Working with Autistic Individuals in Prison-Based Interventions to Address Sexual Offending

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Working with Autistic Individuals in Prison-Based Interventions to Address Sexual Offending Working with autistic individuals in prison-based interventions to address sexual offending Luke Paul Vinter A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Nottingham Trent University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. December 2020. 1 Copyright Statement This work is the intellectual property of the author. You may copy up to 5% of this work for private study, or personal, non-commercial research. Any re-use of the information contained within this document should be fully referenced, quoting the author, title, university, degree level and pagination. Queries or requests for any other use, or if a more substantial copy is required, should be directed in the owner(s) of the Intellectual Property Rights. 2 Acknowledgements Those who know me well know that I am not one to be particularly expressive or sentimental. However, in completing this thesis, I would feel remiss if I did not thank several people. First and foremost, I would like to thank all individuals from HMP Whatton and HMP Stafford (residents and staff alike) who took the time to participate in, advised on, and/or otherwise helped to facilitate my research. Without you all, this project would not have come to fruition. I would like to thank my supervision team- Dr Gayle Dillon, Prof Belinda Winder, and Dr Craig Harper. Gayle; without you, I would not be the same person that I am today. Beyond your guidance on this project, you helped me to build my conceptualisation of autism, taught me how to be strategic, provided me with invaluable career advice, and, most importantly, you have been an incredible role model for how to support others- thank you. Belinda; thank you for your honesty in your feedback (not being afraid to tell me how it is) and helping me to challenge and develop my views on the role of forensic psychology when working with individuals with sexual convictions. Lastly, Craig; thank you for your diligence in consistently providing clear, directive feedback. You struck a great balance between providing direction whilst supporting me to learn independently and develop my own critical viewpoint. I would also like to thank the countless teachers and lecturers, from primary school to university, who have each helped me to grow as an academic. Additionally, thank you to Rob and Jill from MaD Theatre Company. Without you, I would not have the confidence that has brought me this far and will benefit me for the rest of my career. I would like to thank my friends- “I don’t know half of you half as well as I should like; and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve”. To my Macclesfield family- Richard, Leigh, Frida, Audrey, and the rest of Sunday club. Weekends spent out in nature, up in t’ hills, with good food, good drink and plenty of laughs were exactly what I needed to clear my mind, recharge and keep me going. Thank you to Peter. We started this PhD together, and our pub crawls and games nights were certainly some of the most memorable features of my PhD journey. To Alex, from undergrad to PhD, I’ve still not managed to shake you, but here we are; thank you for being the Legolas to my Gimli for the last decade. To Lindsay, thank you for your unwavering thoughtfulness and support. In my final year, when COVID-19 turned the world on its head, and pressure of the looming deadline built, you kept me focussed, healthy and have provided me with a sense of purpose. 3 Finally, I would like to thank my mum (Cheryl), dad (Paul), Nanna (Jean), and our pack of hounds back in Manchester. Collectively, you have instilled in me the competitive drive, work ethic, and no-nonsense northern stoicism that kept me motivated even in the most challenging periods of the PhD. You may have not always understood the ins and outs of the PhD and what it has involved, but nevertheless, throughout my life I have always been able to rely on you all for unquestioning support, in whatever form I have needed. A special thanks to my mum for helping me to collate and staple countless blank research materials, ready for distribution in the prisons. I hope that I have done each of you proud. 4 Abstract Research indicates that autistic individuals are no more likely to offend than anyone else in the general population. However, it has been suggested that when autistic individuals do offend, their offending behaviour can be contextualised by their autism. One of the most common forms of offending reported to be committed by autistic individuals are sexual offences, and research has outlined how autism can contribute to those offences. Additionally, recent research has also indicated that autistic prisoners may experience unique challenges and have specific support needs during their prison sentences, which potentially differ from their non-autistic peers. Despite this, little research has specifically explored how to work with, support and manage autistic individuals with sexual offence convictions (ISOCs) in prison-based interventions to address sexual offending. This thesis details an exploratory sequential mixed method approach used to explore effective work practices with autistic ISOCs in prison-based interventions to address sexual offending. Specifically, this thesis explored the following research questions; ‘How appropriate are current prison-based sexual offending interventions for autistic ISOCs?’ And ‘What is best practice when working with autistic ISOCs in prison-based sexual offending interventions?’. To answer these research questions, the thesis sought to: (i) identify challenges associated with prison-based sexual offending interventions for autistic ISOCs; (ii) identify beneficial features of prison-based sexual interventions for autistic ISOCs; and (iii) to generate evidence-based, practical recommendations on how to work with autistic ISOCs in prison-based sexual offending interventions. This thesis is constructed of six chapters. Chapter 1 provides a broad introduction to the topic background and rationale of the thesis, concluding with the overarching research questions and aims. Chapter 2 provides a discussion of the methodological issues that were relevant to the empirical studies of the thesis, including a rationale for the mixed method design. Chapter 3 reports Study 1, which was a qualitative narrative exploration of the life stories of autistic ISOCs (N= 4). This study incorporated an inclusive, participatory autism research approach, and discusses how diversity and similarities in those life stories may be relevant for interventions. Chapter 4 reports Study 2, a multi- perspective qualitative study that utilised a phenomenologically informed thematic analysis to explore the issues surrounding working with autistic ISOCS in prison-based interventions to address sexual offending, from the perspectives of autistic ISOCs (N= 12) and staff (N= 13). Chapter 5 details Study 3, a quantitative study that sought to confirm qualitative findings reported in Chapter 4; relating to the relationships between autistic traits, the prison social climate, mental wellbeing and readiness to 5 engage with interventions in a sample of ISOCs serving prison sentences (N= 177). Finally, Chapter 6 provides a synthesis and general discussion of the collective findings from the empirical studies. Chapter 6 also details practical recommendations for working with autistic ISOCs in prison-based sexual offending interventions, directions for future research, highlights the original contributions of the thesis, considers broader limitations of the research, and offers a final conclusion. 6 Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ....................................................................................................................................3 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................................................................................5 TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................................................7 LIST OF TABLES .............................................................................................................................................. 10 LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................................................. 11 DISSEMINATION ACTIVITIES ASSOCIATED WITH THIS THESIS ......................................................................... 12 A NOTE ON TERMINOLOGY ............................................................................................................................ 14 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 17 1.1. AUTISM ........................................................................................................................................................ 17 1.1.1. Historical background ........................................................................................................................ 17 1.1.2. DSM criteria ....................................................................................................................................... 18 1.1.3. Sensory differences ............................................................................................................................ 21 1.1.4. Empathy and alexithymia .................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • An Experiment on the Effectiveness of Songs in English L2 Pronunciation
    Università degli Studi di Padova Dipartimento di Studi Linguistici e Letterari Corso di Laurea Magistrale in Lingue Moderne per la Comunicazione e la Cooperazione Internazionale Classe LM-38 Tesi di Laurea Listen and Learn: an experiment on the effectiveness of songs in English L2 Pronunciation Relatrice Laureanda Prof.ssa Maria Grazia Busà Silvia Tizian n° matr.1018717 / LMLCC Anno Accademico 2015 / 2016 Abstract This work is a thesis that aims at verifying the possible effectiveness of using English songs as a means to improve the pronunciation of English as a second language studied by Italian speakers. The first part is a theoretical presentation. After a general introduction in the first chapter where the most widespread language teaching theories are considered, there is a presentation of a series of applications of songs in language teaching contexts, not always focused on improving the pronunciation of a second language. Finally, some examples of the use of music in areas different from language teaching are presented, hinting to the beneficial effects of music itself. The second part is the presentation of the experiment. First of all it explores the theoretical implications which determined the choices made to define the structure of the experiment. This is followed by the presentation of the experiment in all its parts and, in the final chapter, the results obtained from the examination of the pre and post experiment audio recordings. The work ends with the conclusions where some considerations are made in the light of the results. To enter the audio recordings converted into QR codes, an application for the QR codes scanning is required.
    [Show full text]
  • The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz Had Been a Popular Movie, with Richard Dreyfuss Playing a Jewish Nerd
    Begin Reading Table of Contents About the Author Photos Copyright Page Thank you for buying this Henry Holt and Company ebook. To receive special offers, bonus content, and info on new releases and other great reads, sign up for our newsletters. Or visit us online at us.macmillan.com/newslettersignup For email updates on Lenny Kravitz, click here. The author and publisher have provided this e-book to you for your personal use only. You may not make this e-book publicly available in any way. Copyright infringement is against the law. If you believe the copy of this e-book you are reading infringes on the author’s copyright, please notify the publisher at: us.macmillanusa.com/piracy. For my mother I can’t breathe. Beneath the ground, the wooden casket I am trapped in is being lowered deeper and deeper into the cold, dark earth. Fear overtakes me as I fall into a paralytic state. I can hear the dirt being shoveled over me. My heart pounds through my chest. I can’t scream, and if I could, who would hear me? Just as the final shovel of soil is being packed tightly over me, I convulse out of my nightmare into the sweat- and urine-soaked bed in the small apartment on the island of Manhattan that my family calls home. Shaken and disoriented, I make my way out of the tiny back bedroom into the pitch-dark living room, where my mother and father sleep on a convertible couch. I stand at the foot of their bed just staring … waiting.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding the Causes of Male Sexual Assault: a Case Study of the Kokstad Medium Correctional Centre
    UNDERSTANDING THE CAUSES OF MALE SEXUAL ASSAULT: A CASE STUDY OF THE KOKSTAD MEDIUM CORRECTIONAL CENTRE by SIPHELELE NOKWETHEMBA MTSHALI (212535976) Submitted in fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree: Master of Social Sciences, in Criminology and Forensic Studies School of Applied Human Sciences College of Humanities University of KwaZulu-Natal Supervisor Dr. Siyanda Dlamini November, 2018 i DECLARATION This is to confirm that this research is my own work which I have never previously submitted to any other university for any purpose. The references used and cited have been acknowledged. Signature of candidate…………………………………… On the ………………day of ………………………. 2018 (Mtshali, S.N 212535976) ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My gratitude goes to my supervisor Doctor Siyanda Dlamini for his guidance and patience throughout the course of my studies. Most importantly for his constructive feedback. I appreciate the support, love, and sacrifices of my parents Mr. and Mrs. Mtshali and my siblings (Sihle, Sibahle, Thokozani, Thandaza and Liyema) none of this would have been possible without your love. This one is for us. The grace of God for seeing me through these two years and finding favour in His eyes. To my friends who supported me through it all, blessings to you all. Uyabonga uMakhondlo! iii ABSTRACT Correctional centres are regarded as places of rehabilitation; however, this is not always the case. Correctional centres of the 21st century in South Africa seem to be a breeding place for the victimisation of offenders. One of the main purposes of environmental criminology is to successfully prevent the occurrence of crime through crime prevention strategies. Environmental Criminology considers the way in which the environment can contribute to the occurrence of crime and thus developing strategies that will alter the environment into preventing the crime from occurring.
    [Show full text]
  • Outworlds 71 / Afterworlds in a Final Issue of Inworlds
    new to fandom, told I had to meet Bowers – in my mind a a towering image forming. I began my defense, my fear that I could never dear Bill, when we met measure up to such a friend, you couldn’t know how amazed science fiction fan, creator by your strength I would be – of zines, lover of cons. your strength to go on, to be seen, to bring your star-gazer the shock of it all, joy to the con suite – sitting a singular most encompassing angled in a chair, loving the smile, the eyes in the universe of language of fandom. that smile, the extended hand and nod which said “no pretence here, And now in your afterworld welcome, friend of Glicksohn, new and in ours without you, we face, I am not imposing – I am glad gather again on these pages, You are here.” with you in mind – you are back in our spheres of influence, holding us in orbit, accountable, then letting us spin toward eternity. Thank you! –Susan A. Manchester Afterworlds • 1 Afterworlds 1 Susan A. Manchester: new to fandom,… An Eclectic 5 Pat Virzi: Post-It Notes from Beyond Bill Bowers Appreciation… 6 Bill Bowers: July 20, 1943 – April 17, 2005 …and Fanthology… 8 Michael Glicksohn: Upsetting the Parlance of Bowers edited by 10 Cy Chauvin: Bill Bowers: “I need friends… who care.” Pat Virzi, Jeanne Bowman, 13 Michael Glicksohn: Welcome to Energumen 16 Rich Coad, and Alan Rosenthal 15 Leah Zeldes Smith: How I Met Bill Bowers design, layout & production by 17 William M.
    [Show full text]
  • Clashes in Confinement: Men's Gendered Experiences With
    CLASHES IN CONFINEMENT: MEN’S GENDERED EXPERIENCES WITH CONFLICT IN CANADIAN PRISONS By Alicia D. Horton A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIOLOGY IN CONFORMITY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY QUEEN’S UNIVERSITY KINGSTON, ONTARIO, CANADA DECEMBER 2016 Copyright Alicia D. Horton 2016 ABSTRACT This dissertation presents the results of in-depth qualitative interviews with twenty-three formerly imprisoned men regarding their lived experience with prison conflict and the pain of incarceration. The results suggest that prison is a gendered ‘total institution’ (Goffman 1961). The pains that men experience in prison are uniquely gendered in that the deprivations imposed by incarceration– deprivation of autonomy, liberty, goods and services, heterosexual sex, and security (Sykes 1958) – in the reverse, define idealized masculinity as it is currently socially constructed: self-reliance, independence, toughness or invulnerability, material and economic success, and heterosexual prowess. From these shared deprivations emerges a gendered code of conduct that perpetuates a hierarchy among incarcerated men by constructing violent masculinity as a subcultural norm. The results suggest that the gender code in prison represents a set of rules that create opportunities for men to police each other’s gender performance and make claims to masculine statuses. Because status is inextricably tied to survival in this context, many men feel pressured to perform violent masculinities in prison despite privately subscribing to a non-violent sense of self-concept. The results suggest that violence is an expressive and instrumental resource for men in prison. A gender theory of prison violence, methodological findings, theoretical implications, ethical considerations and the short and long term aftermath of violent prison conflict are discussed.
    [Show full text]
  • Earworm 20200720
    EARWORM Written by Austin Everett WRIT-LARGE [email protected] [email protected] VERVE [email protected] [email protected] INT. PITTSBURGH - BLUE LINE SUBWAY - NIGHT Heaters HISS under the feet of daily commuters. Someone COUGHS into their scarf. Another shuffles the Times to the next article, side-eyeing a MAN down the row, who’s feverishly talking to himself... MAN (whispering) Shut up! Shut up. Black trench, dress shirt, brogue shoes. If it wasn’t for his one-sided conversation, he’d blend right in. MAN (CONT'D) I’m going as fast as I can. Other passengers move farther away from him, he notices. MAN (CONT'D) It better work. INT. OFFICE - NIGHT The man’s flashlight combs through file cabinets. MAN It’s not here. He listens for an answer. MAN (CONT'D) I’ve looked through all of them!! Listens, turns to a cabinet in the corner. MAN (CONT'D) I see it. He grabs a crowbar and wedges the locked drawer open. Looks through the contents... Plucks out a folder. MAN (CONT'D) Got it. Where do I go now? INT. RED LINE SUBWAY - CONT. A quick ride. He grips the straps to his backpack. 2. EXT. LIBERTY BRIDGE - NIGHT He hustles to the middle of the bridge. Looks around. MAN I’m here! Tell me!! Listens... Takes the folder out of his bag, then a lighter. He holds it over the ledge and starts the folder on fire. Other pedestrians notice, some walk away, a few raise their phones to their ears.
    [Show full text]
  • Convict Leasing and the Construction of Carceral
    RAGGED BATTALIONS, PLOTTING LIBERTY: CONVICT LEASING AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF CARCERAL CAPITALISM IN FLORIDA, 1875-1925 E. Carson Eckhard AN HONORS THESIS in HIstory Presented to the Faculty of the Department of HIstory of the UniversIty of Pennsylvania in PartIal Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts wIth Honors 2021 Warren Breckman, Honors Seminar Director Mia Bay, Thesis Advisor _____________________________ Sinyen Fei Undergraduate Chair, Department of History I Acknowledgements This project would not have been possIble wIthout the many people who supported me along the way. I would lIke to thank my advisors, MIa Bay and Warren Breckman for theIr constant support, encouragement and feedback on every draft. I am also grateful to the Andrea MItchell Center for the Study of Democracy, whose financIal support made my archival research possIble. I would also lIke to thank Jeff Green, Matt Shafer, GIdeon Cohn-Postar and Paul Wolff MItchell for theIr feedback and support throughout this Process. Thank you also to Scott WIlds for his genealogical assIstance, on this project and on others throughout my tIme at Penn. I would also lIke to thank Kathleen Brown for InsPIring me to pursue historical research and supportIng me these past four years, and Gabriel Raeburn, for IntroducIng me to Penn’s HIstory Department. AdditIonally, NatalIa Rommen and MIsha McDaniel’s love, lIstening and support empowered me throughout this project. Lastly, I am endlessly grateful to my famIly and friends, whose encouragement and patIence made this process possIble and enjoyable. I am especIally thankful for my grandparents, Janie and Harry ClIne, who have nurtured my love of history sInce I was a child.
    [Show full text]
  • Film As a Pedagogical Tool for the Teaching and Learning of Social Justice- Orientated Citizenship Education
    Lights, Camera, Civic Action! Film as a pedagogical tool for the teaching and learning of social justice- orientated citizenship education. Daryn Bevan Egan-Simon A thesis submitted to the Department of Education, Edge Hill University, in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. July 2020 Abstract Citizenship education in England is largely based on a deficit model of young people that positions them as compliant economic subjects rather than active agents of change (Olser and Starkey, 2003; Kisby, 2017; Weinberg and Flinders, 2018). Furthermore, provision for citizenship education has been described as inadequate, ineffective, sterile and lacking in pedagogical innovation (Turner, 2009; Garratt and Piper, 2012; Kerr et al., 2010). This study addresses the question: how can short animated film be used as a pedagogical tool for the teaching and learning of social justice-orientated citizenship education? Within the study, social justice-orientated citizenship education is conceptualised within a framework consisting of four constitutive elements: agency; dialogue; criticality; and emancipatory/ transformative knowledge. As part of the enquiry, a film-based social justice-orientated citizenship education programme (Lights, Camera, Civic Action!) was designed and organically developed with twelve Year 5 children during the Spring, Summer and Autumn Terms of 2018. An intrinsic case study (Stake, 1995; 2005) was employed as the strategy of enquiry with the preferred qualitative methods of data collection being focus group interviews, participant observations and the visual and technical documents created by the children. Thematic Analysis was used as the analytical method for identifying and reporting themes found through the codification of data sets (Braun and Clarke, 2006; Castlebury and Nolen, 2018).
    [Show full text]
  • How Do I Know? Rev. John Allen Hearing This Story About Samuel
    How Do I Know? Rev. John Allen Hearing this story about Samuel makes me worry. Would I have noticed God’s quiet voice in the night? Is my life spacious enough, that I could hear the Holy One whisper? One of my worst habits, which I confess to you here, is that I always sleep with my iPhone on the table about 6 inches from my head. It is usually the last thing I look at before I fall asleep, and the first thing I look at when I wake up. Checking on social media, making sure I have up to the minute news, and in the morning looking at my emails and my calendar for the day. There is a whole world behind that little screen. I am so tempted, lying awake at night, trying to remember the name of that song that is stuck in my head, to just reach over and look it up. Or I am tugged, mere moments after I put it down, with the sense that some new message or post might have popped up in the intervening seconds. If anything calls out to me in the night these days, it is my phone, silently beckoning for my attention. And so I worry. When I hear Samuel’s story. That my spirit is not still enough at night to be attentive to the quiet stirrings of God. A few years ago, a comedian offered his take on why our society seems to have such a huge problem with texting while driving. Something which, I am relieved to be able to say, I do not do.
    [Show full text]
  • FREE PDF Version
    WriteAPrisoner.com’s SELF-HELP GUIDE FOR INMATES Flourishing Through Adversity WriteAPrisoner.com’s SELF-HELP GUIDE FOR INMATES Flourishing Through Adversity Adam Lovell Copyright © 2017 by Adam Lovell Cover design by VisualArts/Fiverr Illustrations by GraphicHarvest/Fiverr Published by WriteAPrisoner.com ISBN-10: 0-692-85478-9 ISBN-13: 978-0-692-85478-5 Author’s Note When I launched WriteAPrisoner.com in 2000 my goal was to help inmates maintain positive relationships with friends and family on the outside. After receiving countless requests for information and advice, the site introduced its first self-help guide, BACK TO WORK. That led to the creation of 15 documents that have since been shared with thousands of inmates. This book has been largely compiled based on the feedback we have received from the prison community. If you would like to share your feedback or success story, please address your letter to: WriteAPrisoner.com Self-help Feedback P.O. Box 10 Edgewater, FL 32132 Wishing you all the best to get your life on track for a bright future! -- Adam Lovell Disclaimer WriteAPrisoner.com makes no claims to be experts on the material in this book and cannot be held liable as a result of any action you take based on this information. This book is an informational guide and is not intended as legal or professional advice. It is recommended that you research all content yourself and consult a professional if you have questions. Table of Contents Section I: The Basics Chapter 1: Going To Prison Chapter 2: Visiting Prison Chapter 3:
    [Show full text]
  • Disclaimer: SM Owns Twilight, but This Plot Is Mine
    Disclaimer: SM owns Twilight, but this plot is mine Written by CaraNo Beta’d by HollettLA 1. I listen to Alice; I really do. "…and then he started talking about how much he had invested in our relationship. I was the one who brought good things into…" But it's easy to tune out. She makes it so incredibly hard for herself. "…I got so mad, ya know? 'Cause he made me feel so fucking cheap…" I sip my Bella. Vodka, Sprite, pear juice, and lime. Oh, yes. I have my own drink here at Click. It's our bar. Well, it's Demetri's bar, but it's our hangout. Rose, Alice, and I meet up here a few times a week just to talk, talk, talk. "…I mean, I'm a fucking catch, right? And then…" I tilt my head a little, bringing back a few words… Hmm. The writer in me doesn't know when we're off the clock. "…all about my assets. He's just not worth it…" It's funny. I write about relationships for a living, but I refuse to be in one myself. "…because I'm valuable…" Instead, I often use Alice and Rose. They inspire me. I'm fascinated. They're both so unlike me. Maybe it's because I grew up without a female role model. "…so, now I'm back on the market." There it is again. Those words. She's talking about what's supposed to be love. But all I hear is "investing", "cheap", "assets", "worth", "market".
    [Show full text]
  • Archived Content Contenu Archivé
    ARCHIVED - Archiving Content ARCHIVÉE - Contenu archivé Archived Content Contenu archivé Information identified as archived is provided for L’information dont il est indiqué qu’elle est archivée reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It est fournie à des fins de référence, de recherche is not subject to the Government of Canada Web ou de tenue de documents. Elle n’est pas Standards and has not been altered or updated assujettie aux normes Web du gouvernement du since it was archived. Please contact us to request Canada et elle n’a pas été modifiée ou mise à jour a format other than those available. depuis son archivage. Pour obtenir cette information dans un autre format, veuillez communiquer avec nous. This document is archival in nature and is intended Le présent document a une valeur archivistique et for those who wish to consult archival documents fait partie des documents d’archives rendus made available from the collection of Public Safety disponibles par Sécurité publique Canada à ceux Canada. qui souhaitent consulter ces documents issus de sa collection. Some of these documents are available in only one official language. Translation, to be provided Certains de ces documents ne sont disponibles by Public Safety Canada, is available upon que dans une langue officielle. Sécurité publique request. Canada fournira une traduction sur demande. VICTIMIZATION BEHIND THE WALLS: SOCIAL CONTROL IN MALE FEDERAL PRISONd A Report on Victimization in Male Prisons Prepared for The Correctional Service of Canada Dennis Cooley Department of Sociology University of Manitoba April 1992 HV 9507 C56 1992 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank the staff of the prisons where interviews were conducted for extending helping hands and easing the administrative difficulties involved in co- ordinating a large project in a small time.
    [Show full text]