Abstract Preacher-As-Witness
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ABSTRACT PREACHER-AS-WITNESS: THE HOMILETICAL APPROACH OF E. STANLEY JONES by Luke Molberg Pederson Witness is a key metaphor that addresses postmodern yearning for authenticity and integrity in preaching in the current cultural milieu of the United States and Canada. The speaking and writing of twentieth-century world missionary and evangelist E. Stanley Jones provided a bountiful source of autobiographical material through which to explore Jones’ self- understanding as preacher-as-witness. The purpose of the study was to describe Jones’ homiletical self-understanding as witness to Jesus Christ, analyze the content of his speaking and writing as it pertains to preaching, and outline his sermonic approach. Jones’ underlying homiletical worldview was probed in its natural context through a grounded theory process of simultaneous data collection, analysis, and synthesis. All of Jones’ twenty-seven published books were scrutinized as well as ten selected sermons in print and in audio and videotape formats spanning sixty years of Jones’ preaching ministry. Samples of my own preaching were appended as examples of the integration of Jones’ approach with postmodern praxis. The focus of the study was not on others’ assessment of Jones, or critical evaluation of his preaching, but on his self- understanding as witness to Jesus Christ as a means to inform the present opportunity for preaching in a postmodern context. The study clarified boundaries between the metaphors of testimony, confession, and witness, offered an extension of Thomas G. Long’s work on the witness of preaching as an underappreciated metaphor for preaching, and presented witness as a theoretical bridge between speaker-driven and audience-driven polarities in preaching. The preacher- as-witness, as revealed in Jones’ speaking and writing, is an integrated person who, through immediate experience of Jesus Christ, speaks and lives out faith in him, respects but exercises discernment in the face of other religious and cultural traditions, centers unwaveringly on Jesus Christ, and introduces, interprets, and commends Jesus Christ in non-defensive public speech. Witness was Jones’ operative homiletical worldview and furnishes a rich metaphor for preachers’ self-understanding in the current postmodern context. DISSERTATION APPROVAL This is to certify that the dissertation entitled PREACHER-AS-WITNESS: THE HOMILETICAL APPROACH OF E. STANLEY JONES presented by Luke Molberg Pederson has been accepted towards fulfillment of the requirements for the DOCTOR OF MINISTRY degree at Asbury Theological Seminary October 31, 2006 Mentor Date October 31, 2006 Internal Reader Date October 31, 2006 Dean, Doctor of Ministry Program Date PREACHER-AS-WITNESS: THE HOMILETICAL APPROACH OF E. STANLEY JONES A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of Asbury Theological Seminary In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Ministry by Luke Molberg Pederson May 2007 © 2007 Luke Molberg Pederson ALL RIGHTS RESERVED TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements...........................................................................................................vii Chapter 1. Problem .............................................................................................................1 Statement of the Problem ..................................................................................1 Purpose Stated ...................................................................................................3 Research Questions ...........................................................................................3 Research Project ................................................................................................4 Biblical and Theological Foundation ................................................................4 Context and Biographical Overview .................................................................4 Jones as Witness.........................................................................................6 Jones as Preacher........................................................................................8 Methodology ....................................................................................................8 Data Collection and Analysis .....................................................................8 Delimitations and Generalizability.............................................................9 Overview of the Study.......................................................................................9 2. Literature .........................................................................................................11 Overarching Homiletical Framework..............................................................11 Conversational/Dialogical/Autobiographical Preaching.................................15 Philosophical and Theological Understanding of Witness..............................18 Biblical Understanding of Witness..................................................................24 Martus .............................................................................................................33 Jones’ Understanding of Witness ....................................................................36 Literature on Jones ..........................................................................................37 iii Biography .................................................................................................37 Theology...................................................................................................42 Missiology ................................................................................................47 Topical Studies .........................................................................................54 Jones’ Methodology Applied ...................................................................58 Hagiography .............................................................................................62 Qualitative Research Design Literature...........................................................65 Overview of the Method...........................................................................65 Role of the Researcher..............................................................................65 Data Collection.........................................................................................66 Data Organization.....................................................................................66 Data Analysis ...........................................................................................68 Summary Guidelines for Qualitative Research ........................................70 Validity, Reliability, and Credibility........................................................71 Autobiographical Analysis in Qualitative Research ................................72 Autobiographical Reflection Research and Jones ....................................73 3. Methodology ...................................................................................................74 Problem ...........................................................................................................74 Purpose ............................................................................................................74 Research Questions .........................................................................................74 Description of the Project................................................................................75 Instrumentation................................................................................................77 Reliability ........................................................................................................77 Validity............................................................................................................77 iv Data .................................................................................................................78 Sources .....................................................................................................78 Collection and Recording Procedures ......................................................79 Analysis ....................................................................................................80 4. Findings ...........................................................................................................82 Jones’ Books....................................................................................................82 Biblical Treatment of Witness..................................................................83 Theology of Witness.................................................................................85 Reliance upon Scripture and the Holy Spirit............................................89 Requisite Firsthand Experience of Jesus Christ .......................................91 Witness Embodied and Integrated in the Person of the Preacher.............92 Congenial and Direct Presentation of Jesus Christ...................................93 Jones’ Reflections on the Practice of Preaching.......................................97 Summary of Jones’ Treatment of Preacher-as-Witness in His Books .....99 Jones’ Sermons..............................................................................................100 Content Description and Analysis..........................................................101 Summary ................................................................................................115