Copyright by Anima Adjepong 2017
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright by Anima Adjepong 2017 The Dissertation Committee for Anima Adjepong Certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Afropolitan Projects: Creating Community, Identity, and Belonging Committee: Ben Carrington, Supervisor Oloruntoyin Falola Gloria Gonzalez-Lopez Jemima Pierre Nestor Rodríguez Afropolitan Projects: Creating Community, Identity, and Belonging by Anima Adjepong, A.B.; M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin May 2017 Dedication To HOLAAfrica! for throwing me a lifeline when I most needed one; and to the Ghanaian Community in Houston, without whom this project would not have been possible. Afropolitan Projects: Creating Community, Identity, and Belonging Anima Adjepong, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2017 Supervisor: Ben Carrington Abstract: Despite a dramatic growth in the numbers of African immigrants to the United States, until recently, this population has been marginal in studies about voluntary migration and race. Likewise, in mainstream scholarship about black identities, Africa appears as a site of imagination and struggle whilst contemporary Africans are frozen in an unchanging, parochial age. My dissertation addresses the marginalization of Africa and Africans in both race and migration studies through an ethnographic case study of a community of Ghanaians in Houston, Texas. The research considers how questions of religion, race, class, and sexual politics shape the community’s boundaries of belonging. I explore how answers to these questions inform members’ relationship with Ghana, Africa, Houston, and the United States more generally. The ways in which the community addresses these issues are part of what I call its Afropolitan projects, which advance a modern non-victimized narrative about Ghana and Africa more generally, and sustain the community’s identity as progressive, modern Ghanaians. By outlining the contours of one community’s Afropolitan projects, my research offers an urgent contribution to understanding contemporary African and black identities. The dissertation argues that within the intentionally curated community of Ghanaians in Houston, members engage Christianity, sexual and racial politics, and class respectability to claim their place in the United States and to a culturally complex and cosmopolitan v Ghanaian/African identity. These practices of belonging are produced through community members’ experiences as Christians, postcolonial Africans, and American residents and citizens. My analysis reveals how this particular Afropolitan project complicates possibilities for the community to find solidarity with working class and queer black/African people and instead aligns itself with heterosexual respectability and middle-class progress. By examining this black/African community formation through a theoretical lens that complicates flattened conceptualizations of community, this project proposes new ways of building solidarities across difference within the black diaspora. vi Table of Contents List of Tables ........................................................................................................... x List of Figures ......................................................................................................... xi Chapter One. Introduction ....................................................................................... 1 Epistemology and motivations ....................................................................... 4 What are Afropolitan Projects? ...................................................................... 8 Overview of the dissertation ......................................................................... 15 Chapter Two. Literature Review ........................................................................... 18 Community as belonging .............................................................................. 18 Culture as contested ideological terrain .............................................. 21 Culture and ethnicity ........................................................................... 23 Culture and identity ............................................................................. 26 Community as an orientation device ................................................... 27 Diaspora, difference, and hybridity ..................................................... 29 Immigration in the United States: When blacks enter .................................. 31 Imagining the immigrant ..................................................................... 33 Black immigrants and ethnicity ........................................................... 35 Racialization and black immigrants .................................................... 41 African Immigrants in the United States ...................................................... 46 Race, identity, and black African immigrants ..................................... 50 Considering gender, class, and sexuality among black/African immigrants .................................................................................................... 55 Conclusion .................................................................................................... 56 Chapter Three. Research Methods ........................................................................ 60 Case Selection: Why Ghanaians in Houston, Texas .................................... 61 The Ghanaian Community ........................................................................... 67 Access to the community .............................................................................. 70 Research Design ........................................................................................... 74 vii Employing “live methods” .................................................................. 77 In-depth interviews .............................................................................. 79 Data analysis ........................................................................................ 88 Invading Ethnography .................................................................................. 89 Taking up space in the field ................................................................. 93 Disorientation in the field .................................................................... 95 The politics of autoethnography: A combative native “I” ................... 98 Methodological Limitations ....................................................................... 100 Ethics .......................................................................................................... 101 Chapter Four. Little Lagos, African ethnicity and the Afropolitan ..................... 103 Introduction ................................................................................................ 103 Race, Ethnicity and Black Immigrant Identities ......................................... 104 From “Ghana Must Go” to #JollofWars: Ghana-Nigeria Relations ........... 108 Being Ghanaian in “Little Lagos” .............................................................. 112 Celebrating being Ghanaian in “Little Lagos” .................................. 114 “Our friends from the Nigerian Community” ................................... 119 MCGH and the “fear of Nigerians” ................................................... 121 Heterosexual politics of Ghanaian identities ..................................... 125 Being African in Houston, Texas ............................................................... 132 “African to my core”: The African identities of U.S.-born Africans 136 Being African from an Experiential Perspective ............................... 144 Houston, African Ethnicity and the Afropolitan ........................................ 149 Becoming Afropolitan, Complicating African as a Black Ethnicity .......... 154 Conclusion .................................................................................................. 156 Chapter Five. “Postracial America” and Being/Becoming Black ....................... 159 Introduction ................................................................................................ 159 Understanding Black Identities .................................................................. 162 Race in a U.S. Context ...................................................................... 163 Post/colonialism, race, and Africa ..................................................... 169 “Black like us” with a Different Mindset ................................................... 177 viii “Black like us” because “all they see is black” .......................................... 186 Obi man so: Ignorance/innocence about racism and postracial America ... 192 Living on “obi man so” in the time of Black Lives Matter ............... 197 Conclusion .................................................................................................. 205 Chapter Six. The Christian America Afropolitan Project ................................... 212 Introduction ................................................................................................ 212 Colonialism, Modernity, and Christianity in Ghana .................................. 215 Being Christian, Being Ghanaian ............................................................... 218 Ghanaian Christians in (white)