Judge Rules Against US Women's Soccer Team in Equal Pay Case
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Established 1961 19 Sunday, May 3, 2020 Sports Judge rules against US women’s soccer team in equal pay case US women left stunned by their defeat on pay issue LOS ANGELES: A federal judge dismissed the nent US women’s team star Megan Rapinoe said United States women’s soccer team’s bid for equal after learning of the court’s decision that the battle pay on Friday, rejecting claims the players had been is not over. underpaid in a crushing defeat for the reigning “We will never stop fighting for EQUALITY,” she world champions. wrote on Twitter. A spokeswoman for the players re- In a 32-page ruling, Judge Gary Klausner of the acted with dismay following Friday’s ruling. “We are US District Court for Central California in Los An- shocked and disappointed with today’s decision, but geles tossed the women’s claim of pay discrimina- we will not give up our hard work for equal pay,” tion, ruling in favour of the United States Soccer spokeswoman Molly Levinson said. Federation (USSF). “We are confident in our case and steadfast in our Klausner did allow the women’s case for unfair commitment to ensuring that girls and women who treatment in areas such as travel, housing and med- play this sport will not be valued as lesser just be- ical support to proceed to trial, set for June 16 in Los cause of their gender. “We have learned that there are Angeles. tremendous obstacles to change; we know that it But the judge said the equal pay claims — the cen- takes bravery and courage and perseverance to stand tral plank of the case — had been dismissed because up to them.” there was evidence the USSF said Friday night women had previously it would continue to work turned down an offer in with the women’s pro- the Collective Bargain- gram to grow the game in ing Agreement negotia- the United States. “We tions to be paid along look forward to working the lines of the US men’s Fighting for with the Women’s Na- team. “The history of ne- tional Team to chart a gotiations between the equality positive path forward and parties demonstrates to grow the game both that the WNT rejected here at home and around an offer to be paid under the world,” it said. the same pay-to-play “We are committed to structure as the MNT, continuing that work to and the WNT was willing to forgo higher bonuses for ensure our Women’s National Team remains the best PARIS: File photo shows US players pose ahead of the France 2019 Women’s World Cup quarter-final benefits, such as greater base compensation and the in the world.” The increasingly acrimonious lawsuit football match between France and USA, at the Parc des Princes stadium in Paris. A federal judge dis- guarantee of a higher number of contracted players,” had taken a dramatic turn in March, when a filing by missed the United States women’s soccer team’s bid for equal pay on May 1, 2020, rejecting claims Klausner wrote. lawyers for the federation argued that US men’s team the players had been underpaid in a crushing defeat for the reigning world champions. — AFP “Accordingly, plaintiffs cannot now retroactively players required a “higher level of skill based on deem their CBA (collective bargaining agreement) speed and strength” than the women. worse than the MNT CBA by reference to what they The filing triggered outrage amongst the women’s at the men’s and women’s World Cups. money than the men on both a cumulative and an av- would have made had they been paid under the players while influential sponsors such as Coca-Cola Germany’s men won $35 million for their victory erage per game basis. MNT’s pay-to-play terms structure when they them- voiced disgust at the remarks. USSF President Carlos in the 2014 World Cup while France earned $38 mil- During that period the women’s national team re- selves rejected such a structure,” he said. Cordeiro later resigned following the uproar, with lion after triumphing in Russia in 2018. The United ceived $24 million and an average of $220,747 per Rapinoe accusing the USSF of “blatant sexism” in its States women, victors in the 2015 and 2019 World game while the men’s team received payments of $18 SHOCKED AND DISAPPOINTED legal filings. The US women, who clinched back-to- Cups, earned total prize money of $6 million over the million and $212,639 per game. Under the current The US women were left stunned by their defeat back World Cup wins with victory at last year’s finals two tournaments. CBA, which was signed in 2017, more than half the on the pay issue. The women had been seeking back in France, had based their claim for back pay in the The USSF argued in court that between the years women’s team players receive an annual base salary pay of $66 million under the Equal Pay Act. Promi- disparities between prize money distributed by FIFA 2015-2019, the women actually were paid more of $167,000. — AFP Olympic Games before winning it at the uled seasons with spectators while Caslavska, only World Championships, European Champi- Coronavirus the NBA and the National Hockey onships and ensuing Olympics. League cancel the unfinished part of Her main rival in Tokyo, Ukrainian-born their regular seasons and stage play- gymnast to win Larisa Latynina, was the only other female US sport off games without spectators with gymnast to win successive golds in the all- youth sports resuming in July. all-around title round competition, in 1956 and 1960. “She shutdown will None of that is assured given the was a phenomenal sportswoman,” Latynina stay-at-home orders remaining in told Reuters after Caslavska died in 2016 place over most of the nation as a re- PRAGUE: When Vera Caslavska bowed her from pancreatic cancer. “Vera and I were cost $12bn sult of the deadly virus that has killed head and turned away in protest at the So- friends and we would give each other pres- more than 63,000 people in the viet anthem during the 1968 Olympics, the ents. We would also swap vinyl records.” United States and infected more than NEW YORK: The $100 billion US Czech gymnast cemented her place as not Czech authorities, however, nearly one million. only one of the country’s greatest athletes stopped Caslavska’s journey to Mexico City sports landscape will lose $12 billion in revenue due to the coronavirus “As an economist, you stand back, but also as a powerful voice against Commu- in its tracks after she publicly opposed So- you look at the carnage that’s taking nist rule. viet rule by signing a dissident manifesto in shutdown, ESPN reported Friday, with deeper cuts if NFL and college place — dumbfounded, awestruck, Two months after Warsaw Pact tanks the spring of 1968. mind-numbing. All of those phrases, swept into Czechoslovakia to crush the Forced to hide in the mountains to avoid gridiron games are wiped out. Analysis of the magnitude of busi- they’re all relevant becaus we just “Prague Spring” reforms, the anti-Soviet arrest, the gymnast only gained permission have never seen anything on this icon dazzled at the Mexico Games, claiming to compete at the last minute. ness losses includes superstar salaries to pay for stadium workers scale,” Rishe told ESPN. four golds and becoming one of only two Figures include $3.25 billion that POTATO SACKS but it might be a conservative esti- women to win successive titles in the all- would have been spent by specta- During her time in hiding, she lifted potato Vera Caslavska mate because it does not include out- around competition. Yet it was her silent mo- tors on pro sports plus $371 million sacks to keep fit and substituted logs for door recreational sport, gambling or ment of defiance as the anthem played of income for stadium and arena during the medal ceremony for the floor ex- beams to prepare for the games where her such individual sports as golf, tennis ond-greatest athlete after runner Emil workers and $2.2 billion in US tele- ercise, when she controversially shared a dominant performances and decision to use and NASCAR, the most popular form Zatopek. When Communist rule ended in vision rights fees. joint gold with a Soviet athlete after the the Mexican Hat Dance as music for one of Czechoslovakia in 1989, President Vaclav of US auto racing. An NFL wipe out would cost judges upgraded the preliminary scores of her routines won the adoration of the local Havel appointed her his adviser for sport and Patrick Rishe, sports business pro- more than $11.5 billion in television her rival, that endeared her to Czechs. fans. Caslavska topped off her remarkable social issues. She also led the Czech Olympic gram director at Washington Univer- revenue while 65 major collegiate It also made her a beloved figure long Olympics by marrying Czech 1,500 metres Committee from 1990 to 1996. Her personal sity in St. Louis, estimated the impact American football programs receive after her sporting career had ended. “We champion Josef Odlozil in Mexico City, 24 life following the country’s “Velvet Revolu- of the shutdown on major US pro and about $4 billion in TV money, about Olympians were the only ones who could hours after her competition ended, in an tion” that ended authoritarian rule in 1989 college sports leagues as well as demonstrate our attitude to the Soviet occu- event that drew thousands of well wishers.