Foundation and Founder
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
76 Foundation and Founder By Sean Cox South of Bar Harbor, a small dirt parking lot marks the entrance to a stretch of land that is perhaps the most significant piece of Acadia National Park on Mount Desert Island. Locals and experienced visitors frequent this small parcel of land and explore the trails that wind through the ruins of an impressive summer estate overlooking Compass Harbor. These grounds present an opportunity to escape the seasonal influx of park and town visitors, and are therefore popular with families and hikers desiring some seclusion. Here, if one takes time to thoroughly observe the surroundings, markers of once-manicured grounds are visible. A brook lined with granite blocks winds through the trees, under the park pathway, and into the forest. Aging white pines dot the property. These trees do not grow straight and limbless as they would in a grove, but instead spread their large lower branches, crowding above formerly wide-sweeping lawns. Seasons of pine needles and brittle leaves coat rough- cut granite steps and the foundations of Crumbling brickwork and exposed mortar on the edge of the estate outlying service buildings, while exposed foundation. Although deterioration is clear, the skill applied in masonry of the grand summer cottage construction is also evident; brick flooring exposed to the elements for crumbles and vanishes beneath new decades has not rippled from abusive winter frost-heaves. Photograph by growth. In what appears to be a neglected the author corner of Acadia, lie both the foundation of the Dorr estate named "Oldfarm," and the foundation of the park itself. 77 Sea-facing elevation of Oldfarm. Courtesy of the National Park Service, Acadia National Park In 1850, Charles Dorr and Mary Ward were As unique as the man who owned it, married and settled in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts. Oldfarm was an eclectic and imposing Their second son, George Dorr, later transcribed cottage, sitting comfortably south of Bar the story of his birth: "on the 29th of December, Harbor and overlooking the Atlantic. 1853 during a wild snowstorm," he wrote, "my The creation of Oldfarm heralded a father plowed his way on foot to carry the good period during which a summering elite news to my grandfather Ward."1 Dorr was born transformed formerly utilitarian lands into a wealthy Massachusetts family, and eventually into opulent statements of personal developed a fashionable summer residence on wealth and romanticized "natural" Mount Desert Island. The land on which the spaces. The mansion was a work of Dorr family built their estate was purchased in art, a creation without duplicate on 1868, and the home completed around 1880. The Mount Desert Island. Its many unique estate, christened "Oldfarm" in reference to the old features embodied the romantic era of farmland on which it was built, was one of the first Bar Harbor cottagers, a period of rapid large summer cottages on Mount Desert Island. construction of grand vacation estates It provided Dorr with an escape from increasingly across the island. The Dorr family had suburban Massachusetts. Within these walls, Dorr employed a Boston-trained architect would eventually craft his plans for a national from Maine—Henry Richards—to assist park on the island his family had so loved. in planning the cottage. The building 78 reflected "practical" ideas generated by of the Porcupine [islands] black against the Charles and George Dorr and the artistic growing light reflected in the Bay, then changing vision of Mary Dorr. Dorr’s writings offer insensibly to green as the light grew stronger."3 vivid descriptions of Oldfarm, ranging A view like this, which today is obscured by the from the record of its conception to the new growth of trees in what was once the foundation, admiration of its early magnificence. inspired Dorr to spend over a decade advocating for the federal protection of lands on Mount Desert The first story we built of granite Island until, in 1916, he finally succeeded in creating split out from tumbled boulders in the Sieur de Monts National Monument. The federal the gorge. At the last some brick protection of this patchwork of formerly private was used that added their touch of land constituted a significant step forward for land color to the warm-toned granite. preservation east of the Mississippi. The area first All was shingled [with] the warm earned its title as national monument, and then, brown, never rotting California in 1919, earned the national park designation. The Redwood. Great chimneys of brick careful crafting of the case by the Hancock County rose above the shingles promising Trustees of Public Reservations (HCTPR), and generous warmth, a promise they Dorr’s articulate and persistent effort, ensured that have well fulfilled. In the interior, federal infrastructure would protect natural spaces the frame was built with extra for future generations of islanders and seasonal strength—my father saw to that— visitors. Alongside other dedicated trustees—among while all the interior was skillfully them Charles W. Eliot—Dorr acted as an advocate, and carefully worked out from caretaker, and superintendent for Acadia, and the best of Michigan White Pine donated decades of his time and vast financial assets … The result, when we at last to realize his vision. Rough and rocky coastline, moved in the summer of 1880, glacial-cut lakes, forested natural habitats, and the the carpenters were still working bald wind-swept summits of Mount Desert Island’s upon the house, was a delightful mountains were all preserved by the Hancock home and a home it has proved County Trustees. Oldfarm was Dorr’s inspiration to be at any season of the year.2 and his gateway to preservation efforts on the island, and it reminds us of similar donations of property Oldfarm stood on the rocky and financial assets from his fellow "cottagers," outcropping overlooking Frenchman which allowed the land to be federally protected. Bay, with the surrounding islands and After Dorr’s death in 1944, Oldfarm stood empty, mainland in the distance. The view as Dorr had no children to inherit the property. from the three-story construction would Dorr never intended for his beloved home to descend have been awe-inspiring. Fortunately, into disrepair or to be reclaimed by the landscape. Mr. Dorr described the view from his Before his death, Dorr had developed plans for Sea Room: "I used to see, day after the estate, but without his continued advocacy, day, this wonderful, slow breaking of the house was doomed. Dorr spent the final years dawn, with the bold rounded mass of his life between Oldfarm and the Storm Beach 79 Cottage—a guesthouse that had been constructed the expense of its conservation. The Park as part of the estate plan and is an official park Service’s report contains data concerning service building today. Although not nearly as the costs for conversion into a concession grand as the mansion, Dorr found it much more building, an administrative outpost, a park convenient in his extreme old age. After Dorr moved museum, or a hybrid office and interpretive permanently into the guest cottage, Oldfarm was site. The extensive lawns, gardens, and rented out to friends and guests. Near the end of his tennis court that surrounded the mansion life, Dorr wrote several letters expressing his wish were prohibitively expensive to maintain, that Oldfarm be preserved as a part of the forested and therefore fell into disrepair. The park island he so loved. In August 1940, Dorr addressed service reported that engineers found a proposal to President Franklin D. Roosevelt: Oldfarm to be "structurally sound," but "mechanical work"—the heating systems, I write about a matter that is much in my electrical wiring, and plumbing—was heart at this time and I hope you look found to be outdated and insufficient. upon it favorably. This old family home, In a methodical fashion, the specialists which has been in its day the scene of composed six pages of typewritten cost much generous hospitality, I would like analysis before finally recommending greatly to have become, yet while I live, the that the park service, "strip Oldfarm of possession of the United States, that it may such shelving, doors, or piping and other serve the President and executive officers in similar materials as may be of use in the maintaining health and vigor for their work.4 Park in the near future, advertise for bids for razing [the] building, and as many Though Dorr desired a presidential retreat to be made of the other Dorr Estate buildings not of his cottage, it was not to be so. President Roosevelt required in the operation of the park."6 responded later that month, "your thoughtful and Oldfarm was ultimately destroyed generous offer to donate this property to the United by the very conservation group that States is very much appreciated. I know of no Dorr had worked so tirelessly to bring to provision of law, however, which would authorize me Mount Desert Island. Though Dorr had to accept it for the purpose you mention."5 Roosevelt hoped that the National Park Service then suggested that the property simply be donated would protect historic treasures such as to Acadia National Park, to be made available for his mansion, the organization decided executive purposes if so needed. His original hopes that the mansion would be too expensive disappointed, Dorr donated Oldfarm to the park. to update and transform and agreed to The house was spared from the great Bar Harbor fire obliterate Dorr’s beloved home. However, of 1947, yet visitors walking the grounds of Oldfarm the job was not entirely finished, and the today see but a shadow of its former glory, and even remains of a few walls were still standing that is slowly disappearing into the undergrowth.