In This Issue
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Ol’ Pioneer The Magazine of the Grand Canyon Historical Society Volume 22 : Number 2 www.GrandCanyonHistory.org Spring 2011 In This Issue Book Review ............................................... 3 The Infinities of Beauty and Terror ........ 4 Louis Schellback’s Log Books, Part 3 .....11 President’s Letter The Ol’ Pioneer The Magazine of the Grand Canyon Historical Society Calling All Grand Canyon Historians!! Volume 22 : Number 2 Spring 2011 Planning and coordination is well under way for the next Grand Canyon History Symposium scheduled for January 2012. We recently sent out a Call for u Papers asking Grand Canyon historians, researchers and writers to submit pro- The Historical Society was established posals to present at the symposium. If you have a Grand Canyon history topic in July 1984 as a non-profit corporation that you have researched (or know somebody working on an interesting topic), to develop and promote appreciation, we strongly encourage you to submit a proposal. The presenters at the last under-standing and education of the symposium were a nice mix of historians, river runners, hikers, writers, park earlier history of the inhabitants and employees and enthusiastic amateur historians - we expect to have a similar important events of the Grand Canyon. mix this year. So, please get the word out – the deadline for submitting propos- The Ol’ Pioneer is published by the als is June 15. Additional details about the symposium and how to submit a GRAND CANYON HISTORICAL proposal can be found on the GCHS website (http://www.grandcanyonhis- SOCIETY in conjunction with The tory.org/). Bulletin, an informational newsletter. And speaking of websites… in addition to our long-standing GCHS website, Both publications are a benefit of membership. Membership in the Society the society now also had its own Facebook page! It has only been public for a is open to any person interested in the few weeks and already has seen nearly 300 users. There are almost daily up- historical, educational, and charitable dates and postings regarding Grand Canyon history trivia, upcoming canyon purposes of the Society. Membership is events and online discussions on various canyon topics. Our current Facebook on an annual basis using the standard page administrators are Amy Horn, Helen Ranney, Karen Greig, Tom Martin calendar; and dues of $20 are payable on the 1st of January each year, and and myself, but anyone can view and post (even non-GCHS members). It is a mailed to the GCHS Treasurer, PO Box great way to keep up with GCHS and Grand Canyon events (as well as raise 31405 Flagstaff, AZ 86002. The Ol’ Pioneer visibility for the society). If you are already on Facebook, simply type ‘Grand magazine is copyrighted by the Grand Canyon Historical Society’ in the search box at the top of the Facebook screen. Canyon Historical Society, Inc. All rights Once you find our page, be sure to click the ‘Like’ button to ‘Friend’ us. Tell reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or used in any form your friends! without permission of the publisher. See you online! Editor: Mary Williams Submit photos and stories to the The Ol’ Pioneer Erik Berg editor of at: mary@ marywilliamsdesign.com or 4880 N GCHS President Weatherford Road, Flagstaff, AZ 86001. (928) 779-3377. Please submit written articles and photos electronically on CD or via email if possible. You may mail photos or slides for scanning if needed. Submissions to The Bulletin should be sent to Karen Greig, [email protected] GCHS Officers Erik Berg, President NOW! Find us on Facebook. John Azar, Vice President Keith Green, Treasurer Amy Horn, Secretary Kirsten Heins, Pioneer Award Cover: First important poet to see the Grand Canyon, and founder of Poetry magazine, Al Richmond, Awards Chair Harriet Monroe. Paul Schnur, Membership Committee John Azar, Outings Coordinator Board of Directors Karen Greig Howard Asaki Kristin Heins John Azar Mona McCroskey The Ol’ Pioneer submission deadlines are going to be roughly the first of Janu- Erik Berg Carol Naille ary, April, July and October and we will publish either three or four issues a Jackie Brown Adair Peterson Keith Green Paul Schnur year, depending on content volume. 2 : Grand Canyon Historical Society www.GrandCanyonHistory.org Book Review: The Butterflies of Grand Canyon by Margaret Erhart by Nancy Greene a place we all love, we are launched into an all too fa- hose of us in the Grand Canyon miliar retelling of the fragility Historical Society spend of the human heart and how much of our time delving into easily it is to be led astray. Tnonfiction accounts of those early Sometimes people do come to canyon pioneers. We spend time their senses, and other times trying to connect all the myriad pieces they never recover. Some- of history from all of the events we’ve times people who have been attended and books we’ve read. My so affected by their experi- advice is to give your brain a break ences and the Grand Canyon from all that hard historic data and landscape can walk away, but empirical research. Just sit back and remain forever altered. Mar- enjoy this delightful tale of historical garet’s literary prose is lush fiction about our favorite place. with images of the canyon, Ms. Erhart, local author and can- the monsoon season and the yon hiking guide, brings us back to electric shock sensations be- the South Rim in the 1950s. This is an tween some of the characters. era some of our members may actu- The dialogue is rich and helps ally remember. She weaves a mur- to move the story along. But der mystery into her story with the there are also those reflective help of the famous skeleton in Emery passages, as one character or Kolb’s garage, tucked away in a boat, another tries to mull over a suspended in the ceiling. Although particularly vexing conun- the principal characters are totally drum of life, with the canyon a creation of the author’s inventive as a backdrop. How many mind, other very real Grand Canyon of us have brought our own personages amble through the pag- looming personal angst to the can- in perspective. Prepare to enjoy this es. Lois Jotter, Elzada Clover, Louis yon rim—only to have that magnifi- historical novel/murder mystery/ro- Schellbach, H. C. Bryant, Ellsworth cent spectacle before us help to alter, mance—excellently crafted, well told Kolb (in his pajamas, no less) and shrink and sometimes totally dissi- and with a setting extraordinaire. of course, Emery and his skeleton pate our puny problems. The canyon When you have finished, your heart all play a part in this gentle murder is a great receptacle for human emo- will float as lightly as the butterflies mystery. With a familiar setting and tion, and helps to put our own lives of the Grand Canyon. These Infinities of Beauty and Terror: Poets and Writers Discover the Grand Canyon by Don Lago it in a lifetime of photographs, only to azines, newspapers, and advertising be shocked by the canyon’s real scale posters still relied on illustrators. The ven today, every person who and shapes and colors. Grand Canyon photographs that tour- comes to the Grand Canyon For the first tourists who stepped ists had seen were black-and-white discovers it anew. Every visitor off the first Santa Fe Railway trains at and of limited quality. The Santa Fe Esees the canyon with their own per- the Grand Canyon in 1901, there was Railway placed its promotional trust sonalities, perceptions, and beliefs. much more room for surprise. Pho- in artists, especially Thomas Moran, Many visitors come thinking they al- tography had not yet become a ubiq- yet Moran’s romanticized depictions ready know the canyon, having seen uitous part of the media; books, mag- of the canyon were so misleading, www.GrandCanyonHistory.org Grand Canyon Historical Society : 3 leaving out the canyon’s true colors etically, helping to define how we litzer Prize winners—who encoun- and geological strata, that many tour- should see a strange new landscape. tered the Grand Canyon were by far ists were left trying to recognize the In the age before academic hyper- the most philosophically ambitious real canyon. Tourists also struggled specialization, Powell and Dutton ab- about it. They saw the canyon as a with the refusal of the Grand Can- sorbed much of 19th century literary great puzzle about the ultimate na- yon and the entire Southwest to fit culture and they applied the best of ture of reality, demanding an answer. into the images of natural beauty in- it in their writings, while the worst They often saw the Grand Canyon as herited from Romanticism, images of of it—the Romantic fancies that saw a symbol of the whole cosmos. Was green fields and blue streams, Edenic landscapes as nothing but giant’s the cosmos a place of order, or chaos? flowers and trees, distant mountains, castles and fairy gardens—was ed- Was the canyon evidence for God, or maybe even a few broken Greek col- ited out by their geological eyes and for ancient and massive natural forc- umns. In its first years, El Tovar Ho- their life-and-death journeys over a es? Did the canyon point toward im- tel offered guests a book in which to rugged land and river. Powell and mortality, or decay? If nature was the record their reactions to the canyon, Dutton left their perceptions not just power behind the canyon, what was and their comments are filled with in eloquent books but upon the land the reality of nature? Was it generous the excitement of discovery, with itself, in the names they choose for or malevolent? For many Grand Can- puzzlement, and with conscientious landscape features.