THE DIAPASON SEPTEMBER, 2008
St. John’s Episcopal Church, Norwood Parish Bethesda, Chevy Chase, Maryland Cover feature on pages 30–31
Sept 08 Cover.indd 1 8/13/08 8:31:35 AM “It was superb!....Brilliant, astonishing, almost American organist Daniel Sullivan’s creative unbelievable, a tour de force...a memorable interpretations, musical depth and engaging and entertaining concert by a very promising stage presence, combined with his command of young organist with style and a formidable a varied repertoire ranging from Renaissance to technique.” (Hexham Courant, England) contemporary works, have earned him a prominent place among the next generation of “A splendid, assured and memorized concert organists. His performances have taken performance.” (The Diapason) him to cities across the United States, including San Francisco, Albuquerque, Chicago, “Organist elevates instrument’s status.” Indianapolis, Cleveland, Boston, Philadelphia, (Albuquerque Journal) Washington DC, Atlanta, and many other venues in other states. “Daniel Sullivan’s warm interaction with an audience and his fiercely beautiful playing He collaborates with pianist Jason Cutmore as need to be experienced by everyone who loves the New York Piano-Organ Duo, and performs the organ, and especially by those who don’t!” with the Second Instrumental Unit, a chamber (Paul Jacobs, organ department chairman, ensemble of diverse instruments devoted to The Juilliard School, New York) playing the new music of current composers. He also performs music written for two organs with Isabelle Demers. In 2007 they premiered their original two-organ transcription of Prokofiev’s “Peter and the Wolf” to the enthusiastic delight of audiences.
Sullivan has been a featured soloist at New York City’s Basically Bach Festival, the Piccolo Spoleto Festival in Charleston, and the White Mountain Musical Arts Annual Bach Festival in New Hampshire. He has performed in Scotland, and England, and has been a prize winner in numerous competitions. His degrees are from Oberlin Conservatory, Yale University, and the Juilliard School where he will join the organ faculty this autumn. instrument, rather than a hard and fast inevitable discussion that the sonatas have designation of an exact physical form. In- not much to do with the classical sonata THE DIAPASON deed, we would not consider a “continuo and its defi ned form. Funny: with Widor, A Scranton Gillette Publication organ” a “portative” despite the fact that it is hardly questioned that his symphonies Ninety-ninth Year: No. 9, Whole No. 1186 SEPTEMBER, 2008 it can be moved. This organ, however, is have not much to do with symphonies, more closely related to its earlier cousin besides using the term for multi-move- Established in 1909 ISSN 0012-2378 in size and form. The Ab Yberg prints re- ment form. Both were obviously looking An International Monthly Devoted to the Organ, fer to that organ as a “Positive,” in part for a contemporary handling of the organ the Harpsichord, Carillon, and Church Music because its intended purpose was to pro- and invented something new, in quite dif- vide music in the family chapel, rather ferent ways, without forgetting the past, than be transported for use. or transforming traditional material in a Christopher Walton new frame. CONTENTS Editor & Publisher JEROME BUTERA [email protected] New England Organbuilders Michael Gailit 847/391-1045 Vienna, Austria FEATURES Symphonic style Inaugurating the new Craighead-Saunders Organ After reading the interesting article Paul Manz book review at the Eastman School of Music Associate Editor JOYCE ROBINSON by Joris Verdin (“Aspects of French I am writing in response to Sarah by Hans Davidsson 21 [email protected] Symphonic Organ Music,” The Dia- Mahler Hughes’s review (June Diapa- 847/391-1044 pason, June, pp. 26–29), I meditated a son) of my book on the life and work of From the Dickinson Collection: Memorizing Controversy few minutes on the term “symphonic” Paul Manz, “The Journey Was Chosen: by Lorenz Maycher 22 Contributing Editors LARRY PALMER and how it appears in the organ world. The Life and Work of Paul Manz,” pub- Harpsichord Apart from my experience that some lished by MorningStar Music Publish- Celebrating the Cathedral Church of Christ still divide the repertoire into good or- ers. While I am genuinely grateful for Choir, Lagos, Nigeria, at Ninety JAMES MCCRAY gan music and symphonic organ music, Ms. Hughes’s work, and appreciative of by Godwin Sadoh 25 Choral Music the term “symphonic” is often identifi ed much of the tone in her review, there are with “romantic,” as it is with “orchestral,” two points that need correcting. NEWS & DEPARTMENTS BRIAN SWAGER as if there were no orchestras in the ba- The fi rst point is a somewhat small Letters to the Editor 3 Carillon roque or classical periods. So then, is point, but those who know, or have stud- Here & There 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10 there any symphonic music before the ied with Paul Manz will understand my HERBERT L. HUESTIS Appointments 6 OrganNet Forum romantic period? What a question. Just need for clarifi cation and correction. Ms. Nunc Dimittis 10 Osiris Organ Archive straight another one: What characterizes Hughes claims that I “lapse into adula- In the wind . . . by John Bishop 12 www.wu-wien.ac.at/earlym-l/organs/local.html “symphonic” music? The symphony was tion,” and she pulls a quote from p. 32 On Teaching by Gavin Black 14 e-mail: [email protected] developed in the Viennese classical era, of the book: “Paul Manz had a healthy and it forms a main part of the Viennese amount of ambition, an almost voracious classical style, developed by Haydn and capacity to learn and grow, and has never REVIEWS Prepress Operations DAN SOLTIS Mozart, and perfected by Beethoven, been one to let the grass grow under his Music for Voices and Organ 16 the one who “received Haydn’s spirit feet.” Anyone who has encountered Paul Book Reviews 17 through Mozart’s hands.” Manz as a colleague, student or friend New DVDs 18 THE DIAPASON (ISSN 0012-2378) is published monthly by Scranton Gillette Communications, Inc., 3030 W. Salt Main compositional features of the will immediately understand that this New Recordings 19 Creek Lane, Suite 201, Arlington Heights, IL 60005-5025. symphonic style are the thematic work isn’t hyperbole; it is merely a statement New Organ Music 20 Phone 847/391-1045. Fax 847/390-0408. Telex: 206041 and the so-called obbligato accompani- of fact. There is no other way to put it. MSG RLY. E-mail:
SEPTEMBER, 2008 3
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 3 8/13/08 8:33:25 AM Music in a Great Space, the con- gneur). For information: 212/288-2520; removal of the organ took ten days and cert series at Shadyside Presbyterian
Jack M. Bethards, Paul Jacobs, Nigel Potts, and Robert J. Russell
Christ & St. Stephen’s Episcopal ist & choirmaster); and Robert J. Rus- Church, New York City, dedicated sell (organist & choirmaster emeritus). their new Schoenstein organ on Trin- That same weekend Paul Jacobs gave ity Sunday, May 18, with the Bishop of the opening dedicatory concert, and the New York presiding. Pictured are Jack series continues with concerts on Octo- M. Bethards (president and tonal direc- ber 25 (Nigel Potts) and November 22 tor of Schoenstein & Co); Paul Jacobs (Thomas Murray). (artist in residence); Nigel Potts (organ-
4 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 4 8/13/08 8:33:56 AM tour, Richards, Fowkes & Co. 11/9, Terence Flanagan; December 7, An “Organ Spectacular” event will the Royal Chapel Protestant Church. A panel discussion will focus on the Handel’s Messiah (Part I); 12/14, Les- occur on October 19 at 4 pm as the Chi- For information:
David K. Lamb Maija Lehtonen Yoon-Mi Lim Ines Maidre Mary Mozelle Organist/Choral Conductor/ Organist/Pianist/ Organist Organist/Pianist/Harpsichordist Organist/Recording Artist Oratorio Accompanist Recording Artist 2004 NYACOP Winner Associate Professor of Organ Assistant Director of Music Director of Music/Organist Senior Lecturer, Organ Faculty Director of Music Grieg Academy of Music Associate Organist First United Methodist Church Oulu Polytechnic Fairlawn Presbyterian Church Bergen, Norway The Falls Church Columbus, Indiana Organ and Violin Columbus, Indiana Falls Church, Virginia with Manfred Grasbeck “The Sights & Sounds Helsinki, Finland of the Pipe Organ”
David F. Oliver Larry Palmer Gregory Peterson Stephen Roberts Clair Rozier Organist/Lecturer/Recording Artist Harpsichordist/Organist Organist Organist/Harpsichordist/Lecturer Organist/Lecturer College Organist Professor of Harpsichord and Organ College Organist and Instructor of Organ Director of Music Director of Music Ministries Meadows School of the Arts Assistant Professor of Music Western CT State University St. David's Episcopal Church Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Southern Methodist University Luther College Director of Music Wayne, Pennsylvania International Chapel Dallas, Texas Decorah, Iowa St. Peter Church Morehouse College Danbury, Connecticut Atlanta, Georgia
Lisa Scrivani-Tidd Michael Stefanek Brennan Szafron Elke Voelker Duo Majoya Organist/Lecturer Organist Organist/Harpsichordist/ Organist/Recording Artist/ Organ and Piano Associate Professor of Music Director of Music Accompanist Lecturer/Conductor/Composer Recording Artists SUNY at Jefferson Aldersgate United Organist and Choirmaster Music Associate Marnie Giesbrecht and Watertown, New York Methodist Church Episcopal Church of the Advent Choir Organist Joachim Segger Redford, Michigan Spartanburg, South Carolina The UNESCO Heritage Professors of Music Imperial Cathedral of St. Mary University of Alberta Speyer, Germany The King’s University College Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
www.ConcertArtistCooperative.com Beth Zucchino, Founder and Director 7710 Lynch Road, Sebastopol, CA 95472 PH: (707) 824-5611 FX: (707) 824-0956 Established in 1988
SEPTEMBER, 2008 5
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 5 8/13/08 8:34:18 AM tion (NCOI). Competition prize winners is the former estate of Goodyear Tire & play the 1907 III/64 Hutchings & Votey were recognized on Wednesday, June 25, Rubber Company founder F. A. Seiber- organ rebuilt by Kerner & Merchant. during the AGO national convention in ling and his wife, Gertrude, and remains Castro received a master of sacred music Minneapolis/St. Paul, Minnesota. this country’s fi nest example of Tudor degree from Boston University, studying Twenty-four applicants were accepted Revival architecture. with Peter Sykes. in the 2007–2008 NYACOP in June 2007: The Aeolian organ at Stan Hywet fi rst place and audience choice prize, comprises 2,670 pipes in 42 ranks locat- Michael Unger; second place, Andrew ed in the hall’s music room. The organ Kotylo; third place, Monica Harper. was played regularly at Stan Hywet Hall Michael Unger is a doctoral student and by both professional musicians and fam- teaching assistant of David Higgs (or- ily members primarily during the 1920s, gan) and William Porter (harpsichord) 30s and 40s. at the Eastman School of Music. Prior Over 300 “organ donors” have made to completing master’s degrees in both gifts in excess of $280,000 to the “Adopt- instruments at Eastman, Unger pursued A-Pipe” appeal. The Kulas Founda- undergraduate studies at the University tion of Cleveland has pledged the fi nal of Western Ontario. A semifi nalist in the $25,000 needed for this project. The 2006 NYACOP and the 2004 Interna- goal is to raise an additional $200,000 Woodberry & Harris façade, St. Mary— tional Organ Competition in Odense, yet this fall, so that the Schantz Organ St. Catherine of Siena, Charlestown, Denmark, Unger is a chamber musician, Company in Orrville, Ohio, can begin Massachusetts published composer, and music director to restore the organ during the winter at South Presbyterian Church in Roches- months when Stan Hywet is closed to windows by Franz Meyer & Co. of Mu- ter, New York. the public. To make a donation or for nich, Germany, and a hammerbeam ceil- Five semifi nalists were selected in more information, call Susan Van Vorst, ing of oak carved by Keely himself. Keely the 2007–2008 NCOI: fi rst prize, Jason V.P. Fund Development, 330/315-3216, designed the neo-gothic organ case as Roberts; second prize, Steven Ball; or visit
Fratelli Ruffatti invests its time and money in research to make a better pipe organ.
We’ve been working for years with noted institutions in Italy and Germany, inventing and testing new ideas for Haarlem Improvisation Competition fi nalists: Gerben Mourik, Jean-Baptiste Du- making better and more ef¿ cient pipe organs. pont, David Cowen, and David Franke (photo credit: Sonja Heimann)
Gerben Mourik has been chosen Ansgar Wallenhorst and Naji Hakim. He Considering that your new pipe organ is unanimously by the jury as the win- won the national improvisation competi- one of the biggest investments you’ll ever make, ner of the 47th International Organ tion in Zwolle in 2003 and was a fi nalist Improvisation Competition held in at the Haarlem competition in 2004. In what does that mean to you? Haarlem, the Netherlands. It was the 2005 he won the improvisation competi- third time Mourik participated in the tion in St. Albans (UK). He is organist competition, and he had already reached in Oudewater and performs regularly as the fi nal round once before. In both both soloist and accompanist. the fi rst two rounds as well as the fi nal, The audience award winner David he was given the highest ratings by the Franke was a member of the Dresden jury. The audience award went to the Kreuzchor. He studied organ and church German candidate David Franke. The music in Stuttgart as a pupil of Ludger other fi nalists were David Cowen (UK) Lohmann, Hans Martin Corrinth and and Jean-Baptiste Dupont (France). Jürgen Essl, and is currently a student of The four contestants each improvised Leo van Doeselaar and Wolfgang Seifen Your international investment ¿ rm. on a theme composed by Ig Henneman. in Berlin. He was a fi nalist in the impro- The jury members included Peter Plan- visation competitions at Haarlem (2006) yavsky, Thierry Escaich, Ansgar Wallen- and St. Albans (2007). horst, Jan Welmers, Bert van den Brink, The competition is part of the Inter- www.ruff atti.com Via Facciolati, 166 • 35127 Padua, Italy organs@ruff atti.com and Stephen Taylor. national Organfestival, Haarlem, the Telephone (39-049) 750-666 Telefax (39-049) 850-483 In the U.S. 330-867-4370 Gerben Mourik studied organ with Netherlands. For information:
6 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 6 8/13/08 8:35:11 AM In the early morning of May 18, Collégial Notre-Dame 2008, Allen Elite™ Opus II made d’Écouis, France. its premier with a series of Dedicated in 1313. comments and organ responses during a Service of Dedication within the morning worship service played by Sarah Soularue. Allen Elite™ It was immediately apparent that this instrument was perfect for Opus II the space. The building acoustic 72 Stops supported the organ beautifully. Three Manuals The organ was used extensively 42 Audio Channels throughout the worship service, providing musical support that French Romantic enhanced every aspect of the specification with joyful celebration. Cavaillé-Coll voices.
ALLEN ELITE™ OPUS II is installed in the Collégial Notre-Dame d’Écouis, a large church dedicated in 1313. The case and façade pipes of the long silent 1898 Jules Anneessens organ still reside in the rear balcony, shared now with the Opus II console and audio system. Opus II is the first Allen Elite™ organ installed in Europe. Its French Romantic specification of 72 stops OPUS II is distributed over three manuals. Cavaillé-Coll voices are present throughout the instrument. Final tonal finishing was masterfully accomplished by Jean-Philippe le Trévou of Allen Studio, Paris.
While Opus II proved to be an outstanding service instrument, the afternoon inaugural concert proved it was also at ease with every demand made of it by well-known and gifted artist, Sophie-Véronique Cauchefer-Choplin, Titular of the Grand Orgue of St. Jean-Baptiste de la Salle, Paris, and Titular Assistant of the Grand Orgue of St. Sulpice, Paris. Her performance of works by composers Bédard, J. S. Bach, Mendelssohn, Vierne, Ropartz, and Widor demonstrated the wide tonal palette of Opus II. Her performance culminated in a spectacular improvisation that brought the capacity audience to its feet in appreciation of both her extraordinary performance and the instrument that “Elite Opus II’s 72 Stop French Romantic responded to her commands with effortless clarity. specification provided the opportunity to further Multiple encores and ovations completed the refine Cavaillé-Coll voices into an instrument concert, ending a truly grand day of music. that will support the desire for music of quality in worship services, as well as an instrument fully capable of meeting the demands of concert repertoire. Forty-two channels of audio enable every stop to speak clearly at characteristic volume levels, creating ensembles that connect beautifully with the excellent building acoustic. The inaugural events that included worship and concert demands demonstrated that the design goals for Opus II have been accomplished.” — Randy Miller, Elite™ Opus II Designer
www.allenorgan.com
150 Locust Street, P.O. Box 36, Macungie, PA 18062-0036 USA Phone: 610-966-2202 Fax: 610-965-3098 E-mail: [email protected] Rev. Gregory Norton has been ap- Diane Bish, Michael Burkhardt, Anna pointed minister of music at Westwood Laura Page, and Fred Swann. United Methodist Church in Los Ange- Mrs. Hamlin conducts church music les. He also serves as music director of workshops nationwide, is an Allen Or- the Claremont Chorale, an independent gan representative and a composer. Her community chorus. Active as an organist, fi rst composition was an SATB anthem, singer, conductor, liturgist, and compos- Grace, written at the time of her mother’s er, his arrangements and compositions death; she was commissioned to write an are published by H.T. FitzSimons and organ composition honoring the late Emerson Music. Norton holds degrees in Tom Hazleton, who had recorded some conducting from Chapman College and of Hamlin’s pieces from Worship Hymns the University of Southern California; he for Organ. She was one of ten compos- attended the Iliff School of Theology in ers contributing to an organ collection Denver and is an ordained minister in in memory of Fred Bock, Encore, En- the United Methodist Church. core, which was premiered at the AGO national convention in Seattle. Her ar- Todd Pettit has been named director rangement of Lead On, O King Eternal of music at St. John Evangelical United was selected for the fi rst sacred concert Church of Christ in Collinsville, Illinois, Kurt-Ludwig Forg at the National Cathedral in Washington, where he plays the church’s three-man- D.C., following the 9/11 tragedy. ual Wicks organ, directs fi ve handbell Kurt-Ludwig Forg played the North A recital hall at her alma mater, North and vocal choirs of all ages, oversees American premiere of a recently dis- Greenville University, bears her name. the direction of the pre-K–second grade covered composition by Johann Sebas- We can be grateful that, in recent wor- Cherub Choir, and assists with contem- tian Bach at St. James United Church, ship-playing seminars, she has focused Scott Lamlein porary worship. A member of the UCC Montreal, Canada, on July 1. The Bach on ways to keep organs alive in present- Musician’s Association, the Association work, Wo Gott der Herr nicht bei uns day worship. Her arrangements are alive Scott Lamlein is presenting a new of Disciples Musicians, and the St. Louis hält, BWV 1128, is a large-scale fanta- and spiritually uplifting, also showing the program in churches in the northeast, AGO chapter, he is also active as a music sia of 85 bars written between 1705 and joys of the organ! What Wondrous Love: A Hymn Festi- education specialist with the Collinsville 1710. A complete copy of the previously —Frances Young Austin val, a worship event that combines great public schools. unknown organ composition was discov- hymns of the church with inspirational ered in March by German researchers New evidence presented in Beverly readings. Scattered throughout the pro- Stephan Blaut and Michael Pacholke as Jerold’s article “The ‘Most Indispens- gram are compositions for organ and for they were going through the papers of able and Most Pleasing Trill’” (The Con- piano, including hymn arrangements. Here & There Wilhelm Rust recently acquired by the sort, Journal of the Dolmetsch Foun- A special feature is the inclusion of the library of Halle University. Rust was a dation, Summer, 2008) reveals that the newest work on the program, a setting 19th-century successor of Bach as Kan- long trills starting on the upper note in of the hymn tune Llanfair by Rob- tor at the Thomaskirche in Leipzig and 18th-century ornament tables were in- ert Lind, written in April of this year. editor of his work. tended primarily for perfect cadences at Throughout the program, Lamlein in- The current catalogue of Bach’s work the end of a piece or section. The title’s vites and encourages the singing—both merely describes the fi rst few bars of the quotation, which derives from C. P. E. through inspirational leadership at the piece in its appendix and does not cite Bach, refers to a little trill that does not keyboard and through an ongoing con- any source. Blaut and Pacholke contend disturb the melodic line, but simply adds versation with his audience. the composition that they discovered tone color. What Wondrous Love: A Hymn had been copied by Rust in 1877 from Festival has been offered at churches a manuscript that has since been lost but in Worcester and Holyoke, MA, and can be traced back to Bach’s immediate Bristol, CT. Upcoming events include circle. They prepared a critical edition of the Hartford (CT) United Methodist the work, which was published by Ortus Church, among others. To see a sample Musikverlag (
RONALD CAMERON BISHOP Consultant Pipe Organs Digital Enhancements PIPE ORGAN COMPANY All-digital Instruments 8608 RTE 20, Westfield, NY 14787-9728 800.382.4225/Bedientorgan.com Tel 716/326-6500 Fax 716/326-6595
7+(25*$162)63$,1 0DGULG 0$5,/<10$621ZLOOOHDG+LVWRULF7RXUWR63$,1 )HEUXDU\WR0DUFK 6HJRYLD 7KLVIRXUWHHQGD\HGXFDWLRQDOWRXUZLOOLQFOXGHRUJDQLVWVRWKHU SHUIRUPLQJDUWLVWVDQGPXVLFORYHUV
6HYLOOH :HZLOOSUHVHQWPXVLFE\6SDQLVK3RUWXJXHVHDQG$PHULFDQ FRPSRVHUV&RQFHUWVZLOOEHSHUIRUPHGE\WRXUSDUWLFLSDQWV /LPLWHGWRSDUWLFLSDQWV &RUGRED 7RWDOFRVWLQFOXGHVDLUIURP'HWURLW &RQWDFW%0,7UDYHO,QF 0DODJD PDVRQWULS#EPLWUDYHOLQFFRP
8 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 8 8/13/08 8:35:37 AM TheThe lovelove ofof musicmusic inin itsits finestfinest expressionexpression
the JOHANNUS revolution www.johannus.com Adriatic Sea, opened Trinity Wall Street’s Lumpur, Adelaide, and the Melbourne “Pedals & Pumps,” a six-concert festival International Festival. He has performed Nunc Dimittis of international organ divas. They played throughout Europe, including two tours original and arranged four-hand music by to Norway, and in 1992 was the fi rst Brit- Rossini and Morandi, and used Carpen- ish organist in 45 years to give concerts John W. Eitzen died May 6 in San ter’s 175 “theatrical stops” that were em- in Romania. Diego; he was 79. Born and raised in bedded in the Trinity organ in 2007 for a Many composers have created new Mountain Lake, Minnesota, he received concert by Carpenter; and then stayed on organ works for Munns, including Gor- a bachelor’s degree in music from St. in New York to sightsee and hear the new don Jacob, Wilfred Josephs, Kenneth Olaf College and a master’s in music Middle organ that he designed. Leighton, Philip Moore, Knut Nystedt, education from the University of Iowa. Barrie Cabena, Robert Cundick, and After teaching instrumental and vo- Vivian Chua. His compact disc record- cal music in Iowa from 1950 to 1962, ing, Flying Visits: Around the World in Eitzen moved to San Diego, where he Seventy-Two Minutes, features a great taught instrumental music for 29 years, diversity of music. Having reached the retiring from the School of Creative and age of 75, Munns has decided to make Performing Arts in 1991. He served as his fi nal American tour in 2008, visiting organist-choirmaster at Trinity Lutheran friends and giving programs in many of Church in Sioux City, Iowa, First Con- his favorite spots around the States. gregational Church in San Diego, and Mission Hills United Church of Christ, and was an active member of the Spreck- els Organ Society, San Diego AGO chap- ter, and California Retired Teachers As- Jaroslav J. Vajda sociation. He is survived by his wife of 38 years, Connie, sons Christopher and History of the Organ, Vol. 1 cover Carl, two grandsons, nieces, nephews, and cousins. to trace the origins, history and develop- ment of the organ. It encompasses the May Josephine Moorer Pollock classical Italian style, the Golden Age in died in Charleston, South Carolina, on sixteenth-century Spain, and the French March 12 at the age of 94. A native of style of the eighteenth century, with Susan Jane Matthews Charleston, she attended Newberry Col- music by Frescobaldi, de Cabezón, de lege. She served as organist-choir direc- Arauxo, Attaignant, de Grigny, Daquin Susan Jane Matthews is featured tor of Trinity United Methodist Church and Couperin. For information: on a new recording, Chosen Tunes, on for 21 years, and was a charter member
AHIGHER L EVEL of E XCELLENCE
Great musicians need extraordinary instruments to deliver magnificent performances.
P.O. Box 156 • Orrville, Ohio 44667 • P 800.416.7426 • F 330.683.2274 • www.schantzorgan.com
10 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 10 8/13/08 8:36:07 AM ®
What would YOU design in Rodgers Organ Architect?
When you choose a Trillium Masterpiece Series® organ from Rodgers, there’s virtually no limit to your power to customize the instrument of your dreams.
With the help of a Rodgers dealer and our exclusive Rodgers Organ Architect® system, you can de- sign your own organ and have it delivered in far less time than you would expect.
Choose from a library of over 500 stops and take charge of every detail of the console layout, down to the function and position of the last toe piston. You’ll have more instantly available combinations First Presbyterian Church, Boise, Idaho than any other organ thanks to the Á exibility of Voice Palette, and you’ll be well prepared for any changes in worship style. And, should your needs change in the future, Trillium Master- piece organs are updatable so you can add features and keep up with new technology.
Now there’s no reason not to get a custom, one-of-a-kind organ. Call your Rodgers representative for a demonstration of Rodgers Organ Architect®.
® Rodgers Instruments LLC A Member of the Roland Group 1300 NE 25th Avenue Hillsboro, Oregon 97124 Inspiration, Innovation and Assurance Since 1958 503.648.4181 • fax 503.681.0444 Email: [email protected] On the Web: www.rodgersinstruments.com Foley-Baker, Inc. of Tolland, Con- formance center, Llewellyn Hall, with inches toward the center of the room. necticut, has removed Skinner Opus 793 a concert featuring a variety of musical We were up high enough to be able to from the Second Church of Christ, Sci- styles and a new Allen organ. In addi- In the wind . . . put a bridge from the top of the tower entist, Hartford, Connecticut. The all- tion to selections played on the school’s by John Bishop across the top of the organ to another original 44-rank instrument, beautifully new pianos, the concert’s fi nale featured tower. It was a three-manual free-stand- maintained for decades by the Thomp- a performance of Bach’s Toccata and ing organ in a classic organ loft with a son-Allen Company of New Haven, has Fugue in D minor. The three-manual, spiral stairway. Must have been 50 feet. been purchased by Harvard University 58-stop Allen Quantum™ organ is in- After his kick the tower didn’t stop mak- for installation at their Memorial Cha- stalled with two sets of audio, one per- ing noise for several seconds, and be- pel. The organ will undergo complete manently mounted on either side of the cause I was holding that frame I couldn’t reconditioning at the Foley-Baker shops proscenium. The second audio comple- steady myself. Nothing bad happened, and then be carefully installed in the ment is suspended above the stage, its but as I refl ect on that moment, espe- Cambridge chambers so as to not dis- height and position adjustable to provide cially watching our crews set up massive turb the original layout any more than optimal sound placement for a wide va- towers of scaffolding today, I can hardly necessary. Richard Houghten of Milan, riety of uses. believe the risk that guy exposed me to Michigan, will renovate, update, and in- The organist for the evening, Lachlan without asking. I would have said no. stall the console from Skinner Opus 906, Redd, is a graduate of the ANU School In another Cleveland church my boss replacing one built by Austin some years of Music and currently holds a post at and I witnessed a near disaster. We ago. Work is scheduled for 2010. Jona- the Cathedral Church of St. Paul, Mel- walked through the nave heading for than Ambrosino was consultant for Har- bourne. In 2007, Llewellyn Hall’s stage, the rear gallery where we were fi nishing vard Memorial Chapel. For information: pianos and other equipment were dam- renovation of the antiphonal organ. The 800/621-2624;
Atlanta First United Methodist Church A.E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Company and Atlanta First United Methodist Church are pleased to announce the recent com- pletion and dedication of their new pipe organ.
This instrument features a 5-manual console and 93 ranks of pipes in 9 divisions. The complete specification is available at www.pipe-organ.com for this and other pro- jects. A.E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Co.
P.O. Box 838, Lithonia, GA 30058 800-836-2726 www.pipe-organ.com
12 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 12 8/13/08 8:36:36 AM
to get knocked over when you stand up. feet? Thirty feet? Four years ago the on the corners of the piece you’re lift- Get your hands on a good industrial The price of the glue, $4.79. The price of Organ Clearing House dismantled the ing, and it’s very strong. A one-inch wide supply catalogue—I have those from the carpet, $47,500. huge Möller organ in the Philadelphia web is rated for 2,000 pounds in vertical Grainger and McMaster-Carr on my desk. A row of tin façade pipes is standing Civic Center. (That organ is now under lift. But keep a good eye on its condi- Go to the “safety” pages and leaf through. against the workshop wall. A worker is renovation in the new workshop of the tion. Recently there was an eerie photo You’ll see lots of things that protect against using a fi ve-pound hammer to break up American Organ Institute at the Univer- in the New York Times in the aftermath stuff you haven’t imagined could happen! the crates that the pipes came in. The sity of Oklahoma.) The organ chamber of the collapse of a construction crane. It Organbuilders are precious. Let’s keep head fl ies off the hammer and dents one was above the ceiling, 125 feet above showed a piece of torn webbing dangling them all in good health. Q of the pipes, and they all fall over, one the fl oor. The demolition company from a hook. That photo prompted us to at a time in slow motion like 15-foot-tall (the building was to be torn down) cut purchase new webbing for our next rig- tin dominos and there’s nothing anyone a hole in the fl oor of the blower room ging job! can do. big enough for the organ parts to pass In the nineteenth century, the great Cheery, isn’t it? through. And we were left standing on Boston organbuilding fi rm of E. & G.G. On Teaching This subject is on my mind for sev- the edge of an abyss. We used full-body Hook suffered two serious fi res, both of by Gavin Black eral reasons. One is that I’ve spent the harnesses and retractable life lines. If which destroyed their workshops. I know last couple days negotiating the rental you fell you’d drop about six feet and the of two North American organbuilders of a huge amount of scaffolding and rig- ratchet-action of the retractable would who have had bad fi res in the last decade. ging equipment for a large project we stop you, something like the seatbelts in Neither was caused by carelessness; will start next week, so I’ve been talking your car. And there you are, hanging 120 in fact, one was caused by lightning. I with salesmen about weight and height feet up. thought about those two colleague fi rms limits and what accessories are neces- working to rebuild their companies when sary to ensure safety. Another reason is Away aloft we heard of a terrible fi re at a boatyard that a locally owned small manufacturing A sailor hollers “Away aloft” as the near us. Washburn & Doughty is a fami- company near us suffered a catastrophic halyard hoists the sail up the mast. The ly-owned company with about a hundred fi re last week. And as we work with scaf- rigger might do the same. He ties a line employees that builds heavy commercial folding companies in New York we hear around the load, hooks it to the line from vessels like tugboats, fi reboats, and ferry- stories about the construction industry, the winch, and up it goes. It’s important boats. It’s quite a spectacle to see a hun- especially relating to recent serious ac- to choose the right type of line—you dred-foot tugboat under construction cidents involving cranes used in the con- don’t want chanciness caused by a line in a small village. And a mighty amount struction of high-rise buildings. that stretches, for example. But what re- of steel goes into the building of such a I love the image of the organbuilder ally matters is the knots you use. Some boat. On Friday, July 11, sparks from a at a wooden workbench, a window open knots are meant to slip. Some are meant cutting torch ignited a fi re that destroyed next to him providing a gentle breeze, a to be permanent. A favorite is the bow- the building. It was routine work for a sharp plane in his hands, and the sweet line, which cannot untie, but also cannot place like that, and newspaper stories smell of fresh wood wafting off the pull so tight that it cannot be undone. told that the fi re was offi cially accidental. workpiece as the shavings curl from the It was developed by early sailors to tie They were able to save a hundred-foot blade of the plane. Or that of the voicer a ship to a dock or mooring. Think of a tug that had been launched and was be- sitting in seclusion with beautiful new large sailing vessel, bow tied to a moor- ing completed at the dock—they cast it Counterpoint I pipes in front of him coming to life un- ing, bouncing on the waves and pulled adrift! But two others that were still in This month I will begin a series about der his ministrations. by the wind for weeks. There’s a terrifi c the buildings were lost and 65 employees the teaching of the playing of counter- But think of that majestic organ case amount of force on that knot. But you were laid off temporarily while the own- point on keyboard instruments. There in the rear gallery with an ornate monu- give the top of the knot a push sideways ers work out how to rebuild. are several reasons why this is an impor- mental crown on the top of the center and it can be taken apart easily. Begin- Ten years ago I was restoring an or- tant subject, one that can and should be tower, covered with moldings, carvings, ning sailors are taught how to tie the gan built by E. & G.G. Hook with lots considered as something meaningfully and gilding, and pushed up against the bowline both left- and right-handed, of help from volunteers from the parish. separate from other aspects of keyboard ceiling. Uplifting, isn’t it? It might be blindfolded. I once had to tie a bowline We were refi nishing the walnut case, and playing—though of course related to eight feet long, six feet wide, and three while diving under a boat in order to re- I mentioned the fi re hazard of rags that them. I will discuss playing counterpoint feet tall. It might weigh 500 pounds, and pair a centerboard control. were soaked with linseed oil. They must on organ and harpsichord, but I hope someone had to put it there. Making it is Different knots are intended for dif- be spread out to dry. If they’re left in a that some of this will also be useful for one thing. Getting it 50 feet off the fl oor ferent purposes. heap they will spontaneously combust. the playing and teaching of counterpoint and placed on those 20-foot legs that A half-hitch is a great knot for secur- One of the volunteers took a pile of the on piano, or for that matter on celesta, hold it up is another thing altogether. ing something temporarily, but it looks rags home and put them in a bucket in electronic keyboards, carillon, etc. Uplifting, all right. a lot like a slip knot. If you don’t know the middle of his backyard. He told us This month’s column will consist of Organbuilders have a variety of skills. the difference you might tie a slip knot later that it had only taken about ten min- some general thoughts, and ways for stu- We work with wood, metal, and leather. by mistake. How will that work when the utes before the bucket was full of fi re! dents and teachers to think about contra- We work with electricity and solid-state weight of a windchest shifts while being This is a pretty gloomy subject. But I puntal music. This is very much a begin- circuitry. We have acute musical ears for hoisted into the organ? write encouraging my colleagues to look ning: it is a vast subject! Next month I discerning minute differences in pipe If your skill set doesn’t include three around their workplaces with a criti- will add specifi c practice suggestions and speech and for setting temperaments. or four good reliable knots, I recommend cal eye toward safety. Be sure you have ways to develop both analytical strategies And we must be material handlers—that you learn them. There are neat books for the proper gear for lifting and moving and playing exercises appropriate to par- specialization of moving heavy things this purpose, predictably available from the things you’re working on. Store your ticular pieces. around safely. boating-supply companies. Some come paints and fi nishes in a fi re-proof cabi- The fi rst reason that the specifi c study To put that tower crown in place you with little lengths of line so you can prac- net. Eliminate the possibility of sparks of playing counterpoint on the keyboard need scaffolding, hoisting equipment, tice in the comfort of your home. fi nding a pile of sawdust and spread out is important is, rather obviously, that a lot and safety gear to keep you from falling. When hoisting heavy parts you can those oily rags. Encourage your workers of keyboard music is counterpoint. This How high up do you need to be before also use nylon webbing. It’s available in to use safety equipment. Safety glasses is, broadly speaking, truer the farther you need that gear? Easy. Ask yourself neat pre-cut lengths with loops on each may look nerdy, but it’s not cool to lose back in time you go, and, also broadly how far you’re willing to fall. Twenty end for easy tying. The webbing is easy an eye! speaking, truer of organ and harpsichord
C\Zkli\_`^_c`^_kj1 8@FBefom`cc\ DXkk_\n9\ccfZZ_`fXe[9iX[Ilc\Æ )''/ I\Yl`c[`e^Xe[X[Xgk`e^(0k_$Z\eklipjc`[\iZ_\jkj
9ilZ\=fnb\jÆ ÈC`m\Fi^Xej]fi;\X[IffdjÉÆg`g\jZXc`e^k\Z_e`hl\j
;\ee`jXe[Kf[[D`ceXiÆ I\jkfi`e^]fc[`e^Y\ccfnj
9iX[c\pAfe\jÆ KfeXcXe[d\Z_Xe`ZXc[\j`^e`jjl\j]fikf[XpËjZ_liZ_\j 8d\i`ZXe@ejk`klk\f]Fi^XeYl`c[\ij J_fgkflijXe[[\dfejkiXk`fejXkIXe[Xcc;p\i8jjfZ%# 8eelXc:fem\ek`fe 9%Ilc\:f%#Xe[I`Z_Xi[j#=fnb\j:f% FZkfY\i()Æ(, =\Xkli\[Xik`jkj1 :ifne\GcXqX?fk\cÆBefom`cc\#K\ee\jj\\ K`dfk_pJd`k_Xk:_liZ_Jki\\kLD: ;p\ifi^Xe Af_e9ifZbXkLe`m%f]K\ee\jj\\ I`Z_Xi[j#=fnb\jfi^Xe Efe$d\dY\iXe[j`e^c\$[XpXkk\e[\\jn\cZfd\ Al[p>cXjjXkJflk_\ie8[m\ek`jkLe`m% 9ifdYXl^_fi^Xe
JZ_\[lc\Xe[i\^`jkiXk`fe]fidXmX`cXYc\Xknnn%g`g\fi^Xe%fi^
14 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 14 8/13/08 8:37:01 AM music than of piano music. The organ sections that are contrapuntal where the In teaching the playing of counterpoint later); however, it can still be an unfortu- and the harpsichord repertoires are full surrounding sections are not. to students who are not already steeped nate place for a student to start. of fugues, older fugue-like forms with A further reason for studying counter- in the (theoretical) study of counterpoint If the fi rst source of a potentially crip- names like “canzona” or “ricercar,” cho- point as a player is that listening to—or or who do not have the experience of pling fear about playing contrapuntal rale preludes that are in a fi xed number listening for—contrapuntal lines is ex- playing a lot of rigorously contrapuntal pieces is a sense that those pieces are by of voices and that involve motivic imita- traordinarily good training for listening pieces, the fi rst task is to make the con- defi nition intellectually (too) complex, tion and development, and other such carefully to anything. Developing the cept of counterpoint as unintimidating as then perhaps the fi rst way to work on al- things. Pieces written in these purely ability to hear, especially, three or more possible. There is no doubt that the for- leviating that fear is by trying to defi ne contrapuntal forms are still common in simultaneous contrapuntal voices with mal theoretical study of counterpoint— contrapuntal music, and specifi c contra- later music, but less so. some degree of independence is perhaps or, more usually, an indirect impression puntal forms such as fugue, in as simple The second reason is that a lot of key- the best training for the ability to hear of what that study is like—can make and commonsense a way as is possible board music that we would not consider all parts of any musical texture, including contrapuntal music seem so complicat- consistent with accuracy. This would in- contrapuntal in a formal way has ele- inner or background harmonies in pri- ed, so intellectually rigorous, so arcane, volve avoiding, at least at fi rst, the laun- ments of counterpoint embedded in it. marily melodic or homophonic music. and so steeped in analytical detail as to dry list of terms that are used to try to This is clearly true, for example, of many The fi nal reason to mention here— be prohibitively frightening to play. This describe contrapuntally constructed Bach preludes (whereas Bach fugues are I’m sure that there are more—is that fright, which usually comes in the fi rst pieces, or the building blocks of those by and large “formal” counterpoint). It is practicing and playing counterpoint is instance from a sense of what the music pieces—terms such as subject, answer, true of many of the keyboard dance piec- the best training for dexterity and inde- is like compositionally, is sometimes en- inversion, augmentation, diminution, es that make up the Baroque keyboard pendence of fi ngers. The physical skills hanced by hearing experienced virtuoso stretto, episode, perhaps many more. suites, and of many toccatas, scherzos, developed by playing counterpoint performers say that counterpoint is more (Fortunately, it seems to me, a simple pieces with fanciful “character” names, will improve the playing of any kind of challenging than other music: that even colloquial way of describing what is go- etc. These elements sometimes consist music, usually both by making it seem a relatively simple Bach fugue, or in- ing on in a piece can often be in fact the of lines of counterpoint that are sur- easier and by making it sound better in vention for that matter, is “harder” than most accurate for that particular piece: rounded or accompanied by other notes the end (or, more meaningfully, by ex- Liszt or Brahms or Beethoven. This may more about this later on.) Also, it would that are not part of the counterpoint, panding the range of ways in which the well be true for that performer (usually be nice if any such defi nitions could also sometimes of implied contrapuntal lines player can play the music, by increasing a performer who was fi rst trained on pi- be interesting and intriguing, and serve in thicker textures, sometimes of short control and security). ano music from the Classical period and to connect contrapuntal music to the rest
EXCEL.
IN WORSHIP
IN PERFORMANCE
At Goulding & Wood, we understand that an instrument must serve the musicians who play it. Every aspect of our design is focused on providing the resources for the varying roles organists must fill. Our tonal designs offer creative and comprehensive resources for the authoritative performance of literature, the nuanced accompaniment of choirs, and the imaginative leadership of congregational singing. Our exclusive slider chest design, with our full ten-year war- ranty, ensures an unsurpassed reliability and effective musical response to the organist’s touch. Our visual designs sensitively complement the surroundings of the instrument while giving the musician ergonomic, intuitive control of the organ’s resources. In all aspects, the instrument creates an ideal setting for the musician’s inspiration to excel, both in worship and performance.
823 Massachusetts Avenue • Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 Voice: 800.814.9690 • Facsimile 317.637.5236 www.gouldingandwood.com
SEPTEMBER, 2008 15
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 15 8/13/08 8:37:19 AM of our musical (and perhaps non-musi- the upper voice, in m. 6, this is just a rep- keyboard music is probably by the tradi- proach to fi ngering and to the practical cal) experience. etition, not counterpoint. When it enters tional, straightforward analogy to sing- side of learning the notes. I will take this So, what is counterpoint and what is in the lowest voice in m. 21 and thereaf- ing, which is probably the original source up in detail next month. Q contrapuntal music? Here are a few at- ter, this is a contrapuntal event.) of both the concept of a contrapuntal tempts at addressing that question, none A contrapuntal piece of music is one voice and the nomenclature. That is, a Gavin Black is the director of the Prince- of which is intended to be complete or that has voices (regardless of whether they contrapuntal voice is a line of music—a ton Early Keyboard Center in Princeton, New defi nitive, or to exclude any others. They do the same thing as one another or dif- melody—that could be sung by an indi- Jersey. He can be reached at
United States Canada 1220 L Street NW 16355 avenue Savoie Suite 100 – No. 200 St-Hyacinthe, Québec Washington, DC J2T 3N1 20005-4018 Tel: (450) 774-2698 Tel: (800) 625-PIPE Fax: (450) 774-3008 Fax: (202) 737-1818 [email protected] [email protected] www.letourneauorgans.com
16 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 16 8/13/08 8:37:37 AM neath are the everlasting arms.” The words based on Psalm 46, will be loved tations are prohibited. Secular words are used only in the last half of the setting; prevailing hymn of the day, A Mighty by choir and congregation. substituted in the score for those perfor- their music appears separately at the Fortress, reverberates throughout Prot- mances. There are fi ve movements, with end. The congregation joins on the tra- estant churches. Thanksgiving brief spoken dialogue for actors prior ditional text and melody as the coda of The most universal celebration of the to the musical setting. The choral score the work. The music generally is easy for late fall was not started by the church. Now Thank We All Our God, Jer- contains the tuneful but not diffi cult everyone, with the treble choir used only Thanksgiving, which began after the Bat- emy Bankson. SATB, congregation, fl ute part. The text tells of the arrival in in conjunction with the adult choir. Full tle of Gettysburg in the Civil War, is usu- organ, with optional brass quartet and life in the new world. This is a very score and instrumental parts for brass ally recognized in the Sunday that pre- or quintet, timpani, and handbells. practical setting that would be a delight- and timpani are available (LB5697) cedes the actual Thursday of the event. MorningStar Music Publishers, ful addition to a worship service. from the publisher. Very useful for most Furthermore, many churches have spe- MSM-60-7016A, $1.75 (M). church choir situations. cial services on the Wednesday before This concertato based on Nun Danket With Grateful Hearts We Thank You, Thanksgiving, and it is not uncommon to Alle Gott has three verses, with the con- Lord, Lloyd Larson. SATB, keyboard, Come, Ye Thankful People, Come, fi nd choirs (and congregation members) gregation singing on the outer two; their and optional congregation, Hope Mack Wilberg. SATB and organ, absent on the Sunday that follows it. A music is included on the back cover for Publishing Co., C 5525, $1.80 (M). Oxford University Press, ISBN 0-19- further complication arises because of reproduction. The second verse is for un- Larson merges words of Mary Kay 386910-1 $1.80 (M+). the start of Advent, which this year is the accompanied four-part choir in a chorale Beall with the traditional Crüger melody This also uses the familiar Alford text last day of November. This means that setting. A full score (MSM-60-7016) and Now Thank We All Our God. The key- and traditional melody as its basis. The in those churches where it is common instrumental parts (MSM-60-7016B) are board part, on two staves, is easy, primar- music is not diffi cult but will require a to have a cantata performed as part of a available from the publisher. The choral ily chordal, support for the voices. The solid, large choir because of the divisi; service, the options are reduced down to score is designed for organ performance, congregation joins in two places on the men move into four parts. The organ three Sundays. Since many families de- but when brass is used it should play from traditional hymn. This is a pragmatic part is on three staves but is mainly part early for Christmas traveling, that the full score; there is an extended solo setting that has the choral music on two chordal throughout. Effective setting for may mean there are only two viable Sun- organ introduction. The music retains the staves with simple, diatonic parts. big choirs. days in 2008 that will provide the best popular melody throughout and is not dif- promise for choir attendance. Neverthe- fi cult. The last verse has a descant above Come, Ye Thankful People, Allen less, music for Thanksgiving is needed the unison melody. Useful for all sizes of Pote. SATB, treble choir, organ, with whether it be a Sunday or Wednesday choirs and situations. optional handbells and congrega- Book Reviews night. And, as St. Ambrose reminds us, tion, Flammer of Shawnee Press, “No duty is more urgent than that of Thanks for the Giving, Robert Powell. Inc., A 7583, $1.75 (M). returning thanks.” So, enjoy these dwin- A Thanksgiving Play with unison/2- The traditional St. George’s Wind- O Clap Your Hands, Gordon Giles. dling daylight hours heading toward the part, fl ute, and keyboard, Choristers sor tune is incorporated, although the Paraclete Press, ISBN: 978-55725- conclusion of the church year. Advent Guild, XCGCA-400, $2.95 (M). text primarily is based on Psalm 67 with 567-9, 160 pp., $25.95; P. O. Box and Christmas are just around the cor- This has a dual character and may be that tune as fi ller between statements. 1568, Orleans, MA 02653; 508/255- ner, and as church choir directors, we all used as a work for children in public The organ part, on two staves, is back- 4685;
The Lord of Harvest, arr. Austin DOBSON CASAVANT FRERES Lovelace. SATB and keyboard, GIA Publications, Inc., G-6826, $1.50 (M). Based on the Welsh tune Arfon with text based on Matthew 13, this joyful anthem has the keyboard part on two staves, usually doubling the vocal lines. There are three verses with only the sec-
ond in a full four-part choral setting. The BOODY TAYLOR music is easy with an inserted quote of St. George’s Windsor, a familiar mel- ody associated with the harvest theme. Reformation
A Mighty Fortress Is Our God, arr. Hal Hopson. Unison choir, congre- gation, organ, with optional brass
quartet and timpani, H. W. Gray DYER R. Publications, GCMR990, $1.30 (M-). This straightforward setting has four verses, with the last one employing a so- prano descant. The congregation sings on all verses but the third, which is for choir and organ with a fl owing, busy key- board accompaniment that offers con- GARLAND FISK trast to the bolder brass accompaniments elsewhere. A 17-measure instrumental introduction strongly sets out the Ein Feste Burg theme. This setting would be of particular interest to smaller choirs FRITTS wanting an anthem that sounds big, but is not diffi cult. The brass parts are avail- able as GCMR9901. A Mighty Fortress, arr. Mark Hayes. SATB, keyboard, brass quintet and percussion, Beckenhorst Press, Inc., BP 1785, $1.75 (M+). How Far Can You Travel in These in a Week? The Hayes setting is more challenging GOULDING & WOOD and contains choral divisi passages. The accompaniment is more developed and Students attending Pipe Organ Encounters sojourned to 17th century Germany, with typical Hayes rhythms that often dance along in 3+3+2. This is an excit- 18th century France, and 19th Century England, all the while captivated in mind, ing arrangement with several contrast- heart, and spirit by the beauty and majesty of the pipe organ and its music. ing verses, including one that moves into minor with a free tempo. The full score and parts (BP 1785A) call for horn, two Young people are forever changed when they play a pipe organ! Join APOBA in trumpets, trombone, tuba, timpani, and supporting AGO outreach programs to the next generation of organists! percussion. For large church choirs this is certain to be a work that will be repeated
frequently and is highly recommended. QUIMBY REDMAN SCHANTZ SCHOENSTEIN & HENDRICKSON Refuge and Strength, Mark Hayes. To receive information about pipe organs SATB and keyboard with optional brass choir, Beckenhorst Press, BP and recognized pipe organ builders 1716, $1.75 (M). A write or call toll free 1-800-473-5270 In this practical Hayes arrangement, P or on the web @ www.apoba.com
the men have limited responsibility and PASI RICHARDS-FOWKES often sing in unison with the women, BO Associated Pipe Organ Builders of America who have long solo sections in two parts. A P.O. Box 155 • Chicago Ridge, Illinois 60415 The music is fast and spirited with driv- ing syncopated rhythms and Hayes’s signature 3+3+2 rhythms. The brass OTT PARSONS parts are available from the publisher NOACK MURPHY LéTOURNEAU KEGG JAECKEL HOLTKAMP (BP1716A). This exciting music, with
SEPTEMBER, 2008 17
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 17 8/13/08 8:37:57 AM Choral Works,” the book is an ebullient there is background on individual com- the work of Roelof Duyschit in 1686, a Bach, Mozart, Reger, and Widor, where- discussion of 30 composers and selected posers, the slant is most assuredly toward year after Bach was born. Christian Vater as the feminine side expresses itself in choral settings that range from Grego- engaging the reader in a passionate re- added the Bovenwerk in 1727, and the the eloquent middle movements by Mo- rian chant to the music of Dominick Ar- alization of the texts and their liturgical organ underwent many generational zart, as well as in Reger’s introspective gento. Each essay, about three pages in implications. These anthems have com- changes so that by 1939 it was unten- chorale preludes. length, concludes with a pensive prayer mon texts that are heard every day in able. The organ was rebuilt in 1989–92 Those eager to hear or play the Müller designed as a personal devotion for the churches throughout the world, and the by Flentrop Orgelbouw, based on the organ will be delighted to know that mu- reader. Another unique feature is the observations found in one work often 1686/1727 instrument, from which only nicipal organ recitals (yes, the city of Haar- fi nal section, a “Four-Session Group may be transferred to other settings of 600 pipes survived that could serve as lem owns it) take place from mid-May to Study,” which offers tips for how the the same text. reference material for the 3,000 new mid-October on Tuesday evenings—and book may be used by groups of divergent Musicians might hope that the essays pipes. In addition, three reeds were also in July and August on Thursday after- people (musicians, choir singers, and would dig deeper into the music. Giles’s added, while the original windchests and noons. In addition, there are the Interna- laymen) in an examination and investi- contributions are from the other side of mechanical action were restored. The tional Organ Improvisation Contest and gation of ancillary messages deep within the spectrum and they offer exuberant 17th-century pitch of a′ = 460Hz was the International Summer Academy, held the settings. attentiveness to overlooked details in the modifi ed to a′ = 440Hz by moving up in even years, such as 2008, 2010, etc. In The opening 20 pages of introduction texts and their meaning. The fi ve essays the pipework, and equal temperament 2006 teachers included Kooiman, van der are a scintillating discussion of the histo- on the different movements of the Mass was chosen to enable performance of Kooy, Latry, Weir, Koopman, Trotter, and ry, background, and justifi cation of music are especially perceptive. 19th- and 20th-century music with other Piet Kee;
27 Marlboro Lane • Eugene, OR 97405 (541) 521-7348 [email protected]
• EASY—online permission and reporting • ECONOMICAL—based on average weekend attendance • THOROUGH—your favorite songs • CONVENIENT—includes a growing list of publishers
LOG ON TODAY! WWW.ONELICENSE.NET
18 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 18 8/13/08 8:38:16 AM elaborate piece on “Should God But Suf- anything electronic. Congratulations to tions on “The Star Spangled Banner,” The recording begins with a perfor- fer to Guide Us” refl ects the composer’s Jos van der Kooy and the producers who Dudley Buck. mance of the fi rst of Mendelssohn’s Six interest in Reger with smatterings of have made these wondrous organs viv- The 1866 Koehnken & Co. organ in Organ Sonatas. In the last several years Rheinberger, Saint-Saëns, and Schubert. idly accessible and in realizing their goal the Isaac M. Wise Temple in Cincinna- a number of these sonatas have been re- On the other hand, Cor Kee’s early piece in making one yearn to jump on a plane ti, Ohio, is probably the most important corded on German instruments that are on a 17th-century Dutch folk tune shares for Holland. surviving instrument produced by the claimed to be “authentic Mendelssohn glimpses of Rossini and Dupré before his Note: The CDs can of course be played once-fl ourishing organbuilding industry organs.” As noticeably the product of a writing delved into twelve-tone. on American players, and the DVDs can of Cincinnati. This 3/45 organ has many German immigrant, Johann Koehnken, The Repertoire: Bavokerk. Bach, be enjoyed on computer media software remarkable features that are not usually who was trained by another Swiss-Ger- Toccata, Adagio and Fuga C Dur, BWV with a DVD driver and reader. found on American-built organs of its man immigrant organbuilder, Mathias 564, and Nun komm’ der Heiden Hei- —Joel H. Kuznik period, such as a 5-rank Cornet on the Schwab of Cincinnati, there is a sense in land, BWV 659. Mozart, Fantasie F New York City Great, and a 4′ Bassethorn (Corno di which the Isaac M. Wise Temple organ is moll, KV 608. Reger, from op. 79b, Ach Bassetto) on the Pedal, to name but two. equally “authentic” for the performance Gott, verlass mich nicht, Morgenglanz According to the article about it in The of Mendelssohn’s works. The fi rst organ der Ewigkeit, Seelenbräutigam, and Wer Tracker, 50:2, Rabbi Isaac Wise seems sonata sounds extremely impressive on weiss, wie nahe mir mein Ende; and Tok- New Recordings to have established an unusual rapport this organ—massive and majestic without kata und Fuge D moll / D dur, op. 59. with organbuilder Johann Koehnken being bottom-heavy, and imposing with- Widor, Toccata, Symphonie V, op. 42:1. when he commissioned what was then out being unduly loud. The same is ap- Daan Manneke, Penoo. Thom Miles plays the restored 1866 the largest instrument yet built in Cin- parent in the next four tracks on the CD, This jaw-dropping DVD disk, featur- Koehnken & Co. organ at the Isaac M. cinnati for his synagogue in 1866. The four more German compositions from ing an organ with a paralyzingly awesome Wise Temple, Cincinnati, Ohio. Thom organ is an amazing survival. Although the fi rst half of the nineteenth century. tonal aura, alternates the large works by Miles, organist. Arsis CD 157,
SEPTEMBER, 2008 19
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 19 8/13/08 8:38:34 AM have been written in a distinctly Jewish English one, and the piece comes off ex- in Detroit. Shenk was one of the editors tional part for just one octave of hand- idiom. The two works found here are tremely effectively on this organ. of the Adoremus Hymnal. It was after his chimes, which carry part of the melodic from Sinfonia 2: Holy Days and Festi- The fi nal work on the compact disc Easter services in 2005 that he suddenly line. A great piece for all ages, with a vals, a compilation of fi ve movements. is Dudley Buck’s well-known Concert took ill and died very soon afterwards. unique technique, which should charm There seems some confusion about this Variations on The Star-Spangled Ban- (See “Nunc Dimittis,” The Diapason, the listener. in the notes, which state that there are ner. This is included partly because September 2005, pp. 10, 12). but three movements and that the over- Dudley Buck is believed to have played The collection includes, as the title Adagio, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, all title is The Three Festivals. In fact, the organ in the Isaac M. Wise Temple states, fi ve separate pieces that work well arr. Malcom Wilson for 2–3 octaves notwithstanding that there are three while participating in the Cincinnati May as wedding processionals and recession- of handbells. Agape (Hope Pub- major festivals in Judaism—Sukkoth, Festivals of the 1870s. As in the Men- als or for general church service festive lishing Company), Code No. 2421, Pesach, and Shabuoth—there are minor delssohn sonata, the Koehnken organ pieces where triumphal music is needed. $3.25, Level 2 (E+). festivals as well. The best known of these produces a very impressive and majestic The pieces in order of publication are: This lovely melody is from Mozart’s is probably Chanukah. Thus Berlinski’s effect in this piece. All told, this is a very 1. Solemn Entry (C Major), 2. Intrada Concerto for clarinet and orchestra (K. Sinfonia 2 was not limited to the three attractive and interesting recording, and (D Major), 3. Processional (E-fl at Ma- 622), and is realized on just two pages. major ones, but includes movements for I thoroughly recommend it. jor), 4. Festive Procession (F major), and It is straightforward ringing through- two of the minor festivals as well. The —John L. Speller 5. Entrée (G Major). All of these pieces out and would be a nice addition to any two movements from Holy Days and St. Louis, Missouri were written between 1974 (Solemn En- handbell library. Festivals included on the recording are try) and 1999 (Intrada). All except for No. 1 Sukkoth (Tabernacles) and No. 3 the fi rst from 1974 were obviously writ- Vision Quest, Cathy Moklebust, for Shabuoth (Pentecost). They are pleasant ten for couples on their wedding day and 5–6 octaves of handbells with hand- mystical works in a modern idiom. New Organ Music still bear the dedication to the soon to- chimes (5 octaves) and percussion. After the Berlinski movements come be-wed couple. So immortalized forever Choristers Guild, CHB494, $6.95 two of the Four Preludes on Jewish is the wedding music for Jim and Amy, (D+). Melodies by William Bolcom (b. 1938), Calvert Shenk, Maestoso: Five Pro- Peter and Alice, Dan and Heather, and According to the information pro- a work specially commissioned in con- cessionals for Wedding or General Peter and Sidney! vided in the preface, a “vision quest” is a nection with Fritz Noack’s restoration Use. Catalog #6030, $8.50, Canti- The style is generally diatonic and com- period of spiritual seeking among certain of the Koehnken organ in the Isaac M. caNOVA Publications, 304/725-2787; positionally conservative, with middle Native American peoples. It is a religious Wise Temple. William Bolcom is not a
ORGAN HISTORICAL SOCIETY The Organ Clearing House P.O. Box 26811 Richmond, VA 23261 PO Box 290786 Open Monday-Friday 9:30am-5:00pm ET Specialists in Choral Charlestown, MA 02129 and Organ Music Ph: 617.688.9290 Telephone: (804) 353-9226 2209 Crestmoor Road, Suite 220 Nashville, TN 37215 [email protected] 615-386-3542 § 800-851-9023 § 615-297-4291 Fax www.organclearinghouse.com www.loisfyfemusic.com
20 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 20 8/13/08 8:38:56 AM Inaugurating the new Craighead-Saunders Organ at the Eastman School of Music Hans Davidsson
When the Eastman School of Music Organ and recent photos, visit
SEPTEMBER, 2008 21
Sept 08 pp. 2-21.indd 21 8/13/08 8:39:17 AM From the Dickinson Collection: Memorizing Controversy Lorenz Maycher
The fi rst installment in this series, “From the Dickinson Collection: Remi- niscences by Clarence Dickinson, Part 1: 1873–1898,” was published in the July 2008 issue of THE DIAPASON. Introduction On March 28, 1893, Clarence Dick- inson, age 19, performed a recital at Church of the Messiah in Chicago in which he played his solo repertoire from memory. The following day’s favorable review in the Chicago Tribune sparked a heated debate among prominent Chi- cago organists, carried out in letters to the editor. Two months later, the journal Music published a symposium on the subject based upon these letters. The following article presents the original Chicago Tribune review and the sympo- sium from Music, documents found in Clarence Dickinson’s personal library, housed at William Carey University in Hattiesburg, Mississippi. (Clarence Dickinson’s own words concerning the memorizing controversy may be found in “Reminiscences by Clarence Dickinson” in the July 2008 issue of The Diapason.) “Memorizing Controversy” is the second Program for Clarence Dickinson’s fi rst installment in a series of articles featur- recital from memory, Church of the ing items from Dr. Dickinson’s library. Messiah, Chicago, March 28, 1893 —Lorenz Maycher Laurel, Mississippi mand of the manual keyboards, but of the pedals and the vast array of mechani- From the Chicago Tribune cal accessories. He must not only com- March 29, 1893 prehend the instrument as a whole, but Clarence Dickinson’s last free organ thoroughly understand the workings of concert this season took place last eve- every detail. It is often necessary to pre- ning in the Church of the Messiah. The pare certain combinations of stops long selections by the young organist includ- before they are brought into action, and ed a Bach Fantasia and Fugue, Ritter’s the mind is constantly forced to act far in Sonata, op. 19, an Offertoire by Batiste, advance of the fi ngers and feet. Buck’s Triumphal March, Mendelssohn’s Now, to burden the mind with memo- “Spring Song,” the Gavotte from “Mi- rizing the notes in addition to these re- gnon,” and Volkman’s Allegretto from op. quirements is as harmful as it is useless, 63. All these were played from memory, and I maintain that organists are heard at and the freedom in expression and in- their best when they are unhampered by creased animation revealed in the play- the mental strain attendant upon com- er’s work, by reason of his being unham- Review of Clarence Dickinson’s memorized recital, Chicago Tribune, March 29, mitting to memory the compositions they pered by notes, lent unusual worth to 1893 play. The “increased animation,” which the performance, and demonstrated that your reporter discovered last evening, I organists, like pianists, are heard at their Rubinstein, Tausig, Buelow, Paderewski, of consciousness, but a few minutes at observed to be rather a frequent hurrying best only when they have memorized the Joseffy, Liebling, Sherwood, Mme. Rive- the keyboard will generally recall them. and unsteadiness of the tempo, caused by compositions they play. Mr. Dickinson King, Miss Aus Der Ohe, Mme. Car- But organ playing without notes is nervousness, which rendered the work of was especially successful in the Buck reño, and many others, some of them much less common. There are organists, the player indistinct and inaccurate. March, the Volkman Allegretto, and the mere pupils, combine to show that there such as the late Arthur Creswold, Fred- In my opinion, greater “freedom of Batiste Offertoire. Miss Meeker and Mr. is nothing at all of an impossible char- eric Archer, and Harrison Wild, who oc- expression” might have been attained if Root were the assisting vocalists, and Mr. acter in memorizing some hundreds of casionally play without notes, while the the player had referred occasionally to Wild joined Mr. Dickinson in the perfor- pieces and playing at a moment’s notice. majority of their public appearances his notes, while the value of his perfor- mance of Jensen’s “Festival Prelude” for Some who teach much more than they are made with notes. It happened a few mance from an artistic standpoint would four hands and double pedal. devote themselves to public playing do weeks since that a young Chicago organ- not have suffered in the least. Among the this. Here in Chicago are Sherwood and ist played an organ programme from most noted organists of my time, whom From Music Mr. Liebling, either one of whom is able memory, and the critic of the Tribune I have known personally and with whose May, 1893 to play at a moment’s notice any one of, commented upon the fact favorably. This playing I am quite familiar are: August Organ-Playing from Memory perhaps, three hundred compositions elicited the following letter: Haupt, Gustav Merkel, A. G. Ritter, W. A Symposium you may chance to call for. Frequently, T. Best, Alexandre Guilmant, Theodore The time has gone by when a pianist these artists never refer to the notes of By Mr. Clarence Eddy: Dubois, Eugene Gigout, Charles M. dare present himself before an audience some of these pieces for years together; Your issue of today contains a report Widor, Dudley Buck, Samuel P. Warren, for a recital from notes. The example of other pieces may momentarily fade out of an organ concert which took place in John K. Paine, Eugene Thayer, Frederic this city last evening. After mentioning Archer, George E. Whiting, and George some of the selections contained in the W. Morgan. programme, your reporter makes the As a rule, all of these artists have been following assertion: “All of these were in the habit of playing from notes in pub- MANDER ORGANS played from memory, and the freedom lic, and even their own compositions. in expression and increased animation Who can say they were at such times not revealed in the player’s work, by reason “heard at their best?” New Mechanical of his being unhampered by notes, lent It would be better for critics to con- unusual worth to the performance, and fi ne themselves to a plain statement of Action Organs demonstrated that organists, like pia- facts than to express an opinion at vari- nists, are heard at their best only when ance with sound judgment based upon a they have memorized the compositions practical knowledge of the subjects they they play.” write upon. As an organist of considerable experi- Exquisite ence, and a personal friend of many dis- By Mr. Harrison M. Wild: Continuo Organs tinguished players of the organ, whose In replying to Mr. Clarence Eddy’s St. Peter’s Square views on this subject coincide with mine, letter in your issue of April 3, wherein I take exception to the import of the he seeks to belittle the memorizing of London E 2 7AF • England above statement. In only one particular organ music as well as the knowledge [t] 011 44 20 7739 4747 is the organ like the piano—namely, that of the critic, I desire to acknowledge [f] 011 44 20 7729 4718 the keyboards are similar. The structure the questionable taste of taking up the [email protected] of the organ is vastly more complicated cudgel against a former instructor, at the than that of the piano, while its scope same time deprecating the motive that www.mander-organs.com and tonal resources are incomparable. In will prompt a great artist to take from Imaginative Reconstructions order to completely master a large organ, one over a score of years his junior one one must not only have a perfect com- word of the praise extended, or to ques-
22 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 22-24.indd 22 8/13/08 8:40:13 AM Clarence Dickinson at the Skinner Clarence Dickinson in 1893 Clarence Eddy Harrison M. Wild console, Brick Presbyterian Church, New York City and, greatest of all, by the effect pro- piano performance, simple or otherwise, have been no freedom acquired in the duced upon the audience, as evidenced is not more artistic without notes than new medium of expression, and hence tion the desirability of possession on the by its attention and applause and the ver- with them? That such memorizing is an opinion could be of little or no value, part of the latter, or anyone, of an ability bal encomiums afterward by musicians physically harmful none but the expert or might be summed up in the following never, to the writer’s knowledge, publicly not in any way interested in the welfare physician or personal experience can words: “I fi nd that I am too nervous with- displayed by the former. of the young musician. determine. That it is for best artistic re- out the notes to do myself or the compo- As for the critic, were he as capable As to memorizing, we can but look at sults, Mr. Eddy will not deny, when he sition justice,” or, “have not the time to of judging an organ performance as Mr. that from two standpoints: fi rst, the do- remembers the performances of artists adequately prepare, but must play, and Eddy, the probability is that Mr. Eddy ing away entirely with the music. The such as Archer, Creswold, Middelschul- hence must use the notes.” That oth- would fi nd in him a rival organist, bet- mere mechanical portion of an organ te, and the like, who were, or are, tried ers have not memorized and given such ter say brother artist, certainly not the performance is so trifl ing that the mind in the fi re of public appearance. I know memory performances thorough trials is critic, an evident thorn in the fl esh. The that can memorize the Bach G minor Saint-Saëns plays by memory. A pupil of no suffi cient reason why it should not be people who read criticisms know that Fantasia and Fugue, or the Thiele Varia- mine, who has studied with Guilmant, done in the future, any more than be- they are but expressions of one man, or a tions, or the Reubke Sonata, can in a says Guilmant has a wonderful memory, cause no one discovered America in the few men. No critic’s criticism tallies with few moments so fi x the registration for and plays at a moment’s notice any one fourteenth century Columbus should not all his readers’ opinions, and the greater a strange organ as to leave fantasy free. I of a host of pieces. Best told a pupil of have in the fi fteenth. the critic, the more heinous becomes the make bold to assert that Mr. Eddy could mine, when the rumor went the rounds The second way of memorizing is the crime of non-agreement. If a critic thinks write out within fi ve minutes the regis- of his failing eyesight, that he could get partial way, needing but a glimpse here as we do, let us bless him. If he doesn’t, tration of the foregoing three numbers along without the notes now, since he and there at the music. How many pos- let us curse our bad luck and hope for for any specifi cation submitted, and, knew by memory most of the music he sess it? The one who can remove the eyes better luck the following time. having done it, would not have to think would need. Mr. Middelschulte told me at any moment for any number of mea- As to the young artist’s concert, I know one beat ahead, since at any particular that Haupt knew by memory all of Bach’s sures, can do without the music, and from it as his fi rst attempt at public playing point a change could be thought of and works, and played them without notes. personal experience I can say that there is by memory, and, barring his pardonable made, when necessary for the effect at But why continue? This surely is suf- much more trouble in fi nding one’s place nervousness, which resulted in a lack of that point or further along. If Mr. Eddy fi cient. Can it be said that anyone of the after a piece is memorized than there is clearness at times, more than compen- will grant the possession of this ability, list of great organists given by Mr. Eddy, in keeping right on by memory. sating amends were made by results the remainder of the organ memoriz- that for one entire season all performanc- Now, to close by answering the ques- obtained in other parts of the works, by ing is placed upon the plane of piano es were by memory? If not, then there tion sure to be put: “You do it with your lightning-like changes of registration, memorizing, and who shall say that the was not a suffi cient trial, there could piano playing, why don’t you do it with
LOYOLA UNIVERSITY CHICAGO E>E: DG<6C 9:9>86I>DC L::@ 8:A:7G6I>DC
Both the Office of Mission and Ministry and Sacramental Life invite the community to a week-long celebration of the new Madonna della Strada Chapel pipe organ. Tours, demonstrations, recitals, guest speakers, and other special presentations will be held at the chapel throughout the week of October 19.
OCT. 19 OCT. 20 OCT. 20, 22, and 23 OCT. 24 ORGAN BLESSING CHAPEL LECTURE SERIES ORGAN DEMONSTRATION DEDICATION RECITAL: Masses at 10:30 a.m., Guest speaker Michael Joncas Find out how an organ works, GUEST ARTIST TOM TRENNEY 5 p.m., and 9 p.m. will discuss the topic of how it was built, and hear Recital at 7 p.m.; Liturgical Music Today great music. 12:30 p.m. Oct. 20 open reception to follow. at 7 p.m. and 23; midnight Oct. 22.
All events are free and open to the public. Please join us for this very special and one-of-a-kind musical celebration at the Madonna della Strada Chapel on the Lake Shore Campus.
For more information, call 773.508.8043 or visit LUC.edu/sacramental_life
Goulding and Wood Pipe Organ Builders, Indianapolis, Indiana, Opus 47
SEPTEMBER, 2008 23
Sept 08 pp. 22-24.indd 23 8/13/08 8:40:35 AM your organ playing?” If multitudinous mer, and I dare say they will, one and all, riding on the car or taking a walk, he can duties, teaching and the like, could be play with their music before them. Does play them over in his mind—certainly a laid aside and my income remain the it follow that masters like Guilmant and pleasure to him. And the more the per- Clarence Eddy autograph (from a 1923 same, I could be found any day between Best are incapable of memorizing what former gets familiar with his pieces, the letter written by Eddy to Clarence 9 and 5 o’clock upon the Unity Church they purpose to play? Indeed, it seems more he likes them, he is not afraid that Dickinson) organ bench, and every programme I to me that if anything, the effi cient or- something might happen while he is played would be by memory, to my ex- ganist is better equipped and qualifi ed to playing them, for he knows his friends treme satisfaction, and to the certain commit music to memory than any other too well. Then, while he is playing, he is enhancing of all artistic effect to such specialist in music. He is, or ought to his own listener; he not only gives plea- a degree as to do a great share toward be, thoroughly familiar with the theory sure to others, but the fi rst and best of the lifting of that onus which clings to an of music, from the simple chord to the all to himself. I have a blind friend in organ performance in the minds of the intricacies of the double counterpoint, Berlin, who studied the organ with me; majority of the people. in order to properly assume the duties I found that the ear keeps good control, of his profession, especially in Catho- while the eye has nothing to do. At the Mr. Louis Falk: lic and Protestant Episcopal churches, same time, I do not deny the diffi culty Harrison M. Wild autograph (from a Clarence Eddy, Esq.: Your reply in where improvisation in accompanying in playing polyphonic music without the 1927 letter written by Wild to Clarence yesterday’s Tribune in relation to playing plainsong is almost imperative. It may, notes. August Haupt, my teacher, played Dickinson) at organ concerts from memory pleased therefore, be understood that the reason once in a concert, where Felix Mendels- me very much. In regard to memorizing: why an organist plays with the music be- sohn was present, the F major “Toccata” I question whether playing or singing fore him is because he considers it to his of Bach by memory; while he was playing from memory is under all circumstances advantage and not because of any defect the second canon, the wind in the pedal the proper way of rendering music in in his musical training. stops suddenly gave out, which confused public, for it very frequently leads the him for a moment. Mendelssohn, who Wilhelm Middelschulte autograph performer into faults, such as inaccura- Mr. Wilhelm Middelschulte: no doubt noticed the little mistake, re- (from an undated letter written by cies, interpolations and mannerisms en- At your request I would say in regard marked, “The second canon occurred, Middelschulte to Clarence Dickinson) tirely foreign to the sense of the compo- to an organist playing from memory: The compared to the fi rst one, a little short.” sition. Witness the contortions of many virtuoso is the interpreter of the idea Haupt told me that he, in his younger in its repertory. The player, independent pianists, violinists, and singers as living of the composer; in order to interpret years, practiced every morning before of notes, has time to do this; the player, examples of my assertion. Again, why well, technical diffi culty in perform- breakfast the six organ sonatas of Seb. confi ned to notes, lets it pass. Moreover, does not Theodore Thomas conduct his ing must not exist for him, then, which Bach, and knew them by memory, but there is the same question of quality of matchless concerts from memory? Does is more important, he must be inspired never risked playing those diffi cult trios attention. When a man knows a fugue not the score, which he is constantly fol- by the idea of the composition so that in public without his notes. in the sense of knowing all the answers, lowing, detract from his ability to prop- the playing appears as a new creation A good result of playing by memory all the modulations, all the little counter erly direct his orchestra? Has he more and not as a studied piece. If he is able would be that the too much neglected themes, which come in here and there, work to perform than an organist sitting to do this, then he is a true artist, whose improvisation of organists will take more he is in much better condition to make before the great Auditorium organ? Let noble profession it is to send light into place, for the musical form of a composi- the hearer realize them also. What kind us see. The conductor uses his brains and “the depths of the human heart” (Rob. tion goes into his fl esh and blood and will of work would an actor make of the “To hands with which to guide from fi fty to Schumann). Can the virtuoso reproduce give him power and confi dence enough be or not to be” if he had to hold the 100 players; the organist uses his brains, the composer’s idea better with or with- to express his own thoughts in appropri- book in hand while giving it?—or “The hands and feet to master fi ve keyboards, out the notes? I am rather inclined to ate form without much preparation. Es- quality of mercy is not strained.” 120 registers, and innumerable combi- leave this an open question. I should say, pecially the thorough musician will profi t The question why orchestral directors nations; he is required to represent every in order to play artistically, it is not nec- by this method. do not direct without notes may as well instrument of a large orchestra, either essary to play without notes. But if the be answered here as elsewhere. They do! individually or collectively, in the per- organist prefers to memorize his pieces, The Editor of Music: Mr. Nikisch, who is always a fi ne pianist, formance of some pieces. What would I think it has its advantage—he bears the When the ground has been so cov- often conducts without notes; always, become of the player’s wits and his ac- composition of great masters like pre- ered by these eminent gentlemen, it is when he knows the work suffi ciently cumulative memory in case of the not cious jewels always with him, in his head perhaps unnecessary to add anything; well. And when he does conduct with- infrequent mishaps to some parts of the and his mind—they are like dear friends nevertheless, as there is a principle in- out notes, you will fi nd that he is doing organ during his playing? The chances to him—constantly in unity with him, volved, Music makes bold to put in its something very different with his men are that he would wish to have his music they grow on him the more he knows oar. The principle of mentally acquiring than when he is half the time keeping his before him. We shall probably have the them. In order to keep them constantly the subject matter of whatever musical place in a score where he has to turn a pleasure of listening to many organists of in memory it is not necessary to always discourse one wishes to address to an leaf at a precise moment once in about world-wide fame during the coming sum- practice at the instrument—while he is audience is exactly the same as that in- forty measures. Von Buelow often con- volved in the reading of an actor or elo- ducts Beethoven symphonies without cutionist. There was a time when actors notes, and they say that he plays them had to depend upon the prompter; now wonderfully. Mme. Carreño told the an actor who does this is recognized as present writer that of all the privileges not “letter perfect” in his part, and there- of Europe, she prized Buelow’s orches- fore not arrived at the point where he is tral readings of Beethoven symphonies Eloquence and Artistry ready to begin to “interpret” it. Elocu- better than anything else. (But this was tionists have discovered for themselves before she married D’Albert.) in Organ Building that they are much more free and effec- Hans Richter, I believe, sometimes tive in their readings when they have the conducts without notes. All conductors text securely in their mind, leaving them of light opera do so; many conductors of free to deliver it with all the emphasis grand opera do so when they have a run and nuance of an original discourse. of a single work. Von Buelow has often Piano recitals would be impossible conducted the “Meistersinger” without from notes. There is not an audience notes. Even Mr. Thomas, who belongs in the world that would sit through a to an older school of conductors, some- recital played from notes. Not even Pa- times conducts without notes, and it is derewski could hold his audience, were safe to assume that if he had to begin he hampered in this way. The reason again his career as leader at the pres- that so many play without notes is that ent time, he would acquire the habit, it is less strain. The mind is more free in order to leave his eyes at freedom to to feel the music. The interpretation control his men. comes home to the hearer. One reason The perfection of orchestral playing for this may be that the player has to be would be where all the players were “let- much more master of his discourse than ter perfect” in their parts, and played when he can depend upon the notes. He them under the eye of the conductor— must have studied it more thoroughly. such a conductor as Nikisch or Tomlins. Few players realize how half-hearted is I mention these rather than Mr. Thomas, the quality of mental attention devoted not because I think them greater, but be- to practice. When a player is trying to cause they belong to a different school— memorize, he has to pay close attention, the school of intense interpretation, and out of this attention grows a fi ner where all the smaller parts of a piece are appreciation of delicate nuances and fully brought out, without intending to beauties of the piece. crowd them into the prominence of the Now this, which is so demonstrated in grand parts. the case of the piano, is still more true In short, whether we take memoriz- of the organ, for, as Mr. Eddy says, the ing as a convenient method of sifting out organ is a very complicated instrument. the incompetents, or as the easy way for Saint Andrew’s Episcopal Church, Denver, CO Besides using the feet for playing, there those who thoroughly possess a musical Timothy Krueger, Music Director, Frank Nowell, Organist are many changes of registration, and not subject, the fact remains that it is the a little adaptation and substitution to do proper thing for all public performers, in order to realize or represent an effect and for all private performers who care which the individual organ may not have about making a living effect. Member, Associated Pipe Organ W. S. B. Mathews John-Paul Builders of America New! To be continued 112 West Hill Street Buzard Classifi ed advertising on Lorenz Maycher is organist-choirmaster Pipe Organ Builders Champaign, Illinois 61820 at First-Trinity Presbyterian Church in Lau- 800.397.3103 • www.Buzardorgans.com THE DIAPASON website: rel, Mississippi. His interviews with William Teague, Thomas Richner, Nora Williams, Al- www.TheDiapason.com bert Russell, and Robert Town have appeared in THE DIAPASON.
24 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 22-24.indd 24 8/13/08 8:40:58 AM Celebrating the Cathedral Church of Christ Choir, Lagos, Nigeria, at Ninety Godwin Sadoh
he history of church choirs in Ni- Tgeria is interwoven with the arrival of Christianity in Nigeria, which dates back to the mid-nineteenth century. The early missionaries from the United States and Europe settled mainly in the southwest (Yoruba) and southeast (Igbo) regions of Nigeria. The conversions of the local indigenes encouraged the mis- sionaries to build several churches for worship and to continue the propaga- tion of the Gospel in Nigeria. It was in these churches that the converts were fi rst exposed to English hymns in four- part harmony. Worship at the Cathedral Church The Cathedral Church of Christ, La- gos, was founded in 1867 by a group of Cathedral Choir Christian worshipers from St. Peter’s Anglican Church, Faji, Lagos, where Sunday Worship maintained to this day. After the era of services were conducted only in Yoruba 7:15 am—Holy Eucharist (Communion Hamlyn, there was a brief period of short Thomas Ekundayo Phillips at the 1932 language. These worshipers were Si- service without choir) appointments of organists such as that organ, at the Cathedral Church, Lagos erra Leonians who spoke mainly English 9:15 am—Choral Mattins (Cathedral of D. J. Williams, J. G. Kuye in 1904, and wanted to have services in English. Choir sings) and later Frank Lacton, a Sierra Leo- Hence, it was agreed that services at the 9:15 am—Contemporary Praise and nian who served until the appointment of Cathedral Church would be conducted Worship (Every fourth Sunday) Thomas Ekundayo Phillips in 1914. exclusively in English. Consequently, the 9:15 am—Cornerstone Fellowship Thomas King Ekundayo Phillips congregation at the Cathedral Church (Youth/college students) (1884–1969) was appointed Organist and strictly committed to having all wor- 9:15 am—Children’s Church (Sunday Master of the Music after completing ship in English, including the sermons, school) his musical training at Trinity College of hymns, announcements, and all special 11:15 am—Holy Eucharist (Communion Music, London (1911–14). Prior to his musical renditions by the Cathedral with or without the Cathedral Choir) appointment at the Cathedral Church, Choir. Another reason for embracing he was organist at St. John’s Anglican worship in English was that the church Sunday Evening Worship Church, Aroloya, and St. Paul’s Angli- was designed to cater to the musical 5 pm—Evensong with the Cathedral can Church, Breadfruit, Lagos. Phillips’s and spiritual needs of the cosmopolitan Choir (fi rst and second Sunday) tenure was a remarkable turning point Lagos society as well as visitors from 5 pm—Community Hymn Singing (third in the history of church music in Lagos outside the country, foreign diplomats, Sunday) and Nigeria as a whole. He built a solid and the various ethnic groups in Nigeria 5 pm—Time of Refreshing (fourth Sun- foundation on which the present choir who communicated fl uently in English. day) stands fi rmly today as one of the best In other words, the congregation at the 5 pm—Psalmody (Whenever there is a cathedral choirs in Africa. He retired in Cathedral Church comprised the elite, fi fth Sunday) 1962 after serving in the music ministry the well-educated, intellectuals, upper- at the Cathedral Church for forty-eight Charles Oluwole Obayomi Phillips middle-class, the affl uent and apparently Weekday Worship years (Trinity Sunday 1914 to Trinity playing the organ at the Cathedral the cream of the Lagos society. I remem- 6 am—Mattins Sunday 1962). Church of Christ, Lagos ber my days at the Cathedral Church as a 6:45 am—Holy Eucharist Thomas Ekundayo Phillips was suc- chorister between 1980 and 1994: almost ceeded by his son, Charles Oluwole everyone communicated in English dur- Saturday Worship Obayomi Phillips (1919–2007), as the ing choir rehearsals and services. Occa- 7:15 am—Mattins Organist and Master of the Music; he sionally, one might hear people commu- 11:15 am—Holy Eucharist faithfully served the church for exactly nicate in Yoruba, but it was always some three decades (Trinity Sunday 1962 to few sentences and they would quickly Cathedral Choir and Masters of the Trinity Sunday 1992). Charles Obayomi switch to English. Music Phillips was born on September 28, While the Cathedral Church of The Cathedral Church of Christ Choir 1919, in Lagos. After attending C. M. S. Christ has received criticism for adopt- is the oldest choir in Nigeria, with an av- Grammar School, Lagos, he proceeded ing a complete English service within erage membership of about fi fty male to Durham University, England, receiv- a Yoruba state and in one of the most voices, half of whom are boys who sing ing a bachelor’s degree in commerce populous African countries, one could the treble part. However, that number with distinction in June 1946. Phillips argue that this decision was worthy, has recently exploded to over eighty started taking private lessons on piano considering the pluralistic nature of strong and dedicated voices—treble when he was only four years old with the indigenous languages in Nigeria. (37), alto (18), tenor (13) and bass (15). Nigeria’s most celebrated international Linguistically, Nigeria is widely diversi- The fi rst choir was organized by Robert musician, Fela Sowande, and as a choir fi ed, with three major ethnic groups— Coker in 1895, comprising young men boy at the Cathedral Church received Yinka Sowande, brother of Fela Yoruba, Igbo and Hausa. In addition, and women. Coker was acknowledged organ lessons under the tutelage of his Sowande there are multiple subdivisions of the to be the fi rst indigenous organist and father. At age fourteen, Phillips had al- major languages, known as local dia- choirmaster in Nigeria, and apparently ready started assuming leadership roles Organist at the Cathedral Church of lects that include hundreds of tongues. the fi rst to occupy this lofty position at in music; fi rst, he rose to the enviable po- Christ until his death in May 2007. Af- With such extensive linguistic diversi- the Cathedral Church of Christ, Lagos. sition of school pianist at C. M. S. Gram- ter Phillips’s retirement in 1992, Yinka fi cation, the government had to adopt Prior to his appointment as organist at mar School and was later appointed by Sowande, Fela Sowande’s younger English as the offi cial language of the the church, he was sponsored by the his father as the assistant organist of the brother who had been Substantive Or- country after independence from Great Cathedral Church to travel to England Cathedral Church in 1933. ganist under Phillips for several years, Britain in 1960 in order to unify the di- to study music in order to form a good Charles Obayomi Phillips studied was temporarily appointed as interim verse ethnic groups. To elevate one of choir suitable for Christ Church, which organ with J. A. Westrup at Durham Master of the Music; he retired on De- the local languages over another would was later elevated to a cathedral status in University, and with Christopher Idonill cember 31, 1992. have caused internal dissatisfaction and 1923. Coker was regarded as a musical in 1976 at the Royal School of Church History was made on January 1, 1993, deep division. genius of his time. He was the fi rst in- Music, London. During his tenure as with the appointment of Tolu Obajimi Interestingly, the Cathedral Church digenous musician to attempt the perfor- Organist and Master of the Music at the as the fi rst female Organist and Master of Christ was one of the few pan-ethnic mances of Western classical music in Ni- Cathedral Church, Phillips maintained of the Music of the Cathedral Church and pan-African congregations in Nige- geria, notably Handel’s Messiah. Coker the tradition of the Cathedral Choir and of Christ. She is the fi rst woman to be ria. Membership in most other churches died on February 9, 1920. developed new ideas that made the choir appointed to the position of organist and was made up of one major ethnic group; The choir was later reorganized dur- soar in standard. In spite of the tremen- music director in any Nigerian church. hence, services were conducted there in ing the tenure of N. T. Hamlyn, a Brit- dous economic upheavals in the political, Obajimi is also the fi rst Nigerian female the indigenous language of the group. ish musician and pastor of the church. social and religious life of Nigeria since organist to play recitals on the pipe or- But at the Cathedral Church of Christ, Hamlyn replaced the women of the choir independence in 1960, music at the Ca- gan. In addition to playing organ and there are Yoruba, Igbo, Edo, as well as with boys and young men, following the thedral Church continues to be the cen- piano recitals all over Lagos, she had ac- descendants of Sierra Leone, Ghana, tradition of most British cathedrals. The ter of inspiration and worship. companied several standard choral works Togo, and other West African countries choir made tremendous progress that es- In addition to his strenuous tasks at such as Messiah, Elijah, St. Paul, Ode for who migrated to Nigeria in the nine- tablished it as a model for other church the Cathedral Church, Charles Obayo- St. Cecilia’s Day, and Thomas Ekundayo teenth and early twentieth centuries. As choirs. Hamlyn provided the choir with mi Phillips served as president of the Phillips’s Samuel. the mother church of the Anglican dio- surplices and erected choir stalls at the Union of Organists and Choirmasters Tolu Obajimi certainly deserves special cese in Lagos, the Cathedral Church of east end of the church. A strict discipli- in Lagos, an organization that oversees recognition and commendation for dar- Christ is always busy with services and narian, Hamlyn was always keen on regu- the maintenance of high standards of ing to step into the very shoes that even other benevolent activities throughout lar and punctual attendance, and was thus music in all Anglican churches in the men found to be extremely challenging. the week: able to set a high standard that has been Lagos diocese. He was the Emeritus Since 1993, she has expanded the mu-
SEPTEMBER, 2008 25
Sept 08 pp. 25-29.indd 25 8/13/08 8:41:43 AM back to the hard work and foundation laid by Thomas Ekundayo Phillips. Phil- lips emphasized strict discipline, regular and punctual attendance at choir prac- tices, correct interpretation of notes, voice balance, articulation, attack, com- portment, reverence in worship, and ut- most sense of good musicianship. His ex- pectations were very high and certainly demanding, but the choir always rose to his standards. During choir practices, as the conductor, Phillips was very sensitive to intonation. He would detect and cor- rect any faulty notes emanating from any section of the choir. He would also call to order any chorister who did not hold his music book correctly, such as covering the face with it or placing it on the lap while seated. The present arrangement Tolu Obajimi, present Organist and where choristers placed their books on Master of the Music, at Cathedral the raised desk did not exist then. Church of Christ organ Thomas Ekundayo Phillips was known to be very meticulous and thorough in sic ministry of the Cathedral Church to everything he did—whether he was the delight and with the support of the dealing with twelve probationers or with choir, clergy and the entire congregation. his augmented choir of over one hun- Cathedral Church of Christ, Lagos One of her most remarkable accomplish- dred voices. One of the criteria to join ments was the creation of the Cathedral the Cathedral Choir or his augmented ents. Each week, the choir comes into Hymn Singing, Psalmody is simply the Church of Christ Choir Orchestra, which choir was the ability to sight-read mu- the church at least four times with a total alternation of readings, in this case the was launched at the 80th anniversary of sic. Furthermore, the singer must have time of about eight hours. The Organist Psalms of David, by members of the con- the choir on November 22, 1998. The had a very good voice to be able to sing and Master of the Music usually devotes gregation, with the chanting of the actual other two signifi cant programs added to under Phillips’s direction. Consequent- thirty minutes to the junior boys or those Psalms done by the congregation and/or the Cathedral Church ministries under ly, his choir learned anthems, hymns, on probation from 6 to 6:30 pm before the Cathedral Choir. The reader presents her leadership are Community Hymn chants, and other standard choral works the main choir practice begins. He/she an historical background of the Psalm— Singing and Psalmody: Chanting the in a very short time. One of the ways he trains them in sight reading of music no- who wrote it, the occasion, why, when Psalms of David. tested his choir to see if they had mas- tation, vocal exercises, and theory of mu- and where the Psalm was likely written. Tolu Obajimi’s successful activities at tered a work was with the accompani- sic. All this training ultimately leads to This approach helps the congregation to the Cathedral Church are not surprising ment. Often, at the last rehearsal of an the boys taking the external examinations have a better understanding of the theo- to those who knew her before she began anthem before Sunday worship, he of the Trinity College of Music, London. logical underpinning of the Psalm, which at the Cathedral Church. She brought would start the choir off with the organ, Successful candidates would receive cer- inevitably would enable them to sing with into the church’s ministry several years and then suddenly stop playing right in tifi cates if they passed the exams. understanding and energy. Through this of experience as a professionally trained the middle of the piece; if the choir fal- The older members of the Cathedral medium, the Master of the Music and musician. Obajimi studied music at the tered and stopped, he would ask, “sup- Choir were never left out of continu- the Cathedral Choir teach the congrega- Guildhall School of Music and Drama, pose the organ broke down during the ous training. Some prominent senior tion the latest techniques of chanting the London, in the 1960s; on her return to performance on Sunday, are you going members of the choir were occasionally Psalms of David, thereby helping them Nigeria, she taught music at Queen’s to stop singing?” His choir did not know sponsored by the Cathedral Choir to the to correct some performance errors dur- College, Lagos, for several years, and an anthem, as far as he was concerned, Royal School of Church Music, London, ing rendition. she also founded and taught at her own until they could sing it convincingly and refresher course training as the funds Interestingly, some Yoruba Psalms Tolu Obajimi Conservatory of Music, confi dently without any accompaniment were available. This normally took place set to music as anthems by Thomas Lagos. Obajimi is presently assisted by and without dropping in pitch. Honor- during summer when the choir was away Ekundayo Phillips are always included Richard Bucknor as Choirmaster, Sina able Justice Yinka Faji, who began as a on vacation in June or July. On return, in the service. Presently, this is one of Ojemuyiwa (the best and most famous choir boy under Charles Obayomi Phil- the choir member would give a report the few avenues in which Yoruba songs Cathedral Choir tenor) as Assistant lips and now sings alto, recounts the of all he learned, paying particular at- are performed in worship at the Cathe- Choirmaster, Jimi Olumuyiwa (former benefi ts of the discipline instilled in him tention to the new innovations in church dral Church of Christ. According to the Cathedral Choir Librarian) as Assisting as a Cathedral chorister: music as practiced in England—in the Master of the Music, the use of Yoruba Choirmaster, and Tunde Sosan as Sub- form of new anthems, hymns or hym- versions of the Psalms in this program stantive Organist. Membership in the choir disciplined nals, latest techniques of chanting the showcases works of talented Nigerian It is important to mention that the me. To me discipline is synonymous with Psalms or singing regular church hymns composers in sacred music and Psalmody/ Cathedral Church of Christ has a rich the choir. It is now a personal taboo for and sacred concerts. hymnody in particular. Special settings of me to miss Sunday services—Mattins and rigid tradition of appointing some- and Evensong. Choir practice at 6 pm on the Psalms were normally performed by one from within the choir to the leader- Tuesdays and Thursdays as a choir boy Choir Ministry the Cathedral Choir only, while the con- ship position of Organist and Master of and now as a choir man, no side talks dur- The role of the choir in the ministry gregation listened with dignifi ed atten- the Music. Charles Obayomi Phillips ing rehearsals, team work, orderliness, of the Cathedral Church of Christ is im- tion. Examples of works in this category received organ lessons from his father, and mutual respect; these and more have mense. The choir leads the congregation include Thomas Ekundayo Phillips’s Emi Thomas Ekundayo Phillips, and gave been and still are the norms of the choir. every Sunday in hymn singing, versicles O Gbe Oju Mi S’Oke Wonni (I Will Lift Tolu Obajimi her fi rst lessons in organ The choir made me bold. I remember one and responses (antiphonal prayers set to Up My Eyes Unto the Hills–Psalm 121) and trained her to the profi cient level Holy Eucharist Sunday service that I was music), special settings of liturgical mu- and Nigbati Oluwa Mu Ikolo Sioni Pada to sing a solo. It was the Agnus Dei. When necessary for appointment as the Cathe- it was time to sing, I stood up and opened sic such as Venite, Benedictus, Te Deum, (When the Lord Turned Again the Cap- dral Organist. Even though Obajimi was my mouth. As soon as I started singing, ev- Nunc Dimittis, Magnifi cat and the Ordi- tivity of Zion–Psalm 126). Interestingly, never a member of the Cathedral Choir, eryone in the congregation looked up and nary of the Mass. The Master of the Mu- during the tenure of Thomas Ekundayo she had been a member of the church my heart started beating fast. I then said sic uses the choir to teach the congrega- Phillips, the evening services on the last for several years and she began by play- to myself, “Yinka, they are looking at you, tion new music. Sunday of each month were always in Yo- ing piano for the 7:15 am Holy Eucha- will you fail?” I almost stopped singing; one The Master of the Music is always at- ruba. The Cathedral Choir would dress rist during Charles Obayomi Phillips’s way or the other, I completed the solo and tentive to how the congregation sings in their red cassocks and surplices, aug- tenure. She was later called upon to ac- sat down. Since then, I have become very church hymns. In order to boost the mented by the voices of the Choral Soci- bold to address a large crowd; in fact, I can company the choir at rehearsals during address the entire nation. Other good vir- standard of congregational singing, Tolu ety with the ladies dressed in white buba the week, and she participated in several tues I picked up include comportment dur- Obajimi introduced a Community Hymn and alari costumes (traditional gowns). concerts such as Mendelssohn’s Elijah ing worship, improved speech control and Singing service slated for the third Sun- The two choirs would perform Phillips’s and Handel’s Messiah in the late 1980s. good manners generally. day of each month. This was designed Yoruba compositions in these services. Tunde Sosan started off as a choir to encourage members of the Cathedral The Cathedral Church of Christ truly boy, and he was trained on the organ by Before a choir boy or man can be ad- Church to attend Sunday evening wor- proves itself to be a unique culturally Tolu Obajimi before he went to study mitted into the choir to sing in Sunday ship. Apart from the roster for church blended congregation in terms of hym- at the Trinity College of Music, Lon- worship, he must fi rst go through the rig- societies and individuals, families are nals used for worship. The church exem- don. Other notable musicians who have orous probationary period that normally also encouraged to sponsor the service. plifi es the nature of an interdenomina- served as honorary organists, substitute last several months. The probationary pe- In this service, the Master of the Music tional faith-based organization with the organists and/or recitalists at the Ca- riod of choir boys is eight months, while writes out the background information use of hymn books from diverse church- thedral Church include Fela Sowande that of adults is around three months. or history of the hymns to be sung in the es. The hymnals used for worship in- (musicologist and organist-composer), I remember my probationary period in program. There is no sermon; however, clude Ancient and Modern, Ancient and Ayo Bankole (musicologist and organ- 1980 while I was still in high school. I at- one or two Bible lessons are inserted into Modern Revised, Songs of Praise, Meth- ist-composer), Modupe Phillips (a son tended the choir practices on Tuesdays the program as epilogue. The service odist Hymn Book, Hymnal Companion, of Thomas Ekundayo Phillips, he played and Thursdays, but on Sundays I would opens and closes with prayer. The format Baptist Hymnal, Saint Paul’s Cathedral the organ at the age of twelve), Samuel sit in the congregation for worship and of the service is simply an alternation of Psalter, Church Hymnal, Alternative Akpabot (musicologist and composer), was never allowed to sing with the choir readings with hymn singing. The histori- Service Book, New English Hymnal, Re- Kayode Oni (concert organist and choir until I completed my three months of cal background of the hymns is read by demption Hymnal, Broadman Hymnal, director), Godwin Sadoh (organist-com- probation. It felt so good in those days to individual members of the congregation, Sacred Songs and Solos, More Hymns poser, choral conductor and ethnomu- put on my beautiful cassock and surplice while the choir and congregation sing for Today, and indigenous hymns written sicologist), Kweku Acquah-Harrison and sing tenor in the most famous Angli- the hymns. Before the last hymn is sung, by Thomas Ekundayo Phillips as well as (Ghanaian organist and music educator), can Church choir in Nigeria. the sponsors and committee members of other members of the choir. Albert Schweitzer (German musicolo- Whenever the boys completed their the service are usually acknowledged. gist and organist), and Ian Hare of King’s probation, they would be formally ad- Whenever there is a fi fth Sunday in Concert Performances College, Cambridge, England. mitted into the Cathedral Choir at a spe- a month, the Cathedral Choir presents The Cathedral Church of Christ Choir cial service in which their parents would special evening music entitled “Psalmo- is well known throughout the southern Choir Training assist them to put on the white surplice dy: Chanting the Psalms of David.” This regions of Nigeria for its seasonal con- The outstanding musical standards of over the black cassock. This was always was also one of the creative innovations of cert performances. The choir sets the the Cathedral Choir today can be traced a moment of joy and pride for the par- Tolu Obajimi. Similar to the Community tone and standard of music through its
26 THE DIAPASON
Sept 08 pp. 25-29.indd 26 8/13/08 8:42:03 AM exceptional renditions of standard classi- the schools of music in London. Hence, eration from the imperialists are some of the performance of the entire three parts cal works. Thus, the extremely rigorous there is a tremendous infl uence of the the commonalities in the themes of the of Thomas Ekundayo Phillips’s Samuel. schedule of the Master of the Music is British worship system at the Cathedral songs. Even though Nigeria obtained her There were some few instances when the further laden with concert activities. Church. Furthermore, most of the com- independence from the British govern- choir staged a concert on Good Friday, Apart from the weekly routine of choir posers of the music used for worship are ment in 1960, the infl uence of British such as John Stainer’s The Crucifi xion practices in preparation for Sunday British—John Ireland, William Byrd, culture is still very strong today. It per- under the direction of Thomas Ekundayo worship, the Master of the Music must John Stainer, Bernard Rose, David Will- meates every aspect of Nigerian exis- Phillips in 1916. According to the Cathe- prepare the choir for concerts, which cocks, John Rutter, Ralph Vaughan Wil- tence, from cultural life to politics, social dral historians, this was the fi rst Good include sacred masterworks, instrumen- liams, Samuel Wesley, Thomas Attwood, life, education, and Christian worship Friday cantata concert in Nigeria. tal pieces, and organ recitals. The con- and Charles Stanley. However, in fair- as observed at the Cathedral Church of There are other times in the year that cert performances are in the form of an ness to the Organists and Masters of the Christ, Lagos. the Cathedral Choir performs concerts Annual Choir Festival, Advent Carol Music, compositions from other Euro- Following the choir festival is the in and outside of the church. Notable Service, Festival of Lessons and Carols, pean nationalities are occasionally used. Advent Carol Service in December. oratorios, cantatas, and orchestral works Easter Cantata, and other types of vari- These include the works of Beethoven, The choir performs selected and tune- have been performed by the choir, such ety concerts throughout the year. Mozart, Bach, and Schubert. ful carols and hymns with themes that as Mendelssohn’s Elijah (performed in Thomas Ekundayo Phillips inaugurated To augment the works of foreign com- talk about the coming of Christ. The 1989), Hymn of Praise, and St. Paul; the Annual Choir Festival at the Cathe- posers, the Cathedral Organist and Mas- carols and hymns are interspersed with Bach’s Christmas Oratorio (performed dral Church of Christ in November 1918, ter of the Music uses the music of se- the reading of six Bible lessons that tell in 1953); Samuel Coleridge-Taylor’s Hi- to celebrate the musical accomplishments lected indigenous Nigerian composers, the story of the promises of the coming awatha’s Wedding Feast; Handel’s Ode of his lovely choir and to showcase the ex- notably past and present choir members Messiah. The lessons are mostly taken to Joy, Judas Maccabaeus, and Ode for pertise of the group. The festival is tra- and organists. The Master of the Music from the book of Isaiah in the Old Tes- St. Cecilia’s Day (performed in 1998); ditionally scheduled for the Sunday near- has always been very careful not to pro- tament, with two short ones from the Haydn’s The Creation; Stainer’s The est to St. Cecilia’s Day (November 22), mote and glorify the compositions of in- New Testament. Daughter of Jairus and The Crucifi xion and takes place in the two main morning digenous musicians who have no direct The Festival of Lessons and Carols has (performed in 1916); Walford Davies’ services (Choral Mattins and Choral Eu- connection with the Cathedral Church always been the climax of the Cathedral The Temple; and Edward Elgar’s Pomp charist) and Evensong. The choir sings Choir. Among the famous Nigerian mu- Choir musical performances for the year. and Circumstance performed by the Ca- hymns, versicles and responses, Psalms, sicians or choir members whose works Therefore, the choir is always at its best, thedral Church of Christ Choir Orches- and beautiful anthems. The evening fes- were often performed include the fa- singing with clarity, tenacity and excel- tra at the 80th anniversary of the choir tival opens with a short organ recital or ther of the choir himself, Thomas Ekun- lence. The festival takes place on the last on November 22, 1998. a variety concert of solo and chamber dayo Phillips, Charles Obayomi Phillips, Sunday in December of every year even These concerts featured solos, choral music that lasts twenty-fi ve minutes, and Fela Sowande, Yinka Sowande, Lazarus if it were after Christmas Day. This al- and instrumental music. The concerts of- it usually closes with an organ voluntary Ekwueme, Tolu Obajimi, Sina Ojemuy- lows other parish churches to have their ten attract dignitaries, professional musi- (postlude). The organ recital is played iwa, and Tunde Sosan. I am looking for- own Christmas services earlier, so that cians, and students from far and near to by one of the Cathedral organists or by ward to the day when my own compo- choirs from all over Lagos could con- the Cathedral Church. The venues of a guest organist such as Kayode Oni and sitions would be included in the music verge on the last Sunday of December to the concerts were either the Cathedral Kweku-Acquah Harrison. repertoire at the Cathedral Church. hear the Cathedral Choir. Church, Glover Memorial Hall, or other It is noteworthy that on the occasion of The choral and organ compositions The Easter season is another high concert halls in Lagos. The hall was al- the eighty-fi rst Choir Festival in 1999, the of Fela Sowande provided a musical point in the musical activities of the Ca- ways packed to capacity. Many visitors to Cathedral Choir marked the thirtieth an- and cultural link with the United States thedral Choir. The Cathedral Church of the Cathedral Church have commend- niversary of the death of Thomas Ekun- because some of Sowande’s pieces are Christ Choir is popularly known for its ed the outstanding singing of the choir dayo Phillips with the publication of some based on African-American spirituals. annual evening concert on Easter Sun- and even remarked that it could favor- of his compositions in book form, Sacred The texts of the spirituals share a com- day. This can take the form of the per- ably compare with the cathedral choirs Choral Works: English and Yoruba. The mon theme with the Nigerian songs of formance of an Easter cantata or the per- in England in terms of quality. Gerald book contains several anthems, hymns, liberation written in the 1940s through formance of a major choral work such as Knight, former Director of the Royal descants for hymns, versicles and re- the 1960s during the era of the national- Handel’s Messiah as performed on Easter School of Church Music, London, once sponses, settings for canticles and Psalms, ist movement that fought for the inde- Sunday, April 19, 1981, and on March 31, remarked that the Cathedral Church of and chants for canticles and Psalms. pendence of Nigeria from the British 2002. The Cathedral Choir traditionally Christ Choir, Lagos, is second to none in The Cathedral Church of Christ is colonialists. The Cathedral Choir could performed the entire three parts of Mes- the whole of West Africa. British in every aspect of its worship, see the spiritual connection between siah once every three years during the Some of these concerts were specifi - ranging from the use of the English lan- African-American slavery and the colo- tenure of Charles Obayomi Phillips; but cally organized to raise funds for either guage to the order of service and the nial experience in Nigeria, which lasted the choir performed only parts two and the Cathedral Church or to buy a new music selections. In fact, all the organists over a century (1840s–1960). The pain, three in 2002. Another Easter cantata organ. For example, Thomas Ekundayo have been directly or indirectly trained in suffering, anguish, and the hope for lib- took place on Sunday, April 7, 1996, with Phillips presented several concerts with
9ALE 5NIVERSITY GRADUATE STUDY IN ORGAN PERFORMANCE AT 9ALE )NSTITUTE OF 3ACRED -USIC AND 3CHOOL OF -USIC
FACULTY 4HOMAS -URRAY 0ROFESSOR OF /RGAN -ARTIN *EAN 0ROFESSOR OF /RGAN *EFFREY "RILLHART /RGAN )MPROVISATION
DEGREES OFFERED -ASTER OF -USIC -ASTER OF -USICAL !RTS !RTIST $IPLOMA $OCTOR OF -USICAL !RTS
#HURCH -USIC 3TUDIES CURRICULUM AVAILABLE &ULL