Molecular Phylogeny of the Crab Genus Brachynotus (Brachyura
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
18860 k - J H\clrubiologia 4 49: 41-46.2001. 41 W P J.P.M. PiiuUt, A.A.V. Flores & C.H.J.M. Fransen teils). Advances iii Decapod Crustacean Research. ¡Q 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands. Molecular phylogeny of the crab genusBrachynotus (Brachyura: Varunidae) based on the 16S rRNA gene Christoph D. Schubart1, José A. Cuesta2 & Antonio Rodriguez2 1 Department o f Biological Sciences, National University o f Singapore, 10 Kent Ridge Crescent, Singapore 119260, Republic o f Singapore Presen! address: Biologie I, Universität Regensburg, 93040 Regensburg, Germany 2Instituto de Ciencias Marinas de Andalucía (CS1C). Polígono de Rio San Pedro s/n, Apartado Oficial, Puerto Real ! 1510, Cádiz, Spain i- Key words: phylogeny, systematics, 16S rRNA, Crustacea, Decapoda, Britdiynoj/ts S' A b stract Vlaams Instituut voor Flanders Marine Institute Tlie crab genus Brachynotus de Haan, 1833 is restricted to the intertidal and shallow subtidal of the Mediterranean and northeastern Atlantic. It is presently recognized to consist of four species, of which three {B. fo resti, B. gem m ellari and B. sexdentatus) are endemic to the Mediterranean. The fourth species, B. atlanticus, is found along the Atlantic coasts of northern Africa and southern Europe, but also extends into the western Mediterranean. This high level of endemism suggests that spéciation within Brachynotus is strongly correlated with the geography and geology of the Mediterranean Sea. A molecular phylogeny based on the mitochondrial large subunit (16S) rRNA gene indicates that the four species of Brachynotus form a monophyletic group within Atlantic Varunidae. The DNA sequence data also show that the genus Brachynotus can be subdivided into two species groups, one comprising B. atlanticus and B. foresti, and the other one B. gem m ellari and B. sexdentatus. W hile B. atlanticus and B. fo resti are clearly genetically distinct, B. gemmellari and B. sexdentatus are identical in the studied region of the 16S rRNA gene, suggesting a recent separation or continuing gene flow. Introduction The geographical confinement of its species, makes Brachynotus a very interesting genus for the study of Crabs of the genus Brachynotus de Haan, 1833 are spéciation and biogeography within the Mediterranean restricted to the western Atlantic and Mediterranean, Sea. despite the fact that many species from different parts The ecological distribution of the crabs belonging of the world, which are now classified in Cyrto to Brachynotus is typically the intertidal and shal grapsus. Hemigrapsus, Leptograpsodes, Tetragrapsus low subtidal zone of rocky or soft bottom shores or Thalassograpsus, had been previously placed in this (d’Udekem d’Acoz, 1999). The resurrection of the genus (see for example Rathbun, 1893; Tesch, 1918; species B. gem m ellari by Froglia & Manning (1978) Tweedie, 1942; Phillips et al., 1984). Today, B ra was mainly based on bathymetric and morphometric chynotus consists of four species. B. a tlanticus Forest, differences of this species and B. sexdentatus. O ther 1957 is found along the Atlantic coasts of northern wise, these two species have overlapping distributions Africa and southern Europe extending into the west and a practically identical morphology. The taxonomic ern Mediterranean (García-Raso, 1984; d’Udekem status o f B. gemmellari is widely accepted, and several d’Acoz, 1999). The other three species, B. fo resti Za- studies on its distribution, ecology and larval stages, riquiey Alvarez, 1968, B. gemmellari (Rizza, 1839) have been published since its recognition (Almaça, and B. sexdentatus (Risso, 1827), are mostly endemic 1985; Stevcic, 1990; Guerao et ah, 1995; Paula, 1996; to the Mediterranean, with occasional findings from Atkinson et ah, 1997; d'Udekem d'Acoz, 1999). the Black Sea, the Suez Canal, and the Gulf of Cádiz The remaining species of Brachynotus are easily (Zariquiey Alvarez, 1968; d’Udekem d’Acoz, 1999). separable on the basis of morphological characters. On 42 43 the other hand, the important question about under primers listed in Table 2. PCR products were purified Table t. Localities, dates of collection and genetic database accession numbers of the specimen of Brachynotus (4 species). Hemigrapsus penicillatus. Cyrtograpsus angulatus an d Eriocheir sinensis used for genetic comparisons. Abbreviations of lying phylogenetic relationships among these mostly and sequenced by dideoxy chain termination with S35 museums where animals were deposited as voucher specimens: BMNH: British Museum of Natural History, London: SMF: sympatric species was never resolved. In this study, we radioactive labeling (at the Pennsylvania State Uni Senckenbcrg Museum und Forschungsinstitut. Frankfurt a. M.: ULLZ: University of Louisiana at Lafayette Zoological compared a 580 basepair region of the mitochondrial versity) or with the AB1 Prism 310 Genetic Analyzer Collection. Lafayette: USNM: United States National Museum. Smithsonian Institution. Washington DNA (large subunit rRNA) in order to test whether using the AB I BigDye terminator mix (at the Univer Brachynotus sexdentatus (Risso. 1827) (EMBL AJ278832) Brachynotus forms a monophyletic group, to help sity of Louisiana at Lafayette). All sequences were Spain: Cadi/.: Puerto de Santa Maria: El Toruno, in aquaculture ponds up to 1.5 m depth: 14. June 1999: coli. A. resolve phylogenetic relationships within the genus, aligned manually using the multisequence editing pro Rodriguez; SMF 25794 and to establish the degree of genetic differentiation gram ESEE (Cabot & Beckenbach, 1989). Distance Greece: Gulf of Amvrakikos: Monidi; 'Ü.5 in - 1.5 m deep muddy bottom with sea grasses", 17. July 1993; coli. C. between the closely related B. gem m ellari and B. matrices of sequence divergence were analyzed using d'Udckem d'Acoz; SMF 25795 sexdentatus. Kimura 2-parameter distances and neighbor joining (NJ) (Saitou & Nei, 1987) with the program MEGA Brachynotus gemmellari (Ri/.za, 1839) (EMBL AJ278833) (Kumar et al., 1993). Maximum parsimony (MP) ana Italy; Ancona. 3 miles off. 15 m depth; 7. July 1963: coll. Froglia; USNM 172093 M aterial and methods lyses were carried out with PAUP (Swofford. 1993), England: Swansea: Queens Dock. M arch-Junc 1957; coll. E. Naylor; BMNH 1957.11.11.1-6 using the heuristic search method with tree bisection For the molecular phylogenetic analysis of B ra and reconnection branch swapping. Gaps were treated Brachynotus atlanticus Forest, 1957 (EMBL AJ27883I) chynotus and allied crabs, we included representat as missing and the tree was rooted by a user-defined Spain: Cádiz: Cabo de Trafalgar: June 1996: coll. J.A. Cuesta; SM F 25706 ives of all the genera of Varunidae occurring in the outgroup. Statistical significance of groups within in Atlantic, i.e. four species (six specimens) of B ra ferred trees was evaluated by bootstrapping with 2000 Brachynotus foresti Zariquiey Alvarez. 1968 (EMBL AJ278834) chynotus, as well as Cyrtograpsus affinis, C. an replications. Greece: Gulf of Amvrakikos: Agia Triada. 4 July 1993; coli. C. d'Udekem d’Acoz; SMF 25796 gulatus, Chasmagnathus granulatus, Cyclograpsus Hemigrapsus penicillatus (de Haan. 1835) (EMBL AJ278835) integer. Eriocheir sinensis and Hemigrapsus penicil France: La Gironde Estuary, Talmont (~ 451 32' N - 0 ' 54' W ); 9 May 1996; coli. P. Noel: SMF 25798 latus (see Table 1). The latter two are East Asian R esu lts species that have been introduced into European wa Cyrtograpsus angulatus Dana. 1851 (EMBL AJ278836) ters during this century (Schnakenbeck, 1924; Noël et The complete alignment of the sequenced 16S rRNA Argentina: Mar Chiquita: January 1996: coli. K. Anger; SMF 24546 al., 1997). 16S mtDNA sequences ofChasmagnathus gene region consisted of 580 positions. Of these, 186 granulatus (EMBL accession number AJ250640), were variable and 114 parsimony-informative. Pair Eriocheir sinensis 1-L Milne Edwards. 1853 (EMBL AJ250642) Cyclograpsus integer (AJ250639), Cyrtograpsus af wise transition to transversion ratios ranged between U.S.A. California: San Francisco Bay: Byron: Stale Fish facility: 11.11.1996; coll. K. I-lieb; ULLZ 4175 fin is (AJ130801), Eriocheir sinensis (AJ250642), 0.74 (outgroup vs. ingroup) and 6.5 (closely related Hemigrapsus oregonensis (AJ250644), Sesarma re species). The MP heuristic search, with transversions ticulatum (Sesarmidae) (AJ 130799) and Tetragrapsus versus transitions weighted 3/1, resulted in two most jo u y i(AJ250647) had been used in a previous study parsimonious Lees. The MP bootstrap analysis (2000 Table 2. Primers used for PCR amplification and se from different localities (see Table 1), which rendered to show that the genera Chasmagnathus and C yclo replicates) yielded a consensus tree of the length 722 quencing of parls of (lie 16S rRNA gene identical results. grapsus need to be classified within the Varunidae with the following tree-fit values: Cl: 0.665, RI: 0.569, The present results also show significant sup l6Sar: 5'- CGCCTGTTTATCAAAAACAT -3' (see Schubart et al., 2000a). Other sequences ob RC: 0.378 (Fig. 1). Results obtained by NJ agreed in port for other phylogenetic groupings. The Varunidae I6L2 5'- YGCCTGTTTATCAAAAACAT -3' tained from genetic databases and included in the the tree topology with MP (only considering bootstrap (sensu Schubart et ah, 2000a) is confirmed as a mono 16L15: 5'- GACGATAAGACCCTATAAAGCTT -3' present study were Eriocheir japonica (AF105242) values > 509c) and are, therefore, combined in Fig. 1. phyletic family (Fig.l: node ‘VAR’; 99 / 99) (see 1472 5'- AGATAGAAACCAACCTGG -3' and Grapsus grapsus (Grapsidae) (AJ250650). The All phylogenetic analyses suggest that B ra also Cuesta & Schubart, 1997; Schubart & Cuesta, 16,Sb/-: 5'- CCGGTCTGAACTCAGATCACGT -3' latter species served as an outgroup for the phylogen ch yn o tu sforms a monophyletic group within the other 1998). Congeneric species belonging to two other I 6 H 16: 5'-T T A T C R C C C C A A T A A A A T A -3' etic analyses. New sequences were submitted to the Varunidae tested in this analysis (bootstrap values of varunid genera were grouped together with relatively EMBL genetic database and can be retrieved under the 100 / 100).