Södertörns University College Spring 2006 Institution for Political Science Master’S Thesis: 20 Points Supervisor: Yonhyok Choe
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Södertörns University College Spring 2006 Institution for Political Science Master’s Thesis: 20 points Supervisor: Yonhyok Choe Political Personality and Foreign Policy Behavior: A Case Study of Kim Jong-Il and North Korea’s Negotiating Behavior Regarding the Nuclear Issue Chung-Hwan Kim ABSTRACT Political Personality and Foreign Policy Behavior: A Case Study of Kim Jong-Il and North Korea’s Negotiating Behavior Regarding the Nuclear Issue Author: Chung-Hwan Kim The aim of this paper is to analyze the North Korean leader Kim Jong-Il’s personality and its influence on North Korea’s negotiating behavior regarding the nuclear issue. Through the theory of social identity shaping and personality disorder, this study has generated a hypothesis by the operationalization of the theoretical framework. By using these analytical methods the following conclusions have been drawn: Kim Jong-Il had experienced a sense of loss and damaged self-esteem in his childhood. He had tried to compensate for these feelings through the film industry (which served as an ideological tool) in order to regain his father’s affection, and he succeeded in becoming recognized for his political ability. However, he overcompensated for these feelings of low self- esteem by removing his potential political enemies. The experiences made him acquire an idiosyncratic character and personality disorder. This study has found that North Korea’s nuclear negotiations with the United States since 1993 have reflected Kim Jong-Il’s personality. The model of the study can be used as a basis for further academic studies in the practical exploration of the correlations between a country’s foreign policy and its leader’s personality. Keywords : Kim Jong-Il, sense of loss, power seeking, personality, nuclear weapons program, negotiating behavior i Table of Contents Chapter 1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................1 1.1 Background .......................................................................................................................1 1.2 Purpose of the Study and Research Questions ..................................................................2 1.3 Methodology and Materials ..............................................................................................3 1.3.1 Methodology ..........................................................................................................3 1.3.2 Materials.................................................................................................................4 1.3.3 Trustworthiness and Impartiality ...........................................................................5 1.4 Scope of the Study.............................................................................................................5 1.5 Hypothesis.........................................................................................................................9 1.6 Previous Research ...........................................................................................................10 1.7 Structure of the Study......................................................................................................11 Chapter 2. Theoretical Framework................................................................................................12 2.1 Experiences in Early Years and Personality ...................................................................12 2.1.1 The Development of Psycho-Social Identity .......................................................12 2.1.2 Power Seeker Model ............................................................................................13 2.1.3 Power as Compensation .......................................................................................14 2.2 Personality and Policy Behavior .....................................................................................16 2.2.1 The Impact of Personality on Politics ..................................................................16 2.2.2 Personality and Foreign Policy Behavior.............................................................17 2.3 Typology of Personality Disorder...................................................................................19 2.3.1 Compulsive Personality Disorder.........................................................................20 2.3.2 Narcissistic Personality Disorder .........................................................................21 2.3.3 Paranoid Personality Disorder..............................................................................22 2.4 Critical View of Theories................................................................................................22 Chapter 3. Experiences in His Early Years ...................................................................................24 3.1 Dismal Days: Birth and Childhood .................................................................................24 3.1.1 Controversy over Kim Jong-Il’s Birth .................................................................24 3.1.2 Babyhood and Childhood.....................................................................................25 3.2 Leadership Development: Adolescence..........................................................................28 3.3 Involvement in Politics: University Days .......................................................................29 3.4 Kim Jong-Il’s Rise as Successor: Successful First Political Post at the KWP................30 3.4.1 Domestic and International Situation...................................................................30 3.4.2 Kim Jong-Il’s Struggle With His Uncle and Stepmother.....................................32 3.4.3 Secret Nomination of the Successor.....................................................................33 Chapter 4. Kim Jong-Il’s Political Personality and Policy Behavior............................................35 4.1 Kim Jong-Il’s Sense of Loss and Low Self-Esteem........................................................35 4.1.1. Sense of Loss.......................................................................................................36 4.1.2 Low Self-Esteem ..................................................................................................37 4.2 Looking for Power as Compensation: Hypothesis 1.......................................................37 4.2.1 Regaining His Father’s Affection ........................................................................38 4.2.2 Devotion to the Film Industry to Show His Loyalty to His Father......................40 4.3 Kim Jong-Il’s Political Personality: Hypothesis 2 ..........................................................42 4.3.1. Character .............................................................................................................42 4.3.2. Worldview...........................................................................................................44 ii 4.3.3 Style......................................................................................................................45 4.4. Idiosyncratic Policy Behavior: Hypothesis 3.................................................................46 4.4.1 Narcissistic Policy Behavior ................................................................................47 4.4.2 Paranoid Policy Behavior.....................................................................................48 4.5 Discussion .......................................................................................................................50 Chapter 5. Analysis of the Negotiating Behavior Regarding the Nuclear Issue and Kim Jong-Il’s Personality: Hypothesis 4..52 5.1 The Origin of the Nuclear Crisis on the Korean Peninsula.............................................52 5.2 The First Nuclear Crisis and Negotiations with the U.S.................................................53 5.3 The Second Nuclear Crisis and Negotiations with the U.S.............................................55 5.4 The Influence of Kim Jong-Il’s Personality on Nuclear Negotiations............................61 5.4.1 North Korea’s Position on the Nuclear Issue.......................................................61 5.4.2 Kim Jong-Il’s Personality and the Nuclear Issue.................................................63 5.5 Summary .........................................................................................................................66 Chapter 6. Findings and Conclusions............................................................................................68 6.1 How Was Kim Jong-Il’s Experiences in His Early Years?.............................................68 6.2 How Has Kim Jong-Il’s Personality Affected the North’s Nuclear Negotiations?.........69 6.3 Implications and Future Research...................................................................................70 References .....................................................................................................................................73 iii List of Abbreviations CVID Complete, Verifiable, Irreversible Dismantlement – the basic condition for the abolishment of North Korea’s nuclear weapons program that the Bush administration had demanded. Although the U.S. these days refrains from using this term as countries involved point out that the term also arouses feelings amongst the North Koreans, it is still the U.S.’s fundamental