AL SOCIET IC Y G O O F L A O M E E G R I E C H A T GROUNDWORK Furthering the Influence of Earth Science The state of interactions among tectonics, erosion, and climate: A polemic Peter Molnar, Dept. of Geological Sciences, Cooperative what “controlled” the change in those quantities, or what Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES), “drove” them. The occurrence of change, external to “equation University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309-0399, (1),” transforms questions that concern drivers or controls from USA;
[email protected] being ill posed to well posed. In the earth sciences, perhaps no concept illustrates better a state of quasi-equilibrium than isostasy. Isostasy is not a pro- Since Dahlen and Suppe (1988) showed that erosion can cess; it exists. On short time scales (thousands of years), vis- affect the tectonics of the region undergoing that erosion, cous deformation can retard the inexorable trend toward geodynamicists, tectonic geologists, and geomorphologists isostatic equilibrium, as is illustrated well by the rebound fol- have joined in an effort to unravel the interrelationships lowing the melting of Pleistocene ice sheets. Thus, on such among not only erosion and tectonics but also climate, which time scales, one might understand pressure differences in the affects erosion and is affected by tectonics. The fruits of this asthenosphere as “driving” the overlying lithosphere and sur- effort grow continually, as shown in part by the attraction that faces of Canada or Fennoscandia upward. On longer geologic this subject has for students and young scientists. Yet, it seems time scales, however, isostasy is maintained as a state of equi- to me that progress has been limited by a misconception that librium; like the perfect gas law, “isostasy,” therefore, does not has stimulated this polemic.