GT2 H STAR H TUESDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2010 ON ON0 GTA VOTES

Joe Pantalone officially enters the oping facilities like BMO Field and RACE FOR THE MAYOR’S CHAIR 2010 race. The Ward 19, Trinity-Spadi- Allstream Centre. na councillor says the city Jan. 14: A Toronto Star-Angus PATTY WINSA 10 per cent. nounces he will not run, despite should develop more Reid poll has Smitherman with 44 URBAN AFFAIRS REPORTER Jan. 5, 2010: Giorgio Mammoliti, polls that suggest he would be private-sector per cent, followed by Adam Dec. 14, 2009: Rocco Rossi declares councillor for Ward 7 York West, a front-runner over rival for- partnerships, as Giambrone with 17 per cent his mayoral ambitions during a files papers to run with a promise to mer Liberal deputy premier he did as chair (Giambrone has not yet de- speech at Nathan Phillips Square. “to tame the Godzilla” – a reference George Smitherman. of Exhibition clared). Rossi polls at 15 per cent, He positions himself as a fiscal to the city’s ballooning budget. Jan. 8: Smitherman Place’s board Pantalone at 5 per cent and conservative, promising to sell off Jan. 7, 2010: , who lost to registers to run. of governors, Mammoliti at 4 per cent. 58 per Toronto Hydro and cut his salary by Mayor David Miller in 2003, an- Jan. 13: Deputy Mayor while devel- cent wwere undecided.

STEELES AVE. W. STEELES AVE. E. Ward Riding T. 24

T.

39 CNR H 1 + 2 North .

1 NGE S u E m FINCH AVE. E. O b HWY. 400 8 3 + 4 Etobicoke Centre er Y FINCH AVE. E. R 41 iv

e DUFFERIN ST. 7 IEW AV 5 + 6 Etobicoke-Lakeshore r 23 33 42 BATHURST S r R be i 7 + 8 York West Hum ve r BAYV West 10 MARKHAM RD. SHEPPARD AVE. E. 9 + 10 9 HWY. 401 40 JANE ST. 11 + 12 York South-Weston 2 HWY. 401 HWY. 401 . 13 + 14 Parkdale-High Park . ELLESMERE RD.

15 + 16 Eglinton-Lawrence DIXON RD. 34 D. 44

25 R 38

MILLS RD 12 YONGE ST 17 + 18 Davenport 15 16 37 43

19 + 20 Trinity-Spadina HWY. 401 DON

BRIMLEY

BATHURST ST.

CALEDONIA RD. EGLINTON CNR MORNIGSIDE AVE. 21 + 22 St. Paul's ICTORIA PARK AVE.

V AVE. W. 11 EGLINTON AVE. E. MARKHAM RD. 23 + 24 Willowdale 4 22 26 25 + 26 Don Valley West 3 DUNDAS ST. W. 21 17 NA AVE. 27 + 28 Toronto Centre-Rosedale 35

SPADI 31 29 + 30 Toronto-Danforth 27 29 Humber River 36

18 E. 31 + 32 Beaches-East York 13 20 NE ST. DANFORTH AVE.

R

5 U 33 + 34 Don Valley East HWY. 427 19 28 30 32

PARKSIDE DR. 14

35 + 36 ERSITY AV

DOVERCOURT RD.

SHERBO Etobicoke Creek QEW COXWELL AVE. 37 + 38 Scarborough Centre QUEEN ST. E.

UNIV

39 + 40 Scarborough-Agincourt BATHURST ST. 41 + 42 Scarborough-Rouge River 6 43 + 44 Scarborough East THE WARDS

THE WINNERS Results as of press time. For updates see thestar.com

MAYOR WARD 5 ETOBICOKE-LAKESHORE44/46 WARD 13 PARKDALE-HIGH PARK 49/49 Mike Yen 3436 16% Raj Rama 969 5% Robert Spencer 3970 23% 1864/1870 Justin Di Ciano 8558 41% Sarah Doucette 10100 47% Dean Maher 1173 6% Daniel Murton 633 3% Diane Hogan 2341 13% 380201 47% 8492 41% Bill Saundercook 7893 37% Roman Polochansky 463 2% Eric Brazau 562 3% Sean Gladney 2233 13% George Smitherman 287393 36% Morley Kells 2304 11% Nick Pavlov 2109 10% Ken Osadchuk 307 1% Eddy Gasparotto 1727 10% 94840 12% John Chiappetta 1109 5% Redmond Weissenberg- WARD 29 TORONTO-DANFORTH 28/28 Marvin Macaraig 866 5% Rocco Rossi 4973 1% Rob Therrien 305 1% er 1139 5% WARD 21 ST. PAUL’S 37/37 Mary Fragedakis 7430 42% Vicki Breen 663 4% George Babula 3242 0% Jackelyn Van Altenberg 228 1% Joe Mihevc 9824 56% Jane Pitfield 4966 28% Robert McDermott 518 3% Tony Ashdown 475 3% Rocco Achampong 2781 0% WARD 6 ETOBICOKE-LAKESHORE45/45 Shimmy Posen 5328 30% Jennifer Wood 4269 24% Roman Danilov 210 1% Abdullah-Baquie Ghazi 2746 0% 12228 60% WARD 14 PARKDALE-HIGH PARK 37/37 Peter Nolan 921 5% Chris Caldwell 885 5% Michael Alexander 2452 0% Jem Cain 5847 29% 8542 52% Beth McLellan 644 4% John Richardson 138 1% Vijay Sarma 2233 0% Michael Laxer 717 4% Ryan Hobson 2798 17% Alex Freedman 454 3% Mike Restivo 81 0% WARD 37 SCARBOROUGH CENTRE Sarah Thomson 1876 0% Wendell Brereton 605 3% Michael Erickson 2434 15% Marius Frederick 295 2% 38/38 Jaime Castillo 1862 0% Cecilia Luu 466 2% Bill Vrebosch 668 4% WARD 30 TORONTO-DANFORTH 35/35 Michael Thompson 15129 84% Dewitt Lee 1685 0% David Searle 375 2% Cullen Simpson 531 3% Isabelle Champagne 1571 9% Douglas Campbell 1420 0% WARD 22 ST. PAUL’S 47/47 8766 45% Gus Koutoumanos 529 3% 11892 52% Liz West 8507 44% Fawzi Bidawi 1014 6% Kevin Clarke 1400 0% Barry Hubick 342 2% Sergio Otoya Salazar 375 2% WARD 7 YORK WEST 30/30 Chris Sellors 8037 35% Andrew James 620 3% Joseph Pampena 1308 0% Jules-José Kerlinger 331 2% Giorgio Mammoliti 5338 44% Elizabeth Cook 1900 8% Mark Dewdney 518 3% David Epstein 1198 0% István Tar 177 1% Nick Di Nizio 3601 30% William Molls 869 4% Mihaly Varga 313 2% WARD 38 SCARBOROUGH CENTRE41/41 Monowar Hossain 1186 0% Jimmy Talpa 135 1% Michael Flie 1178 0% Victor Lucero 1038 9% Angie Tingas 262 1% Glenn De Baeremaeker 11166 62% Andreas Bogojevic 198 1% Don Andrews 1023 0% Sergio Gizzo 706 6% WARD 23 WILLOWDALE 62/62 Glenn Middleton 4541 25% 44/44 Gary Walsh 143 1% Weizhen Tang 885 0% Sharon Joseph 547 4% WARD 15 EGLINTON-LAWRENCE 13666 66% Tushar Shah 824 5% Daniel Walker 795 0% Chris MacDonald 491 4% Josh Colle 6668 40% Dusan Kralik 2456 12% Kirk Jensen 708 4% Keith Cole 794 0% Larry Perlman 249 2% Rob Davis 5399 33% Peter Clarke 2129 10% WARD 31 BEACHES-EAST YORK 39/39 Sandip Vora 643 4% Michael Brausewetter 791 0% Scott Aitchison 129 1% Ron Singer 2275 14% John Whyte 1445 7% Janet Davis 11177 63% Stefano Tesoro 89 1% Tony Evangelista 1173 7% Barry Goodhead 736 0% Charles Sutherland 1055 5% Robert Walker 1945 11% WARD 39 SCARBOROUGH-AGINCOURT Giuseppe Pede 472 3% Charlene Cottle 730 0% Peter Agaliotis 1468 8% 38/38 Eva Tavares 464 3% Tibor Steinberger 729 0% WARD 8 YORK WEST 41/41 Brenda MacDonald 1412 8% 9931 68% William Reitsma 64 0% WARD 24 WILLOWDALE 52/52 Christopher Ball 690 0% 4724 41% Rasal Rahman 1065 6% Kevin Xu 3640 25% James Di Fiore 649 0% David Shiner 10523 58% Peter Li Preti 4372 38% Sonny Cho 4986 28% Donna Braniff 505 3% Caldwell Williams 994 7% Diane Devenyi 627 0% 35/35 Antonius Clarke 1487 13% WARD 16 EGLINTON-LAWRENCE Eugene Loo 1611 9% Leonard Subotich 93 1% John Letonja 587 0% Karen Stintz 11607 61% Arthur Smitherman 268 2% Bob Nahiddi 903 5% WARD 40 Himy Syed 576 0% Naseeb Husain 243 2% Terry Mills 4243 22% WARD 32 BEACHES-EAST YORK 38/38 SCARBOROUGH-AGINCOURT 44/44 Carmen Macklin 565 0% John Gallagher 129 1% Michael Coll 1799 9% Mary-Margaret McMa- 12458 74% Howard Gomberg 472 0% Ramnarine Tiwari 117 1% Roy Macdonald 1453 8% WARD 25 DON VALLEY WEST 42/42 hon 15159 65% Ken Sy 1935 11% David Vallance 442 0% Gerardo Miniguano 53 0% 9258 45% Mark State 433 0% Cliff Jenkins 8756 43% 5998 26% Bryan Heal 1862 11% 25/25 Phil Taylor 425 0% WARD 17 DAVENPORT Joanne Dickins 1968 10% Keith Begley 753 3% Cheng-Chih Tsai 580 3% Colin Magee 397 0% WARD 9 YORK CENTRE 29/30 Cesar Palacio 6124 43% Tanya Hostler 368 2% Bruce Baker 477 2% Jonah Schein 4764 33% Selwyn Firth 392 0% 5161 44% Brad Feraday 354 2% WARD 41 SCARBOROUGH-ROUGE Tony Letra 2022 14% Ratan Wadhwa 288 0% Gus Cusimano 5138 44% Martin Gladstone 210 1% RIVER 45/45 Ben Stirpe 731 5% WARD 26 DON VALLEY WEST 53/53 Gerald Derome 249 0% Gianfranco Amendola 1040 9% Neil Sinclair 190 1% Chin Lee 12557 71% Maria Marques 384 3% John Parker 6203 31% Wilson Basantes 239 2% Albert Castells 66 0% Patricia Sinclair 2718 15% Brian Bragason 125 1% Jon Burnside 5788 29% Stefano Picone 134 1% Kieron Pope 63 0% Danny Chien 2507 14% COUNCILLORS Kar Rasaiah 94 1% Mohamed Dhanani 5627 28% Yunus Pandor 1452 7% 45/45 42/42 WARD 10 YORK CENTRE Tanvir Ahmed 377 2% WARD 33 DON VALLEY EAST WARD 42 SCARBOROUGH-ROUGE WARD 18 DAVENPORT 29/29 WARD 1 ETOBICOKE NORTH 37/37 3159 19% Shaukat Malik 216 1% 7946 58% RIVER 39/40 Ana Bailão 6277 44% Vincent Crisanti 5505 41% Nancy Oomen 2777 17% Nawab Salim Khan 169 1% Fil Giannakopoulos 2787 20% Raymond Cho 10037 53% Kevin Beaulieu 4911 34% Suzan Hall 4996 37% Brian Shifman 2632 16% Mike Ihnat 1886 14% Neethan Shan 6221 33% Frank De Jong 869 6% Omar Farouk 1573 12% Igor Toutchinski 2605 16% David Raines 1162 8% Shamoon Poonawala 577 3% Hema Vyas 776 5% WARD 27 TORONTO Sharad Sharma 883 7% Konstantin Toubis 1887 11% Mohammed Ather 456 2% Magda Gondor Berkovits 935 6% Joe MacDonald 669 5% CENTRE-ROSEDALE 86/87 Ted Berger 388 3% WARD 34 DON VALLEY EAST 45/45 Ruth Tecle 426 2% Jarred Friedman 850 5% Kirk Russell 326 2% Kristyn Wong-Tam 7437 28% Peter D’gama 169 1% Denzil Minnan-Wong 8743 53% Namu Ponnambalam 419 2% Joseph Cohen 535 3% Nha Le 154 1% Ken Chan 6979 26% Peter Youngren 6484 40% George Singh 339 2% Eric Plant 355 2% Ken Wood 106 1% Chris Tindal 3402 13% Stephan Stewart 1140 7% Leon Saul 315 2% WARD 2 ETOBICOKE NORTH 37/37 Mohammad Muhit 94 1% Simon Wookey 2126 8% Edward Zaretsky 326 2% Venthan Ramanathava- Doug Ford 12660 72% Joanna Teliatnik 70 0% Joel Dick 1652 6% Robert Freedland 244 1% vuniyan 116 1% Cadigia Ali 2346 13% Drago Banovic 186 1% Doug Carroll 52 0% Robert Meynell 1221 5% WARD 35 SCARBOROUGH Luciano Rizzuti 828 5% Abdirazak Elmi 42 0% Enza Anderson 1110 4% SOUTHWEST 42/42 Rajinder Lall 736 4% Ella Rebanks 830 3% Michelle Berardinetti 8293 50% WARD 43 SCARBOROUGH EAST 37/37 WARD 11 YORK SOUTH-WESTON 43/43 Andrew Saikaley 637 4% Ben Bergen 373 1% Adrian Heaps 6020 37% 9334 61% 10544 67% WARD 19 TRINITY-SPADINA 41/41 Jason Pedlar 455 3% Susan Gapka 366 1% Malik Ahmad 850 5% John Laforet 4440 29% Fulvio Sansone 2290 14% 9125 45% Gary Leroux 282 1% Victoria Doyle 429 3% Bhaskar Sharma 758 5% Leo Marshall 1718 11% Karen Sun 4207 21% Paul Spence 240 1% Ed Green 253 2% Benjamin Mbaegbu 489 3% WARD 3 ETOBICOKE CENTRE 40/40 Abdi Hashised 1235 8% Sean McCormick 3650 18% Jonas Jemstone 142 1% John Lewis 183 1% Samuel Getachew 392 3% 13521 72% Jim Likourezos 1313 7% Ram Narula 108 0% Jay Burnett 173 1% Peter Kudryk 2684 14% David Footman 518 3% WARD 12 YORK SOUTH-WESTON 38/38 Perry Missal 74 0% Peter Tijiri 90 1% Ross Vaughan 1585 8% Karlene Nation 417 2% WARD 44 SCARBOROUGH EAST 42/42 3636 27% John Morawietz 76 0% Roger Deschenes 1010 5% Rosario Bruto 398 2% Ron Moeser 10185 47% Nick Dominelli 3214 24% Jason Woychesko 70 0% George Sawision 356 2% WARD 28 TORONTO Diana Hall 9901 46% Steve Tasses 2748 20% Jason Stevens 121 1% CENTRE-ROSEDALE 59/59 Mohammed Mirza 749 3% WARD 4 ETOBICOKE CENTRE 41/41 Vilma Filici 2204 16% Pam McConnell 11883 63% WARD 36 SCARBOROUGH Heath Thomas 627 3% Gloria Lindsay Luby 9789 47% Richard Gosling 1073 8% Howard Bortenstein 3730 20% SOUTHWEST 42/42 John Campbell 9480 45% Joe Renda 343 3% WARD 20 TRINITY-SPADINA 61/62 Dennis Hollingsworth 1128 6% Gary Crawford 4392 25% Daniel Bertolini 1602 8% Angelo Bellavia 221 2% 15621 74% Both right wing and left wing councillors took hits

NEWCOMERS from GT1 the win was razor-thin, with a re- wards where the previous occupant Council warhorse Howard Mos- Councillor Olivia Chow got the cov- count possible. had moved on. coe, who didn’t run again, will be eted job of child advocate. But newcomers will also be In Ward 9 (York Centre), left-wing While the city moved right in the replaced by Josh Colle. With the help of henchmen like looking to make a mark, and there councillor Maria Augimeri was also mayor’s race, Ward 29 (Toronto- How the factions and the non- deputy mayor working are plenty of them. in a too-close-to-call battle with Danforth) bucked the trend at the aligned will mesh with the new the back rooms, he cobbled togeth- Rob Ford’s brother, Doug, cruised Gus Cusimano. council level. Right-wing councillor mayor will be one of the first things er ever-changing majorities from to an easy victory in Ward 2 (Etob- Right-wing as well as left-wing Case Ootes, who didn’t run again, to watch as the council gets down to day to day. icoke North), the seat vacated by councillors were in trouble. will be replaced by Mary Frageda- business. Miller, by contrast, worked with a the new mayor. He’ll be a crucial Voters in Ward 13 (Parkdale-High kis, who was endorsed by two local There isn’t a lot of history to go on, solid core of council loyalists. council ally. Park) tossed veteran Bill Saunder- MPPs. For- since Toronto was recast as a me- Those who voted the wrong way In Ward 35 (Scarborough South- cook in favour of newcomer Sarah mer councillor Jane Pitfield, trying gacity with its current political were dumped — as former council- west), Michelle Berardinetti sound- Doucette. for a comeback, was defeated. structure only in 1998. In that time, lor Brian Ashton discovered, when ly defeated incumbent Adrian In Ward 5 (Etobicoke Lakeshore), In Ward 19 (Trinity-Spadina), for- the city has had two mayors with he lost his place on the mayor’s ex- Heaps in a rematch of 2006. Heaps Peter Milczyn lost his seat on coun- merly held by Pantalone, left-lean- contrasting styles of dealing with ecutive committee for opposing the had generally supported Miller, and cil to Justin Di Ciano. The intensity ing Mike Layton had little trouble their councils. mayor in a vote on the land transfer had been criticized after council of development in the ward had taking the seat. Former mayor Mel Lastman was and vehicle registration taxes. voted to cover the expenses he ran been a big issue. But in Ward 22 (St. Paul’s), where centre-right, but pragmatism Although Miller generally needed up in defending himself against In Ward 25 (Don Valley West), councillor Michael Walker retired, trumped any ideology. He faced a to win support from a handful of charges of improper spending in right-wing councillor Cliff Jenkins his former executive assistant, council covering a range of political centrist councillors to get his agen- the previous campaign. lost to Jaye Robinson, former spe- Chris Sellors, couldn’t hold the seat approaches, but made it work part- da through council, the right wing In another Scarborough rematch, cial events organizer for the city in against a challenge from former ly by identifying key left-wing coun- on city council was essentially cut incumbent Ron Moeser narrowly the days of Mel Lastman. school trustee Josh Matlow. cillors and keeping them happy. out of the action. held his seat against a challenge Sandra Bussin, the speaker of the And Ward 27 (Toronto Centre- For example, Lastman gave coun- The impotence left some stewing from Diana Hall. Hall, an assistant outgoing council, lost a bitter battle Rosedale) voters chose Kristin cillor Jack Layton the job of attack- in smouldering resentment. Hav- to former councillor Gay Cow- to Mary-Margaret McMahon in Wong-Tam, rejecting the appeal of ing homelessness, and some free- ing been excluded from power for bourne, ran for the Conservatives Ward 32 (Beaches-East York). outgoing councillor Kyle Rae to dom to craft environmental policy the past seven years, the right wing in the 2007 provincial election. But Other newcomers moved into support Ken Chan. — both issues near to his heart. will now want its share of power.