World Bank Document
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IPP219 v.2 Public Disclosure Authorized Social Assessment study for Eco-farming and Sustainable Rural Development Project -World Bank Loan Project Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Beijing, P.R. China March 2007 Public Disclosure Authorized Implementation Agency: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), Beijing Person in charge of project: Mrs. Dr. Zhao Lixin, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), Beijing Team leader: Mrs. Zhang Yanli, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), Beijing Main compilation of the SA report: Mrs. Zhang Yanli, Master of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), MoA, Beijing Prof. Jiang Aiqun, Department of Rural Sociology, China Agricultural University, Beijing Participant in the SA: Mr Li Bingfeng, Dual Bachelor of Management and Economy, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), Beijing Mrs Wang Aihua, Bachelor of Economic Management, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Engineering (CAAE), Beijing Mrs Zhang Li, Master of Sociology, China Agricultural University, Beijing Mrs Xu Lei, Master of Sociology, China Agricultural University, Beijing Content I Introduction and Summary ...........................................................................................................5 1.1.1 Background and main objective .............................................................................5 1.1.2 Project content and scale ........................................................................................6 1.1.3 Brief introduction of the proposed area ..................................................................6 1.2.1 Objective of the Social Assessment .......................................................................7 1.2.2 Approaches and Related Methodology ..................................................................7 1.2.3 Introduction of Field Visit Sites .............................................................................8 1.2.4 Time schedule of Field Research ........................................................................... 9 2 . Brief introduction of the Social-economic profile of the project area .......................................12 2.1 Social and economic profile of the project areas in Guangxi ..........................................12 2.1.1 Social and economic profile of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region ...............12 2.1.2 Social and economic profile of the project areas .............................................13 2.1.3 Social and economic profile of the sample villages .............................................15 2.2 Social-economic profile of the project area in Chongqing Municipality ........................18 2.2.1 Social-economic profile of Chongqing Municipality ...........................................18 2.2.2 Social-economic profile of the project area .........................................................19 2.2.3 Social-economic profile of the sample villages ...................................................20 (1) Banzhu Village in Fulv Town ..................................................................................20 2.3 Brief introduction of the Social-economic profile of the project area in Anhui province ..............................................................................................................................................22 2.3.1 Social-economic profile of Anhui Province .........................................................22 2.3.2 Social-economic profile of the project area .........................................................22 2.3.3 Social-economic profile of Taihu county and sample villages .............................23 2.3.4 Social-economic profile of Guichi district and sample villages ...........................26 2.4 Brief introduction of the Social-economic profile of the project area in Hunan province ..............................................................................................................................................28 2.4.1 Social-economic profile of Hunan Province ........................................................28 2.4.2 Social-economic profile of the project area in Hunan province ...........................29 2.4.3 Social-economic profile of the sample villages ...................................................29 2.5 Social-economic profile of the project areas in Hubei Province .....................................32 2.5.1 Social-economic profile of Enshi Autonomous Prefecture in Hubei Province ....32 2.5.2 Social-economic profile of Xiangfeng County and sample villages ....................33 3 Expected social impacts analysis ...............................................................................................37 3.1 Project beneficiaries and their attitudes towards the project ...........................................37 3.1.1 Definition of project beneficiary ..........................................................................37 3.1.2 Beneficiary group's attitudes towards the project ................................................39 3.2 Expected social benefit assessment .................................................................................40 3.2.1 Increase farmers' income and improve their living conditions ............................40 3.2.2 Increase rural employment and optimize agricultural structure ...........................41 3.2.3 Reduce epidemic diseases and increase rural health level ...................................42 3.2.4 Change backward living habits and improve rural community environment ......43 3.2.5 Relieve house work loan and promote women's development ............................44 3.2.6 Promote the establishment of farmers' cooperatives .......................................... 45 3.2.7 Strengthen capacity building ................................................................................46 3.3 Local community members' training status and needs ....................................................46 3.3.1 Farmer training status in project areas .................................................................46 3.3.2 Community member's training needs ..................................................................47 3.3.3 Some problems with current trainings .................................................................48 3.4 Project's potential risks and counter-measures ...............................................................48 3.4.1 Management risks and counter-measures............................................................. 49 3.4.2 Risks related to project beneficiaries and counter-measures ................................51 3.4.3 Natural risks and counter-measures .....................................................................52 3.4.4 Technical risks and counter-measures ..................................................................53 3.4.5 Policy risks and counter-measures .......................................................................53 3.4.6 Market risks and counter-measures ......................................................................53 3.5. Possible negative impacts of the proposed project .........................................................54 3.5.1. The richer villagers shall geet more benefits and the disadvantaged group marginalized ..................................................................................................................54 3.5.2 Improper management of the loan will promote farmers' getting into the habit of depending on others ......................................................................................................55 3.5.3 Local government's over-loaning shall affect regional social-economic development ..................................................................................................................56 4 Conclusions and recommendations ............................................................................................56 4.1 Conclusions .....................................................................................................................56 4.2 Recommendations ...........................................................................................................57 4.3 Discussion: Participatory Project Management System ..................................................59 4.3.1 Participation mechanism in project designingtplanning period ...........................60 4.3.2 Participatory mechanism in project implementation period ................................. 60 4.3.3 Participatory mechanism in project supervision and evaluation period ............... 61 4.3.4 Mechanism of involving the disadvantaged to participate in the project .............61 4.4 Communication strategy and training .............................................................................62 5 Social indicators for project monitoring and assessment ...........................................................62 6 . Annex ......................................................................................................................................65 6.1Terms of reference of social assessment (TOR) ..........................................................65 6.2 Selection criteria of field visit sites .................................................................................65 6.3 Interview outline for village and farmer .........................................................................65 6.4 Interview outline for county level ...................................................................................65