They, Them, and Theirs Contents

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

They, Them, and Theirs Contents THEY, THEM, AND THEIRS Jessica A. Clarke CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 896 I. NONBINARY GENDER ............................................................................................................ 904 A. The Diversity of Nonbinary Gender Identities ............................................................ 905 B. Reasons for Bias Against Nonbinary People ................................................................ 910 C. Convergences and Divergences with Other Rights Struggles ..................................... 914 1. Feminist Arguments .................................................................................................... 915 2. Transgender Rights ...................................................................................................... 921 3. Sexual Orientation ...................................................................................................... 925 4. Intersex Variations ...................................................................................................... 928 5. Antiracist and Postcolonial Struggles ....................................................................... 930 II. A CONTEXTUAL APPROACH TO NONBINARY GENDER RIGHTS ............................... 933 A. Against Universal Definitions of Sex and Gender ....................................................... 933 B. Regulatory Models for Nonbinary Gender Rights ....................................................... 936 1. Third-Gender Recognition ......................................................................................... 937 2. Sex or Gender Neutrality ........................................................................................... 940 3. Integration into Binary Sex or Gender Regulation ................................................ 945 III. LEGAL INTERESTS IN BINARY SEX OR GENDER? ....................................................... 945 A. Identification .................................................................................................................... 947 B. Antidiscrimination Rules ................................................................................................ 951 1. Data Collection and Affirmative Action ................................................................... 952 2. Pregnancy Protections ................................................................................................ 954 3. Misgendering and Pronouns ...................................................................................... 957 C. Sex-Specific Roles and Programs ................................................................................... 963 1. Education ..................................................................................................................... 963 2. Athletics ........................................................................................................................ 966 3. Workplaces .................................................................................................................... 974 D. Sex-Segregated Spaces ..................................................................................................... 981 1. Restrooms and Changing Facilities .......................................................................... 981 2. Housing ......................................................................................................................... 983 E. Health Care ....................................................................................................................... 986 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................. 990 894 THEY, THEM, AND THEIRS Jessica A. Clarke∗ Nonbinary gender identities have quickly gone from obscurity to prominence in American public life, with growing acceptance of gender-neutral pronouns, such as “they, them, and theirs,” and recognition of a third-gender category by U.S. states including California, Colorado, Minnesota, New Jersey, Oregon, and Washington. People with nonbinary gender identities do not exclusively identify as men or women. Feminist legal reformers have long argued that discrimination on the basis of gender nonconformity — in other words, discrimination against men perceived as feminine or women perceived as masculine — is a harmful type of sex discrimination that the law should redress. But the idea of nonbinary gender as an identity itself appears only at the margins of U.S. legal scholarship. Many of the cases recognizing transgender rights involve plaintiffs who identify as men or women, rather than plaintiffs who seek to reject, permute, or transcend those categories. The increased visibility of a nonbinary minority creates challenges for other rights movements, while also opening new avenues for feminist and LGBT advocacy. This Article asks what the law would look like if it took nonbinary gender seriously. It assesses the legal interests in binary gender regulation in areas including law enforcement, employment, education, housing, and health care, and concludes these interests are not reasons to reject nonbinary gender rights. It argues that the law can recognize nonbinary gender identities, or eliminate unnecessary legal sex classifications, using familiar civil rights concepts. What gender am I? I bet you thought either male or female before I even asked the question. And this assumption is called the gender binary. I was born non-binary, meaning my body and mind don’t fit into either gender. At the age of 2, I told my parents I wasn’t a girl. At 12, I was the only person on my football team without a penis. And today at 36, I can wield a chainsaw 50 feet up a tree, and I’m also really a soft sensitive artist type. ––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– ∗ Professor of Law, Vanderbilt University Law School. Thanks to Toby Adams, Bradley Areheart, Genny Beemyn, Stephanie Bornstein, Mary Bryson, Erin Buzuvis, Mary Anne Case, Paul Castillo, Arli Christian, David Cruz, Heath Fogg Davis, Robin Dembroff, Deborah Dinner, Elizabeth Emens, Katie Eyer, Joseph Fiskhin, Andrea Freeman, Andrew Gilden, Michele Goodwin, Aimi Hamraie, Gautam Hans, Jill Hasday, Aziz Huq, Alex Iantaffi, Neha Jain, Dru Levasseur, Bill McGeveran, Shannon Minter, Amy Monahan, Rebecca Morrow, Douglas NeJaime, AJ Neuman Wipfler, Bethany Davis Noll, David Noll, Aaron Potenza, Jessica Roberts, Darren Rosenblum, Laura Rosenbury, Alan Rozenshtein, Naomi Schoenbaum, Jennifer Shinall, Russell Spiker, Maayan Sudai, Hudson Taylor, Ezra Young, the University of Minnesota Public Law Workshop, the Insti- tute for Advanced Study at the University of Minnesota, the Vanderbilt LGBT Policy Lab, the University of Chicago Workshop on Regulation of Family, Sex, and Gender, and the law faculties at the University of Minnesota and the University of Florida for conversations and comments on this project. Thanks to Katie Hanschke of the Vanderbilt Law Library for tracking down sources. For research assistance and valuable substantive feedback, I am grateful to Maria Brekke, Emily Lamm, Sara Lewenstein, Jessica Sharpe, Derek Waller, Claire Williams, and the editors of the Harvard Law Review. All opinions expressed here are my own. 895 896 HARVARD LAW REVIEW [Vol. 132:894 Our identities, who we know ourselves to be, is affected by our biol- ogy and the environment, nature and nurture. There are non-binary folks who are intersex, they have ambiguous genitalia, chromosomes that are not XX or XY. 1 in 100 people have bodies that differ from standard male or female. And there are non-binary folks who do have genitalia that is consid- ered standard male or female, but our brains have always been transgender. And collectively, we are the solid evidence that there is, and always has been, a spectrum of gender variation in the human species. — Carly Mitchell1 INTRODUCTION With stunning speed, nonbinary gender identities have gone from obscurity to prominence in American public life. The use of gender- neutral pronouns such as “they, them, and theirs” to describe an indi- vidual person is growing in acceptance.2 “All gender” restrooms are appearing around the country.3 And an increasing number of U.S. ju- risdictions are recognizing a third-gender category. In June 2016, an Oregon court became the first U.S. court to officially recognize nonbi- nary gender identity.4 In October 2017, California passed its Gender Recognition Act,5 a law allowing any individual to change the sex ––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– 1 Gender Identity: Female, Male, or Nonbinary: Hearing on S.B. 179 Before the Assemb. Standing Comm. on Judiciary, 2017–2018 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Cal. 2017) [hereinafter Cal. Assemb. Judiciary Hearing] (statement of Carly Mitchell), https://ca.digitaldemocracy.org/hearing/53965? startTime=705&vid=55910b927084f97bc382c39bf0ecade2 [https://perma.cc/H8T3-NJ6R]. 2 See, e.g., THE ASSOCIATED PRESS STYLEBOOK 274 (Paula Froke et al. eds., 2017) (advising journalists in describing “people who identify as neither male nor female or ask not to be referred to as he/she/him/her” to “[u]se the person’s name in place of a pronoun, or otherwise reword the sentence, whenever possible. If they/them/their use is essential, explain in the text that the person prefers a gender-neutral pronoun. Be sure that the phrasing
Recommended publications
  • Is Male Androphilia a Context-Dependent Cross- Cultural Universal? Raymond B
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Anthropology Faculty Publications Anthropology, Department of Winter 1-13-2017 Is Male Androphilia a Context-Dependent Cross- Cultural Universal? Raymond B. Hames University of Nebraska Lincoln, [email protected] Zachary H. Garfield Washington State University, Vancouver, [email protected] Melissa J. Garfield Washington State University, Vancouver, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/anthropologyfacpub Part of the Family, Life Course, and Society Commons, Gender and Sexuality Commons, Multicultural Psychology Commons, Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons, Social Control, Law, Crime, and Deviance Commons, and the Social Psychology and Interaction Commons Hames, Raymond B.; Garfield, Zachary H.; and Garfield, Melissa J., "Is Male Androphilia a Context-Dependent Cross-Cultural Universal?" (2017). Anthropology Faculty Publications. 132. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/anthropologyfacpub/132 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Anthropology, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Anthropology Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. Published in Archives of Sexual Behavior 46 (2017), pp 63–71. DOI 10.1007/s10508-016-0855-7
    [Show full text]
  • Gender Equality Observations in the Swedish Research Council's Review
    A GENDER-NEUTRAL PROCESS – GENDER EQUALITY OBSERVATIONS IN THE SWEDISH RESEARCH COUNCIL’S REVIEW PANELS 2016 SWEDISH RESEARCH COUNCIL 2017 A GENDER-NEUTRAL PROCESS – GENDER EQUALITY OBSERVATIONS IN THE SWEDISH RESEARCH COUNCIL’S REVIEW PANELS 2016 VETENSKAPSRÅDET Swedish Research Council Box 1035 SE-101 38 Stockholm © Swedish Research Council VR1709 ISBN 978-91-7307-353-0 A GENDER-NEUTRAL PROCESS – GENDER EQUALITY OBSERVATIONS IN THE SWEDISH RESEARCH COUNCIL’S REVIEW PANELS 2016 Lisbeth Söderqvist Patrik Baard Anders Hellström Camilla Kolm PREFACE One of the Swedish Research Council’s principal tasks is to fund basic research of the highest quality. Gender equality is a quality issue for the entire research system and the Research Council has a duty to promote gender equality within its own area of operations. Over the course of several years, the Research Council has built up its knowledge of how efforts to increase gender equality in conjunction with research funding can be conducted. One tool that the Research Council is using is gender equality observations. These have been conducted every two years since 2012. The aim of these observations is to review, from a gender equality perspective, the meetings at which experts discuss applications for research grants that the Research Council has received. These meetings are a central aspect of the Research Council’s research grant allocation process. The observations are part of wider gender equality efforts within the Research Council that also encompass the development of other parts of the evaluation process in order to achieve the Research Council’s gender equality objectives. Previous gender equality observations have resulted in recommendations that, together with an internal development process, have led to improvements to the Research Council’s procedures.
    [Show full text]
  • Gender Neutrality and the Definition of Rape: Challenging the Law’S Response to Sexual Violence and Non-Normative Bodies
    GENDER NEUTRALITY AND THE DEFINITION OF RAPE: CHALLENGING THE LAW’S RESPONSE TO SEXUAL VIOLENCE AND NON-NORMATIVE BODIES ELISABETH MCDONALD* In 2005 the legislature of Aotearoa New Zealand chose for the second time, the first occurring in 1986, to retain the offence of rape as one of the ways in which the crime of sexual violation may be committed. The current definition of rape means that only those with a penis can be guilty of this offence, and only those with female genitalia can be a victim of such a crime. Despite use of the term in public vernacular being wider than the legal definition, little advocacy has been focussed on reforming this law, although those in the trans and intersex communities recognise their experiences are not reflected in the description of rape. In this piece I note the importance, and difficulty, of making visible within the legislative framework both the gendered nature of sexual offending as well as the vulnerabilities of those who have non-normative bodies. By considering the theory and critical analysis which informed the debates and law reform undertaken in other jurisdictions, I conclude that it is time to reconsider the actus reus of rape in Aotearoa New Zealand, with the aim of extending its scope so as to be responsive to all communities’ experiences of sexual violence. I INTRODUCTION Beginning with reform which took shape primarily in the mid-1970s, most common law jurisdictions have now adopted revised definitions of varying types of sexual offences. Early advocates for change were primarily concerned with the limited scope of the traditional crime of rape, including the requirement for force and the marital exemption.1 Feminists also agitated for * Professor, School of Law, University of Canterbury.
    [Show full text]
  • Gender-Sternchen, Binnen-I Oder Generisches Maskulinum, … (Akademische) Textstile Der Personenreferenz Als Registrierungen?*
    Gender-Sternchen, Binnen-I oder generisches Maskulinum, … (Akademische) Textstile der Personenreferenz als Registrierungen?* Helga Kotthoff (Freiburg) Abstract For more than 40 years, a debate on gender-related person references has been taking place in the German-speaking world. My contribution starts with a differentiation of four registers, which are currently practiced in writing and have developed specific reasoning discourses and specific social contexts of usage, as I try to show. I am going to examine these four styles of gendered person reference as “registers” in the sense of anthropological linguistics (Agha 2007). This concept of “enregisterment” implies that the producers connect themselves to a socio-symbolic cosmos and can be perceived with cultural evaluations (in production and re- ception), for example, as conservative, feminist, queer, liberal (Kotthoff 2017). Here I shall explore their (socio)linguistic underpinnings within conceptions of language ideology in order to grasp the communication-reflexive charges of these discourses. 1 Einleitung Seit über 40 Jahren findet im deutschsprachigen Raum eine Debatte um geschlechterbezogene Personenreferenzen statt. Mein Beitrag setzt bei einer Binnendifferenzierung von vier Registern an, die sich inzwischen mit spezifischen sozialen Verortungen herausgebildet haben, was ich zu zeigen versuche. Die traditionelle Schreibpraxis mit einem generisch gemeinten, ge- schlechtsübergreifenden Maskulinum1 (Typ 1), wie sie etwa von Eisenberg (2017), Glück (2018) oder dem Verein für Deutsche
    [Show full text]
  • Graphemic Methods for Genderneutral
    Graphemic Methods for Gender­Neutral Writing Yannis Haralambous & Joseph Dichy Abstract. In this paper we present a model and a classification of graphemic gender­neutral writing methods, we explore current practices in French, Ger­ man, Greek, Italian, Portuguese and Spanish languages, and we investigate in­ teractions between gender­neutral writing forms and regular expressions. 1. Introduction: The General Issue of, and behind, Gender­ Neutral Writing The issue behind gender­neutral writing is that of the representation of inter­gender relations carried by languages. What is at stake is the representation of equality, or not, between genders. The issue is also re­ ferred to as “inclusive writing,” which apparently refers to human rights, but does not cover all cases, i.e., lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans­gender persons. The term “Gender­Neutral Writing” is, in fact, both clearer and more inclusive. Generally speaking, languages are conservative, if not archaic. A sig­ nificant example is that of the idea of time, which is traditionally repre­ sented as a dot sliding along a straight line in a continuous movement. This has been a philosophical image of time since ancient Greek philoso­ phers and throughout the Middle Ages both in Arabic and European phi­ losophy, but can no longer be considered as a valid representation after 20th century existentialist philosophers and Heidegger’s Sein und Zeit. Yannis Haralambous 0000-0003-1443-6115 IMT Atlantique & LabSTICC UMR CNRS 6285 Brest, France [email protected] Joseph Dichy Professor of Arabic linguistics Lyon, France [email protected] Y. Haralambous (Ed.), Graphemics in the 21st Century.
    [Show full text]
  • The Duke University Student Leadership and Service Awards
    The Duke University Student Leadership and Service Awards April 21st, Washington Duke Inn 1 Order of Program Please be seated, we will begin at 6pm Hosts for the Evening Phillip McClure, T’16 Dinner Menu Savanna Hershman, P’17 Salad Baby Field Greens, Poached Pears, Spiced Welcome Walnuts, Champagne Vanilla Dressing Dinner Rolls Freshly Brewed Iced Tea Address by Steve Nowicki, Ph.D. Dean of Undergraduate Education Chicken entrée: Grilled Breast of Chicken, Maple Scented Award Presentations Sweet Potato, Pencil Asparagus, Morel Julie Anne Levey Memorial Leadership Mushroom Sauce Award This meal is free of gluten and dairy Class of 2017 Awards Baldwin Scholars Unsung Heroine Award or Betsy Alden Outstanding Service-Learning Award Vegan entrée: Butternut, Acorn and Spaghetti Squash, Your Three Words Video Golden Quinoa, Arugula, Carrots, Asparagus, Sweet Potato Puree Additional Recognition This meal is free of gluten and dairy Award Presentations Dessert Reception on the Patio Lars Lyon Volunteer Service Award Chocolate Whoopie Pie Trio Leading at Duke Leadership and Service Gourmet Cookies Awards Vegan Dessert: Cashew Cheesecake Algernon Sydney Sullivan Award Regular & Decaffeinated Coffee and William J. Griffith University Service Assorted Hot Tea Award Student Affairs Distinguished Leadership and Service Awards 2 Closing 1 Julie Anne Levey Memorial Leadership Award The Presenters Lisa Beth Bergene, Ph.D. Associate Dean, Housing, Dining and Residence Life Daniel Flowers Residence Coordinator, Southgate and Gilbert-Addoms The Award The
    [Show full text]
  • Selected Resources for Understanding Racism
    Selected Resources for Understanding Racism The 21st century has witnessed an explosion of efforts – in literature, art, movies, television, and other forms of communication—to explore and understand racism in all of its many forms, as well as a new appreciation of similar works from the 20th century. For those interested in updating and deepening their understanding of racism in America today, the Anti-Racism Group of Western Presbyterian Church has collaborated with the NCP MCC Race and Reconciliation Team to put together an annotated sampling of these works as a guide for individual efforts at self-development. The list is not definitive or all-inclusive. Rather, it is intended to serve as a convenient reference for those who wish to begin or continue their journey towards a greater comprehension of American racism. February 2020 Contemporary Alexander, Michelle. 2010. The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. Written by a civil rights litigator, this book discusses race-related issues specific to African-American males and mass incarceration in the United States. The central premise is that "mass incarceration is, metaphorically, the New Jim Crow". Anderson, Carol. 2017. White Rage. From the Civil War to our combustible present, White Rage reframes our continuing conversation about race, chronicling the powerful forces opposed to black progress in America. Asch, Chris Myers and Musgrove, George Derek. 2017. Chocolate City: A History of Race and Democracy in the Nation's Capital. A richly researched and clearly written analysis of the history of racism in Washington, DC, from the 18th century to the present, and the efforts of people of color to claim a voice in local government decisionmaking.
    [Show full text]
  • Lessons Learned from Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
    LESSONS LEARNED FROM JUSTICE RUTH BADER GINSBURG Amanda L. Tyler* INTRODUCTION Serving as a law clerk for Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in the Supreme Court’s October Term 1999 was one of the single greatest privileges and honors of my life. As a trailblazer who opened up opportunities for women, she was a personal hero. How many people get to say that they worked for their hero? Justice Ginsburg was defined by her brilliance, her dedication to public service, her resilience, and her unwavering devotion to taking up the Founders’ calling, set out in the Preamble to our Constitution, to make ours a “more perfect Union.”1 She was a profoundly dedicated public servant in no small measure because she appreciated just how important her role was in ensuring that our Constitution belongs to everyone. Whether as an advocate or a Justice, she tirelessly fought to dismantle discrimination and more generally to open opportunities for every person to live up to their full human potential. Without question, she left this world a better place than she found it, and we are all the beneficiaries. As an advocate, Ruth Bader Ginsburg challenged our society to liber- ate all persons from the gender-based stereotypes that held them back. As a federal judge for forty years—twenty-seven of them on the Supreme Court—she continued and expanded upon that work, even when it meant in dissent calling out her colleagues for improperly walking back earlier gains or halting future progress.2 In total, she wrote over 700 opinions on the D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Kathoey Phenomenon in Thai Cinema the Iron Ladies : El Fenómeno Kathoey En El Cine Tailandés
    ISSN 2173-5123 From the Iron to the Lady: The Kathoey Phenomenon in Thai Cinema The Iron Ladies : El fenómeno kathoey en el cine tailandés Recibido: 26 de octubre de 2011 Aceptado: 25 de noviembre de 2011 Milagros Expósito Barea Universidad de Sevilla [email protected] Abstract Even though they lack any legal rights, the kathoey , also known as ladyboys , have great social relevance in Thailand. We face a different way of looking at homosexuality, starting with a more tolerant consideration from the religious point of view thanks to the way it is conceived through karma. The successful release of The Iron Ladies (Thongkonthun, dir., 2000) initiated the production of an increasing number of gay films in Thailand. Choosing the standpoint of queer theory, this paper attempts to put across the reasons behind the success these films have found, studying the way Thai culture, particularly its cinema, depicts the various homosexual factions: the portrayal of the kathoey as a role model; an approach to the boom of male homosexuality in films; an investigation of the use of stereotypes; the evolution of the commercial gay comedy or the upsurge of dramas aimed at homosexual audiences. Keywords Thai cinema, gay cinema, kathoey, ladyboys. Resumen A pesar de que carecen de derechos legales, los kathoey , también conocidos como ladyboys , tienen una gran relevancia social en Tailandia. Nos encontramos ante una forma diferente de ver la homosexualidad, más tolerante en determinadas cuestiones, gracias a la visión que ofrece el budismo partiendo de una serie de preceptos fundamentados en el karma. El éxito alcanzado por la película The Iron Ladies (Thongkonthun, dir.
    [Show full text]
  • ESG Report Viacomcbs 2019
    ACTIONEnvironmental, Social, and Governance Report ViacomCBS 2019 Introduction Governance On-screen Workforce Sustainable Reporting content and and culture production indices social impact and operations Contents Introduction 3 CEO letter 4 Our approach to ESG 6 About ViacomCBS 9 About this report 10 Our material topics 11 Case study: Responding to a global pandemic 12 Aligning with the UN Sustainable Development Goals 15 Governance 17 ESG governance 19 Corporate governance 20 Data privacy and security 22 Public policy engagement 23 On-screen content and social impact 24 Diverse and inclusive content 26 Responsible content and advertising 31 Using our content platforms for good 33 Expanding our social impact through community projects 35 Workforce and culture 38 A culture of diversity and inclusion 40 Preventing harassment and discrimination 45 Employee attraction, retention, and training 46 Health, safety, and security 48 Labor relations 50 Sustainable production, and operations 51 Climate change 53 Sustainable production 58 Environmental impacts of our operations and facilities 60 Supply chain responsibility 63 Consumer products 66 Reporting indices 68 GRI Index 69 SASB Index 81 COVER IMAGES (FROM LEFT TO RIGHT): CBS, NCIS; CBS Sports; CBS, Super Bowl LIII; CBS News, CBS This Morning ViacomCBS ESG Report 2019 Introduction Governance On-screen Workforce Sustainable Reporting content and and culture production indices social impact and operations Introduction Welcome to our first ESG Report, Action: ESG at ViacomCBS. As we unleash the
    [Show full text]
  • FYE Int 100120A.Indd
    FirstYear & Common Reading CATALOG NEW & RECOMMENDED BOOKS Dear Common Reading Director: The Common Reads team at Penguin Random House is excited to present our latest book recommendations for your common reading program. In this catalog you will discover new titles such as: Isabel Wilkerson’s Caste, a masterful exploration of how America has been shaped by a hidden caste system, a rigid hierarchy of human rankings; Handprints on Hubble, Kathr­n Sullivan’s account of being the fi rst American woman to walk in space, as part of the team that launched, rescued, repaired, and maintained the Hubble Space Telescope; Know My Name, Chanel Miller’s stor­ of trauma and transcendence which will forever transform the way we think about seual assault; Ishmael Beah’s powerful new novel Little Family about young people living at the margins of society; and Brittany Barnett’s riveting memoir A Knock at Midnight, a coming-of-age stor­ by a young la­er and a powerful evocation of what it takes to bring hope and justice to a legal system built to resist them both. In addition to this catalog, our recently refreshed and updated .commonreads.com website features titles from across Penguin Random House’s publishers as well as great blog content, including links to author videos, and the fourth iteration of our annual “Wat Students Will Be Reading: Campus Common Reading Roundup,” a valuable resource and archive for common reading programs across the countr­. And be sure to check out our online resource for Higher Education: .prheducation.com. Featuring Penguin Random House’s most frequently-adopted titles across more than 1,700 college courses, the site allows professors to easily identif­ books and resources appropriate for a wide range of courses.
    [Show full text]
  • A Former TMZ Employee Said She Was Fired After Complaining About a Sexist, Toxic Work Environment
    A Former TMZ Employee Said She Was Fired After Complaining About A Sexist, Toxic Work Environment buzzfeednews.com/article/krystieyandoli/ex-tmz-employee-lawsuit A former TMZ employee filed a lawsuit against the celebrity gossip show’s parent companies Warner Bros. Entertainment and EHM Productions on Tuesday alleging gender discrimination and retaliation. Bernadette Zilio, 27, worked at TMZ and TooFab, another entertainment site owned by Warner Bros. and EHM Productions, from 2015 to 2020 and said she was fired after she complained to HR about a culture of toxicity and sexism. TMZ founder Harvey Levin, TooFab Managing Editor Shyam Dodge, and TooFab Senior Producer Ross McDonagh are also named in the lawsuit. In the complaint, which was filed Tuesday with the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing, Zilio said she went to Warner Bros. HR representatives in April 2019 about issues of “sexism, belittlement, preferential treatment and lies running rampant on [her] team.” She told HR that she felt there was a division of how men and women were treated on her team, and that when she spoke up about McDonagh writing articles she considered sexist and offensive, such as one that compared Rihanna getting sick with bronchitis and the “attack on her lungs” to her being attacked by Chris Brown, her concerns about making light of domestic violence were dismissed. The complaint also says that Zilio and her female colleagues described the work environment as “a boys’ club,” “100% a bro fest,” and a “freaking frat house.” “The first time I went to HR, they launched an investigation,” Zilio told BuzzFeed News.
    [Show full text]