Ian Browne Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, the University of Manchester
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Battye, Browne, Dickinson, Heron, Maffei, Pourtsidou 2013 MNRAS, 434, 1239 [arXiv:1209.0343] BINGO: A novel experiment for HI intensity mapping at z=0.1-0.5 Ian Browne Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, The University of Manchester BINGO : BINGO Players BAOs from JBCA, Manchester Brazil Richard Battye Filipe Abdalla (UCL) Integrated Marie-Anne Bigot-Sazy Elcio Abdalla (Sao Paolo) Michael Brown Raul Abramo (Sao Paolo) Ian Browne Alex Wueunsche (INPE) Neutral Michael D’Cruze Thryso Villela (INPE) Peter Dewdney (SKA PO) +engineers (INPE) Richard Davis Gas Clive Dickinson Uruguay Keith Grainge Gonzalo Tancredi Bruno Maffei Manuel Caldas Alkistis Portsidou (->Portsmouth) Emilio Falco Observations Peter Wilkinson Ana Mosquera KACST, Saudi Arabia Zurich (ETH) Yaser Hafez Alex Refregier Adam Amara Christian Monstein Outline • Very brief background • BINGO approach • Current design • Expected performance • Where we are now • L-BASS as a test platform (Battye, Weller & Davies, 2004; Peterson 2006) Consider cell at z=0.5 (30 arcmin)2 Equivalent to (8h-1Mpc)3 s 8 ~ 1 Dfobs = 1MHz 10 Average HI mass in side the cell = 1.2 x 10 Msun Brightness Temp = approx 100 mK with fluctuations = O(1) Typical Noise Level on 1MHz is 50mKs1/2 -> around 3days to detect 100 mK BINGO approach • Let’s try and make life as easy as possible – Build on CMB experience – No moving parts – Room temperature amplifiers – Sidelobes as low as possible – Low cross polarization – observe in circular • Build quickly! Tenerife Experiment (circa 1990-6) JBO/Cambridge/IAC CMB expt led by Rod Davies History, but an inspiration for BINGO and L-BASS BINGO concept • Correlation receiver • Use celestial pole as reference • Long focal length to get wide field of view with single dish • Multiple scalar horn feeds to give coverage and clean beams • Exploit local landscape for structural support and RFI screening Single dish limitations • Resolution limited by size and size limited by money (<50m) • Mobile phones 900MHz to 950MHz combined with resolution => observations between 960MHz and 1260MHz • Field of view is modest (~15 degrees) even with long focal length • Need big feed horns • Need a clear view of celestial pole BINGO concept (revised) Key specifications Dish diameter : 40m Resolution : 0.67 deg Frequency range : 960 - 1260MHz (z=0.12 - 0.48) Number of feeds : ~50-70 (dual pol.) No cryogenics : Tsys ≈ 50K Digital correlation receiver <<50 MHz channel resolution (Δz<0.05) Most r/x components “off-the-shelf” Survey Design Observation time : several years Area : 10 x 200 deg2 – drift scan Static telescope with 2 ≈40m Guiding principle : simplicity ! wire-mesh dishes (No moving parts) BINGO site selected: Quarry Castrillon is almost perfect (Minas Corrales, N. Uruguay) Precise optimization of the optics suggests that we can fit in a bigger focal plane array – at least 15 deg x 15 deg – subject to cost Horn array (detectors) ≈40m Primary Secondary mirror mirror Courtesy Bruno Maffei & Adrian Galtress Castrillon RFI tests – looks good! Courtesy Christian Monstein, Gonzalo Tancredi, Manuel Caldas Clean spectrum Above 960 MHz Correlation receiver (Celestial pole) Reference Phase A/ D beam switch L/ O Computer Science Phase A/ D beam switch Hybrid Hybrid Mixer • 1/f knee frequency of typical receivers is ≈1 Hz • Perfect correlation r/x can remove the 1/f if well balanced • Plan to use Celestial Pole as reference • To achieve 1mHz we need : - Input matching to < 3% - Hybrid accurate to < 1.5% Prototype receiver being • Replace function of second hybrid with digital tested at Jodrell Bank backend. BINGO beams Edge pixel – co-polar Edge pixel – cross-polar Projected BAO detection ≈5 sigma detection should be achievable in 1 year on sky (probably 2 years real time) (we have been conservative in our error budget) 1 full year of observations (2000 sq deg.,0.7 deg FWHM) 50 feeds (dual pol) Tsys=50K Measurement of acoustic scale to dkA/kA≈ 0.024 (2.4%) (comparable to the current best optical surveys at present) BAO “Hubble diagram” BINGO BINGO w=-0.84 w=-0.93 We have to be unconventional Horn ideas and must coat lightweight materials with conducting surfaces. Insulating foams Glass reinforced fibre (GRP) Stacked aluminium sections Vacuum deposition Flame spraying Metal tape Paint 3D printing Foam sheets – second test of concept. Feed statistics • The real thing needs to be 4.5m long and 1.7m diameter! • The test horn is 2m by 0.55m • Made from 78 sheets of builder’s insulation board each 25mm thick. Plus copper tape • Constructed by hand • It works! • (Circular to rectangular transition also made from foam and copper tape) Return loss Insertion loss. Red is transition alone The next step • Make an instrument at Jodrell that can test BINGO concept – Test horns – Test receiver stability – Test noise performance – Test digital backends • Do some astronomical observations – L-BASS L-BASS; L-Band All Sky Survey • Learning exercise for BINGO • CMB foregrounds • Checking ARCADE 2 result • Two identical large horns. One looks at NCP while the other pointed in elevation • ~15 degree resolution L-BASS players: • Circular polarization Peter Wilkinson • Correlation receiver measures Ian Browne sky minus reference Bruno Maffei • 50 MHz band around 1420MHz Et al. • Cold load for absolute calibration Summary of the ARCADE 2 result presented in Hooper et al., 2012 (arxiv.org:1203.3547) Possible ARCADE explanations • Sources. Need to be completely new population several times larger than extrapolation. • Incorrect temperature accounting. Has the Galactic component been properly subtracted? (L-BASS should do better job) • Dark Matter decay? • ???? Horn 5m Horn 5m Axle Support Support frame frame Hybrid and Flexible receiver cable L-BASS • Two logical steps: – Map the sky relative to NCP – Measure the absolute brightness of NCP but postpone this • Both horns identical with circular beams. Use foam sheets as a test for BINGO • Both can point at NCP so “self-referencing” can be done during mapping • Need a well calibrated and reliable connection between horns and static Magic-tee. Use cables! • For absolute calibration replace alternative horns with a temperature-monitored matched load in a dewar. BINGO additional science • Life history of hydrogen - First detection of an FRB - from the strength of signal as a function of redshift. • Fast Radio Bursts (FRBS) -- A completely new area. Detection machine and in a BINGO phase-2 we could add outriggers and do astrometry. • Radio recombination lines – come for free and will be an order of magnitude deeper than anything before. • Other Galactic science Concluding remarks • BINGO is a competitive BAO experiment using intensity mapping idea - total build cost $4M - proposals in to FAPESP and MERCORSUR • Cosmology is presently systematics limited • S/N is not the only driver and checking the BAO measurement made in the optical is important • There is plenty of additional science to be done, including FRBs • Building L-BASS as a working test-bed for BINGO instrumentation is the plan for this summer .