EDUCATION Mr. Mitchell has provided project management and technical analysis capabilities for a wide variety of projects requiring environmental review, B.S., Civil Engineering, San including transportation and transit, industrial, institutional, commercial, Francisco State residential, mixed-use, educational and recreational projects. He has served University as project director / project manager for a number of CEQA environmental 23 YEARS documents, including environmental review for sports facilities and sporting EXPERIENCE events, capital improvement projects, wineries and vineyards, quarries, university and local school district master plans, specific plans, planned use

developments, transit service plans, multi-modal stations, and demolition projects. Mr. Mitchell’s technical analysis responsibilities include required CEQA/NEPA analysis of transportation, air quality, noise, land use and policies, and infrastructure issues.

Sports and Concert Facilities / Special Events Golden State Warriors Event Center and Mixed-Use Development SEIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Paul recently managed a Subsequent EIR for a landmark $1 billion, privately funded development within the thriving Mission Bay neighborhood in San Francisco. The centerpiece is an 18,000-plus–seat event center that will be the new home of the Golden State Warriors basketball team, during the NBA season, and provide a year-round venue for a variety of other uses, including concerts, family shows, other sporting events, cultural events, conferences and conventions. Office, retail, and open space uses and structured parking are also proposed. A Subsequent EIR (SEIR) was prepared for the project, tiering from the 1998 Mission Bay Final SEIR. The project was processed under CEQA streamlining legislation of both AB 900 (“environmental leadership project”) and SB 743. The SEIR included substantial detailed modeling for transportation, air quality, health risks, noise, utilities, and wind and shadow; a helipad airspace assessment, site-specific archaeological testing, urban decay analysis, and stand-alone TMP. Important considerations included ensuring effects of the project on the adjacent UCSF Mission Bay campus and its medical center were fully addressed, and cumulative environmental effects of events of the proposed event center in conjunction with concurrent baseball games at nearby AT&T Park. The Final SEIR was unanimously approved by the City in December 2015. The SEIR adequacy was upheld by the California Superior Court and the California Court of Appeals on all accounts, and in January 2017, the California Supreme Court denied a petition to consider the case for further review. The project will be constructed in time for the Golden State Warriors 2019-20 season.

Prior to GSW selecting the Mission Bay site, GSW proposed an equally ambitious proposal on Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 in San Francisco. This prior proposal included an event center, hotel, residential, retail and

maritime uses (including a San Francisco Fire Department fire boat station, water taxi stop and cruise ship berth), and substantial open space. The Piers 30-32 site would have required substantial repair and structural upgrades to the piers, which are currently in disrepair. This project presented a variety of environmental concerns to be addressed in an EIR, including short-term marine biological, hydrologic/water quality and noise impacts from the pile driving and other in-water construction; and long-term transportation effects from increased project traffic and associated air quality emissions. 34th America’s Cup and Cruise Terminal EIR, San Francisco, CA. Co- Project Manager. Paul recently managed the EIR for two projects: 1) the proposed 34th America’s Cup (AC34) - a series of international sailing events to be held in the San Francisco Bay in summer-fall 2012/2013; and 2) a new San Francisco Cruise Terminal. The AC34 project sponsors, the City of San Francisco and the America’s Cup Event Authority, propose a variety of facilities and services needed to support the events, including team bases, media operations, hospitality, and entertainment and spectator venues. A substantial number of temporary and permanent improvements would occur at several Port of San Francisco piers, as well as at Crissy Field, Marina Green, Fort Mason, Aquatic Park, Alcatraz and Fort Baker to accommodate the AC34 events. The site of the proposed America’s Cup Village (at Piers 27-29) would also ultimately serve as the site of the Port’s proposed modern new cruise terminal. The projects posed a number of unique environmental concerns, including potential marine biological and hydrologic/water quality impacts from the proposed installation of two miles of temporary floating docks, wave attenuators and other in-water construction; short-term air quality effects from AC34 event-related recreational, charter and team support boats, and long- term air quality emissions from cruise terminal cruise ships; substantial AC34 event-related traffic impacts; and potential environmental effects associated with long-term development at a number of Port properties. The EIR also addressed a variety of proposed implementation plans proposed to support the AC34 event, including a “People Plan” (transportation management), Parks Events Operations Plan, and Water and Air Traffic Plan. The EIR for this large project was completed in record time - 9 months. The Final EIR was certified by the City of San Francisco on December 15, 2011. Sonoma State University Concert Pavilion, Sonoma, CA. Project Director. Paul directed the completion of the environmental review for a proposed new concert pavilion at Sonoma State University as part of a minor revision to its Master Plan. The concert pavilion is the latest addition to the Green Music Center complex on the University campus. The project consists of a state-of- the-art outdoor venue to serve various musical and arts programs and accommodate a wide range of artists and performances, including symphonic music, opera and dance, and amplified genres of pop and rock. The proposed facilities include a large pavilion structure spanning a performance stage, LED video screens, sound/light towers, and fixed seating within a landscaped amphitheater. ESA completed an EIR addendum to the original Master Plan EIR to evaluate environmental effects of these proposed permanent facilities which would be developed instead of temporary facilities that were originally envisioned. Piedmont Skate Park Environmental Review, Piedmont, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the completion of the environmental review for a proposed City-owned and -operated skate park in Piedmont. The proposed skate park was developed in response to a growing demand for a public skate facility in the City. Principal issues included geotechnical

considerations (the facility is located adjacent to steep slopes), and traffic and pedestrian access issues. Mixed-Use Development Pacific Union College Ecovillage EIR, Napa County, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation an Administrative Draft EIR for a proposed “Ecovillage” in the unincorporated community of Angwin in Napa County, on land owned by the Pacific Union College (PUC). The project included 380-units of new housing, 72,500-square-feet of commercial uses, organic farm, and a variety of supporting recreation, transportation and infrastructure improvements. In addition, the EIR addressed development of 230 acres for potential vineyards/wineries, and preservation of over 1,100 acres of forest land. The project proposed a number of sustainable features, including but not limited to, upgrade of the PUC’s wastewater treatment plan to provide tertiary-treated water for agricultural irrigation and landscaping; springwater capture and rainwater harvesting; and sustainable technologies, including photovoltaic (PV) panels and geothermal heat pumps; the production of locally-farmed organic food; and implementation of an aggressive transportation demand management program. Further, a “synergistic” relationship was envisioned between the proposed Ecovillage and the PUC, where the Ecovillage would be served in part by the PUC’s cogeneration plant (which burns natural gas, generating electricity and providing steam for heating), and the PUC would benefit from the Ecovillage’s proposed PV system. Prior to publication of the Draft EIR, the Ecovillage project went on hold, pending resolution of funding and other project-related issues. Educational Facilities Sonoma State University Master Plan Revision EIR, Sonoma County, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation of an EIR for Sonoma State University for a major revision to its Master Plan. The University’s 219- acre campus is located immediately east of the city of Rohnert Park, in Sonoma County. The University proposed over 260,000 square feet of instructional expansion, a 100,000-square-foot music center and concert hall (Green Music Center), a 215,000-square-foot University Center, soccer stadium, and substantial increases in on-site student housing and parking. In addition, under the plan, a large parcel of land adjacent to the campus was planned to be acquired for future student housing. The principal issues associated with the project include traffic, circulation and parking, land use, and potential hydrologic and biological impacts to a seasonal creek that runs through the campus. ESA has also since completed several EIR Addendums for the University for Subsequent Minor Revisions to its Master Plan, including for additional on-site housing and academic facilities, a wastewater equalization project, and a concert pavilion. Hillsborough City School District Measure B Facility Program Environmental Review. Project Manager. Paul managed ESA’s preparation of an Initial Study/ Mitigated Negative Declaration and a number of supporting technical studies for the District’s Measure B Facility Program. The HCSD is comprised of three elementary schools and one middle school located in the Town of Hillsborough. The program included new facility construction (including new classrooms, performing arts centers, administration and multi- purposed buildings), as well as modernization and renovation of the District’s aging facilities. A controversial element of the project included the proposed removal of approximately 60 mature eucalyptus trees at one school site to accommodate a number of off-site transportation improvements. Technical

support studies that were completed included a cultural resources evaluation (one of the schools was determined potentially eligible for listing on the California Register of Historical Resources), a biological constraints study (one of the elementary school buildings was constructed over San Mateo Creek) and a noise study of internal “pod” building noise issues. Los Altos School District Environmental Review, Los Altos, CA. Project Manager/Director. ESA has prepared multiple environmental review documents for the Los Altos School District to address potential environmental effects associated with facility improvements and enrollment increases for the Bullis Charter School, which operates on portions of two of the District’s campuses. The environmental documents addressed creative ways to alleviate peak period school generated traffic and related noise effects, including identifying mitigation measures that changed the charter school’s bell schedule for instruction start and end times. Campbell Union High School District Environmental Review, Campbell, CA. Project Manager. For the past 12 years, Paul managed environmental review of several school improvement programs for the District for, including those funded through Measures C and G in Santa Clara County, as well as from other funding sources. The District serves more than 7,000 high school students in the cities of San Jose, Campbell, and Saratoga. Improvements have provided for the repair and modernization of existing school facilities and for construction of new facilities. Notable environmental issues addressed were to related projected increases of student/faculty and correlating increases traffic and parking demands, aesthetics (e.g., from new stadium lighting), and local community disruption effects (e.g., dust, noise, and traffic) associated with short-term construction activities. Burlingame School District Environmental Review, Burlingame, CA. Project Director. Under an on-call environmental services contract with the District, Paul directed the preparation of a number of environmental review documents, including an Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration for the District for a proposed new elementary school (Hoover Elementary School). Proposed improvements include remodeling of the historic former school building, demolition of a former cafeteria building, construction of new classroom building, and various circulation, parking and drainage improvements. Also analyzed environmental effects of improvements proposed at the District’s six other schools (Burlingame Intermediate School and Franklin, Lincoln, McKinley, Roosevelt, and Washington Elementary Schools), including new classroom building construction and modernization, and conversion of natural turf athletic fields to synthetic turf. West Contra Costa Unified School District New Middle School Environmental Review. Project Manager. Paul managed the environmental review for a new middle school for the West Contra Costa Unified School District (WCCUSD). The WCCUSD proposed to develop a middle school on the site of the former Ells High School in the City of Richmond. The principal environmental issues involved with the project involved potential hazardous materials, noise and traffic. Quarries Roblar Road Quarry Project EIR, Sonoma County, CA. Project Manager. Paul recently managed the completion of the EIR for a controversial new hard rock quarry in southern Sonoma County, adjacent to a former landfill. The applicant proposed to mine approximately 570,000 cubic yards annually over a 20-year use permit. Project approvals included a Mineral Resource zoning change, and a Surface Mining Conditional Use Permit. The project

presented a number of environmental and technical issues, geotechnical (e.g., slope stability, geologic hazards, blasting impacts) and hydrogeologic issues (e.g., alteration of groundwater gradient and flow, potential seepage into quarry, runoff effects to local creeks), and effects to biological resources. In addition, the project would create a new source of air emissions (including dust and diesel) and noise from on-site mining and processing and off-site quarry truck traffic, and visual impacts from mining. Other important issues include the effects associated with the project’s participation in the Williamson Act Easement Exchange Program, compatibility with surrounding agricultural and residential uses, and consistency with the County’s General Plan and Aggregate Resources Management Plan. The Final EIR was certified in December 2010. Canyon Rock Quarry Expansion Project EIR, Sonoma County, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the team preparing the EIR for a controversial expansion of the Canyon Rock Quarry, located west of Forestville in northern Sonoma County. The quarry proposed to expand to either the west or the north of its existing vested rights and permitted area. Primary environmental issues include potential hydrologic and water quality impacts to Green Valley Creek (which extends through the site), effects on biological resources, truck traffic impacts, air toxic impacts from increases in operations, noise (including blasting) impacts to nearby residents, and potential cumulative impacts when considering a quarry expansion adjacent to the Canyon Rock Quarry proposed by another applicant. The Final EIR was certified by the County Board of Supervisors in spring 2006. Pilarcitos Quarry Expansion EIR, San Mateo County, CA. Deputy Project Manager. Paul co-managed the team preparing the EIR for a proposed long- term expansion of the Pilarcitos Quarry, located in unincorporated San Mateo County approximately two miles east of the City of Half Moon Bay. The project would require approval of a proposed master plan for mining and reclamation (under which nine expansion areas would be mined over the next 100 years), as well as an amended Surface Mining Permit (subject to renewal every five years) and a Coastal Development permit. Important environmental issues include potential effects to environmentally sensitive habitat areas (ESHAs) identified on the project site, and geologic and hydrogeologic considerations, particularly given the presence of the Ox Mountain Landfill in the adjacent valley. Transportation, Transit and Multimodal Doyle Drive Environmental and Design Study Project, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Paul served as Project Manager of technical studies in support of an EIR/EIS for the proposed Doyle Drive Environmental and Design Study Project. The project proposes to replace the roadway leading to the south anchorage of the Golden Gate Bridge to improve seismic, structural, and traffic safety of the roadway. The San Francisco County Transportation Authority, working with the Federal Highway Administration and Caltrans is considering a number of alternative roadway designs (including tunnel alternatives). For the project, ESA prepared technical studies for air quality, noise and vibration, and the natural environment, and contribute to the EIR/EIS. Construction is currently underway, and expected to be completed in 2015. AC Transit Service Plans Environmental Review. Project Manager. Completed environmental review of several AC Transit service plans, as follows:

 AC Transit Service Deployment Plan (SDP). The SDP provided transit service deployment policies, and proposed a reorganized local transit network. The proposed changes focused on core transit routes within the District service area, in addition to an overhaul of the local service network within Central Alameda County. Major issues of environmental review included effects on transit availability, traffic and circulation, regional emissions, localized noise impacts, and socioeconomic considerations.  AC Transit Transbay Comprehensive Service Plan (CSP). The CSP guided the future service for AC Transit’s Transbay bus routes. The environmental review of the CSP focused on estimating the projected ridership associated with the bus route network alternatives; and evaluating the effect on traffic and circulation, air emissions, localized noise impacts, and socioeconomic considerations.  AC Transit Fremont-Newark Transit Development Plan (TDP). The TDP proposed extensive changes in bus routes within AC Transit’s Special Transit District II to provide a “grid” route network based on main streets, establish formal headway targets, develop transit hubs and create flexible service routes. Tracy Multimodal Station Environmental Review, Tracy, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation of environmental analysis of a proposed multimodal station in the downtown Tracy. The San Joaquin Regional Rail Commission proposed development of a passenger train station to accommodate planned commute rail service between the Bay Area and the Central Valley, and facilities to serve other transportation modes, including local and inter-city bus service, taxi service and bicyclists. The primary issues are those related to traffic generated at the station, train and other vehicular noise, and land use compatibility issues. Parking Facility Improvements at the Larkspur Ferry Terminal Environmental Review. Project Manager. Paul managed the environmental analysis for new surface parking facilities proposed by the Golden Gate Bridge Highway and Transportation District within a portion of the former Northwestern Pacific Railroad right-of-way adjacent to the Larkspur Ferry Terminal. Institutional Sutro Tower Improvements, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Paul is currently managing environmental review for a number of proposed communications and site improvements at Sutro Tower in San Francisco. At 977 feet tall and consisting of 3½ million pounds of steel, Sutro Tower is one of the Bay Area’s most visible icons. In 2009, Sutro Tower converted from analog to all-digital radio and TV transmissions, and underwent a number of structural upgrades to accommodate the required additional communications equipment. Sutro Tower now proposes additional communication improvements on the tower (including up to 50 broadcasting antennas, microwave dishes and cameras) and various ground-level improvements including retaining wall, erosion control and access road widening. In addition to the requisite array of environmental issues being analyzed, the project’s radio frequency radiation effects are also being addressed in the environmental document. New Morgan Hill Courthouse EIR, Santa Clara County, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the completion of an EIR for a new courthouse in

Morgan Hill proposed by Santa Clara County Facilities and Fleets Department (formerly General Services Agency). The project consisted of a full service Superior Courthouse, Offices for the District Attorney, Public Defender and Probation, and associated parking and infrastructure. The EIR also analyzed a potential City-owned and operated fire station on an approximate 0.5-acre surplus area of the project site. Principal environmental issues included traffic and parking, stormwater detention and drainage, and noise impacts (particularly those associated with operation of the potential fire station). The Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors certified the Final EIR and subsequently approved the Mitigated Project Alternative from the EIR as the preferred project. Santa Clara County Health Center Environmental Review, Santa Clara County, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the team conducting the environmental review of a proposed new County Valley Health Center (VHC) in Sunnyvale. The new VHC would consist of a 44,000 square-foot, three- story building, that would replace an existing 16,000 square-foot VHC that currently occupies the project site. The proposed VHC would provide expanded space for existing health services currently offered at the existing VHC, as well as provide a number of new health and support services not currently offered at this site, including dentistry, a pharmacy, and alcohol/drug services. Principal environmental issues include traffic and circulation, land use compatibility and utilities. Geneva Office Building Demolition Project EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the team that prepared an EIR for the proposed demolition of the Geneva office building and substation in the City of San Francisco. The wood-frame and brick building, owned by MUNI, was built in 1900 and is a designated city landmark. Thus, a key issue in the EIR was the project’s effect on cultural resources and historic preservation. Potential off-site transportation effects from the proposed post-use of the project site, and potential for encountering hazardous materials during demolition, were also assessed. Residential Clover Springs Residential Development EIR. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation of an EIR and environmental constraints study for a proposed hillside residential development in the City of Cloverdale. The site was primarily undeveloped and varied in terrain and natural features, containing a natural creek, and a large number of trees (including native oaks), as well as other potentially sensitive plant and animal species. Given the complexity of environmental issues, prior to submittal of a site plan by the applicant, ESA first prepared constraints and opportunities study of existing conditions for the City that served to influence the location and design of the development proposal. Principal environmental issues include potential geologic hazards, aesthetic impacts, impacts to biological resources, and potential fire hazard impacts. Northeast Rohnert Park Specific Plan EIR. Project Manager. Paul is currently overseeing the preparation of an EIR for the City of Rohnert Park for the proposed Northeast Area Specific Plan. The specific plan calls for development of a residential community of approximately 1,060 dwelling units in a variety of housing densities and types, 18 acres of parks and bikeways, and nearly 57 acres of other open space on an approximately 272- acre site adjacent to the northeastern edge of the city. The property consists primarily of former agricultural land, and contains a number of old buildings as well as two riparian corridors. Critical environmental issues include traffic

and circulation; and biological resources, including wetlands and California tiger salamander; water supply and utilities. ESA is coordinating this EIR with the EIRs for a number of other project/plans proposed within or adjacent to the City of Rohnert Park. Redwood Village EIR, San Rafael, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation of an EIR for a planned residential development in the city of San Rafael. The project consists of 134 residences, a neighborhood park, a wetland mitigation area, and a church expansion on the 17-acre site. Residence types include townhomes and medium to large single-family homes. The majority of the site was once owned by PG&E, and carried a public/quasi-public general plan and zoning designation. As a result, the project required a number of City approvals, including a general plan amendment and zoning change. Environmental issues assessed in the EIR include land use and planning consistency, transportation, hydrology, noise, and biological resources. Upon certifying the Final EIR, the City also adopted the Mitigated Project Alternative as the preferred project. Kiernan Business Park and Carver-Bangs Specific Plans Final EIR. Project Manager. Paul managed the completion of a Final EIR for two specific plans in Modesto which would provide for development of approximately 800 acres of business park, commercial, office and residential uses, as well as allow for a number of transportation improvements. The major environmental issues were related to traffic and circulation, including impacts level of service on project area roadway segments and intersections; and increases in demands on the local school district. Commercial Henry Cornell Winery EIR, Sonoma, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the completion of a Focused EIR for a proposed winery in eastern Sonoma County. The winery was proposed on the Cornell Farms property and would have a maximum annual production capacity of 10,000 cases. The project would include development of winery buildings; a 10,000 square-foot wine cave; access and parking improvements; various project-related infrastructure improvements for water harvesting and storage, wastewater treatment, conveyance and disposal; and landscaping improvements. The ambitious project design proposed to offset its use of groundwater for winery operations by using harvested rainwater and treated winery process water to reduce existing water demand for vineyard irrigation, and for landscape irrigation. The principal environmental issues were geologic issues associated with proposed construction on slopes in the vicinity of landslides; hydrologic and water quality issues related to project groundwater use, alteration of existing drainage patterns, and on-site application of treated process water; and biological issues associated with effects to on-site special-status plant species. The Final EIR was certified by the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors on December 11, 2012. Burlingame Safeway EIR, Burlingame, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the preparation of the EIR for a controversial Safeway store that would have replaced the existing Safeway store in downtown Burlingame. The project proposed to demolish three structures and developed a combined Safeway/Walgreens, and several small retail shops within one structure. The principal environmental issues associated with the project included traffic and parking, visual quality and aesthetics, historic tree resources, and operational noise. The EIR was certified by the city council, but the project itself was subsequently denied.

“McChevron,” Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Paul managed the completion of the environmental review of a combined Chevron gas station, convenience store and McDonald’s restaurant. The development would require the demolition of a former restaurant (J.J.’s Diner) on the site. This “flying saucer” shaped building is one of the few remaining “California Coffee Shop” style buildings remaining in the state, and is a Potential Designated Historic Property in Oakland. Thus, a key issue in the EIR was the project's effect on cultural resources and historic preservation.

EDUCATION Jennifer is an environmental analyst with a diverse background non-profit B.A. Environmental CEQA/NEPA law firm management, environmental policy with EPA, outdoor Studies & Political education, and biological fieldwork. This background provides Jennifer an Science, University aptitude for public speaking, client support, and document publication. of California Santa Barbara Jennifer has served as an associate analyst and deputy project manager for environmental planning and impact documents including the preparation of 5 YEARS’ programmatic and tiered analysis in accordance with CEQA and NEPA EXPERIENCE regulations. Her analytical experience includes assessing project-related PROFESSIONAL impacts to land use, plans and policy consistency, recreation, utilities, public AFFILIATIONS services, population and housing, hazards and hazardous materials, geology AND TRAINING and soils, agricultural resources, sea level rise, and floodplain management. Board Member Association of Environmental Professionals City of San Francisco HUD Region IX, 24 1500 Mission Street IS and EIR, City of San Francisco, CA Deputy Project CFR Part 58 Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided project support with Training the preparation of the Water Supply Assessment, as well as the Plans and Policies, Alternatives, and Cumulative analyses for the Preliminary EIR of which ESA is currently preparing. The project would involve the demolition of the two existing buildings on the project site and construction of two new towers—a 38-story, 380-foot-tall residential building (550 dwelling units) at the corner of Mission Street and South Van Ness Avenue, and an 18-story, 260-foot-tall office building on 11th Street between Market and Mission Streets. 1629 Market Street IS and EIR, City of San Francisco, CA Deputy Project Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided project support by drafting and project coordination support for the preparation of the Water Supply Assessment as well as the Initial Study and EIR of which ESA is currently preparing. The proposed project would demolish the three existing buildings and construct six new 55- to 85-foot-tall buildings containing 477 market-rate residential units, 107 affordable supportive housing units. In addition, the project would provide 9,275 square feet of active ground-floor commercial uses, 27,296 square feet of space for the Local 38 Plumbers and Pipefitters Union, 344 below grade parking spaces, and 22,395 square feet of publicly accessible open space in accordance with the Market and Octavia Area Plan. Central SoMa Plan Programmatic and Project EIR, City of San Francisco, CA Technical Assistance. Jennifer provided project support with generation of the Summary Table, updates to the IS analysis per project alterations, and the Alternative Analysis matrix for the Preliminary EIR of which ESA is currently preparing. The Plan would allow for intensified job growth and additional housing along either side of the new Central Subway light rail line in the area bounded by Market, Second, Townsend, and Sixth Streets. The Plan, which aims to capitalize on the increased transit availability, would allow for increased heights around light rail stations and also proposes new open spaces and changes to the street network to

facilitate travel by pedestrian, bicycle, and bus. These street network changes would extend east and west the Plan area on Howard and Folsom Streets, and include the potential for converting both to two-way traffic. MOHCD/NEPA 730 Stanyan EA, City of San Francisco, CA Project Manager. Jennifer served as Project Manager to coordinate technical staff and reports under an On-Call agreement with the San Francisco Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD). The EA, fulfills the environmental review requirements of 24 CFR Part 58 in HUD’s recommended EA format while comparing two primary project alternatives. The project considers the development of affordable housing within a five to seven-story building in the Haight-Ashbury neighborhood of San Francisco. Mission Bay South Block 6 West EA, City of San Francisco, CA Project Manager. Jennifer served as Project Manager to coordinate technical staff and reports under an On-Call agreement with the MOHCD. In addition, Jennifer is preparing analysis on several sections of the EA, which fulfills the environmental review requirements of 24 CFR Part 58 in HUD’s recommended EA format. The project includes the development of affordable housing (135 units) within a proposed 5-story building in the Mission Bay neighborhood of San Francisco. 1064-1068 Mission Street EA, City of San Francisco, CA Project Manager. Jennifer served as Project Manager to coordinate this EA prepared for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services on behalf of the MOHCD. The project includes the development of housing for formerly homeless residents (150 units for formerly homeless adults and 100 units for formerly homeless seniors) within a proposed 65-foot tall building and an 85- foot tall building in San Francisco’s SoMa neighborhood and within the greater Downtown. 88 Broadway Street and 735 Davis Street EA, City of San Francisco, CA. Deputy Project Manager. Jennifer served as Deputy Project Manager to coordinate the preparation of an EA in accordance with 24 CFR Part 58. The project includes the development of affordable family and affordable senior housing (178 units) along with commercial uses and childcare services within two proposed 6-story buildings in the North Beach neighborhood of San Francisco. Brooklyn Basin EA, City of Oakland, CA. Deputy Project Manager. Jennifer provided project management support, and drafting of the EA which fulfills the environmental review requirements of 24 CFR Part 58 in HUD’s recommended EA format. ESA prepared an EA on behalf of the City of Oakland for development of approximately 465 dwelling units of affordable housing within the larger 3,100-unit Brooklyn Basin Project. The EA considered and updated the analysis previously prepared in the certified EIR. Due to the projects location within the preliminary flood insurance risk maps, the EA required the preparation of the 8-step process under Executive Order 11988. 1150 3rd Street EA, City of San Francisco, CA Deputy Project Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer served as Deputy Project Manager to coordinate technical staff, reports, and ensure the project achieved the objectives for a satisfactory and timely completion. In addition, Jennifer prepared analysis on several sections of the EA, which fulfills the environmental review requirements of 24 CFR Part 58 in HUD’s recommended EA format. The project includes the development of affordable housing (101 units) within a proposed 5-story building. In the Mission Bay neighborhood of San Francisco. 4th and Folsom Project EA, City of San Francisco, CA Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided support by preparing the EA analysis on several sections of the EA checklist as part of ESA’s larger contract work with the City of San Francisco. ESA provides as-needed environmental review services for the Mayor's Office of Housing Part 58 Funded Projects in San Francisco. Contra Costa / East Bay Richmond Bay Specific Plan Programmatic EIR, City of Richmond, CA. Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided the analysis for the Geology, Soils and Minerals section, as well as Utilities, Hydrology and Water Quality, and provided assistance with the preparation and peer review of non-technical sections for the Draft EIR. Further, Jennifer provided project support with the preparation of the Response to Comments and Final EIR. The City of Richmond South Specific Plan and PEIR has contracted ESA to provide CEQA and Environmental Hydrology services. Richmond's vision for the 'South Shoreline' (Study Area) is to transform this currently underutilized industrial waterfront area into a revitalized, pedestrian-oriented district that would integrate a mixture of high-intensity research and development uses with new medium-density housing options anchored by the Richmond Bay Campus. It is the City's intent to develop a Specific Plan that capitalizes and compliments the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LABEL) in development for the Richmond Field Station (RFS) and Regatta properties by UC Berkeley and LABEL. Richmond Terminal One EIR, City of Richmond, CA. Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided peer review for submission the Draft EIR and the response to Comments for the Final EIR which ESA completed. The Richmond Terminal One Development proposes a residential multifamily condominium complex, attached townhomes, and single family homes. It also proposes recreational trails and a public park, which would connect the San Francisco Bay Trail along the South Richmond Shoreline. Bayview Residential Project EIR, Contra Costa County, CA. Technical Assistance. Jennifer provided peer review of each section in assistance with the preparation of the Final EIR as managed by ESA. The proposed project would develop 163 single-family homes and associated internal roadways on 42-acres and create two open space parcels of approximately 12 and 15 acres. Technical analyses for the EIR are related to the project’s proposed extensive grading plan that would substantially alter the existing topography of the project site, new land use designation that would require an amendment to the General Plan, and the project’s proximity to various heavy industrial uses. This EIR is currently under review. 19th and Broadway Project Exemption, City of Oakland, CA. Technical Assistance. Jennifer prepared the Final Checklist under CEQA Exemptions for this project for which ESA is currently preparing the Final Exemption Checklist. This project proposes 451-unit, 36-story building with lower floor retail and office use, and a restoration of a historic building in downtown Oakland. This Checklist is currently under review. City of Alameda, Alameda Marina Master Plan EIR, Alameda County, CA. Deputy Project Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer is currently assisting the EIR effort for the redevelopment of the 44-acre Alameda Marina

property on the Oakland Estuary. The comprehensively redeveloped property will include a mix of 779 new housing units, 150,000 square feet of retail and office uses, 550 boat slips, and 4.5 acres of public open space, including a new segment of the San Francisco Bay Trail. A significant component of the project will include the complete revitalization of the existing dock and shoreline infrastructure. Issues of concern for the project include transportation, aquatic resources, and historic architectural resources. Johnson Drive Economic Development Zone Programmatic EIR, City of Pleasanton, CA. Technical Assistance. Jennifer provided assistance with the response to comments of the Draft EIR for this controversial project. The Johnson Drive Economic Development Zone Programmatic EIR is a Focused EIR, relying on the existing General Plan and Housing Element Update EIRs. While covering potential environmental impacts generated by the project, and specifically focusing on traffic, air quality, and visual impacts, as well as any other areas not adequately covered by the existing EIRs. This EIR is currently under review. North Bay Upper Road Land Division EIR, Town of Ross, CA. Deputy Project Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer provided project support with the preparation of the Response to Comments and Final EIR. ESA provided technical expertise to complete an EIR started by a separate consulting firm for a proposed controversial three-lot subdivision. Watson Ranch Specific Plan Project EIR, City of American Canyon, CA. Environmental Analyst. Jennifer prepared the analysis for the Utilities and Public Services section, and provided peer review for the Draft EIR. The Watson Ranch Specific Plan Project proposes residential single and multifamily units, a mixed use retail center, elementary school, and space for future community center. It also proposes recreational trails and a public park. South Bay Stanford University 2018 General Use Permit EIR, Santa Clara County, CA. Deputy Project Manager and Environmental Analyst. Jennifer is currently assisting with the Program EIR for the County of Santa Clara for Stanford University’s proposed 2018 General Use Permit. The 2018 General Use Permit would authorize nearly 2.3 million net square feet of academic and academic support facilities and over 3,000 net new housing units/beds on its lands in unincorporated Santa Clara County, anticipated to take place between 2018 through 2035. Development would be constructed on vacant land, infill sites and redevelopment sites within Stanford’s Academic Growth Boundary. Stanford seeks County approval of the proposed General Use Permit and related amendments to the Stanford Community Plan and County Zoning Map. Stanford’s proposes to continue to implement Transportation Demand Management (TDM) programs, off-campus trip reduction programs and other measures to help Stanford achieve its No Net New Commute Trips standard. Other commitments include conversion to electric buses in its Marguerite fleet by 2035, and the use of Tier 4 construction equipment to reduce air quality and greenhouse gas emissions.

EDUCATION Chuck has more than 45 years of experience in applied environmental studies and project management, including over 36 years at ESA. Chuck, B.S., Mechanical Engineering, Stanford one of the founders of ESA, serves as consultant and directs work in applied University technical studies, impact analysis and environmental impact report/statement 45 YEARS (EIR/EIS) preparation. He has directed and contributed to more than 275 EXPERIENCE CEQA/NEPA impact studies and 500 technical studies in air quality, wind effects, health and safety, noise, vibration, visual effects and electromagnetic hazard. He has directed studies of more than 50 major industrial and public works projects, such as San Francisco's Southwest Water Pollution Control Plant; sewage solids handling facilities at the San Jose - Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant; modifications to the San Pablo (earthfill) Dam; flood control works; quarries; pipelines and industrial developments. Chuck’s recent efforts have focused on energy projects, including refineries that include cogeneration facilities, but also include electric transmission and distribution facilities. He serves as Project Director, Project Manager, Lead Technical Investigator, and Senior Technical Consultant.

Selected Experience Summaries, Project Director and Lead Investigator. He directed ESA’s pioneering Cellular Telephone Systems Environmental Review and Permitting work, which including preparation of Proponent's Environmental Assessments (PEAs) for the use of the California Public Utilities Commission, and prepared CEQA studies for more than 100 cell sites in the nine Bay Area counties over a four-year period. He also directed environmental permit support studies for over two dozen individual cell sites for proposed cellular radiotelephone systems in Northern California. He prepared technical studies, including evaluations of EMF and safety effects, and directed Initial Studies and Mitigated Negative Declarations for PG&E substations and power lines in Los Gatos, Petaluma; San Jose, and Santa Clara. He directed EIRs and EAs for five Satellite Earth Station projects, at Jamesburg, Mountain House, the San Francisco Presidio and El Toro Marine Base, California, and Tooele Army Depot, near Salt Lake City, Utah. e was technical task leader for the public health and safety analysis for the Gibraltar Peak Communications Site EIR, which included radiofrequency radiation modeling and on-site existing radiofrequency radiation level measurements. The Gibraltar Peak site included hundreds of antennas, with a range of transmitter powers from a few watts to thousands of watts and EMR frequencies from AM radio to FM radio, TV, cellular and microwave communications links.

General CEQA United Technologies Corporation (UTC) Facility Demolition, Grading, and Remediation EIR. Project Manager. Chuck managed preparation of an EIR for the United Technologies Corporation project which proposed to demolish, grade and remediate the site of its Pratt & Whitney Rocketdyne San Jose Facility, located approximately five-miles south of San Jose, in Santa Clara County. The site is currently undergoing a long-term Site Closure Program and contains over 200-buildings, structures, and stations on 1,900-acres with an additional 3,300-acres of underdeveloped buffer areas surrounding the facility. In total, the project site contains 5,200-acres. The facility was previously used to design and manufacture solid propellant rocket motors for the military and aerospace industry but discontinued production in 2004. No new construction was proposed on the site. No new construction was proposed on the site; the objective was to return the land, as much as possible, to it’s original rural agricultural state. The closure action involved very large on-going programs to monitor biological effects, surface water quality and groundwater contamination in the rural agricultural area. The EIR work also required coordination with several agencies including BAAQMD, SWRCB and DTSC, on the mitigation of impacts of the remediation work, as well as the previous site contamination. City of San Jose Digital Microwave Interoperability Project, San Jose, CA. Project Director. Chuck is assisting the City of San Jose Police Department in conducting environmental reviews, preparing CEQA and NEPA documents and providing environmental monitoring for the proposed construction of and/or modifications to the microwave transmission towers for the Santa Clara County emergency communications system. This system will allow first responders to improve local incident response times as well as allow the County to better manage regional incidents. Since the project requires both local and federal approvals, ESA is preparing a joint CEQA/NEPA Initial Study/Environmental Assessment that covers the system as a whole and also analyzes the impacts at each individual antenna location. The main issues of the project are biological resources, cultural resources, and public health and safety. 399 Fremont Street CEQA Analysis. Project Director. Having previously completed a Program EIR for the Rincon Hill Plan in San Francisco, ESA prepared a subsequent analysis under CEQA for a 430-unit residential building at 399 Fremont Street, within the Plan area. Employing a relatively novel approach in San Francisco, ESA and its subconsultants prepared technical studies covering historical resources, transportation, wind, and visual quality effects of the planned tower, which supported environmental review under CEQA Guidelines Sections 15168 and 15183, meaning that no new EIR was required and the CEQA documentation need only show that the project was consistent with the conclusions of the Program EIR for the area plan. The new building, which will contain 41 floors of residential space and be approximately 400 feet tall, was approved in June 2006. Pappas Radio Tower CEQA Documentation, Sonoma County, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed an EIR for the construction of three 616- foot AM radio signal antenna towers and accessory buildings at 5400 Highway 37, in Sonoma County. The project would occupy approximately 27 acres on Tubbs Island, at Sears Point, just east of the intersection of State Route 121 and State Route 37. ESA has peer-reviewed and verified all applicant-supplied information and prepared an Initial Study in order to identify CEQA checklist topics that would require further analysis or would require the development of measures to mitigate impacts. The EIR, which is currently being written, addresses visual quality, biological resources, agricultural resources and land use. Particular issues of concern are possible adverse visual effects caused by the construction of the lit towers, the conversion of agricultural land to wetlands (as proposed by the applicant’s landscaping plan), and bird mortality issues. Other issues raised during the scoping meeting and any comments provided by the general public are also being incorporated into the EIR. Sonoma County Permit and Resource Management Division is serving as the lead agency for this project. Bay Point Waterfront Strategic Plan EIR, Pittsburg, CA. Project Director. Chuck directed the preparation of the EIR for the Contra Costa County Redevelopment Agency’s proposed Bay Point Waterfront Strategic Plan. The Redevelopment Agency proposal was to revitalize the Bay Point waterfront area by developing a full-scale marina with related commercial and support uses, medium-density housing, interconnected open space and pedestrian walkways, and natural open space. A majority of the Plan Area is located within the jurisdiction of the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC). The Bay Point Waterfront Strategic Plan required an Amendment to the Contra Costa County General Plan to change both the Urban Limit Line and the land use designations for some portions of the site. Although not the subject of substantial controversy among the public, the EIR did involve extensive efforts to coordinate marina and wetland issues with the adjacent landowner and to develop mitigation measures that would be acceptable to BCDC, as well as measures that would be acceptable to LAFCO and local utility districts. Washington Hospital Healthcare System EIR, Fremont and Alameda County, CA. Chuck is assisting in the preparation of an EIR for a proposed redevelopment and expansion of the approximately 31-acre Washington Hospital Healthcare System's medical campus in the City of Fremont, near the City's Central Business District. The project would implement the 2030 Expansion Plan and would result in an increase of approximately 550,000 gross square feet of medical facilities for inpatient, administrative, and general services (from 313,000 to 863,000 gross square feet). The project would consist of about 350 hospital beds in a bed tower containing 10 nursing wards and the following additional facilities: Emergency Room (ER); Intensive Care Unit/Critical Care Unit (ICU/CCU); Surgery; Radiology; and Diagnostic and Treatment facilities with a Cath Lab. The project would also include construction of a new staff parking garage and a central power plant/laundry facility; extension to the ambulance care services; and a new main entry, atrium, and plaza area as well as new landscaping and reorganizing the surface parking. Demolition and new construction would occur strategically over several years to ensure continued operations of the Hospital. The issues to be analyzed in the EIR include land use, plans, and policies; traffic, transportation, circulation, and parking; air quality; noise; geology, soils, and seismic safety; hydrology, drainage, and water quality; public health and safety; cultural resources; utility service systems; energy; public services; and visual quality.

Refinery Experience City of Benicia Valero Crude by Rail Project, Benicia, CA. Project Director. Chuck is overseeing EIR for the Valero Crude by Rail project for the City of Benicia. The proposed project would include installing rail spur tracks

and new transfer equipment, and infrastructure that would enable the Valero Refinery, located in Benicia, CA to receive a portion of its crude oil deliveries by railcar. The Draft EIR is anticipated to be circulated in spring 2014. City of Benicia Valero Improvement Project EIR, Benicia, CA. Project Director. Chuck directed preparation of the EIR for this controversial $140 million, 7-year project for the City of Benicia. The VIP installed typical refining equipment to modernize, optimize, and expand the operation of the Valero Benicia Refinery primarily to allow processing of broader ranges of crude oil than are now possible at the Refinery. These changes included piping, heat exchangers, instrumentation, catalytic reactors, fractionation equipment, pumps, compressors, furnaces, tanks, and their associated facilities. The VIP was proposed as a major improvement project for the Refinery and was to span seven years in duration. Given the closeness of the Refinery to the City, there was substantial local community interest in this project. ESA assisted the City in all phases of the environmental review of the project and interaction with the local community which included such critical issue areas as air quality, public health and public safety. This project also considered issues related to a City wastewater reuse plan for the refinery. The EIR was certified in June 2003. ESA continues to support the City with as needed mitigation monitoring services to ensure Valero's environmental compliance with the approved project. Currently ESA is conducting monthly mitigation monitoring compliance inspections during the next phase of VIP construction. City of Richmond Chevron Refinery Renewal Project EIR, Richmond, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed the preparation of a Draft EIR for the proposed renewal project at Chevron's refinery in Richmond. The proposed replacement facilities and equipment will be designed and constructed utilizing current engineering technology which reduces air emissions, increases energy efficiency, improves equipment and process reliability, and provides for inherently greater safety. ESA also conducted an extensive analysis of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the proposed project, and worked with the City of Richmond to develop comprehensive mitigation measures to fully offset potential increases of GHGs from the project. ConocoPhillips San Francisco Refinery Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel Project, Rodeo, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed the team that examined the environmental effects of, and prepared the EIR for, a series of improvements proposed at the ConocoPhillips Refinery at Rodeo, CA. The ULSD project's objectives were to give the Refinery the capability to produce Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel to meet the EPA's January 2006 deadline, to increase production capacity of the refinery and improve the ability to process low-cost high sulfur crude oils. The ULSD project was the first of its kind involving the production of Ultra Low Sulfer Diesel Fuel in Northern California. Following a review of the project's complex elements, the study traced the chain of their potential environmental impacts, including air quality, water quality, traffic, public health and public safety effects, within the local area and throughout the broader region. The study required careful technical analysis to assess the direct and the indirect impacts that could result from constructing and operating the project. In response to the published Draft, nearly 300 comment letters were received. Although over 90% supported the project, more than 300 questions and technical comments required substantive answers to be prepared and published in the Final EIR. The EIR was certified in 2003. The ULSD project was built over the next several years and is currently in operation. *Updated 8/19/10 ConocoPhillips Clean Fuel Expansion Project, Rodeo, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed a team that prepared the EIR and worked closely with the Community Development Department of Contra Costa County on CEQA compliance for the proposed Clean Fuels Expansion Project (CFEP) at the ConocoPhillips Rodeo Refinery. The CFEP objectives were to add new facilities and modify existing facilities to increase the production of clean fuels. ConocoPhillips wanted to be able to use those Heavy Gas Oils that were being produced at the Refinery and sold into the HGO and fuel markets, to produce cleaner-burning gasoline and ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuels targeted for the California market. In addition to increasing cleaner-burning gasoline production, the CFEP increased the Refinery's production of ultra- low-sulfur diesel fuels. The CFEP included construction of a new hydrogen plant to produce the additional hydrogen needed in the production of additional fuel. The hydrogen plant was constructed and is operated by a third party (Air Liquide) on a designated site within the Refinery. Specific environmental project concerns were the potential impacts to air quality, noise, public safety and public health, and water quality. The County’s approval of the CFEP EIR was appealed by project opponents. ESA provided substantial direct assistance to the County in preparing substantive answers and rebuttals to the many technical comments and claims of the appellants. The County upheld its approval and certified the EIR in 2007; the project was completed and began operation in 2009. Updated Aug 19, 2010 ConocoPhillips Refinery Projects EIRs, Rodeo, CA. Project Manager. Chuck led the teams that prepared EIRs and worked closely with the Community Development Department of Contra Costa County on CEQA compliance for two controversial projects at the ConocoPhillips Rodeo Refinery. ESA prepared and ultimately provided legally defensible environmental documentation for the County that focused primarily on contentious air quality and health issues raised by neighbors from Rodeo to the Carquinez Straits and land-use conflict issues in unincorporated Rodeo. In 2002, ESA began work to prepare the EIR for the Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel Project (ULSD). The ULSD project's objectives were to give the Refinery the capability to produce Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel to meet the EPA's January 2006 deadline, to increase production capacity of the refinery and to improve the ability to process low-cost high sulfur crude oils. The ULSD project was the first of its kind involving the production of Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel in Northern California. Following a technical review of the project's complex elements, the study traced the chain of their potential environmental impacts, including effects to existing local air quality, noise, energy, water quality, transportation and public health and public safety effects, within the local area and throughout the broader region. The study required careful technical analysis to assess the direct and the indirect impacts that could result from constructing and operating the project. In response to the published Draft, nearly 300 comment letters were received. Although over 90% supported the project, more than 300 questions and technical comments required substantive answers to be prepared and published in the Final EIR. The EIR was certified in 2003. The ULSD project was built over the next several years and is currently in operation. In 2005, ESA began work to prepare an EIR for the Clean Fuels Expansion Project (CFEP) at the ConocoPhillips Refinery. The CFEP objectives were to add new facilities and modify existing facilities to increase the production of clean fuels.The CFEP objectives were to add new facilities and modify existing facilities to increase the production of clean fuels. ConocoPhillips wanted to be able to use those Heavy Gas Oils that were being produced at the Refinery and sold into the HGO and fuel markets, to produce cleaner- burning gasoline and ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuels targeted for

the California market. In addition to increasing cleaner-burning gasoline production, the CFEP increased the production of ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuels. The CFEP included construction of a new hydrogen plant to produce the additional hydrogen needed in the production of additional fuel. The hydrogen plant was constructed and is operated by a third party (Air Liquide) on a designated site within the Refinery. Specific environmental project concerns were the potential impacts to air quality, noise, public safety and public health, and water quality. The County’s approval of the CFEP EIR was appealed by project opponents. ESA provided substantial direct assistance to the County in preparing substantive answers and rebuttals to the many technical comments and claims of the appellants. The County upheld its approval and certified the EIR in 2007. The project was completed and began operation in 2009. Richmond Refinery Chevron Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade, Richmond, CA. Project Manager. Directed all of the day-to-day work, for the EIR (certified in 1994) for the Chevron Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade project at the Richmond Refinery. The EIR involved extensive technical analysis to identify the impacts, including air quality, traffic, fiscal, health and safety and accident effects, that could result from the complex $750 million project to produce the new Clean Fuels and to upgrade major portions of the refinery to improve operating efficiency. City of Richmond Master Contract, Contra Costa, CA. Project Manager. Mr. Bennett currently directs the Richmond Master Contract, under which over a dozen EIRs have been prepared. Among these are four Richmond projects: EIR for the Brickyard Cover Commercial Buildings (in progress), EIR for Chevron Refinery Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade, EIR for Richmond Master Plan Update, and Negative Declaration for the California Advanced Environmental Technology Corporation’s (CAETC) hazardous materials transfer facility. He also served as the Project Manager, directing all of the day-to-day work, for the EIR (certified in 1994) for the Chevron Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade project at the Richmond Refinery. The EIR involved extensive analysis to identify the impacts, including air quality, traffic, fiscal, health and safety and accident effects, that could result from the complex $750 million project to upgrade major portions of Chevron's Richmond refinery. ConocoPhillips Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel and Strategic Modernization Project EIR, Contra Costa County, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed a study to examine the effects of a series of improvements proposed at the ConocoPhillips Refinery at Rodeo, CA. The project would give the Refinery the capability to produce Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel to meet the EPA’s January 2006 deadline, increase production capacity of the refinery and improve the ability to process low-cost high sulfur crude oils. Following a review of the project’s complex elements, the study traced the chain of their potential environmental impacts, including air quality, water quality, traffic, public health and public safety effects, within the local area and throughout the broader region. The study required careful technical analysis to assess the direct and the indirect impacts that could result from constructing and operating the project. In response to the published Draft, nearly 300 comment letters were received. Although over 90% supported the project, more than 300 questions and technical comments required substantive answers. The draft of the Final document has been prepared and awaits County approval. Ultramar Golden Eagle Refinery’s Second Phase Clean Fuels Project EIR Addendum, Contra Costa County, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed the preparation of an Addendum to the existing EIR. The study first involved careful and detailed technical work to correctly identify the project’s many complex process unit elements and distinguish them from other on- going (cumulative) projects at the Martinez refinery. The County’s approval of the project was appealed by project opponents. ESA provided substantial direct assistance to the County in preparing substantive answers and rebuttals to the several hundred technical comments, claims and assertions of the appellants. The County subsequently upheld the approval of the refinery’s proposed modification program. University Experience UCSF Medical Center at Mission Bay Subsequent EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed the EIR for UCSF’s integrated medical facility to serve children, women and cancer patients in Mission Bay, near its existing 43-acre biomedical campus. The project is to be undertaken in two major phases. The “LRDP Phase” will construct a 979,000-gross- square-foot, 289-bed Medical Center on the east parcel of the project site and structured and surface parking on the west parcel. For rapid access to UCSF’s specialized level of care for critically ill children and pregnant women, a helipad will be constructed on the northernmost portion of the Medical Center to accommodate helicopter transport. The “Future Phase” (second phase) will provide an additional 808,000 gross square feet of Medical Center facilities that will replace the surface parking on the west parcel. The Subsequent EIR tiers off of a previous EIR for UCSF’s Hospital Replacement Program that was also prepared by ESA under Chuck’s direction. The Regents approved the project and construction of the LRDP Phase facilities began in 2010. U.C. Davis Long Range Development Plan EIR, Berkeley, CA. Project Manager. Prepared the Health and Safety and Hazardous Materials analyses for the new U.C. Davis LRDP. He also directed the preparation of EIRs for U.C. Davis on a new Environmental Service (HazMat) Facility and a new Contained Research (Biohazard Level 3) Facility on the western portion of the campus. The evaluation focused on the handling, storage and disposal of hazardous materials at the Environmental Service Facility and focused on the operation of Biohazard Level 3 laboratories and contained greenhouses at the Contained Research Facility. In the same time frame, he directed preparation of various technical studies and a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the Equine Analytical Chemistry Laboratory. U.C. San Francisco Revised Laurel Heights Plan EIR, San Francisco, CA. Health Risk Assessment Analyst. Chuck directed and served as lead technical investigator on two separate studies to assess the effects of exhaust emissions from planned University of California, San Francisco animal care and biomedical research facilities at each of the existing UCSF Parnassus and at the new UCSF Mission Bay campuses. The effort included work to characterize the dilution of toxics in the exhaust stack flows and to determine the risks that would result. Both efforts involved working with the building tenants to characterize the emissions and the project architects and engineers to develop effective exhaust stack designs and operating parameters. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Building 51 and Bevatron Demolition Project EIR/EA, Alameda County, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed both the CEQA EIR and the NEPA EA for the Building 51 and Bevatron Demolition Project at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, which included evaluation of human health risks and impacts of accidents

and upset. Major environmental issues analyzed in the EIR/EA include the mitigation of significant impacts to the historic Bevatron, traffic and circulation associated with hauling of demolition materials through the City of Berkeley, handling and disposal of hazardous and radioactive materials, noise, air quality, public health and safety, visual quality and land use and planning. Public controversy focused on the historic impact and potential health risks to the public from the demolition. In 2009, work began on the long term project to dismantle and remove the Bevatron and to demolish Building 51, which houses it. U.C. Berkeley Haas Pavilion, Berkeley, CA. Project Manager. Chuck studied the potential for reflected solar glare from the new Haas Pavilion to adversely affect baseball players at adjacent Evans Field, where intercollegiate baseball games are played on the Campus. After preliminary findings of the study were presented, the design of the Pavilion was altered to eliminate certain windows that would have reflected the image of the late afternoon sun into the eyes of players on the right side of the field during a part of the collegiate baseball season. UCSF Building 19A Health Risk Assessment (HRA), San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed a screening study to support design development of Building 19B at the UCSF Mission Bay Campus and performed wind tunnel testing of building exhaust stacks and conducting a health risk assessment for the operation of proposed Phases 1 and 2 of Building 19A. The HRA measured the potential for emissions of toxic air contaminants from exhaust stacks as well as stationary diesel emergency generators. Numeric modeling and the results of the wind tunnel testing of the exhaust stacks were used to determine peak and annual average exposures for important receptors. ESA worked closely with UCSF EH&S to develop emission estimates that reflect as accurately as possible the reasonably foreseeable chemical use within the buildings. UC San Francisco Building 24 Fume Hood Exhaust Stack Testing, Design Assistance and Health Risk Assessment, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Under contract to UC San Francisco, ESA prepared a Health Risk Assessment at this first UCSF building in the new Mission Bay campus. ESA worked with the UCSF project team to identify and quantify the critical sources of toxic emissions, assess the public exposures to these toxic emissions that would result from the operation of the building, and evaluate the overall health risk to the public from the normal operation of the building. Because the building is planned to be located next to a day-care center and near a future public school site, the normal numerical screening models were considered to be too uncertain for sole use. The source term came from projected use of toxic materials, the physical data on dilution of exhaust came from the wind-tunnel tests and one year of local meteorological data was used to determine the frequency of exposure. This result was an independent empirical estimate of the potential acute and chronic health impacts that could result from the operation of the project. This empirical estimate was then compared with the standard numerical modeling results, which yielded a higher estimate of the health risk than did the empirical method. With this information in hand, the UCSF design team was able to make logical design decisions based on the known design factors, cost and overall effectiveness of the HVAC and toxic exhaust systems. ESA also conducted wind-tunnel tests to assist in the design and placement of fume hood exhaust stacks to serve the chemical laboratories, biological research laboratories and animal facilities. In addition to design assistance, ESA worked with project architects and engineers to develop rational criteria to measure the performance of the fume hood and generator exhaust system systems. ESA worked with the project team to develop effective and cost- conscious solutions to problems found. UCSF Long-Range Development Plan Hospital Amendment EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Chuck managed the EIR on the Hospital Amendment to UCSF’s 1996 LRDP. ESA staff analyzed air quality and noise impacts from the construction and operation of the proposed Hospital based on the criteria set-forth in the CEQA and Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) CEQA guidelines. ESA staff also assessed air quality effects of traffic using URBEMIS and analyzed Toxic Air Contaminant emission impacts using a risk-based approach. The LRDP Amendment addresses the inclusion and upgrading of UCSF's Hospital facilities that were addressed in the original LRDP. The 1996 LRDP did not consider the proposed facilities and functions because, at that time, they were to be under the control of the merged UCSF-Stanford clinical entity. The termination of the UCSF-Stanford Health Care entity left UCSF with a LRDP that did not address the existing clinical facilities, the changes needed to meet the growth in demand for services, or the seismic safety mandates of Senate Bill 1953 and subsequent legislation. Wind and Shadow Chiron Corporation Master Development Plan Pedestrian Wind Tests and Health Risk Assessment, Emeryville, CA. Project Manager. Chuck provided detailed technical studies for the Chiron project to evaluate health risk to the neighbors that could result from Chiron's nearly one million square feet of research laboratories, proposed to be located next to a residential neighborhood. Used a combination of wind tunnel and numerical modeling studies to assess potential impacts. Directed preparation of the complex biological, chemical and physical health and safety, hazardous materials / site contamination and air toxic evaluations performed on the project. 555 Washington Street Wind and Shadow Studies, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Managing the wind and shadow studies for the proposed residential high-rise tower at 555 Washington Street in the downtown area of San Francisco commonly known as the Financial District. The project would demolish two existing buildings (nine-story structure at 545 Sansome Street and a single-story structure at 501-505 Washington Street) and construct a 38-story, approximate 390-foot-tall residential building with ground floor retail and four basement levels of parking. ESA is preparing a Proposition K shadow study for the proposed project, which includes running shadow movies to determine times of year, times of day and context area affected by the proposed project and calculating net new shadow on affected properties. ESA is also conducting a wind tunnel test for the proposed project. 100 California Street Shadow Study, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Prepared scaled drawings that could be used to evaluate potential shadows cast by the proposed 100 California Street building on the open spaces in the vicinity, in compliance with Proposition K Ordinance. ESA is preparing an Initial Study and Mitigated Negative Declaration for a proposed 52,000- square-foot office building on San Francisco’s Embarcadero, one block south of the Ferry Building. The project, which is intended by the sponsor to be the first office building in San Francisco to receive Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Platinum certification as a “green” building, will have glass facades interspersed with planters containing vines that would help cool the building and reduce energy use.

Third and Mission Streets High-Rise Building - Proposition K Shadow Study, San Francisco, CA. Technical Advisor. Served as technical resource and advisor to the staff of the San Francisco Department of City Planning leading to development of the ordinance that regulates the shadow effects of high-rise buildings on dedicated public open spaces. Worked with Department staff in developing methods to present shadow information to the City Planning Commission and to the public. Palace Hotel Shadow Digital Model, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Prepared a digital model of the Palace Hotel that includes new construction near the Palace, including the St. Regis tower and new housing tower (both at Third and Mission), and any other nearby new construction that would affect the skylight of the Garden Court. Older Experience Contra Costa County NPDES Ordinance, Contra Costa County, CA. Project Manager. Working on an expedited schedule, Chuck directed the team that worked closely with senior County planning staff to prepare a Negative Declaration for Contra Costa County's current Stormwater Management and Discharge Control Ordinance. In February 2003, the RWQCB San Francisco Bay Region added Provision C.3 in the Contra Costa Clean Water Program municipalities’ stormwater NPDES permit. The RWQCB mandated that Contra Costa municipalities (within their jurisdiction) impose new, more stringent requirements to control runoff from development projects. In response, the County proposed to replace the existing ordinance with a new ordinance. The new ordinance provides the same environmental protection as the existing ordinance and also implemented the new more stringent NPDES permit C.3 provisions imposed by the RWQCB. Main environmental issues included water quality impacts as well as public health impacts that could result from implementation of the stormwater management Best Management Practices that are required by the ordinance.

Pacific Enterprises and Enova Proponents Environmental Assessment, Los Angeles, CA. Project Director. Prepared for use by Pacific Enterprises and Enova, parent companies of Southern California Gas Company and San Diego Gas and Electric Company respectively, in support of the parent companies’ merger application to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC). The document evaluated the environmental effects that could result from the merger of the holding companies into a new parent company, now called Sempra Energy. This work was prepared on an extremely accelerated 3-week schedule that required very substantial effort by nearly 10 key ESA staff, who worked nights and weekends for the duration of the work to help the client meet their inflexible submittal deadline. After the submittal, similar efforts were required to prepare formal responses to technical comments and interrogatories by project opponents as a part of the CPUC process. Site Selection. US Ecology Low-Level Radioactive Waste Site. Directed ESA’s effort to establish and operate meteorological stations to provide data to support selection for a disposal site in Southern California. In addition to initial shorter-term efforts for meteorological site selection, planning, construction and operation to screen each of the candidate areas, it was required to conduct longer-term measurements, exceeding the minimum 1- year of continual measurements and meeting the specific operational data gathering reliability standard, for the prime site. He also prepared ESA's QA/QC Plan to meet strict NRC quality assurance requirements and served as the Quality Control Officer for the duration of the program. Included preparation of Proponent's Environmental Assessments (PEAs) for the use of the California Public Utilities Commission, as well as environmental permit support for over two dozen individual cell sites for proposed cellular radiotelephone systems in El Dorado, Sacramento, Napa, Monterey, and Ventura Counties, as well as more than 100 cell sites in the nine Bay Area counties over a four-year period. Satellite Earth Station Projects’ EIRs and EAs, Monterey, CA. Project Director. As director of the Jamesburg Earth Station EIR, Mr. Bennett coordinated the measurement and evaluation of microwave radiation associated with operation of the existing 97-foot diameter parabolic antenna and the projected increase in radiation due to the 62-foot and 105-foot diameter (receiving/transmitting) antennas proposed for site expansion. Mr. Bennett directed the preparation of a series of three Preliminary Environmental Assessments for the Department of Defense's Commercial Telecommunications Network (DCTN), under contract to AT&T. ESA's reports examined the installation of earth terminals (receiver / transmitter stations) at The Presidio in San Francisco and the El Toro Marine Base in California and at the Tooele Army Depot, near Salt Lake City, Utah. The visual impact of the satellite dishes was the most significant issue raised for sites on military bases. Mr. Bennett directed five Satellite Earth Station project EIRs and EAs. As director of the Jamesburg Earth Station EIR, he coordinated measurements by Stanford Professor Bruce Lusignan and performed the evaluation of microwave radiation associated with operation of the existing 97-foot diameter parabolic antenna and the projected increase in radiation due to the 62-foot and 105-foot diameter (receiving / transmitting) antennas proposed. Mr. Bennett directed the preparation of a series of three Preliminary Environmental Assessments for the Department of Defense's Commercial Telecommunications Network (DCTN), under contract to AT&T. ESA's reports examined the installation of earth terminals (receiver / transmitter stations) at The Presidio in San Francisco and the El Toro Marine Base in California and at the Tooele Army Depot, near Salt Lake City, Utah. There, the visual impact of the satellite dishes was the most significant issue raised. California Advanced Environmental Technology Corporation’s Hazardous Materials Transfer Facility Negative Declaration. Project Director. Work included preparation of a supporting technical study of the risk from possible accidents, and Mr. Bennett made presentations of these technical findings at three separate meetings to neighborhood community action groups including the West County Toxics Coalition and the Toxic Cloud Task Force, and to study sessions of the City Council and Environmental Assessment Panels. U.S. Postal Service Master Contracts, CA. Project Director. He was the primary contact with the client, assigns staff, and provides oversight direction of all of the more than 120 NEPA and related studies performed over a five- year period in the western U.S. for siting U.S. Postal Service facilities. In Mr. Bennett's long-time work involving communications facilities, he commonly addresses issues of health effects, visual impact, and alternate project location and configuration. Mr. Bennett has agency coordination experience with CPUC and FCC. He also directed the microwave interference and health risk analyses for the Pacific Plaza, the Golden State Tower, and the R Street Corridor EIRs for the City of Sacramento. In each of these studies, there were concerns that the buildings would interfere with

established microwave communications links as well as with long-range weather radar of the Weather Service. ESA examined the interference concern and also evaluated the health-related questions for individuals working within the buildings close to the microwave link paths. Mr. Bennett evaluated the EMR exposures that would result in residences in the Communications Hill development in San Jose, which was proposed adjacent to microwave and communications antennas on the site. The health issues related to developing housing were addressed by comparing the computed exposures for residents with the existing national exposure standards. In addition to work on many other environmental studies, he directed studies of more than 30 major projects, such as San Francisco’s Southwest Water Pollution Control Plant; sewage solids handling facilities at the San Jose – Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant; modifications to the San Pablo (earthfill) Dam; a geothermal test well; flood control works; quarries; pipelines and residential, commercial, industrial, and recreational development. Prior to co-founding ESA, Mr. Bennett was employed for over 10 years at the U.S. Naval Radiological Defense Laboratory (NRDL) at Hunter’s Point, where he worked on large-scale experiments on liquid and particulate radioactive contaminants in the environment. Mr. Bennett’s work at NRDL focused on environmental transport and dispersion phenomena research involving use of radionuclides and on developing search / location techniques and applications of underwater acoustics. He served as a member of the RADCON emergency radiological incident response team of the laboratory. San Francisco Giants Downtown Stadium Wind Studies, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Directed wind tunnel study and analysis to determine the better of two feasible orientations for the Stadium, and then to determine the general wind conditions at seats in the stadium bowl. Made comparisons with conditions in the present ballpark, 3-Com Park. Conducted subsequent wind testing to determine pedestrian comfort and safety for public areas around the stadium. Also advised the ballpark’s architects on measures to mitigate wind conditions in problem areas. Kirby Canyon Visual Impact Analysis, Santa Clara County, CA. Project Director. Chuck carried out a technical study to assess the significance of lighting and glare effects that would occur within the adjacent community of Morgan Hill as a result of adding a new 4-lamp 440,000 lumen, bank of lights to enable night cover and fill operations at the work face of the Kirby Canyon Landfill, in Santa Clara County, California. EIRs involving Glare, Visual and Shadow as Major Issues Brickyard Cove Commercial Buildings EIR, Richmond, CA. Project Manager. For this project, a visual impact of the proposed buildings was of great concern to residents of the Brickyard Landing condominiums, which overlooks the project. Two sets of photo-realistic computer-generated visual simulations were developed to show the views from those residential units that would be most affected by the view change. These were intended to allow planning commissioners and residents to assess the visual change. Richmond Refinery Chevron Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade EIR, Richmond, CA. Project Director/Manager. The EIR involved extensive analysis to identify the impacts, including air quality, traffic, fiscal, health and safety and accident effects, and the visual effects (including the effect of altered nighttime lighting at the refinery) that could result from the complex $750,000,000 project to upgrade major portions of the refinery. EMF Communications Hill Technical Study, San Jose, CA. Mr. Bennett evaluated the EMR exposures that would result in residences in the Communications Hill development in San Jose, which was proposed adjacent to microwave and communications antennas on the site. The health issues related to developing housing were addressed by comparing the computed exposures for residents with the existing national exposure standards. Skynet Earth Station Satellite Dish, Alameda County, CA. Project Director. Mr. Bennett prepared an environmental assessment for AT&T's 13- meter Skynet Earth Station satellite dish at Altamont Pass. The report was prepared to satisfy FCC requirements regarding the installation of antennas with a diameter greater than 30 feet. ESA staff investigated the geology and soils of the project area, and calculated microwave radiation levels. The earth station broadcasts at 6 GHz with an average power of 500 watts. The isolation of the site precluded concern for EMR exposures to the station’s power of 500 watts. Gibraltar Peak Communications Site EIR, Santa Barbara, CA. Technical Task Leader and Senior Technical Reviewer. Provided the public health and safety analysis for the Gibraltar Peak Communications Site EIR, which included radiofrequency radiation modeling performed by Dr. Arthur W. Guy of the University of Washington Bioelectromagnetics Research Laboratory and on-site existing radiofrequency radiation level measurements by Dr. Bruce B. Lusignan of Stanford University's Communication Satellite Siting Program, Santa Barbara, CA. The Gibraltar Peak site included hundreds of antennas, with a range of transmitter powers from a few watts to thousands of watts and EMR frequencies from AM radio to FM radio, TV, cellular and microwave communications links. The principal investigator for the evaluation of the biological effects was Dr. Guy. Microwave Interference and Health Risk Analyses, Sacramento, CA. Mr. Bennett also directed the microwave interference and health risk analyses for the Pacific Plaza, the Golden State Tower, and the R Street Corridor EIRs for the City of Sacramento. In each of these studies, there were concerns that the buildings would interfere with established microwave communications links as well as with long-range weather radar of the Weather Service. ESA examined the interference concern and also evaluated the health-related questions for individuals working within the buildings close to the microwave link paths. GTE Mobilnet Site Cell EIR. Project Manager. Project included a 35-foot tower supporting three transmitting antennas and associated receiving antennas and a pre-fabricated equipment shelter proposed adjacent to the Fisher Junior High School in Los Gatos, CA. The EIR included a detailed field test program to characterize radiofrequency radiation (RFR) levels at points of closest public access and in areas that children would occupy throughout the school day. The test program, conducted by Professor Bruce Lusignan of Stanford, erected a temporary cellular transmission facility, complete with transmitters and antennas. RFR (radio-frequency radiation) levels were measured with precision instruments at representative locations on the grounds of the school and on adjacent public areas. Simultaneously, a literature search was conducted by Professor Jerrold Bushberg of U.C. Davis, to review current knowledge about the effects of exposure to RFR and

to assess existing standards for exposure to RFR. Current laboratory and epidemiological literature were reviewed, as they represent the sources for recommended exposure limits. The processes by which the standards are set and updated were reviewed and conclusions about the adequacy of the standards to address the impacts of the proposed project were presented. Finally, the efforts of the two studies were integrated: the results of the measurement of RFR levels were used to evaluate the potential for adverse health effects with the project. The measured RFR levels for the site were compared to existing standards for general population exposure to RFR to determine whether the existing facilities present a significant adverse impact to public health and safety. He directed ESA’s pioneering Cellular Telephone Systems Environmental Review and Permitting work, which including preparation of Proponent's Environmental Assessments (PEAs) for the use of the California Public Utilities Commission, as well as environmental permit support for over two dozen individual cell sites for proposed cellular radiotelephone systems in El Dorado, Sacramento, Napa, Monterey, and Ventura Counties, as well as more than 100 cell sites in the nine Bay Area counties over a four-year period. CPUC Project Experience. In Mr. Bennett's long-time work involving electric power and communications facilities, he commonly addresses issues of health effects, as well as issues of alternate project location and configuration. Among recent projects, under a master contract with the CPUC, he managed the preparation of and also contributed technical analyses to Initial Studies and Mitigated Negative Declarations for the following PG&E 115 kV substation and power line projects: the Vasona 230 kV-12 kV Substation in Los Gatos; the Corona 115 kV-12 kV Substation in Petaluma; the FMC 230 kV-12 kV Substation in San Jose; and the North San Jose Capacity Project in San Jose and Santa Clara, including construction of a 230 kV power line and a 230 kV-12 kV substation to provide secondary capacity to serve the rapid and substantial industrial and growth in North San Jose. Mr. Bennett coordinated detailed CEQA Initial Studies and prepared the EMF and Safety analyses for the CPUC's Negative Declarations for PG&E's proposed Vasona 230 kV - 12 kV substation and for the Corona and FMC 230 kV - 12 kV substations and power lines. He also is currently performing similar analyses for several transmission line and substation projects, in Sonoma, Lake and Santa Clara counties, California. Under a master contract with the CPUC, he recently prepared technical studies, including evaluations of EMF and safety effects, and directed preparation of Initial Studies and Mitigated Negative Declarations for the following PG&E substation and power line projects: the Vasona Substation in Los Gatos; the Corona Substation in Petaluma; the FMC Substation in San Jose; and, the North San Jose Capacity Project in San Jose and Santa Clara. Mr. Bennett served as advisor to the City of San Jose in evaluating potential EMF implications for a city park that could be developed within the right-of- way of a 115 kV transmission line; for a neighborhood advisory council, he prepared a third-party evaluation of EMR materials presented by LA Cellular on a proposed cell site; and, he directed preparation of an EIR on a proposed GTE Mobilnet cell site. Richmond Refinery Projects, Richmond, CA. Project Manager. Directed all of the day-to-day work, for the EIR (certified in 1994) for the Chevron Reformulated Gasoline and FCC Upgrade project at the Richmond Refinery. The EIR involved extensive analysis to identify the impacts, including air quality, traffic, fiscal, health and safety and accident effects, that could result from the complex $750 million project to upgrade major portions of the refinery. Glare Analysis Experience. Conducted studies of proposed buildings that would have highly reflective glass or metal skins to determine if glare from those buildings would cause safety problems for vehicle operators on adjacent roadways or would cause safety problems or otherwise impair the usability of nearby open spaces or walkways. He also has consulted to architects to assist them in the design of large glass atriums where internal lighting, glare and contrast, and insulation could pose comfort and/or safety concerns for the public. Solar Shading Studies. Has directed and conducted several hundred solar shading studies related to open spaces and pedestrian use areas for high- rise offices and other building projects proposed in San Francisco and other cities. These studies had different objectives; many were required by cities for the analysis of the environmental effects of those projects, while others were carried out to inform the owners or to assist the project architects in the design of the buildings and/or layout of amenities and landscape features.

Wind Analysis Experience. Chuck directed over 150 wind tunnel tests for high-rise buildings proposed in San Francisco, Oakland, Los Angeles, Sacramento and other California cities and has served as technical advisor to the staff of the San Francisco Department of City Planning in the development of the City’s ordinance to regulate the wind effects of high-rise buildings on pedestrians and public open spaces. He developed the wind data analysis and computer code used by all wind consultants in processing wind tunnel test data for San Francisco projects. He directed the wind tunnel study and analysis to determine the better of two feasible orientations for the Giants Downtown Stadium, and then to determine the general wind conditions at seats in the stadium bowl and public spaces nearby. Additionally, Chuck’s work has included wind studies of the planned new 49er Stadium and Mall at Candlestick Point. His most recent work includes wind consulting services and wind tunnel tests of pedestrian winds for a proposed City administration building, the Moscone Center Expansion Project, the Gap World Headquarters Building, and several other buildings in San Francisco.

EDUCATION B.S., Public Affairs, Rachel offers knowledge of Bay Area ecology, environmental regulations, Environmental and environmental planning, through eleven years of environmental Management, Indiana consulting work. She has project experience in preparing complex CEQA and University, School of NEPA analysis of project-related impacts on biological resources, writing Public and Environmental Affairs habitat assessments and permit applications, implementing restoration mitigation monitoring and reporting plans, conducting wetland delineations, 11 YEARS construction compliance monitoring and SWPPP inspection, and surveying EXPERIENCE for nesting birds and special-status species (California red-legged frog, Specialized Training California tiger salamander, western pond turtle, San Joaquin kit fox, Golden Gate Audubon burrowing owl, Ridgway’s rail, San Francisco dusky-footed woodrat, and salt and California marsh harvest mouse). Rachel develops and implements project-specific Academy of Sciences, environmental training programs, manages compliance monitoring and Master Birder Training Course, Feb.-Dec. reporting documentation, and tracks and manages environmental data in 2014 support mitigation and monitoring plans. She acts as project manager and Focused Classes on compliance manager for a variety of environmental compliance projects in Birds of the Bay Area, the Bay Area. 2010, 2011, 2012, 2014, 2017 Prior to joining ESA, Rachel served as an Environmental Multi-media and San Francisco State, Research Contractor for federal agencies, and assisted in forest inventories, Basic Wetland avian surveys, and invasive vegetation monitoring for non-profit groups in the Delineation Training, Central Valley and Sierra foothills. 2014 Transportation Worker Identification Credential (TWIC), Golden State Warriors Arena LLC, Event Center and Mixed-Use 2009 Development at Mission Bay Blocks 29-32 Supplemental Environmental UC Berkeley Impact Report, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel performed Extension CEQA reconnaissance surveys of the project area and authored the biological Training, 2008 resources impact analysis for the project environmental document. The Laguna de Santa project consists of an ambitious proposal by the Golden State Warriors Rosa Foundation, (GSW) to construct a world-class arena/event center at Mission Bay Blocks Rare Pond Species 29-32 in San Francisco that would serve as the new home for GSW Survey Techniques Workshop, 2008 headquarters and basketball games, as well as a year-round venue for concerts, cultural events, conventions and other uses such as a hotel and PROFESSIONAL residential housing. AFFILIATIONS The Wildlife Society, Turnstone Consultants, Pier 70 Environmental Impact Report, San San Francisco Bay Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel performed reconnaissance surveys of the Area, Chapter project area and authored the terrestrial biological resources impact analysis Treasurer 2013 - 2015 for the EIR. ESA served as a subconsultant to Turnstone Consulting for American certain technical sections of the document including Air Quality, Biological Ornithologists Union resources, Wind/Shadow, Sea Level Rise, and Cultural Resources. The Golden Gate Audubon proposed project would include demolition eight existing buildings, and Society construction of replacement and new housing, office, and retail uses, new infrastructure, open space and community amenities on a 28-acre site located in the southeast corner of the approximately 66-acre Port-owned area known as Pier 70 in the City’s Central Waterfront, as well as an adjacent 7-acre area fronting Illinois Street between 20th and 22nd Streets.

SFPUC, Oceanside Water Pollution Control Plant (OSP) Odor Control Optimization Project, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel is the task lead for rare plant surveys of the OSP building 230 green roof in support of constructing the plant’s new stack. She is currently conducting surveys of the 25,000 square- foot disturbance area with a focus on San Francisco spineflower which is known to the central dune scrub green roof. Survey results will inform the project environmental document describing presence of rare plants, potential impacts the project could have, and influence as- needed compensatory mitigation. SFPUC, Restoration and Revegetation Services, Sunol Valley Division, CA. Project Manager and Biologist. Rachel supervises and provides field support for long-term monitoring of on-site mitigation for several Water Supply Improvement Program projects in the Sunol Valley region. She oversees and participates in field teams implementing qualitative and quantitative monitoring and reporting, and provides recommendations for restoration treatments and vegetation maintenance to ensure successful completion of mitigation commitments. Rachel manages project and contract invoicing for this ESA+Orion Joint Venture and regularly communicates with the team project managers and field staff. Contra Costa County, Bayview Residential Project, Contra Costa County, CA. Biologist. ESA is preparing an EIR for the proposed infill residential development in the Vine Hill/Pacheco Boulevard area of unincorporated Contra Costa County. The proposed project would develop 163 single-family homes and associated internal roadways on 42-acres and create two open space parcels of approximately 12 and 15 acres. Technical analyses for the EIR are related to the project’s proposed extensive grading plan that would substantially alter the existing topography of the project site, new land use designation that would require an amendment to the General Plan, and the project’s proximity to various heavy industrial uses. The EIR will also analyze the potential environmental impacts related to the required extension and upgrade to offsite utility lines. Rachel performed a reconnaissance survey of the project area is preparing the biological resources impact analysis for the EIR. HydroScience Engineers, Inc., Memorial Park Wastewater Treatment and Infrastructure Replacement Project, unincorporated San Mateo County, CA. Biologist. The San Mateo County Parks Department and the County Department of Public Works proposes to implement the Memorial Park Wastewater Treatment Infrastructure Replacement Project which includes replacement of the existing wastewater treatment plant, repairs and replacement of pipes and manholes, and other necessary upgrades to the wastewater treatment system from wastewater conveyance to disposal. San Mateo County has hired HydroScience Engineers, Inc., to design the system improvements and ESA is preparing the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) and providing permitting support to HydroScience Engineers, Inc. for the project. Rachel authored a biological resources constraints analysis to support the forthcoming project CEQA analysis and to identify project components in the design phase which could be modified to avoid or reduce potential impacts to biological resources. City of Burlingame, SFO@Technology Center, Burlingame, CA. Biologist. Fox Bayshore Investments, LLC, proposes to develop an office/life science campus on a 6.2-acre site at 1300 Old Bayshore Highway in the City of Burlingame. The project is adjacent to San Francisco Bay and would include development of two buildings comprising approximately 259,700 square feet (sf) of building development, along with site transportation, infrastructure, recreational and landscaping improvements. The project would remove five buildings on the project site totaling approximately 127,200 sf, including several one- to two- story commercial buildings and a former movie theater. ESA is preparing the project Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) for the City of Burlingame. Rachel conducted a reconnaissance survey of the project site and prepared the biological resources impact analysis for the IS/MND. San Mateo County Airports, Halfmoon Bay Airport Taxiway, Access Road Fence, and Drainage Improvements Project, Halfmoon Bay, San Mateo County, CA. Biologist. ESA provided environmental permitting support, pre-construction surveys and compliance monitoring and reporting services during removal and replacement of two drainage culverts and the perimeter chain-link fencing at the Half Moon Bay Airport. ESA also prepared the revegetation plans for the culvert disturbance areas. Rachel monitored during construction for California red-legged frog, San Francisco gartersnake, San Francisco dusky-footed woodrat, and nesting birds. California red-legged frog adults and tadpoles were present within the culvert work area drainages. Victor Quan, 590 Leland Avenue Biological Survey, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. ESA conducted biological reconnaissance surveys to evaluate the presence of rare plants in coastal scrub habitat on and adjacent to the project site, where the project sponsor proposes to demolish an existing church building and construct five single-family dwellings. Rachel performed botanical surveys of the project site and prepared a results memorandum. San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, Pacific Rod and Gun Club Upland Soil Remediation Project Restoration Monitoring, San Francisco, CA. Biologist/Project Manager. Rachel is the task lead on conducting annual quantitative and qualitative monitoring of restored riparian, coastal scrub, and upland landscaped habitats within the former Pacific Rod and Gun Club, located on the southwest shore of South Lake Merced. Prior to restoration, the site underwent soil remediation as required by the California Regional Water Quality Control Board for the historical contamination of the site by lead shot and targets made with asphaltic materials or petroleum pitch. Monitoring tasks include a survival, health and vigor assessment of planted trees, shrubs, willows, and knotweed, vegetative cover assessment in restored wetlands using both line-intercept and 1m2 quadrat survey methods along several transects, and photo documentation. Rachel interprets the monitoring data and prepares the annual reports. She previously acted as compliance manager during the remediation effort and authored the biological resources assessment for the project IS/MND. Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District, Golden Gate Bridge Physical Suicide Deterrent System and Wind Retrofit Environmental Compliance Monitoring, San Francisco, CA. Environmental Compliance Monitor. Rachel conducts weekly environmental compliance field inspections of the construction sites on the north and south ends of the Golden Gate Bridge to ensure compliance with a variety of project permits and plans, including stormwater management, public access, and protection of the Mission blue butterfly habitat adjacent the project site and within the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, among others. Rachel developed and is implementing the worker environmental awareness training program, conducts surveys for peregrine falcons and other nesting birds during breeding season, prepares reporting documentation, reviews

contractor submittals, and attends weekly progress meetings with project partners. California State Coastal Conservancy, Hamilton Wetlands Wildlife Monitoring, Novato, CA. Biologist. ESA is implemented a monitoring program to document the effects of public access on shorebirds resulting from use of the pedestrian trail adjacent to restored wetlands. ESA developed the monitoring protocol with the SCC as a condition of the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission permit for the Hamilton Wetlands Restoration Project. Rachel was the task-lead for the monitoring effort which occurred between November 2017 and January 2018 during the spring and fall migrations. Rachel authored the technical report summarizing monitoring observations and conclusions of the study.

California State Coastal Conservancy, Giant Marsh Living Shorelines Project, Contra Costa County, CA. Biologist. Rachel authored the Biological Assessment of Ridgway’s rail and salt marsh harvest mouse on the project that includes enhancing subtidal, intertidal, and transition zone habitats. The project is being led by the California State Coastal Conservancy and consists of an integrated habitat enhancement design to achieve multiple biological and physical benefits.

Town of Hillsborough, Sanitary Sewer Rehabilitation and Replacement Project, Hillsborough, CA. Biologist. ESA prepared the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration and permit applications for the Town’s Sanitary Sewer, Water Main, and Cherry Creek Pump Station Rehabilitation and Replacement Project. Several of the utility lines or associated facilities cross or are located adjacent to jurisdictional wetlands, waters, or occur within riparian areas. Pipeline replacement is expected to utilize either pipe bursting, pipe reaming, open trench, or cured in place methods of construction. Rachel prepared the project’s wetland delineation, biological resources impact analysis for the IS/MND, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biological assessment for California red-legged frog, San Francisco gartersnake, and San Mateo Wooly Sunflower, and permit applications to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, California Department of Fish and Game, and California Regional Water Quality Control Board.

California Public Utilities Commission, Monterey Peninsula Water Supply Project, Monterey County, CA. Biologist. ESA prepared the project environmental documentation identifying potential impacts of California American Water Company’s (CalAm) proposal to develop a new source of potable water for several coastal communities in Monterey County. Rachel assisted in preparing the biological resources impact analysis of the CEQA document and conducted presence/absence surveys for special-status plant and animal species within the project boundary.

City of Pacifica, Capistrano Emergency Wall Repair, Pacifica, CA. Biologist. Rachel performed pre-construction surveys for central California coast steelhead, California red-legged frog, western pond turtle, and roosting bats within San Pedro Creek. The project involved an emergency repair of a failing concrete retaining wall associated with a fish ladder on San Pedro Creek. University of California Berkeley, Haas School of Business Expansion Project, Berkeley, CA. Biologist. ESA provided permitting support services for campus expansion of the Haas Business School that involved re-routing a culvert on Strawberry Creek and relocating a historic building. Restoration of the redwood understory abutting the creek was required as mitigation for stream bed and bank impacts. Rachel assisted in designing the restoration planting plans and selecting the locally-native species planting pallet appropriate for the campus environment. Kleinfelder, Chabot Dam Construction Monitoring, San Leandro, CA. Biologist. ESA is the environmental compliance program manager during the construction phase of the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) Chabot Dam seismic upgrade project. The purpose is to reduce the possibility of damage to the earthen dam and reservoir outlet works due to a large earthquake on the adjacent Hayward Fault. The main components of the project include cement deep soil mixing (CDSM) to strengthen the soils within the downstream toe of the dam down to bedrock and install a new reservoir outlet pipeline and valves. Wildlife species concerns include Alameda whipsnake, California red-legged frog, San Francisco dusky-footed woodrat, nesting birds and roosting bats. ESA performed pre-construction special-status plant and animal surveys, developed and implemented the worker environmental awareness training program, relocated woodrat middens under informal guidance from CDFW, and are currently monitoring during construction. Rachel conducted pre-construction wildlife surveys and monitors construction activities near sensitive resources. City of Oakland, Oak Knoll Mixed Use Community Plan Project Supplemental Environmental Impact Report, Oakland, CA. Biologist. ESA is currently preparing an Environmental Impact Report for a proposed mixed use development of residential neighborhoods, commercial development, and open space and recreational facilities on approximately 165 acres of the former decommissioned Naval Medical Center Oakland property at Oak Knoll. Rachel performed reconnaissance surveys of the project area and authored the terrestrial biological resources impact analysis for the EIR. Placeworks, Pigeon Point Lighthouse General Plan CEQA and SFPUC, Westside Recycled Water Project, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel prepared the Biological Assessment for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service of potential project-related impacts to California red-legged frog, a federal-listed threatened species. ESA prepared the EIR for the San Francisco Westside Recycled Water Project and is currently supporting the project permitting efforts. The project purpose is to reduce the City and County of San Francisco’s reliance on potable water for nonpotable uses by meeting the current water demand of several SFPUC customers that have substantial irrigation needs, including Golden Gate Park, Lincoln Park golf course, and portions of the Presidio. Highly treated wastewater will be produced at a new recycled water treatment plant and distributed via pipeline network to a series of reservoirs and pump stations. Kiewit Infrastructure West Co., San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge Marine Foundation Demolition, Oakland, CA. Biologist. Rachel acted as an environmental monitor of the Pier E3 demolition, providing support to the Kiewit/Manson Joint Venture Team in moving the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge East Span removal project forward. Pier E3 was the first and largest pier to be removed and formerly supported the east end of the cantilever section of the original Bay Bridge. Rachel’s responsibilities included monitoring for nesting birds, general water quality conditions, marine mammals, hazing birds, and documenting observations in daily reports.

Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District, Monte Bello Open Space Preserve Bridge Replacement IS/MND, Palo Alto, CA. Biologist. Rachel performed reconnaissance surveys of the project area and authored the biological resources impact analysis for the project Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration. The project includes the removal and replacement an existing pedestrian bridge and the installation of an additional pedestrian bridge over Stevens Creek and Tributary Creek waterways within the District’s trail system. Wildlife species concerns included nesting birds, roosting bats, San Francisco dusky-footed woodrat, San Francisco gartersnake, California red-legged frog, foothill yellow-legged frog, and red- bellied newt. Presidio Trust, New Presidio Parklands Project Environmental Assessment, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. ESA prepared the Environmental Assessment sections for cultural, biological, and visual resources to support the Presidio Trust in NEPA compliance for the New Presidio Parklands Project. Rachel performed a reconnaissance survey of the project site and authored the biological resources section of the Environmental Assessment. SFPUC, Pacific Rod and Gun Club Upland Soil Remediation Project Compliance Monitoring, San Francisco, CA. Environmental Compliance Manager/Project Manager. Rachel managed the environmental construction compliance inspection and monitoring team that conducted pre-construction surveys and monitoring onsite biological resources during soil remediation of the Pacific Rod and Gun Club. Primary concerns during project implementation included potential impacts to special-status plants, western pond turtle, roosting bats, nesting birds, and jurisdictional wetlands along the north shoreline. Rachel conducted pre-construction nesting bird, special- status plant, and tree canopy density surveys, and was the primary contact for project compliance concerns. She was the task lead for collection and reintroduction of San Francisco spineflower seeds from a rare plant population identified at a project backfill material source near the San Francisco Zoo. Rachel also authored the project’s Tree Monitoring Plan and Restoration As-Built Report. She regularly communicated with the client project managers, authored and reviewed environmental compliance reporting documentation, restoration-related RFIs and submittals, and managed project invoicing and progress reporting. Rachel previously authored the biological resources impact analysis for the project IS/MND lead by ESA. McMillen Jacobs Associates, Vista Grande Drainage Basin Improvement Project Environmental Impact Statement / Environmental Impact Report, Daly City, CA. Biologist. ESA is working with the City of Daly City to provide project planning, CEQA/NEPA documentation, and environmental permitting for the Stormwater Drainage Project in the Vista Grande Basin. The project purpose is to address storm-related flooding in the Basin, specifically the downstream area around the Vista Grande canal and tunnel at Lake Merced Boulevard and John Muir Drive while providing a consistent water supply for management of Lake Merced. Preparation of the EIR/EIS has required internal review and ongoing coordination with Daly City (CEQA lead agency), National Park Service (NEPA lead agency), McMillan- Jacobs Engineer (design engineer), and SFPUC (Lake Merced responsible agency). ESA manages an ongoing public outreach program, and is also managing regulatory permitting and agency coordination with the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, California Coastal Commission, California State Lands Commission, and the California Department of Fish and Game regarding biological resource and water quality issues related to stormwater diversion and capacity. ESA has implemented biological and wetland resources surveys; cultural resources studies; water quality investigations (including a water quality sampling program) issues related to NPDES and protection of beneficial uses; coastal processes/erosion analysis; and land use and recreation studies, and development of visual simulations. Rachel authored the biological resources impact analysis for the EIR/EIS and performed protocol surveys for nesting peregrine falcons and nesting bank swallows in the vicinity of the Vista Grande project location at and around Fort Funston. SFPUC, Little Yosemite Fish Passage Project Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration, Sunol Regional Wilderness, CA. Biologist. ESA conducted the CEQA compliance and permitting processes in support of SFPUC’s proposed Alameda Creek fish passage improvements. The proposed project involves creek bed modifications through the Little Yosemite reach of Alameda Creek to increase pool depths and reduce fall drops to facilitate steelhead migration. ESA has also conducted several technical studies to support the CEQA and permitting effort, including preparation of a wetland delineation, cultural resources surveys, and protocol-level surveys for special-status plants with potential to occur on the project site. Rachel performed a reconnaissance survey of the project area and authored the biological resources impact analysis for the CEQA document. San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department, Beach Chalet Avian Monitoring, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel developed implemented the Beach Chalet Athletic Fields Renovation Project’s Avian Monitoring Plan (AMP). The field renovations include updates to the athletic facilities as well as the addition of ten 60-foot tall light installations. As the fields exist along the Pacific Flyway migration route, the California Coastal Commission requested an AMP to study the potential adverse impacts on resident and migratory birds resulting from the light installations. The AMP includes pre- construction baseline surveys and post construction monitoring during fall and spring migrations while the lights are in use. A report will summarize the AMP results at the end of the monitoring period, provide conclusions on the lighting impacts on birds, and provide recommendations as necessary. City of Oakland, 12th Street Wetland Mitigation Monitoring, Oakland, CA. Biologist. ESA is providing technical monitoring and reporting of the mitigation planting site for five years which includes quantitative wetland vegetation monitoring, upland vegetation monitoring, and hydrologic monitoring associated with the Lake Merritt 12th Street Reconstruction and 10th Street Channel Improvement Project. Rachel is the task lead who performs qualitative and quantitative wetland vegetation monitoring once annually, upland vegetation monitoring on a monthly basis, hydrologic monitoring six times annually, provides management recommendations to the City, and prepares the annual reports to the permitting agencies. ESA PWA designed the marsh mitigation site for the project. SFPUC, Pacific Rod and Gun Club Upland Soil Remediation Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. ESA prepared the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) for the remedial action project which involved excavation and appropriate off-site disposal of up to 46,500 cubic yards of soils containing elevated concentrations of lead and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) from the site and backfilling of excavated areas with clean imported fill material. ESA

also drafted environmental permit applications and developed a Riparian and Wetland Restoration and Mitigation Monitoring Plan (RWRMMP) for the project located on the southwest shore of South Lake Merced. Rachel authored the biological resources impact analysis for the project which discussed potential impacts to special-status plants, special-status bats, nesting birds, and jurisdictional wetlands. Hunters View Associates, Hunters View Phase II Bird Survey, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. ESA performed pre-construction nesting bird surveys in advance of construction on the second phase of the Hunters View Redevelopment Project which replaces existing buildings with high-density, multi-family, and mixed-income residences in the Hunters Point neighborhood of San Francisco. Rachel developed and managed the project budget, performed the nesting bird surveys, and authored the associated technical memorandum. Sutro Tower, Inc., Sutro Tower Environmental Impact Report Addendum, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel conducted the site assessment and authored the biological resources impact analysis for the addendum to the Sutro Tower Digital Television Project EIR under which erosion prevention and control elements were incorporated into the original project. ESA prepared the original CEQA assessment for the project which analyzed the conversion of the analog/digital television antenna to an all digital system. These improvements included replacement of a number of the tower’s large antennae; structural upgrades to the tower to meet all applicable Building Code wind resistance requirements and accommodate the placement of new digital television equipment on the tower; alteration, replacement or addition of a number of small ancillary antennae and equipment on the tower, transmitter building rooftop and secured grounds; and addition of auxiliary equipment and electrical, elevator and public safety improvements. Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District, Golden Gate Bridge Seismic Retrofit Phase IIIA Environmental Compliance Monitoring, San Francisco, CA. Environmental Compliance Monitor, Deputy Project Manager. Rachel conducted weekly environmental compliance monitoring field inspections of the construction site between fall 2011 and spring 2014 to ensure contractor’s compliance with project permits and plans, including stormwater management, public access, and protection of the Mission blue butterfly habitat adjacent the project site and within the Golden Gate National Recreation Area. Rachel authored quarterly reports documenting project compliance, coordinated development of the project’s restoration and revegetation plans, and regularly interfaced with project partners within the Golden Gate Bridge District and the National Park Service. She tracked project budget through monthly invoicing and managed reporting documentation. The lead agency of this project is the Golden Gate Bridge Highway and Transportation District. Wood Partners, 55 Laguna Redevelopment Pre-construction Technical Reports, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Conducted pre-construction avian surveys and a tree assessment and prepared the technical memorandums in support of the redevelopment project located in downtown San Francisco. ESA previously prepared the CEQA and NEPA analysis for the project. University of California San Francisco (UCSF), Long Range Development Plan EIR, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. ESA is prepared the EIR for the 2014 Long Range Development Plan (LRDP) and Rachel authored the impact analysis on biological resources. The LRDP will guide campus growth and development of the University through the year 2035. UCSF is projecting to grow by approximately 2.4 million square feet over this time period, accommodating an additional 900 students and 11,000 employees. Some projects under the LRDP include a new 308,000-square foot hospital addition at the Parnassus Heights campus site and several new research and office buildings at the Mission Bay campus site as well as over 500 residential units. City of San Bruno, Hotel at the Crossing Initial Study, San Bruno, CA. Biologist. Conducted the initial site assessment and authored the biological resources impact analysis for the development of a hotel site near the Crossing Mall in the City of San Bruno. Provisions for the hotel development were included in the U.S. Navy and Its Environs Specific plan, adopted by the City in 2002 and amended in 2005. Ronald Yu, Palou-Phelps Biological Assessment, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel conducted site assessments and authored an environmental assessment of biological resources within and surrounding a proposed residential development adjacent the Palou-Phelps Mini Park and Significant Natural Area, as designated by the City of San Francisco recreation and Parks Department. ARUP PB Joint Venture, Doyle Drive Construction Monitoring and Mitigation Planning, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. The Presidio of San Francisco’s (the Presidio) Doyle Drive is located at the southern approach to the Golden Gate Bridge. The project involves replacement of Doyle Drive to improve the seismic, structural, and traffic safety of the roadway within the setting and context of the Presidio and its purpose as a National Park. Rachel acted as the primary compliance monitor between summer 2010 and summer 2012, during which time she provided on-going environmental trainings to project personnel, conducted weekly compliance environmental monitoring, on-going bird surveys during nesting season, and conducted annual vegetation monitoring of project wetlands. She conducted quarterly avian and noise monitoring at established locations on the project site and authored analysis on project-related noise impacts on birds in the Presidio, specifically those in Crissy Marsh and at Dragonfly Creek. North Coast County Water District, Pacific Recycled Water Project, Pacifica, CA. Deputy Project Manager, Biologist. Rachel acted as the primary liaison with the North Coast County Water District (NCCWD) and oversaw a team of biologists, including ESA’s subconsultant Swaim Biological Inc., in conducting pre-construction surveys and monitoring for San Francisco gartersnake, California red-legged frog, and San Francisco dusky- footed woodrat during the installation of a recycled water line and construction of a pump station. She performed pre-construction surveys for nesting birds, developed the worker environmental training program, tracked project budget through monthly invoicing, and managed compliance monitoring documentation. Carollo Engineers, Harding Park Recycled Water Project, San Francisco, CA. Biologist. Rachel conducted ongoing nesting bird surveys along the project alignment during installation of the recycled water line and pump station. She also tracked project budget in this phase through monthly invoicing. ESA prepared an EIR for the City of Daly City for the project, which includes 4,700 feet of 18" line along Lake Merced Boulevard from the City of Daly City’s Wastewater Plant to the maintenance yard at City and County of San Francisco’s Harding Park Golf Club. The project also includes a buried

storage tank located in the maintenance yard parking lot (60 x 100 x 20' deep) and will also serve as a base to the parking lot. ESA worked with the City of Daly City and coordinated with SFPUC and City and County of San Francisco in preparing the EIR. The EIR was certified and the project was approved in late 2009. City and County of San Francisco, Harry Tracy Water Treatment Plant Long Term Pre-Construction Surveys, Millbrae, CA. Deputy Project Manager/Biologist. ESA conducted the pre-construction surveys, environmental trainings, and weekly site inspections during the first phase of the Water Treatment Plant upgrade project consisting of tree and scrub removal on the project site with a presence of dusky-footed woodrats and potential for special-status bats. Rachel developed and implemented the worker environmental training program and conducted weekly site inspections for project compliance with CEQA mitigation measures. She acted as a project liaison between the client, contractors, and ESA field staff throughout pre-construction operations. Livermore Amador Valley Water Management Agency, Export Pipeline Western Terminus Project, San Leandro, CA. Biologist. The project involved using a hydro directional drill to install new pipe beneath San Leandro marshland and open-cut trench installation of a 2000 ft. treated wastewater pipeline through transitional upland areas bordering the marsh. Rachel conducted daily surveys and routine monitoring for salt marsh harvest mice and Ridgway’s rail during construction, managed daily compliance documentation, and drafted the final construction compliance report for the City of San Leandro and project permitting agencies. She assisted in the development of the environmental training program, designed the training trifold booklet, and regularly conducted trainings for new project personnel throughout the duration of the project. Rachel assisted in four years of annual vegetation monitoring to track performance of the restored tidal marsh, upland grassland and coastal scrub habitats with success criteria established in the project permits. SFPUC, Water System Improvement Program, Northern CA. Document Coordinator. Rachel assisted with the development and continued maintenance of a database designed to track responses to comments for a controversial Draft EIR, for the SFPUC. The EIR was designed to provide an analysis of proposed regional water system improvements, including the identification and clarification of environmental issues and potential trade- offs, to build a foundation for and streamline CEQA review of subsequent projects.

EDUCATION General - Karl, Program Manager with ESA’s Bay Area Community Development Group, has managed the preparation of Environmental Impact B.A., Urban Studies, San Francisco State Reports (EIR) and Mitigated Negative Declarations (MND) for numerous University residential projects, large office projects, civic development projects, and 23 YEARS rezoning projects. In addition to his management role, he has technical EXPERIENCE expertise in the areas of land use, zoning and plan consistency; architectural resources; and traffic, transportation and parking. Karl also specializes in PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS development of EIR alternatives and comparative analysis of their potential effects. Association of Residential – Karl has managed the preparation of Environmental Impact Environmental Professionals Reports (EIR) and Negative Declarations (MND) for numerous residential projects, primarily in San Francisco and Oakland. In addition to his management role, he has technical expertise in the areas of land use, zoning and plan consistency; architectural resources; and traffic, transportation and parking. Karl also specializes in development of EIR alternatives and comparative analysis of their potential effects. Commercial – Karl has managed the preparation of Environmental Impact Reports (EIR) and Mitigated Negative Declarations (MND) for several large office projects, including Hines’ 560 Mission Street building in San Francisco and Shorenstein’s 555 City Center project in Oakland. In addition to his management role, he has technical expertise in the areas of land use, zoning and plan consistency; architectural resources; and traffic, transportation and parking. Karl also specializes in development of EIR alternatives and comparative analysis of their potential effects. Non-Profit Clients – Karl has managed the preparation of CEQA documents for several non-profit organizations in the Bay Area, including Citizens Housing Corporation, Mercy Housing, Habitat for Humanity, and California College of the Arts. In addition to his management role, Karl has technical expertise in the areas of land use, zoning and plan consistency; architectural resources; and traffic, transportation and parking. He also specializes in development of EIR alternatives and comparative analysis of their potential effects. Public/Civic Projects – Karl has managed Environmental Impact Reports (EIR) for several large civic development projects involving multiple subcontractors, including San Francisco’s new Civic Center courthouse and Asian Art Museum and Oakland’s City Administration Buildings and Coliseum Arena expansion. In addition to project management, Karl has technical expertise in land use, zoning and plan consistency; architectural resources; traffic, transportation and parking; and public services impacts. He also specializes in development of EIR alternatives and comparative analysis of their potential effects. Since joining ESA in 1990, He has managed EIRs for several large civic projects in San Francisco and the Bay Area. General Plan Amendments – Since joining ESA in 1990, Karl has managed Environmental Impact Report (EIR)s and rezonings including the San Francisco Eastern Neighborhoods Rezoning EIR, Rincon Hill Plan EIR,

Oakland’s Land Use and Transportation Element plan, and the Oakland Estuary Plan. His involvement and experience in a variety of projects makes him an expert in the processes and intricacies of all areas of land use planning.

Central South of Market (SoMa) Plan, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl is managing the EIR for this Plan, which would allow for intensified job growth and additional housing along either side of the new Central Subway light rail line in the South of Market district. The Plan, which aims to capitalize on the increased transit availability, would allow for increased heights around rail stations and also proposes new open spaces and changes to the street network to facilitate travel by pedestrian, bicycle, and bus. Karl is overseeing the work of three transportation subconsultants and six other subcontractors, along with ESA’s in-house technical team. As part of the same contract, Karl is also serving as project director for a separate EIR on the Moscone Center Expansion project. 101 Hyde Street, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl is serving as project director for preparation of a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the proposed construction of a new residential/retail building on the site of an existing limited-service post office in San Francisco. The project sponsor proposes an eight-story, 80-foot-tall, building containing 85 dwelling units above ground-floor retail space and basement parking. The site is located at the edge of San Francisco’s Civic Center and Tenderloin neighborhoods, and immediately proximate to the Uptown Tenderloin Historic District, which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Alameda Point Project, Alameda, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior oversight and direction during ESA’s preparation of the EIR for the reuse of the former Naval Air Station-Alameda. After an unsuccessful attempt at partnering with a master developer, the City of Alameda elected to proceed as developer of the 880-acre site. The project involved amendments to the City’s General Plan and Zoning Ordinance and adoption of a precise plan to allow implementation of a reuse plan that will accommodate 5.5 million square feet of commercial, office, and manufacturing/warehouse space and more than 1,400 housing units. ESA completed the EIR on an aggressive schedule to meet the City’s requirements, with EIR certification and project adoption occurring one year from the start of ESA’s work. Transit Center District Plan and Tower, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for the Plan that governs the southern portion of the downtown Financial District, roughly bounded by Market Street, the Embarcadero, Folsom Street, and Third Street. The Plan area included both private properties and properties owned or to be acquired by the Transbay Joint Powers Authority (TJPA) in and around the adopted Transbay Redevelopment Project Area and Transbay Terminal. The EIR also evaluated at a project-specific level the Transit Tower, a 1,000-foot-tall office tower to be located adjacent to the new Transbay Transit Center, which began construction in 2010 and which will serve as a regional transit hub and potential future terminal for planned Caltrain Downtown Extension and California High-Speed Rail service. The Plan included new policies and controls for land use, urban form, and building design, as well as impact fees and other funding mechanisms to direct funding to the Transit Center and other public infrastructure, as well as a public realm plan to improve the pedestrian environment. Police Department Building, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed ESA’s portion of the preparation of a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the San Francisco Police Department Forensic Services Division and Traffic Company building in the City’s Bayview District. The project is a key component of the City’s Justice Facilities Improvement Program (JFIP), which seeks, over a period of 10 years or more, to relocate critical public safety functions from the seismically challenged Hall of Justice. Karl managed ESA’s work as a subconsultant to Weiss Associates, on an extremely tight schedule to allow completion of CEQA prior to a Board of Supervisors deadline for consideration of bond funding for the project and other JFIP components. Mission Bay EIR Addenda, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed and prepared major portions of two fast-track addenda to the 1998 Mission Bay Subsequent EIR for two separate projects in San Francisco’s Mission Bay Redevelopment Area. The first project obtained revised entitlements from the Commission on Community Investment and Infrastructure (successor to the Redevelopment Agency Commission) to develop a mixed-use hotel, residential, and retail project on a site formerly approved for a hotel alone. The second project obtained revised entitlements to construct a facility providing extended stay bedrooms and associated facilities to support families of patients receiving in-hospital medical treatment, primarily at the new University of California, San Francisco, Medical Center approaching completion nearby. New Mission Theater Renovation and Residential Development, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior management direction for ESA’s work on a major mixed-use project in San Francisco’s Mission District. The project proposed a new multi-family residential building with ground-floor retail space, along with renovation and reuse of a long- shuttered, historic movie theater next door. For the residential component, the project entailed demolition of a department store and construction of a new eight-story, 114-unit building with its primary entrance on the west, or Bartlett Street, facade. The residential building was constructed in 2014. Immediately to the north, the project proposed renovation of the historic New Mission Theater and re-occupancy of that structure as a new cinema. The project also involves streetscape improvements to enhance the pedestrian realm on Bartlett Street, due to begin implementation in conjunction with occupancy of the residential units. Home Depot Store, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl is serving as Project Director of ESA’s EIR for a proposed new Home Depot store in San Francisco’s Bayview District. The store would replace a disused and largely vacant former newspaper printing plant located near Cesar Chavez Street, a major artery in southeast San Francisco that links two nearby freeways, U.S. 101 and I-280. The project marks Home Depot’s third attempt to develop a store in San Francisco. Santa Rosa General Plan EIR, Santa Rosa, CA. QA/OC Oversight. Karl provided senior level technical oversight for the EIR which analyzed effects of a focused update to the General Plan 2020, including preparation of a new Housing Element and incorporation into the General Plan of recently adopted area plans, circulation plans, and strategic plans. ESA also prepared the original EIR for the City’s General Plan 2020, which addressed elements of natural and biological resources, land use policy, urban design, conservation of open space, scenic highways, fire hazards, air quality, noise, and energy conservation.

Landbank Central & Wolfe Campus, Sunnyvale, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior management direction and review for ESA’s preparation of an EIR for this 775,000-square-foot office campus in Sunnyvale. The project would replace nine single-story tilt-up R&D buildings with three connected, six-story, Class-A office buildings, along with a multi-level parking garage and a separate two-story amenities building for campus users. The project sponsor intends to achieve LEED® Platinum certification as a “Net-Zero ready” amenities building (i.e., designed to be ready for add-ons to achieve a net-zero energy system) , with features including a solar photovoltaic array on the parking garage roof, solar photovoltaic-ready roofs, light pollution reduction features, and use of reclaimed water. Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) Statewide On-Call CEQA Services. Project Director. Karl is overseeing a master service contract with the Administrative Office of the Courts-Judicial Branch of California to provide CEQA services on the construction of new courthouses throughout California. CEQA services include preparation of initial studies/mitigated negative declarations, environmental impact reports, and constraints analyses to assist the AOC with site selection. Typically the sites are undeveloped parcels of at least 5 acres in either urban or rural settings. The main issues and concerns at most of the sites analyzed have included biological resources, tree removals, cultural resources, and traffic. ESA prepared CEQA documents for courthouses in Sonoma (Santa Rosa), El Dorado (Placerville), Los Angeles (Santa Clarita), and Santa Barbara counties. R & L Terminals EIR, Oakland. Project Director. Karl directed an EIR for R+L Carriers to develop a 53,000 square foot transportation terminal with 63 dock doors on Pardee Drive in Oakland. The operation of the project would entail excepting long-haul regional orders and transferring them to smaller trucks for delivery. The project site is located at the terminus of Pardee Drive north of Swan drive, adjacent to the Martin Luther King Jr. Regional Shoreline. The Project site is currently used as an off-site parking lot of the Oakland International Airport. The main issues of concern were potential lighting and noise disturbances to nearby wildlife, subsurface contaminations, as well as increased truck traffic on local roadways. Western SoMa Plan EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior level direction for the EIR for this area plan developed by a task force of residents and business persons. The Plan, approved in 2013, evolved from the earlier Eastern Neighborhoods Rezoning effort, and the community-driven process resulted in a plan to protect existing residential enclaves and districts, while attempting to channel commercial and office growth to the southern portion of the Plan area, closer to the Caltrain tracks along Townsend Street. Eastern Neighborhoods Rezoning, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl coordinated preparation of the EIR for the proposed rezoning of four of San Francisco's Eastern Neighborhoods. The project was intended to permit housing development in some areas currently zoned for industrial use while preserving an adequate supply of land for non-residential, non-retail, and non-office businesses. Karl managed the work of eight subcontractors to assist in the implementation of improvements to the streetscape, transportation system, open space, and ultimately new urban design policies which would result from the new plans. The rezoning and neighborhood plans were approved in 2008, and ESA’s EIR paved the way for numerous Community Plan Exemptions to be prepared for Plan-compliant projects within the Eastern Neighborhoods. Sunnydale-HOPE Redevelopment Master Plan IS and Focused EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl is providing senior level QA/QC and oversight for a joint CEQA and NEPA EIR/EIS and a supporting Archaeological Research Design and Treatment Plan (ARDTP) for the 50- acre Sunnydale-HOPE Redevelopment Plan Project. The project sponsor, Sunnydale Development Co., LLC (comprised of co-developers Mercy Housing California and The Related Companies of California), proposes to demolish 785 family and senior dwelling units at the Sunnydale and Velasco public housing complexes in the Visitacion Valley neighborhood of San Francisco. The project would build 1,700 units of replacement and new housing, new and reconfigured street network, 11.4 acres of new parks and open space and 16,200 square feet of neighborhood retail. Key environmental issues to be analyzed include temporary effects to residents during the phased construction period, aesthetics, air quality, noise, and traffic and circulation. [DO NOT USE EL CAMINO REAL/MENLO PARK PROJECT] El Camino Real/Menlo Park Downtown Specific Plan EIR, Menlo Park, CA Project Director. Karl oversaw the preparation of the EIR for this Plan, which seeks to enhance the area around the Menlo Park Caltrain station and the nearby stretch of El Camino Real. The Specific Plan aims to build upon existing investment by the City and other stakeholders, focusing on improvements in both the private and public realms, with an eye towards enhancing transit use and improving the character and vitality of the City's major commercial corridor and downtown. ESA documented existing conditions in the Plan area to provide the other team members baseline data, and evaluated environmental impacts along with other team members to ensure that environmental effects were considered as the Plan was refined. The Plan was adopted by the City Council in 2012. North Beach Library, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior QA/QC review and direction for ESA’s preparation of a focused EIR on the construction of a new branch library in the City’s North Beach neighborhood. He also managed a subconsultant-prepared Historic Resources Evaluation, which analyzed the existing branch library building, which is proposed for demolition once the new library is open in Spring 2014. The project attracted extensive interest from stakeholder in North Beach and beyond, generating voluminous comments from both project proponents and opponents. ESA’s EIR was upheld by the Board of Supervisors, on appeal from the Planning Commission, and withstood a San Francisco Superior Court challenge. The Columbarium Mitigated Negative Declaration, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior review and direction for an MND prepared to analyze expansion of the San Francisco Columbarium, the only remaining (human) cemetery in San Francisco. The historic building and grounds, once part of the Odd Fellows Cemetery on Laurel Hill, was approved for expansion by construction of two new buildings to contain approximately 5,400 new niches for the keeping of cremation ashes. 1050 Valencia Street Mitigated Negative Declaration, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior review and direction for an MND prepared to analyze demolition of an existing restaurant and construction of a new five-story residential/retail/restaurant building. The new building was approved to contain 12 dwelling units and 2,000 square feet of restaurant space. The MND is required because of a former gas station on the site. In

addition to his management role, Karl evaluated potential effects of the project on the nearby Liberty-Hill Historic District. ESA’s MND withstood an appeal to the Board of Supervisors from neighbors concerned about building height, noise, and parking. Rincon Hill Plan EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed this EIR that analyzed increased residential density in the Rincon Hill area near the base of the Bay Bridge. His study included extensive analysis of the visual and urban design aspects of options for varying numbers of residential towers and associated improvements to the streetscape and pedestrian environment within the project locale. Rincon Hill High-Rise Residential Towers EIRs, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared follow-on CEQA analysis for three separate high-rise towers proposed in the Rincon Hill area of San Francisco. His analyses tiered from the Rincon Hill Plan EIR, with each project involving the construction of a 400-foot tower with 300 to 350 dwelling units and underground parking. Historic Wharf J-10, Port of San Francisco, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the focused EIR to demolish historic Wharf J-10 in the Fisherman’s Wharf area. The wharf and former fish-processing building that sits atop it were vacated by the Port in 2000 when severe structural damage was noted. The Board of Supervisors subsequently voided a CEQA exemption and preparation of a full EIR was mandated. 900 Minnesota Street, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for a project involving the adaptive residential reuse of an industrial building, formerly the Esprit Clothing Company. The proposal, in San Francisco’s Central Waterfront area included retention of one historic 19th century building and the demolition of several newer structures to allow for the development of 150 dwelling units in total. Southern Waterfront Supplemental EIR (SEIR), Port of San Francisco, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl coordinated efforts of ESA air quality specialists and five subcontractors in analyzing effects related to relocation of several construction aggregate industry users from Mission Bay Redevelopment Area to Port property. The SEIR evaluated the effect of a rail- truck bridge proposed by the Port to link the Port’s two major cargo facilities at Piers 80 and 94-96, with focus on air quality impacts of the proposed operation. On-Call Environmental Services, San Francisco Department of Public Works, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed three consecutive two-year contracts for environmental planning and noise monitoring consultation services for DPW. His role as manager includes supervision of subcontractor services; projects undertaken for this contract included the EIR for the new North Beach Library and demolition of Wharf J- 10 for the Port of S.F. Asian Art Museum SEIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Principal Author. Karl coordinated preparation of an extensive evaluation of effects relating to the proposed move of the museum to the old library building, a contributory structure within both a National and Local Historic Landmark District. He relied on several Historic Structure Reports prepared by separate preservation architects, and material obtained from the San Francisco Art Commission and members of the preservation community. The controversial project was later approved by the City. Courts Building EIR and Main Library EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Deputy Project Manager. Karl coordinated and edited work of ESA staff and subcontractors for both major Civic Center projects. After completion of the Main Library project, the city kept ESA on a sole-source basis for an EIR for the new courts building, which was to be built across the street from its previous location at City Hall. Karl analyzed key topics of architecture, urban design, alternatives for both projects, and coordinated efforts regarding transportation studies and circulation issues associated with development. 475 Brannan Street EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the focused EIR used for the remodeling and expansion plan of an architecturally significant building in the South of Market Plan area. His analysis focused on whether the addition of two floors to an existing two- story building would adversely affect its historic character. 246-250 Front Street EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared the EIR to analyze effects on a downtown conservation district, associated with the demolition of two architecturally “contributory” buildings. He analyzed effects stemming from the demolition process on architectural resources. State of California San Francisco Civic Center Complex (“State Office Building”) Final EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared the response to comments for a controversial high-rise state office building in the Civic Center. His responses addressed design factors related to the overall visual sensitivity of the Civic Center area included in the original EIR. Of chief concern were issues relating to land use compatibility and policy conformity of the State building, which opened to the public in 1998. California Culinary Academy, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl acted as project manager and author of an EIR addendum, prepared for the conversion of educational use portions of a newly constructed but largely unoccupied office building in San Francisco’s Potrero Hill neighborhood. The building now houses the second campus of the California Culinary Academy. 150 California Street EIR Addendum, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared an addendum to the original EIR done by ESA in 1989 for this office building, which was completed in 2000. His addendum focused on potential shadow and wind effects of the completed structure, as its design varied with the changes to the landscape of the region. The original project had shadow impacts on protected open space and was revised to verify that the new design would not cause shadow impacts. 535 Mission Street MND and Addendum, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared a MND and a later Addendum for a 27-story, 300,000-square-foot office tower near the site of San Francisco’s Transbay Transit Center. The project was proposed at the location where ESA had previously completed an EIR and a SEIR for two different office towers; the MND evaluated a proposed residential tower on the same site, and the 2007 Addendum relied on analysis in both the SEIR and the MND. Following an aborted start to construction during the Great Recession of 2008, the office tower was completed in 2014. Western Addition Area A-2 Redevelopment Plan Extension, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the MND for amendment of the Western Addition A-2 Redevelopment Area. The MND was required to permit construction of two senior housing developments on parcels once

occupied by the now-demolished Central Freeway, as well as construction of the mixed-use Fillmore Heritage project (completed 2007) at the heart of a planned Jazz District. Karl helped conduct an extensive analysis of potential shading of two parks in close proximity to the planned sites. Alabama Street Family Housing Project, San Francisco, CA. Project Director. Karl assisted in the creation of a MND for a 150-unit affordable housing residential project. He managed the MND for the planned housing development to be completed by the non-profit, Citizens Housing Corporation in San Francisco’s northeast Mission District. 833 Jamestown Avenue, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl was Project Manager of the MND for a 200-unit condominium project in San Francisco’s Bayview District, near Candlestick Park. He addressed concerns regarding stability of the hillside behind the project site were a primary topic of analysis, along with public services, views, and traffic and pedestrian safety. The completed MND explored issues of concern at a near-EIR level of detail. One South Park, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl acted as project manager for the MND for conversion of a former manufacturing and warehouse building to residential use on San Francisco’s South Park. 3995 Alemany Blvd, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed and authored the MND for this mixed-use residential and retail project in southwestern San Francisco, near the Daly City, city limit. The project renovated an aging shopping center and added 400 apartment units atop the retail buildings on a site within walking distance of the Daly City BART station. 280 Divisadero Street, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Principal Author. Karl authored the focused EIR on a proposal to renovate a carriage house behind an existing City Landmark home in San Francisco’s Lower Haight neighborhood. His analysis considered compatibility issues with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards, as well as differences between the standards and CEQA significance thresholds. Harrison Street Mixed-Use Development, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl is the manager of this project, overseeing development of 660 residential units and 55,000-square-feet of retail space. The site is currently in low-intensity light industrial use on Harrison Street between 3rd and 4th Streets in San Francisco, adjacent to the I-80 freeway. Rezoning of Eastern San Francisco Neighborhoods, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl coordinated preparation of the EIR for the proposed rezoning of four of San Francisco's Eastern Neighborhoods. The project was intended to permit housing development in some areas currently zoned for industrial use while preserving an adequate supply of land for non- residential, non-retail, and non-office businesses. Karl managed the work of eight subcontractors to assist in the implementation of improvements to the streetscape, transportation system, open space, and ultimately new urban design policies which would result from the new plans. The rezoning and neighborhood plans were approved in 2008. 222 Second Street EIR, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the preparation of an EIR for a 25-story office building at the southwestern edge of San Francisco’s Transbay Terminal area. The new building, which broke ground in 2013, is being developed at the site where a prior office proposal was approved in the late 1980s but never built. Karl managed ESA’s in-house analyses of transportation, shadow and wind impacts, and analysis of land use consistency and policy conformance, along with a sub-consultant’s evaluation of effects on archeological resources and the project architect’s preparation of photomontages for use in ESA’s visual quality analysis. 3400 Cesar Chavez Street (555 Bartlett Street) Mixed-Use Project, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the preparation of an Initial Study and MND for a proposed residential-retail development on the important corner of Mission and Cesar Chavez Streets in San Francisco's Mission District. The project replaced a former retail paint store, with a four- story building 60-unit residential building with ground floor retail space that contains a Walgreens pharmacy and three smaller retail stores. [DO NOT USE 255 SEVENTH STREET PROJECT] 255 Seventh Street (Westbrook Plaza), San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for demolition of potentially historic buildings to allow for construction of 49-units of affordable housing and a new location for the South of Market Health Center. The EIR also evaluated project effects on the remaining industrial land supply in San Francisco, drawing upon ESA’s contemporaneous Eastern Neighborhoods EIR. [DO NOT USE PALACE HOTEL TOWER PROJECT] Palace Hotel Tower, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. As project manager, Karl is overseeing all aspects of the EIR for proposed construction of a 60-story tower addition to the city landmark Palace Hotel, located at the corner of Market and New Montgomery Streets. The project would entail demolition of the Hotel's non-historic Southwest corner, which was constructed as part of a 1988-1991 renovation of the hotel. Other San Francisco Experience Karl analyzed the land use impacts for a proposed underground high-voltage power line to connect two existing power plants in San Francisco’s Central Waterfront and Bayview districts. Oakland Project Management Broadway/West Grand EIR, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed an EIR on Signature Properties’ 475-unit residential-plus-retail development at Broadway and West Grand Avenue in Oakland. The project resulted in the demolition of several buildings identified as historical resources under CEQA, while the EIR studied various preservation alternatives. Marks Building Project (380-388 12th Street), Oakland, CA. Project Manager and Principal Author. As manager and author of this focused EIR, Karl outlined potential issues associated with the removal of a small historic commercial building to be replaced with a larger residential one. The goal of this project was to show the steps necessary to retain the original structure’s façade to be used on the new building. The plan was ultimately approved for construction, but was not implemented due to structural issues found in the demolition process. Oakland General Plan Update EIR and Estuary Plan EIR, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for the new Land Use and Circulation Element of the General Plan and oversaw the work of three consultants on citywide analyses of effects on land use, transportation, air quality, noise, and public services. The EIR examined the impacts associated with development opportunities in the downtown and Coliseum areas of

Oakland. Karl subsequently managed a separate EIR for the Estuary Policy Plan, part of the general plan which sets policy guidelines for the City’s waterfront area. California College of the Arts (CCA) Student Housing Negative Declaration, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl prepared of a Negative Declaration relating to construction of a student dormitory adjacent to the main campus of the CCA in Oakland's Rockridge district. The college sought to fill a need for affordable student housing by redeveloping an existing surface parking lot. Karl addressed concerns expressed by neighbors near the construction zone regarding traffic, parking, and potential view loss due to construction. University of California - Office of the President (UCOP) EIR, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the preparation of an EIR for the development of a 12-story office building in downtown Oakland, located adjacent to the Downtown Oakland Historic District and the Key System Building listed on the National Register of Historic Places. He coordinated the work of five subcontractors on fast-track along with in-house transportation staff to analyze impacts on parking and transit. Karl successfully met the project's construction schedule, by completing the transportation study and EIR, including responses to comments, all in less than eight months. Oakland City Administration Building EIR/EIS, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the production of an EIR/EIS for replacement of earthquake-damaged City offices. Included in the reports were analyses of land use planning and the effects on architectural resources and urban design in the Downtown Historic District. Additionally, Karl coordinated the efforts of six additional subcontractors for varied work assignments. Oakland Coliseum Arena EIR, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the preparation of two EIRs for major projects at the Oakland- Alameda County Coliseum, which included expansion of the coliseum and replacement of the 15,000 seat arena with a 20,000-seat arena, primarily to accommodate increased Golden State Warriors basketball attendance. Karl coordinated subcontractor’s traffic analysis and ESA’s in-house team in preparation of the EIR for the expanded arena and prepared an alternatives analysis. Oakland City Center Project EIR. 555 City Center, Oakland, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for the first commercial office building constructed in the City Center project area since 1990. The project totaled 2.2-million-square-feet incorporating 200 residential units, ground floor retail space, and 800 subsurface parking spaces. Karl’s team provided complete analyses of traffic impacts, shadow, city view, and ground level wind issues associated with construction. Karl subsequently managed preparation of two addenda for a second site in the City Center to change from the original EIR’s proposed office space to residential, and back again to office use. Other Project Management Alameda Boatworks Residential Project, Alameda, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior-level review and direction to ESA staff who prepared a focused EIR for a 240-unit residential project along the Alameda waterfront of the Oakland Estuary, near the Park Street Bridge. The site is a former shipyard that has undergone remediation to the satisfaction of the state Department of Toxics Substances Control. Besides documenting the completed remediation, the EIR evaluated potential impacts to historic resources on the project site, including large-scale industrial manufacturing plants and sheds built in 1910-1930, traffic impacts on local streets and regional routes, as well as noise and air quality impacts that would result from project traffic. Bayview Residential Project, Contra Costa County, CA. Project Director. Karl provided senior-level review and direction for preparation of focused EIR for a residential development in the Vine Hill/Pacheco Boulevard area of unincorporated Contra Costa County, near Martinez. The project would develop 163 single-family homes and associated internal roadways on 42 acres and create two open space parcels of approximately 12 and 15 acres. Technical analyses for the EIR are related to the project’s proposed extensive grading plan that would substantially alter the existing topography of the project site, new land use designation that would require an amendment to the General Plan, and the project’s proximity to various heavy industrial uses, including two refineries, as well as the required extension and upgrade of utility lines. San Pablo General Plan EIR, San Pablo, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed ESA’s preparation of prepared several technical sections for the environmental impact report on the San Pablo General Plan update, completed in 2010. Working under contract to Dyett & Bhatia, ESA prepared the analyses of Air Quality, Biological Resources, Hydrology, and Hazards/Hazardous Materials. The Air Quality section was one of the first general plan EIR analyses to be completed subsequent to the June 2010 adoption of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District's revised CEQA Guidelines, and therefore incorporated newly required analyses of toxic air contaminants from local and regional sources. This work follows ESA's participation in the City's prior General Plan update in 1995 Fruitvale Transit Village Initial Study/EA, Oakland, CA. Deputy Project Manager. The project, sponsored by the nonprofit Unity Council and funded by a variety of local, state, and federal agencies, is a unique combination of residential and commercial uses, a branch library, childcare facility, senior center, social service agencies, and a community-based health clinic, all designed to be easily accessible by public transportation. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory’s Long-Range Development Plan (LRDP) EIR. Berkeley, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the EIR for the LRDP, a requirement of the Lab’s management by the University of California. Highlighting health issues associated with development over a 20-year planning horizon at the lab site in the Oakland-Berkeley hills was a main focus of the EIR. Attention also focused on analysis of the endangered Alameda Whipsnake and its local habitat, and changes in view of the lab from nearby areas. Montclair Lucky Supermarket, San Leandro, CA. Project Manager. Karl provided key components of CEQA documentation for the demolition and rebuild of an existing Lucky’s Supermarket to be expanded on the existing lot. The Northern California Division of Lucky’s Supermarket opted to move the footprint of an existing store on the same lot to allow for expansion of up to an extra 11,000-square-feet and to address seismicity issues relating to the Supermarkets’ original location, directly over the San Andreas Fault. Hercules General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements Update EIR, Hercules, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the project which would allow for construction of five million-square-feet of commercial development and 2,570 residential units over a 15-year period. He coordinated the completion of an EIR that outlined issues including traffic, school and park impacts, and

wetlands. The updates focused on the less-developed western portion of the City, where planners and a citizens panel identified the potential for expansion of the City's commercial base. Palo Alto Medical Foundation (PAMF) EIR, Palo Alto, CA. Deputy Project Manager. Karl coordinated the efforts of eight subcontractors in analysis of the PAMF relocation to a highly constrained site adjacent to El Camino Real and CalTrain tracks. The project proposed medical clinics and offices, conference and education space, research facilities totaling 315,000-square- feet, and about 1,000 parking spaces. Key issues were access to the site from El Camino Real and downtown Palo Alto, transit connections, pedestrian and bicycle circulation, and parking. City of Salinas Mountain Valley EIR, Salinas, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed the preparation of an EIR for a proposed 850-unit residential project on 200-acres to be annexed by the City of Salinas. Hausrath Economics Group, under subcontract to ESA, prepared a Services and Facilities Financing Plan to meet the requirements of the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission. Other issues of concern included traffic, water use, groundwater overdraft, and loss of agricultural land. Regency Mobile Home Estates EIR, Pittsburg, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed an EIR required for the development of a mobile home park located near heavily used railroad lines. The project rezoned the project site from its current industrial use status to that of residential use. Noise was of chief concern during the EIR process along with, flood hazards, traffic, and hazardous materials from land uses surrounding this former industrial site. Franklin Canyon Golf Course Annexation SEIR, Hercules, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed analysis of this project, which proposed construction of 875 residential units, a hotel, and upgrade of an existing golf course all located on 633-acres annexable land. A special feature of the SEIR was a health risk assessment of the potentially toxic air emissions from the nearby Coke-processing plant. Karl also oversaw analysis of other key issues including transportation, vegetation and wildlife, and the provision of public services including schools. Affordable Housing Development, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager. Karl managed and authored the CEQA MND and a separate NEPA Environmental Assessment for Habitat for a Humanity. The project developed 12 affordable single-family homes in San Francisco on former BART property. Key issues included in the analyses were noise related issues associated with the planned site and its proximity to the BART tracks and I-280 freeway.

EDUCATION Heidi is a Registered Professional Archaeologist specializing in California archaeology. She has prepared numerous cultural resources studies in M.A., Cultural Resources compliance with the California Enviornmental Quality Act and Section 106 of Management, Sonoma the National Historic Preservation Act, including surface surveys, subsurface State University surveys, site significance evaluation, mitigation recommendations, and B.A., Anthropology, consultation with the State Historic Preservation Officer. Heidi has developed San Francisco State several interactive GIS databases to assist regulatory agencies with cultural University resources management and preservation decisions. Heidi has conducted 17 YEARS numerous records searches at the California Historical Resources EXPERIENCE Information System and has assisted with consultation efforts with several CERTIFICATIONS/ Native American tribes. REGISTRATION Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), 15140 San Francisco Planning Department As-Needed Archaeology Hazardous Waste Consulting Services. Archaeologist. ESA has been selected to provide as- Operations and needed archaeological resources consultant services to the San Francisco Emergency Response Planning Department. The Department has included ESA for archaeological 40 hour course resources analysis available to both public and private clients. completion and active renewal 34th America's Cup EIR/EA and Permitting. Archaeologist. Heidi provided PROFESSIONAL archaeological services for America’s Cup 34, hosted by San Francisco in AFFILIATIONS 2012 and 2013. A comprehensive records search was completed to Society for California determine if any archaeological or other cultural resources were located Archaeology within the established Area of Potential Effects for the event, including areas that will be used for primary event facilities as well as spectator areas around Society for Historical Archaeology the margins of the Bay. Numerous cultural resources were reported including many significant military-related features. A Conditions Assessment Report was completed for all cultural properties within the jurisdiction of the National Park Service. The conditions assessment included a review of existing conditions and provisions for the protection of sensitive resources including fencing and monitoring plans during the event. Western SoMa Community Plan, Rezoning of Adjacent Parcels and 350 Eighth Street Project, San Francisco. Archaeologist. Based on a summary of technical report prepared by William Self Associates, Heidi prepared the prehistoric and historic-era archaeology section of the Environmental Impact Report that addresses environmental impacts of the Western SoMa Community Plan, Rezoning of Adjacent Parcels and the 350 Eighth Street project. The Western SoMa Community Plan Cultural Resources section included an extensive overview of the area history and archaeological sensitivity.

250 4th Street Archaeological Services, San Francisco. Archaeologist. As a subconsultant to Far Western, ESA assisted in revising a draft Archaeological Research Design and Testing Plan (ARDTP) by expanding the scope to include historic-era archaeology. Heidi prepared the sensitivity assessment adding historic-era sections in the background and context, research design, treatment plan, and a testing plan sections of the ARDTP.

SFPUC San Joaquin Communications System Upgrade Project, Central Valley. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for the San Joaquin Communications System Upgrade Project. The project consists of installation of microwave radio antennas on either new or existing radio towers at 20 project locations. Tasks for the report included a records search for 21 locations spanning the Central Valley, surface survey of the 21 project locations, and a comprehensive summary of the investigations. SFPUC Bay Division Pipeline No. 3 and 4, Hayward, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for the replacement of the Bay Division Pipeline over the Hayward Fault. A previously documented prehistoric archaeological resource is located within the project boundaries. Heidi assisted with consultation efforts between the Army Corps of Engineers, the San Francisco Planning Department, and the State Historic Preservation Officer to strategize the approach that will be used to resolve adverse effects to this National Register of Historic Places-eligible site. A Historic Properties Treatment Plan and Memorandum of Agreement were developed and approved by the State Historic Preservation Officer. SFPUC, Westside Recycled Water Project, San Francisco. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for the San Francisco Westside Recycled Water Project. The project, a component of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission’s Water System Improvement Program (WSIP), includes construction of several facilities and installation of approximately six miles of pipeline on the Westside of the City of San Francisco. The archaeological report complies with the WSIP Archaeological Guidance documents. Completed components include delineation of the archaeological CEQA Area of Potential Effects, a records search at the Northwest Information Center, and the Archaeological Survey Plan documents. SFPUC, Groundwater Project, San Francisco. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for the San Francisco Groundwater Project. The project includes construction of several facilities and installation of approximately six miles of pipeline on the Westside of the City of San Francisco. The archaeological report complies with the WSIP Archaeological Guidance documents. Completed components include delineation of the archaeological CEQA Area of Potential Effects and the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report. SFPUC Crystal Springs Pipeline No. 2 Replacement Project, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for this five-mile pipeline replacement project in San Mateo and San Francisco counties. The on-foot survey was completed in 2006; Heidi has updated the records search and applied the WSIP Archaeological Guidance to comply with the current SFPUC standards. SFPUC Pulgas Environmental Analysis Services, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. ESA prepared an Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration for the Pulgas Discharge Channel Modifications project. The project is needed to correct operational deficiencies of the channel and repair the sub- drain pipe beneath the channel, thus ensuring its structural integrity and water delivery reliability. Heidi completed an extended subsurface archaeological survey to supplement previous archaeological research conducted at the project location. SFPUC Pulgas Dechloramination Facilities Modification, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the Historic Context and Archaeological Survey Report for the facilities upgrade at the Pulgas Dechloramination Facilities at Crystal Springs Reservoir in San Mateo County. The project included a records search at the Northwest Information Center, contact with Native American representatives, an on-foot survey of the project area, and a report disseminating the results of the research.

City of Alameda, Encinal Terminals EIR, Alameda County, CA. Cultural Resources Analyst. ESA is preparing an Initial Study and Focused Environmental Impact Report for redevelopment of an abandoned 32-acre wharf and shipping terminal site on the Oakland Estuary. When completed, the project will provide a mixed-use development to include approximately 600 new housing units, a marina with up to 160 boat slips and a harbormaster’s office, between 30,000 and 50,000 square feet of commercial/office and restaurant uses, and over three acres of waterfront- related public open space and parks. Issues of concern for the project include traffic, aesthetics, and land use. Concord Hills Regional Park Land Use Plan, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi reviewed the existing technical studies and surveys prepared for the proposed Concord Hills Regional Park property provided by East Bay Regional Park District, to support the development of an Existing Conditions Report. Heidi prepared a technical memorandum describing the studies reviewed; the past and present site conditions as they pertain to cultural resources, to complete Land Use Plan development and completion of the CEQA analysis. Heidi completed a CHRIS records search to determine whether site conditions have changed since completion of the most recent cultural resource studies. EBMUD Cultural Resources Data and Training, Alameda and Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. ESA’s Cultural Resources Group is working with East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) to provide comprehensive information regarding known cultural resources, specifically archaeological resources, within the EBMUD service area. Tasks have included conducting a records search at the Northwest Information Center of the California Historical Resources Information System. The results of the records search were incorporated into a Geographic Information System database and described in a table that includes site types and attributes. ESA also recommended policies to ensure that cultural resources data remains confidential within agency jurisdiction. ESA will also be conducting an in- house cultural resources awareness training lead by a Secretary of the Interior-qualified archaeologist. The training will consist of a presentation describing the types of cultural resources that could be encountered during

ground disturbing activities and a strategy outlining the procedures to follow in the event that cultural resources are identified. ESA has provided draft training materials in a presentation format (PowerPoint) that EBMUD can use for future training.

EBMUD Cultural Resources Support – McArthur / Davenport Pipeline Replacement Project and South Reservoir Replacement Project. Archaeologist. ESA is providing cultural resources studies for two EBMUD projects to support State Revolving Fund loan applications from the State Water Resources Control Board. To comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, ESA is completing a cultural resources studies that include development of an Area of Potential Effects, a records search using the recently completed database search from the Northwest Information Center, initial coordination with the Native American Heritage Commission, a geoarchaeological review of the potential for buried sites, an intensive pedestrian surface survey, and cultural resources survey reports documenting the methods and findings.

LAVWMA Pipeline Connection Project, San Leandro, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the archaeological study for the Livermore- Amador Valley Water Management Agency (LAVWMA) 1,200-foot pipeline connection project at Roberts Landing. The project extends through a previously recorded cultural resource that includes former Roberts Landing, the Trojan Powder Works remains, the ‘Caretaker’s Residence’ remains, and the Bluebird Dump. The site was previously determined not eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places. This previous evaluation was reconfirmed during a supplemental survey and recommendations. Kaiser Center Development Project, Oakland, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi conducted a site sensitivity study for the Kaiser Center Development Project in downtown Oakland near Lake Merritt. The records search and a review of historic documents and maps indicated that the project area was once the location of a convent and boarding school. The Convent of Our Lady of the Sacred Heart was established in 1868 and remained at the location until 1957. It was determined that archaeological deposits and features associated with the school could exist beneath the current building and be exposed during ground-disturbing activity. Recommendations included the development of a research design and testing program that would appropriately mitigate any adverse impacts to significant cultural resources. North Richmond Specific Plan, Richmond, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the archaeological component of the cultural resources section for the North Richmond Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors authorized a General Plan Amendment study to re-designate 57 acres of land now designated for industrial use to a mix of residential, commercial, open space, and public uses in support of a master-planned residential development. Heidi conducted a records search and reconnaissance field survey for archaeological sites. San Leandro Fiber Optic Cable Addendum and Monitoring, San Leandro, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed a cultural resources study for the San Leandro Fiber Optic Cable Project and provided Section 106 consultation support to the City for funding through the Economic Development Department. Heidi conducted a records search at the Northwest Information Center and a survey to determine whether archaeological sites extend into the project Area of Potential Effects. Heidi worked with the State Historic Preservation Officer to conclude a finding of No Historic Properties. The SHPO recommended additional monitoring in archaeologically sensitive areas; Heidi managed a group of archaeological technicians to conduct monitoring over a period of several months. Zone 7 Bank Repair Projects, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi conducted the cultural resources study for the Alameda County Flood Control and Water Conservation District (Zone 7 Water Agency) bank repair projects. The projects consist of work locations along engineered and natural water courses in the cities of Dublin, Pleasanton, and Livermore. Heidi completed a records search at the Northwest Information Center and a survey to determine whether archaeological sites extend into the project locations. Heidi also worked with the Nototomne Cultural Preservation Northern Valley Yokut/Ohlone/Bay Miwuk to assess affects and develop mitigation strategies. Alameda Marina Project, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed an archaeological resources study for the Alameda Marin Project, which proposed to redevelop the 44-acre Alameda Marina property. Heidi completed a records search at the Northwest Information Center and identified a prehistoric archaeological site with human remains in the project area. Heidi recommended a Significant and Unavoidable finding in the CEQA document and the development of an Archaeological Research Design and Treatment Plan to resolve potential adverse effects to the significant resource. BART to Livermore Project, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the cultural resources section of the CEQA document for the BART to Livermore Project, which would extend the BART tracks from Dublin to Isabel Avenue in western Livermore. Heidi completed background research, a geological analysis, and a surface survey for the project.

EBMUD Cultural Resources Data and Training, Alameda and Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. ESA’s Cultural Resources Group is working with East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) to provide comprehensive information regarding known cultural resources, specifically archaeological resources, within the EBMUD service area. Tasks have included conducting a records search at the Northwest Information Center of the California Historical Resources Information System. The results of the records search were incorporated into a Geographic Information System database and described in a table that includes site types and attributes. ESA also recommended policies to ensure that cultural resources data remains confidential within agency jurisdiction. ESA will also be conducting an in- house cultural resources awareness training lead by a Secretary of the Interior-qualified archaeologist. The training will consist of a presentation describing the types of cultural resources that could be encountered during ground disturbing activities and a strategy outlining the procedures to follow in the event that cultural resources are identified. ESA has provided draft training materials in a presentation format (PowerPoint) that EBMUD can use for future training. EBMUD West of Hills Project, Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Cultural Resources Survey Report and EIR section for pipeline replacement/improvement of approximately 10 miles of the Wildcat Aqueduct and Central Pressure Zone Pipelines, in Richmond, San Pablo, El Cerrito, and Berkeley. The project was completed to comply with both Section 106 of

the National Historic Preservation Act and the California Environmental Quality Act. Heidi completed background research, contacted Native Americans, and conducted a surface survey in the project Area of Potential Effects. Heidi worked with EBMUD staff to identify appropriate and timely recommendations for additional subsurface study to be completed following EIR approval. Montalvin Manor, Richmond, Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Archaeological Survey Report and Historic Properties Survey Report for a local assistance project sponsored by the Caltrans District 4. The project, proposed by Contra Costa County Department of Public Works, includes transportation improvements intended to upgrade pedestrian circulation along San Pablo Avenue in northern Contra Costa County. The project included background research and an intensive survey. Vasco Wind Energy Project, Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the cultural analysis for the Vasco Wind Energy Project. The project would decommission approximately 435 existing and aging turbines and replace them with up to 54 larger wind-generating turbines. The cultural section included a summary of the records search and archaeological survey of the project area. Tres Vaqueros Wind Energy Project, Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Archaeological Survey Report for the Tres Vaqueros Wind Energy Project, which includes replacing existing turbines and civil/electrical infrastructure with new wind turbines. The archaeological study included a records search at the Northwest Information Center and an archaeological survey of the project area. Additional efforts included an extended subsurface archaeological investigation, site recordation, and additional protective measures for potentially impacted archaeological sites. Richmond Advanced Recycled Water Expansion Project, Richmond, Contra Costa County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the CEQA-plus cultural resources section to comply with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. Previous research indicated that no cultural resources would be affected by the proposed project. Heidi updated the records search and incorporated an analysis for buried site potential using historical maps and geological data. Richmond Shoreline Specific Plan, Richmond, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the cultural resources section of the Environmental Impact Report for the Richmond Shoreline Specific Plan. The Specific Plan area includes one of the largest archaeological sites in the San Francisco Bay Area – the National Register of Historic Places listed Stege Mound Archaeological District. Heidi recommended that due sensitivity for archaeological sites, the high potential for buried sites that would not be visible due to development, and the lack of specific ground-disturbing impact proposals warrant comprehensive archaeological study and survey for individual projects once development plans have been outlined in order to determine the presence or absence of archaeological resources, related with proposed impacts of site-specific development. West County Wastewater District State Revolving Fund Application Projects, Alameda County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the cultural resources analysis for the West County Wastewater District Master Plan and resulting projects for the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) application process. SWRCB is required to comply with Section 106 and concur with the State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO). Heidi created an interactive GIS-based database that provides cultural resources site location information within the District operation area so specific projects could be compared and effects determined. Heidi has provided SHPO documentation for SWRCB to use in their consultation efforts on two separate applications with additional applications forthcoming.

San Antonio Wetlands Mitigation and Conservation Bank Cultural Resources Study, Marin County. Project Manager/Archaeologist. Heidi completed a Phase I cultural resources study for the San Antonio Road Wetland Mitigation and Species Conservation Bank Project in Marin County. The study included a literature and records search, contact with Native Americans, and a field survey. Archaeological survey identified nine cultural resources—three prehistoric sites, one prehistoric isolate, and five historic- period resources—within or immediately adjacent to the Area of Potential Effects (APE). Three of the sites are considered legally significant. The sites are part of the San Antonio Creek Archaeological District and have been recommended eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. ESA has recommended avoidance of significant archaeological sites and consultation with the State Historic Preservation Officer, the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in determining whether the project would have an adverse effect on prehistoric properties and if so, what actions would be necessary to resolve or reduce those effects. Marin Countywide Bicycle Parking Pilot Program Cultural Resources Studies, Marin County. Project Manager/Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the Historic Properties Survey Report and Archaeological Survey Report for this local assistance project sponsored by Caltrans District 4. The project included the installation of eight bicycle racks in various locations throughout Marin County. The cultural resources study included background research and an intensive survey. The ASR concluded with a finding of no historic properties affected. Lagunitas Creek Watershed and Devil’s Gulch Cultural Resources Studies, Marin County. Archaeologist. Heidi conducted a cultural resources study for Marin Municipal Water District’s Devil’s Gulch and Lagunitas Creek Restoration Projects. The Devil’s Gulch study included a records search, field survey, site recordation, site evaluation, Native American contact, and successful consultation with the State Historic Preservation Officer on behalf of MMWD and the National Park Service. The Lagunitas Watershed project included similar tasks as well as additional coordination with the California Department of Parks and Recreation. Marin County Emergency Operation Facility, San Rafael. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the archaeological resources study for the Emergency Operation Facility. Three archaeological sites are located in the vicinity. Heidi recommended consultation with the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria, the culturally affiliated federally recognized Native American tribe in Marin County, and additional subsurface investigation when the final site location is chosen. Mt. Tamalpais State Park East Peak Facilities Management Plan, Marin County. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the cultural resources assessment for this State Park management plan. The purpose of the study was to identify previously recorded cultural resources, including prehistoric and historic- period archaeological resources, buildings, structures, and places of importance to Native Americans located within the plan area and to outline

procedures for future identification efforts prior to implementation of the plan. Heidi recommended additional work in regards to historic-era cultural resources related to the historic railroad and tavern on the summit. Heidi also recommended continued Native American involvement during the planning process. San Anselmo Flood Protection Project, San Anselmo and Fairfax, Marin County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed a surface and subsurface archaeological study for the San Anselmo Flood Protection Project. The project consists of the removal of two buildings over San Anselmo Creek and the creation of a flood diversion and storage (FDS) basin in Fairfax. Heidi completed a records search at the Northwest Information Center and a surface survey. Due to the heightened archaeological sensitivity of the FDS project area, Heidi completed a subsurface survey using a mechanical backhoe to exposes subsurface strata and further delineate the archaeological potential.

Alpine Road Trail Improvements Project, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed a cultural resources study for this trail and creek improvement project in the unincorporated Menlo Park and Portola Valley areas of San Mateo County. Background research indicated that a prehistoric shell midden site, has been previously identified within the project Area of Potential Effects (APE). The current survey effort identified midden soil within the previously recorded site boundaries and recommended the site be considered a historic property for National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) compliance (and a historical resource for the purposes of CEQA). Heidi recommended procedures to avoid the site during construction activities by creating an area of Archaeological Sensitivity. Heidi also recorded a historic-era refuse concentration and a historic-era bridge in the APE; both were recommended as not significant resources. Pigeon Point Light Station State Historic Park (Pigeon Point) General Plan, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi complete an archaeological resources assessment for the Pigeon Point Light Station State Historic Park (Pigeon Point) General Plan. The assessment included background research, development of a historic context, and a surface survey. Recommendations included monitoring during construction to ensure that significant cultural resources associated with the numerous uses of the point during the prehistoric and historic period be treated appropriately. Milagra Battery Trail Project, Pacifica, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi conducted the cultural resources assessment for the Milagra Battery Trail Project in the Golden Gate National Recreation Area administered by the National Park Service. Heidi recorded Fire Control Station BS Construction #129 and determined that while not individually considered a significant resource (i.e. a historic property or historical resource) and despite having been moved from its original location, Fire Control Station BS Construction #129 is considered a contributing resource to the San Francisco Harbor Defenses National Historic Landmark District. For management purposes, NPS considers this contributing resource to be a historical resource (CEQA) and a historic property (Section 106). Heidi also recorded the remains of a paved road. The road is associated with Nike Site SF-51 and is not considered a historic property or a historical resource and no additional consideration is necessary. Monte Bello Open Space Preserve Bridge Projects, San Mateo County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the cultural resources study for the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District Monte Bello Open Space Preserve Bridge Projects. The study included a records search and surface survey. Heidi concluded the bridge construction areas and access routes have a low potential for the discovery of unknown cultural resources.

Santa Clara County ECOMM Digital Microwave Project at Fire Station 28, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. Heidi worked with the San José’s Fire Station No. 28, the U.S. Department of Commerce, National Telecommunications and Information administration to provide environmental review for the Santa Clara County communications department. During project construction, ESA staff identified intact portions of prehistoric site CA- SCL-143, and recommended the site as eligible for listing in the National Register. Due to the general sensitivity of the area, ESA recommended that an archaeological and Native American monitor be on site during all ground disturbing activities for the project. BART VTA Berryessa Extension Project, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. Heidi, with R. Scott Baxter, acted as Co-Field Directors for the BART project, which included historical archaeological pre-construction testing and reporting of areas determined archaeologically sensitive, in coordination with Far Western and VTA staff. Heidi completed Silicon Valley Rapid Transit Project Safety Training, as well as Hazardous Waste Operations and Emergency Response (HAZWOPER) training, specifically for working in the BART right-of-way. Extended Archaeological Survey, AboveNet, North 1st Street, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. AboveNet, a fiber optic cable company, proposed to install approximately 4,100 feet of cable using directional drilling methods along North 1st Street in San José. One prehistoric archaeological resource (CA-SCL-302) had been previously documented in the path of the proposed alignment. Heidi worked with AboveNet to avoid this resource by placing bore pits and manholes outside of areas of known archaeological sensitivity and using direction drill techniques to install the fiber optic cable at a depth below the known site (a depth of approximately 15 feet below ground surface). Heidi and an ESA geologist were present during all fieldwork. An Ohlone/Costanoan tribal representative from the Amah/Mutsun Tribal Band was also present during the subsurface investigation. San José/Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant Master Plan, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. Heidi is the archaeologist for the City of San José’s master plan to rebuild the San José/Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant and convert land uses on the plant's 2,700-acre site on the South Bay's shoreline. ESA completed a cultural resources assessment for the Project, which included a records search at the Northwest Information Center, a surface survey, and an analysis for the sensitivity of cultural resources. Numerous archaeological sites have been uncovered in the Santa Clara Valley that are buried beneath feet of alluvial fill, naturally deposited by the San Francisco Bay environment. While no cultural resources were identified during the investigation for the WPCP Project, mitigation measures for Program-level additional research and accidental discovery were recommended. Lower Berryessa Creek Project, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. To facilitate compliance with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Section 106 requirements, Heidi completed a cultural resources assessment for the Santa Clara Valley Water District’s Lower Berryessa

Creek project, including a records search at the Northwest Information Center and a survey of the unsurveyed alignments. The project includes flood control improvements in three creek alignments (Berryessa, Calera, and Tularcitos) that would result in the containment of the channels’ design flow. The assessment included both project-level (near term) and program- level (long-term) components. Heidi updated the Lower Berryessa and Lower Calera Creek components of the project with a revised records search, survey, and analysis. Zanker Road Development Project, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. To comply with the Program-level research required by the San José/Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant Master Plan EIR, Heidi completed a Phase I and Extended Phase I Survey for the Zanker Road Development Project Area. Heidi managed the Extended Phase I Subsurface Testing Program to ensure that prehistoric archaeological site components from a nearby site did not extend into the proposed development area. Heidi proposed a buffer area around the site boundaries to ensure that ground disturbance would not cause impacts to this potentially National Register eligible site. Construction Enabling Project, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. To comply with the Program-level research required by the San José/Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant Master Plan EIR, Heidi completed a Phase I and Extended Phase I Survey for the Construction Enabling Project Area associated with development in the facilities associated with the Master Plan. Heidi managed the Extended Phase I Subsurface Testing Program to ensure that prehistoric archaeological site components from a nearby site did not extend into the proposed development area. The area was concluded to not contain any cultural resources that could be impacted by ground disturbance. Silicon Valley Regional Communication System, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. The Silicon Valley Interoperability Authority (SVRIA) is the sponsor for the proposed Silicon Valley Regional Communications System (SVRCS) Upgrades Project. The SVRCS will replace the many existing analog public safety radio systems currently in use in Santa Clara County with a new digital radio system. Heidi completed the cultural resources study for the project, which includes upgrades to 13 existing communication sites and 2 new digital radio sites. Based on the results of the records search, the survey results, and the existing conditions, Heidi concluded there was a low potential for ground disturbing activities to encounter archaeological or historical resources. Almaden Lake Project, San José, Santa Clara County. Archaeologist. Heidi completed the cultural resources assessment for the Almaden Lake Project in San Jose. The project proposed to address the water quality issues related to mercury and anadromous fish. Heidi completed background research and surface survey of the project area and concluded that no impacts would results from project ground disturbance.

North San Pablo Bay Restoration and Reuse Project, Sonoma, Marin, and Napa Counties. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared the cultural resources section for four wastewater utilities and one water agency in the North San Pablo Bay region of California who have joined forces to plan a project that would considerably expand the use of recycled water region wide. The study area includes pipeline segments throughout Marin, Sonoma, and Napa counties. A records search and several updates were conducted at the Northwest Information Center of the California Historical Resources Information System. Approximately 250 archaeological sites and historic structures have been previously recorded within the study area. Surface surveys and extended subsurface surveys were conducted to assess previously known archaeological resources and determine whether additional resources may be affected by the project. A finding of No Adverse Effect to Historic Properties was determined by the lead agency, the Bureau of Reclamation. Invasive Spartina Project, Cultural Resources Sensitivity Study. Archaeologist. Heidi prepared a cultural resources sensitivity study for the Invasive Spartina Project sponsored by the State Coastal Conservancy. The study included comprehensive background research at the Northwest Information Center for approximately 5,000 acres throughout the San Francisco Bay Area. The records search used the Information Center’s updated GIS database system to establish where treatment areas intersected known cultural resources. Heidi identified several specific areas and recommended avoidance to ensure cultural resources protection. Heidi also completed a cultural resources awareness training with personnel from the project in agreement with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service archaeologist.

CDFG Suction Dredge Mining Permitting Project. Archaeologist. Heidi researched and analyzed the impacts that small-scale recreational suction dredge mining has on cultural resources in and adjacent to California’s waterways. The analysis concluded that those activities had significant and unavoidable impacts to cultural resources, including historic-period and prehistoric archaeological sites, potential shipwreck locations, as well as Traditional Cultural Properties and human remains. Primary concerns were that intensive studies required for site specific information on cultural resources is not within the jurisdictional authority of the Department of Fish and Game.

EDUCATION Brian is a Certified Wildlife Biologist who offers specialized experience leading projects with complex regulatory, mitigation, and construction/environmental M.S., Environmental Studies, San Jose State compliance backgrounds. He is experienced with biological resources University throughout California and he routinely coordinates with scientists, planners, B.A., Biology, and resource agency staff to resolve issues that affect biological issues. Brian is University of California, trained and proficient in permitting procedures and requirements under CEQA, Santa Cruz NEPA, the federal and California Endangered Species Act(s), California Fish & 21 YEARS EXPERIENCE Game Code, and federal and California Clean Water Acts. He holds a federal 10(a) federal Recovery Permit for vernal pool branchiopods, California red- CERTIFICATIONS/ REGISTRATION legged frog, and California tiger salamander; and he performs a wide range of focused biological surveys throughout the State. He is also a co-investigator on a Certified Wildlife federal 10(a) permit for Central California Coast (CCC) coho salmon and CCC Biologist - The Wildlife Society, 2004 steelhead.

California Scientific Collecting Permit ALTERNATE ID# 003068 Brian is a Certified Wildlife Biologist who offers specialized experience leading small to large projects with complex regulatory and compliance backgrounds. Federal Recovery Permit #TE-027422-5 As a CEQA and NEPA expert, he excels at regulatory compliance, strategic (fairy shrimp, permit planning, and preparing accurate and defensible environmental California tiger documentation. Other services that Brian leads include endangered species salamander, and surveys, habitat evaluations, constraints and opportunity studies, and California red-legged frog) restoration planning. He leads resource agency permitting efforts and construction compliance monitoring assignments throughout California. Brian NMFS Federal frequently acts as a technical liaison between project design and engineering Recovery Permit #16506 (Central clients, and between ESA’s environmental planning and permitting specialists. California Coast coho salmon and CCC steelhead) East Bay Regional Park District, McCosker Stream Restoration and Recreational FAA-certified Infrastructure Improvements, Canyon, CA. Sr. Wildlife Biologist. Brian was the Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) pilot lead biologist during ESA’s preparation of planning-level through construction documents to support the development of a new 250-acre regional park. TRAINING Significant project features include daylighting 2,700 linear feet of culverted CDFW California creek channel, reconstructing the channel and reestablishing the riparian Aquatic Bioassessment corridor, providing the site civil engineering for public access including park Workshop roads and trails, water supply, and facilities layout. Wetland Delineation Training Course, U.S. The DeSilva Group, SMP-30 Expansion CEQA Compliance, Regulatory Permitting, Army Corps of Compliance Monitoring, and Rare Amphibian Pond Creation, Alameda County, CA. Engineers Sr. Wildlife Biologist. Brian the lead wildlife biologist responsible for preparing Desert Tortoise Survey permit applications and negotiating compensatory mitigation in support of the Techniques Workshop, Biological Opinion from the USFWS and Incidental Take Permit from CDFW. ESA Desert Tortoise Council started by providing a series of biological surveys and permitting strategy in support of preparation of an EIR for the expansion of the aggregate quarry, conducting protocol-level surveys for California red-legged frog (CRLF) and

California tiger salamander (CTS). Brian worked closely with ESA hydrologists to design a 1-acre breeding pond for rare amphibians and model annual water levels. In 2017, ESA is continuing its 2nd year of performance monitoring at the created amphibian habitat, which is functioning as designed. Port of San Francisco (for Weiss Associates), As-Needed Environmental and Related Professional Services, City and County of San Francisco, CA. Sr. Wildlife Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist under the Port’s as-needed services contract with Weiss Associates. In this capacity, he performed a detailed biological review that supported the CEQA analysis for the Crane Cove Park Project (within the Pier 70 Master Plan area). This project required permit from the USACE, the RWQCB, and San Francisco BCDC; consultations with the USFWS and NMFS; and coordination under Section 106 of the NHPA. Brian collaborated closely with Port staff to prepare and submit permit applications the Biological Assessments. Port of Redwood City, Wharves 3 and 4 Fender Replacement Project, San Mateo County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the senior biologist overseeing preparation of the CEQA Mitigated Negative Declaration, which the Port adopted in January 2017, and permitting documentation with federal and state regulatory agencies. ESA, as a sub-consultant to COWI Marine North America, is providing CEQA compliance and permitting assistance for improvements proposed for Wharves 3 and 4 at the Port of Redwood City. Improvements include new dolphins, fenders and/or panels, and would be designed to accommodate both barges and bulk carriers. The Port plans to construct the project in summer 2017. BART to Livermore Extension Project, San Francisco Bay Area, CA. Sr. Biologist. Brian is managing the regulatory permitting, biological surveys, and CEQA/NEPA biological resources analysis for the project-level environmental review of this major BART expansion project, which builds upon the BART to Livermore Extension Program EIR. He provides senior level direction and strategic advice to BART related to biological impacts and mitigation issues. The current effort is examining a full range of options to meet the regional connectivity and congestion relief goals for the proposed project. Golden State Warriors Arena, San Francisco, CA. Sr. Biologist. Brian was a senior member of the ESA team that provided environmental permitting services for the Golden State Warriors’ proposed development on the San Francisco waterfront. He prepared the environmental analysis for the proposed event center that will serve as the new home of the Golden State Warriors basketball team and a year-round venue for concerts and other events. Brian and the ESA permitting team used their recent extensive experience gained in conducting environmental review for the 34th America’s Cup events. The Warriors broke ground on the $1 billion Chase Center in January 2017 and will occupy the facility during the 2019-2020 season. Doyle Drive Stormdrain Outfalls Biological Assessment, San Francisco, CA. Sr. Biologist. Brian Prepared the USFWS Biological Assessment for the City’s proposed Doyle Drive Stormdrain outfall. The project, funded by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, was a part of a larger ESA effort to obtain regulatory permits, conduct construction monitoring, and prepare regulatory compliance documentation per CEQA/NEPA mitigation commitments. Recology Hay Road Landfill, Fairfield, CA. Senior Biologist. In support of the planned expansion of the Hay Road Landfill, Brian led the field team that provided focused special-status wildlife surveys, including surveys for California tiger salamander and listed vernal pool branchiopods in 85 distinct vernal pools. The landfill is located in the Jepson Prairie; an area that is rich in sensitive vernal pool resources. Rare species that were identified included vernal pool tadpole shrimp, vernal pool fairy shrimp, and tricolored blackbird. ESA is assisting Recology in permitting the planned expansion with federal and state regulatory agencies. Truckee River Legacy Trails, Truckee, CA. Senior biologist. Brian served a senior technical role in supporting the Phase 3B of the Truckee River Legacy Trail Project to assist the Town of Truckee in minimizing and restoring wetland impacts following construction of the trail over Martis Creek. As senior biologist on this project, he performed a focused foothill yellow-legged frog survey and assisted with permitting efforts. The Phase 3B trail segment consists of a paved recreation trail for use by cyclists, pedestrians, and other non-motorized uses located outside of the Town of Truckee. S.F. Public Utilities Commission, Alameda Creek Recapture Project, Alameda Creek, CA. Senior Biologist. As part of the ESA/Orion team, Brian supported the CEQA analysis and performed focused habitat reviews for sensitive wildlife in Alameda Creek, including the foothill yellow-legged frog and California red- legged frog to better represent the impact of the proposed recapture on the wildlife resources within Alameda Creek. Bureau of Land Management, San Bernardino County, Bechtel Development Company, Inc., Soda Mountain Solar Project PA/EIS/EIR, San Bernardino County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian actively worked with ESA’s Project Manager, the NEPA and CEQA lead agencies, and the Applicant team to prepare a Plan Amendment (PA)/ EIS/ EIR under the Federal Land Policy Management Act (FLPMA), NEPA, and CEQA, respectively, for a 350-megawatt (MW) photovoltaic (PV) solar power plant and related infrastructure to be constructed, operated, maintained and decommissioned within an 4,179-acre right-of-way on BLM administered public lands. County approval of well permits also will be required. Key biological resource considerations related to the local presence of desert tortoise, Mojave fringe-toed lizard, Mohave tui chub, golden eagle, and bighorn sheep. The Proposed PA, Final EIS/EIR was issued June 4, 2015. U.S. Bureau of Land Management, Blythe Mesa Solar Project, Riverside County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. ESA provided BLM project management assistance and peer review support to BLM for the Blythe Mesa Solar Project. The project involves the construction of a 480 MW photovoltaic solar facility located on lands within the jurisdiction of the County of Riverside and City of Blythe and a generation tie line that traverses lands administered by the BLM. On behalf of BLM, Brian critically reviewed the NEPA biological resources materials that were submitted in support of the Draft EIR/EA and directed the resolution of key biological issues for the project.

Palo Verde Mesa Solar Project EIR, Riverside County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian assisted in preparing portions of the draft and final EIR for the Palo Verde Mesa Solar Project. Renewable Resources Group, Inc. proposed the construction, operation, and decommissioning of the Palo Verde Mesa Solar Project (PVMSP or Project), a 470 megawatt (MW) alternating current solar photovoltaic (PV) electrical generating facility and associated infrastructure to provide site access and connection to the statewide electricity transmission grid. The Project site is located on approximately 3,400 acres in the Palo Verde Mesa region of Riverside County—3,250 acres for the solar facility site and 143

acres for the 230 kilovolt (kV) gen-tie line. Key biological resource issues included burrowing owl, desert tortoise, rare plants, and avian interactions with project facilities.

Bureau of Land Management, NextEra Energy Resources LLC, Modified Blythe Solar Power Project EIS, ROD, and Construction Plan Review, Riverside County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist who supported preparation of an EIS and ROD under FLPMA and NEPA for the BLM for Level 3 variance to a right-of-way grant issued in 2010 for the Blythe Solar Power Project. Proposed modifications to the existing approval included changing the solar technology to PV from the previously-approved solar thermal parabolic trough; reducing the footprint to approximately 4,138 acres from the originally approved 6,831 acres; and reducing the anticipated power output to 485 MW from the 1,000 MW the original project would have produced. Key issues included interagency coordination, desert tortoise, Mohave fringe-toed lizard, and rare plants. The ROD was signed August 1, 2014. Bureau of Land Management Solar Millennium – Palen Solar Power Project Final EIS, Riverside County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist for the Final EIS based on a joint CEQA-equivalent and NEPA document that had been prepared in coordination with the California Energy Commission for the Palen Solar Power Project. The project proposed to construct, operate, maintain, and ultimately decommission a 500 MW concentrated solar thermal electric generating facility that would use solar parabolic trough technology to generate electricity. The project site is located primarily on BLM-administered public land in the California inland desert in Riverside County. Key issues included avian and bat impacts caused by collision with project structures, desert tortoise, and habitat for the Mohave fringe-toed lizard. The Final EIS was completed in May 2011, and the ROD was completed in July 2011, but was not signed. Bureau of Land Management, BrightSource Energy, Inc. and Abengoa Solar LLC, Palen Solar Electric Generating System Supplemental EIS, Riverside County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist for the preparation of a Supplemental EIS under FLPMA and NEPA for the BLM for a proposed 500 MW solar electricity generation facility (including two 750-foot power towers, each topped by a 10-foot tall lightning rod and Federal Aviation Administration- required lighting) and ancillary facilities, including an access road, 230-kV electric generation-tie (gen-tie) transmission line, redundant telecommunication cable, and 8-inch natural gas pipeline within a 5,200-acre proposed right-of-way application area. Key considerations included avian and bat impacts caused by solar flux and collision with project structures, desert tortoise, and habitat for the Mohave fringe-toed lizard. The Applicant withdrew its application on September 26, 2014, before issuance of the Final Supplemental EIS. Fresno County, Recurrent Energy Development Holdings, LLC – Tranquillity Solar Generating Facility Project EIR, Fresno County, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was the lead biological analyst during ESA’s preparation of an EIR for Fresno County to analyze the impacts of a proposed 400 MW PV electricity generating facility and related infrastructure on approximately 3,732 acres of low-production agricultural lands where production values have been substantially degraded by chemical impairment and lack of water. The project received final approval in October 2014. California High Speed Rail Project, Environmental Compliance for Merced to Fresno Construction Package 1 (CP1), Merced to Fresno, CA. Senior Biologist. As a subconsultant to the Tutor Perini Zachary Parsons (TPZP) Joint Venture, ESA is providing environmental compliance support services for the Merced to Fresno Construction Package 1 (CP1), the 29-mile first segment of the California High Speed Rail design/build project. ESA is supporting TPZP and the Authority by providing both biological and cultural resources technical studies, including conducting historical and archaeological surveys, evaluations, and implementation of mitigation measures, in support of the design and construction of the project. Further, ESA is leading pre-construction surveys for targeted species (i.e., California tiger salamander, San Joaquin kit fox, Swainson’s hawk, burrowing owl, and rare plants) and providing all biological monitoring during construction. Lastly, ESA is providing GIS support throughout construction to document habitat disturbances in real time and demonstrate compliance with numerous environmental compliance commitments. As a senior project biologist since 2013, Brian has conducted pre-construction surveys, biological surveys (general and focused), and provided QA/QC oversight to maintain project compliance with MMRP requirements and project environmental permits. Marin Municipal Water District. California Red-legged Frog Surveys. Project Manager and Lead Biologist. Brian coordinated with fisheries biologists at MMWD to assess their maintenance projects in the Lagunitas Creek Watershed and performed a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service protocol-level survey to ascertain the presence and distribution of California red-legged frogs in the local project vicinity. The survey results informed which areas needed coordination with resource agencies to address potential impacts to red-legged frogs. Henry W. Coe State Park, Sacramento, CA. Project Manager and Technical Lead. Brian provided federal and state permit assistance and senior biological oversight to day use improvements facilities at Henry W. Coe State Park. He prepared federal and state permit natural resource applications from federal and state agencies for redevelopment of their day-use and visitor center. Development of habitat improvements intended to create breeding habitat for CRLF, such as the design and development of sediment basins, improvement of existing springs, and vegetation planting were also featured in the redevelopment plan. Hiram Lewis Park and Detention Basin IS/MND, Windsor, CA. Technical Specialist. Brian prepared a biological analysis in support of the Hiram Lewis Park and Detention Basin project in the Town of Windsor. He prepared portions of an IS and MND for proposed recreational and flood control facilities. Brian also assisted in preparing permit applications and supporting documents for the Corps, the CDFW, and the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB). Newhall Park Siltation Basins, Concord, CA. Project Manager & Senior Biologist. As part of a mitigation monitoring plan consistent with CDFW guidelines, Brian managed a revegetation effort which was implemented as part of a larger Streambed Alteration Agreement. Brian assessed habitats for special status wildlife species, and conducted protocol-level surveys for CRLF. Minimal Threat Flood Control Maintenance Regional Biological Assessment. Senior Biologist. Brian was a primary technical author of a regional biological assessment (RBA) prepared on behalf of the Bay Area Stormwater Management Agencies (BASMAA) to secure a Regional General Permit (RGP) from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) and a Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) for flood control projects that have minimal effect on water quality. A

RGP was sought by the OPC participating agencies to streamline the permitting process for those activities posing a minimal threat to water quality. Vallejo Sanitation and Flood Control District CEQA Document to Support Fish & Game Permit Application, Vallejo, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian conducted habitat assessments and protocol-level surveys for CRLF at nineteen aquatic sites in the City of Vallejo. His assessment was used to support CDFW permit applications for sites throughout the City. Windsor Creek and East Windsor Creek Flood Control Projects, Windsor, CA. Biologist. Brian performed an ecological habitat assessment and constraints analysis of Windsor Creek for CRLF, California freshwater shrimp, western pond turtle and other sensitive species located around the East Windsor Creek Flood Control Project area. His assessment was used in coordination with a flood management plan developed with Boyle Engineering Corporation, which outlined five alternatives to alleviate chronic flooding along a one-mile segment of creek bed. Ultimately, Brian’s analysis was used as part of a CEQA document on the preferred alternative. Zone 7 Stream Maintenance Management Plan (SMMP), Lead Biologist. Brian was the technical lead for biological resources for the Zone 7 Stream Management Master Plan (SMMP) CEQA analysis. This effort identified and implemented a series of projects in the upper Alameda Creek Watershed to meet multiple objectives, including: flood protection, water supply, sediment management, habitat corridors, water quality and recreational corridors. The SMMP was developed through a series of stakeholder meetings to identify projects that meet multiple objectives on a subwatershed basis. The SMMP identified 45 projects within 10 subwatershed areas. These projects range in project type, scale, engineering detail, level of potential environmental effect. Bureau of Reclamation, North San Pablo Bay Restoration and Reuse Project, Santa Rosa, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian supervised completion of the EIR biological resources analysis and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service fisheries and terrestrial Biological Assessments. This complicated, tri-county CEQA/NEPA project would implement a cooperative system for delivering recycled water to users throughout Sonoma, Napa, and Marin counties, including the Napa Salt Marsh Restoration Area. Aidlin Aquatic Monitoring Program. Project Manager and Technical Specialist. Since 1997, Brian has worked for Geothermal Energy Partners and Calpine in The Geysers to monitor steelhead habitat and populations. He monitors steelhead populations and water quality on an annual basis to assess overall stream health near geothermal power generation facilities. Alviso Boat Launch Facility Biological Assessment, Alviso, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the senior biologist supervising the field review and Biological Assessment for this controversial boat launch facility. Located in the South Bay’s Alviso Slough adjacent to the Don Edwards National Wildlife Refuge (NWR), this salt marsh provides nesting habitat for California clapper rail, western snowy plover, and salt marsh harvest mouse. Bear Canyon West Ford Flat Aquatic Monitoring Program. Project Manager and Technical Specialist. In support of ongoing geothermal power generation activities in the Geysers, Brian has monitored steelhead and rainbow trout in the Bear Canyon watersheds to assess stream health in the Geysers region from 1997 to present. Brian performed all aspects of fish and water sampling, which included electrofishing capturing, identifying, and measuring fish in the watershed area to determine long-term environmental impacts of geothermal development and operation, and reporting. Beringer-Blass Wine Estates EIR, Saint Helena, CA. Project Manager and Lead Biologist. Brian was the senior biologist for the project EIR and subsequently prepared biological and wetland permitting documentation for submittal to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps), USFWS, and California Department of Fish and Wildlife for impacts to listed species and wetlands for biological surveys of the 218-acre project site. He performed protocol-level surveys of the Beringer site for listed fairy shrimp species in 2001 and 2003, prepared an Ecosystem Restoration Plan and Long Term Management Plan that specified how and where mitigation wetlands would be created. Additionally, he identified long-term management obligations and was responsible for all aspects of wetland design, preserve management, agency coordination, and ultimately testified as a vernal pool fairy shrimp expert before the Napa County Board of Supervisors. Brentwood Transfer Station Expansion Initial Study (IS). Technical Specialist. Brian performed a focused habitat assessment for special status invertebrates and amphibians in support of an IS for expansion of the Brentwood Transfer Station. His focused assessment submitted to the USFWS considered the potential presence of listed fairy shrimp, California red-legged frog and California tiger salamander on existing solid waste transfer station property and on adjacent parcels proposed as expansion sites. Byron Road Bridge Improvements Project, Contra Costa County, CA. Technical Specialist. Brian performed a detailed habitat assessment for vernal pool fairy shrimp for a proposed bridge improvement project in Contra Costa County. Part of his assessment required the locating of several sensitive areas to identify where fairy shrimp surveys were conducted in previous years. California Public Utilities Commission, San Joaquin Cross Valley Loop 22 kV Transmission Line EIR, Tulare County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian led field surveys and prepared the Biological Resources section of an EIR that reviewed four proposed alignments for the Cross Valley Loop Project. The evaluation included an analysis of potential effects to listed fairy shrimp species, California tiger salamander, San Joaquin kit fox and rare plants, which are known to occur on each of the alignments. Field surveys covered a linear distance of greater than 20 miles that included a variety of sensitive natural communities, ecological reserves and varied wetland habitats. California State Lands Commission, Hansen Sand Mining Project. Senior Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist on this CEQA project to allow the 10-year reauthorization of sand mining activities in Central San Francisco Bay and the Carquinez Straits. The analysis considered the potential effects of continued suction dredge mining on marine resources including the commercial Dungeness crab and Pacific herring fishery of San Francisco Bay, invertebrate food chain support, marine mammals, and common and special status fish. Particular attention was given to potential effects to delta smelt, longfin smelt and salmonids. Casa Diablo IV Geothermal Power Plant, Joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Mammoth Lakes CA, US Bureau of Land Management. Senior Project Biologist. Brian was the lead biological analyst for the Joint EIS/EIR for the construction and operation of a 33 megawatt geothermal power plant and associated well field in Mammoth Lakes, CA. He reviewed the technical reports submitted on behalf of the applicant,

commenting on document adequacy and the need for additional site information. Key biological issues addressed in the analysis include maintaining movement corridors for blacktailed deer, groundwater use and associated effects City of Petaluma Ellis Creek Water Recycling Facility. Biological Specialist. Brian provided specific expertise for the City of Petaluma’s Ellis Creek Water Recycling Facility, which provides Petaluma with improved reliability, increased capacity, and higher quality wastewater treatment services. He performed focused surveys for California red-legged frog and was brought in to provide senior oversight of salt marsh harvest mouse management issues at the facility. He continues to provide long-term O&M and permitting support to the operating facility. Contra Costa Water District, Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion Project EIS/EIR, Contra Costa County, CA. Biological Task Lead. Brian managed and led the biology team during wetland, botanical, and wildlife studies in support of the reservoir expansion project. He was the primary biologist representing the expansion project during agency team meetings and providing information and updates on biological study finds to state and federal environmental regulators. Brian was senior author of the CEQA/NEPA biological resource analysis and Action Specific Implementation Plan (ASIP), the CALFED Bay-Delta analysis equivalent to a USFWS Biological Assessment. He continued to manage the compliance and monitoring team during the 2011-2012 construction period. Contra Costa County, Tres Vaqueros Wind Energy Project, Contra Costa County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian led the effort to perform field surveys and prepared the Biological Resources section of the EIR. The evaluation included an analysis of turbine impacts on bats and raptors, as well as effects on California tiger salamander, California red-legged frog, burrowing owl and San Joaquin kit fox. ESA prepared an EIR for the project, which entails "repowering" of the existing facility by replacing all of the existing turbines and civil/electrical infrastructure (except for the on-site substation) with 42 new wind turbines. CALFED Yolo County Parks & Recreation Land Management Plan, Yolo County, CA. Technical Specialist. As a component of a three year program, Brian led a two year effort to survey for vernal pool tadpole shrimp on a 640-acre site, including a US Air force Communications Facility under his federal 10(a) Recovery Permit. These protocol level surveys were used as baseline studies on wetlands and uplands and associated endangered and threatened species to develop a final conservation and management plan. The plan included endangered species management, invasive species eradication, a detailed monitoring program, and adaptive management. Ultimately, a series of state and federal regulatory documents including federal endangered species act section 7 biological assessments were prepared. City of Livermore Pressure Zone 3 Improvements MND, Livermore, CA. Wildlife Biologist. Brian conducted field reconnaissance of existing Altamont Reservoir facilities to identify specific mitigation measures necessary to avoid negative project impacts on sensitive species. He worked closely with the Livermore project team to implement pre-construction surveys and construction monitoring to ensure that biological resource areas were not adversely affected. Improvements included installation of a three million gallon tank adjacent to the City's existing Altamont Reservoir, improvements to the Altamont Pump Station, and a looped pipeline connection from the tank to the City's distribution system. City of San Leandro Shoreline Marshlands Area, San Leandro, CA. Senior Biologist and Technical Specialist. From 1997 to present, Brian has assisted the City of San Leandro with ongoing wildlife and vegetation monitoring and resource management at Roberts Landing and the San Leandro Marina. Elements monitored at the site included salt marsh harvest mouse, pickleweed growth, non-native Spartina alterniflora, waterfowl, and tidal conditions in problematic slough areas. In early years Brian prepared annual management reports documenting the status of non-native cordgrass expansion and the reestablishment of invertebrate populations as part of an ongoing marshland management contract. More recently, in 2014 he performed bat and nesting bird surveys in support of a bridge repair project near the Marina. Contra Costa Water District, Multipurpose Pipeline, Contra Costa County, CA. Wildlife Biologist. Brian monitored compliance effectiveness and adequacy of a Biological Opinion written as part of a larger pipeline routing study. His analysis was prepared in coordination with an EIR/EIS for the pipeline project as a subcontractor to Montgomery Watson. The entire project included a 22-mile pipeline and pump station and four-mile pipeline and pump station in northern Contra Costa County. Los Angeles County Parks and Recreation MNDs, Los Angeles County, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian has led survey efforts for special status plant and wildlife species throughout Los Angeles County parks. He has prepared numerous public services and utilities sections for LA County parks projects, including the Loma Alta County Park Gymnasium, Arrastre Canyon Staging Area and Connector Trail, and Acton County Park. Crystal Springs Trunk Sewer Improvement IS, Hillsborough, CA. Sr. Wildlife Biologist. As part of an environmental compliance monitoring contract, Brian performed a focused survey for California red-legged frog and assessed habitat conditions for other special status species, including local steelhead populations that would be potentially affected by the replacement of a undersized and failing sewer line for the Town of Hillsborough. Brian’s monitoring was necessary for this project, as the technique used for the sewer line replacement relied on an innovative pipe-bursting method to minimize construction impacts to high quality riparian habitat. Department of Water Resources, East Branch Aqueduct Improvement and Enlargement Project EIR, Los Angeles County, CA. Biologist. As the senior project wildlife biologist, Brian was responsible for focused field surveys in support of CEQA documentation and project permitting. He performed protocol-level surveys for California red-legged frog and identified a new population of the endangered arroyo toad near the project. Brian prepared the Biological Resources portion of the project EIR and the Biological Assessment in coordination with the USFWS. ESA has conducted technical studies to complete the EIR and has begun negotiating permit requirements and restoration planning with resource agencies including the USACE, RWQCB, and USFWS. Department of Water Resources, Piru Creek Arroyo Toad Population Monitoring, Ventura County, CA. Senior Biologist. Mr. Pittman is the lead investigator for a population study of the arroyo toad population in middle Piru Creek, between Pyramid Lake and Lake Piru. The creek serves as the primary water delivery route between the two reservoirs, and also supports one of most important remaining populations of the endangered arroyo toad. As such, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) required a monitoring plan and ongoing population studies as a condition of continued water deliveries. Surveys are

performed in coordination with DWR, and consider the health and status of toad breeding relative to water releases, natural runoff, and populations on a nearby natural waterway. Department of Water Resources, South Bay Aqueduct Improvement and Enlargement Project EIR, Alameda County, CA. Sr. Biologist. Brian was the senior wildlife biologist on this project from 2003 to 2014. He directed surveys for special-status wildlife species and was senior author of the USFWS Biological Assessment. Brian was instrumental in the identification and selection of mitigation sites. During construction from 2005 to 2014, he had a senior role in preconstruction surveys, compliance monitoring, agency coordination, and later with the enhancement, monitoring, and management of mitigation sites. Brian’s observations of the California tiger salamander were published in a peer- reviewed journal following the completion of this project. East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) San Pablo Dam Seismic Upgrade EIR, Orinda, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian was responsible for assessing habitat for special status wildlife species likely to be affected by a major Seismic Upgrade Project to the San Pablo Dam, deemed necessary by the California Division of Safety of Dams. The dam secures 866-acres of surface area water with a shoreline of 14-miles, supporting a variety of wetland habitat and protected species, including CRLF, Alameda whipsnake, and western pond turtle. Brian’s analyses of impacts to special status species was necessary for permitting of the Seismic Upgrade. Duck Creek Biological Resource Surveys, San Joaquin County, CA. Lead Investigator. Brian was the lead investigator for an extensive vernal pool reconnaissance survey that considered the potential presence of vernal pool fairy shrimp in a roughly 2,000 acre area. More than 150 pools were assessed to determine the potential presence of listed fairy shrimp in the study area. California Public Utilities Commission, Falcon Ridge Substation EIR, San Francisco, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was the lead biological analyst during ESA’s preparation of an EIR under contract to the CPUC to evaluate the potential impacts of Southern California Edison’s proposed Falcon Ridge Substation project. He reviewed technical reports submitted on behalf of the applicant and commented on document adequacy and the need for additional site information. Sensitive species included San Bernardino kangaroo rat, coastal California gnatcatcher, and Delhi Sands flower-loving fly. The Final EIR was completed in October 2012. Gallo Vineyards Sun Lake Ranch Vineyard Development and ECP, Healdsburg, CA. Technical Specialist. Brian performed a protocol-level habitat assessment for CRLF in support of CEQA review for an Erosion Control Plan. The proposed Sun Lake Ranch vineyard development is for Gallo Vineyards in Pope Valley, and will nearly double the existing vineyard acreage when complete. Brian’s assessment was submitted to the USFWS, who formally concurred with his findings. Golden Gate Bridge District Ferry Terminal Expansion, Sausalito and San Francisco, CA. Technical Specialist. Brian was the technical biological resources lead for expansion projects at the Sausalito Ferry Terminal and San Francisco Ferry Terminal. He prepared two Caltrans Natural Environmental Study reports in support of this project. Key issues for the expansion included potential impacts to herring spawning areas, marine mammals, sensitive natural habitat (eelgrass beds), and salmonids. Hasley Canyon Project EIR, Los Angeles County, CA. Technical Specialist. Brian led a USFWS protocol-level survey effort for the federally listed arroyo toad and CRLF on the Hasley Canyon project site. His surveys considered construction impacts on local amphibian populations affected by the construction of 209 single-family residences, a golf course, open space areas, lakes and an equestrian trail on the 433-acre site in unincorporated Los Angeles County. Highway 101 Off-ramp Widening, Windsor, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian designed and directed special status species surveys and impact analysis for the Highway 101 Widening Project in Windsor. He was also principle investigator and author of a Caltrans Natural Environment Study and Biological Assessment for East Windsor Creek in support of the widening project. This project included coordination and consultation with personnel from USFWS, CDFW, and the Corps. Hollister Airport Biological Services, Hollister, CA. Technical Specialist and Lead Biologist. In support of the Hollister Airport runway widening and safety project, Brian assisted the City in developing a strategy to identify and protect California tiger salamanders and burrowing owls on the airport during construction. Over the course of a week, he led a team of wildlife biologists that cleared approximately 90 acres airport lands prior to the runway expansion project. L.A. Cellular Wireless Environmental Documentation, Southern, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian led a focused survey effort to determine the potential impacts of 48-cellular tower locations throughout Los Angeles, San Bernardino, and Riverside Counties. His analysis was used to determine the effects of unique tower sites effect on desert tortoise populations. Brian headed subsequent formal consultation efforts with the USFWS for several sites, and negotiated a programmatic Biological Opinion for impacts to desert tortoise. California Public Utilities Commission, Lakeview Substation EIR, Lakeview, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was the senior biological analyst during ESA’s preparation of an EIR under contract to the CPUC to evaluate the potential impacts of Southern California Edison’s Lakeview Substation project. This project would construct a substation in an agricultural field and establish transmission lines across undeveloped portions of the San Jacinto foothills, in areas that generally support kangaroo rats and special-status plants. The Final EIR was completed in August 2012. Lancaster Water Reclamation Plant 2020 Facilities Plan Program EIR, Lancaster, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian led extensive wetland and biological surveys covering over 10-square-miles in the Antelope Valley in support of an EIR assessing the impacts of expanding a water treatment plant that discharges onto U.S. Military, Los Angeles County, and privately owned properties. Brian conducted the initial project screening analysis which focused on Mohave ground squirrel, desert tortoise, burrowing owl, seasonal wetlands, and numerous rare plants. Following the screening analysis, he directed focused wildlife surveys for Mojave ground squirrel in support of the project EIR, and co-authored the Biological Resources section of the EIR. Lehigh Permanente Quarry Reclamation Plan EIR, Santa Clara Co., CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the senior biologist for the Lehigh Permanente Quarry Reclamation EIR analysis that considered potential options for restoring the quarry upon its closure. Key to the analysis was the potential presence of salmonid habitat in the stream that traversed the quarry and the presence of California red-legged frogs in several locations, including within active quarry ponds. As a result of this project, the County recognized the ESA team for “exemplary work and analysis” in preparing the EIR.

Livermore-Amador Valley Water Management Agency (LAVWMA) Pipeline, Alameda County, CA. Wildlife Biologist. Brian designed and directed a comprehensive field review for the 21-mile LAVWMA pipeline between Livermore and San Leandro. He assessed habitat suitability and developed mitigation measures to reduce impacts to less-than-significant levels for a variety of special status plants and wildlife, including CRLF, burrowing owl, tiger salamander, fairy shrimp, and steelhead. Brian also acted as the primary author of the biological resources section of an EIR outlining historic and current endangered species distribution along the pipelines’ path, and prepared CDFW and USFWS permitting documents. City of Livermore California Red-legged Frog Predator Control Program. Between 2006 and 2012, Brian was the lead investigator in a California red-legged frog predator control effort performed for the City of Livermore. To kick-off this effort in 2006, he led the fish recovery and salvage program during the draining of a 1.5-acre off-channel pond located at Springtown Golf Course. The pond was fully drained using a high capacity pump. Brian rescued several hundred native fish from the drained pond and removed aquatic species that are predatory on the native red-legged frog. Following the dewatering effort, predator control efforts continued for six years as a condition of the City’s water impoundment permit in Altamont Creek. Los Vaqueros Recreation Company, Fish Stocking Permit Support. Project Manager and Lead Biologist. Brian worked closely with the Contra Costa Water District and their concessionaire the Los Vaqueros Recreation Company to permit trout stocking of the 1,500 acre Los Vaqueros Reservoir in Contra Costa County. As the result of a 2010 lawsuit, the California Department of Fish and Game stopped stocking many reservoirs with hatchery fish and began requiring focused wildlife surveys in support of the new permit process. Brian performed surveys for California red-legged frogs in Los Vaqueros Reservoir, identifying frog use in two areas adjacent to, but not within the reservoir. He continues to coordinate with CDFW to resolve issues related to the stocking permit. Mai/Chardonnay Resort EIR, Suisun City, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian prepared the focused biological constraints analysis in support of the biological analysis for the proposed development of a 46-acre resort hotel and vineyards in Napa County. He was the technical lead for the wetland delineation, and prepared the biological resources section of the EIR which analyzed potential environmental effects related to compatibility with the Airport Industrial Area Specific Plan. Bureau of Land Management, NextEra Energy Resources LLC – McCoy Solar Energy Project EIS and Record of Decision, Riverside County, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist supporting ESA’s preparation of Plan Amendment, EIS, and Record of Decision under FLPMA and NEPA for the BLM for a 750 MW photovoltaic (PV) solar power plant and related infrastructure within an approximately 7,700 acre right-of-way on BLM-administered public land near Blythe, California. When the Record of Decision was signed in March 2013, the MSEP became the second largest solar project ever approved on BLM land. Key biological issues included the presence of burrowing owl, desert tortoise, wildlife movement, and rare plants. Metropolitan Transportation Commission 2030 Plan EIR, San Francisco Bay Area, CA. Lead Biologist and Technical Lead. Brian guided the biological resources portion of an EIR for the Metropolitan Transportation Commission's Transportation 2030 Plan that analyzed the project's impacts on energy, noise, geology and seismicity, water resources, and biological resources. His section outlined impacts the transportation plan will have on Bay Area biological resources. This plan, which encompasses all transportation investments in the Bay Area Region, includes regional project and program priorities as well as local transportation projects to the year 2030. Monterey Highway Soccer Park Project EIR, San Jose, CA. Senior Project Biologist. Brian acted as the senior project biologist for a project-level EIR for the Monterey Highway Soccer Park for the City of San Jose's Parks, Recreation and Neighborhood Services Department (PRNS). Of chief concern were the presence of wetlands and local California tiger salamanders in the area. His regional analysis of salamander populations concluded the species absence on the site, and the USFWS subsequently concurred with his findings. Mount Diablo State Park Habitat Conservation Plan, Clayton, CA. Project Manager and Technical Lead. As project manager, Brian was responsible for all aspects of preparing a Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) for Mount Diablo State Park. The document supported long-term construction, rehabilitation, operations/maintenance, and habitat restoration projects covering the entire 20,000-acre park over a 20-year span. The draft HCP was completed but not put into action by the USFWS or State Parks, as the stated approach greatly diminished effects to rare plant and wildlife. However, the HCP provided the foundation for the subsequent management of sensitive resources. Commented [BTP1]: Note that after the HCP was completed, State Parks opted not to finalize this HCP; so use this qual sparingly. Nacimiento Water Project Design-Phase Environmental Services. San Luis Obispo County, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian is the principal wildlife investigator for the Nacimiento Water Project raw water pipeline alignment, which traverses northern San Luis Obispo County. He was senior author of the project Biological Assessment and negotiated permit conditions with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Brian monitored bald eagle nesting along the Nacimiento River and led protocol-level surveys for fairy shrimp (under his 10(a) Recovery Permit), arroyo toad, and CRLF. Brian is acting as a project liaison, working directly with the USFWS, Ventura County through the permitting process. Napa River Restoration, Rutherford Reach 8 Large Mammal Surveys, Rutherford, CA. Technical Specialist. In support of the Napa River Restoration Project, Brian provided support services to ensure that the local bobcat population was not affected by construction. He monitored bobcat movements using eight separate camera stations and coordinated findings closely with the California Department of Fish and Game. Upon establishing that cats were not denning in the project area, Brian continued to monitor the site to ensure that large earthmoving did not affect the bobcat population. Ostrom Road Landfill Fairy Shrimp Management Plan, Yuba County, CA. Project Manager and Technical Lead. Brian conducted vernal pool fairy shrimp surveys at the Ostrom Road Landfill in Yuba County. His surveys were used to determine grazing patterns of local fairy shrimp populations. Brian used the findings to develop a grazing and management plan for the 200-acre site which contained roughly 10-acres of vernal pool habitat. Norcal Master Contract Ostrom Road Landfill, Yuba County, CA. Project Manager and Senior Biologist. Brian acted as project manager and technical lead for fairy shrimp surveys at the Ostrom Road landfill, which wanted to increase operating capacity from 335 tons per day to a proposed 975 tons per day. To accomplish this goal, the landfill would increase hours of operation to 24 hours a day on the 200-acre site, 10-acres of which were vernal pool habitat. Brian was Senior Author of the management plan for in-perpetuity conservation easement over the site.

Pappas Radio Tower CEQA Documentation. Sonoma, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was lead biologist for an EIR that examined potential impacts related to a cluster of 600+ foot tall radio towers that were proposed in the Napa/ Sonoma marshlands. Principal issues he addressed included impacts to salt marsh dependent species (e.g., salt marsh wandering shrew, salt marsh harvest mouse, and California clapper rail), and potential bird strike/collision hazards posed by towers and their associated guy wires. Presidential Substation EIR, Thousand Oaks, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the technical lead for biological resources on a complex EIR analysis that included a new substation and numerous powerline alignments that were proposed within sensitive coastal sage scrub habitat. Multiple years of surveys were performed for the endangered Coastal California gnatcatcher and Lyon’s pentachaeta, with the former species present in the project area. The EIR was certified in March 2013. Rio Mesa Area Plan EIR, Rio Mesa, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was primary author of the biological resources section of the combined EIR/EIS for the proposed 3,500-acre mixed-use development. His analysis focused on potential impacts to special status wildlife, including California tiger salamander, listed fairy shrimp species, and wetlands located just north of Fresno, California. Roblar Road Quarry, Roblar Road-New Alternative, Sonoma County, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian was the senior contributor to the Biological Resources section of the Roblar Road Quarry Project and also performed focused surveys for California tiger salamander, California red-legged frog, and American badger. The project considered the expansion of an existing quarry and creation of a new access road through rural farmland in Sonoma County. The EIR for this project was certified in 2010. San Francisco Littoral Cell Regional Sediment Management Plan, San Francisco and San Mateo Counties, CA. Senior Biologist. This assessment, performed for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, considered the potential coastal shoreline management options to counter climate change effects over a 50 year period. The assessment considered the effects of various management methods, including managed retreat, shoreline armoring, and sand importation, among others, on sensitive and common biological resources that inhabit the coast from San Francisco to Pacifica. San Francisco Marina Renovation Program EIR, San Francisco, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian prepared a biological constraints analysis that considered potential impacts to pinnipeds, salmonids and pacific herring associated with upgrades and new construction for harbor offices, recreation uses, and public access improvements to existing marina facilities. The San Francisco Marina is a major municipal recreation and boating center located between the Presidio to the west and Fort Mason Center to the east along the City's Northern Waterfront. The biological analysis he authored addressed local fish species that could be affected by waterside improvements, requiring removal and repositioning of existing breakwater and dredging operations. San Francisco Littoral Cell Coastal Regional Sediment Management Plan (CRSMP), San Francisco, CA. Senior Biologist. A CRSMP is a comprehensive guidance and policy document that discusses how regional sediment management can be implemented in an expeditious, cost-effective, and resource-protective manner. Brian led the biological analysis for the CRSMP for a segment of the Golden Gate Littoral Cell along the San Francisco and San Mateo County Pacific coastline. San Francisco International Airport (SFO) Master Plan NEPA documentation. Brian prepared portions of the biological resources and hydrology analyses in support of the new International Terminal, boarding areas and aircraft gates, parking garage, ground transportation center and automated people mover, roadway and circulation system improvements, ALP approval, potential application for PFC funding, and other airport and commercial improvements. Santa Clara County On-call Biological Services, Santa Clara County, CA. Project Manager. Since 2001, Brian has been the project manager and senior technical lead for the County of Santa Clara in the review and analysis of biological resource issues on the Stanford University Campus. In this capacity, he regularly directs and performs focused biological surveys at Stanford to ensure compliance with County conditions. Tasks that have been conducted under this project include focused surveys for the California tiger salamander, CRLF, breeding birds, special status plants, and focused arboreal assessments, among many others. Santa Clara Valley Water District, Calabazas Creek California Red-legged Frog Habitat Assessment, Santa Clara County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the lead biologist tasked with examining the suitability of Calabazas Creek to support California red-legged frogs. This field review was performed in support of a flood protection project that included elements that were within potentially suitable red-legged frog habitat. The results of the habitat assessment were incorporated into the project EIR. SFPUC Sunol Dam and Niles Dam Removal Project, Alameda, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the senior technical lead for wildlife surveys and prepared the Biological Assessment submitted to the USFWS. The issues he addressed included a great blue heron nesting rookery located above Sunol Dam, and potential habitat for the Alameda whipsnake and CRLF. Overall, the goals of the dam removal were to provide fish passage and to address public safety and liability issues associated with the dam. Sonoma County Water Agency (SCWA) On-Call Environmental Compliance Services, Sonoma, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian performed detailed surveys of more than 20-miles of proposed pipeline routes and facilities spread throughout urban and rural portions of the City of Sonoma. In support of the CEQA analysis, he performed surveys to evaluate the potential presence of steelhead trout, CRLF and California freshwater shrimp in Sonoma Creek and major tributary streams. This information was summarized into an Opportunities and Constraints Analysis, which formed the basis for the Biological Resources analysis in the project EIR. Sonoma County Water Agency Photovoltaic Project, Sonoma County, CA. Senior Biologist. Brian was the senior project biologist for this project which considered installation of approximately 4-acres of solar panels with the goal of producing 1.0 megawatts of electrical energy to offset energy consumption resulting from operations of the Sonoma Valley County Sanitation District facilities. The sanitation district opted to install over 7,000-square-feet of solar panels which would double as covered parking for district employees at local headquarters. South Cordelia Reservoir Resource Protection and Management Plan, Fairfield, CA. Senior Biologist. As Senior Project Biologist, Brian assisted in the development of a Resource Protection and Management Plan for the South Cordelia Zone 7 Water Reservoir Project. The project required the construction of a five million gallon water tank, water transmission and overflow pipelines,

pump station, buried valve vault adjacent to the Reservoir on its southeast edge, and construction of an access drive to an existing PG&E access road. Brian’s plan added species to an existing MND including CRLF, callippe silverspot butterfly, and burrowing owl. Species protection measures were developed through informal consultation with both USFWS and CDFW. Stanford Carnegie Foundation Monitoring, Santa Clara County, CA. Project Manager and Senior Project Biologist. Brian participated in all aspects of biological and archaeological monitoring related to implementation of the Carnegie Foundation Use Permit at Stanford University. He worked closely with Santa Clara County, Stanford University and the Carnegie Foundation to prepare a Conservation Easement Enhancement Plan to protect and restore habitat for the California tiger salamander over a five year period. Prior to construction, Brian worked on implementing a California tiger salamander recovery plan and monitored salamander activity on the work site. Stanford Trail Alignment Supplemental EIR (SEIR), Santa Clara County, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian was involved in all stages of the initial Stanford Trails alignment review, wildlife surveys, and the biological resource analysis for the Stanford Trails SEIR. Key issues he analyzed were the presence of CRLF in close proximity to two trail alignments and the local presence of California tiger salamanders in upland habitat. All analyses were done as a condition pursuant to General Use Permit guidelines that the University contributes a segment of the County’s S-1 trail. Toscana Subdivision EIR, Sonoma County, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian was the senior technical lead on a complex EIR for a subdivision project located in the Santa Rosa Plain. The project site presented a number of technical challenges, including the presence of California tiger salamanders and rare plants both locally and on the site. Key to the analysis were considerations of maintaining habitat continuity with existing salamander populations and addressing potential hazards to moving animals from traffic. Windsor Creek Drainage Improvements IS/MND, Windsor, CA. Lead Biologist. Brian assisted the Town of Windsor in the determination of preferred locations for future bypass conduits along Windsor Creek. In his attempt to mitigate cumulative drainage impacts from new urban development in the town, he conducted a focused biological analysis of five alternative alignments to identify environmental factors that would assist in the conduits’ placement. Brian prepared portions of an IS/MND for the project, and assisted in obtaining permits from the Corps, the RWQCB, and the CDFW. Yosemite Institute Crane Flat Educational Facility EIS, Yosemite National Park, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. Brian was the senior wildlife biologist for the Crane Flat Redevelopment Program; a Yosemite National Park partner. He was responsible for preparing the biological resources portion of an EIS, which was required to build on an existing Civilian Conservation Corps site with unique historic significance. Key issues included in Brian’s analyses were potential impacts to great gray owl and California spotted owl breeding and foraging areas. Zone 7 Altamont Creek/Arroyo Las Positas Channel Restoration, Livermore, CA. Project Manager and Senior Biologist. Brian was responsible for all aspects of natural resource permit compliance during and following construction of the Altamont Creek/Arroyo Las Positas Channel Restoration Project. He oversaw the training program for construction personnel and led the compliance monitoring effort during construction. Following in-stream sediment removal activities, he monitored CRLF populations, stream revegetation, and stream sedimentation rates as part of a five-year mitigation monitoring program. Using his expertise in designing and implementing riparian revegetation strategies, Brian led a successful effort to revive the initial failed restoration attempt at this site. Zone 7 Chain of Lakes Biological Support, Livermore, CA. Senior Wildlife Biologist. In 2012, Brian managed ESA’s biological resources team in support of the Chain of Lakes water storage and infiltration project, which stabilized the lake side slopes and removed silt to promote water infiltration. He led U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) protocol-level surveys for CRLF in 2012 and facilitated permitting with the USFWS. He worked closely with field biologists during preconstruction wildlife surveys and monitoring. The project was permitted and successfully completed in fall 2012. Zone 7 Flood Control Permitting and On-call Services 2001- 2017, Livermore, CA. Project Manager. Over a 16-year contracting period, Brian has been responsible for managing and directing a variety of on-call services related to CEQA compliance, focused biological and botanical surveys, stream restoration, permitting assistance with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and coordination with regulatory agencies to ensure compliance with environmental permits. He has performed focused surveys and provided permitting support for more than 100 individual projects located throughout the Livermore-Amador Valley. Zone 7 Stanley Pilot Project, Livermore, CA. Project Manager and Senior Biologist. As key components of this stream enhancement and restoration project, Brian managed a team that prepared a wetland delineation, Biological Assessment for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and CEQA analyses for noise and biological resource issue topics. The assessment incorporated numerous years of California red-legged frog surveys that ESA performed at this location. The project is scheduled for construction in 2013. SELECTED PUBLICATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS Pittman, B. 2017. Stream-breeding Amphibians of The Geysers Region of Sonoma and Lake Counties: a Summary of 19 years of Aquatic Monitoring. Presentation at the California/Nevada Amphibian Populations Task Force 2017 meeting. Pittman, B. 2010. California Tiger Salamander Larval Growth Observations. Presentation at the 2010 Wildlife Society Western Section Conference. Pittman, B. 2005. Observations of Upland Habitat Use by California Tiger Salamanders Based on Burrow Excavation. Transactions of the Western Section of the Wildlife Society 41:26-30; 2005. Pittman, B.T. 1996. A Survey of Inbenthic Macrofauna at a South San Francisco Bay Salt Marsh. Master's thesis, San Jose State University.

Matt has more than 25 years of experience in archaeology and has a wide EDUCATION range of experience in prehistoric and historical archaeology in the United Ph.D., Anthropology States and abroad, with more than 15 years managing large and complex (Archaeology projects in both the private and public sectors. Matt is a specialist in maritime Program), University of California, Berkeley archaeology, and was a Senior Maritime Archeologist with the National Park Service’s Submerged Resources Center from 1993-2011. He has M.A., Anthropology participated in or directed more than 50 archaeology projects for state, (Archaeology Program), University federal and international agencies both on land and underwater since 1993. of California, Berkeley Matt was an elected member of the Advisory Council on Underwater Archeology from 2002-2010 and he served as Council Chair from 2008-2010. M.A., Nautical Archaeology and He has written numerous articles, book chapters, and monographs, and has Maritime History, East edited several books. Matt has been a member of the Register of Carolina University Professional Archaeologists since 2005. At ESA, Matt serves as a program B.A., Anthropology manager for prehistoric, historical, and maritime archaeological technical (Archaeology studies. Matt has conducted numerous technical studies and impact Emphasis), University assessments for compliance with federal and state laws including NHPA of California, Santa Barbara Section 106 and CEQA. CERTIFICATIONS/ REGISTRATION Forest City Developers, Pier 70 Special Use District Development Register of Professional Project, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Senior Archaeologist. Archaeologists Under a subcontract to Turnstone Consulting, ESA prepared an 24-Hour Hazardous Archaeological Research Design and Treatment Plan (ARDTP) for the Pier Waste Operations and 70 Development Project in San Francisco, California. Matt was responsible Emergency Response, for preparing the ARDTP for the San Francisco Planning Department, which 2012 included a detailed archaeological sensitivity assessment and treatment plan Instructor, Nautical for the Pier 70 redevelopment. Archaeology Society (NAS), 2002 Golden State Warriors Arena, LLC, Event Center & Mixed-Use Development at Mission Bay Blocks 29-32 SEIR (Golden State Warriors Instructor, National Association of Arena), San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist. ESA prepared an Underwater Instructors archaeological testing program for the Golden State Warriors Event Center at (NAUI), 2002 Mission Bay Blocks 29-32 in San Francisco’s Mission Bay waterfront. Matt PROFESSIONAL was responsible for preparing the Archaeological Testing Plan and is AFFILIATIONS managing and coordinating implementation of the testing program. Society for Historical Tishman-Speyer, Transbay Block One/160 Folsom Street Project, San Archaeology (Board of Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Senior Archaeologist. ESA prepared Directors, 2008-2010) an Archaeological Testing Program for the Transbay Block One/160 Folsom Advisory Council on Street Project. Matt is responsible was responsible for preparing the Underwater Archaeology (2002- Archaeological Testing Plan and managing and coordinating implementation 2010; Chair, 2008- of the testing and monitoring program, which included the potential for 2010) maritime archaeological resources within the former San Francisco Bay. Society for California Boston Properties, 101 First Street (Salesforce Tower) Project, San Archaeology Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Senior Archaeologist. ESA prepared an archaeological monitoring program for the Salesforce Tower Project located in San Francisco, California. Matt was responsible for preparing the

Archaeological Monitoring Plan, coordinated preparation of an archaeological sensitivity training video for construction workers participating in the project, and coordinated implementation of the monitoring program during mass excavation of the Salesforce Tower site. Treasure Island Community Development, LLC, Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island Archaeological Mitigation Project, San Francisco, CA. Project Manager and Senior Archaeologist. ESA prepared an Archaeological Testing Program, as well as an Archaeological Monitoring Program, for the Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island Major Phase I – Subphase I Development Project. Matt was responsible for supervising preparation and implementation of the Archaeological Testing Plan, the testing results report, an Archaeological Monitoring Plan, and managing and coordinating implementation of the on-going monitoring program. California High Speed Rail Authority, California High Speed Rail Merced to Fresno Construction Package 1, Central Valley, CA. Senior Archaeologist and Project Manager. As a subconsultant to the Tutor Perini Zachary Parsons (TPZP) Joint Venture, ESA is providing environmental compliance support services for the Merced to Fresno Construction Package 1 (CP1) segment of the California High Speed Rail project. Tasks included conducting pre-construction surveys for cultural resources, compliance monitoring during construction, and compliance tracking and reporting. Approximately 29 miles in length, CP1 includes cultural resources such as the historic Chinatown in downtown Fresno. Matt is managing ESA’s overall cultural resources role in the project, including coordinating and managing archaeological surveys and monitoring of various preconstruction activities between Madera and Fresno. Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development, 1415 Scott Street Archaeological Testing Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist. ESA prepared an archaeological testing program for the 1415 Scott Street Development Project in San Francisco, California under an on- call contract for MOHCD. Matt was responsible for preparing the Archaeologial Testing Plan. Oyster Development Corporation, 1634-1690 Pine Street Archaeological Testing Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist and Project Manager. ESA prepared an archaeological testing program for the 1634- 1690 Pine Street Development Project in San Francisco, California. Matt was responsible for preparing the Archaeologial Testing Plan and for implementing archaeological testing and monitoring on the project site. Lincoln Properties Group, 350 Bush Street Archaeological Testing Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist and Project Manager. ESA conducted an archaeological testing program for the 350 Bush Street Development Project in San Francisco, California. Matt was responsible for implementing archaeological testing and monitoring on the project site. San Francisco Department of Public Health, Southeast Health Center Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist and Project Manager. Under a subcontract to Weiss Associates, ESA prepared an Archaeological Testing Program for the Southeast Health Center in San Francisco. Matt was responsible for preparing the Archaeological Testing Plan and managing and coordinating implementation of the testing program. Tishman-Speyer, Tranbay Block One/160 Folsom Street Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist and Project Manager. ESA is preparing an Archaeological Testing Program for the Tranbay Block One/160 Folsom Street Project. Matt is responsible for preparing the Archaeological Testing Plan and managing and coordinating implementation of the testing and monitoring program. Far Western Anthropological Group, Alice Griffith Redevelopment Project, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist. Matt assisted in preparing an archaeological testing plan for the Redevelopment project in San Francisco, California. Pioneer Law Group, LLP, Sacramento Entertainment and Sports Center & Related Development, Sacramento, CA. Senior Archaeologist. Matt helped produce an archaeological sensitivity training video for construction workers participating in construction the new Sacramento Kings arena in downtown Sacramento, California. SFPUC, Westside Recycled Water Project EIR, San Francisco, CA. Senior Archaeologist. Matt is providing archaeological analysis for the San Francisco Westside Recycled Water Project, a part of the San Francisco Water Supply Improvement Program. The proposed project will include recycled water treatment, storage, and distribution facilities for users located on the west side of San Francisco. Water will be treated to a tertiary level at the Oceanside Recycled Water Treatment Facility, and a network of pipelines will distribute the recycled water to a series of reservoirs and pump stations, including the Golden Gate Park Reservoir & Pump Station, the Booster Pump Station at Golden Gate Park, and the Lincoln Park Reservoir & Pump Station located near Lincoln Park Golf Course. Nextera Energy Resources, LLC Genesis Phase II Ethnography Study, Palm Springs, CA. Senior Archaeologist. ESA is conducting an intensive ethnographic study of the I-10 Solar Energy corridor that runs from Palm Springs, CA to Arizona for the Palm Springs BLM. Work involves interviews with tribal elders, compilation of past ethnographic studies including archived film and sound recordings housed at institutions in California, Arizona, Nevada and Washington, D.C. ESA is also assisting tribes to develop in- house ethnography programs, create learning tools for future generations including interactive programs, as well as complete a film documentary. Matt helped produce an ethnographic dictionary for one of the Native American tribes involved in the project.

Environmental Protection Agency, Oakland Estuary Enhancement Project, Section 106 Compliance, Oakland, CA. Maritime Archaeologist, Garcia and Associates. As part of a multi-agency clean-up effort of the Oakland Estuary, Matt worked as a subconsultant to Sonoma State University’s Anthropological Studies Center to identify and evaluate submerged cultural resources within the Oakland Estuary as part of Section 106 compliance. Pacific Gas & Electric, Maritime Archaeology Data Request Responses for PG&E’s Embarcadero-Potrero 230kV Transmission Project Proponent’s Environmental Assessment (PEA), San Francisco, CA. Maritime Archaeologist, Garcia and Associates. Matt worked as subconsultant to CH2M Hill to address data requests about mitigating the underwater portion of the project’s impacts to submerged cultural resource. Analyzed geophysical data, identified potential cultural resources, and recommended mitigation measures.

Chris Sanchez has more than 24 years of experience managing, conducting EDUCATION and monitoring air quality, greenhouse gas, noise and energy investigations B.S., Environmental and surveys for urban development, transportation, and infrastructure Science, University of projects. He has prepared greenhouse gas emission inventories for nine California, Berkeley years since the passing of Assembly Bill 32. His professional training and U.C. Berkeley experience have augmented an academic background in air quality, physics, Extension; Toxic Air chemistry, meteorology, and energy. Chris has a bachelor’s degree from Contaminants U.C. Berkeley in Environmental Science with additional studies from U.C.B. 24 YEARS in toxic air contaminants. He is trained and proficient in the CalEEMod air EXPERIENCE quality emissions model as well as in air dispersion modeling using the AERMOD dispersion model. He is proficient in use of the traffic noise model of the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and the Roadway Construction Noise Model. He has been involved in dozens of major projects including major commercial airport master plans, divestiture of the State of California’s power plants, mining projects and reclamation plans, rail transit extension projects and arena construction projects.

The 34th Americas Cup and James R. Herman Cruise Terminal and Northeast Wharf Plaza Environmental Impact Report, Environmental Assessment (NEPA) and General Conformity Determination, San Francisco, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared fast-track CEQA and NEPA documentation as well as a federal General Conformity Determination and technical and logistical support for complex multi-agency regulatory compliance. For the environmental impact report, relative to CEQA, an emissions inventory was assembled for a variety of unique sources including race support vessels, race-sponsored spectator vessels, spectator vessels, helicopter operations and cruise ship hoteling emissions resulting from the temporary decommissioning of shore side power. For the NEPA documentation, a greenhouse gas emission inventory was developed to account for AC34 impacts to existing federal GHG inventories. The noise analysis for both the CEQA and NEPA documentation examined noise impacts associates with construction, generators supplying temporary power, amplified music at event venues, helicopter noise, fireworks and noise from increased traffic volumes. A General Conformity Determination was conducted to verify compliance with the 1993 Amendments to the Clean Air Act and the State Implementation Plan, which included dispersion modeling to demonstrate that federal air quality standards would not be exceeded. Port of San Francisco, Mission Bay Ferry Landing Project, San Francisco, CA. Air Quality Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris assessed the air quality greenhouse gas and noise impacts associated with the Port of San Francisco’s construction of a new passenger ferry terminal in the Mission Bay area of the City of San Francisco waterfront. The new Mission Bay Ferry Terminal will serve ferry passengers traveling to and from a wide range of developments at Mission Bay and Pier 70, including the new

Golden State Warriors Arena. Emissions from ferries, dredging and offset passenger vehicles were estimated and a net decrease in GHG emissions was demonstrated. As much of the construction would require in-water work for dredging and installation of piles for the pier and floats, specialty equipment would be required such as a clamshell dredge, barge-mounted pile drivers and drill rigs and cranes, tugs and scows. Where specialty equipment pieces are used, emission factors from the California Air Resources Board’s 2011 Off-Road Equipment Model (OFFROAD2011) emission rate program CARB’s Commercial Harbor Craft Emissions Inventory and CARB's Barge and Dredge Emission Inventory were used to quantify emissions. Golden Gate Bridge District ADA Ferry Terminal Improvements Environmental Assessment, San Francisco and Sausalito, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. This project includes ferry terminal improvements required to bring passenger loading and disembarking into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and utilities rehabilitation at the three terminals, as well as the option for companion projects that include a new layover berth at San Francisco and a new maintenance slip at Larkspur. Chris prepared air quality, greenhouse gas and noise analysis for NEPA documentation. Noise impacts included assessment of pile driving noise and vibration, as well as relocation of ferry idling areas. City of San Francisco, Event Center and Mixed-Use Development 2015 Draft Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality and Noise Analyst. Prepared fast-track CEQA documentation and logistical support for complex multi-agency regulatory compliance for a proposed arena, office and retail development in the Mission Bay area of San Francisco. For the noise analysis, construction-related noise levels from rapid impact compaction were assessed for impacts on people as were vibration impacts. Air quality emissions and health risks from construction and operation were reported and analyzed using the latest methodologies of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District and the City of San Francisco Environmental Planning Department. Responses to voluminous comments were prepared as a result of vigorous organized opposition to the project. City of City of Sunnyvale, Landbank Central Sunnyvale Campus Environmental Impact Report. Noise Analyst. Prepared noise impact analysis for a proposed campus-style office/R&D facility located in Central Sunnyvale. The development would likely become the headquarters for a technology firm. City of San Francisco, Moscone Center Expansion Initial Study. Air Quality Analyst. The project involves reorganization of the lower-level exhibition spaces, as well as new above-ground construction along Howard Street. Chris prepared the air quality analysis estimating construction-related and operational using CalEEMod Land Use Emissions Model and custom calculations to account for increased truck and forklift emissions from the increased in annual events at the exhibition halls. Brisbane Soils Processing Facility Technical Studies, Brisbane CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse gas and noise technical Studies. Chris prepared Technical studies to inform an initial Study and Negative Declaration for a proposed permit extension for an existing soils processing facility in the Brisbane Baylands. The Project would result in existing soils processing operations to continue for a 5-year period, including screening, crushing, grinding and mixing the materials to create premium topsoils, sands, and aggregate mixes made from recycled materials. Additionally, a new windrow composting process was proposed for up to 12,500 cubic yards of compost materials to be processed or stored onsite at any given time. Analysis considered emissions from truck trips, fugitive emissions of organic gasses from composting and additional diesel equipment proposed to be put in operation. A detailed noise survey was conducted and impacts and mitigation measures identified. Contra Costa Water District, Los Vaqueros Reservoir Phase 2 Expansion, Draft Supplemental EIR/EIS, Contra Costa County, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris conducted the air quality, GHG and noise analysis for the proposed expansion of Los Vaqueros reservoir. The Phase 2 Expansion project would expand Los Vaqueros Reservoir from the existing 160 thousand acre feet (TAF) to a proposed 275 TAF storage capacity as well as upgrade existing conveyance facilities, and construct new conveyance facilities. Analysis included an estimate of construction-related emissions from excavation and off-haul of materials a, a comparison of emissions with project revisions and an estimated change in GHG emissions associated with energy demand from conveyance. Construction noise impacts and operational noise impacts of new facilities were also estimated. City of Alameda, Alameda Marina EIR. Alameda CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris conducted the air quality, GHG and noise analysis for the proposed redevelopment of the 44-acre Marina. The project included up to 153,172 sf of commercial space, up to 760 residential units, as well as park areas, paths, trails, and shoreline improvements. Impacts from both in-water and land based construction work were assessed including pile driving impacts on local noise receptors. Emissions were calculated for mobile sources and energy-related greenhouse gases. Santa Clara County, Stanford University, General Use Permit Update EIR. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas, Noise and Energy Analyst. The 2018 General Use Permit would authorize nearly 2.3 million net square feet of academic and academic support facilities and over 3,000 net new housing units/beds on its lands in unincorporated Santa Clara County, anticipated to take place between 2018 through 2035. Applicant sponsored environmental studies were peer reviewed and incorporated into the EIR as applicable. The analysis included future year greenhouse gas emissions in 2030 and considered the University’s progress toward meeting the GHG reduction targets of the State of California’s recently updates Climate Change Scoping Plan. Other commitments considered include conversion to electric buses in its Marguerite fleet by 2035, and the use of Tier 4 construction equipment to reduce air quality and greenhouse gas emissions. Kilroy Realty, New Flower Mart Project CPE, San Francisco, CA. Noise Analyst and Senior Review of Air Quality. Chris prepared the noise analysis for the Community Plan Evaluation for this project. The proposed project would demolish all of the existing buildings on the project site, including the existing wholesale flower market and accessory space, as well as the surface parking lot and additional vacant buildings. The project, one of the largest development sites in Central SoMa, would include three new buildings (the Market Hall Building, the Blocks Building, and the Gateway Building) containing approximately 2,032,800 square feet of office space, 204,200 square feet of retail space, and a new wholesale flower market

consisting of 115,000 square feet of vendor space plus adjacent at-grade and below-grade loading areas. The noise analysis examined the redistribution of substantial truck trvel across the site and potentially impact adjacent live/work units. City of Emeryville Noise Ordinance Update, Emeryville, CA. Noise Analyst. Since the adoption of the City of Emeryville’s Noise Ordinance in 2003, much of the City’s industrial areas have been converted to commercial and residential uses. Over the last 14 years, residences built near industrial and commercial facilities have increased by 54 percent, which resulted in a noticeable increase in the number of noise complaints submitted to the City Police Department. Since the existing Noise Ordinance did not have objective, quantitative noise criteria, enforcement personnel did not have the ability to determine whether noise exposure levels are in violation of the current qualitative standards of the City’s Noise Ordinance. ESA conducted a city-wide noise monitoring effort establishing ambient noise levels by zoning district. Chris presided over a community meeting to present RSA’s work plan and solicit public comment. Results and a proposed new noise ordinance with quantitative standards was presented to the Planning Commission. Action by the City Council is still pending. City of Alameda, Encinal Terminals EIR, Alameda County, CA. QA/QC review of Noise Analysis. ESA prepared an Initial Study and Focused Environmental Impact Report for redevelopment of an abandoned 32-acre wharf and shipping terminal site on the Oakland Estuary. When completed, the project will provide a mixed-use development to include approximately 600 new housing units, a marina with up to 160 boat slips and a harbormaster’s office, between 30,000 and 50,000 square feet of commercial/office and restaurant uses, and over three acres of waterfront- related public open space and parks. Issues of concern for the project include traffic, aesthetics, and land use. BART to Livermore Environmental Analysis, San Francisco Bay Area, CA. Noise and Vibration Analyst. Chris prepared the noise and vibration impact analysis for this major BART expansion project, which builds upon the BART to Livermore Extension Program EIR. Analysis involved applying FTA methodology using train frequencies, length of cars reference sound exposure levels and vibration curves to predict noise and vibration impacts at existing and future receptors located along the extension alignment. Analysis included not only standard BART trains but also diesel multiple units as an alternative as well as an express Bus alternative adding platforms along I-580. Noise from switching gear, horns, parking facilities, generators, and transformers were also assessed. Additionally, highway widening for the required right-of-way necessitated an evaluation of potential noise impacts to moving the highway closer to existing receptors. City of Richmond, Richmond South Shoreline Specific Plan EIR. Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas Analyst. Chris prepared to the air quality and greenhouse gas impact analysis for the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the Richmond South Shoreline Specific Plan. Chris estimated construction and operational emissions associated with a 20-year Specific Plan. The specific plan will provide a long-term blueprint for guiding improvements in an approximately 220-acre site in the City’s Southern Gateway Change Area. Chris worked with the City and its counsel to develop an approach that emphasized the Plan beneficial location in a priority development area as minimizing the air quality and GHG impacts compared to such development occurring in more peripheral areas of the Bay Area. San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Biosolids Digester Facilities Project EIR. Senior Noise Review. Chris provided senior review of the noise impact analysis for the EIR for construction of new solids processing, energy recovery and odor control facilities at San Francisco’s Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant in south east San Francisco. Multi-year construction noise and operational noise sources including new facilities to upgrade the digestion, solids treatment, and odor handling processes as well as new digester gas treatment and energy recovery facilities. Fresno County, Tranquillity Solar Generating Facility Environmental Impact Report, Fresno, CA. Senior Air Quality Analyst. ESA prepared the environmental impact report (EIR) for the Tranquility Solar Generating Facility, a 400 MW PV facility occupying a 3,572-acre site in Fresno County. This is the first and only successfully completed and approved EIR for a solar project in Fresno County. This project, which included the proposed construction of eight substations, a Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) switching station and 200 MW of battery storage, comprised eight individual PV projects proposed for construction on contiguous parcels. Each project was assigned a separate Conditional Use Permit (CUP) by the County and all eight were evaluated within the same EIR, which identified impacts and mitigation measures on a project-by-project basis. This allowed the Applicant, Recurrent Energy, flexibility in determining how and when each of the eight projects would be developed while utilizing the most efficient CEQA approach for schedule and budget. ESA worked closely with the County, the Applicant, and resource agencies to address concerns related to air emissions, biological resources, groundwater and water supply, aesthetics, and traffic. The project was approved in 2014. University of California at San Francisco Research Facility and Parking Garage Expansion at San Francisco General Hospital Draft Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. ESA is currently preparing an environmental impact report for a proposed UCSF research building on the campus of San Francisco General Hospital (SFGH). In support of its programs at the SFGH campus, and to meet UC seismic safety requirements, UCSF proposes to develop a 175,000 square foot research building on an existing surface parking lot. Because the proposed building would displace existing surface parking, the proposed project includes the expansion of the City-owned SFGH parking structure, a project which would be undertaken by the City. Chris prepared the assessment of air quality, greenhouse gas and noise impacts associated with construction and operation of the proposed facilities, with a separate analysis conducted for each element as both the research building and parking garage would be developed under the guidance of separate lead agencies. Oak Knoll Mixed Use Community Plan Project Supplemental Environmental Impact Report. Senior Air Quality and Noise Analyst. ESA is currently preparing an Environmental Impact Report for a proposed mixed use development of residential neighborhoods, commercial development, and open space and recreational facilities on approximately 165 acres of the former decommissioned Naval Medical Center Oakland property at Oak Knoll. The proposed development would locate residential land uses within close proximity of Interstate 580. Chris performed an analysis of potential noise impacts to sensitive land uses and identified mitigation measures to address noise exposure impacts. Assessment of air quality impacts included health risks to existing and proposed sensitive receptors from a proposed multi-phased construction schedule as well as addressing significant and

unavoidable impacts in light of the recent California Supreme Court decision In Sierra Club v. County of Fresno (Friant Ranch). Energize Eastside Power Transmission Project Draft Environmental Impact Statement. Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared technical analysis for a new 18 mile long transmission line for Puget Sound Electric on the eastside of its service area beginning in Bellevue and crossing through multiple local jurisdictions. Impacts were considered for multiple transmission options including overhead transmission lines, underground transmission lines, and underwater transmission lines as well as a host of alternatives to the project including installation and operation of natural gas fired peaker plants. Greenhouse gas emissions were estimated from construction and operation including life-cycle emissions from concrete to be used in transmission tower footings, and underground line encasement. Potential noise from peaker plant operations was also assessed. 1028 Market Street Noise and Vibration Technical Report, San Francisco Project manager. Chris prepared noise and vibration assessment for a proposed 13-story, 120-foot-tall residential building with ground-floor retail in San Francisco’s Civic Center neighborhood. The project, which would have 186 dwelling units would locate these uses on a major transit corridor with vehicle traffic, substantial bus traffic, operations of the City’s historic F-line streetcars at ground level and MUNI light rail and BART rail transit below ground. The analysis examined the potential for both noise and vibration to impact the proposed residential uses as well as the application of the recently adopted Section 90.1 of the San Francisco Administrative Code which protects existing places of entertainment from encroachment by residential or other sensitive land uses. 1500 Mission Street, San Francisco Air Quality and Noise Technical Studies. Air Quality and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared technical analyses for incorporation into an Initial Study for the proposed demolition of the two existing buildings on the project site and construction of two new towers—a 38-story, 380-foot-tall residential building (550 dwelling units) at the corner of Mission Street and South Van Ness Avenue, and an 18-story, 260-foot-tall office building on 11th Street between Market and Mission Streets. The 466,500-square-foot office building would be occupied by City of San Francisco offices, and would include a permit center for the Planning Department and Department of Building Inspection on the first two floors. Discovery Park Outdoor Concert Event Noise Assessment and Sound Control Plan Development. Project Manager. Chris has prepared an assessment of off-site noise impacts for concert events at Discovery Park in Sacramento County annually over the past four years. Long-term noise monitoring locations were established based on public complaints of concert noise. Monitoring was conducted during non-concert weekends and during concert events. Data was used to develop a Sound Control Plan that establishes a not-to-exceed noise limit at the sound board to maintain noise levels in the community consistent with standard requirements of the County Noise Ordinance. The Sound Control Plan also contains requirements regarding speaker and stage directions as well as time limits. The sound Plan was subsequently implemented for the following concert events and continues to evolve with input from continued sound monitoring from both ESA and promotors. Sunnydale-Velasco HOPE-SF Master Plan Combined Environmental Impact Report/Environmental Impact Statement, San Francisco, CA. Air Quality and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality and noise impact analysis for a combined Environmental Impact Report / Environmental Impact Statement for the San Francisco Department of City Planning (CEQA) and San Francisco Mayor’s Office (designated HUD NEPA lead agency), respectively. The project involves the redevelopment of an existing 785-unit San Francisco Housing Authority development with 1,700 units of residential space, as well as ancillary commercial and community facility uses. Noise analysis was conducted consistent with the requirements of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Air quality analysis included an evaluation of health risks resulting from diesel emissions associated with project construction. Three additional alternatives are analyzed at an equal level of detail. Los Altos Unified School District –Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration for Covington, Blach and Egan School classroom additions and enrollment changes. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris provided CEQA analysis for the proposed shifting of enrollment including peak assembly days at a centralized school location as well as for new classroom facilities. Noise impacts included increased noise from vehicle traffic, increases in the number of students in the outdoor play areas and stationary equipment. City of Eureka General Plan Update. Noise Analyst. Chris prepared baseline noise analysis study for the update to the City of Eureka’s General Plan Update. Long-term noise monitoring was performed at eight locations throughout the City limits to establish background noise levels. Monitoring locations were selected on the basis of gathering data across a spectrum of geographical locations. Also considered were monitoring previous monitoring locations capturing the extent of existing residential areas nearest the two airfields in the environs of the City. City of Seattle Comprehensive Plan Environmental Impact Statement. Prepared the air quality greenhouse gas and noise impact analyses for the City of Seattle’s Comprehensive Plan pursuant to the State of Washington’s State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA). The air quality and noise analysis focused on ensuring land use compatibility to avoid localized pollutant concentrations and noise adjacent to freeways and industrial areas. Available research on increased cancer risks was used to demonstrate the need for adequate buffer areas and noise modeling of freeways throughout the City was conducted to establish noise contours. Monterey Peninsula Water Supply Project Environmental Impact Report, Monterey, CA. Noise Analyst. Under contract with the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), Chris prepared the noise impact analysis of an environmental impact report for the California American Water Company (CalAm) Monterey Peninsula Water Supply Project (MPWSP) in accordance with CEQA. The primary project elements include a seawater intake system, a desalination plant, aquifer storage and recovery facilities, and over 20 miles of conveyance pipelines and associated infrastructure. Key issues include potential impacts from 24-hour drilling and operation of slant wells and aquifer storage and recovery wells open trench pipeline installation and construction and operation of a desalination plant. Much of the construction work was assumed to occur 24-hours a day and analysis of noise impacts to adjacent sensitive receptors had to account for this possibility. Seattle City Light Denny Substation –Discipline Studies and Draft Environmental Impact Statement. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise

Analyst. Prepared technical analysis pursuant to the State of Washington’s State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) for the construction and operation of a proposed new electrical substation, transmission lines and distribution network in the South Lake Union District of Seattle Washington. Discipline reports were prepared from which the DEIS was developed. Three dimensional noise modeling conducted for the substation site was used to assess noise impacts both in terms of compliance with the City’s Noise Ordinance standards as well as to estimate the increase in noise levels over existing conditions. Air pollution emissions were estimated using a variety of models and compare to thresholds for conformity with the federal Clean Air Act. Quality Greenhouse gas emissions were estimated from construction and operation including fugitive emissions of sulfur hexafluoride, a potent greenhouse gas. Mitigation measures were identified to maintain Seattle City Light policy of maintaining a net zero increases in operational greenhouse gas emissions. University of California at San Francisco Long Range Development Plan Draft Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. ESA prepared the environmental impact report for the 2014 Long Range Development Plan (LRDP) of UCSF. The LRDP will guide campus growth and development of the University over a 20+ planning horizon through the year 2035. UCSF is projecting to grow by approximately 2.4 million square feet over this time period, accommodating an additional 900 students and 11,000 employees. One key component of the LRDP is to address Senate Bill 1953, which mandates that all inpatient hospital facilities in the State of California meet more stringent seismic regulations by 2030. To meet this mandate, UCSF is proposing to build a new 308,000-square foot hospital addition at the Parnassus Heights campus site. In addition, the Mission Bay campus site is anticipated to grow substantially over the lifetime of the LRDP with multiple buildings proposed, including new research and office buildings as well as over 500 residential units. Chris prepared the assessment of air quality, greenhouse gas and noise impacts for each of the four campuses potentially affected by growth envisioned in the LRDP as well as cumulative regional contributions. This two-prong approach required of both project-level and overall plan-level criteria. City of Oakland, Broadway-West Grand Mixed-Use Project 2013 Environmental Impact Report Addendum. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and/ Noise Analyst. CEQA documentation for the proposed modification to the Broadway – West Grand Mixed-Use Project, originally approved by the City Planning Commission in 2004 and evaluated in the 2004 environmental impact report. The 2013 Modified Project would reduce the number of residential units and associated open space, increase the commercial floor area, reduce the number of parking spaces, reduce the project heights, and retain and renovate several existing buildings, including historic resources, previously approved for demolition. The environmental impact report Addendum analyzed 2013 Modified Project’s consistency with the effects of the original project and examined whether there are new, or more severe, significant effects. Updated analysis for Air Quality and Greenhouse Gases were included for informational purposes. Nut Tree Airport Master Plan Update Draft Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas Analyst. The Master Plan update for Nut Tree Airport establishes guidelines for improving the Airport’s facilities over the next 20 years. The Master Plan represents a comprehensive effort to identify the type and extent of facilities that are required to meet forecasted aviation demand and FAA standards for a public use airport designated as a general aviation airport. The Project includes three phases of development that would occur over the next 20 years. Air quality and GHG emission inventories were compiled using aviation forecasts for future years and construction-related emissions were also estimated. Contra Costa County, Phillips 66 Propane Recovery Project Environmental Impact Report, Rodeo, CA. Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas Analyst. ESA assisted Contra Costa County with the preparation of an environmental impact report for the Phillips 66 Propane Recovery Project. The project includes installation of facilities that will allow Phillips 66 to recover propane from the refining process. Air Quality and greenhouse gas impacts relative to CEQA were analyzed using a variety of sources including the proposed permit amendment provided by the applicant. The Draft Environmental Impact Report is expected to be released for public review in the second quarter of 2013. SFPUC North Shore to Channel Force Main Project MND, San Francisco, CA. Peer Reviewer of Air Quality Subconsultant. Chris provided peer review of air quality analysis for the MND for the implementation of the North Shore to Channel Force Main Project, which consists of construction of a new force main, installation of two underground vaults for flow control at the northern terminus of the new force main, and replacement/relocation of water mains. Once constructed, the proposed project would require periodic operations review and maintenance, similar to existing conditions, and would not generate new vehicle trips as part of the new maintenance. Therefore, this analysis looked at potential short-term effects of construction. San José/Santa Clara Water Pollution Control Plant Master Plan Program Environmental Impact Report, San José, CA. Air Quality Analysis. Chris used CalEEMod to estimate emissions associated with long- term development in a proposed Clean Tech Center. Master Plan would designate areas of the project site for light industrial, institute, and office/R&D, as well as retail uses and these future development scenarios would result in both operational and construction-related emissions that were quantified and assessed for impacts related to CEQA thresholds. Plan Bay Area Environmental Impact Report. Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the noise impact technical section for the Plan Bay Area Environmental Impact Report, a comprehensive regional plan in response to SB 375. In a joint effort led by the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) and Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) in partnership with the other regional and local government agencies and transportation partners, Plan Bay Area is an integrated land-use/transportation plan. Chris took traffic volume data for freeways, highways and arterial roadways throughout the Bay Area nine-county region provided by MTC and created customized software to determine the relative percentage of roadway in each county that exceeded the Caltrans Noise Abatement Criteria for the proposed Plan Bay Area and its alternatives. Noise impacts of the associated Sustainable Communities Strategy were also analyzed as this portion of the Plan promoted infill growth along transit corridors where ambient noise levels are frequently elevated and may be inappropriate for residential land uses. College of Marin Child Study Center Environmental Impact Report, Larkspur, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality, greenhouse gas and noise analysis for the environmental impact report for the proposed Child Study Center on the Larkspur Annex of the Kentfield campus of the College of Marin. The new

building was not addressed in the Program Environmental Impact Report completed by the Marin Community College District for the Bond Spending Implementation Plan for the Kentfield campus that was certified in November 2007.. College of Marin New Academic Center Environmental Impact Report, Larkspur, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality, greenhouse gas and noise analysis for a Focused Environmental Impact Report for a proposed New Academic Center on Kentfield campus of the College of Marin. The new building, as proposed with the retention of the Austin Science Center, was not addressed in the Program Environmental Impact Report completed by the Marin Community College District for the Bond Spending Implementation Plan for the Kentfield campus that was certified in November 2007. Broadway Plaza Long-Range Master Plan Environmental Impact Report, Walnut Creek, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality, greenhouse gas and noise analysis for environmental impact report for the Broadway Plaza Long Range Master Plan. Broadway Plaza is a nationally-recognized 800,000 square-foot (four- square block) open-air retail shopping center anchored by Neiman Marcus and Macy's stores in downtown Walnut Creek, California. The project, sponsored by Macerich Northwestern, considers a net 300,000 gross square feet (gsf) retail space expansion and relocates approximately 650 parking spaces and potentially another 100,000 gsf of new residential uses located over proposed underground parking. The project also proposes removal of existing underutilized areas; reconfigured parking structures and site access to improve vehicular and pedestrian circulation and safety; and interior and exterior architectural improvements to the rest of the shopping center. ESA prepared a Draft Environmental Impact Report and also prepared a supplemental report to consider modified alternatives for the proposed Macy's expansion. Alta Bates Summit Medical Center, Summit Campus Seismic Upgrade and Master Plan Environmental Impact Report, Oakland, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis, noise analysis and greenhouse gas impact analysis for seismic improvements and construction of a state of the art medical center in Oakland California. Greenhouse Gas analysis included development of project-level and post mitigation emission inventories as well as a project- specific Greenhouse Gas Reduction Plan identified as mitigation. Draft Environmental Impact Statement for Extension of F-Line Streetcar Service to Fort Mason, San Francisco CA. Noise Analyst. Chris prepared a noise and vibration impact analysis for the proposed extension of historic streetcars along San Francisco Municipal Railway’s F-line. Historic railcars of the F-line come from around the world and are from diverse manufacturers and eras of railcar development. A cutsom methodology was develped to adderss the unique circumstances of the project. Rather than rely on FTA data for baseline railcar noise, monitoring of the sound exposure level (SEL) of the F-line railcar fleet on both straitaways and on turns was conducted. A composite SEL for the fleet was developed and, as worst case analysis with consultation of the lead agency, a composite SEL of the noisiest 6 cars was calculated to predict noise impacts to receptors along the proposed alignment. March Inland Port General Aviation Facilities Improvement Environmental Impact Report, Riverside County, CA. Air Quality and Greenhouse Gas Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis, and greenhouse gas impact analysis for improvements and construction to develop a General Aviation facility on 11.5 acres of vacant property within the March Air Base in Riverside County. Emissions from aircraft, ground service equipment, fuel tanks, and motor vehicles were inventoried and assessed for impacts relative to thresholds of the SCAQMD. A local significance threshold analysis was also performed for construction impacts. Kaiser Center Office Project Environmental Impact Report, Oakland CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis, noise analysis and greenhouse gas impact analysis for 1.5 million square feet of office and commercial uses in two new high-rise towers. Pacific Union College Angwin Campus Development Environmental Impact Report, Napa County. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis, greenhouse gas analysis and noise impact analysis for the proposed campus expansion that included multiple “green building” techniques. Noise analysis included multiple long term noise monitoring station to assess noise from on campus co-generation facility and the adjacent airport. Air Quality impacts and analysis were prepared consistent with new guidance published by the Bay Area Air Quality Management District. Treasure Island Development Plan Environmental Impact Report, San Francisco, CA. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis and greenhouse gas impact analysis for 8,000 residential unit development on Treasure Island. Analysis included calculation of emissions from ferries, diesel bus trips, alternative- fueled shuttle buses, natural gas and grid electricity, credits for photovoltaic systems, water and wastewater treatment and conveyance, solid waste generation and the beneficial impact of carbon sequestration from trees. Air Quality impacts and analysis were prepared consistent with new guidance published by the Bay Area Air Quality Management District. Brisbane Baylands Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas and/ Noise Analyst. Chris is preparing the air quality, greenhouse gas and noise impact analysis for an environmental impact report for a specific plan to develop the Baylands Landfill site in Brisbane. The Plan addresses the 446-acre eastern portion of the 659-acre Baylands area. The Phase I area consists of 328 upland acres, located generally between the Bayshore Freeway (US 101) and the Union Pacific/Caltrain railroad corridor, and the 118-acres of the Brisbane Lagoon. The upland area is a former landfill site, most of which is currently undeveloped. Overall, the Specific Plan would allow for up to 5 million square feet of commercial retail, office, hotel, and light industrial development on 175-acres (not including 54-acres of roadway rights-of-way) and would preserve 99-acres of upland open space and parkland and 118-acres of open water within the Brisbane Lagoon. Home Depot Environmental Impact Report, San Francisco, CA. Air Quality and Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis and noise impact analysis for the proposed Home Depot warehouse at the location of the former Schlage Key factory in San Francisco, California. Noise impacts concerned not only motor vehicle trips but also daily operations of Home Depot including, sawing of lumber and vacuum trucks using noise data collected from existing store locations.

San Rafael Rock Quarry Amended Quarry Permit and Amended Reclamation Plan Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality/Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis and noise impact analysis for the proposed amended quarry permit and reclamation plan, that would result in this facility operating for an additional twelve to fifteen years. Issue areas included operational emissions of on-site excavation equipment on-site processing equipment and heavy duty-diesel truck and barge (tugboat) transfer of mined materials. Noise analysis included the impacts of rock blasting practices and impacts. Reclamation-related issues included impacts related to increased excavation depths and material relocation throughout the quarry site. Pilarcitos Rock Quarry Expansion Environmental Impact Report, San Mateo County. Air Quality/Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the criteria air pollutant analysis and noise impact analysis for the proposed long-term expansion that would result in this facility excavating an additional 256 acres of new areas. Issue areas included operational emissions of on-site excavation equipment on-site processing equipment and heavy duty-diesel truck transfer of mined materials. Noise analysis included the impacts of rock blasting practices and impacts. United Technologies Corporation Facility Site Closure Program Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality /Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality and noise impact analysis for the demolition, decommissioning and remediation of a former rocket motor manufacturing facility in Santa Clara County. Analysis included an evaluation of emissions generated by demolition, removal and transport of contaminated soils, pre-demolition decontamination with thermal convection systems and post-remediation site reclamation. This analysis also included one of the first published greenhouse gas inventory and analyses to be included in an environmental impact report and listed on the state of California database of greenhouse gas-related CEQA documents. Altamont Landfill and Resource Recovery Facility Class II Expansion. Air Quality / Noise Analyst. Chris authored air quality, noise and energy sections for Performed inventory of air pollutant emissions, including fugitive dust and criteria pollutant emissions from cell construction, daily equipment and truck operations, landfill gas emissions, and gas-powered turbine emissions. He assessed the potential for odor impacts. Chris also examined increased operational noise of the facility, noise generated by increased truck trips, and noise generated by construction of landfill cells. Catellus Mixed-Use Development Subsequent Environmental Impact Report, Alameda, CA. Air Quality / Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality and noise impact analysis for a Subsequent Environmental Impact Report (SEIR) that describes the environmental consequences of revising the previously-approved Catellus Mixed Use Development Master Plan (also referred to as the Alameda Landing Mixed Use Development) that was analyzed in the 2002 Catellus Mixed Use Development Environmental Impact Report and 2005 addendum to the environmental impact report. Key topics of in-depth analyses include impacts associated with traffic and circulation, traffic-related air quality and noise impacts, and biological resources impacts associated with in-water construction. Concord Redevelopment Plan Amendment Environmental Impact Report. Air Quality / Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality and noise impact analysis for an environmental impact report (EIR) to amend the Concord Redevelopment Plan, by adding additional areas of the city an existing redevelopment plan. (These areas have not yet been finally decided upon by the City.) ESA's sections of the EIR address air quality, biological resources, cultural resources, energy, geology and soils, hydrology and water quality, and noise. ESA will be able to make use of the work already completed for the Concord General Plan Update Draft Environmental Impact Report. City of Mountain View 1950 Colony Street Initial Study. Air Quality / Noise Analyst. Chris prepared the air quality and noise impact analysis for an Initial Study for a 108-unit rowhouse complex at 1950 Colony Avenue, adjacent to US 101 and near a proposed bicycle/pedestrian overpass along Permanente Creek. The site is occupied by office buildings built in the 1970s and operated as a circuit board manufacturing facility. This site has been identified by the EPA as a superfund site. Issues include remediation and public safety, outside ambient noise levels, and the impact of the project on air quality. The project would require an amendment to the General Plan and rezoning. UC Davis Contained Research and Environmental Services Facility. Air Quality / Noise / Energy Analyst. Chris performed emissions inventories that summarized all sources of criteria and toxic air pollutants including fume hoods, passenger and truck traffic, ground support equipment, boiler emissions, off-site electricity generation, and fuel distribution and storage. Traffic emissions were based on the California Air Resources Board's EMFAC7F (approved by the EPA) composite emissions factors. He incorporated the results of a Health Risk Assessment for toxic air contaminants into the analyses for each respective environmental impact report. Caltrans Doyle Drive Study, San Francisco. Noise Analyst. Managed a noise study for Caltrans of traffic noise impacts associated with improvements to Doyle Drive in San Francisco, the elevated roadway at the southern anchorage of the Golden Gate Bridge. Noise impacts examined in the study included those associated with new roadway geometries for six different alternatives, some of which included tunnels. The Traffic Noise Model of the Federal Highway Authority was used to predict future noise levels. The model was calibrated using noise monitoring data collected by ESA at eleven locations along the corridor. An area of acoustic turbulence around proposed tunnel portals was identified based on noise monitoring of existing tunnel portals. Noise and vibration impacts of construction activities were also assessed. San Francisco Multi-Year Wastewater Pipeline-Tunneling Project. Compliance Noise Monitoring and Reporting. Provided compliance noise monitoring and reporting for a multi-year wastewater pipeline-tunneling project for the City of San Francisco. He has established and maintained 24- hour noise monitoring stations at residences located adjacent to heavy-duty construction activities and performed short-term spot monitoring of equipment operation to verify compliance with the City Noise Ordinance and the applicable construction contract. Data is collected and graphed in weekly reports with recommendations for noise abatement and future monitoring.