The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select!
PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015 Wards R/N, R/C, R/S, P/N, P/S
WAS YOUR CORPORATOR THE RIGHT CHOICE? Don’t just Vote. Select!
CONTENT BRIEF & DATA SOURCE
Content Explanation Source Attendance Total of General Body Meetings and Committee • www.Praja.org Meetings. Average attendance of 227 corporators = 77% • RTI reply from BMC.
Corporator Fund Each corporator is entitled to two funds annually- • Entitlement- http://bit.ly/1PLOq2N Expenditure Status (1) Corporator Fund, and • Corporator Fund Expenditure Data- (2) Development Fund. http://portal.mcgm.gov.in/irj/portal/anon Financial Corporator Fund Development Fund ymous/qlpurordcdetails. Average Year annual entitlement annual entitlement Expenditure of 227 corporators = 92.97% • Development Fund info not included in 2012-13 60 lakh 40 lakh this report. 2013-14 60 lakh 40 lakh 2014-15 60 lakh 1 crore Promise & Performance Each corporator was asked the following questions in Promise and Performance as declared by the One-liners the interview conducted by MumbaiVotes- corporator in a two minute video/audio (1) Performance: Major work done in term so far interview with MumbaiVotes. (2) Promises: Plans for remaining part of term. Contact Details Phone number provided. Find more on website. Affidavit filed for candidature Don’t just Vote. Select!
PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATORS (CITY LEVEL ISSUES)
URBAN PLANNING ENVIRONMENT EDUCATION ROADS PUBLIC TRANSPORT ₹
POVERTY ALLEVIATION HEALTH ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WATER SUPPLY SLUM IMPROVEMENT Don’t just Vote. Select!
MUMBAI = 227 WARDS = 227 CORPORATORS
90
80 77
70
60 53 50 40 30 30 28
NO. OF CORPORATORS CORPORATORS OF NO. 20 14 11 9 10 2 1 1 1 0 POLITICAL PARTIES SHS BJP INC MNS IND NCP SP ABS RPI BSKP BRKP (A) RULING COALITION Don’t just Vote. Select!
RULING COALITION PARTY PERFORMANCE A questionnaire* consisting of projects and plans promised in the Shiv Sena – Bharatiya Janta Party (SHS-BJP) 2012 MCGM Manifesto was first sent to the Shiv Sena and BJP spokespersons on April 26, 2015. Despite several follow-ups, this was the response we received- Questions SHS Response BJP Response A plan will be made for more parking space No Response No Response Plan shall be made to give concession and encouragement for those co-operative societies No Response No Response who keep their building premises clean. Graveyards will be made available with PNG gas (natural gas) to prevent excess use of wood No Response No Response and to stop pollution and bad smell. In order to prevent diseases like Thalassemia, AIDS etc., blood testing services shall be No Response No Response provided at the Municipal Corporation's laboratory at very cheap rates. All municipal schools will be repaired and have computer labs in the next three years. No Response No Response Bus services like 'Fort-ferry' shall be started in the many parts of Mumbai city and suburbs. No Response No Response Policy of developing 'Hawkers ground' shall be accepted. No Response No Response Project affected citizens of Mumbai due to different municipal projects shall be given houses No Response No Response or compensation as per 'Ready-reckoner' for which 15 years inhabitation shall be the eligibility. * Few promises stated here. Questionnaire listed 117 promises extracted from SHS-BJP 2012 MCGM Manifesto. Don’t just Vote. Select!
PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PARAMETERS
QUALITATIVE QUANTITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – October 2015 Time Period: March 2012 – March 2015
PERFORMANCE: WORK DONE ATTENDANCE
PROMISE: WORK TO BE DONE
CORPORATOR FUNDS EXPENDITURE
CORPORATOR’S CONTACT NUMBER LINK TO INTERVIEW Don’t Just Vote. Select! INTERVIEWS TAKEN IN 6 CLUSTERS
COVERED IN THIS REPORT: CLUSTER 3- Constituency Numbers 1-52 R/N: Borivali, Dahisar R/C: Borivali R/S: Kandivali P/N: Malad P/S: Goregaon, Malad Don’t just Vote. Select!
ATTENDANCE Below Average Above Average
100 100 100 90 90 90
80 80 80
70 70 70 60 60 60 50 50 50 40 40 40 30
ATTENDANCE (in (in %) ATTENDANCE 30 30
ATTENDANCE (in (in %) ATTENDANCE ATTENDANCE (in (in %) ATTENDANCE 20 20 20 10 10 10 0 0 0
R/N Ward Corporators R/C Ward Corporators R/S Ward Corporators Don’t just Vote. Select!
ATTENDANCE Below Average Above Average 100 100 90 90
80 80
70 70 60 60 50 50 40 40
30 30
ATTENDANCE (in (in %) ATTENDANCE ATTENDANCE (in (in %) ATTENDANCE 20 20 10 10 0 * 0
P/N Ward Corporators *Replaced disqualified corporator. Data unavailable. P/S Ward Corporators Don’t just Vote. Select!
CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS Below Average Above Average
100 100
100
90 90 90
(in %) (in 80 80 80 70 70 70 60 60 60 50 50 50 40 40 40 30 30 30 20 20 20 10
10 %) (in EXPENDITURE FUND CORPORATOR
10 %) (in EXPENDITURE FUND CORPORATOR CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURE FUND CORPORATOR 0 0 0
R/N Ward Corporators R/C Ward Corporators R/S Ward Corporators Don’t just Vote. Select!
CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS Below Average Above Average
100 100
* 90 90 80 80 70 70 60 60 50 50 40 40 30 30 20 20
10 10
CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE (in %) (in EXPENDITURE FUND CORPORATOR CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE (in %) (in EXPENDITURE FUND CORPORATOR 0 0
P/N Ward Corporators *Replaced disqualified corporator. Data indicative of both corporators. P/S Ward Corporators Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/N Ward- Borivali, Dahisar Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Abhishek Vinod SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have cleared the ECONOMIC AFFAIRS: I have the https://youtu.be/f 9769539111/ Ghosalkar bottleneck at Kandarpada and budget for a mangrove park & fish ZgAJah7Eqc 8879997001 completed the CC road. aquarium. Sheetal Mukesh SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: Nearly all the roads INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct https://youtu.be/B 9870337777/ Mhatre & footpaths in the ward have been two FOBs at Anandnagar & Dahisar txOIYrlwus 8879997002 repaired. checknaka.
Sheetal Ashok Mhatre INC INFRASTRUCTURE, ECONOMIC AFFAIR: INFRASTRUCTURE: I will install https://youtu.be/Y 9867322422/ I have sanctioned Rs. 40 lakhs for CCTV cameras as a security F6nAFC2qHg 8879997003 maintenance of two big gardens. measure.
Udesh Shantaram SHS INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I provided INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I will https://youtu.be/ 9821117531/ Patekar the hilly areas with water supply by develop the Alakhnanda play wvebUFllXhE 8879997004 installing boosters in the water pumps. ground with sports facilities for the youth such as gym, cricket and different indoor games for which I have got Rs. 3 crores passed. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/N Ward- Borivali, Dahisar Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Prakash Yashwant MNS MISCELLANEOUS: My ward is known for *No reply* https://youtu.be/- 9820164443/ Darekar cleanliness, for all the facilities and QbWBOmQkgY 8879997005 services.
Hansaben Gunvantrai SHS MISCELLANEOUS: Problems of water, *No reply* https://youtu.be/z 9869019232/ Desai toilets, children's school admission are RX4L3fw_pQ 8879997006 the day-to-day issues solved thus far.
Dr. Shubha Umesh SHS ENVIRONMENT, HEALTH, SANITATION: Upcoming project https://youtu.be/ 9869866978/ Raul INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made a bird for Dahisar river will be along the mkalqQyb3dc 8879997007 park for their protection, two lines Ganges improvement gymnasiums for women, two yoga project. centres. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/C Ward- Borivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Shivanand Narayan INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have done up all INFRASTRUCTURE: The road from https://youtu.be/ 9869142749/ Shetty the four gardens in my ward. Neelam Pride to HD Ground will be vfvb4vLkxf4 8879997008 done in CC & I will develop Gorai Gaothan. Manisha Ashok BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got Govind *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9320123413/ Chaudhari Nagar road made. T6KkJW-xNn8 8879997009
Riddhi Bhaskar NCP INFRASTRUCTURE: Some slum dwellers ECONOMIC AFFAIR, https://youtu.be/ 9869664997/ Khursange have been regularised and I've repaired INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got an b_5qbh-0HRM 8879997010 all the broken non-functional toilets. approval of 2.75 crores for the crematorium.
Shilpa Shirish Chogle MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: To reduce pollution *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9833888025/ of the river, I have got big meshes placed sES59_Zik_0 8879997011 in drains. Asawari Anil Patil BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have taken up all *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9322243615/ the road repairs, CC and asphalt, that agbIJ_Y6Oj8 8879997012 were lying incomplete since 25-30 years. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/C Ward- Borivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Chetan Chandrakant MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made 10 INFRASTRUCTURE: I will try to https://youtu.be/ 9867391966/ Kadam roads and 2 gardens. upgrade water facilities. U4VrRWtN0mU 8879997013
Bina Paresh Doshi BJP SANITATION: I have completed HEALTH, OTHER: I will inaugurate https://youtu.be/ 9870479227/ unfinished roads in Natakvala lane and the BMC diagnostic centre. j3cpO4Hyy9k 8879997014 Haridas nagar. Mohan Ramchandra BJP HEALTH & SANITATION: There are no INFRASTRUCTURE, SEWAGE: I will https://youtu.be/ 9869168373/ Mithbaokar mosquito related problems in my ward. provide sewage lines to slum areas. WAmy6pyfepg 8879997015
Pravin Rivakchand BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I am building a INFRASTRUCTURE: Four new https://youtu.be/ 9322704829/ Shah sports stadium in Chikuwadi at the cost gardens will be completed in a few l3RTTQHv7qo 8879997016 of Rs. 190 crores. months, by Diwali 2015. Sandhya Vipul Doshi MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have developed POLITICAL AFFAIR: I'm trying to get https://youtu.be/ 9821117777/ one big theme garden, 5 small gardens, the MHADA open plots RP/GP -s935RHjveo 8879997017 one big park, and I have done up 27 km transferred to BMC in my Ward. of minor roads. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/S Ward- Kandivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Shrikant Krishna SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have provided *No Reply* https://youtu.be/x 9967542708/ Kavathankar various facilities such as toilets, UqeEyQeEfg 8879997018 footpaths, student scholarships. Neha Vinayak Patil INC *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9769279325/ 8879997019 Shailaja Vijay Girkar BJP INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I have got INFRASTRUCTURE: The BMC https://youtu.be/l 9819710844/ an old dispensary bulldozed and swimming pool is planned to be NtkdRjX-34 8879997020 received approval for building a four enlarged to an olympic size storey dispensary in its place. swimming pool.
Ramashish Gopal INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have worked on 10 INFRASTRUCTURE: I will make 8 https://youtu.be/o 9892907975/ Gupta roads. new roads. ez_RWqlTBM 8879997021
Sunita Ramnagina BJP SANITATION: I made my constituency a *No Reply* https://youtu.be/s 8879997022 Yadav 'zero garbage‘ ward. 8tmIq9A4OM
Prajakta Vikas (Sawant) SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* https://youtu.be/x 9967542708/ Vishwasrao UqeEyQeEfg 8879997023 Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/S Ward- Kandivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Yogesh Janardhan INC POLITICAL AFFAIR: I fought for 3 years INFRASTRUCTURE: My focus in the https://youtu.be/ 9821087312/ Bhoir with the Forest Department, went to immediate future will be now to uv1pjZ5mgxA 8879997024 Delhi for the matter and even courted get a fire brigade station, cemetery arrest once and got the NOC to provide and hospital for my ward. basic services for slum dwellers on forest land. Dr. Ajanta Rajpati INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have solved the INFRASTRUCTURE: I will redo 13 https://youtu.be/ 8879997025 Yadav problem of major nullah which used to small roads in slum pockets have 3AmUt0_C-YY overflow into the houses of the poor received special funds from the within ten minutes of rainfall. commissioner.
Sagar Singh Thakur INC *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 8879997026
Mukeshkumar BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have done 4-5 road INFRASTRUCTURE: I will renovate https://youtu.be/ 9769390993/ Himmatlal Mistry and replaced 50 year old water pipes. Sardar Vallabhai Patel garden and mJWVpTJLAV0 8879997027 Khajorao garden with amenities for senior citizens and children. Geeta Aashish Yadav INC HEALTH: I've provided water in each of INFRASTRUCTURE: Recently a https://youtu.be/ 9892850871/ the housing gullies solving all water space for dispensary has been 0If2uhihnLI 8879997028 woes. alloted by BMC.This will be developed. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Ajit Damodar Bhandari SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have undertaken *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9820284410/ the work of building a bridge to Versova. X5OtKBlQxCI 8879997029
Vishwas Pandurang SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I am getting a garden INFRASTRUCTURE: The work of https://youtu.be/ 8879997030 Ghadigaonkar and community hall constructed. installing a chimney at Charkop 9gOIp13fV-c Naka cremation toilet blocks at Kachpada will begin soonbegin soon. Parminder Ratansingh INC INFRASTRUCTURE: A project pending INFRASTRUCTURE, SANITATION: https://youtu.be/ 9820784572/ Bhamra since the past 40 years of constructing a Work on toilet blocks at Kachpada ADcRz7YOgQ8 8879997031 road above Link Road has been will begin soon. completed. Anagha Prakash SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869273617/ Mhatre 8879997032 Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Ramnarayan BJP HEALTH: My first initiative for Mumbai INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct https://youtu.be/ 9869080789/ Amtharam Barot was the anti-tobacco campaign a jogging track at Ramleela FnZaCrNGWEs 8879997033 Maidan.
Sunil Daulat Gujar SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have done work of MISCELLANEOUS: I will work on https://youtu.be/ 9820333203/ gardens and roads. roads and sewerage line. _rMof-Xtcac 8879997034
Bhomsing Hirsing INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got nine new MISCELLANEOUS: I will solve https://youtu.be/ 9969457170/ Rathod pipelines laid and functional. I have ninety percent of the slum nhQ9oNwcxfc 8879997035 constructed an open gym for women dweller’s remaining problems, be and senior citizens. it about gullies, roads or water provision.
Prashant Dashrath SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have constructed INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH & https://youtu.be/ 9702597025/ Kadam an open gym for women and senior SANITATION: I will provide facility d7HzJoGVOt4 8879997036 citizens. of lavatory, water and electricity to people living in Sanjay Gandhi National Park. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Manisha Sadashiv Patil SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9320671296/ 8879997037
Rupali Ajit Raorane NCP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have undertaken INFRASTRUCTURE: I will install https://youtu.be/ 9869360739/ various works with respect to widening lights at Shantaram Lane Highway. gukew7PjjYk 8879997038 of roads and beautification of gardens. Sayali Sunil Varise INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got nine new MISCELLANEOUS: I will solve https://youtu.be/ 9969457170/ pipelines laid and functional. ninety percent of the slum nhQ9oNwcxfc 8879997039 dweller’s remaining problems, be it about gullies, roads or water provision. Gyanmurty SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have solved water INFRASTRUCTURE: I will set up a https://youtu.be/ 9702597025/ Ramchandra Sharma woes in all houses and ensured pothole- community hall and a mini sports PRwfJZtj5_s 8879997040 free road. complex. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Vinod Babaji Shelar SHS HEALTH & SANITATION: Mine is the first *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9320671296/ garbage-free ward in Mumbai. cIUH9Wsnor8 8879997041
Deepak Pandurang NCP *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869360739/ Pawar 8879997042
Qumarjahan INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got passed 80 INFRASTRUCTURE: I am trying to https://youtu.be/ 9969457170/ Mohammad Moin street light poles whose work has been make the Hindi municipal school a q8328AOLL2g 8879997043 Siddiqi completed. ground-plus-one structure.
Cyril Peter D’souza SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I've got a 6 storey *No Reply* https://youtu.be/ 9702597025/ hospital made in Malwani and two BMC U4i5snqTGxM 8879997044 schools constructed. Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/S Ward- Goregaon, Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Sneha Vinayak Zagde INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have completed HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I will https://youtu.be 9821513340/ work of 15 roads- 5 cement concrete start a medical dispensary in my /9v1xc_Frnoo 8879997045 and 10 asphalt. ward.
Varsha Swapnil SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have built three HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I plan https://youtu.be 9833261857/ Tembvalkar gardens near Upper Govind Nagar. to build a speciality hospital for /41Nl57KYP-0 8879997046 cardiac care on a BMC plot.
Jitendra Hiralal Valvi SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9757196595/ 8879997047
Sunil Vaman Prabhu SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9820702777/ 8879997048 Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/S Ward- Goregaon, Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO. Lochana Chandrakant SHS SANITATION, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have *No Reply* https://youtu.be 9594989816/ Chavan successfully installed a water tank for /_daEGxzK004 8879997049 one public toilet in my constituency.
Rajan Vasant Padhye SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have provided road SANITATION: The waste https://youtu.be 9820702709/ facilities, solved the issue of gutters and segregation plan has also been /nEk-HRZIfbc 8879997050 worked towards the provision of water passed by the BMC and now it will facilities. be implemented building-wise so that less amount of waste reaches the dumping ground.
Pramila Dilip Shinde SHS HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have INFRASTRUCTURE: I will provide https://youtu.be 9920059494/ provided facilities like CT scan and NIC (Network Interface /Hq_2U3kMko4 8879997051 special ward for children in hospital. Controller).
Kiran Vinay Patel INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made CC roads *No Reply* https://youtu.be 9967090845/ in my ward. /upeR-MBbv7o 8879997052
Don’t just Vote. Select! What this report won’t do… What can you do? Let them know that you are watching them!
SMS or call your Signup for regular corporator and let updates for your them know- corporator’s promises “I have read the & performance- MumbaiVotes Report http://mumbaivotes.com Card.” /pages/newsletter/
You have the Make an issue about Right to Copy your issues- (The MumbaiVotes ‘Copy Right’ Law) Call/SMS your corporator and request - Share this report him/her to address - Share the videos your civic issues.
Like on Facebook: www.facebook.com/MumbaiVotes Follow us on Twitter: @mumbaivotes