Pennsylvania Magazine of HISTORY and BIOGRAPHY
THE Pennsylvania Magazine OF HISTORY AND BIOGRAPHY Reinterpreting the "Very Trifling Mutiny" at Philadelphia in June 1783 N A LETTER OF JANUARY 16, 1784, to the Marquis de Chastellux, Thomas Jefferson reported "some dissatisfaction in the army at not Ibeing paid off before they were disbanded, and a very trifling mutiny of 200 soldiers in Philadelphia." Some historians have likewise dismissed the unrest in the Continental army at the moment of its disbandment. They consider that George Washington quelled the officers' conspiracy at Newburgh in March 1783; they then project the image of an army that suffered patiently during the war and departed quietly after it—an image designed to reassure European observers that the fledgling nation I would like to thank Elizabeth M Nuxoll, Kenneth R Bowling, E James Ferguson, Clarence L Ver Steeg, Robert F Hueston and two anonymous readers for their thoughtful and constructive criticisms of this article It derives in part from research undertaken for The Papers of Robert Morris, a project sponsored by Queens College, CUNY, and funded by the National Endowment for the Humanities, the National Historical Publications and Records Commission, and the private contributors listed in its volumes 1 See Julian P Boyd, et al, eds , The Papers of Thomas Jefferson (Princeton, 1950-), 6 466 Jefferson appears to be quoting financier Robert Morns, who described the mutiny as "a trifling Thing which has no Importance in itself and which might derive some by treating of it senously" See RM to the consortium of Dutch bankers, Dec 31, 1783 (first letter), in E James Ferguson, John Catanzanti, et al, eds, The Papers of Robert Moms (hereafter, PRM) (Pittsburgh, 1973-), vol 8, forthcoming THE PENNSYLVANIA MAGAZINE OF HISTORY 6C BIOGRAPHY Vol.
[Show full text]