This Electronic Thesis Or Dissertation Has Been Downloaded from the King’S Research Portal At
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This electronic thesis or dissertation has been downloaded from the King’s Research Portal at https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/ The characteristics of non-clinical fetishists, sadomasochists and transvestites. Gosselin, C C The copyright of this thesis rests with the author and no quotation from it or information derived from it may be published without proper acknowledgement. END USER LICENCE AGREEMENT Unless another licence is stated on the immediately following page this work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International licence. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ You are free to copy, distribute and transmit the work Under the following conditions: Attribution: You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work). Non Commercial: You may not use this work for commercial purposes. No Derivative Works - You may not alter, transform, or build upon this work. Any of these conditions can be waived if you receive permission from the author. Your fair dealings and other rights are in no way affected by the above. Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 09. Oct. 2021 -I -It % THE CHARACTERISTICS OF NON-CLINICAL FETISHISTS9 SADOMASOCHISTS AND TRANSVESTITES by Christopher C. Gosselin A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of the University of London Psychology Departmentt Institute of Psychiatry, De Crespigny Park, LONDON, S, E-5. January 1980 2 4. iiih;im- i CHAPTER Is BACKGROUND AND LITERATURE SURVEr 11 Introduction 11 Definitions and backgrounds (a) Fetishism. 12 Definitions and backgrounds (b) Sadomasochism 24 Definitions and backgrounds (c) Transvestism 47 Studies of variants and their behaviour 35 (a) Fetishism 56 . (b) Sadomasochism 57 (c) Transvestism 58 Trestment*studies 64 Aetiology of the sexual variations here studied 68 (a) Innate predisposition 69 (b) Physiological influences 72 (c) Traumatic experience 74 (d) Upbringing and learning experiences 75 Occurrence and interrelatedness of variations 80 S-ing up 81 CHAPTER III SAMPLES AND INSTRU=S 83 I Subjects 83 Materials 88 Methodst (a) Checks on the robustness of the Wilson Sax Fantasy Questionnairet 93 U) Response-consistency test 93 (2) Factor analysis comparisons 93 (b) Methods used in the main study 94 3 CHAPTER 1711 RESULTS 96 Data from tests on the Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaires (1) Response consistency over I month, test-retest paradigm 96 (2) Factor analysis comparisons 98 Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaire tests: Conclusions 104 Main study results 105 (1) Sex patte rn comparisonst (a) Individual themes 105 (b) Category ratings 117 (c) Group similarities 118 (d) Sex drive 121 (e) Sexual satisfaction 123 (2) Personality studies 136 (3) Sadists and masochists, sadism and masochism 141 (4) Studies of responses to items within the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire 148 (5) Studies of demographic, enviromental and child- rearing variables 152. (a) Age 152 (b) occupational status 156 (c) Presence or absence of partner 157 (d) Permissiveness of upbringing 158 (e) The role of punishment in childhood 159- CHAPTER IVt MINORITY GROUPS 161 Subjects 161 Resultst (1) Sex pattern comparisons (a) General ift (b) Group similarities 169 (a) Sexual drive 171 (2) Other WSPQ variables 172 (3) Personality studies 181 CHAPTER ,Vs DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS 184 RMRENCES 193 L. LIST OF TABIES Table Is Average change in ratings during a test-retest trial of each question in the Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaires 10 subjects used, test-retest interval 1 month* 97 Table 2ai Highest-value loadings of WSFQ fantasy themes on Varimax factors, control male samples 99 Table 2bi Highest-value loadings of WSFQfantasy themes on Varimax factors, male sademasochist samples 100 Table 2cs Highest-value loadings of WSPQ fantasy themes on Varimax factors, transvestite sample, 100 Table 2di Highest-value loadings of WSFQ fantasy themes on Varimax factors, rubber fetishist sample. 101 Table 3ai Highest-value loadings of WSFQ activity themes on Varimax loadings, control male samples 102 Table 3bi Highest-value loadings of WSPQ activity themes on Varimax factors, male sadomasochist sample* 103 Table 3cs Highest-value loadings of WSFQ activity themes on Varimax loadings, transvestite sample* 103 Table 3di Highest-value loadings of WSFQ activity themes on Varimax loadings, rubber fetishist sample. 104 Table 4as Mean ratings (and standard deviations) of male variant and control groups for fantasy and activity on each theme of the Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaire. 106 Table 4be_ The directions of differences and the significances of the differences between variant and control groups' ratings on each theme of the WSFQ* 107 Table 5t t-values for the difference between variant and control groups on their typifying theme in the WSFQo log Table 6ai Fantasy and activity ratings for categories according to Wilson, variant and control groups, plus si-ed ratings for all themeso 117 Table 6bi Category ratings as in Table 6a expressed as x. percentage of the total fantasy or activity output for the group in questim, 117 5 Table 71 Correlations between variant and normal groups on WSFQratings, plus differential significances. 119 Table 81 Mean ratings by the T group on reasons for cross- dressinge 120 -Table 9as Mean values (and standard deviations) of variant and control groups on measures of sex, drivee 121 Table 9bi Correlations for variant and control groulps between measures of sex drive. 121 Table 10i Ratings of sexual satisfaction of variant and control groups, plus Inter-measure correlations. 124 Table 11: Correlations of ratings of various WSFQ fantasies with ratings of sex mal drive and satisfaction, variant and control groups. Notes N group is a comparison sample of younir non-variant males taken from data by Wilson (1978)- 127 Table 121 Correlations WSFQ of ýexualratings of various activities with ratings of drive and satisfactiont variant and control groupso 131 Table 13, Mean scores (and standard deviations) of variant and control groups on personality factors measured by the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire* 136 Table 14as Correlations of key fantasy Items with Eysenck personality dimensions for S, L and T groups combined. 140 Table 14bt Correlations of key fantasy Items''from. the group concerned with Eysenck personality dimensions for that groups 140 Table 151 Mean scores (and standard deviations) on Eysenck personality dimensions of sadomasochists divided into those who are primarily sadistic and those who are primarily masochistic. 142 Table 161 Average correlations between ratings for sadistic and masochistic fantasies and Eysenck personality Dimensions, S group. 143 Table 17t Sadism scores, masochism scores and total fantasy ratings for all themes, control and variant groups 145 6 Table IS a Percentage of affirmative responses. for variant and control groups to selected questions from the Eysenck Personality Questionnaires 149 Table 19% Average sociometric status of variant and control groups* 157 (and Table 20a -Mean ratings standard deviations) of variant and control groups on aspects. of social background and upbringings 157 Table Z'-1 Correlations between Incidence of corporal punishment in childhood and various types of sexual fantasy for variant and control groups., 159 Table 22as Idean ratings (and standard deviations) of minority variant and control groups for fantasy and activity on each theme in the Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaire. 162 Table Z2bs 'The directions of differences and the significance -of difference between minority variant and -control groups* ratings on each theme of the WSFQ@ 163 Table Z3s Mean ratings (and standard deviations) for various measures of sex drive, minority variant and control groupse 1.64 Table 2ILas 7antas7 and activity ratings for categories according to Wilson, minority variant and -control groupst plus summed ratings for all themes* 166 Table Zkbs Category ratings as in Table 24a expressed as a percentage of the total fantasy or activity output for the group in question. 166 Table 25as Correlations between variant and control groups (including minorities) on WSFQ fantasy ratings, plus differential significances. 170 Table 251bs Correlations between variant and control groups (including minorities) on WSFQ activity ratings, plus differential significances, 170 Table 26, j Correlations for minority variant and control groups between measures of sex drive. 172 Table 271 Mean ratings (and standard deviations) for the remaining WSFQquestions, minority variant and control groups* 173 7 Table 281 Correlations of ratings of various WSFQ fantasies and activities with ratings of sexual drive and satisfaction, minority variant and control groups* 174 Table 29t Average correlations of fantasy and activity ratings for Intimate, Sadistic and Masochistic category themes with ratings of punishment frequency, '180 Table 301 Mean scores (and standard deviations) of minority variant and control groups on personality factors measured by the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire. 181 8 LIST OF FIGURES Fig. Ii The Wi2son Sex Fantasy Questionnaire* 89 Fig* 22 The relationship between fantasy and activity for control and variant groups (lines of best fit drawn through activity/fantasy scattergrams for each group). 125 Fig. 3a3