Written Public Comments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UPDATED: 02/06/17 @ 5:00 p.m. WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS This is a summary of comments that were submitted as part of and following the public hearing held at the November 21, 2016, Plan Commission meeting (including supplemented comments submitted for the January 17, 2017, and February 6, 2017, Plan Commission meetings). Docket Number: 1609-PUD-16 Petitioner: Pulte Homes of Indiana, LLC by Ice Miller, LLP Request: Petitioner requests a change of zoning of 799 acres +/- from the AG-SF1: Agriculture / Single-Family Rural District to the Wood Wind Planned Unit Development (PUD) District to allow for a mixed-use development to include a golf course, single-family residential, multi-family residential and commercial uses. (Link to September 6, 2016, Public Comments) Public Comments: Enclosed Attachments: 1. Laufter, Ross 2702 W 146th St (02/06/17, 11/03/16) 2. Davenport, Kim, Ken and Oni (11/04/16) 3. Huntsinger, Nina (11/04/16) 4. Davis, John 15515 Towne Rd (11/09/16) Davis, Charles (01/17/17) Davis, Nancy (01/17/17) Davis, Joe (01/16/17) Whitson, Carol (11/21/16) 5. Armstrong, Lisabeth 16414 Towne Rd. (02/05/17, 01/17/17) 6. Tatum, Susie (01/17/17) 7. Hedges, Stacy Century 21 Scheetz (11/15/16) 8. Murphy, Thomas W 161st St (01/16/17) 9. Albertson, Mark (11/15/16) 10. O’Connor, J Andrew and Megan 15201 Shelborne Rd (02/06/17, 11/15/16) Szigethy, Steven (11/21/16) 11. Levins, Richard and Sandy 15630 Towne Rd (02/05/17, 01/16/17) 12. Humphrey, Kurt (11/16/16) 13. Schreiber, Mary (11/16/16) 14. Gibson, Erin and Rick 2131 W 166th St (11/16/16) 15. Armstrong, Mikael (11/16/16) 16. Henry, Randy (11/16/16) 17. O’Neal, Doc Cohoat and O’Neal Management (11/17/16) Page 1 of 3 UPDATED: 02/06/17 @ 5:00 p.m. 18. Stafford, Cynthia and Steve 15736 Towne Rd (02/06/17, 01/15/17) 19. Smith, Jalene The Pines of Westfield (01/17/17) 20. Ackerson, Nels (11/17/16) Jamese, Karen 21. Moyer, Greg 15001 Shelborne Rd (02/06/17, 01/20/17, 01/17/17) 22. Connor, Mark Centennial (11/18/16) 23. Thompson Family Wood Wind Golf Course (01/15/17) 24. Davis, Bill High School Athletic Director (11/19/16) 25. Passman, Richard 3510 W 151st St (02/06/17, 01/17/17) 26. Mendler, Kerri (119/16) 27. Cook, Derek and Cherie 1740 W 161st St (02/05/17, 01/16/17) 28. Thayer, Teresa (11/20/16) 29. Koss, Bill and Karen 15411 Shelborne Rd (02/06/16, 11/20/16) 30. Scott, Ashley Viking Meadows (11/20/16) 31. Emmert, Beverly (11/20/16) 32. McColgin, Robert (11/20/16) McColgin, Scott (11/20/16) 33. Cohoat, Matt (11/19/16) 34. Crandall, Judy (01/16/17) 35. Rice, Melissa Beacon Point (11/21/16) 36. Henry, Marcia (11/21/16) 37. Polizzi, Steve (11/21/16) 38. Kotsanos, James and Annetta 0 W 156th St (11/21/16) 39. Cohoat, Jeff 16362 Trace Blvd, N Dr (11/21/16) 40. DiMascio, Mike 17028 Towne Rd. (01/17/17) 41. Welch, Diana on behalf of Anna Fesenko (11/21/16) 42. DuBois, Suzy (02/05/17, 01/20/17, 01/16/17, 11/21/16) 43. Gehr, Edwin (11/21/16) 44. Sochar, Cynthia and David (02/06/17, 01/16/17) 45. Plankis, Joe (11/21/16) 46. Lauft, Ross (Public Hearing PowerPoint) (11/21/16) 47. Westfield Citizens for Responsible Growth (11/21/16) 48. Watson, Bruce Centennial (11/21/16) Page 2 of 3 UPDATED: 02/06/17 @ 5:00 p.m. 49. Scheetz, Mike (11/22/16) 50. Hymbaugh, Karen 2929 W 159th St (02/06/17, 01/16/17) 51. Daly, John 15936 Little Eagle Creek Ave (01/15/17) 52. DuBois, John (Public Hearing PowerPoint) (11/21/16) 53. Pielemeier, Tracy (01/16/17) 54. Severson, Leah (01/17/17) 55. Martin, Mindy (02/06/17, 11/21/16) 56. Burkman, Kristen (02/06/17, 01/20/17, 01/20/17, 01/16/17, 11/21/16) 57. Motsinger, Joshua (Central Christian Church) (12/28/16) 58. Citizens Energy Group (01/09/17) 59. Beckner, Martin (01/16/17) 60. Gllim, Sarah 16505 Little Eagle Creek Ave (01/16/17) 61. McCurry, Clint (01/16/17) 62. Smith, Denny 15951 Little Eagle Creek Ave (02/07/17, 01/16/17) 63. Van Natta, Bruce and Alison 1812 W 156th St (01/16/17) 64. Hall, Stacy 2001 W 166th St (01/16/17) 65. Knight, Jon and Dawn (01/16/17) 66. Arnold, Kyle and Twyla (01/16/17) 67. Frei, Scott (01/17/17) 68. Masser, Mark (01/17/17) 69. Watkins, Sarah W 166th St (02/06/17, 01/23/17, 01/17/17) 70. Responsible Growth Alliance of Westfield (01/17/17) 71. Naas, Linda 161st Street Neighbors (01/17/17) 72. Fineis, Ken Little Eagle Creek Avenue (02/06/17) 73. Smith, Robert 136 S 9th St, Noblesville, IN (02/06/17) 74. Tolan, Danielle Washington Township Trustee (02/05/17) 75. White, Gloria (02/06/17) 76. Armstrong, Laurence 2553 S 1200 E (02/06/17) Page 3 of 3 Jesse Pohlman From: Laufter, Ross J. <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, February 6, 2017 11:01 AM To: Council Members; APC; Andy Cook; Jesse Pohlman; Matt Skelton; [email protected]; [email protected] Cc: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; dub164 @aol.com Subject: Pulte Woodwind Local Business Node Please do not approve the PUD as it exist currently. This PUD does not follow the comprehensive plan or the UDO. Look at my email below and see the red arrows pointing to the violations of this PUD. 1. A multi‐family unit qualifying as MF‐1 should not be located within one half (.5) miles of another multi‐family zoning district. 2. MF‐1 Maximum Number of Dwelling Units: Forty‐eight (48) per project/district. Let’s stay Westfield not Westfilled. There is too much density and not enough true greenspace in this PUD as it exist today. Ross Laufter From: Laufter, Ross J. Sent: Friday, January 20, 2017 1:37 PM To: '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]' Cc: [email protected]; [email protected]; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]' Subject: Pulte Woodwind Local Business Node APC, Council Members and Mayor Please understand my family does not want a gas station or apartments next to our residence in the Local Business node. The apartments are in violation of the UDO for being within .5 miles of another MF district. See graphic below. Also note in the graphic how much commercial is approved and how much more is being proposed. This was not the intention of the Comprehensive Plan. Thanks, Ross Laufter CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential Appartments would be a 1 violation of the UDO and privileged information or may otherwise be protected by law. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message and any attachment thereto. 2 Jesse Pohlman From: Ross Lauft <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, November 3, 2016 5:22 PM To: APC; Jesse Pohlman; Council Members; [email protected]; Kristen Burkman; Tina Laufter Subject: Wood Wind PUD vs. the Right Development Westfield APC and Council, As a resident of Westfield and a homeowner who will be impacted greatly by the Wood Wind PUD, I ask you kindly to take my and all the impacted homeowners interests into consideration when making decisions on this development. I think Kristen Burkman and Suzy DeBois have done a great job in rallying the community to make sure this development is done right. I strongly agree with their cause and emphasize the points below... 1. Eliminating the apartments from the proposal 2. My rural lifestyle and property values should not be negatively impacted by new development per the comp plan and 5 criteria for a zoning change 3. Architecture should be in context (we all have unique, custom homes out here) per the comp plan 4. Density should be less as you move west from Ditch Road and north from 146th and south from 32 per the comp plan 5. Open space should increase per the comp plan 6. There should be meaningful transition between rural residences and new development per the comp plan ‐ with this density, a meaningful transition doesn't exist. 7. Lowering the total number of homes to 670 ‐ Less Dense 8. Increasing Buffers for adjoining long term rural residences 9. Adding Outdoor Recreation amenities such as parks, fishing/paddle boat water features, dog park, community garden, picnic areas, bocce ball courts, etc. Increasing open green space in all areas 10. Decreasing density as the development moves north and west Sincerely, Ross Laufter From: Kristen Burkman <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, November 3, 2016 4:10 PM To: Abigail Angrick; Adam Essex; [email protected]; Becky Moyer; Brandee; Brandy Dravet; Brenda Myers; brianlcardinal; Bruce Van Natta; Cindy; Cook; Cynthia Stafford; Dave Sochar; David Todd; Dawn Knight; [email protected]; Dick Levins; [email protected]; Erin Gibson; Gary Vance; [email protected]; gloria White; Henry Armstrong; James Engle; Joe Mccarthy; John Daly; Karen H; [email protected]; Kemmer, Dennis; Ken Fineis; Ken Kingshill; Kendra Essex; Leah Severson; lisabeth armstrong; Mark Behrens; Megan; Melissa Noparstak; Michael DiMascio; Michael Pingleton; [email protected]; [email protected]; nancy martin; Noah Herron; 1 [email protected]; Patrick Heitz; Paul Zawadzki; Riley Pingleton; robertbehring; Robyn Wilds; [email protected]; rpassman; Sarah Watkins; [email protected]; Stacy Hall; Stephenie Franco; susie tatum; [email protected]; T.