Regulating Methylation at H3K27: a Trick Or Treat for Cancer Cell Plasticity
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
cancers Review Regulating Methylation at H3K27: A Trick or Treat for Cancer Cell Plasticity Provas Das and Joseph H. Taube * Department of Biology, Baylor University, Waco, TX 76706, USA; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 29 August 2020; Accepted: 23 September 2020; Published: 29 September 2020 Simple Summary: Regulation of gene expression is important for appropriate cell development but can also lead to inappropriate cell transformation resulting in cancer. Modification to the proteins that wrap DNA is essential for regulating gene expression. Mutations in the enzymes that modify such proteins are being discovered in many cancers. This review will cover present knowledge of these enzymes as they relate to cancer initiation and progression. Abstract: Properly timed addition and removal of histone 3 lysine 27 tri-methylation (H3K27me3) is critical for enabling proper differentiation throughout all stages of development and, likewise, can guide carcinoma cells into altered differentiation states which correspond to poor prognoses and treatment evasion. In early embryonic stages, H3K27me3 is invoked to silence genes and restrict cell fate. Not surprisingly, mutation or altered functionality in the enzymes that regulate this pathway results in aberrant methylation or demethylation that can lead to malignancy. Likewise, changes in expression or activity of these enzymes impact cellular plasticity, metastasis, and treatment evasion. This review focuses on current knowledge regarding methylation and de-methylation of H3K27 in cancer initiation and cancer cell plasticity. Keywords: H3K27me3; EZH2; KDM6A; KDM6B; cancer cell plasticity 1. Introduction Regulation of gene expression depends on access to the genome and recruitment of trans-acting factors, both of which are processes that are impacted by the histone modification state. Modification of specific histones can be pathologically altered by aberrant “writers” that add modifications, “erasers” that remove modifications, or by the mutation of the histone structure which can prevent the residues from being modified [1,2]. Along with these modifications, alteration in the “readers” can alter the functional outcome of the modification. Tri-methylation of the 27th lysine residue on histone H3 (H3K27me3), while just one of many such modifications, plays an important role in developmentally driven gene silencing and in cancer initiation and progression. This review will cover present knowledge on the role of H3K27me3 and the enzymes which modify this residue in cancer, with a particular focus on cellular plasticity. 2. Histone Methylation and Demethylation: An Historical Perspective Although largely thought of as a genetic disease, current evidence establishes that epigenetic aberrations can play profound and ubiquitous roles in cancer origin and progression [3–5]. Results from large-scale cancer genome sequencing projects describe that an unanticipated 50% of human cancers harbor mutations in chromatin-related proteins [6,7]. Overwhelming evidence supports the notion that specific genetic, environmental, and metabolic stimuli can disrupt the homeostatic balance in chromatin machinery, which can cause either aberrantly restrictive or permissive responses. Such stimuli can Cancers 2020, 12, 2792; doi:10.3390/cancers12102792 www.mdpi.com/journal/cancers CancersCancers2020 2020, 12, ,12 2792 2 of2 of 33 32 responses. Such stimuli can act on quiescent or premalignant cells to promote malignancy and/or acttumor on quiescent cells to hasten or premalignant their progression cells to and promote adaptation. malignancy The ubiquity and/or tumor of such cells stimuli to hasten means their that progressionepigenetic anddefects adaptation. are involved The ubiquity in various of suchaspects stimuli of cancer means [8–10]. that epigenetic defects are involved in variousHistone aspects modifications, of cancer [8–10 DNA]. methylation, chromatin architecture, and the expression of non- codingHistone transcripts modifications, drive the DNAepigenetic methylation, state of a ce chromatinll. The N-terminal architecture, tails of and histones the expression can undergo of a non-codingvariety of transcriptspost-translati driveonal the covalent epigenetic modifications state of a cell. which The can N-terminal then impact tails ofcritical histones DNA-dependent can undergo a varietyprocesses of post-translationallike replication, transcription, covalent modifications and repair which [11,12]. can thenHistone impact methylation critical DNA-dependent is mediated by processesmethyltransferases like replication, that catalyze transcription, the mono-, and di-, repair or tri- [11 methylation,12]. Histone of specific methylation residues. is mediated Dynamic byand methyltransferasesreversible methylation that catalyzeof histones the plays mono-, an important di-, or tri- role methylation in the regulation of specific of gene residues. expression. Dynamic Two andmajor reversible families methylation of histone of methyltransferases histones plays an importantare lysine role methyltransferases in the regulation (KMTs) of gene expression.and protein Twoarginine major methyltransferases families of histone methyltransferases(PRMTs). Whereas aremeth lysineylation methyltransferases of some lysine residues (KMTs) andis associated protein argininewith activation methyltransferases of gene transcription (PRMTs). Whereas (e.g., H3K4 methylation, H3K36, and of some H3K79), lysine methylation residues is associatedof other residues with activationis associated of gene with transcription repression of (e.g., gene H3K4, transcript H3K36,ion (e.g., and H3K79),H3K9, H3K20, methylation and H3K27) of other [13–15]. residues Some is associatedhistone modifications with repression are of enriched gene transcription at distinct (e.g.,regions H3K9, (i.e., H3K20, enhancer and, promoter, H3K27) [13 or–15 coding]. Some sequences) histone modificationsof the gene, though are enriched H3K27me3 at distinct is distributed regions (i.e.,wide enhancer,ly across enhancers promoter, and orcoding promoters sequences) [16]. Moreover, of the gene,mono-, though di-, H3K27me3or tri-methylation is distributed of a single widely residue across enhancerscan alter the and affinity promoters of “reader” [16]. Moreover, proteins mono-, to the di-,methylated or tri-methylation histones ofand a singlemay have residue distinct can alterfunctional the affi consequencesnity of “reader” [17]. proteins to the methylated histonesIn andparticular, may have tri-methylation distinct functional of the consequenceslysine at the 27th [17]. amino acid on histone H3 (H3K27me3) is a criticalIn particular, determinant tri-methylation of chroma oftin the accessibility lysine at the and 27th gene amino expression. acid on histoneThe “writer” H3 (H3K27me3) of H3K27me3, is aenhancer critical determinant of zeste 2 (EZH2) of chromatin (Figure accessibility 1), has been and known gene to expression. be involved The in “writer”tumor progression of H3K27me3, in an enhanceroncogenic of zestecapacity 2 (EZH2) for over (Figure twenty1), hasyears been [18–20] known. Detailed to be involved reviews in concerning tumor progression the activity in anand oncogenichistory of capacity the H3K27me3 for over methyltransferases, twenty years [18– 20EZH1]. Detailed and EZH2, reviews are available concerning [21,22]. the activityNevertheless, and historythe more of the recent H3K27me3 uncovering methyltransferases, of Jumonji-domain-containing EZH1 and EZH2, proteins, are available which are [21 capable,22]. Nevertheless, of catalyzing thethe more demethylation recent uncovering of H3K27me3, of Jumonji-domain-containing has revealed additional proteins, complexity which are capablesurrounding of catalyzing H3K27me3 the demethylation(Figure 1). of H3K27me3, has revealed additional complexity surrounding H3K27me3 (Figure1). FigureFigure 1. Regulated1. Regulated addition addition and removaland removal of H3K27me3 of H3K27me3 is critical foris maintainingcritical for cellularmaintaining homeostasis. cellular Functioninghomeostasis. as membersFunctioning of protein as members complexes, of protein the indicated complexes, enzymes the possessindicated the enzymes biochemical possess activity the tobiochemical alter the methylation activity to state alter at the H3K27 methylation while chromodomain-containing state at H3K27 while chromodomain-containing proteins, among others, haveproteins, the capacity among toothers, interpret have the the methylation capacity to state. interpret Disruption the methylation in this balance, state. whetherDisruption through in this mutationsbalance, (indicatedwhether through by strikethroughs), mutations (indicated altered recruitment by striketh (indicatedroughs), altered by change recruitment in nucleosome (indicated color), by over-expressionchange in nucleosome (indicated color), by additional over-expression boxes) or under-expression(indicated by additional (indicated boxes) by fewer or under-expression boxes), has the potential(indicated to driveby fewer and/ orboxes), support has tumorigenesis the potential through to drive the and/or expansion support of cell tumorigenesis fate identity. through the expansion of cell fate identity. Cancers 2020, 12, 2792 3 of 33 2.1. Molecular Mechanisms The primary H3K27me3 “writer” protein, EZH2, is the enzymatic component of the polycomb repressor complex 2 (PRC2) and is capable of catalyzing methylation of non-methylated H3K27 to either a di- or tri-methylated state. The C-terminal SET domain