Document generated on 10/02/2021 10:47 p.m.

Ontario History

Strange Fatality: The Battle of Stoney Creek, 1813 By James E. Elliott Robin Wylie

Volume 102, Number 1, Spring 2010

URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1065603ar DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1065603ar

See table of contents

Publisher(s) The Historical Society

ISSN 0030-2953 (print) 2371-4654 (digital)

Explore this journal

Cite this review Wylie, R. (2010). Review of [Strange Fatality: The Battle of Stoney Creek, 1813 By James E. Elliott]. Ontario History, 102(1), 128–129. https://doi.org/10.7202/1065603ar

Copyright © The Ontario Historical Society, 2010 This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/

This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal. Its mission is to promote and disseminate research. https://www.erudit.org/en/ 128 ONTARIO HISTORY

Strange Fatality: The Bat- tle of Stoney Creek, 1813 By James E. Elliott Toronto: Robin Brass Studio, 2009. viii + 311 pages. $24.95 soft- cover. ISBN 978-1-896941-58-5 (www.rbstudiobooks.com)

n the early hours of Sunday, 6 June 1813, Elliott be­ the in the Niagara Penin- gins his nar- sula launched a desperate night attack rative with Ion a much larger American force at Stoney the Ameri- Creek (near Hamilton, Ontario). Despite can taking of near disaster at the outset, a small group Fort George of British regulars managed to capture by amphibi- the American artillery and, in the process, ous invasion and the British retreat to Queen- capture the two American commanders, ston. Brigadier General Vincent decided to Brigadier Generals Chandler and Winder. withdraw to Burlington Heights (Hamil- Beginning with this desperate gamble—a ton) where some 1,800 troops were poised. night attack by some eight hundred Brit- Two American brigades pursued, reaching ish troops upon a force of more than three Gage farm, camping just west of the hamlet thousand Americans—the American cam- of Stoney Creek. Reconnaissance revealed paign to capture the Niagara peninsula un- how vulnerable the British would be in an ravelled. The Americans retreated to Fort open, daylight contest, and therefore they George and by December 1813 had aban- gambled on the surprise night attack. The doned Canadian territory for the safety of American army was known to be poorly state. The battle of Stoney Creek led by politically appointed generals and has thus entered the list of decisive strug- had few, experienced regular soldiers. The gles, from Heights in 1812 to Gage farm camp was no exception. It had Lundy’s Lane in 1814, in the successful de- few pickets and the artillery had no infan- fense of in the try support. on the Niagara frontier. The action began at 2:20 a.m. on6 James Elliott, a journalist with the June and lasted about one hour. Some Hamilton Spectator and a consultant for 800 British regulars easily overcame the Canada: A People’s History, has written pickets (most of whom were sleeping) and an account of this defensive victory that is charged the Americans camped out on the intensely detailed, carefully documented, meadow below the farm. However, inap- well illustrated, and relatively well organ- propriate cheering by the British lost the ized. He breaks up those decisive days of element of surprise, and their command the American invasion (27 May-9 June and control of the troops broke down. The 1813) into some forty units of narrative majority of the American infantry rallied description in which both American and at the brow of the meadow and poured a British actions are told and examined. withering fire down upon the British. The Eight appendices focus on the order of bat- British scattered to the woods, but one tle, weapons and casualties. small group captured the American artil- book reviews 129 lery, plus the two American commanders, forensic methods have been able to dem- and the American defense fragmented. onstrate the brutal character of the battle, From initial surprise, to incipient disaster, possibly including battlefield executions. to sudden victory, the British organized a And thirdly, Elliott challenges the rather rapid retreat before dawn could reveal how perverse reinterpretation, by Victorian- low their strength really was. The Ameri- era citizens, of the meaning of the Stoney cans withdrew to Fort George amid fear Creek Battlefield Park for (apparently) of a counter-offensive by the Royal Navy, their own purposes. He claims that the and were on the defensive for the rest of park displays (including a monument built 1813. Elliott estimates that over 200 Brit- to rival Brock’s at Queenston Heights) do ish troops were imprisoned, wounded or not properly refect the military and politi- killed, a casualty rate of 25 per cent versus cal circumstances: a representative example the American rate of about 10 per cent. of the great power of military competition Elliott gives a stirring account of these that characterized eastern North America events but some contextual comments are until the War of 1812. Elliott finds the in order. Despite the strong production— park to have been, instead, an expression organization, maps, and historic images— of late nineteenth century imperialism, and his care in documenting both sides of focused on Canadian settlers who were by- the story in greater detail than ever before, standers in the clash, and celebrating peace some reorganization would help the nar- with the . This is all provoca- rative. Readers need a timeline. Failure to tive thinking, and it is a mystery why El- conclude the narrative with the American liott has relegated the role of critical versus evacuation in 1813 is odd. The appendices social memory to a remote part of such an could also be reordered, placing the rel- engaging manuscript. evant War of 1812 material first. Three of the appendices conceal what Robin Wylie I would regard as the most significant as- Douglas College, Vancouver, B.C. pect of the book: challenging assumed truths. First, Elliott debunks the claimed Bibliography: role of Canadian scouts like Billy Green, Canada: A People’s History, Videorecording. for which there appears to be no docu- Toronto: Canadian Broadcasting Corpora- mentation. Next, he shows how modern tion, 2000-2001.

“Union is Strength”: W. L. Mackenzie, the Children of Peace, and the Emer- gence of Joint Stock Democracy in Upper Canada By Albert Schrauwers Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2009. 320 pages. $70.00 hard- cover. ISBN 978-0-8020-9927-3 (www.utppublishing.com)

n this tightly-packed, ambitious is a tale of corporate, charitable, commer- volume, Albert Schrauwers depicts cial, and political development. If it has a a fresh version of the history of hero, it is not William Lyon Mackenzie UpperI Canada of the 1820s and 1830s. It (despite the book’s title), but David Will-