(Public Pack)Agenda Document for Planning Committee, 04/12/2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Public Document Pack NOTICE OF MEETING PLANNING COMMITTEE WEDNESDAY, 4 DECEMBER 2019 AT 10.00 AM THE EXECUTIVE MEETING ROOM - THIRD FLOOR, THE GUILDHALL Telephone enquiries to Democratic Services Tel 023 9283 4870 Email: [email protected] If any member of the public wishing to attend the meeting has access requirements, please notify the contact named above. Planning Committee Members: Councillors Hugh Mason (Chair), Judith Smyth (Vice-Chair), Matthew Atkins, Steve Pitt, Lee Hunt, Donna Jones, Terry Norton, Luke Stubbs, Claire Udy and Gerald Vernon- Jackson CBE Standing Deputies Councillors Chris Attwell, George Fielding, Jo Hooper, Suzy Horton, Frank Jonas BEM, Gemma New, Robert New, Scott Payter-Harris, Lynne Stagg, Rob Wood and Tom Wood (NB This agenda should be retained for future reference with the minutes of this meeting.) Please note that the agenda, minutes and non-exempt reports are available to view online on the Portsmouth City Council website: www.portsmouth.gov.uk Representations by members of the public may be made on any item where a decision is going to be taken. The request needs to be made in writing to the relevant officer by 12 noon of the working day before the meeting, and must include the purpose of the representation (e.g. for or against the recommendations). Email requests to [email protected] or telephone a member of the Technical Validation Team on 023 9283 4826. A G E N D A 1 Apologies 2 Declarations of Members' Interests 3 Minutes of the previous meeting held on 6 November 2019 (Pages 5 - 8) 4 Chair's notices - Dates of future meetings 1 Members are asked to agree meeting dates for the remainder of the municipal year (all Wednesdays at 1pm): 8 January, 19 February, 11 March and 15 April 5 Updates on previous planning applications 6 Update on nitrates The Development Manager will give an update on the nitrates situation. Planning Applications 7 19/01097/FUL - Southsea Seafront from Long Curtain Moat in the west to Eastney Marine Barracks in the east (Pages 9 - 114) Flood and coastal erosion management scheme comprising a combination of vertical sea wall, raising and realignment of the promenade, construction of stepped revetment, rock armour revetments and groynes, secondary defence walls and bunds, beach widening and management, and all associated works, highway alterations, removal of trees and landscaping. Scheme includes the removal and repositioning of 34no. Grade II listed lamp columns, 3no. Grade II listed shelters and 6no. Grade II listed monuments, works affecting the grade II listed South Parade Pier, regrading and works to the grade II listed Southsea Common and works to the grade I listed Naval memorial. The proposal constitutes EIA development. 8 19/01090/LBC - Seafront shelters Nos.7. 8 and 11, Clarence Esplanade, Southsea Removal, refurbishment and relocation of three seafront shelters 9 10/01088/LBC - Monuments, various locations, Clarence Esplanade, Southsea Removal and relocation of 6no. Grade II listed monuments - Trafalgar, Chesapeake, Peel Shannon, Aboukir, Trident and Crimean - to include construction of replacement plinths 10 19/01129/LBC - South Parade Pier, South Parade, Southsea, PO4 0SW Raising and resurfacing of the existing promenade adjacent to and under the pier and canopy, construction of adjacent vertical flood defence walls and associated works, widening of the beach and the installation of flood gates to the eastern access 11 19/01089/LBC - Lamp columns, various locations, Clarence Esplanade, South Parade and Eastney Esplanade, Southsea, PO4 0SW 2 Removal, repair and relocation of 34no. Grade II listed lamp columns along the seafront 12 19/01091/LBC - RN War Memorial, Clarence Esplanade, Southsea Raising of existing planters and seating (to south of memorial), provision of new access steps from the promenade and new seating, replacement lighting blocks and associated re-grading of Southsea Common 13 19/00592/REM - Former Drayton Dairy, Station Road, Portsmouth Application for the approval of reserved matters in respect of layout, scale, appearance, materials and landscaping for the development of 108 dwellings with associated roads, cycle paths, footpaths, car parking and 'pocket park' as approved by outline application 17/00224/out (amended plans received September and November 2019) 14 19/01382/FUL - Knight & Lee, 53 - 57 Palmerston Road, Southsea, PO5 3QE Mixed use development comprising change of use of building, with partial demolition and extension at roof level (500sq.m. net floorspace) and excavation works at basement level, to provide retail (Class A1), café (A3), bars (A4), 43-bed hotel (C1), gymnasium (D2), cinema (D2) and offices (B1) with associated plant, equipment and enclosures 15 18/02089/FUL - 142 Milton Road, Portsmouth, PO4 8PN Construction of 4 storey residential block to form 12 flats; to include 13 car parking spaces with associated bicycle and refuse storage (following demolition of public house) Members of the public are permitted to use both audio visual recording devices and social media during this meeting, on the understanding that it neither disrupts the meeting nor records those stating explicitly that they do not wish to be recorded. Guidance on the use of devices at meetings open to the public is available on the Council's website and posters on the wall of the meeting's venue. Whilst every effort will be made to webcast this meeting, should technical or other difficulties occur, the meeting will continue without being webcast via the Council's website. This meeting is webcast (videoed), viewable via the Council's livestream account at https://livestream.com/accounts/14063785 3 This page is intentionally left blank Agenda Item 3 PLANNING COMMITTEE MINUTES OF THE MEETING of the Planning Committee held on Wednesday, 6 November 2019 at 1pm in the Executive Meeting Room - third floor, the Guildhall These minutes should be read in conjunction with the agenda and associated papers for the meeting. Present Councillors Hugh Mason (Chair) Judith Smyth (Vice-Chair) Matthew Atkins Steve Pitt Terry Norton Claire Udy Welcome The chair welcomed members of the public and members to the meeting. Guildhall, Fire Procedure The Chair explained to all present at the meeting the fire procedures including where to assemble and how to evacuate the building in case of a fire. 91. Apologies (AI 1) Apologies for absence had been received from Councillors Lee Hunt, Donna Jones, Lynne Stagg and Luke Stubbs. 92. Declaration of Members' Interests (AI 2) No interests were declared. 93. Minutes of the previous meeting held on 9 October 2019 (AI 3) RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting held on 9 October 2019 be approved as a correct record to be signed by the Chair. 94. Updates on previous planning applications (AI 4) The Development Management Lead reported that: 25 Battenberg Avenue - retrospective application for a front dormer. The Inspector upheld the delegated decision to refuse this application on the grounds that it is too large and intrusive. Applications for a front dormer have now been refused three times. 29 Marmion Road - application for a rear extractor duct on the future café/ restaurant. The Inspector overturned the committee's decision to refuse the application on the grounds that there is a variety of design, age and uses of buildings in the conservation area; on balance the arrangement at the rear of the building was utilitarian but functional and that the fenestration would remain the dominant feature. The material would be the same colour as the render. It would be a more discreet location in respect to the conservation area and the main drag on Marmion Road. 1 Page 5 95. Updates on nitrates (AI 5) This item was discussed at the end of the meeting. The Assistant Director Planning & Economic Growth reported that the Mitigation Strategy had been drafted and was currently with Natural England the key statutory body whose support the council is seeking. They have assured the council that their comments would be submitted by Friday. Members would then be notified before it can be used towards the end of this month. In response to questions from the committee, he explained that planning permissions are on track to be considered by the end of the month but it could be at the start of December. It was agreed that a brief note be provided to all Planning Committee, if the information from Natural England is received on Friday. 96. 19/00762/FUL - 104 Elm Grove, Southsea PO5 1LP - Change of use from retail (Class A1) to restaurant/ café (class A3) to include installation of extraction system to the rear. (AI 6) The Planning Officer introduced the application. Deputations are not minuted, but can be viewed as part of the webcast of the meeting: https://democracy.portsmouth.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=157&MId=4247&V er=4 Robert Levin, the freeholder of the premises and Mr Essa, the applicant gave deputations in favour of the application. Members' Questions. In response to questions from members, the following points were clarified by the Planning Officers: Decisions made at the Planning Committee do not impact on any future decisions. The nearby Coop is currently open. The premises at number 104 was open when the application was submitted. Now the business at number 106 appears to have expanded into number 104. The premises at 110 and 112 are excluded from the Primary Frontage policy. The reasons for the boundaries for the policy are not recorded. The rationale for the policy is set out in the preamble to the Local Plan. It explains that each local centre has different needs and thresholds for the varying uses. Many factors influence the success of business including many nuances: how that particular sector is fairing; customer care; price points etc. The number of vacant premises is low in this primary frontage and indicates that it is relatively healthy.