Pursuing the Infinite the Mathematicians and the Heretical Sect Is Not in Doubt

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Pursuing the Infinite the Mathematicians and the Heretical Sect Is Not in Doubt NATURE|Vol 458|23 April 2009 OPINION population are sustained for the rest of this the best we can hope is that we can manage that some infinite sets were larger than others. century, but at a huge cost — the complete them ourselves, taking over the heavy respon- A group of French mathematicians at the turn loss of all the natural ecosystems of the world. sibility for keeping Earth habitable, which Gaia of the century — including Emile Borel, Henri Most of us, living in cities and insulated from once did for us automatically. Lebesgue and René Baire — were searching the natural environment, would barely notice The more likely outcome is that we would for a systematic way to determine the size of until it was too late to do anything about it. barely manage them at all. In that case, we these infinite sets. This aroused the scepticism This is what many politicians, economists and would face a sequence of global environmental of colleagues such as Henri Poincaré, who industrialists seem to want — their mantra of crises and a steady degradation of the planetary claimed that Cantor’s hierarchy of infinities unceasing economic growth implies that we environment that would eventually kill just as had “a whiff of form without matter, which should take for ourselves all Gaia’s resources many of us as a sudden collapse. Given that, is repugnant to the French spirit”. According and squeeze from them the maximum short- perhaps we had better hope that Lovelock is to the authors, the French researchers found term gain, leaving nothing for the future. right, and Gaia does for us — or most of us — themselves at the edge of an “intellectual Following this vision, we will need to trans- before we do for her. ■ abyss” where, “under the influence of their form the entire planet into a factory farm to Andrew Watson is a professor at the School of ultra-rationalistic traditions, they lost their feed our 10 billion or 15 billion mouths. There Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia, nerve” and abandoned their work. will be no room on this giant spherical feedlot Norwich NR4 7TJ, UK. The situation was different in Moscow, for anything but ourselves and our half-dozen e-mail: [email protected] where the Russian mathematicians took up species of domestic plants and animals. Gaia, the same problems with zeal and eventually the natural Earth system, will have disappeared. Watch Oliver Morton’s interview with James resolved them, advancing the far-reaching As for the underpinning biogeochemical cycles, Lovelock at www.nature.com/nature/videoarchive. field of measure theory and launching descriptive set theory. Graham and Kantor argue that the spiritual views of these math- ematicians were crucial to their scholarly work. That there were ties between some of Pursuing the infinite the mathematicians and the heretical sect is not in doubt. The geometer Dmitri Egorov Naming Infinity: A True Story of Religious a number of Russian intellectuals. Among believed in name worshipping. His student Mysticism and Mathematical Creativity them was a handful of mathematicians in Pavel Florensky, a mathematician turned by Loren Graham and Jean-Michel Kantor Moscow who, working in the young field theologian, held that the ‘set of all sets’ might Belknap/Harvard University Press: 2009. of set theory, also found themselves dealing be God himself. The eminent mathematician 256 pp. $25.95, £19.95 with the infinite. Nikolai Luzin was privately sympathetic to These Russian mathematicians had been the sect. racing their French colleagues to take the None of this illuminates a substantive con- Religious mystics have a long history of measure of infinite sets of real numbers. In nection between the ideas of the monks and borrowing from mathematics. It is less com- 1891 the German mathematician Georg Can- the mathematicians. These Russian scholars mon for mathematicians to draw on religion. tor made a crucial advance when he proved did push forward where the French would In Naming Infinity, historian of science Loren not, so it is reasonable to ask whether their Graham and mathematician Jean-Michel Kan- religion gave them an edge: did their belief tor argue that an esoteric Christian sect con- that both God and sets could be named into tributed to advances in set theory in Russia existence help them deal more creatively in the first decades of the twentieth century. with the infinite? The authors do not settle In pursuing their claim, they reveal a much this question, and never fully explain why the larger drama: the flourishing of mathemat- work of the Russians should have required a ics under the repression of the early Soviet belief in name worshipping as opposed to regime. another spiritual belief. In the end, they back- Graham and Kantor pedal to say they are “not claiming a unique begin in 1913, when the or necessary relationship” between mysticism Imperial Russian Navy and mathematics but are merely saying that stormed a monastery on the heresy of name worshipping “played a role a Greek peninsula where in their conceptions”. They don’t, however, say a sect of Russian Orthodox what that role was. monks had fled to pursue a Whatever their ties, the mathematicians 24–30; 1991/SPRINGER SCI. & BUS. MEDIA; N. MALYSHEV/ITAR-TASS 24–30; 13, mystical practice known as and the heretics suffered similar fates under name worshipping. Holding the Soviet regime. For a time both escaped the heretical view that God the worst treatment. The name-worshippers comes into existence when named, these hid in the shadows as Vladimir Lenin went monks believed that repeating the name of after the mainstream Orthodox church. MATH. INTELLIGENCER MATH. Jesus while controlling their breath and heart- Mathematicians survived longer than other beat would bring them closer to the infinite. academics because, unlike physicists or Their persecution at the hands of the Tsar in Secret-police archives document the execution of chemists, they did not need special equip- C. E. FORD C. E. FORD the ensuing years aroused the sympathy of mathematician Pavel Florensky by the Soviet regime. ment, and unlike historians or philosophers, 971 © 2009 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved OPINION NATURE|Vol 458|23 April 2009 their findings did not immediately fall foul useful to the government. It is not clear why ‘right’ size places it correctly in its — and our of Soviet dogma. Stalin listened, but his whim ensured the future — physical universe. Eventually the Stalinist state caught up with of a discipline. How We Live and Why We Die is a translation everyone. Egorov was detained in 1930 for It will be hard for the uninitiated to follow from another language — biology. Years ago, “mixing mathematics and religion” and died in Naming Infinity, owing to the book’s uneven Bob Burchfield, then the editor of the Oxford prison. Florensky confessed under torture and exposition and narrow biographical focus. English Dictionary, told me that biology had was sent to the Gulag, where he studied perma- The connection between mathematics and more words of its own than any other area of frost and seaweed before his execution in 1937. mysticism is tenuous. The real drama appears knowledge, 60,000 or so — a greater number The case of Luzin is a miraculous exception. around the edges, as the researchers survive than most of the world’s languages. Thus the In 1936 he was accused of collaborating with famine, repression and war long enough to set scale of biological language is a measure of foreigners by the Marxist mathematician Ernst the direction for a century of mathematics. It how biology has overwhelmed its history. Kolman, who proclaimed, “Soviet science will is a story of the persistence of intellectual life The meanings of these words — the things rip away your mask!” He was saved by a let- against the wrecking tide of history. ■ and ideas that lie behind them — have to be ter to Joseph Stalin from the physicist Peter Jascha Hoffman is a writer based in New York. negotiated into the semantic space of our eve- Kapista, who argued that Luzin might yet be e-mail: [email protected] ryday, more familiar world. Indeed, the book shows just how unfamiliar, eclectic, mongrel, or simply borrowed and recycled, the biologi- cal vocabulary is: HOX genes, sonic hedgehog, The hidden language of cells spindle, apoptosis, aster, telomere, P53, French flag model, and so on. How We Live and Why We Die: The Secret colour is false. What we don’t know so well is Translation from biology is harder than that Lives of Cells how cells and molecules actually behave, and from a national language where much in its by Lewis Wolpert how their behaviour explains ours. culture would be recognizable and the nego- Faber and Faber: 2009. 256 pp. £14.99 Wolpert’s book has no pictures and few tiation of meaning easier. It is a difficulty all too numbers. So, if you do not know about the size apparent in How We Live and Why We Die. And and appearance of cells and their mol ecules, it is a difficulty emphasized by the telegraphic The greatest implication of evolutionary you won’t discover it here. This matters because style Wolpert has adopted. The book says, for theory is the common kinship of living things. in biology, size is so often the key to under- instance, that “Animal cells like ours generate It is expressed no better than by Henry Harris standing both anatomy and physiology. A cell’s energy from the breakdown of their food when in The Birth of the Cell (Yale University Press, size is conceptual, not merely a fact.
Recommended publications
  • Placing World War I in the History of Mathematics David Aubin, Catherine Goldstein
    Placing World War I in the History of Mathematics David Aubin, Catherine Goldstein To cite this version: David Aubin, Catherine Goldstein. Placing World War I in the History of Mathematics. 2013. hal- 00830121v1 HAL Id: hal-00830121 https://hal.sorbonne-universite.fr/hal-00830121v1 Preprint submitted on 4 Jun 2013 (v1), last revised 8 Jul 2014 (v2) HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Placing World War I in the History of Mathematics David Aubin and Catherine Goldstein Abstract. In the historical literature, opposite conclusions were drawn about the impact of the First World War on mathematics. In this chapter, the case is made that the war was an important event for the history of mathematics. We show that although mathematicians' experience of the war was extremely varied, its impact was decisive on the life of a great number of them. We present an overview of some uses of mathematics in war and of the development of mathematics during the war. We conclude by arguing that the war also was a crucial factor in the institutional modernization of mathematics. Les vrais adversaires, dans la guerre d'aujourd'hui, ce sont les professeurs de math´ematiques`aleur table, les physiciens et les chimistes dans leur laboratoire.
    [Show full text]
  • Theological Metaphors in Mathematics
    STUDIES IN LOGIC, GRAMMAR AND RHETORIC 44 (57) 2016 DOI: 10.1515/slgr-2016-0002 Stanisław Krajewski University of Warsaw THEOLOGICAL METAPHORS IN MATHEMATICS Abstract. Examples of possible theological influences upon the development of mathematics are indicated. The best known connection can be found in the realm of infinite sets treated by us as known or graspable, which constitutes a divine-like approach. Also the move to treat infinite processes as if they were one finished object that can be identified with its limits is routine in mathemati- cians, but refers to seemingly super-human power. For centuries this was seen as wrong and even today some philosophers, for example Brian Rotman, talk critically about “theological mathematics”. Theological metaphors, like “God’s view”, are used even by contemporary mathematicians. While rarely appearing in official texts they are rather easily invoked in “the kitchen of mathemat- ics”. There exist theories developing without the assumption of actual infinity the tools of classical mathematics needed for applications (For instance, My- cielski’s approach). Conclusion: mathematics could have developed in another way. Finally, several specific examples of historical situations are mentioned where, according to some authors, direct theological input into mathematics appeared: the possibility of the ritual genesis of arithmetic and geometry, the importance of the Indian religious background for the emergence of zero, the genesis of the theories of Cantor and Brouwer, the role of Name-worshipping for the research of the Moscow school of topology. Neither these examples nor the previous illustrations of theological metaphors provide a certain proof that religion or theology was directly influencing the development of mathematical ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Naming Infinity: a True Story of Religious Mysticism And
    Naming Infinity Naming Infinity A True Story of Religious Mysticism and Mathematical Creativity Loren Graham and Jean-Michel Kantor The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, En gland 2009 Copyright © 2009 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Graham, Loren R. Naming infinity : a true story of religious mysticism and mathematical creativity / Loren Graham and Jean-Michel Kantor. â p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-674-03293-4 (alk. paper) 1. Mathematics—Russia (Federation)—Religious aspects. 2. Mysticism—Russia (Federation) 3. Mathematics—Russia (Federation)—Philosophy. 4. Mathematics—France—Religious aspects. 5. Mathematics—France—Philosophy. 6. Set theory. I. Kantor, Jean-Michel. II. Title. QA27.R8G73 2009 510.947′0904—dc22â 2008041334 CONTENTS Introduction 1 1. Storming a Monastery 7 2. A Crisis in Mathematics 19 3. The French Trio: Borel, Lebesgue, Baire 33 4. The Russian Trio: Egorov, Luzin, Florensky 66 5. Russian Mathematics and Mysticism 91 6. The Legendary Lusitania 101 7. Fates of the Russian Trio 125 8. Lusitania and After 162 9. The Human in Mathematics, Then and Now 188 Appendix: Luzin’s Personal Archives 205 Notes 212 Acknowledgments 228 Index 231 ILLUSTRATIONS Framed photos of Dmitri Egorov and Pavel Florensky. Photographed by Loren Graham in the basement of the Church of St. Tatiana the Martyr, 2004. 4 Monastery of St. Pantaleimon, Mt. Athos, Greece. 8 Larger and larger circles with segment approaching straight line, as suggested by Nicholas of Cusa. 25 Cantor ternary set.
    [Show full text]
  • SOMMAIRE DU No 129
    SOMMAIRE DU No 129 SMF Mot du Pr´esident .................................... .............................. 5 Rapport Moral ....................................... ............................... 7 MATHEMATIQUES´ D´ecomposition effective de Jordan-Chevalley, D. Couty, J. Esterle, R. Zarouf ........ 29 HISTOIRE Liouba Bortniker, R. Brasseur ................................................... 51 Le bicentenaire d’Evariste Galois (1811-1832), C. Ehrhardt .......................... 71 PHILOSOPHIE DES MATHEMATIQUES´ Sur la production des concepts en math´ematiques, V. G´erard ........................ 75 ENSEIGNEMENT Contribution sur les programmes de terminales . ......................... 91 Contribution sur la sp´ecialit´eISN . ...............................104 Compte-rendu de r´eunion sur les masters enseignement et les concours . 106 EN HOMMAGE A` PHILIPPE FLAJOLET Philippe Flajolet, le fondateur de la combinatoire analytique, B. Chauvin, B. Salvy, M. Soria, B. Vall´ee ................................................... ...............113 Philippe Flajolet chez ALGO, A. Bostan, N. Broutin, F. Chyzak, V. Collette, P. Dumas, B. Salvy ................................................... .........................115 My friend, L. Devroye ................................................... ...........116 Vingt-cinq ans de compagnonnage scientifique avec Philippe Flajolet, B. Vall´ee . 118 Avoir eu vingt ans avec Philippe, J.-M. Steyaert ....................................121 CARNET Yahya ould Hamidoune, A. Plagne ..................................................123
    [Show full text]
  • Biography of N. N. Luzin
    BIOGRAPHY OF N. N. LUZIN http://theor.jinr.ru/~kuzemsky/Luzinbio.html BIOGRAPHY OF N. N. LUZIN (1883-1950) born December 09, 1883, Irkutsk, Russia. died January 28, 1950, Moscow, Russia. Biographic Data of N. N. Luzin: Nikolai Nikolaevich Luzin (also spelled Lusin; Russian: НиколайНиколаевич Лузин) was a Soviet/Russian mathematician known for his work in descriptive set theory and aspects of mathematical analysis with strong connections to point-set topology. He was the co-founder of "Luzitania" (together with professor Dimitrii Egorov), a close group of young Moscow mathematicians of the first half of the 1920s. This group consisted of the higly talented and enthusiastic members which form later the core of the famous Moscow school of mathematics. They adopted his set-theoretic orientation, and went on to apply it in other areas of mathematics. Luzin started studying mathematics in 1901 at Moscow University, where his advisor was professor Dimitrii Egorov (1869-1931). Professor Dimitrii Fedorovihch Egorov was a great scientist and talented teacher; in addition he was a person of very high moral principles. He was a Russian and Soviet mathematician known for significant contributions to the areas of differential geometry and mathematical analysis. Egorov was devoted and openly practicized member of Russian Orthodox Church and active parish worker. This activity was the reason of his conflicts with Soviet authorities after 1917 and finally led him to arrest and exile to Kazan (1930) where he died from heavy cancer. From 1910 to 1914 Luzin studied at Gottingen, where he was influenced by Edmund Landau. He then returned to Moscow and received his Ph.D.
    [Show full text]
  • Science and Nation After Socialism in the Novosibirsk Scientific Center, Russia
    Local Science, Global Knowledge: Science and Nation after Socialism in the Novosibirsk Scientific Center, Russia Amy Lynn Ninetto Mohnton, Pennsylvania B.A., Franklin and Marshall College, 1993 M.A., University of Virginia, 1997 A Dissertation presented to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Virginia in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Dcpartmcn1 of Anthropology University of Virginia May 2002 11 © Copyright by Amy Lynn Ninetta All Rights Reserved May 2002 lll Abstract This dissertation explores the changing relationships between science, the state, and global capital in the Novosibirsk Scientific Center (Akademgorodok). Since the collapse of the state-sponsored Soviet "big science" establishment, Russian scientists have been engaging transnational flows of capital, knowledge, and people. While some have permanently emigrated from Russia, others travel abroad on temporary contracts; still others work for foreign firms in their home laboratories. As they participate in these transnational movements, Akademgorodok scientists confront a number of apparent contradictions. On one hand, their transnational movement is, in many respects, seen as a return to the "natural" state of science-a reintegration of former Soviet scientists into a "world science" characterized by open exchange of information and transcendence of local cultural models of reality. On the other hand, scientists' border-crossing has made them-and the state that claims them as its national resources-increasingly conscious of the borders that divide world science into national and local scientific communities with differential access to resources, prestige, and knowledge. While scientists assert a specifically Russian way of doing science, grounded in the historical relationships between Russian science and the state, they are reaching sometimes uneasy accommodations with the globalization of scientific knowledge production.
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:1710.05659V1 [Math.HO]
    FROM POLAND TO PETERSBURG: THE BANACH-TARSKI PARADOX IN BELY’S MODERNIST NOVEL NOAH GIANSIRACUSA∗ AND ANASTASIA VASILYEVA∗∗ ABSTRACT. Andrei Bely’s novel Petersburg, first published in 1913, was declared by Vladimir Nabokov one of the four greatest masterpieces of 20th-century prose. The Banach-Tarski Paradox, published in 1924, is one of the most striking and well-known results in 20th-century mathematics. In this paper we explore a potential connection between these two landmark works, based on various interactions with the Moscow Mathematical School and passages in the novel itself. 1. INTRODUCTION Andrei Bely (1880-1934) was a poet, novelist, and theoretician who helped lead the Symbolist movement in Russia in the early 20th century. His most regarded work is the modernist novel Petersburg, published serially in 1913-1914 then in a revised and shortened form in 1922. Vladimir Nabokov (1899-1977) famously declared Petersburg one of the four greatest works of prose of the 20th century, along with Joyce’s Ulysses, Kafka’s Metamorphosis, and Proust’s A` la recherche du temps perdu. As with these three other works, the scholarly literature on Petersburg is vast and continues to grow; for instance, a volume of essays on Petersburg celebrating its centennial was just released [Coo17]. An emerging direction of scholarship has been to better understand the origins and meaning of the remarkably frequent mathematical imagery in Petersburg [Szi02, Szi11, GK09, Sve13, Kos13, GV17]. That Bely had an interest in math is not surprising: his father was the influential math- ematician Nikolai Bugaev1 (1837-1903) who is credited with creating the Moscow Mathemat- ical School, one of the most active and successful groups of mathematicians in recent history [Dem14, DTT15].
    [Show full text]
  • Mathematical Symbolism in a Russian Literary Masterpiece
    MATHEMATICAL SYMBOLISM IN A RUSSIAN LITERARY MASTERPIECE NOAH GIANSIRACUSA∗ AND ANASTASIA VASILYEVA∗∗ ABSTRACT. Andrei Bely’s modernist novel Petersburg, first published in 1913, is considered a pinnacle of the Symbolist movement. Nabokov famously ranked it as one of the four greatest mas- terpieces of 20th-century prose. The author’s father, Bugaev, was an influential mathematician and for 12 years served as the president of the Moscow Mathematical Society; he was also a source of inspiration for one of the main characters in the son’s novel. While the philosophical views and po- litical leanings of the mathematicians surrounding Bely, and their impact on Petersburg, have been a topic of recent academic interest, there has not yet been a direct investigation of the surprisingly fre- quent and sophisticated mathematical passages in the book itself. We attempt here to rectify this gap in the scholarly literature, and in doing so find a rich tapestry of mathematical ideas and allusions. 1. INTRODUCTION Andrei Bely (1880-1934) was a fascinating, if somewhat tragic, figure. He grew up under the stern tutelage of his internationally renowned math professor father, Nikolai Bugaev (1837-1903), and studied the natural sciences at the University of Moscow before turning to the literary arts. In fact, it was because of the father’s fame and reputation that Bely took up a pseudonym when launching his literary career, rather than publishing under his birth name, Boris Bugaev [Moc77, p. 31]. Both father and son were polymaths with vast philosophical interests. They seemed intent on expanding the theoretical foundations of their respective subjects (math for the father, poetry and prose for the son) to quixotic extents: they believed they could explain, and even justify, historical events and contemporary social movements through their abstract work.
    [Show full text]
  • Multiplication, Oil Spill, Arcimboldo – and Sliced Bread
    Welcome to the 25th issue of the Primary Magazine. Our famous mathematician is Sierpiński, we look at the art of Giuseppe Arcimboldo, and our CPD opportunity aims to develop subject knowledge in multiplication. It’s in the News! features the oil spill disaster in the Gulf of Mexico. Contents Editor’s extras In this issue we tell you of some research about parents and the way they ‘help’ their children with mathematics. We also have news from one of our regional projects and a variety of things for you to look at. It’s in the News! We explore yet another disaster! This one is the oil leak caused by the explosion of the rig Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico. The slides provide opportunities for work with such mathematical concepts as measurement, data handling, compass points and coordinates. The Art of Mathematics The art of Giuseppe Arcimboldo, born in Milan, Italy, in 1527. He is best known for his portraits of human heads made up of vegetables, fruits, sea creatures, tree roots and other everyday objects. Focus on… This article has to be ‘the greatest thing since sliced bread’! This month is the 82nd anniversary of the first sliced loaf of bread. The original loaf-slicing machine was invented by Otto Frederick Rohwedder. A little bit of history In this issue we look at a potted history of Sierpiński, a Polish mathematician well known for his contribution to various elements of mathematics, not least fractals. As well as finding out about the mathematician himself we explore his work on fractals, with ideas for great activities to do with your pupils.
    [Show full text]
  • Visiting Mathematicians Jon Barwise, in Setting the Tone for His New Column, Has Incorporated Three Articles Into This Month's Offering
    OTICES OF THE AMERICAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY The Growth of the American Mathematical Society page 781 Everett Pitcher ~~ Centennial Celebration (August 8-12) page 831 JULY/AUGUST 1988, VOLUME 35, NUMBER 6 Providence, Rhode Island, USA ISSN 0002-9920 Calendar of AMS Meetings and Conferences This calendar lists all meetings which have been approved prior to Mathematical Society in the issue corresponding to that of the Notices the date this issue of Notices was sent to the press. The summer which contains the program of the meeting. Abstracts should be sub­ and annual meetings are joint meetings of the Mathematical Associ­ mitted on special forms which are available in many departments of ation of America and the American Mathematical Society. The meet­ mathematics and from the headquarters office of the Society. Ab­ ing dates which fall rather far in the future are subject to change; this stracts of papers to be presented at the meeting must be received is particularly true of meetings to which no numbers have been as­ at the headquarters of the Society in Providence, Rhode Island, on signed. Programs of the meetings will appear in the issues indicated or before the deadline given below for the meeting. Note that the below. First and supplementary announcements of the meetings will deadline for abstracts for consideration for presentation at special have appeared in earlier issues. sessions is usually three weeks earlier than that specified below. For Abstracts of papers presented at a meeting of the Society are pub­ additional information, consult the meeting announcements and the lished in the journal Abstracts of papers presented to the American list of organizers of special sessions.
    [Show full text]
  • University Press Amsterdam University Press in De Naam Van Oneindigheid
    In de naam van oneindigheid Amsterdam University Press Amsterdam University Press In de naam van oneindigheid Een waargebeurd verhaal over religieus mysticisme en wiskundige creativiteit Loren Graham & Jean-Michel Kantor Vertaling Lukas M. Verburgt AUP Amsterdam University Press Oorspronkelij k verschenen als: Loren Graham & Jean-Michel Kantor Naming Infijinity. A True Story of Religious Mysticism and Mathematical Creativity. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. Cambridge, Massachusetts & London, England, 2009. © 2009 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College Published by arrangement with Harvard University Press Vertaling: Lukas M. Verburgt Afbeelding omslag: Michail Vasilevitsj Nesterov, De fijilosofen. Sergej Nikolajevitsj Boelgakov en Pavel Florenski, 1917. © Russisch Staatsmuseum, St. Petersburg, Rusland / The Bridgeman Art Library Ontwerp binnenwerk: Crius Group, Hulshout isbn 978 94 6298 317 5 e-isbn 978 90 4853 309 1 (pdf) e-isbn 978 90 4853 310 7 (ePub) nur 685 ǀ 708 © L. Graham, J-M. Kantor / Amsterdam University Press B.V., Amsterdam 2016 Alle rechten voorbehouden. Niets uit deze uitgave mag worden verveelvoudigd, opgeslagen in een geautomatiseerd gegevensbestand, of openbaar gemaakt, in enige vorm of op enige wij ze, hetzij elektronisch, mechanisch, door fotoko- pieën, opnamen of enige andere manier, zonder voorafgaande schriftelij ke toestemming van de uitgever. Voor zover het maken van kopieën uit deze uitgave is toegestaan op grond van artikel 16B Auteurswet 1912 jº het Besluit van 20 juni 1974, Stb. 351, zoals gewij zigd bij het Besluit van 23 augustus 1985, Stb. 471 en artikel 17 Auteurswet 1912, dient men de daarvoor wettelij k verschuldigde vergoedingen te voldoen aan de Stichting Reprorecht (Postbus 3051, 2130 KB Hoofddorp).
    [Show full text]
  • A Note About Mikhaïl Lavrentieff and His World of Analysis in the Soviet Union (With an Appendix by Galina Sinkevich) Athanase Papadopoulos
    A note about Mikhaïl Lavrentieff and his world of analysis in the Soviet Union (With an appendix by Galina Sinkevich) Athanase Papadopoulos To cite this version: Athanase Papadopoulos. A note about Mikhaïl Lavrentieff and his world of analysis in the Soviet Union (With an appendix by Galina Sinkevich). 2019. hal-02406071 HAL Id: hal-02406071 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02406071 Preprint submitted on 12 Dec 2019 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. A NOTE ABOUT MIKHA¨IL LAVRENTIEFF AND HIS WORLD OF ANALYSIS IN THE SOVIET UNION ATHANASE PAPADOPOULOS WITH AN APPENDIX BY GALINA SINKEVICH Abstract. We survey the life and work of Mikha¨ıl Lavrentieff, one of the main founders of the theory of quasiconformal mappings, with an emphasis on his training years at the famous Moscow school of theory of functions founded by Luzin. We also mention the major applications of quasiconformal mappings that Lavrentieff developed in the physical sciences. At the same time, we re- view several connected historical events, including the sad fate of Luzin during the Stalin period, the birth of the scientific Siberian center of Akademgorodok, and the role that Lavrentieff played in the organization of science and research in the Soviet Union.
    [Show full text]