relations matter for economic development, and in particular help to explain growth trajectories in EurAsia between the Neolithic Revolution and the present. Firstly, we offer a set of hypotheses drawn from the literature about the links between gender relations and economic development. Secondly, we approach gender relations via the classification and measurement of historical family systems, and offer a set of global maps of the institutions concerning marriage, inheritance and family formation that determine the degree of agency that women enjoyed at the micro level. Thirdly, we use these concepts to explain the genesis of the EurAsian pattern in family systems and gender relations as a by-product of the spread of agriculture and the process of ancient state formation that followed the Neolithic Revolution 10,000 years ago. Finally, we link these patterns in family systems and female agency to economic growth after 1300; we empirically demonstrate that high female agency was conducive to growth between 1500 and 1800 and was also positively correlated to growth during the Great Divergence between 1800 and 2000. The ‘reversal of fortune’ that happened within EurAsia between 1000 and 2000, whereby the ancient centers of state formation and urbanization in the Middle East, India and China were overtaken by regions at the margin of the continent (Western Europe, Japan, Korea), can be explained by the spatial patterns in gender relations and family systems found there (and reconstructed here).
    [Show full text]
  • The Caste Question: Dalits and the Politics of Modern India
    chapter 1 Caste Radicalism and the Making of a New Political Subject In colonial India, print capitalism facilitated the rise of multiple, dis- tinctive vernacular publics. Typically associated with urbanization and middle-class formation, this new public sphere was given material form through the consumption and circulation of print media, and character- ized by vigorous debate over social ideology and religio-cultural prac- tices. Studies examining the roots of nationalist mobilization have argued that these colonial publics politicized daily life even as they hardened cleavages along fault lines of gender, caste, and religious identity.1 In west- ern India, the Marathi-language public sphere enabled an innovative, rad- ical form of caste critique whose greatest initial success was in rural areas, where it created novel alliances between peasant protest and anticaste thought.2 The Marathi non-Brahmin public sphere was distinguished by a cri- tique of caste hegemony and the ritual and temporal power of the Brah- min. In the latter part of the nineteenth century, Jotirao Phule’s writings against Brahminism utilized forms of speech and rhetorical styles asso- ciated with the rustic language of peasants but infused them with demands for human rights and social equality that bore the influence of noncon- formist Christianity to produce a unique discourse of caste radicalism.3 Phule’s political activities, like those of the Satyashodak Samaj (Truth Seeking Society) he established in 1873, showed keen awareness of trans- formations wrought by colonial modernity, not least of which was the “new” Brahmin, a product of the colonial bureaucracy. Like his anticaste, 39 40 Emancipation non-Brahmin compatriots in the Tamil country, Phule asserted that per- manent war between Brahmin and non-Brahmin defined the historical process.
    [Show full text]
  • POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: an Introduction, Third Edition
    POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: An Introduction, Third Edition Ted C. Lewellen PRAEGER Political Anthropology POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY An Introduction Third Edition Ted C. Lewellen Foreword by Victor Turner, Written for the First Edition Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lewellen, Ted C., 1940– Political anthropology : an introduction / Ted C. Lewellen ; foreword to the first edition by Victor Turner.—3rd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–89789–890–7 (alk. paper)—ISBN 0–89789–891–5 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Political anthropology. I. Title. GN492.L48 2003 306.2—dc21 2003052889 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright ᭧ 2003 by Ted C. Lewellen All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2003052889 ISBN: 0–89789–890–7 0–89789–891–5 (pbk.) First published in 2003 Praeger Publishers, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.praeger.com Printed in the United States of America The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10987654321 CONTENTS Foreword, Written for the First Edition vii Victor Turner Preface ix 1. The Development of Political Anthropology 1 2. Types of Preindustrial Political Systems 15 3. The Evolution of the State 43 4. Religion in Politics: Sacred Legitimacy, Divine Resistance 65 5. Structure and Process 81 6. The Individual in the Political Arena: Action Theory and Game Theory 95 7.
    [Show full text]
  • CONFLICTING CONCEPTIONS of the STATE: Siam, France and Vietnam in the Late Nineteenth Century
    CONFLICTING CONCEPTIONS OF THE STATE: Siam, France and Vietnam in the Late Nineteenth Century MARTIN STUART-FOX UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND The first advance of French imperialism in Indochina had by ranee of the position of others. This paper seeks to analyze these 1867 gained for France the colony of Cochinchina and a protec­ conceptions of the state and show how they influenced the torate over some two-thirds of present-day Cambodia. The actions and responses of the three nations involved. Franco-Prussian war and events in Europe briefly distracted French attention from the Far East, but not for long. Once the expedition of Doudart de Lagree and Francis Garnier had CONCEPTIONS OF THE STATE shown conclusively that the Mekong could never serve as "a river road to China," interest shifted to the Red River. Hanoi was Historians of Southeast Asia often face problems in using terms seized in November 1873. Attempts by Vietnamese Emperor Tu drawn from and applicable to European polities and societies to Due to reactivate Vietnam's tributary dependence on China refer to non-European equivalents that do not conform to (1879) only provided an excuse for further French encroach­ European models. Even terms like "divinity," "kingship," and ments. Tonkin was occupied and brought under French control "power" need to be glossed to bring out regional cultural differ­ (1883-1885), though resistance of one form or another contin­ ences, and to reveal the complexities that distinguish non­ ued well into the 1890s. European from European understanding of relationships and The seizure of Tonkin and imposition of French protection meanings implicit in their connotations.
    [Show full text]
  • 2 the Origins and Limits of Coercive Power
    22 Power and Its Disguises their objectives on a global scale. Though particular situations always reflect the interaction of the local and the global, local social and cultural histories I' now find expression in action in ways that are part of a common experience of modernity. as I stress in Chapter 7. Only concrete, contextualized analysis 2 THE ORIGINS AND LIMITS OF COERCIVE of particular situations will enable us to understand what is happening and POWER: THE ANTHROPOLOGY OF why it is happening (in Europe and the United States as well as other parts of the world). But little that is happening anywhere can be understood STATELESS SOCIETIES without reference to the historical discontinuities produced by the rise of the modern state and modern forms of power. Although Clastres' s polemic against traditional political anthropology would be an appropriate starting-point for a discussion of 'stateless' societies. the late Stanley Diamond advanced a critique of the state which is broader than Clastres's observations about indigenous South American societies. Diamond's 19 51 PhD dissertation was an ethnohistorical study of state formation in the West African kingdom ofDahomey, but his wider paradigm for a 'dialectical anthropology' reflected his New York Jewish background and experience as a volunteer with the British Army during the Second World War in North Africa. There he met Black African 'volunteers' from South Africa. Pressed into service by the South African government through the good offices of chiefly clients of the regime, these men were sent to die in an unknown land in an unknown cause in place of Whites (Gailey 1992: 4).
    [Show full text]
  • The Construction of Gender Identity in Indonesia
    Rachmah Ida, "The Construction of Gender Identity in Indonesia: between Cultural Norms, Economic Impli cations, and State Formation," Masyarakat, Kebudayaan dan Politik , Th XIV, No 1, Januari 2001, 21-34. THE CONSTRUCTION OF GENDER IDENTITY IN INDONESIA: BETWEEN CULTURAL NORMS, ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS, AND STATE FORMATION * Rachmah Ida Lecturer at Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Airlangga University ; graduated from Airlangga University (BA), and Edith Cowan University (MA) Abstrak Tulisan ini membahas bagaimana identitas perempuan dan laki -laki dalam era transfor- masi di Indonesia telah dikonstruksi oleh norma -norma budaya dan sosial yang berke m- bang dalam masyarakat serta formasi negara dalam wacana penciptaan/pembentukan identitas-identitas warganya terutama konsep dan terminologi ‘perempuan’ sebagai ibu, istri, dan jati diri perempuan itu sendiri. Dalam tulisan ini disinggung pula bagaimana organisasi-organisasi perempuan Islam seperti Muslimat dan Aisiyah telah berupaya m e- lakukan diskusi publik tentang perlunya melakukan reinterpretasi terhadap penafsiran dalil-dalil agama tentang peran dan kedudukan perempuan. Kata-kata Kunci: gender, Indonesia, norma -norma, budaya, sosial, formasi negara, Musilmat, Aisiyah The position of women in t he trans- ciety, still follow and hold the ideal formation era of Indonesia is still norms of traditional Javanese cu l- considered problematic. Indo nesia is ture and the tenets of Islam. On the in transition from being an agrarian contrary, ‘modern women’ are pe r- society to becoming an i ndustrial ceived as having a modern lifestyle society or between traditional and following the global movement and modern. Consequently, women as develop themselves in adapting to members of the society are also in a the movement of modernization a c- similar crucial position.
    [Show full text]
  • The Politics of Development in Botswana : a Model for Success?
    The politics of development in Botswana : a model for success? http://www.aluka.org/action/showMetadata?doi=10.5555/AL.SFF.DOCUMENT.crp3b10008 Use of the Aluka digital library is subject to Aluka’s Terms and Conditions, available at http://www.aluka.org/page/about/termsConditions.jsp. By using Aluka, you agree that you have read and will abide by the Terms and Conditions. Among other things, the Terms and Conditions provide that the content in the Aluka digital library is only for personal, non-commercial use by authorized users of Aluka in connection with research, scholarship, and education. The content in the Aluka digital library is subject to copyright, with the exception of certain governmental works and very old materials that may be in the public domain under applicable law. Permission must be sought from Aluka and/or the applicable copyright holder in connection with any duplication or distribution of these materials where required by applicable law. Aluka is a not-for-profit initiative dedicated to creating and preserving a digital archive of materials about and from the developing world. For more information about Aluka, please see http://www.aluka.org The politics of development in Botswana : a model for success? Author/Creator Picard, Louis A. Publisher L. Rienner Publishers (Boulder) Date 1987 Resource type Books Language English Subject Coverage (spatial) Botswana Source Northwestern University Libraries, Melville J. Herskovits Library of African Studies, 968.11 P586p Rights By kind permission of Louis A. Picard and Lynne Rienner Publishers, Inc. Description The State and Society. The Tswana Polities and British Colonialism in Southern Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • "Segmentary State" and Politics of Centralization in Medieval Ayudhya
    88 SUNAIT CHUTINT ARANOND "Iudia ou Sian" by A llain Mannesson Mallet, 1683. "MANDALA," "SEGMENTARY STATE" AND POLITICS OF CENTRALIZATION IN MEDIEVAL AYUDHYA SUNAIT CHUTINTARANOND DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY, FACULTY OF ARTS CHULALONGKORN UNIVERSITY theory is based on the. assumption that the king, by One of the most common uses of the term mandala is nature, aspires to conquest, an~ that the adjacent king defined as follows in every standard Sanskrit-English diction­ is his enemy-for the two are not in immediate com­ ary: "A circular orb, globe, wheel, ring, circumference, any­ petition and the other neighbor of the enemy would also stand to bendfit from the weakening of the latter. thing round or circular."1 However, this term means "circle" in Surround and conquer.8 many senses:2 in its geo-cosmological connotation, it is the circle of continents around the central mountain of the universe-­ My primary concern is not, however, to provide any Mount Meru;3 in a ritual sense, it is borrowed to describe any detailed discussion regarding the origins and the diagram of magic circle used in sorcery;4 in politics, it is the circle of a king's Kautilya's mandala construction, which have already been illus­ near and distant neighbors.5 The political meaning of the term trated in ancient Sanskrit manuscripts and extensively described mandala is directly illustrated in the Arthasastra of Kautilya (a in books on Indian political philosophy.9 Instead, I am inter­ Machiavellian Hindu text on political management tradition­ ested in the ways in which Kautilya's theory of mandala has been ally attributed to Kautilya at the end of the fourth century B.C., interpreted by historians for the purpose of studying ancient but, in fact, at least as likely to represent a school compiled at states in South and Southeast Asia.
    [Show full text]
  • "United in Diversity"?: Problems of State- and Nation-Building in Post
    "UNITED IN DIVERSITY"?: PROBLEMS OF STATE- AND NATION-BUILDING IN POST- CONFLICT SITUATIONS: THE CASE OF BOSNIA- HERZEGOVINA Joseph Marko* I. UNITED IN DIVERSITY? EUROPEAN CHALLENGES A. Two Models of the EuropeanNation-State The motto of "United in Diversity,"' coined for the United States, is now also prominently featured in the preamble of the Treaty Establishing a Constitution for Europe.2 Currently, globalization and economic and cultural homogenization affect the European Union and her member states. At the same time, European integration has set in motion market liberalization and its accompanying legal homogenization. As such, is this motto only a hollow phrase? When comparing U.S. federalism to EU integration, one must initially account for an important aspect-the American colonies, before and after winning a war of independence, never became nation-states in the sense of modem ethnonationalism. 3 Quite the contrary, the process of European integration after 1945 was based on processes of state formation and nation- building spanning several centuries. For example, nation-building in Western Europe, dating back to the Medieval Ages, left Europe politically fragmented. This fragmentation is thus not only due to the East-West divide of the Cold War between the Soviet empire and Western democratic states, but also due to the different state structures that these nation-states have adopted. Despite the breakdown of communism in 1989, this political situation continues to affect south East Europe today. * Professor of Public Law and Political Sciences, University of Graz, Austria; Director of the Minority Rights Institute, European Academy Bozen-Bolzano, Italy. From 1997 to 2002, Joseph Marko was one of the three international judges on the Constitutional Court of Bosnia-Herzegovina appointed under the Dayton Agreement by the President of the European Court of Human Rights.
    [Show full text]