Giacomini Marsh Restoration Site Special Status Animal Species: Reconnaissance and Compliance
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Giacomini Marsh Restoration Site Special Status Animal Species: Reconnaissance and Compliance Final Report to the National Park Service Point Reyes National Seashore prepared by Avocet Research Associates 65 Third Street, Suite 25 Point Reyes Station, California 94956-0839 22 November 2002 Please cite this report as follows: Avocet Research Associates. 2002. Giacomini Wetlands Restroation Site: Special Status Animal Species—reconnaissance and compliance. Final Report to Point Reyes National Seashore, National Park Service. 22 November 2002. Giacomini Wetlands Restoration Site Special Status Animal Species: Reconnaissance and Compliance Lead author Jules Evens Avocet Research Associates 65 Third Street, Suite 25, Point Reyes Station, California 94956-0839 415/663-1148 <[email protected]> Contributing authors William Carmen, PhD, Carmen Ecological Consulting. Richard Stallcup, Avocet Research Associates and Point Reyes Bird Observatory Sean White, Carmen Ecological Consulting. Viola Toniola, Point Reyes Bird Observatory. Project title Environmental Compliance/Baseline Wildlife Surveys for the Giacomini Wetland Restoration Project. Task Agreement No. 009 Cooperative Agreement No. 1443-CA-8530-00-44 between the National Park Service, Point Reyes National Seashore and The Point Reyes Bird Observatory. Government Technical Representatives Lorraine Parsons, Wetland Ecologist, Point Reyes National Seashore. 415/464-5193 Brannon Ketchum, Hydrologist, Point Reyes National Seashore Kristi Swofford, Contracting Officer, Point Reyes National Seashore. i Giacomini Wetlands Restoration Site Special Status Animal Species Table of Contents Section I Executive summary Section II. Introduction and overview II-a. Regional context II-b. Wildlife resources II-c. Invertebrates II-d. Fishes II-e. Herpetofauna II-f. Birds II-g. Mammals Section III. Species accounts of special status animal species known to have occurred or potentially occurring on the site. III-a. Federally Threatened and Endangered Species III-b. Federal Species of Concern III-c. California Species of Special Concern III-d. “Species to watch” III-e. Unlisted species of local concern or conservation importance. III-f. Candidate species (listed or denied) Section IV. Literature cited. List of figures. Table I. Special status animals potentially affected by restoration. Table II-A: Special status animal species: listed status and occurrence Table II-B: Annotated list of special status animal species: habitat and local occurrence. ii Appendices: reports of field surveys Appendix A. Red-legged Frog Surveys at Giacomini Wetlands, Point Reyes National Seashore. By Gary M. Fellers and Greg Guscio. Appendix B. California Freshwater Shrimp (Syncaris pacifica) and Tidewater Goby (Eucyclogobius newberryi) Surveys, Giacomini Ranch, Marin Co. by Darren Fong Appendix C1. An Evaluation of Fish Resources on Giacomini Ranch by William Carmen. Appendix C2. Fish Surveys at Giacomini Wetlands Restoration Site, 2002 by William Carmen and Sean White. Appendix D. Breeding Bird Survey of Giacomini Wetlands, 2002 by Jules Evens, Richard Stallcup, and Viola Toniolo. Appendix E. Winter Bird surveys of Giacomini Wetlands: Nov. 1, 2001-Feb. 15-2002. by Jules Evens and Richard Stallcup Appendix F. Fall Bird surveys of Giacomini Wetlands: Aug. 1 –Nov. 1, 2001 by Jules Evens and Richard Stallcup Appendix G1. Mammals of the Giacomini Wetlands by William Carmen. Appendix G2. Small mammal field surveys at Giacomini Wetlands by William Carmen iii Section I. Executive Summary As a necessary component of the compliance phase of the Giacomini Wetland Restoration Project, this report documents wildlife use and occurrence of special status animal species on the restoration study site. We collected information from the California Natural Diversity Data Base (NDDB), the USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS), as well as National Park Service (NPS) biologists, local scientists and naturalists. We also conducted general surveys to document overall wildlife use and focused surveys to document use by special status species. The Giacomini wetlands lie in the historic floodplain of Lagunitas Creek, the dominant watercourse in the Tomales Bay watershed. Beginning in 1947, the mouth of Lagunitas Creek was channelized and manmade levees were constructed along the northern edge of the tidal marsh in order to convert the historic wetlands into pastureland for the Giacomini ranch. The channelization of Lagunitas Creek and the diking and conversion of tidal marsh to agricultural pasture has resulted in a general decline in wildlife resources. Nevertheless, the study site currently supports a diverse array of animal species, a large proportion of which have some special status because their populations are considered at-risk. The biodiversity found on the study site mirrors that found in adjacent habitats and the wider region. The mosaic of habitats in the project area, and the close proximity of a diverse mix of wetlands, provides a complex of habitats that further enhances the wildlife use of the study site. Nearby wetland habitats include open bay, estuarine sloughs and creeks, tidal flats, tidal marsh, brackish and freshwater marsh, and riparian thickets. Upland habitats in the immediate vicinity include mixed broadleaf evergreen forest, conifer forest, coastal scrub, coastal grassland, and remnant coastal prairie. In total, 77 special status species occur on or immediately adjacent to the project area. The preponderance (approximately 70%) of these special status species would not be affected by habitat restoration, largely because their occurrence is incidental to the habitat characteristics of the site. Twenty one special status species known to occur on or adjacent to the site that might be potentially affected by habitat changes include— one reptile, one amphibian, one mammal, two invertebrates, five fish, and eleven birds (Table 1 I). Almost all of these species are associated with wetland habitats—riparian, fresh, brackish or tidal marshes, or associated watercourses. Table I. Special status species potentially occurring at the Giacomini wetlands that may be directly affected by restoration alternatives. Scientific name Common name Status† Habitat Mammals Lutra canadensis sonorae southwestern river otter CSC watercourse Birds Agelius tricolor tricolored blackbird CSC, pasture, marsh BSSC1 Circus cyaneus northern harrier BSSC2. marsh & field Coturnicops noveboracensis yellow rail BSSC2 Marsh Dendroica petechia brewsteri yellow warbler BSSC2,S riparian forest 2 Elanus leucurus white-tailed kite CSC, S3 marsh & fields Empidonax difficilis pacific-slope flycatcher CSC Riparian Geothlypis trichas sinuosa common yellowthroat CSC, Marshes BSSC2 Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus California black rail CT Marsh Nycticorax nycticorax black-crowned night-heron CSC, S3 riparian/marsh Porzana Carolina sora BSSC3 Marsh Rallus longirostris obsoletus California clapper rail FE Marsh Amphibians & Reptiles Rana aurora draytonii California red-legged frog FT fresh marsh Clemmys marmorata mormorata northwestern pond turtle CSC fresh marsh Fishes Eucyclogobius newberryi tidewater goby FE tidal waterways Lavinia symmetricus ssp 2 Tomales roach CSC tidal waterways Oncorhynchus kisutch coho salmon FT tidal waterways Oncorhynchus mykiss irideus steelhead FT tidal waterways Oncorhynchus tshawytscha chinook salmon FT tidal waterways Invertebrates Ischnura gemina San Francisco forktail FC upland marsh damselfly fresh pools Syncaris pacifica California freshwater shrimp FE fresh stream † Listing codes FE Federal Endangered; FT Federal Threatened; FC Federal Candidate; CT California Threatened; CSC California Special Concern Species (CDFG 2002c); BSSC California Department of Fish and Game Bird Species of Special Concern, numeral following (1-3) indicates priority ranking (CDFG 2002a); S = Natural Heritage status rankings at the S (subnational) level for California S1 = critically imperiled, S2 = imperiled, S3 = vulnerable to extirpation or extinction. S4 =Statewide population apparently secure, factors exist to cause concern (NatureServe 2001; see for expanded definitions). 2 Several species that occur on the site serve to illustrate the opportunities available and the constraints imposed by special status species if habitat restoration, conversion, or enhancement occurs. • The endangered tidewater goby was discovered during this study in a remnant portion of lower Tomasini Creek. The creek’s course had been altered as part of the water budget management operation on the Giacomini ranch, however a malfunctioning tide gate at the mouth has allowed some tidal influence, a fortuitous situation for this estuarine fish whose habitat had been eliminated elsewhere on the study site. The opportunity for restoration and/or enhancement of tidewater goby habitat on the site is high. • The threatened California red-legged frog has a viable breeding population in the freshwater marsh on the western portion of the study site. This population exists because of the perennial flow of freshwater into a remnant tidal marsh and because of a relatively abundant source population of frogs on adjacent lands. The delicate salinity range tolerated by this species, and its susceptibility to predation by bullfrogs (also present on portions of the study site), is a constraint that will have to be addressed as restoration alternatives are evaluated. • The threatened California black rail is resident in the fully-tidal marsh immediately adjacent to the study site;