Brownfield Redevelopment in Toronto: an Examination of Past Trends And

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Brownfield Redevelopment in Toronto: an Examination of Past Trends And Land Use Policy 19 (2002) 297–309 Brownfield redevelopment in Toronto:an examination of past trends and future prospects Christopher A. De Sousa* Department of Geography, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Bolton 410, P.O. Box 413, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201-0413, USA Received 10 July 2001; received in revised form 15 February 2002; accepted 28 March 2002 Abstract Although the development of greenfield sites in suburban peripheries is still the predominant trend in Canada, in the decade of the 1990s a growing inclination to redevelop under-utilized urban brownfield sites emerged. This study describes brownfield redevelopment patterns in the former ‘‘City of Toronto’’ during the 1990s and examines the key factors shaping them. The relevant data for the study were compiled from a City of Toronto land-use database, the appurtenant policy and planning studies, interviews with stakeholders, and case studies. Toronto’s redevelopment experience has obvious implications for cities of similar socio-cultural and socio-economic character undergoing redevelopment planning and can thus be viewed as a ‘‘case-in-point’’ in brownfield redevelopment planning and policy. r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Brownfields; Redevelopment; Toronto Introduction examines analytically the redevelopment issues in the City of Toronto during the decade of the 1990s as a In Canada, as in the United States, there has been a case-in-point for viewing such redevelopment generally. growing interest to renew urban areas for the purpose of The questions that guide the present examination are: improving the quality of life in the city. In this regard, the redevelopment of brownfield sites has received * How has brownfield redevelopment evolved in particular attention from policy makers and urban Toronto over the last decade? researchers because of the wide-ranging benefits that * What factors have contributed to the patterns of such redevelopment can generate for urban commu- redevelopment? nities—e.g. expand the tax base, clean up contaminated * Can any broader implications be distilled from the lands, lead to job creation, promote a revitalized and Toronto case? positive image of urban life. Governments at all levels in Canada have thus started implementing a wide range of innovative policies and programs designed to promote brownfield redevelopment, although the level of support Background information remains inferior to that provided generally in the US. This notwithstanding, the interest in redevelopment has Toronto is Canada’s largest city. In 1998, it restruc- gained momentum, because of a combination of market tured its municipal government, merging seven previous forces and social trends motivating urban dwellers to jurisdictions (Old Toronto, North York, Etobicoke, seek ways of improving urban life and thus improving Scarborough, York, East York, and Metro Toronto) its overall ‘‘image’’. into a mega city of over 2.4 million people, which is, in On the basis of a City of Toronto land-use database, a turn, surrounded by four regional municipalities (Dur- review of relevant policy and planning reports, inter- ham, Halton, Peel, and York) adding 2.3 million people views with key stakeholders, and case studies, this paper to the Greater Toronto Area. The former City of Toronto (before the merger), which is the focus of this *Tel.:+1-414-229-4874; fax:+1-414-229-3981. research and is referred to below as Central Toronto, E-mail address: [email protected] (C.A. De Sousa). has a population of over 650,000 (comprising 14% of 0264-8377/02/$ - see front matter r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. PII:S 0264-8377(02)00024-8 298 C.A. De Sousa / Land Use Policy 19 (2002) 297–309 the Greater Toronto Area) and covers an area of sector financially responsible for cleanup and redevelop- 97 km2. ment. They see their own role primarily as a regulatory and advisory one (De Sousa, 2001). In Ontario, the Brownfield redevelopment Ministry of the Environment can order the remediation of a brownfield site through its Environmental Protection Brownfields are defined by the US Environmental Act. But, in practice, the assessment and remediation of Protection Agency (1997) as ‘‘abandoned, idled, or brownfields unfolds primarily as a voluntary process under-used industrial and commercial facilities where regulated largely by the Ministry’s Guideline for Use at expansion or redevelopment is complicated by real or Contaminated Sites in Ontario (1996). This provides perceived environmental contamination’’. The term relevant information to property owners and other covers both known contaminated sites as well as those interested parties on how to assess and remediate only suspected of being contaminated because of brownfield sites. While not legally binding, those who previous land-use activities (e.g. waste disposal, manu- follow the Guideline to the letter have tended to get facturing, service stations, etc.). In Canada and the US development permits approved more quickly, avoid this term is synonymous with contaminated lands, having financing requests rejected, and decrease their derelict lands and former industrial sites. The term liability risks. In general, those interested in redevelop- brownfield is, however, the one favored by both public ing a site are required to assess its soil quality, remediate and private sector stakeholders because it avoids the it in accordance with government approved criteria, negative connotations associated with words such as make provisions for future liability (given that no contaminated and derelict, and because it constitutes a governmental provisions currently exist), and finance semantic counterpart to greenfield, the term often used the entire project. to refer to an agricultural land site located on the urban In contrast to most US jurisdictions, Ontario does not periphery. currently have a permanent funding or financing The brownfield problem is an extensive one in program for attracting private investment to brown- virtually every industrialized nation because of the fields, nor does it offer public protection from future gradual, but steady, migration of industries from the liability. It was only in 2000 that the Ontario govern- city to greenfield areas since the mid-1970s, leaving ment announced its intentions to introduce brownfields many large cities with vast areas of under-utilized or legislation to address key financing, liability, and vacant industrial sites (Gertler et al., 1995). While much technical guidance issues as part of its ‘‘Made-in- information on the scale of the problem is currently Ontario’’ Smart Growth Initiative. The City of Toronto, available in the US and Europe, only sporadic data can like other municipalities in Ontario, is responsible for be found on Canadian cities where, according to some land-use planning and economic development activities estimates, as much as 25% of the urban landscape is related to managing brownfield sites under the regula- potentially contaminated as a result of previous tory aegis of the provincial government. industrial activities (Benazon, 1995, p. 18). Typical reasons given for remediating and redeveloping these sites range from environmental to social and economic Schematic overview of the relevant literature benefits as identified by the Sustainable Development theoretical framework (European Commission, 1996; The literature examining the redevelopment of brown- Bartsch, 1996; NRTEE, 1998). Advocates of Smart fields and contaminated lands in Canada is extremely Growth in particular, highlight the potential of brown- limited. To date, much of the research that does exist field redevelopment for encouraging ‘‘smart’’ urban has either concentrated on technical aspects of the development, since it tends to reduce the use of public problem (Gaudet et al., 1992; Sheppard et al., 1992; funds for new infrastructure, ameliorate the quality of Smith and Stanley, 1995) or on the viability of policies the environment, attract investment to older urban for regulating and/or stimulating redevelopment activ- centers, and improve the social conditions of local ities (Ford et al., 1994; Therrien, 1995; CCME, 1996, communities, while emphasizing the central role of 1997; NRTEE, 1996a, b, c, 1997, 1998; De Sousa, 2000, private sector development at the same time (Smart 2001). It has been estimated that the province of Ontario Growth Network, 1999). has 3900 contaminated sites (NRTEE, 1996a), which, according to other estimates, is likely to be a low Regulation of brownfield sites in Ontario assessment. Benazon (1995), for instance, has suggested that as much as 25% of the land area in Canadian cities Currently, the regulation of brownfield redevelop- is potentially contaminated. The old City of Toronto ment in Canada is largely the responsibility of the prepared a map pinpointing areas of potential soil provincial and municipal levels of government. The contamination in 1994 (see Fig. 1). Although the general approach of governments is to hold the private map itself was published, its dataset was not. An C.A. De Sousa / Land Use Policy 19 (2002) 297–309 299 Fig. 1. Areas of potential soil contamination in Central Toronto, 1994 (City of Toronto Planning and Development Department, 1994). attempt to produce a similar inventory for the amalga- share of residential housing starts in all large Canadian mated mega city in 1997 did not proceed beyond the urban centers between 1994 and 1998, relative to planning stage (MTPD, 1997).1 The best estimate for the peripheral municipalities. He speculated
Recommended publications
  • Toronto Has No History!’
    ‘TORONTO HAS NO HISTORY!’ INDIGENEITY, SETTLER COLONIALISM AND HISTORICAL MEMORY IN CANADA’S LARGEST CITY By Victoria Jane Freeman A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of History University of Toronto ©Copyright by Victoria Jane Freeman 2010 ABSTRACT ‘TORONTO HAS NO HISTORY!’ ABSTRACT ‘TORONTO HAS NO HISTORY!’ INDIGENEITY, SETTLER COLONIALISM AND HISTORICAL MEMORY IN CANADA’S LARGEST CITY Doctor of Philosophy 2010 Victoria Jane Freeman Graduate Department of History University of Toronto The Indigenous past is largely absent from settler representations of the history of the city of Toronto, Canada. Nineteenth and twentieth century historical chroniclers often downplayed the historic presence of the Mississaugas and their Indigenous predecessors by drawing on doctrines of terra nullius , ignoring the significance of the Toronto Purchase, and changing the city’s foundational story from the establishment of York in 1793 to the incorporation of the City of Toronto in 1834. These chroniclers usually assumed that “real Indians” and urban life were inimical. Often their representations implied that local Indigenous peoples had no significant history and thus the region had little or no history before the arrival of Europeans. Alternatively, narratives of ethical settler indigenization positioned the Indigenous past as the uncivilized starting point in a monological European theory of historical development. i i iii In many civic discourses, the city stood in for the nation as a symbol of its future, and national history stood in for the region’s local history. The national replaced ‘the Indigenous’ in an ideological process that peaked between the 1880s and the 1930s.
    [Show full text]
  • Self Guided Tour
    The Toronto Ghosts & Hauntings Research Society Present s… About This Document: Since early October of 1997, The Toronto Ghosts and Hauntings Research Society has been collecting Toronto’s ghostly legends and lore for our website and sharing the information with anyone with an interest in things that go bump in the night… or day… or any time, really. If it’s ghostly in nature, we try to stay on top of it. One of the more popular things for a person with a passion for all things spooky is to do a “ghost tour”… which is something that our group has never really offered and never planned to do… but it is something we get countless requests about especially during the Hallowe’en season. Although we appreciate and understand the value of a good guided ghost tour for both the theatrical qualities and for a fun story telling time and as such, we are happy to send people in Toronto to Richard Fiennes-Clinton at Muddy York Walking Tours (who offers the more theatrical tours focusing on ghosts and history, see Image Above Courtesy of Toronto Tourism www.muddyyorktours.com) We do also understand that at Hallowe’en, these types of tours can Self Guided Walking Tour of fill up quickly and leave people in the lurch. Also, there are people that cannot make time for these tours because of scheduling or other commitments. Another element to consider is that we know there are Downtown Toronto people out there who appreciate a more “DIY” (do it yourself) flavour for things… so we have developed this booklet… This is a “DIY” ghost tour… self guided… from Union Station to Bloor Street….
    [Show full text]
  • Integrating Transportation and Land Use Planning at the Metropolitan Level in North America 185
    Integrating transportation and land use planning at the metropolitan level in North America: multilevel governance in Toronto and Chicago Integrando o planejamento de transporte e de uso do solo em escala metropolitana na América do Norte: governança multinível em Toronto e Chicago Fanny R. Tremblay-Racicot[a], Jean Mercier[b] Licenciado sob uma Licença Creative Commons DOI: 10.7213/urbe.06.002.SE04 ISSN 2175-3369 [a] Ph.D candidate in Urban Studies at Department of Geography and Urban Studies, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA - United States, e-mail: [email protected] [b] Ph.D in public administration (SU), professor at Université Laval, Québec, QC - Canada, e-mail: [email protected] Abstract This article compares the policies and processes by which transportation and land use planning are integra- ted in metropolitan Toronto, Canada, and Chicago, in the United States. Using twenty-four semi-structured interviews with key informants, it describes the array of interventions undertaken by governmental and non-governmental actors in their respective domains to shed light on how the challenge of integrating trans- portation and land use planning is addressed on both sides of the border. Evidence concerning the political dynamics in Toronto and Chicago demonstrates that the capacity of metropolitan institutions to adopt and implement plans that integrate transportation with land use fundamentally depends on the leadership of the province or the state government. Although the federal government of each nation can bypass the sub-national level and intervene in local affairs by funding transportation projects that include land use components, its capacity to promote a coherent metropolitan vision is inherently limited.
    [Show full text]
  • Toronto Police Service Community Consultation and Volunteer Manual
    1 November 2019 2 Volunteers and Community Policing The Toronto Police Service (Service) recognizes that volunteers are an integral and vital component of community policing. Service volunteers are welcomed and valued in every community, and their service to the organization is invaluable. Our volunteers serve as the first point of contact between the community and the Service. They make an impact and strengthen ties in our communities, they serve to enhance the delivery of police services, and assist in numerous community engagement initiatives and programs. The Mission Statement of the Toronto Police Service Volunteer Program is; “To create meaningful partnerships through trust, understanding, shared knowledge, effective community engagement and to maintain safety and security in our communities.” Connected by Commitment Revised November 2020 2 3 MESSAGE FROM THE TORONTO POLICE SERVICES BOARD On behalf of the Toronto Police Services Board, I would like to extend our deep and sincere appreciation to all of our volunteers for giving your time, energy, and dedication to the Toronto Police Service and to all of the communities that make up the City of Toronto. The Toronto Police Service is recognized as outstanding model in the policing community in the way in which it consults with its communities. The Board is extremely proud of this achievement and is committed to continuously working to ensure that we remain a progressive leader in this vital area. Strong and meaningful partnership with the community is an essential component of the Board’s emphasis on community policing. Indeed, The Way Forward, the Transformational Task Force’s action plan report, charts an approach to policing that is founded on embracing partnerships to create safe communities.
    [Show full text]
  • 378 Yonge Street Area Details
    LANDMARK CORNER OPPORTUNITY FLAGSHIP RETAIL LOCATION YONGE STREET & GERRARD STREET CORY ROSEN Goudy Real Estate Corp. VICE PRESIDENT, SALE REPRESENTATIVE Real Estate Brokerage Goudy Real Estate Corp. Real Estate Brokerage Commercial Real Estate (416) 523-7749 Sales & Leasing [email protected] 505 Hood Rd., Unit 20, Markham, ON L3R 5V6 | (905) 477-3000 The information contained herein has been provided to Goudy Real Estate Corp. by others. We do not warrant its accuracy. You are advised to independently verify the information prior to submitting an Offer and to provide for sufficient due diligence in an offer. The information contained herein may change from time to time without notice. The property may be withdrawn from the market at any time without notice. TORONTO EATON CENTRE YONGE & DUNDAS 1 YONGE STREETS RETAIL THE AURA RYERSON UNIVERSITY 378 YONGE ST. RYERSON UNIVERSITY 378 YONGE STREET AREA DETAILS Flagship retail opportunity at the corner of Yonge & Gerrard Street in the heart of Toronto. Proximity to Toronto Eaton Centre, Yonge Ryerson University is home to over 54,000 students in its various & Dundas Square, Ryerson University, and much more. 378 Yonge undergraduate, graduate and continuing education courses along Street is the point where the old Toronto meets the new Toronto - a with 3,300 faculty & staff. Ryerson University is not only expanding building designed by renowned architect John M. Lyle. but is also home to Canada’s largest undergraduate business school, the Ted Rogers School of Management. YONGE & DUNDAS THE AURA Yonge & Dundas Square and 10 Dundas is one of Toronto’s main attractions boasting open air events, a 24 multiplex theatre, 25 The Aura Condominium is Toronto’s tallest residential building, eateries, and many shops.
    [Show full text]
  • York Online Undergraduate Research
    Revue YOUR Review Volume/Tome 3 (2016) York Online Undergraduate Research Intended to showcase York University (Toronto, Canada) student research, Revue YOUR Review is an annual, refereed e-journal offering an opportunity for York University students to prepare a paper for publication. The journal is multidisciplinary, open-access, and bilingual: articles are published in English or in French. Revue York Online Undergraduate Research Review is associated with York University’s annual, multidisciplinary Undergraduate Research Fair. Articles are revised from top essays submitted for York University credit courses and accepted as poster presentations at the juried Research Fair. Submissions are reviewed by an Editorial Board comprised of York University faculty members, writing instructors, librarians, and students, and may also be sent to expert readers within the discipline. Together, the Research Fair and its associated e-journal offer students an educational experience in researching, writing, preparing an abstract, designing and presenting a poster session, and revising a paper for publication—all components in the cycle of scholarly knowledge production and dissemination. Author rights are governed by Creative Commons licensing. La Revue YOUR Review se propose de mettre en valeur la recherche des étudiants de premier cycle et offre aux étudiants de l’Université York (Toronto, Canada) l’occasion de rédiger un article pour la publication. Cette revue annuelle à comité de lecture et à libre accès est pluridisciplinaire et bilingue (anglais/français). La Revue York Online Undergraduate Research Review est liée à la foire annuelle de recherche de l’Université York. Les articles ont été sélectionnés et révisés des meilleures dissertations soumises pour un cours de premier cycle à l’Université et acceptées comme présentation d’affiches à cette foire, elle-même sous la direction d’un jury.
    [Show full text]
  • Rapid Transit in Toronto Levyrapidtransit.Ca TABLE of CONTENTS
    The Neptis Foundation has collaborated with Edward J. Levy to publish this history of rapid transit proposals for the City of Toronto. Given Neptis’s focus on regional issues, we have supported Levy’s work because it demon- strates clearly that regional rapid transit cannot function eff ectively without a well-designed network at the core of the region. Toronto does not yet have such a network, as you will discover through the maps and historical photographs in this interactive web-book. We hope the material will contribute to ongoing debates on the need to create such a network. This web-book would not been produced without the vital eff orts of Philippa Campsie and Brent Gilliard, who have worked with Mr. Levy over two years to organize, edit, and present the volumes of text and illustrations. 1 Rapid Transit in Toronto levyrapidtransit.ca TABLE OF CONTENTS 6 INTRODUCTION 7 About this Book 9 Edward J. Levy 11 A Note from the Neptis Foundation 13 Author’s Note 16 Author’s Guiding Principle: The Need for a Network 18 Executive Summary 24 PART ONE: EARLY PLANNING FOR RAPID TRANSIT 1909 – 1945 CHAPTER 1: THE BEGINNING OF RAPID TRANSIT PLANNING IN TORONTO 25 1.0 Summary 26 1.1 The Story Begins 29 1.2 The First Subway Proposal 32 1.3 The Jacobs & Davies Report: Prescient but Premature 34 1.4 Putting the Proposal in Context CHAPTER 2: “The Rapid Transit System of the Future” and a Look Ahead, 1911 – 1913 36 2.0 Summary 37 2.1 The Evolving Vision, 1911 40 2.2 The Arnold Report: The Subway Alternative, 1912 44 2.3 Crossing the Valley CHAPTER 3: R.C.
    [Show full text]
  • ANNUAL REPORT 2016 Cover Image Credits: Dominique Van Olm, Herman Custodio, Heritage Toronto TABLE of CONTENTS
    HERITAGE TORONTO ANNUAL REPORT 2016 Cover image credits: Dominique van Olm, Herman Custodio, Heritage Toronto TABLE OF CONTENTS ABOUT HERITAGE TORONTO ......................................................................... 4 YEAR-END MESSAGE ................................................................................... 5 HERITAGE TORONTO AWARDS ...................................................................... 6 KILBOURN LECTURE ..................................................................................... 6 HISTORICAL PLAQUES ................................................................................. 11 TOURS ......................................................................................................14 SPECIAL PROGRAMS ...................................................................................16 GET INVOLVED ...........................................................................................18 JOIN THE CONVERSATION .......................................................................... 20 FINANCIAL SUMMARY ................................................................................21 SPONSORS & DONORS .............................................................................. 22 ABOUT HERITAGE TORONTO Heritage Toronto is a charitable agency of the City of Toronto with a mandate to enhance the understanding and appreciation of Toronto’s past and present among residents and visitors through education, commemoration and celebration of the city’s diverse people, places and events.
    [Show full text]
  • Redeveloping the Distillery District, Toronto
    Place Differentiation: Redeveloping the Distillery District, Toronto by Vanessa Kirsty Mathews A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Geography University of Toronto © Copyright by Vanessa Kirsty Mathews 2010 Place Differentiation: Redeveloping the Distillery District, Toronto Doctor of Philosophy Vanessa Kirsty Mathews, 2010 Department of Geography University of Toronto Abstract What role does place differentiation play in contemporary urban redevelopment processes, and how is it constructed, practiced, and governed? Under heightened forms of interurban competition fueled by processes of globalization, there is a desire by place- makers to construct and market a unique sense of place. While there is consensus that place promotion plays a role in reconstructing landscapes, how place differentiation operates – and can be operationalized – in processes of urban redevelopment is under- theorized in the literature. In this thesis, I produce a typology of four strategies of differentiation – negation, coherence, residue, multiplicity – which reside within capital transformations and which require activation by a set of social actors. I situate these ideas via an examination of the redevelopment of the Gooderham and Worts distillery, renamed the Distillery District, which opened to the public in 2003. Under the direction of the private sector, the site was transformed from a space of alcohol production to a space of cultural consumption. The developers used a two pronged approach for the site‟s redevelopment: historic preservation and arts-led regeneration. Using a mixed method approach including textual analysis, in-depth interviews, visual analysis, and site observation, I examine the strategies used to market the Distillery as a distinct place, and the effects of this marketing strategy on the valuation of art, history, and space.
    [Show full text]
  • Inclusion on the City of Toronto's Heritage Register – Laird in Focus – 90 Laird Drive, 180 Laird Drive and 20 Research Road
    ~TORONTO REPORT FOR ACTION Inclusion on the City of Toronto's Heritage Register – Laird in Focus – 90 Laird Drive, 180 Laird Drive and 20 Research Road Date: October 7, 2019 To: Toronto Preservation Board North York Community Council From: Senior Manager, Heritage Preservation Services, Urban Design, City Planning Wards: Ward 15 – Don Valley West SUMMARY This report recommends that City Council include the properties at 90 Laird Drive, 180 Laird Drive and 20 Research Road on the City of Toronto Heritage Register. The properties are located on the west side of Laird Drive between Vanderhoof Avenue and Millwood Road and the north side of Research Road. As part of the Laird in Focus Planning Study, City Planning initiated a Cultural Heritage Resource Assessment (CHRA) to ensure that all properties of cultural heritage value or interest were appropriately identified, understood and conserved as part of an up-to- date planning framework. The three properties identified for inclusion on the City's Heritage Register, along with the four properties already listed on Laird Drive highlight the 1920s -1940s as a period of significance in the development of Leaside, when many finely crafted buildings were constructed as part of the Town of Leaside's growth. Together, the six properties on Laird Drive enrich the understanding of the area's sense of place and demonstrate the continued importance of this historic commercial and industrial spine for Leaside's growth and prosperity. The property on Research Road is one of the rare surviving structures representing Leaside's major contribution to Canada's military in both world wars.
    [Show full text]
  • 923466Magazine1final
    www.globalvillagefestival.ca Global Village Festival 2015 Publisher: Silk Road Publishing Founder: Steve Moghadam General Manager: Elly Achack Production Manager: Bahareh Nouri Team: Mike Mahmoudian, Sheri Chahidi, Parviz Achak, Eva Okati, Alexander Fairlie Jennifer Berry, Tony Berry Phone: 416-500-0007 Email: offi[email protected] Web: www.GlobalVillageFestival.ca Front Cover Photo Credit: © Kone | Dreamstime.com - Toronto Skyline At Night Photo Contents 08 Greater Toronto Area 49 Recreation in Toronto 78 Toronto sports 11 History of Toronto 51 Transportation in Toronto 88 List of sports teams in Toronto 16 Municipal government of Toronto 56 Public transportation in Toronto 90 List of museums in Toronto 19 Geography of Toronto 58 Economy of Toronto 92 Hotels in Toronto 22 History of neighbourhoods in Toronto 61 Toronto Purchase 94 List of neighbourhoods in Toronto 26 Demographics of Toronto 62 Public services in Toronto 97 List of Toronto parks 31 Architecture of Toronto 63 Lake Ontario 99 List of shopping malls in Toronto 36 Culture in Toronto 67 York, Upper Canada 42 Tourism in Toronto 71 Sister cities of Toronto 45 Education in Toronto 73 Annual events in Toronto 48 Health in Toronto 74 Media in Toronto 3 www.globalvillagefestival.ca The Hon. Yonah Martin SENATE SÉNAT L’hon Yonah Martin CANADA August 2015 The Senate of Canada Le Sénat du Canada Ottawa, Ontario Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A4 K1A 0A4 August 8, 2015 Greetings from the Honourable Yonah Martin Greetings from Senator Victor Oh On behalf of the Senate of Canada, sincere greetings to all of the organizers and participants of the I am pleased to extend my warmest greetings to everyone attending the 2015 North York 2015 North York Festival.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    backhouse 02text (xi-322) 4/22/04 4:06 PM Page 3 INTRODUCTION Y about to meet Mrs. Elizabeth Bethune Campbell, a woman of formidable intellect, wit, and sarcasm, with the determination of steel. Her book, Where Angels Fear to Tread, written in and self- published in from her home in the rectory of St. John’s Episcopalian Church in Jamaica Plain, Boston, raised considerable controversy when it first appeared. Mrs. Campbell’s fascinating entan- glement with the law spanned fourteen years. It began in , when she first came across an unsigned copy of her mother’s will while sort- ing through musty family trunks. The saga peaked in , when Mrs. Campbell appeared on her own behalf to argue her case in front of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London. The legal battle finally ended in , when the Ontario Court of Appeal issued its last decision on the matter of costs relating to the complex web of litiga- tion spawned by Mrs. Campbell’s inheritance. The story that Mrs. Campbell tells is extraordinary, and not only because she appears to have been the first woman to argue in front of the Law Lords at the Privy Council. Mrs. Campbell’s description of the barriers she surmounted before emerging victorious in England unveils the intricate, multilayered world of overlapping intrigue and influence that constituted the early-twentieth-century Ontario legal system. From her unique vantage point as both an insider and an out- sider, she comments on the actions of lawyers and judges with acuity and perspicacity. Others might have thought as she did.
    [Show full text]