1 the End of the Local School? a Comparative

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

1 the End of the Local School? a Comparative Paper prepared for the CPSA Annual Conference, Ryerson University, Toronto, May 30 – June 2, 2017 Do not cite or quote without permission of the author THE END OF THE LOCAL SCHOOL? A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF SCHOOL CHOICE POLITICS IN SWEDEN AND FRANCE1 Anne Lachance, Queen’s University This article examines the politics of school choice in Sweden and France. It seeks to explain why Swedish reformers succeeded in abolishing the residentially-based school system, while equally motivated French politicians could only implement a modest relaxation of residence-based admission criteria. To understand this variation in policy outcomes, I take a two-fold institutional and coalitional approach. First, I argue that Swedish institutions were more open to change than French institutions, especially at the implementation stage. Second, Swedish reformers attracted a broader support for their policies. Even after the right-wing government lost power, the Social Democrats could not find enough support in Parliament to reform the new system as much as they wanted. In France, the government was unable to build a coalition that was broad enough to fully implement its policy agenda. The collaboration with local governments was difficult, and unions protested strongly against the reform. During the last 25 years, the spread of school choice policies has been the most important trend in the evolution of education systems in advanced democracies (Musset, 2012). School choice reforms share the objective of breaking the traditional link between public schooling and neighbourhood (Berry Cullen, 2005). In choice-based education systems, there no longer is a ‘local public school’ frequented by all the children who live nearby. Residence-based admission criteria are weakened, and families are empowered to select from several school options. As a result, public schools must compete to attract students. By positing parents as consumers and schools as competing service providers, school choice policies create ‘educational markets’ (Feinberg and Lubienski, 2008: 2). In 1994, only a handful of countries had implemented school choice arrangements (OECD, 1994). However, by 2010, nearly two-thirds of OECD countries had followed their lead (Musset, 2012). One of the countries that moved the furthest in this direction is Sweden. After the 1991 election, center-right parties formed a coalition government, thereby ending nine years of social democratic rule. The government undertook reforms that radically transformed the way education was delivered. It replaced the residentially-based system with a universal school voucher system, in which families were given a tuition voucher that they could use in any school (Proposition 1992/93:230).2 The voucher system not only included public schools, but also schools run by private groups (called “free schools” in Sweden). Vouchers used in free schools were worth 85% of the value of vouchers used in public schools (Proposition 1991/92:95). That percentage was lowered to 75% in 1994, after the Social Democrats came back to power. However, they reversed their decision in 1996, and free schools began to receive the same amount per student as public schools (Proposition 1995/96:200). The transition towards a choice-based education system, therefore, was accepted by all the major political parties by the middle of the 1990s. At the opposite end of the spectrum, the French government failed to abolish its residentially-based school system, even though the main candidates in the 2007 election supported school choice reforms. In fact, one of Nicolas Sarkozy’s core electoral promises was to abolish the ‘school map,’3 which had been used to organize the attribution of students to public schools since 1 This project is supported by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. 2 The “Proposition” is the bill passed in Parliament. It is listed under Sveriges Regeringen in the bibliography. 3 The school map divides French departments in small zones. All students who reside in a zone are expected to attend the same public school (Van Zanten and Obin 2010). 1 Paper prepared for the CPSA Annual Conference, Ryerson University, Toronto, May 30 – June 2, 2017 Do not cite or quote without permission of the author 1963. After the abolition of the school map, Sarkozy argued, families would be able to choose any public school that fitted their needs better than the neighbourhood school (Soulé, 2007). His main opponent in the election, the socialist Ségolène Royal, also said she supported the abolition of the school map, before she reconsidered her position and argued for a relaxation of residence-based admission criteria (Soulé, 2006a). After Sarkozy’s election, the new Education Minister, Xavier Darcos, was asked to launch the education reforms. In the spring of 2007, residence-based admission criteria were relaxed (Education nationale, 2007a). This was supposed to be the first step in the progressive abolition of the school map, which Darcos expected to complete by 2010 (Education nationale, 2007b). However, he never took a second step in that direction. Instead, the commitment to abolish the school map was abandoned. This article seeks to explain why Swedish politicians succeeded in abolishing the residentially-based school system while equally motivated French politicians were unable to do so. To understand this variation in policy outcomes, I will take a twofold ‘institutional’ and ‘coalitional’ approach. First, I argue that Swedish institutions were more open to change than French institutions, especially at the implementation stage. Indeed, Swedish policy makers faced few obstacles after winning the support of Parliament, and previous education reforms facilitated the introduction of school choice. In contrast, the French government had many challenges to overcome at the implementation stage. In particular, it had to negotiate with local authorities with which it shared authority over the school map. Second, I argue that the Swedish actors succeeded at building a broader coalition in favour of school choice policies than their French counterparts. In Sweden, the left was divided over school choice policies: the Social Democrats and the small Left Party were against the reforms, while the Green Party supported the changes. Furthermore, teachers’ unions did not strongly oppose the reforms. In France, while the Socialists were divided over this issue during the electoral campaign, the left parties and their allies ultimately opposed a united front against the reforms after the election. The article is organized in four sections. The first focuses on the theoretical approach used in the paper. In the second section, the methods used to collect data are presented. The third and fourth sections of the article respectively examine the Swedish and French cases. Historical Institutionalism, the Power Resources Theory, and Policy Change To understand why Swedish policymakers succeeded in abolishing the residentially-based school system while their French counterparts could not, this article takes a twofold approach which combines historical institutionalism and the power resources theory. Historical institutionalism provides tools to understand the way institutional change unfolds, and emphasizes the importance of timing and sequencing in explaining political outcomes. However, this approach lacks a theory of action when it comes to explaining policy change. Therefore, it will be supplemented with the power resources theory, an approach which clearly identifies the driving forces behind institutional reforms. Historical institutionalism Like other variants of new institutionalism, historical institutionalism seeks to elucidate the role that institutions play in determining political outcomes (Hall and Taylor, 1996: 936). Historical institutionalists argue that the existing institutions of a polity constrain the political process, since the forces driving change are mediated by contextual features inherited from the past (Hall and 2 Paper prepared for the CPSA Annual Conference, Ryerson University, Toronto, May 30 – June 2, 2017 Do not cite or quote without permission of the author Taylor, 1996: 941). Political institutions, state structure, and state-interest groups relations therefore all shape politics (Immergut, 1998: 17). The most distinctive feature of historical institutionalism is its understanding of historical development, which it considers to be ‘path-dependent.’ Path-dependency refers to the way the initial steps taken in a direction conditions further movement on the same path (Pierson 2000, 74). Pierson (2000: 76) argued that institutions go through three phases: first, an initial critical juncture begins a movement towards a certain path; second, the institution enters its 'phase of reproduction,' in which positive feedback reinforces the trajectory that was initiated earlier; and third, the path ends when new events transform the previous equilibrium. In between these critical junctures, therefore, institutions are relatively stable. As Pierson puts it, during the reproduction phase, “change continues, but it is bounded change.” (Pierson, 2000: 76). Many scholars have used some form of the path-dependency argument over the last decades (e.g. Mahoney, 2001; Capoccia and Kelemen, 2007), while other authors have developed tools to understand bounded change that occur in between crises (e.g. Hacker, 2004; Thelen, 2004; Streek and Thelen, 2005). While historical institutionalism is helpful to explain how institutions constrain
Recommended publications
  • Handlingsplan För Publicitet
    Naturskyddsföreningens valenkät 2014 Fråga om ägardirektiv för Vattenfall Genomförd inom ramen för Westanders ”Stora Valenkäten 2014” 2014-08-20 Innehåll 1. Sammanfattning .................................................................................................................. 3 2. Samlat resultat .................................................................................................................... 4 3. Svaren per parti ................................................................................................................... 5 4. Svaren per län ..................................................................................................................... 6 4.1. Svarsfrekvens per län .................................................................................................... 6 4.2. Svar per län och kandidat med kommentarer: Vattenfall .............................................. 7 1. Sammanfattning Westander genomförde våren 2014 Stora valenkäten till 510 riksdagskandidater på valbar plats. Totalt deltog 22 aktörer i enkäten. Naturskyddsföreningen deltog bland annat med följande fråga: Statliga Vattenfall är en stor ägare av kolkraftverk och miljardsatsar för att planera för nya kärnkraftverk i Sverige. Anser du att Vattenfall ska få nya ägardirektiv som anger att bolaget ska fasa ut användningen av fossila bränslen, avbryta satsningen på nya kärnkraftverk och bli ledande i omställningen till ett helt förnybart energisystem? Med svarsalternativen: Ja Nej Tveksam/vet ej/vill ej svara 354
    [Show full text]
  • Visions of the Future: What Can Be Achieved with a Baltic Sea Strategy?
    Visions of the Future: what can be achieved with a Baltic Sea Strategy? Documentation package Included is the following: • Overview programme • Seminar flyer • Presentation by Dr. Christian Ketels • Presentation by Alf Vanags • Presentation by Ulf Johansson • Contact information for participants For additional information, please contact Dr. Mikael Olsson, Sida Baltic Sea Unit, Box 1271, SE-621 23 Visby, Sweden. E-mail: [email protected] or [email protected]. Phone: +46-(0)732-572511 The future Baltic Sea Region Possible paths of development in the light of the emerging EU-strategy for the region Overview programme, 7-8 July, 2008 On 7-8 July, 2008, the Baltic Sea Unit constitutes one of the prioritised areas of the (Östersjöenheten) of the Swedish International Swedish presidency. Development Cooperation Agency (Sida) and Baltic Development Forum, in cooperation The meeting will focus on the parts of the with the Centre for Baltic and East European Baltic Sea Strategy that aim to deepen Studies (CBEES), Södertörn University integration and increase the global College, will arrange an international competitiveness of the region. seminar/workshop with the aim to present and discuss visions of the future of the Baltic Sea Region as well as the challenges that need to be overcome to reach the goal of a well integrated and prosperous region. The programme brings together key politicians, civil servants, practitioners and high-level academic expertise in the areas of discussion. A total of three seminars and three workshops are arranged during the two days. All events take place right in the centre of medieval Visby on the premises of the Baltic Sea Unit (Östersjöenheten) (Donners Plats 1).
    [Show full text]
  • Plikt Att Förhindra Radikalisering
    M156 Kommittémotion Motion till riksdagen 2016/17:3290 av Andreas Norlén m.fl. (M) Plikt att förhindra radikalisering Förslag till riksdagsbeslut 1. Riksdagen ställer sig bakom det som anförs i motionen om ett förtydligat ansvar för skolhuvudmän och andra som arbetar med barn och unga att främja demokratiska värderingar och motverka extremistiska värderingar och tillkännager detta för regeringen. 2. Riksdagen ställer sig bakom det som anförs i motionen om innebörden av ett förtydligat ansvar för skolhuvudmän och andra som arbetar med barn och unga att upptäcka och motverka radikalisering och tillkännager detta för regeringen. 3. Riksdagen ställer sig bakom det som anförs i motionen om att öka kunskapen i kommuner och skolor och hos andra aktörer om hur radikalisering kan upptäckas och motverkas på ett tidigt stadium och tillkännager detta för regeringen. Inledning En viktig del i arbetet mot extremism och terrorism är förebyggande insatser. Riksdagen tillkännagav den 3 februari 2016, på förslag av allianspartierna i konstitutionsutskottet, för regeringen att det finns anledning att se över behovet av ett förtydligat ansvar för skolhuvudmän och andra som arbetar med barn och unga att motverka radikalisering, liksom formerna för ett sådant ansvar. Den här motionen syftar till att närmare beskriva vad detta ansvar bör innebära. Allianspartiernas förslag var inspirerat av den så kallade prevent duty (”plikt att förhindra”) som lagreglerades i Storbritannien 2015. Här nedan följer därför först en beskrivning av den brittiska lagstiftningen och därefter följer en diskussion om vad som bör göras i Sverige. Prevent duty i Storbritannien Beskrivningen här nedan bygger på rapporten ”Prevent duty” i Storbritanninen från riksdagens utredningstjänst (dnr 2015:1960).
    [Show full text]
  • 80 År För Öppenhet Och Frihet
    80 år för öppenhet och frihet 80 år för öppenhet och frihet Copyright © Moderata Ungdomsförbundet Redaktör: Erik Bengtzboe Formgivning: Hellsten Kommunikation AB Illustration: Emy Eriksson / Hellsten Kommunikation AB Tryck: Livonia Print, Lettland 2014 ISBN: 978-91-637-7112-5 Förord 7 Gunnar Hökmark: Fred har den frie och ingen annan 9 Beatrice Ask: Politik som verktyg, inte som mål 21 Ulf Kristersson: Blicka framåt! 31 Fredrik Reinfeldt: Vi har valt öppenheten och friheten 39 Gunnar Strömmer: När skickade du en blomsterkvast till SSU senast? 47 Tove Lifvendahl: Frihet, kärlek och kapitalism 55 Christofer Fjellner: Politik handlar om konflikter 63 Johan Forssell: Att bygga ett nytt land 73 Niklas Wykman: Friheten behöver alla sina vänner 83 Erik Bengtzboe: Ett moderat ungdomsförbund som vill mer 95 ör 80 år sedan bildades det som i dag har blivit Sve- riges största politiska ungdomsförbund. Ända sedan 1934 har vi stått upp för frihet, för öppenhet och för individen; mot tvång, protektionism och kollektiv- Fism. Genom åren har den kampen sett olika ut, men vår tilltro till människor har alltid varit okuvad. Vi tror på människor och på framtiden, och vi är övertygade om att om människor bara får chansen, ja då kan vi också skapa stordåd. Stordåd kräver dock att kropp, plånbok, själ och hjärna är fri. I din hand håller du en samling med texter från några av oss som fått den fantastiska möjligheten att leda denna spänstiga och alltid lika pigga 80-åring genom tiderna och vara förbundsordförande för Moderata Ungdomsförbun- det. Jag är otroligt glad att så många tidigare förbundsord- föranden hade möjlighet att delta och bidra med sina per- spektiv på Moderata Ungdomsförbundet och sin tid som förbundsordförande.
    [Show full text]
  • Karin Erika MARKIDES Ulrica MESSING
    European Commission Karin Erika MARKIDES Deputy Director General, Vinnova, Sweden Karin Markides was awarded a Master of Science Degree from the University of Stockholm in 1974 and a Ph.D. from the same University in 1984. In 1986, Karin was appointed Docent in Analytical Chemistry at the University of Stockholm. Between June 1984 and August 1990, Karin held different academic positions at the Chemistry Department of Brigham Young University, USA. Since 1989, she holds a Chair and Professorship in Analytical Chemistry at the Chemistry Department of the University of Uppsala, Sweden. She is also a Visiting Professor at Stanford University, Chemistry Department, USA. Since April 2004, he holds the position of Vice Director General at VINNOVA (Swedish Agency for Innovation Systems). She is also holds the Chair, is a board member and member of several scientific and academic societies. Karin Markides the author of more than 200 scientific publications and owns 6 scientific patents. Ulrica MESSING Minister of Communications and Regional Policy of Sweden Ulrica Messing was born in Hällefors, Sweden, on January 31, 1968. In high school she attended the social studies programme. She started her political career in 1987 when she became ombudsman at Sandviken and Gävleborgs branches of the Swedish Social Democratic Youth League. In 1990 she continued her social work for “Hassela Solidaritet and Hassela Kollektivet”, a substance abuse treatment centre. In the same year she became alternate member of the Swedish Social Democratic Youth League. In 1991 she became a member of the Swedish Riksdag and one year later, member of the National Board of Institutional Care and the National Board for Youth Affairs.
    [Show full text]
  • What Did You Learn in School Today? How Ideas Mattered for Policy Changes in Danish and Swedish Schools 1990-2011
    What did you learn in school today? How ideas mattered for policy changes in Danish and Swedish schools 1990-2011 Line Renate Gustafsson PhD Dissertation What did you learn in school today? How ideas mattered for policy changes in Danish and Swedish schools 1990-2011 Politica © Forlaget Politica and the author 2012 ISBN: 978-87-7335-162-8 Cover: Svend Siune Print: Juridisk Instituts Trykkeri, Aarhus Universitet Layout: Annette B. Andersen Submitted 13 January 2012 The public defense takes place 25 May 2012 Published May 2012 Forlaget Politica c/o Department of Political Science and Government Aarhus University Bartholins Allé 7 DK-8000 Aarhus C Denmark Table of content Translations and abbreviations .......................................................................................................................... 15 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................................................................... 19 Chapter 1: Introduction .............................................................................................................................................. 23 1.1 Empirical puzzle .......................................................................................................................... 23 1.2 The research question: How did ideas change? .................................................... 24 1.3 The argument in brief .............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Snabbprotokoll 1999/2000:127, Onsdagen Den 14 Juni-Kl. 9.00
    Protokoll 1999/2000:127 Riksdagens protokoll 1999/2000:127 Onsdagen den 14 juni Kl. 9.00 – 17.56 19.00 – 20.26 1 § Val till riksdagsstyrelsen Företogs val av tio ledamöter och tio personliga suppleanter för le- damöterna i riksdagsstyrelsen. Enligt ett från valberedningen inkommet protokoll hade valbered- ningen berett de på föredragningslistan upptagna valen till riksdagssty- relsen. Valberedningen hade därvid enhälligt beslutat om gemensam lista som framgick av utdelad promemoria i kammaren. Kammaren godkände valberedningens förslag och valde – för tiden från den 1 juli 2000 och för återstoden av innevarande valperiod – till ledamöter i riksdagsstyrelsen Sven Hulterström (s) Per Unckel (m) Berit Andnor (s) Mats Lindberg (s) Lars Bäckström (v) Göran Hägglund (kd) Anders Björck (m) Marianne Carlström (s) Inger René (m) Martin Nilsson (s) Kammaren godkände valberedningens förslag och valde – för tiden från den 1 juli 2000 och för återstoden av innevarande valperiod – till personliga suppleanter för ledamöterna i riksdagsstyrelsen Britt Bohlin (s) Beatrice Ask (m) Marianne Jönsson (s) Anita Johansson (s) Ingrid Burman (v) Maria Larsson (kd) Per Bill (m) Jarl Lander (s) Carl Fredrik Graf (m) Göran Magnusson (s) 1 Prot. 2 § Ny riksdagsledamot, m.m. 1999/2000:127 14 juni Upplästes och lades till handlingarna följande från Valprövnings- nämnden inkomna Berättelse om granskning av bevis för riksdagsledamot och ersättare för riksdagsledamöter Till Valprövningsnämnden har från Riksskatteverket inkommit bevis om att Sven Brus (kd), Norrköping, utsetts till ny ledamot av riksdagen fr.o.m. den 4 september 2000 sedan Dan Ericsson (kd) avsagt sig sitt uppdrag som riksdagsledamot. Från Riksskatteverket har också inkommit protokoll angående utseende av ersättare.
    [Show full text]
  • LE MONDE/PAGES<UNE>
    www.lemonde.fr 58 ANNÉE – Nº 17850 – 1,20 ¤ – FRANCE MÉTROPOLITAINE --- DIMANCHE 16 - LUNDI 17 JUIN 2002 FONDATEUR : HUBERT BEUVE-MÉRY – DIRECTEUR : JEAN-MARIE COLOMBANI 0123 ARGENT Ce que Chirac va faire de sa victoire Les atouts de l’épargne salariale L’UMP devrait obtenir la majorité absolue des députés. L’agenda et les priorités du deuxième gouvernement Raffarin Gouvernement. A l’issue du f « Le Monde » ATTENTAT DE KARACHI second tour des législatives, l’Union pour la majorité présidentielle donne le calendrier Un nouveau « djihad » devrait obtenir la majorité absolue à du nouveau pouvoir contre l’Amérique p. 3 l’Assemblée nationale. Reconduit à Matignon, Jean-Pierre Raffarin fera ITALIE sa déclaration de politique générale f Remaniement : au Parlement le 2 ou le 3 juillet. Padre Pio, saint Dans son deuxième gouvernement, quelques nouvelles p. 4 de nouvelles personnalités ? Les têtes et un départ moderne, canonisé noms cités : Philippe Douste-Blazy, Jacques Barrot, Hubert Falco, Pierre f Bédier ou Pierre-André Wiltzer. Mis Difficultés : les en examen dans un dossier de finan- promesses fiscales et cement politique, Renaud Don- nedieu de Vabres sera sans doute la dégradation des remplacé au ministère délégué aux finances publiques affaires européennes par Patrick / Devedjian. Les salaires des ministres probablement augmentés. p. 6 f Sécurité : police et Dossiers. La dégradation des finan- justice au Parlement SÉCURITÉ ces publiques rend difficile la mise dès juillet en œuvre des promesses électorales. Les flashballs sont-ils Fin juin, l’audit ferait apparaître un Sécurité. Les lois-programmes sur la Législatives. Nos reportages à Tou- Privatisation. Selon nos informa- f dangereux ? p.
    [Show full text]
  • 12-02-17 CV Gilles De Robien EN
    1 GILLES DE ROBIEN AMBASSADOR AND FORMER M INISTER FRENCH GOVERNMENT DELEGATE TO THE ILO GOVERNING BODY SINCE 2007 P RESIDENT OF THE I NTERNATIONAL L ABOUR C ONFERENCE IN 2 01 0 C OORDINATOR OF THE SOCIAL DIMENSION FOR THE G 2 0 IN 2 0 1 1 Social dialogue: a passionate commitment throughout a lifetime of experience BUSINESS / PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS POLITICS / DIPLOMACY — A profession First as an employee, then as a company director, GILLES DE ROBIEN worked in the private sector for 25 years (insurance and finance). — A dedicated commitment GILLES DE ROBIEN has chaired professional organizations at the local level. He was a national officer of the Chambers of Liberal Professions and of the National Insurers Federation . — An active parliamentarian GILLES DE ROBIEN entered political life in 1986: Member of Parliament, 1986-2002; Vice-President of the French National Assembly ; President of a parliamentary group of 215 Deputies ; named "Parliamentarian of the Year”, 1996 . Architect of several laws, including the one known as the “ Robien Law ”, much appreciated by employers and employees alike. This law facilitated company agreements on working hours and the creation of jobs on an “ EVERYBODY WINS ” basis . — Mayor and President of an Urban District GILLES DE ROBIEN ran a city of 136,000 inhabitants – AMIENS – for 19 years and created an Urban District Community of 180,000 inhabitants, with a budget of €500 million and a staff of 3,000. He was known for his rigorous, economical management which respected public money, and was named best mayoral manager in France by “Challenge” magazine in 2008.
    [Show full text]
  • Assemblée Nationale Débats Parlementaires Journal Officiel De La
    o Année 2003. – N 22 [2] A.N. (C.R.) ISSN 0242-6765 − CPPAP 0503 B 05115 Mercredi 12 mars 2003 ASSEMBLÉE NATIONALEDÉBATS PARLEMENTAIRES JOURNAL OFFICIEL DE LA RÉPUBLIQUE FRANÇAISE CONSTITUTION DU 4 OCTOBRE 1958 12e Législature SESSION ORDINAIRE DE 2002-2003 160e séance COMPTE RENDU INTÉGRAL 2e séance du mardi 11 mars 2003 48 . 1874 ASSEMBLÉE NATIONALE – 2e SÉANCE DU 11 MARS 2003 SOMMAIRE PRÉSIDENCE DE M. JEAN-LOUIS DEBRÉ POLITIQUE DE LA RECHERCHE (p. 1882) M. Philippe Vitel, Mme Claudie Haigneré, ministre délé- 1. Décès d’un député (p. 1875). guée à la recherche et aux nouvelles technologies. M. le président. PRÉVENTION DE LA TOXICOMANIE 2. Questions au Gouvernement (p. 1875). DANS LES ÉTABLISSEMENTS SCOLAIRES (p. 1883) AVENIR DES SALARIÉS DE METALEUROP (p. 1875) MM. Jean-Paul Garraud, Xavier Darcos, ministre délégué à MM. Albert Facon, François Fillon, ministre des affaires l’enseignement scolaire. sociales, du travail et de la solidarité. Suspension et reprise de la séance (p. 1884) RÔLE DES NATIONS UNIES (p. 1875) MM. François Bayrou, Jean-Pierre Raffarin, Premier PRÉSIDENCE DE M. RUDY SALLES ministre. PRÉVENTION DES EXPULSIONS (p. 1876) 3. Remplacement d’un député décédé (p. 1884). Mme Janine Jambu, M. Gilles de Robien, ministre de l’équipement, des transports, du logement, du tourisme et 4. Entreprises de transport aérien. − Discussion d’un projet de la mer. de loi adopté par le Sénat (p. 1884). IRAK (p. 1877) M. Charles de Courson, rapporteur de la commission des MM. Jacques Barrot, Jean-Pierre Raffarin, Premier ministre. finances. INFRASTRUCTURES DE TRANSPORT (p. 1878) M. Jean-Pierre Gorges, rapporteur pour avis de la commis- MM.
    [Show full text]
  • The Royal Court Annual Report
    THE ROYAL COU rt THE ROYAL COUrt A NNUAL REPO ANNUAL REPOrt THE ROYAL COUrt rt The Royal Palace of Stockholm 2008 2008 111 30 Stockholm Tel: 08-402 60 00 www.kungahuset.se CONTENTS THE YEAR IN BRIEF ...................................................................4 CARL XVI GUSTAF – SWEDEN’S HEAD OF STATE .................5 REPORT FROM THE MARSHAL OF THE REALM ........................ 6 ROYAL COURT For Sweden – With the Times ........................................................................7 Financial reporting ........................................................................................ 7 The Court Administration’s use of funds ...................................................... 8 Staff ...............................................................................................................9 THE COURT ADMINISTRATION Offi ce of the Marshal of the Realm ..............................................................10 Offi ce of the Marshal of the Court with Offi ce of Ceremonies ...................12 H.M. The Queen’s Household .....................................................................16 H.R.H. The Crown Princess’s Household ................................................... 19 H.R.H. The Duchess of Halland’s Household ..............................................21 The Royal Mews ......................................................................................... 22 THE PALACE ADMINISTRATION The Royal Collections with the Bernadotte Library .................................... 24 The Offi
    [Show full text]
  • Audition De M. Gilles De Robien, Ministre De L'équipement
    1 COMMISSION D’ENQUÊTE SUR LE CONTRÔLE, LA RÉGULATION ET L'ÉVOLUTION DES CONCESSIONS AUTOROUTIÈRES Mercredi 11 mars 2020 - Présidence de M. Éric Jeansannetas, président - La réunion est ouverte à 15 h 45. Audition de M. Gilles de Robien, Ministre de l’Équipement, des Transports, du Logement, du Tourisme et de la Mer de 2002 à 2005 M. Éric Jeansannetas, président. – Mes chers collègues, nous poursuivons nos auditions en entendant M. Gilles de Robien, ministre de l’Équipement, des Transports, du Logement, du Tourisme et de la Mer de 2002 à 2005, au moment de la privatisation des autoroutes. Cette audition est diffusée en direct sur le site internet du Sénat. Elle fera l’objet d’un compte rendu publié. Monsieur le ministre, je vous remercie de vous être rendu à notre convocation. Après vous avoir rappelé qu’un faux témoignage devant notre commission d’enquête est passible des peines prévues aux articles 434-13, 434-14 et 434-15 du code pénal, je vous invite à prêter serment de dire toute la vérité, rien que la vérité, levez la main droite et dites : « Je le jure. » Conformément à la procédure applicable aux commissions d'enquête, M. Gilles de Robien prête serment. M. Vincent Delahaye, rapporteur. – Avec vous, monsieur le ministre, nous allons forcément aborder l'aspect historique. En effet, nos travaux ont à la fois pour objet de 2 clarifier le passé en répondant à toutes les questions que l'on peut encore se poser à son sujet et, en même temps, de mener un travail plus prospectif pour aider les futurs décideurs à envisager la suite qui devra être donnée à ces concessions.
    [Show full text]