e b o t i n a.r.thomson 2002 teahouse N northwest:scale 1/8" southeast:scale 1/8"

The Japanese Teahouse : Ritual and Form Buddhism had branched after about 600bc, into several distinct teachings. Of these, A Paper for M.Cohen’s Seminar on Architectural Proportion Mahayana (meaning 'big raft') Buddhism worked its way to Tibet, Mongolia, China, Korea May 2002, UBC | SoA and Japan. Of these five regional variations is the 'intuitive' school of Mayahana - or Zen. Submitted by a.r.thomson Zen (strictly literally!) means, 'meditation that leads to insight'.

In order to make some sense of the Teahouse design, and more specifically its mode of Mahakasyapa, apparently, was the only acolyte present at The Flower Sermon, who proportioning, scale and materiality, it is necessary to understand something of the context understood. The Flower Sermon, it is said, was one where, "Standing on a mountain with his out of which the ‘Culture of Tea’, aka. ’Teaism’ first developed. This paper will attempt to disciples around him, Buddha did not on this occasion resort to words. He simply held aloft distill some sense of this ambient culture, and then relate the aesthetic of Zen, to the a golden lotus." (H.Smith, pg 134) components of the Teahouse proper, and finally, conclude with an examination of the proportions used in the Teahouse design. UBC’s Nitobe Teahouse was the primary resource Mahakasyapa was declared the Buddha's successor. 28 patriarchs later, in 520ad, studied, which is unique in that it is a ‘traditional’ structure on foreign soil, and thus Bodhidharma introduced the teaching of Zen to Japan. This teaching consisted of the required a collaborative effort of several designers and builders, of different cultures, to 'transmission outside of scripture' which Mahakasyapa understood, and subsequently realize. transmitted. At the core of Zen training is the practice of Zazen, or sitting meditation, upon which all subsequent contemplative arts and studies are built. It is also said that through The context of Zen culture speaks volumes about the far eastern approach to aesthetic this meditation, the aesthetic sense develops, such that a correct understanding of the arts of ideals, and casts light on what would otherwise be considered a merely ‘vernacular’' Zen can be discerned. approach to design and construction. The early Tea Masters had an indelible influence on the whole of Japanese culture, from the aestheticism of food presentation, to dress and That the epiphany at the core of Zen training was symbolized by an aesthetic gesture, can morality, etiquette and architecture, flower arrangement and landscape design. Much that is explain the highly ‘aestheticized’ aspect of the teaching. It is very much about direct taken for granted in Japanese culture can be traced directly to this culture of Tea. experience, as opposed to immersion in the world of ideas and words.

The 'Way of Tea', more commonly known as Chado, is something that could be called an experience of 'total art'. All aspects of Chado stand in distinct relationship to one another, with the ultimate aim of 'awakening' the participant.

Awakening in this context, refers to the Buddhist state of sustained enlightenment, an expanded and clear sense of consciousness, that extends to every living thing - in time and beyond time. This relates to the Buddhist theory of evanescence, which is also common to Taoist thought, that the phenomenal world is no mere reflection of cosmic law, but that it is the very expression of these laws - that, "It is in us that God meets with Nature, and yesterday parts from tomorrow. The present is the moving Infinity, the legitimate sphere of the relative. Relativity seeks adjustment; adjustment is art.“ Okakura pgs. 23,35

Chado is a fusion of Taoist and Buddhist art that embodies the most striking - and probably best known - teaching of the Buddha, The Flower Sermon. UBC’s Nitobe Teahouse, North Elevation

Part of the rigor of Zen is to '...crash the word barrier' Hpg136 with the help of ritualized common roots in the Tea culture of Zen. In fact, everything in the tea environment is given experience, and precise Forms - in order to know of things ‘in themselves’. “The followers to assist in the arising of this state in the participant - not the least of which is the tea itself. of Zen aim at direct communion with the inner nature of things, regarding their outward accessories only as impediments to a clear perception of truth.” Okakura pg. 41 To summarize the chief principles of the Zen aesthetic, although this does no service to the more direct approach that the tradition merits, can arouse at least a beginner’s interest, which is all that could be hoped for here.

Design Principles

These principles were essentially culled and synthesized from various fragments of Kakuzo Okakura’s Book of Tea:

The Mundane, the Ephemeral and Quality The most difficult to understand are these notions of the spiritual in the mundane, and the A 4” teacup of the kind used in (artist unknown) striving for perfection in the sphere of the mundane. However, therein lies the rigor of the Zen tradition - that the ‘imperfection’ of life can somehow only be most intensely realized in Just as every movement in the form of the tea ceremony is calculated and exact, so is the striving after perfection. The complacently imperfect has no need to realize the spiritual, as form of the tea house, and its contents. The use of asymmetry in design for Chado is one of there is some assumption that it is either already perfect, or that perfection is impossible, its more prominent features. This is said to allow the participant to complete the whereas the initiate strives for perfection in the constant realization of shortcomings. In this arrangement, that is to say, that the form of the space is made such that the direct way the process of Zen carries greater meaning than any fixed state, and provides a truer participation of the occupant is bidden. This is related to the Taoist and Zen conception of understanding of the difficulty, and necessity of the ideal of perfection. beauty. "The dynamic nature of their philosophy laid more stress upon the process through which perfection was sought, than upon perfection itself. True beauty could be discovered only by one who mentally completed the incomplete". Okakura pg. 57

There is also an asymmetry that is revealed in the experience of the tea ceremony - that being one's ineptitude measured against the requirements imposed by the 'rules'. There are so many, that it requires an acute awareness of one's every breath and motion, which is not usually so. However, mere conformance to rules is not the point, as Basho says of Haiku poetry, “Learn all the rules, then forget them.”

To 'do' Chado correctly, requires a different state of mind or consciousness. In the same way, the martial art Aikido cannot be done from habit. Both require a relaxed and aware The Evanescence of the Tao can only be realized in the process of perfection, and it is too relationship with the body, which is said to bring this state of mind. This state, receptive and late to realize this when we are dead. The teahouse is a metaphor for the flimsy abode of the alert, can receive the subtlety of knowledge that is communicated through the 'language' of body in the stream of eternity, which “…become resolved into the original waste.” Okakura forms in gardening, ikebana, calligraphy and other contemplative arts - that all have pg. 54. For this reason, it is constructed of slender members, of impermanent materials, and with a lifespan roughly equivalent to a human life.

Program Changefulness, Compromise, Flexibility “definition is always limitation, the ‘fixed’ and ‘unchangeless’ are but terms for the The programmatic aspects of Chado and its architectural forms: stoppage of growth.” Okakura pg. 32 This principle can explain the ready acceptance of the Canadian module of 2x2’s, 4x4’s and the 3x6’ tatami - over the (for us) obscure system of Jowo, an early Tea Master (15th cent.) is said to have canonized the Tearoom’s proportions, Japanese lumber, and the traditional, 2‘-8“, 5‘-7”(+/-) tatami. from the tatami mat itself - which is the subsequent generator of all Japanese architectural proportion, to the cabinets and utensils found therein. The Vacuum The teahouse is alternatively called the Abode of Vacancy, and the Abode of the Arrival Unsymmetrical. Okakura pg. 44 “In leaving something unsaid, the beholder is given a - The Roji, or Garden Path, connects the Machiai with the tearoom. It is a path of deliberate chance to complete the idea and thus a great masterpiece irresistibly rivets your attention irregularity, and consists of gravel and stepping stones, intended to call attention to the act until you seem to become actually a part of it. A vacuum is there for you to enter and fill up of walking. Many Roji are based on interpretations of particular Haiku, or metred poems. to the full measure of your aesthetic emotion.”Okakura pg. 37

Left - entrance to UBC’s Nitobe Garden. (not a Roji, although it has one) Right - A proper Rojii, Left - somewhere in Japan A Kakoi-Sukiya in Japan

Waiting Relativity The Machiai is the portico where the guests assemble to be called by incense to the “Zennism, like Taoism, is the worship of relativity. One master defines Zen as the art of ceremony. feeling the polar star in the southern sky. Truth can be reached only through the The Host/Hostess comprehension of opposites.”Okakura pg. 39. The Midsuya is the anteroom where tea utensils are prepared and washed, and host/hostess

prepare, and wait (while guests seat themselves) for the ceremony. Asymmetry The principle of the vacuum and asymmetry are related toward the same end, that the human The Call completes the picture (not as an idea, but as an actual fact), and that the unknowable Tao can Guests are summoned noiselessly by incense, to proceed along the Roji from the Machiai only be suggested by the incomplete, the vacuum, and the relationship of oneself to the space.

Nitobe Memorial Garden Entry "I am in Japan," was the reaction of the Crown Prince of Japan as he walked through Through a small door, not more than three feet in height, (to inculcate humility.) UBC's renowned Nitobe Memorial Garden, three kilometres from the Botanical Garden. The exquisite work of art was created out of two-and-a-half acres (one hectare) of virgin forest Bowing by landscape architects and gardeners recommended by the government of Japan. Making obeisance to the Tokonoma on entry, which typically houses/features one or two of It honours Inazo Nitobe (1862-1933) whose goal was "to become a bridge across the the other contemplative arts, those of painting/calligraphy, and flower arrangement. These Pacific." Among many other memorials to him is his portrait on the 5,000 yen note. change regularly to express specific wisdom, or to harmonize with the given time of year. Considered to be the best traditional, authentic Japanese Tea and Stroll Garden in North The Tokonoma is the shrine of any Japanese home or temple, and consists of a small alcove, America and among the top five Japanese gardens outside Japan, the Nitobe Garden or slightly raised base (i.e. 4“), and typically measures about 1.5’ x 3’. includes a rare authentic Tea Garden with a ceremonial Tea House. Each tree, stone and shrub has been deliberately placed and is carefully maintained to The Tea Ceremony reflect an idealized conception and symbolic representation of nature. There is harmony The Sukiya = tearoom, can be built into an existing house (Kakoi), or function as a among natural forms -- waterfalls, rivers, forests, islands and seas -- and a balance of standalone building. The orthodox tearoom itself is a 4-½ mat room (10sf), which is meant masculine and feminine forces traditionally attributed to natural elements. to accommodate no more than 5 persons. This proportion is rooted in Buddhist scripture, Realizing that many native trees and shrubs could be trained and pruned in typical from the Sutra of Vikramaditya.Okakura pg. 48 Japanese fashion, the garden's creators incorporated them as unique features. Some maple and cherry trees and most of the azaleas and iris were brought from Japan. The Ceremony of Tea itself, sometimes together with meals, and the ritualized manner of art A place of reflection, where each step reveals a new harmony, the garden is designed to appreciation, are all programmatic forms that occur in the Sukiya itself. It is said that a good suggest a span of time -- a day, a week or a lifetime -- with a beginning, choice of paths, tearoom can be as costly as a mansion, as that the trades that build them are typically trained and ending. Although it is appreciated by all who visit, it is highly recommended Nitobe in Zen, and operate at an exquisite level of detail, with very select materials. visitors take advantage of tours. Come in spring for the tree blossoms, in summer for irises, or fall for the maples. As in all of the other components of the UBC Botanical Garden, the subtleties of the Nitobe Departure Memorial Garden can be enjoyed throughout the year: a reflecting pond with Koi, streams In the case of a protracted, or an evening tea, lanterns form part of the tea garden landscape. and waterfalls, magnificent stone lanterns and the teahouse, each unique and meaningful to Typically of granite, and taking many forms, the lanterns serve to focus and integrate all of the visitor's enjoyment. the specifically arranged vantage points within the garden. - from the ubc botanical garden’s website… http://www.ubcbotanicalgarden.org/nitobe/

The nitobe teahouse This background should give us some context to examine the plans against, and to observe the proportional and scalar devices employed, with an eye to why they were employed. All of the formal components and elements of program can be found in the example of Nitobe’s Teahouse and Garden.

Photographs and vr panoramas

Entry to sukiya and veranda

East elevation North elevation

North elevation

View to garden and veranda (note lanterns) West and North Elevations

even the best of us fudge measurements when we don’t have them in front of us, and that we Procedure often forget to measure important details until the drawing of the building reveals the The Teahouse was measured in the CAD Bootcamp workshop for 2002, which I instructed. obvious - that we are missing data! The aspect of architecture that is three-dimensional Twelve students were assigned to measure and input the Teahouse in a CAD platform of accounting is as reliable as ‘regular accounting‘. There is nothing ‘missing’. There is only their choice. Reference to an undimensioned floor plan was allowed. We took measurements confusion resulting from incomplete facts. This became obvious with one aspect of from a common datum at the Northeast corner, and took one set of measurements around the reconciling the exterior with the interior dimensions, there was one ‘pocket of hidden perimeter, which were then elaborated and confirmed by measurements from the interior. space‘, something like a framed chase, which threw everybody.

The goal of the assignment was to discover the hidden logic of the building, if there was one, and to use that as a logic to organize the 3D model that would be built by each student.

All drawings on the subsequent three pages are entirely my own work, which has been revised three times (during three workshops). At this phase, I had no idea that the Tatami was the governing module, neither did I know anything about the reason for the arrangements of rooms or their relationship to the garden.

This workshop has allowed me to observe the varied approach that students take when measuring a building, such as; the inherency to depend on existing drawings to organize one’s own (I made the first plans without reference to this), the use of a system of measurement that may or may not be rational with respect to the design (i.e. One German insisted on using Metric, which required extensive measurements that did not readily reveal G.Vose, North Elevation G.Vose, West Elevation the shorthand of the module), and the frequent omission of vertical measurements (i.e. Roof (note, pitch shown as 30deg, actual is 20deg.) ridge height, window elevations, floor elevation, etc.). Also, students appeared to resist trusting the module, over their measurements, until later measurements confirmed the module governed. The fact that the autocad floor plan from campus planning was inaccurate did not help.

It seems that this autocad drawing was simply digitized from the working drawings on record from before the teahouse was even built, in the late 60’s. Measurements of posts such as 3 7/8” instead of 4” reveal this kind of inaccuracy. Overall dimensions also expanded the teahouse beyond that which the 3x6’ module would allow, which effectively warped the tatamis in the drawings. I was also chastised for the way that I arranged the mats in my first drawing (by an instructor from the Urasenke Chado Foundation), only to discover on a later visit, that despite how the mats ought to be, that is not how they are.

The workshop was co-instructed by Gwyn Vose, who made a beautiful model and G.Vose, East Elevation G.Vose, Floor plan renderings, with the wrong roof pitch, and some misplaced . I mention this only because

KEYPLAN BYCAMPUSPLANNING&DEVELOPMENT COPYRIGHT OTHEUNIVERSITYOFBRITISHCOLUMBIA JAPANISETEAHOUSE-NITOBEGARDENS BUILDING 4 3 2 1 c A A 2 1994 B 1 E 9 3 B TEA HOUSE C 8 7 4 10 D 6 FLOOR ADDRESS E 5 1903 WestMall,V621T2 GROUND D F C SCALE PAGE OF 1:100 1 1 CONSTRUCTION DATE KEYPLAN DATE No. STORAGE HOUSE TICKET BOOTH DATE DENOTES LASTREVISION 28 FEB94 22 21 PROJ. No. 11 1959/1993 DRAWN DWG. No. AI 476 DIG BY \KEYPLANS\476\476-A1.DWG posts measure4"x4" overall langthoffby6" veranda longerthanexisting match currentconfiguration note: tatamimatsasproposeddonot autocad keyplan, scale1:100 e b o t i n a.r.thomson 2002 teahouse N

main floorplan:3/16"=1' main

N

e

a.r.thomson 2002 a.r.thomson

teahouse n-1:1/8"=1' section

machiai

b

o

t

sukiya i

n roji

25'-10"

2'-6" 6'-2" 3'-2" 4'-4" 5'-6" 3'-10"

2 1/4" 4"

4" 1'-11 3/4"9" 4" 4" 1'-3"7 1/2"4" 4" 4"

5'-1" 2'-10" 2'-1 1/2" 5'-2" 3'-6" 5 3/4" n-2:1/8"=1' section

4"

3 3/4"

tokonoma sukiya entry sukiya

4'-1" 4'-5" 4'-4" 4'-10" midsuya

4" 4" sukiya 8 1/2" 1'-1/4" 4'-8" 6'-2" 5'-10" 2'-7 1/4" 4"

4" midsuya

3'-11 1/2"

2'-10" 6'-4" n-3:1/8"=1' section 25'-3 3/4" 5'-1" 1'-11" 2'-1/2"

4" 4"

sukiya

3'

large roji 27'-3 3/4"

6'

6'-4" machiai

6'

4"

12'-4"

interior large sukiya large

3'

2'-8" veranda 4"

3'

section n-4:1/8"=1' section

entry tokonoma 4" 5'-1 3/4" 4'-11 3/4" 6'-5 1/4"

3'-1" 3'-5"

entry 1'-1 1/4" bench 1'-5 1/4" 4"

4" 4" 4" 4" 10"4" 4" main 5'-8" 3' 4' 8'-2"

8" 6' 8'-6" 8'-6"

23'-4" elevation:east elevation:south elevation:west elevationion:north

tokonoma vestibule entry veranda entry sukiya large sukiya bench main entry veranda sukiya entry roofs shoji and sukiya e b o t i n a.r.thomson 2002 teahouse N purlins on 4"x4" of 1.5"x1.75" rafters roofplan andstructurescale:3/16"=1' overhang veranda roof bench roof entry sukiya extends hip, tokonoma sukiya roofat

The Language of Teahouse proportions Sections The sections reveal the slight variations from the main entry, the sukiya entry, the hallway elevation, and the differences in ceiling height in the different rooms. The sukiya is the most complex room in section, with penetrations of the exterior roofs into the ceilings and vice versa. The exterior of the sukiya is intimately fused with the exterior, in both massing and fenestration, which is probably the origin of this trait in the modern architecture of Mies, Wright and Erickson. Tatami The Tatami governs. That is a simple fact. The Tatami in this case measures exactly 3 x 6 The Elevations feet, and can be arranged in many ways, which determines the size and quality of a given Elevations best portray the broad overhang (3‘), grade beam on rock foundations, window room. From palaces to tea-huts, to homes, the Tatami is the code of proportion that almost and shoji, and give some sense of the openness and lightness of the teahouse. When all all Japanese architecture follows. In its logic is the 1:2 ratio, 1:1 ratio, and 2:3 ratios. Sorry, shojii are opened, the roof appears to hover., and from certain perspectives, where one can no golden section. In the book, The Power of Limits, extensive references are made as to the see clear through the building to a tree or lantern perfectly framed in the distance, the sense Architecture of Zen somehow conforming to the Golden Mean, but after searching high and of the ephemeral and the evanescent is acute. low, it simply could not be found without inferring it from some ridiculous geometric manipulation. The structural grid also lines up where there are tatami-seams or joints. The Perspectives exception to this rule, is the 4’ wide hall. The experience of the building is very different than the sense that the drawings convey. Because we see perspectivally, in actual fact the roof appears broader, and the pitch steeper Structural Module than it actually is - and the sense of shelter - even though the structure is never heated, is The structural lumber of the teahouse begins from ½” x ½” members used in shojii screens, unmistakable. the first layer of roof structure, shelving, cabinets and other details. Then to ¾” for shelving, 1 ½” x 1 ¾” for rafters (second layer) and working up to 4”x4” for all columns. Beams Conclusion ranged from 4” (i.e. top-plates), to 6”, to 10”. Some rounded members and bamboo were In conclusion, it must be remarked that an immersion in the ambient culture that produced a used on the veranda, , and in the sukiya and tokonoma, as per tradition. given architecture can lend a much better understanding of both the program of the building, as well as its form. It is still unclear to me how the tatami was derived, and why it in This structural logic did not overlap the module of the tatami, but ran parallel. That is to say, particular holds such importance in the architecture of Japan, but before this project, I didn’t 4” separated every room, and could be read from the 4” thresholds. The structure ‘frames’ even know what a tatami was. It was incredible to discover the logic of the building, which every room with 4” members, from the corners to the ceilings, to the floors. All shojii probably prevails through design and construction. Drawings are often wrong, and screens are set into this 4” structure, which then serves three functions, as an aesthetic communication is often lacking, but a foreordained module is a sure thing. That a rectangle ‘break’, as hardware, and as structure. can generate so many interesting spaces, by virtue of simply adding its different lengths is something that will not be forgotten - and lastly - it is worth discovering a building on its Apparently, Japanese lumber modules are similar (according to the Japanese participants) own terms and in its own language, instead of imposing some kind of a priori system i.e. but not identical to our imperial dimensions. The adoption of the Canadian lumber module Phi, or the generatrix, or any other, as they may obscure the message that the building is is probably an expression of respect and flexibility to the way of working here. actually communicating.

0.3648 repeat 1/5 0.3654, etc. 5/6 1/4 1/1 2/3 1/1 1/2 1/5 1/2 3/4 0.547, ETC. 1/2 O.725, ETC. 2/3 / the module:0.5",1.5",1.75",4",6",8",36"or3',72"6',9',12' 2 1/10 1/3 1/3 1/9 3/4 phi 1/1 3/4 e b o t i n a.r.thomson 2002 teahouse N

References

Keith Snyder of The Urasenke Foundation of Vancouver

Junji Shinada, Master Gardener of The Nitobe Memorial Garden, UBC.

The Nitobe Garden Teahouse, UBC.

UBC dept. of Campus Planning, Original Working Drawings for the Teahouse and AutoCad Keyplan

Okakura, Kakuzo, 1862-1913. The book of tea / [Tuttle ed.] Rutland, Vt., C.E. Tuttle Co. [1956]

Smith, Huston. Religions of man. [1st ed.] New York : Harper, [1965].

Doczi, György, 1909- The power of limits : proportional harmonies in nature, art and architecture / Boulder, Colo. : Shambhala Publications ; [New York] : distributed in the U.S. by Random House, 1981.

UBC Botanical Gardens Website http://www.ubcbotanicalgarden.org/nitobe/

Laozi. Tao te ching : the definitive edition / New York : Jeremy P Tarcher/Putnam, 2001.