"Another Way": the Pneumatology of Deleuzean Minoritarian Communal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Denver Digital Commons @ DU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 1-1-2014 "Another Way": The Pneumatology of Deleuzean Minoritarian Communal Interpretation in Scripture, the 16th Century Radical Reformation, and Alternative 21st Century Anabaptist Community Jeremy Garber University of Denver Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd Part of the Continental Philosophy Commons, Mass Communication Commons, and the Practical Theology Commons Recommended Citation Garber, Jeremy, ""Another Way": The Pneumatology of Deleuzean Minoritarian Communal Interpretation in Scripture, the 16th Century Radical Reformation, and Alternative 21st Century Anabaptist Community" (2014). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 974. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/974 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. “Another Way”: The Pneumatology of Deleuzean Minoritarian Communal Interpretation in Scripture, the 16th Century Radical Reformation, and Alternative 21st Century Anabaptist Community __________ A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the University of Denver and the Iliff School of Theology Joint PhD Program __________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy __________ by Jeremy Garber June 2014 Advisor: Dr. Jeffrey H. Mahan ©Copyright by Jeremy Garber 2014 All Rights Reserved Author: Jeremy Garber Title: “Another Way”: The Pneumatology of Deleuzean Minoritarian Communal Interpretation in Scripture, the 16th Century Radical Reformation, and Alternative 21st century Anabaptist Community Advisor: Dr. Jeffrey H. Mahan Degree Date: June 2014 Abstract This dissertation proposes a constructive theology of the Holy Spirit called the “pneumatology of minoritarian communal interpretation,” the alternative creation of meaning within an oppressive majority context. It illustrates the convergence of Deleuzean philosophy with Anabaptist pneumatology and media communal interpretation theory in three particular locations: 1) selected mentions of the Holy Spirit in the Hebrew Bible and Christian New Testament; 2) the 16th century Radical Reformation; and 3) “Another Way,” a 21st century alternative Anabaptist group focused around the spiritual discussion of art and popular media. Chapter One outlines the three theories. Chapter Two examines the Holy Spirit in the Hebrew Bible, particularly 1 Samuel 8, the book of Ezekiel, and the Gospel narratives. Chapter Three examines the pneumatological writings of the Radical Reformers, concentrating particularly on their theologies of the intersection between church and the surrounding majoritarian culture. Chapter Four outlines my original field research with Another Way, and examines the tension between minoritarian communal interpretation and the 21st century semiotic regime. Chapter Five then summarizes the conversations between theory and illustration to propose the pneumatology of minoritarian communal interpretation for Christian theology. ii Acknowledgments Primary thanks go to the members of my advisory and dissertation committee, Dr. Jeffrey Mahan, Dr. Carl Raschke, and Dr. Amy Erickson. Dr. Mahan as my dissertation director deserves special mention for his warm personal encouragement coupled with an unrelenting editorial eye. Thanks to Don Garber, a peerless copy editor and enthusiast of religious studies who also happens to be my father. Without his help and that of my mother, Connie Garber, I and my family would not have survived to produce a dissertation. Thanks also to Dr. Troy Osborne of the University of Waterloo, who cast a professional historian’s eye on a theologian’s reading of the Radical Reformers. Thanks to Verlin Garber for a gift of supporting my scholarship, intervening at a point that I can only call miraculous. Likewise thanks to encouragement financial, professional and personal from Dr. Terrence Tice and Dr. Cathie Kelsey, who display minoritarian Christianity in their scholarship and in their mentoring relationships as well. Bernard of Chartres may have said that scholars are dwarfs on the backs of giants, but as the dissertation will show, I prefer to think that all these scholars and friends are rhizomes in the web of the Holy Spirit. iii Table of Contents Chapter One: The Holy Spirit: A Constructive Proposal for a Pneumatology of Minoritarian Communal Interpretation ............................................................................... 1 I. Introduction ................................................................................................................. 1 II. Deleuze and Guattari: Rhizomes, Violence, and Minoritarian Necessity .................. 5 Key Concepts in Deleuze and Guattari ..................................................................... 10 III. John Howard Yoder: “But We Do See Jesus” ........................................................ 22 The Shape of the Minoritarian Christian Community .............................................. 29 IV. Media Studies and Interpretive Community ........................................................... 32 Chapter Two: The Spirit in Scripture: The Minoritarian Community and the Despotic Regime .............................................................................................................................. 37 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................... 37 II. 1 Samuel 8: Movement into the Despotic Regime ................................................... 46 III. Ezekiel and the Spirit’s Role of Becoming ............................................................. 58 IV. Jesus Christ of Nazareth: The Minoritarian Community of Jesus’ Spirit ............... 73 The Minoritarian Community ................................................................................... 79 V. The Gospel Narratives and the Prophetic Imagination ............................................ 84 John Howard Yoder and The Politics of Jesus: The Shape of the Christian Minoritarian Community .......................................................................................... 88 Chapter Three: The Spirit in History: The Minoritarian Community and the Theological History of the Radical Reformation ................................................................................ 100 I. Introduction: Anabaptist Communal Hermeneutics and Minoritarian Community 100 II. Yoder’s Ecclesiology and the Minoritarian Community ....................................... 103 III. Pneumatology, Ecclesiology, and Community in the Radical Reformation ........ 109 A. The Swiss Anabaptists and Minoritarian Ecclesiology...................................... 109 B. South German Anabaptists and the Mystical Enunciation of Desire ................. 115 C. The Radical Anabaptists: Desire Unleashed ...................................................... 120 D. The Middle Way: The Unsuccessful Mediation of Majority and Minority ....... 129 E. Menno Simons and the Sedimentation of Anabaptist Desire ............................. 136 F. Politics of the Minoritarian Community ............................................................. 141 IV. Conclusion—Majoritarian and Minoritarian Tensions in the Radical Reformation ..................................................................................................................................... 146 Chapter Four: The Spirit in the 21st Century: Media and Spirituality in the Interpretive Community of “Another Way” ....................................................................................... 149 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................. 149 II. Another Way: Art, Spirituality, and Interpretation in Denver, CO ........................ 149 A. A Typical Another Way Gathering .................................................................... 151 B. Another Way and the Longing for Community ................................................. 167 III. “Spiritual but Not Religious” ................................................................................ 175 A. Spiritual Good, Religious Bad ........................................................................... 175 iv B. Tension Between Modernist Subjectivity and the Desire for Community ........ 179 C. Media and Minoritarian Identity ........................................................................ 182 IV. Theories of Interpretive Community .................................................................... 190 A. Stanley Fish and the Authority of Interpretive Communities ............................ 190 B. Theoretical Models of the Semiotic Study of Media and Religious Studies ..... 198 V. Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 202 Chapter Five: The Spirit Among Us: Observing the Pneumatology of Minoritarian Communal Hermeneutics................................................................................................ 205 I. Introduction: Tying the Strands of Conversation Together ..................................... 205 II. Common Sense: Minoritarian Thought, Creativity, and Movement .....................