Sunland Tribune

Volume 29 Article 4

2003

"Letter from Okeechobee" 1880s Editorial of Gabriel Cunning to Bartow Informant and Tampa Sunland Tribune

Michael Reneer

James M. Denham

Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/sunlandtribune

Recommended Citation Reneer, Michael and Denham, James M. (2003) ""Letter from Okeechobee" 1880s Editorial of Gabriel Cunning to Bartow Informant and Tampa Sunland Tribune," Sunland Tribune: Vol. 29 , Article 4. Available at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/sunlandtribune/vol29/iss1/4

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Sunland Tribune by an authorized editor of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "Letter From Okeechobee" 1880s Editorial Of Gabriel Cunning To Bartow Informant and Tampa Sunland Tribune

Michael Reneer and Dr. James M. Denham of Boully's informants wrote irregularly, think justice demands that Gabriel Gunning's "Letter from Okeechobee" Okeechobee should be heard," became a mainstay in the first six months wrote Gabriel Cunning on June of the paper's existence. 30, 1881. So began Cunning's As the county seat of Polk County, brief but interesting career as correspon­ , Bartow offered many prospects to dent to the Bartow Informant and Tampa Boully and other migrants seeking a new Sunland Tribune. Gabriel Cunning's given start in the post Civil War era. In 1880, name is unknown; his home and real iden­ Polk's population stood at slightly more than tity is likewise unknowable. And yet, letters 3,100 inhabitants. Even so, this total was from a man calling himself Gabriel Cunning poised to advance rapidly. At the time and claiming a home in "Okeechobee Cunning addressed readers of the Bartow County"! appeared in the Bartow Infor­ Informant, cattle and subsistence farming mant from June to December 1881. was the chief economic pursuit of pioneers Cunning also penned three missives to the in the Lower Peninsula. Indeed, the cattle Tampa Sunland Tribune in 1878 and 1881. industry was the true key to riches for the His humorous and informative letters pioneers of South Florida. Before the Civil reprinted here shed light on the social, eco­ War, the cattle trade with Cuba was sub­ nomic, and political times of the lower stantial, but after the war it brought consid­ Florida frontier in the 1880s. erable wealth to the region. At the end of the The first issue of the Bartow Informant Civil War, the focus of trade shifted from appeared only two weeks before the first supplying Confederate and Union forces to installment from Gabriel Cunning. The supplying Cuba. In the decade after the war, proprietor of this new journalistic enter­ pioneers shipped almost 200,000 head of prise was D.W.D. Boully, who emigrated to cattle from Florida to Cuba.2 In 1878, for Bartow after a failed attempt in the news­ example, the Tampa Sunland Tribune re­ paper business in Blountsville, Alabama. It ported that cattlemen shipped 8,012 head of was common practice for small-town nine­ cattle worth $112,168.00 from the Tampa teenth century newspapers such as Boully's Bay ports of Tampa and Manatee.3 While Informant to make use of guest "infor­ cattle shipments from were sub­ mants" or "correspondents" to provide stantial during these years, it is unlikely that readers with information on places and they ever equaled the numbers shipped events from nearby locales. Such articles from Punta Rassa, in Charlotte Harbor, spurred community interest and were Florida's oldest shipping point. In 1879, F.A. eagerly sought after by the general reading Hendry, of Fort Myers, estimated that in the public. In addition to Cunning's "Letter five previous years an average of 10,000 from Okeechobee" column, Boully's paper head of cattle, at a price of $14 per head, included letters and articles from Manatee were shipped each year from Punta Rassa.4 County, Charlotte Harbor, Hernando Citrus and vegetable growing also attract­ County, Ft. Meade, and Tampa. While some ed migrants. Nearly every edition of news- 13 papers published in Tampa, Orlando, Bartow Kississimee River. Below Fort Bassinger, and other South Florida towns contained and located near the western shore of Lake articles for perspective migrants extolling Okeechobee, was the village that grew the various advantages of certain crops and around abandoned Fort Center. It is likely the availability of land. By way of example, · that Cunning addressed his readers from on September 4, 1879, the Tampa Sunland one of these two settlements. Just to the Tribune, in an article titled "Culture and south of these two settlements lay the Shipment of Vegetables," lauded the ease . South Florida's earli­ and profitability with which garden peas, est settlers speculated on the feasibility of cucumbers, tomatoes, potatoes, and squash­ connecting the river to the lake, but by es could be grown in South Florida. 1879, these high hopes were about to be re­ But if Cunning and his neighbors in the alized. In the spring of that year, a Tampa southern peninsula were to truly prosper, newspaper reported that J.L. Meigs, a U.S. they needed communication and trans­ Surveyor, had arrived in Fort Myers "on his portation links to the isolated region. They way to the headwaters of the Caloosahatchee yearned for iron rails to reach their isolated to give the river a thorough survey, and to communities. Cunning's dispatches speak make a report upon the feasibility, of open­ to these aspirations. In 1867, telegraph ing the Okeechobee into the river." F.A. messages could be received at Punta Rassa Hendry of Fort Myers, and a number of his and, in 1884, the first trains chugged into associates, were conducting an indepen­ Tampa. By that time thousands of migrants dent survey of their own.11 were heading to the region to invest in cit­ While this trackless region was home to rus groves. Phosphate strikes in the late the , cattlemen, panthers, and on­ 1880s attracted hundreds of others.s ly a few hardy homesteaders, local citizens Cunning also writes of Hamilton Disston's were optimistic about the fertility of the soil purchase of four million acres of land from and the desirability and prospects of out­ the state of Florida for $.25 per acre. side immigration. One newcomer boasted Disston's dream was to use the latest tech­ that "Okeechobee is one of the finest lakes nology to drain the overflowed lands. in Florida with only 2 islands in it with fine Through this scheme thousands of acres of hammock and prairie land nearly all around land could be sold at cheap prices to it suitable for cane, com, rice or vegetables migrants who could grow citrus and a mul­ also for fruits, oranges, guavas, bananas, titude of other tropical crops. Cunning pine apples &c. The Indians have fields and speaks to this scheme plus speculates on raise fine com, potatoes, pumpkins, and the nefarious political machinations that bananas, which all grow finely and with made it possible. little cultivation. Lovers of picturesque In 1880, only three counties and only a scenery should made a trip through, when few settlements graced the southern part of the canal is completed, plenty of game of the peninsula south of Polk County: nearly all kinds, and fish in abundance."12 Manatee (pop. 3,500), Dade (pop. 257) and Cunning addressed readers of the Monroe County (pop. 11,800).6 Informant and the Sunland Tribune at the (which would become the region's only real time when White Conservatives had retak­ city) contained just a few dozen people in en control of state government. Florida had 1880. Because the vast majority of Monroe overthrown Radical Republican rule four County's population resided in the island years earlier. Florida's Bourbon governors, village of Key West, no more than 5,000 George Drew and William D. Bloxham, souls would have lived in the southern brought their economic policies to a public peninsula south of Bartow. This total in­ eager for better times. It was a policy of low cluded approximately 200 living taxes, slashed state expenditures, and land in five villages. 7 Only a few cattle trails and giveaway schemes calculated to lure primitive roads, cut primarily by the army's Northern investment capital to the state to corps of engineers during the Seminole develop the · state's ··resources and lure Wars, linked distant frontier outposts such migrants to Florida's open spaces. By 1880, as Pine Level (Manatee County Seat), the in Florida, as in the rest of the South, the village of Manatee (now Bradenton),8 Fort Republican Party (now discredited among Green, Fort Ogden,9 Fort Myers, and Fort white Southerners as the party of Carpet­ Bassinger,10 on the west bank of the baggers, Scalawags, and African-Americans), 14 became a marginalized victim of the solid Okeechobee county presents induce­ Democratic South. Cunning's letters are re­ ments to emigration far superior to any flective of white conservative public opin­ county in Florida, or to any other state or ion of the time. Readers of the Informant territory on the continent. One of its great and Sunland Tribune would have reveled in advantages is, that it has room enough for his stories. Both were Conservative Demo­ all who may come, possessing all that vast cratic papers in a state increasingly taken expanse of country extending from the over by Bourbonism.13 Atlantic ocean on the east, to the empire of Cunning addressed the readers of the Manatee on the west; bounded by the sand Informant and the Sunland Tribune in the mountains, or backbone of Florida, on the manner and style of the southern humorists north, and running south to infinity; of the ante- and post-hel- including the great ium periods. Such writers lake which bears its as Mark 1\vain and Joel name, with the For health Okeechobee stands Chandler Harris no doubt and Big served as a model for superb - she has no gra

"Letter from Okeechobee" Bartow Informant, October 20, 1881 Gabriel Cunning Ed. Informant

t has been determined upon the part of I the people of Okeechobee to keep clear of lawyers, believing them to be detrimental to the good of society; and the present condi­ tions of our county; such that litigation would work a great hardship to many of our people. For instance, many of our county officers have, through ignorance _of law, charged higher fees than the law strictly allows; and some of them, through actual necessity, have been compelled to use pub­ lic money, which they honestly design to refund so soon as the railroad comes, and two stout cabbage palmettos logs prepared. they can dispose of their real estate. There for the purpose. The testimony being heard, are also a great many of our guardians and our little upstart walked around behind a administrators that are, from the same cabbage stump, on top of which he had an cause, behind on settlement, and they and armful of his leather-back books stacked. their bondmen would be ruined, was it not He began his speech, and soon convinced for the clemency of Judge Pluck - he having the bystanders that he was an unsophisti­ much of their money borrowed, which they cated idiot, by using all kinds of Seminole loan him at low per cent., kindly allowing words, which he had picked up from the him to charge liberal costs, and paying him squaws during his short stay among us - a little besides, he in a most noble and gen­ such terms as "res geste," lis pendens,32 erous manner refrains from oppressive sine qua non,33 ad infinitum,34 and other measures. Seminole gibberish, which no Indian him­ This being the condition of things, we self, could have understood. He then well knew that the advent of a little, snivel­ opened his books and began reading and ing, strap toad lawyer in our midst would oh! forever! such sights and immensities as soon set Okeechobee in a buzz - would that poor fellow did read! He beat Bill soon have all our official bondmen seated Arp's35 lawyer - no touch! He read from into a gin-shop, and all the old widows and [William] Blackstone36 on immigration, orphans clapper clawing at the heels of [Joseph Kinnicutt] Angell37 on limitation, Judge Pluck for the benefit of said lawyer [James] Kent38 on meditation, [Theophilus] collecting their estate on the halves. Such a Parsons39 on concentration, [Joel Prentiss] state of affairs would ruin our prosperity, Bishop40 on recreation - and for my life I unless we burnt our courthouse; and that can't tell how many actions he did read we hate to do. Therefore we set our faces about. But all that had any point was a like flint against the location of a lawyer in story written by a fellow named Baiment our midst, and were quite fortunate in on broken buggies and borrowed horses. cold-shouldering every one who put in his As he finished reading, a nigger and half­ appearance, till he disappeared in the breed on the jury got to quarreling in saw-grass. Indian. Sheriff McKillop was lying on the But recently we got hold of rather a pine straw sound asleep. Judge Pluck was tough customer, who did not seem to see leisurely lighting his cob pipe at the a point, or take a hint. Said customer was a mosquito fire, paying no attention whatever little, box-toad, dwarf of a fellow, with right to the disturbance - it being no unusual pants, swallow-tailed coat, standing collar, occurrence in his court. But the little and a zinc trunk, full of leather-back books. Pickwickety lawyer, wishing to say He seemed determined to stay; and, despite something to look smart, remarked, that as the frown, sneers, insinuations, reproaches, the sheriff was asleep, he would recom­ rebuffs, insults, slights, reflections, cold mend that the court appoint an elisor41 to shoulders, and such like, he persisted in keep order - pronouncing the word elisor in remaining. Judge Pluck tried to bluff him old style. Judge Pluck dropped his pipe, by demanding a month's board in advance, and, clenching his fists, made for the speak­ supposing he couldn't chink; but he er, exclaiming, "You scoundrel! You villain, chinked. dog and thief! You dare insult me by asking Fearing he might create disturbance in that my wife be appointed sheriff of my own our county matters, we took the precaution court? I'll show you, sir, that Annalizer to hide all our court and county records in Pluck, if she was a Minorcan when I married a hallow cypress. We thought this ought to her, is not the wife of a county judge and check mate him, but it failed. He still stayed mistress of a hotel and act to be scandalized and nosed around, till at last he got up a lit­ by a scabbed nosed salamander like you!" tle lawsuit, and filed the papers before The thunder-struck attorney, who had Judge Pluck. The Judge holds court in the been falling back in good order as the judge cypress park on the edge of the lake, at the advanced, felt suddenly relieved by sheriff junction of Guiteau Street and ship canal. McKillop springing between them, and The case coming on, Judge Pluck took seizing the Judge in his arms, slowly hustled his seat upon a cypress stump cushioned him back to his cypress stump. The sheriff with a hog-skin, while the jury occupied insisted that the Judge hold his boots and 29 calm down, so that the lawyer could within my rule, sir. Don't doubt by authori­ apologize or explain. ty again, if you don't want to get saddled The Judge at last cooled, and the little with a fine for contempt." fellow explained - you bet he explained - The little box-toe had to explain again, and to our surprise, the took up one of the and then he began closing but before he got leather-backed books and read, sure to the amen, he suggested that he had enough, that in case of the absence of a abridged his arguments and made his sheriff, the judge could appoint an officer in speeches rather multum in paroum. 43 his place, called an elisor. This was a new The Judge looked fierce again, when point in Okeechobee, and slightly reflected sheriff McKillop interrupted the speaker by on the ignorance of the court. The Judge telling him that the Judge's knowledge of felt chawed. He apolo- Indians was very shaky gized at arm's length, and he had better not and in furtherance of By this time our leading citi- use any more Seminole justice ordered Major terms. The little fellow Plute, the clerk, to en­ ~ens in concla